EXPERIMENT : 25 Days Tomato Plant Growth Comparison SOIL VS HYDROPONIC | Hydroponics For Beginners

Подписаться 37 тыс.

Просмотров 53 тыс.

50% 1

EXPERIMENT : 25 Days Tomato Plant Growth Comparison SOIL VS HYDROPONIC | Kratky | Hydroponics For Beginners
**Masterblend works both in soil and hydroponic gardening. Masterblend tomato formula was use for this experiment.
Here is how to make your own nutrient solution
• Mix Your Own Hydroponi...
Here is where you can get the Masterblend
➡️ amzn.to/45WwRvI
Other supplies I used for my hydroponics needs
➡️ www.amazon.com...
Disclaimer: Some of these products are affiliate links, when you purchase any items from these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases without any extra cost from you. This helps support my channel. Thank you!
More hydroponic videos links here:
Quick Guide: How To Grow Lettuce No Greenhouse No Pump - • Growing Hydroponic Let...
How To Germinate Seeds On Clay Pebbles, Hydroton or LECA - • How To Germinate Seeds...
How To Sterilize Cocopeat - • How To Sterilize Cocop...
Temporary Measures To Reduce Heat - • Temporary Measures To ...
Make Your Own Hydroponic Nutrient Solution - • Make Your Own Hydropon...
How To Germinate Basil Seeds - • How To Germinate Basil...
How To Germinate Lettuce Seeds - • How To Germinate Lettu...
How To Grow Sitaw (Yard Long Beans) - • Beginners Guide : Step...
How To Germinate Lettuce Seeds Using Egg Trays - • Lettuce Seed Germinati...
How To Grow Strawberry - • EXPERIMENT Part 2: Gro...
How To Grow Eggplant - • First Time To Grow Soi...
How To Grow Tomatoes - • First Time Growing And...
How To Grow Cucumber - • This is How I Grow Hyd...
How To Grow Watermelon - • Hydroponic Watermelon ...
Alternative Cheap Netcups - • The Cheapest Alternati...
How To Make DIY Grow Box - • How To Make A Grow Box...
Soil VV Hydro - • EXPERIMENT : 25 Days T...
#soilvshydroponics
#hydroponicsforbeginners
#hydroponics
#soilless
#diyhydroponics
#tomatoes

Опубликовано:

15 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 41

@gner208 2 года назад

Ang galing may bago na nmn ako natutunan dito salmat sa pagbabahagi kapatid 🙏♥️

@Human.Inteligence. 5 месяцев назад

407 deserves more, thanks for the hard-work with fun and amazing results in making of this video,

@MrSinghKhanna Год назад

If the upper part of the plant mirrors the growth of the root system, then dirt being more dense and more effort to push through, than water, this outcome makes perfect sense. If both plants have the same amount of nutrients in them, then the smaller plant is more nutrient-dense by volume.

@RasecDia 2 года назад

Informative and useful content

@highdesertoffgrid4225 5 месяцев назад

This is interesting. I notice you seem to double the recommended nutrient solution. Any issues with this?

@dennismac3466 2 года назад

You used nutrients optimized for hydroponics on a soil plant. Not really fair. To be fair, you need to grow both in what works best for both. That said, Tomatoes do well in hydroponics.

@healinghobbies 2 года назад

Thank you! I appreciate your input😊🌱 I missed to include what nutrients was use for this experiment. Masterblend was used on both which works best in soil and hydroponics gardening.

@montanateri6889 Год назад

@@healinghobbies Sorry, but you misunderstood the information. The soil already has nutrients in it. Potting soil, outside soil,. both have nutrients. So by watering it with the nutrient water, you were giving it an nutrient overload, which may be why it turned out smaller. Masterblend is primarily used for hydroponics and there's very little information on using it with in ground tomatoes and vegetables that includes dosing and frequency details. One can assume, since soil already has nutrients in, you can't mix the masterblend the same for soil as you would for hydroponics. For your test, the soil plant should be fertilized with normal soil fertilizers.

@patrickwilson9783 Год назад

Masterblend is a synthetic fertilizer synthetics have been used in soil for ages in both commercial and backyard gardens all over the world

@dennismac3466 Год назад

@@montanateri6889 I use it in containers with soilless media. It works well. And I have used it in soil plants, just about anything you might have in a veggie garden, and it works well, better that guessing whether you have the right amount of compost, or manure. But for my soil tomatoes, using it as directed for hydroponics gave my tomatoes way too much nitrogen, and resulted in now flowers but massive plants. The next season, I skipped the cal=nitrate for the tomatoes. I have fairly decent soil, so likely had a nitrogen overload that tomatoes are more sensitive to. But it worked well for squash, corn, cucumber, etc, etc in my soil garden, but I used about twice per week, with plain water in between. I've been gardening for several decades, so I can read plants pretty well. I did have some great corn using it. I grow corn in circles maybe a meter in diameter, planting one circle every week or ten days so I have a steady harvest at peak ripeness for several weeks. It gave me real sweet melons= cantaloupe and watermelons. I bought it in the large, 25 lb bag, and figured out that it was as cheap as using 'normal' veggie 'Big BOx' store fertilizers.

@coldgravaton7711 3 месяца назад

@@dennismac3466 hey 👋. Did the Tomatoes still produce fruits 🍅??

@dliv1687 Год назад

Did you have to transplant the hydroponic plant to a larger container?

@healinghobbies Год назад

Yes, I moved it to a larger container. A 5 gallon bucket should work for any fruiting plants.

@miyaminlee 29 дней назад

In Thai we have a proverb that says “the war hasn’t been over, don’t be too quick to count the deceased.“ Why don’t you watch them grow until the end?

@magsinoclan 2 года назад

very nice

@AdamPapendieck Месяц назад

what i see is there is alot more stem in the hydroponic/kratky

@adelaidamanapsal1113 2 года назад

Hello sis..full strength na ang nutrient soln ang nilagay mo from the start?

@healinghobbies 2 года назад

Hi sis, opo itinest ko sa full strength para hindi abala sa pag timpla ng separate nutsol. Pede rin sa pag start ng seed kung cocopeat gamit u full strength na agad. Try ko siya gawin ng vids comparison. Full vs half siguro pag may time. Keep Growing sis! Salamat po🙂🌱

@adelaidamanapsal1113 2 года назад

@@healinghobbies ok sis..e try ko din full strength while seedlings pa..salamat sis, naka ka inspire ang mga videos mo.🥰🤗💚

@healinghobbies 2 года назад

Salamat sa suporta sis😍. I'm glad to hear na may nakukuha kayo mga ideas and tips. Naiinspire din po ako mag create ng content when I hear such feedback. Keep going! Keep growing!🌱 and much Love po💜

@AKB114 2 года назад

If you use growing medium like coco peat instead of soil and compare with kratky setup, then which one will yield good results?

@montanateri6889 Год назад

coco peat and coco coir do not have nutrients in them. Soil does. The fallacy in the test is that she watered the soil, which already has nutrients in it, with the nutrient water. So it could be stunted from having to much nutrients. Peat and Coir or even clay pebbles or rockwool, are just like using the sponge, it just holds the seedling in place, they are a sterile medium. Coco peat and coco coir are used in soil to help soil retain moisture, they don't contain any nutrients and can't be used by themselves to grow something in, you'd have to add the nutrient water which would then be comparing apples to apples.

@DeadeyeJoe37 Год назад

What was holding the kratky tomato plant up as it grew bigger. It just looked like you had a foam cup with the bottom cut off and a pool noodle, but I would think the plant would slip through the pool noodle once it got bigger and heavier

@healinghobbies Год назад

What I love using is hydroton or lava rock its provide great support as the plant grows taller and bigger. Recycle XL foam drinking cups from gas station is perfect size too for netcups, It's tall enough to hold the plant and bottom fits 3" holes. The pool noodle wont help when plants grow bigger. I only use it for the purpose of this experiment. If you check some of my tomatoes and eggplant videos most of them are in XL foam cups. I hope this helps🌱🙂

@topquark35 2 года назад

Ate rhise plastic cups? Also, what's your experience with foam vs rockwool vs coco peat for kratky?

@healinghobbies 2 года назад

Do you mean rinse or use plastic cups po ba? I like foam for convenience, reusable, easy and not messy to use. Mostly, I use them for green leafy vegetables. I wouldn't recommend it for warmer season it tends to heat up if growing outdoor. Cocopeat - great for growing strawberries and to start seeds for germination. For lettuce, I seldom use them it tends to dried up plus a bit messy but only in my experience. I can see it works for others. Most of my set up are on Kratky, probably it suits best for NFTor semi NFT system as it will keep the cocopeat moist. I also use leca/hydroton for fruiting plants like tomatoes, eggplants, cucumber etc.. it provides great support and moisture to the plants. I haven't tried rockwool yet. I hope this helps. Keep growing po!🌱🙂

@topquark35 2 года назад

@@healinghobbies Thanks sa insights! I'm just starting out. Will probably just stick to rockwool and LECA/hydroton for now. Your crops look fabulous. Nakaka-inspire. Salamat. Anyway, I was talking about the oversized cups na mini container.

@healinghobbies 2 года назад

You’re welcome po! Happy to share😊 at salamat din po na-iinspire rin ako mag content kapag may mga nababasa ako msgs galing sanyo na naiinspire rin. May mashare na simple tips base sa experience ko. Yung XL cups po pala maganda po siya sa mga fruiting plants as netcups lalo na sa kamatis , sili at talong. Hindi matutumba ang puno. Maraming salamat po ulit🌱😊

@topquark35 2 года назад

@@healinghobbies Your vids are a delight to folks like me na mahilig magtanim at magluto. Plan to watch a lot of your other vids tuwing may time. Maraming matutulungan at maiinspire talaga lalo na etong Kratky/hydroponics-related, especially sa mga panahon ngayon when laging may threat ng food crisis and minsan mahirap lumabas to get fresh veggies. Please keep doing what you're doing. Thank you so much as well! ❤

@montanateri6889 Год назад

Soil alreadt has nutrients in it, so one can't compare that way. Watering the soil cup with the same nutrient as the kratky will cause certain micro nutrients and even some major ones, to be duplicated as there are already nutrients in the soil. So the slower growth of the soil based plant could be because of nutient overload -- its getting nutrients from its soil and from the liquid. To compare, one needs to only fertilizer the soil container with the normal fertilizer you would use in soil and the kratky with the Hydroponic liquid fertilizer. If you adjust it that way and compare, I would guess they'd be the same growth rate in a indoor environment, but in an outdoor one with the soil you have to fight nature, pests, wind, storms, lack of sunshine, too much sunshine, etc... , so the outdoor tomato plant won't do as good as a protected indoor plant that has light fan blown breeze in exact doses.

@patrickwilson9783 Год назад

If you had an overabundance of nutrients then he would get pH lockout and that wasn't the case here also you would see nutrient burn and I did not see that also

@metro3692 3 месяца назад

How do you know the soil has nutes? I make my own. Peat moss,perlite,compost and worm castings. Not enough nutrients to do any harm.

@AgriNetzFarmtv 21 день назад

becuase you used chemical nutrient the soil is organic but i still go with organic

@present_vs_future 20 дней назад

what is wrong with going chemical?

@pablopope5145 23 дня назад

Dont eatvplants not grown in soil

@bobhopman4648 18 дней назад

@@pablopope5145 care to explain? Ideally with references, examples in current times, experimentation, trusted sources of information.

@pablopope5145 18 дней назад

@@bobhopman4648 common sense

@bobhopman4648 18 дней назад

@@pablopope5145 1 - misnomer it's not common 2 - if you grow them you have control over what you use so what inherently makes not using soil unhealthy 3 - can you actually try to be somewhat informative?