Field of Vision - In the Absence

Подписаться 19 тыс.

Просмотров 453 тыс.

50% 1

When the passenger ferry MV Sewol sank off the coast of South Korea in 2014, over three hundred people lost their lives, most of them schoolchildren. Years later, the victims’ families and survivors are still demanding justice from national authorities.
Directed by Yi Seung-Jun
See more from Field of Vision here: fieldofvision.org

Опубликовано:

29 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 674

@haruxzn3284 3 года назад

"I will bring you home with your friends. I will keep my promise" It hurts so much

@CaitlinxDavis 2 года назад

“when we left the scene, there were small birds in the rain and wind. those tiny birds were flying around in the storm. the birds were so tiny and beautiful and their call so touching. but it sounded like the students wailing, asking me not to leave them behind.” been two years since i first watch this documentary and that line still makes me sob my eyes out

@kkaeyuu 4 года назад

“they said, “it will be okay and stay put.” but only the people who didn’t follow the order survived.” - a passenger on sewol-ho this was exactly what happened to the passengers on sewol. on april 16th, the only people the survived, were the ones who broke the rules.

@divvimeghana6643 2 года назад

Yes it's true , it was heartbreaking, if they have just jumped in the water also may be with the life jackets they might be saved , why the government handled the situation like this oh my God, poor fellows can't imagine their suffering

@jhannettvegaa.7549 Год назад

때리고 싶었지만 그래도 달라지는 건 없었고, 움직이지도 말고 나가지도 말라고 해서 자기도 모르게 사형을 선고받았다.

@아이스블루-f5v 4 года назад

시간을 되돌릴수만 있다면, 화면속에서 꺼내 줄 수 있다면... 아이들의 얼굴을 손으로 쓰담어 보니 6년전 그때처럼 또다시 마음을 추수릴 수가 없네요. 어제 같은데 벌써 6년이란 시간이 지났다니 기가 막힙니다. 아직도 돌아오지 못한 3명의 아이들, 여전히 풀리지 않는 의문들... 우리는 모두가 죄인입니다. 미안해...잊지않을게 🎗

@The_Jakkal 4 месяца назад

T_T I know we don't know eachother, but * hugs *

@dramaqueen9228 4 года назад

24:23 the police officer wipping down her tears but not being able to open this door for them. It hit hard and in the heart. Following the orders must be so difficult sometimes.

@ipadista 2 года назад

I was about to post the same, Im glad somebody else noticed. Usually the terrible decisions are made by higher ups far away in an office, and the ground troops are forced to carry out cruel and often pointless actions just to save face, for those responsible for what transpires.

@j_117 Год назад

Oh boo-hoo, poor bootlickers, just as complicit..

@자유산행 4 года назад

기억해야할 분노의 사건을 담담하게 담은 영상에 경의를 표합니다. 이 짧은 영상이 그 날의 흔적을, 여운을 너무나 잘 담고 있기에 놀랐습니다. 고맙습니다...

@sfmelon 4 года назад

배가 뒤집히는 그 순간이 너무 슬프다. 민간잠수사님들의 떨리는 목소리가 너무 아프다. 빨리 낱낱이 진상이 밝혀졌으면....

@jungsong1626 4 года назад

It hurts, but we will watch and remember.

@elevatorface Год назад

As a British Korean, when this happened I was in Korea and heartbroken but unsurprised. By then I'd already spent decades in Korea. Even in 2023, whenever I talk about Korea to ppl I have a lot of indignance towards the country. If any country could have an incident like this (though Korea isn't the only one, though with this many youth fatalities it may be), it would be Korea. But this incident still hurts my heart and always will. Those poor children. I have to leave out some personal feelings towards the captain and majority of crewmates because of ToS. But there is smth specific that I defintely think those ppl should be doing sooner than later. And I hope they do. There's just so much anger and rage surrounding this particular incident, because the captain, majority of the crewmates, rescue, and the government did so many things wrong that many other countries wouldn't have. I want good things for Korea. But if this was going to happen anywhere, it was going to be Korea. I know things are a lot better now with their government. God bless the future generations, but I pray constantly that I don't have to go back there ever again, that I don't end up trapped again in a country with so much need to improve on so many fronts to the detriment to their people. I spent half my life there and it scarred me irreparably. All the native Korean friends I have there were grateful and hopeful that I could leave finally. Many Koreans are just as kind and brilliant as you can find anywhere else in the world. But leaving them in Korea, their country, felt like I was leaving them on a sinking ship. I hope Korea will continue to grow and be better for its people. They deserve a better country that what it has been so far.

@woollybullyz 4 года назад

마음이 아픕니다. 머라고 위로를 해야할지 모르겠지만 그고통 이루말할수 없겠지만 감히 힘내시라고 말씀드리고 싶습니다. 정말 우리는 이사건을 잊어서는 안될것입나다. 삼가고인의 명복을 다시한번 빕니다.

@dreamminn 3 года назад

It's been 7 Years now... my love and prayers are with the victims family and friends.🎗

@lovesue761 4 года назад

다시 또 아프네요ㅠㅠ 아카데미 본선진출을 축하드리며 더욱 널리 알려지길~🙏 잊지않았고 진상규명과 책임자처벌을 간절히 빕니다!

@ahoybobby 4 года назад

I feel so sad that this is the first time I am learning about this disaster. This was not reported well in the US

@Whofan06 4 года назад

A story of everyone involved waiting for instructions from the people above them or the people they were supposed to trust and none of it ever came, and everyone at the top just assumed everything was okay because they weren't listening to any other information. It's haunting that those kids predicted their own fate by saying the people who ignored the subway stay put order survived. Everyone who fought for themselves survived and everyone who trusted their leaders lost their lives. I almost couldn't blame the president at one point when the rescuers literally put on a show instead of doing anything to make her think it was good. I imagine its hard to lead when everyone just blows smoke up your ass. But she's the one that created the culture that made that necessary and more important than actually doing a damn thing. I feel like that crying police officer says a lot, what it feels like to be a cog in the wheels of a broken machine, trying your best to keep working or being unable to cause nothing else around you is doing its job, least of all the elites. The two parts that sickened me the most were seeing the fuck-ass captain escaping first, and the order to evacuate and rescue coming when the whole ship was already underwater. How disconnected from reality can you possibly be while those kids depended on you? May they rest in peace, they didn't deserve such a failure from the grown ass adults in the world.

@longmire5504 4 года назад

To me, this disaster would be an unforgettable tragedy for the rest of my life. Since it has been passed almost 6 yrs, I still cry whenever I see this video. At that time, the President was Park-Keun-hye. She´d been impeached and sentenced 30 years in prison of the corruptions and duty abandonment. Personally, she must have deserved to be sentenced by death sentence.

@isabelford7715 3 года назад

A big salute to the civilian divers!!! You guys are the real heroes!

@jinsungkim4710 4 года назад

세월호 생각만해도 지금도 눈물이..언제쯤.. 괜찮아질까요.. 더 분통터지는건 저기 관련자들은 다 승진했다는거..

@뿡가-k1h 4 года назад

ㅠㅠ.그때를생각하면가슴이찢어질만큼아프네요. 박근혜와자한당을용서할수없어요.두번다시이런일이일어나서는안됩니다ㅠㅠ

@alix4949 3 года назад

I was on the other ferry, and on the way to Jeju. On April 16, we knew that the ferry was tilting. I thought they were still alive because everyone was telling the news, but I remember my sister was on this ferry, and she was saved.

@starsandsunsets 4 года назад

Thank you. This is heartbreaking and I pray that everyone will get the justice they deserve. And peace for the families left behind.

@난나나나쏴-p1b 4 года назад

처음 세월호라는 소식을 접한 초등학생이었었던 나는 수련회가 취소되어서 속상한 마음만 들고 세월호 사건에 대해서 그렇게 깊게 생각하지 못했었지만 지금은 그때 단원고 학생들과 같은 나이가 되니 마음이 너무 무겁다. 그리고 예전에 생각했던 세월호에 대해 관심을 가지지 않고 그냥 넘겼던 나를 원망한다. 아마도 배 안에서 제주도에서 어떤 일을 할지 설레는 마음으로 이야기를 했었을텐데... 진짜 이 영상을 보고 1분도 안돼서 눈물이 흘렀다.그 황금같은 시간에 구조를 할 생각을 하지 않는 저렇게 무책임한 선장과 선원, 헬기 두 대...정말 어이가 없어서 말이 안나온다. 분명 초기 대응을 잘했더라면 이렇게 많은 사람들이 나오진 않았을 거라고 생각한다. 정확하게 사건을 이해하고 지시했더라면 이 정도로 많은 사망자가 나오지 않았을것이다. 잊지 않겠습니다🎗

@Jumpingkitty 4 года назад

잊지 않겠습니다

@milknattawadee3133 3 года назад

เต็มติ๊กต๊อกเลยจนเราต้องได้มาดู หดหู่ใจมากคะ จนไม่อยากเห็นอีกเลย เศร้าใจ 🎗️🎗️🇹🇭🇰🇷

@양영주-u8e 4 года назад

물위의 작은새가 가지말라고 하는거같다는 말에 하염없이 눈물이 나네요.구할수있는 생명을 안구하는 이런 비극은 없어야합니다.

@yiessyv.5228 5 месяцев назад

23:57 Seeing the pain of those parents, my god I could not help crying, how unfair they were to them.

@user-dasilta 4 года назад

우리는 잊지 않습니다...

@INOCUBE 4 года назад

잊지 않을께~~

@rini177 2 года назад

they cared more about being seen as a hero and making a good scene than they did about the fact that these kids were about to drown, that makes me so infuriated

@yanilee5456 4 года назад

Remember, Remind. 왜냐고 다시 한번 잊지말고 물을 수 있기를

@초딩-y4s 4 года назад

기록하고 기억해주셔서 감사합니다

@jabbasmovies 4 года назад

What an incredibly powerful and sad film.

@Wowboy77 4 года назад

아카데미 도서관에 영구 보존되겠죠

@dhstyle77 4 года назад

슬픔이 바다가 되어 그 안에 내 눈물을 가둔다.

@프리-k4u 4 года назад

두려워 못 보겟습니다. 분노가 치밀어 오릅니다. 나쁜넘들~~~

@dddaa25 4 года назад

the only thing that came across to my mind while watching this is "what if those so-called rescuer's families who were trapped in the ship instead? will they help and rescue passengers more seriously?" i mean, the tragedy happened in South Korea and in 2014, which means the technology is much more advanced. especially it happened not really far from the mainland (it's different if happened in the middle of the high seas). but why do they, especially government and coast guard, act like it's just a small matter and didn't take it seriously? there's no problem with the communication too. i'm really glad the responsible ones of this tragedy are punished, but the dead of innocent people won't be back....

@saramsarams 4 года назад

잊지않을게요 미안합니다

@Baekisung 4 года назад

정말 눈물이 나서 제대로 못보겠네요. ㅠㅠ 아무리 우파 유튜버들이 그냥 덮어버리려고 애를 써도, 절대로 우리가 잊어서는 안됩니다. 부재의 기억, 즉 국가부재의 기억이지요. 나쁜 놈들 천벌을 받을 것이에요 !!!!!

@loirentchavarria5185 2 года назад

estoy muy impactada con lo sucedió...me impresiona la negligencia te TANTO LA PRESIDENTE COMO DE LA GUARDIA COSTERA....DE MI PARTE SIENTO UN DOLOR TERRIBLE Y NO ME IMAGINO COMO SE SENTIRÁN LOS PADRES O SERES QUERIDOS QUE PERDIERON A UN SER AMADO...SE QUE YO NO PASE POR ESE ACCIDENTE PERO HUBIERA DADO LO QUE FUERA PARA QUE NO PASARA Y NO SE PERDIERAN TANTAS VIDAS🥺😭MIS MAS SENTIDO PÉSAME PARA AQUELLAS PERSONAS QUE PERDIERON A SUS SERES QUERIDOS😢ESTE HECHO ES DEMASIADO FUERTE Y MUY TRÁGICO

@scalezzsss5344 3 года назад

if they was not waiting..they would have survived

@จิราพรไกลทุกข์ 3 года назад

ฉันเสียใจกับเหตุการณ์ครั้งนี้😔❤

@통치꽁조림-o5l 4 года назад

왜 애들보고 움직이지 말라 했습니까..왜 가만히 있으라고 한거에요

@영화병동24시 4 года назад

We are deeply grateful to FIELD OF VISION for investing on the theme of the Sewol ferry disaster. I am so grateful that the In the Ansence was nominated for the Academy Awards. The vast ocean expressed on the screen feels really frustrating. I would like to thank the producers and director Lee Seung-jun recording all the memories so that we can remember the memories that we can never forget. We upload RU-vid review of In the Absence. -> ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-cDsKleWT_aQ.html 세월호참사를 주제로 투자를 해주신 FIELD OF VISION 에 깊이 감사드립니다. 부재의기억이 아카데미상 후보에 오른 것을 정말 감사하게 생각합니다. 화면에 표현된 망망대해가 참으로 막막하게 느껴집니다. 결코 잊을 수 없는 기억을 기록으로라도 기억할 수 있도록 남겨주신 제작사와 이승준 감독님께 감사하고 응원을 드립니다. 부재의 기억 유튜브 영화평을 올려봅니다. -> ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-cDsKleWT_aQ.html

@haroldkang3056 4 года назад

학생들 얼굴만은 가슴이 아파서 정말로 못보겠네요....

@TheCristii25 Год назад

Que horrible e indignante la negligencia por todas partes, primero con un Capitán cuyo cargo le quedó muy grande, hasta la guardia costera y la presidenta. ¿Como es posible que van a mandar un solo bote de la guardia costera para al menos 300 personas en emergencias? si el capitán fue el primero en abandonar el ferry, UN FERRY, mínimo debieron hacerse la idea de la cantidad de personas que habían allí, en serio que da mucha pena e indignación porque esas vidas pudieron haberse salvado a tiempo de no ser por esas personas tan mediocres :'(

@이지나-o3c 4 года назад

대통령, 국회의원 잘못 뽑은 우리 어른때문에

@foxdebb 4 года назад

11: 10 초 누구냐?

@loisagbas9208 4 года назад

"Dont tell me to wait, the kids were killed while waiting"

@sph6908 4 года назад

I’m one of the people who worked directly at the scene immediately after the sinking. I feel this movie largely skipped a very important part - the utterly incomprehensible behavior of state agencies in the days following the sinking. The days immediately afterwards when the parents came to the small port from which rescue works were organized and still hoped their child may have survived in one of the airpockets. The heart-wrenching hours and days of desperation when the parents waited and stared at the ocean imagining their child just about clinging to life in the dark and cold water inside the ship while the time was clicking by and nothing was hapenning. The way the government treated the parents. The way the government agencies including the coast guard sabotaged the efforts of civilian divers and civilian scientists and specialist who came to help. The way the high government official took the helicopter that was supposed to transport a korean student in serious condition from the port to hospital. The student then had to be transported by road, which took a lot of time and the student died.... there’s just so many things... I feel this part was just brushed over in the movie. The reality was much worse and really truly utterly incomprehensible. It’s scary that a government of a democratic country could reach such lows. I’m proud that at the end the Korean people took power into their hands and the government has changed. Korea reforms really fast and I have hopes for the future but the Sewol times were really a dark period...

@Sea_witch_ 4 года назад

I'm so sorry for what you had to go through, and the pain and endless suffering the families cling to now, I only pray for them to be blessed and continue their lives in peace, and for the lost ones to find the light. Such a shame that the gov. had to act that way, the disappointing actions of ex-president Park will not be forgotten, and I hope nowadays they act differently than their past leaders. Do you know by chance any other video that could give me a more detailed explanation of the tragedy? Its hard to look for in english or english subs :/ Bless you.

@Whofan06 4 года назад

I feel like they got the incomprehensibility across pretty well with what they did cover, I can only imagine the rest. They mentioned how they didn't bother telling anyone there were no air pockets and no hope from day one, and refused to let the divers keep working for 3 years. I'm proud there was some accountability in that government, I feel like if this happened in the US everyone would cry and protest but not a single politician, let alone the president, would lose their job, and it would be business as usual. Its a shame they had such a failure of leadership in the first place but its hopeful to see that being rectified, even if it is too little too late.

@yeonkkot 4 года назад

I would recommend you: ‚Crossroads’by a British film maker Neil George. ‚Diving Bell’ shows the hardship and the desperate situations of the civil divers and the headless, cold and corrupt government Koreas at that time.

@Sea_witch_ 4 года назад

@@yeonkkot thank you kindly!

@bluecarps 3 года назад

They were all my age and I just can't stop crying. All of them would've been starting work now. I wonder what profession each of them would have wonderfully filled. They all sounded so witty, so full of life, optimism, hope and trust. I wonder how vivaciously each one of them would've developed their personalities. They all listened so well, they were all such good boys and girls, if only the adults instructing them weren't as selfish, self-serving, negligent, lazy and evil as people. I really hope and pray from the bottom of my heart that they are all happy and in peace now. Hope they always remain just as full of joy, life and happiness. Do you have any resources that I can read up on to know about all the other issues, discrepancies and corruption that wasn't covered in this film? I don't know why but for some inexplicable reason I just can't move on from this tragedy after having viewed this film 3 days ago. I keep revisiting the student's recordings, the parent's and divers interviews. My mind always seems to steer back to the victims', several times throughout the day, despite trying to distract myself. The sharp aching pain with each in take of breathe that I get, makes me feel like, those last moments of recorded film are of my very own friends. Friends I knew, friends I wanted to have in my life as I grew up. I get chocked up with an overwhelming sense of loss, even though I never knew a single person on board and don't even speak the same language or share the same nationality. I lost both my parents to horrific murders when I was 11, their death is also shrouded under government corruption and agenda and I never really had hope for any justice or reconciliation. I also similarly didn't know for 3 days if my parents were dead or alive, while helplessly watching the situation being broadcasted on all national tv channels..Maybe that's the reason why I am drawn to the victims of Sewol, due to certain similar experiences and age. Anyway, I would greatly appreciate any resource you can direct me towards.

@amypond2180 4 года назад

“I remember everything with acute pain, I cannot forget. But how come you, the elites of the society claim that you don’t know and you don’t remember?” -late Kim Gwan Hong

@nabi617 4 года назад

Late Kim Gwan Hong was a volunteer diver for Sewol rescue operation.

@amypond2180 4 года назад

Insoon Kim yeah I know. It’s to painful for him to heard those elites said something like that.

@bangtanfoxy 4 года назад

ru-vid.com/group/PLj0tACTYfiV7CwsrzzeE28Yl613Zk3nFX

@NanaD-ve9tt 3 года назад

This is so so heartbreaking.I’m American so it’s very hard to watch some of the documumentaries. One was a 8 hour show. It broke my heart as the narrator was one of the fathers of a child on sewol ferry. I couldn’t understand a lot of the comparisons bcuz they were in Korean but it had English subtitles and I get most of what happened well, actually what didn’t happen and the neglect and the coverup. I wish I could understand more of what happened but I understand the heartbreak and anger. The part that really gets me is of course no one deserves to be left to die and when it’s children it’s just worse but these kids were so dam obedient and trustworthy and they were betrayed they were failed they were lied to. The captain and the employees were to see the passengers safety first. The fact that citizens cared more than the people responsible is just ridiculous on the part of those at fault! Not even sympathetic at all. My heart goes out to all of the families.

@NanaD-ve9tt 3 года назад

What was the reason they told the kids to stay put?? Why didn’t they want them on deck in life vests ? At least to try and be saved I totally am confused??

@oatmeal3423 4 года назад

I’m not even a South Korean, but this tragic incident will forever pain my heart. I cannot even begin to imagine how the victims must have felt when they realised the help they were waiting for all along was never going to arrive. The pain and sorrow their loved ones will carry for the rest of their lives, knowing the cruel fact that their children were brutally left to die in the sinking ship. The guilt they are not responsible for but will carry, for telling their loved ones to obey instructions for their safety. I’m not sure about this, but I read that there was a recent re-investigation into the case, and I hope it finally brings the truth to light, and finally give closure to all that need it to move on. I don’t want to wish evil on anybody, but I sincerely wish that those responsible for these children’s deaths are prosecuted, and may they rot in hell, and even then, it will never be enough compensation. I am not religious, but I pray and hope that these students are in a better place, and they can rest in peace, somehow. Lastly, though it will literally not make any difference, I will make it a point to visit the memorial site when I’m in Korea one day, and let them know that I’m just one of the many who will remember their lives. 🕯🙏

@rylamontefalco7040 3 года назад

"Kids were killed while waiting. They waited and died". It hurts so much for a parent who has lost a child 😭

@hyeonsukyang2366 4 года назад

Don't move. Stay still where you are now. And the ship captain was rescued by maritime police first. He is not a human.

@aderynmawr 3 года назад

That was a truly disgusting act - to leave his ship with so many people still aboard.

@containedchaos3661 5 лет назад

I cried so hard. It took me an hour to finish this. I am so angry at how poorly the situation was "handled". The kids could have been saved!! Even the civilian diver said so. Those poor kids!!! And the diver that committed suicide because of the trauma. I'm glad the President was impeached but I wanna know if the other "elites" were punished too

@vb8428 4 года назад

She took the blame for many of the company and goverment officials poor handling

@habitusb 4 года назад

sadly.. “the elites” they were not punished at all. the Truth of Sewol is sunk still.

@skman1 4 года назад

The other “elites” should be punished. And I believe it will be done some day.

@깐따삐야-w4w 4 года назад

V B What responsibility did she take? She and key government officials at that time concealed the case and evaded responsibility. No one was punished. The victim's family still demands punishment. The Attorney General at that time is now a major opposition leader and is looking for the next general election. This is ridiculous.

@깐따삐야-w4w 4 года назад

MiekoNeko 웃기지마. 뭐가 역겨운데? 대통령 이라는 사람이 무책임을 넘어 국민을 기만했어. 사건 당시는 물론 사건 후에 그녀는 희생자 가족들에게 어떤 협조도 하지 않고, 제대로 된 조사도 하지 않았어. 희생자의 유가족들은 여전히 사건의 진실을 요구하고 제대로 된 수사를 요구하고 있어. 아는척 가짜 정보 흘리지마. 역겨우니까.

@wrongorange 3 года назад

it is so hurtful to hear them talk about making a good scene at around 11:00 THESE ARE REAL LIVES OF CHILDREN you can't use those to boost your reputation and your ego

@fia9514 3 года назад

Ikr it's really disgusting

@aderynmawr 3 года назад

All they cared about was themselves and how they’d be perceived. A lot of those people should be in jail.

@melissaq8854 3 года назад

if they wanted to make a good scene they wouldve reacted fast and done more to get the kids out

@JJangByung 4 года назад

아카데미 지명보고 알게되었다. 왠만한 세월호 다큐는 다 봤다고 생각했는데... 기생충 6개부문 노미네이션만큼이나 기쁜 소식이지만, 정작 이렇게 보고나니 또 힘들다. 우리 시대의 트라우마. 하지만 이렇게 계속 아파야 잊지 않고 기억하는거겠지.

@520번버스언제오냐 4 года назад

저도 아카데미 지명 소식 듣고 왔습니다.. 이렇게 많은 시간이 흘렀음에도 또 아프네요

@NetsiJoni 4 года назад

아마도 남은 시간 ...진실을 알게 된다해도..우리의 트라우마로 남게 되겟죠...

@cat1024 4 года назад

단편수상기대해보았는데..놓쳤지만..지명된것만으로..세계에.알릴수있는기회겠죠~~어제.. 기생충 4관왕을해서 들떴지만..평생잊으면 안될일이죠.. 지도자를 진짜 잘뽑아야된다는걸 세월호이후로알게됐죠~~ㅠㅠ

@깊카만원 4 года назад

저도 마음이 아픕니다.....

@txxx.yung117 4 года назад

No entendí 😔🎗️

@chebbbbb 4 года назад

6년 전 그날 일어났던 끔찍한 참사와 그 이후 이어졌던 부끄러운 일들을 다시 한번 상기시켜주네요. 누군가 영상으로, 글로 계속 기록하고 전하는 덕분에 더 잊지 않고 기억할 수 있습니다. 고맙습니다. 그리고 지금 우리가 이 영상에서 볼 수 있는 것들보다 훨씬 더 많은 부분들이 투명하고 명확하게 드러나게 되길 원합니다. 대통령기록물로 지정된 세월호 사건 관련 자료들의 공개를 촉구합니다.

@Cristina-Dwk23 3 года назад

Mis más sincero pésame a las familias que perdieron a sus seres queridos 😞😞 en esta tragedia. Paz a todas sus almas 🙏

@stay6102 3 года назад

una pregunta a la chica que le borraron la cara que estaba con las demas , es por que murio o por que esta viva? perdon por preguntar eso

@Fersi11 3 года назад

@@stay6102 Lo mismo me pregunto

@dominicespinosa6576 3 года назад

@@stay6102 lo más probable que muerta y la censuren por respeto

@stay6102 3 года назад

@@dominicespinosa6576 aaaah gracias por decirme 🤗

@vb8428 4 года назад

Glad it got that Oscar nom, I never knew this story in such grim detail.

@bangtanfoxy 4 года назад

ru-vid.com/group/PLj0tACTYfiV7CwsrzzeE28Yl613Zk3nFX

@홍홍홍-d4q 4 года назад

슬퍼도 눈 감지말고 두 눈 부릅 뚜고 보고 또 봐야 할 영상... 그리고 꼭 기억해야 할 영상... 잊지 않고 있습니다 기억하고 있습니다 이제 곧 그날이 또 돌아오겠지만 유족분들의 마르지 않는 눈물은 진실규명만이 멈추게 할 수 있는데 대한민국 사법부는 ...

@이승정-n5j 4 года назад

네 울면서 보고있어요 울면서.....

@cat1024 4 года назад

@@이승정-n5j 첫 시작부터..울고있어요~~애들 얼마나 무서웠을까?ㅠㅠㅠ

@웃음향기-w3n 4 года назад

맘아파 못보겠어요.

@dirtyboom7 4 года назад

하필이면 그 순간에 발현된 인간들의 집단적인 멍청함이 한도 끝도 없이 원망스럽고 저정도로 멍청한 대화들이 오고가는게 나는 지금도 도저히 믿어지지가 않는다 오죽했으면 차라리 음모론이 더 귀에 들리는거 아닌가.. 도무지 믿어지지 않을 정도로 멍청한 인간들이.. 아직도 무죄라는건 또 얼마나 이나라 지휘체계와 법이 엉망진창인건지 종합적으로 잘 보여주는것 같다

@Dokjaga 4 года назад

Last year I graduated from high school and even received flowers, now I am 20. Just thinking any of them was the same age as me...breaks my heart. How hopeless did them feel? when I think of them, my tears blind my eyes...I'm foreigner, honestly nationality should not matter in these cases, this is something we should not forget even whether we are Korean or not. *Let us always remember 2014.4.16* As long as I live, them too, 4.16 forever in my memory.

@jinriking 4 года назад

so do I

@bangtanfoxy 4 года назад

ru-vid.com/group/PLj0tACTYfiV7CwsrzzeE28Yl613Zk3nFX

@이대순-x4p 4 года назад

이거 찿기 힘들었습니다. 한글판도 올려주새요.아카데미 지명되고야 알게됨 . 의도된 살인인데. 누가 왜 구랬는지... 박정희때도 비슷한 사건이 있었다고함.

@eungjukim9257 4 года назад

진짜 열불 난다. 이런 거지같은놈들때문에 애들이 죽은 생각을 하니.

@sowoojoo 4 года назад

if only the children ignore the announcement from captain to stay still inside the ship... there must be more survivor.. everyone, trust your guts when you were facing the same situation. you are the most precious soul for your own self afterall

@ShrooMIR05 4 года назад

It breaks my heart but i can't blame them, when we were young we were told to listen to our elders, because the elders are full of wisdom. On this situation they had to rely to the adults, they had to listen to the adults. My hand was shaking as i was watching the footage of the kids sitting and laying casually, chatting and waiting to be rescued, and knowing none of these kids were saved, it just so traumatizing to watch. I can't finish watching this.

@sowoojoo 4 года назад

See how the student's parents regretted not to ask their children to get out from the ship?? I can't believe on society anymore because in the end of the day, the one who trully care about us except our own self was our parents.

@allanc750 4 года назад

I was in Gwangju at the time and was watching the news early morning and this was being reported live. i kept watching and an hour goes by and thought "how come they're not doing anything to save the passengers?". another hour goes by and the ship was listing even more. My heart sank as the ship went down and all you can see was the tip of the ship. Never in my life that i could experience something like this just watching helplessly. It hurts just to watch this again feeling for those many young lives lost which could have been saved.

@fia9514 3 года назад

Yeah, but in that situation people usually believe in the people in charge.. maybe they were following the instructions because they trusted the captain, the crews, and the rescue team. Such a shame those people betrayed the passenger's trust and just saved themselves.

@kiri1204 4 года назад

왜 그랬을까요? 왜 그 아이들을 구하지 않았을까요? 무엇을 위해 그랬을까요? 아직도 풀리지 않는 제 마음속의 의문입니다. 잊지 않겠습니다. 20140416

@즈아가-d9h 4 года назад

모든 사건은 나중에 누가 최종적으로 이익을 얻느냐 보면 그게 범인이지.

@뒤죽박죽익명 4 года назад

@엔터채널 너?

@김기원-n2h 4 года назад

@엔터채널 댓글 수준하고는...ㅈㄱㅇㅅㄲ

@돼지파괴자 4 года назад

전국민을 살인의 목격자로 만들어버린......

@Hillers62 4 года назад

박 대통령은 부패한 방식으로 궁극적으로 책임을졌다

@noodsofnoods 4 года назад

I was at the different ferry on the same sea, same time, and for the same reason - Apr. 16th 2014, on the way of school trip to jeju island. When my friends (we were 15) saw the news at first, we thought it wasn't a big deal. Why? because the news said "all students have been rescued", which soon revealed that it was fucking misinformed. They wore life vests and even took a chance to play with it, without chances to know the true situation. Though I was not involved in the tragedy, I remember my whole family called to me and crying, I remember the rage when the number of survivals goes down from over 300 to less than 100, due to the misinformation. I just hope this kind of hellhole never happens again. Thank you for making this, and congrats for nomination on Oscar.

@simesno4137 4 года назад

Many thanks for sharing this, this was absolutely tragic. Regards from Spain. 💛💛💛

@badirang84 4 года назад

어느새 6년이되어갑니다.. 하지만여전히 진실규명은 이루어지질않았습니다.. 올해는꼭 진실규명이이뤄져서 돌아가신분들과 유가족분들의 한이풀리면좋겠습니다.

@BM-zw2vi 4 года назад

아프고 괴로워도 똑바로 마주하며 절대 잊지 말아야 할 기억을 다시 상기시켜 주셔서 고맙습니다. 내 아이, 친구, 가족을 잃어 누구보다 더 괴로울 사람들이 저 너머 진실을 위해 싸우고 있습니다. 반드시 모든 일이 투명하게 드러나길 바랍니다. 그래야 곁을 지키고 있는 사람들도 조금 더 마음 편히 보내 줄 수 있고, 먼저 떠난 사람들도 편히 잠들 수 있을 테니까요. 힘냅시다. 힘내세요. 절대 잊지 맙시다. 세월호는 사고가 아닌 사건이라는 것을 절대 잊지 마세요.

@schneiderx7 4 года назад

우리는 잊지 않습니다

@NetsiJoni 4 года назад

@엔터채널 이상하게 너같은 넘들이 튀나오거든.....불안해?

@yesican0907 4 года назад

@엔터채널 뭐지 이 모지란 일베새끼는?

@동산맛-e1u 4 года назад

얼마나 이 나라에 무능력한 인간들이 정권을 잡았었는지, 얼마나 능력없는 공무원들이 요직에 앉아서 일했었는지 뼈저리게 보고 느꼈던 사건이었다.

@melinauwu7160 3 года назад

Apenas me vengo enterando y si me pego muy fuerte esa noticia tan fea, espero que estén bien todos 🎗️♥️

@woowooHoot 4 года назад

잊지 않아야 하고 아직도 드러나지 않은 그날의 진실을 반드시 밝혀야 합니다.

@쾌청-p2l 4 года назад

부재의 기억 , Could you wright it in Korean titles for korean people can search? Please. Because when I heard that this movie was on RU-vid, I was so happy, but I couldn't find it right away. I wish more people could watch such a good movie. Thank you.

@auraxxs8851 3 года назад

You should also watch: Diving bell the truth shall not sink with Sewol.

@Hi-lb8cq 3 года назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-54RNX_LUqV0.html

@Hi-lb8cq 3 года назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-54RNX_LUqV0.html

@LilyKim1011 4 года назад

세월호 사건 이후, 생존자 가족도 유가족도 아닌 저는, 세월호 사건 관련 영상과 기사를 피했고 그래서 보지 않았어요. 너무 거대한 슬픔이라 그 사건에 다가가지 않았고, 그저 상투적인 동정만 했던 거 같아요. 이런 제 마음이 진실을 외면했네요. 앞으로는 똑바로 보고 똑바로 듣고 외면하지 않겠습니다.

@movietrailerkor 4 года назад

아카데미상 후보 축하드립니다.

@mediaian8767 4 года назад

"부재의 기억", 유튜브에서 검색하기 불가능해요. 온갖 기레기들의 뉴스들만 올라와요. 영어 외에도, 한글 제목으로도 검색될 수 있게, 신경 좀 써주세요.~

@bindeulangel4006 4 года назад

7:6 청와대에서 10시15분에 전화해서 대뜸 세월호 침몰 영상 보내라고 그걸 빨리 가져와야 한다고.. 아이들은 죽어가고 있는데 박근혜에게 보여줄 영상이 더 중요한 저 미친자들... 정말 화가 치밀어 오릅니다. 정말 인간들이 아니네요.. 짐승 보다 못한 자들이네요..ㅠㅠ

@aeun71 4 года назад

vip 어디 해상관광 온거같네....열불나네....7시간 어디 쳐박혀 있다가 배 침몰하고 애들 다 죽고나니 침몰배 구경하러 왔냐?????

@heeut 4 года назад

룰루랄라 속 편하게 살던 내가 촛불을 들게 만든 사건.

@jameswu8292 4 года назад

If you look closely at 9:21, you can see a student trapped inside the boat desperately punching the window trying to escape :(

@fia9514 3 года назад

Is it on the upper window? I had to slowed the video down to see it

@florallswann 3 года назад

@@fia9514 Down by the water. I think it's their arm. God.. it hurts to see that there were still kids in there who never escaped.

@aderynmawr 3 года назад

@@fia9514 I make it at 9:22 - the third window from the left. There’s a red and white buoy or life jacket or something just below it. It’s incredibly sad.

@aderynmawr 3 года назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-MkyFbcnIQV4.html

@shangimishra8881 3 года назад

@@aderynmawr yes I saw it 😭😭😭😭😭

@희망찬세상-v6c 4 года назад

아이구 울화통터져 구조할 시간이 충분하고도 넘쳤는데 도대체 모하고 있었던건지

@T얼바인 4 года назад

영상 시작 2분, 기울어진 배에 탄 천진 난만한 아이들이 나온다. 눈물이 터지고 숨이 막혀 STOP을 눌렀다. 내 생애 영원히 볼 수 없는 다큐멘터리가 될 듯 싶다.Two minutes into the video, there are innocent children on a tilted boat. Tears burst and suffocated, pressing the STOP button on the video. I think it will be a documentary that I will never see in my life.

@andiuptown1711 4 года назад

😪

@clownk7218 4 года назад

인명구조에 '대부분 나왔다' '거의 다 나왔다' 이게 말이 됩니까 단 한 명이 배에 갇혀있다고 생각해도 그렇게 속 편한 소리 못하죠. 인간이라면. 정말 당신들이 인간입니까

@wednesday658 4 года назад

먹먹하다.. 죽음앞에 가족을 보고싶어하며 숨막혀죽어가던 아이들을 생각하면.. 머리로 알고있던 내용에 대해 영상을보며 이제야 아이들을 위한 눈물을 흘린다.. 가족들에게 어떤 위로도 힘이 되지 않을것 만같다 세월호 이후 결혼하고 세아이의.엄마가 된지금 우리 아이가 저 안에 있을거란 상상만으로도 마음이 감당이.안된다 이 큰 희생을 치룬 아이들과 유족을 통해.. 그 희생이.헛되지않도록 정부의 부정부패와 구조환경의 비리가 조금도 남지않고 훤히 밝혀지고 새롭게 바르고 청결하게 세워지길 기도하고 기도한다

@수구레-z1d 4 года назад

이늠들 때문에 몇십년을 힘들게 살고 있다. 하지만 멀리 떠난 우리의 아이들을 생각하면 네가 격는 피해는 아무것도 아닌 것 같다. 난 아직도 살아있으니......

@The_Jakkal 4 месяца назад

You don't know me, but * hugs *

@ym3707 4 года назад

진실이 아직도 밝혀지지않고... 슬픔은 아직도 계속되고 있고... 숨기고픈 자들의 발악은 끝을 모르고 있네요....ㅜㅜ

@Jay-ty9km 4 года назад

2020 OSCAR NOMINEE. 11:20 Chilling !!! (VOICE) (Before the ferry sank) "we should have landed on the ship earlier and made a GOOD SHOW. It's a shame...!!!" I will pray for a thousand years for the WHOLE truth to come out. Never again, never! *** SEWOL FERRY MASSACRE 4.16.2014 *** 소름. (음성) 세월호가 침몰하기 전에 선상에 항공 구조단을 "진작 좀 내렸다가 그.림.이.됐.어.야.하.는.데..." 천년이 지나도 잊혀지지 않고 이 악마들의 만행이 낱낱히 드러나길 소원합니다.

@starsandsunsets 4 года назад

To the makers of this documentary, congratulations on the Oscars nomination.

@heojaeseok6554 4 года назад

잊지않겠습니다. 우리는 진실이 밝혀지기를 기도합니다.

@badirang84 4 года назад

내가족이이런일을겪을수도 있는문제입니다.. 지겹다고하시는분들은 좀인간다운생각을하시면 좋겠습니다

@letshaveameal1804 4 года назад

아.....마음이 또...미어집니다... 누구는 그러더군요...지겨운이야기다..지친다고. 시간이 많이 지났지만..그날의 슬픔과 먹먹함은 지금도 생생합니다 머나먼 바다로 기나긴 여행을 떠나신 그날의 모든분들을 위해... 구조시 실수와 과오는 분영히 밝혀서 다음의 재난을 분명히 대비해야합니다 참...책임자들의 무능과 책임회피는 곧 살인과 직결되는 일임을 알하야하며...모든 책임자들은 무거운 처벌로 경각심을 주어야합니다....

@powerful4232 4 года назад

배가 어느정도 기울어지면 침몰할꺼란 예상을하고 안내방송으로 퇴선명령을 내려야 하는데 반대로 가만있어라고 하는게 옳은 선택이었을까,골든타임에 헬기가 2대나 뜨있는데 적극적으로 구조행위를 하는 인원이 보이지 않는게 정상인가 여객선에 사람이 안보이는데 배에 연락하여 구명조끼입혀 퇴선시켜야 했고 구조대 내려보내고 헬기방송으로도 퇴선명령 했어면 최대한의 인명을 구할수 있지 안았을까, 초동에서 현장에서 적극적으로 대응하는 인원이 하나도 볼수없어니 평소에 훈련이 안되있는듯하다 지휘부도 현황파악을 하고 골든타임안에 적극적구조 지시를 내렸다면 그나마 많은 인원을 구했을 것이다. ''사고는 났어나 그들은 철저한 외톨이였다,,

@mirunamu4100 4 года назад

잊지 않겠습니다. 진실이 밝혀지길 바랍니다

@jazzycozzy 4 года назад

5년을 넘게 파헤쳤는데 무슨 진실을 원하는 걸까? 진짜 박근혜가 오컬드 영화마냥 제물로 바쳤다느니 하는 이야길 믿는 거?

@kyuberry8871 3 года назад

es humillante e insolente como todos mis compañeros de clase dejaron en visto mis mensajes acerca de esto. Si yo llevo llorando por esto desde que tengo la capacidad de realizar las cosas imaginate los padres, pero no solo ellos, sino tambien los supervivientes. Todos quieren sobrevivir hasta que se dan cuenta de que es mejor morir con tus amigos que tener un trauma de por vida

@김프로-r7n 4 года назад

사랑스런 아이들...왜 안구했을까.

@edancho2943 4 года назад

전부 다 구명보트 입어놓고 간판에 나와 있으라고만했어도 살았는데.....ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 또래 아이 엄마라 세월호관련 영상은 볼때마다 울게됩니다.

@johnkim6939 4 года назад

다시 봐도 가슴이 아프다.. 자한당 니들은 용서가 안된다 절대 잊지 않겠다

@김영미-o3o7o 4 года назад

민주당은 없었나요??

@김기원-n2h 4 года назад

@@김영미-o3o7o 한심하다 보고를 받고 움직여야했던 주축을 놔두고 이런데 와서 에라이 정신 나간것아

@김기원-n2h 4 года назад

@@김영미-o3o7o 너나 쳐 주무세요

@김기원-n2h 4 года назад

@@김영미-o3o7o 어 그럼 이제 자 잘자

@이은해와계곡여행 4 года назад

@@김영미-o3o7o 니는 문재인 싫은게 아니라 그렇게 자한당이 좋은거겠지~

@narasarang6380 4 года назад

아직도 심장이 떨리고 맘이 아파서 제대로 보지를 못하겠네요 ㅠ

@heyimolga6215 4 года назад

At 11:30 when the person said everyone was saved and no one was inside the ship.... The tone of his voice was very odd. I could tell he was lying through his teeth about the situation when he said everyone was safe. Idk how to explain this but 'ah y-yeah... They were saved' it sounded to me like 'ah yeah... Of course they were saved...( Not (they're not saved)') ' I hope someone understands what I am trying to say