FNAF Theory: They're Still Not Free! (FNAF Security Breach) 

Something that I don't see people talk a lot about is how important FNaF2 is to understanding the origins of Golden Freddy. In the first game, if you punched in "1987" on the custom night menu, you would get jumpscared by Golden Freddy and your game would crash. Most people chalk it up as a fun little Easter egg but knowing that FNaF2 takes place in 1987 we start painting a picture. Golden Freddy is in FNaF2, but he's different now. In the first game Golden Freddy had a chance to randomly appear at any night at any time, but not in FNaF2. Instead, Golden Freddy doesn't appear until Night 6, the same night that Phone Guy tells us "someone used one of the suits- We had a spare in the back, a yellow one. Someone used it- Now none of them are acting right." Whatever happened with that "yellow suit" was the catalyst that created Golden Freddy. I think after FNaF3 everyone just collectively agreed that this "yellow suit" was the Spring Bonnie suit, but clearly there's a strong connection between whatever happened and Golden Freddy.

It's cool to not only see my art once again to bring the visuals to life, but to see my theory being used in a video in such detail. Well done!

Pizzeria Simulator was important in regards to narrowing down just how many souls there were in the animatronics: - Molten Freddy: Remnant from souls of Gabriel, Jeremy, Susie, Fritz, and Cassidy (the original missing 5 kids who possess the FNAF 1 crew) - Springtrap: Possessed by the soul of William Afton - Circus Baby: Possessed by the soul of Elizabeth - Lefty/Puppet: Possessed by the soul of Charlie Pizzeria Simulator establishes through these characters just how many souls roam the halls at Freddy's : 8.

I think the souls in the toy animatronics had their “happiest day” in fnaf 3 (except for Charlotte/Charlie) instead of the original kids that were also killed by William Afton. So instead it’s their souls inside the blob which is why it’s all the fnaf 1 animatronics plus whoever’s soul is inside Funtime Freddy.

I like the cinematic idea of Michael giving his brother the party he deprived him of. It does show that he’s grown as a person and really regrets what he did.

This video is almost nostalgic, and almost brings a tear to my eye to see old type of lore, been with this franchise for 8 years, and this lore just feels like home

You didn't talk about how RXQ is explained using the pieces! In Into the Pit, it's shown how characters from memories can sometimes leak into the real world as weird hallucinations. So RXQ is BV's spooky misinterpretation of Spring Bonnie's shadow (seen in FNaF4), given life in memory (seen in FNaF3), and brought irl by agony majyyks (seen in FNaF2) (as hinted by "What is seen in shadows...", probably) Edit: I'm undecided on whether Shadow Freddy is the same, but I lean toward no :/

Your theories are always the best ones out there, they are full of information and are super consistent! Would like to hear your opinion on the spirit on The Happiest Day being TheCryingChild, since thats what I always assumed since the location is pretty similar to the FNAF 4 location and TheCryingChild being the one with an incomplete birthday, plus Cassidy being confirmed to not being free after The Happiest day. I might have missed something in the novels since I didnt got the chance to read them so maybe is that. Great theory :D !

The sheer confidence in which you say things that i (a long time fnaf fan whos been intrested in the lore for years) barley understand and need to re-listen to to fully grasp is amazingly satisfying to hear.

I agree with pretty much all of this theory…but I just have one question. Why are BVs memories shattered among the MCI kids? Are you saying he knew them before he died? It *would* explain Cassidy’s question of “was your favourite ride the carousel” in the logbook - BV has probably been to Freddy’s and seen it

Also, I always thought it was weird that BV's traumatic memory of his own death would be a "Happiest Day"... Maybe it's similar to how the broken MCI souls thought William was their friend in The Fourth Closet?

I just personally don't think "Happiest Day" happens until Blob is gone, because it made clear the MCI are still around during FFPS. Henry confirmed that. Edit: I would presume it would be the actual souls, since it doesn't attack Glamrock Freddy, and it what happens in The Fourth Closet. And there's the possibility that Glamrock Freddy's "friends" is the Blob.

Awesome theory, I think the only issue would be that fnaf 4 wasn't going to exist and was made due to Scott's reaction to our reaction to springtraps jumpscare. I guess that could be countered with fnaf 3 ending newspaper showing springtrap and saying "the end?" But it still feels off to make the third game unsolvable until the fourth if Scott was happy to end it at 3 and again made 4 because of springtraps jumpscare. Unless he intended the ending be up to the imagination of the player but realised that wasn't a satisfactory ending kinda like count the ways ending leading into the final stichwraith arc where at first it was up to us to believe Millie's fate but ended with a solid answer to it at the end

This video encouraged me to go down a rabbithole is constantly reading and rereading these books. Thanks 😩

i liked this theory, i personally had a very similar theory, but also i have my own theory/thing to add more, like for example, the UCN, fnaf vr, ar and security breach happening in a timeline after the events of fnaf 3's bad ending and c.c's connection with glamrock freddy (in this case, things like the final lines of the Afton ending, the mechanic of placing parts of other animatronics could also be a representation of the parts for the happiest day / c.c's memories , the fredbear and family dinner references, "I am not me" and stuff)

I just found you with this video and im so glad i did, such a high quantity vid and i love the ideas. Keep it up!

I think its safe to say that Cassidy and Andrew are one and the same. Andrew is the book stand-in for Cassidy. Much like how Jake and the stitchwraith is the book stand-in for Bite victim and Golden Freddy. This is supported by MatPat's We solved Golden Freddy theory 2 years back. Nonetheless I'm lovin' the theories you're pumping out. I also forgot to subscribe!

I personally have always viewed the blob as a "hard-drive" of remnant that then uploaded the spirits into other places in the pizzaplex in security breach. I've made more fleshed out theories on this basis but this theory is really helpful in fleshing out the rest of that theory. Thanks!

at first I was like wait how are the heads and suits also possessed. But no you’re right the head symbolism is present throughout the games

I just found your channel and i'm genuinely not regretting it haha. Good job on your theories, you make some great points in them too! I honestly can't even begin to bust some of the hypothesies or theories you've talked about. Also, do you have a discord server by any chance? If not, you should definetly make one, it would make it alot easier to share or talk about things like you did in this video. I'd live to join! c:

I am very convinced, well done! It’s not often I hear a theory and I really go “oh, that makes sense, damn.”

my head gets confused with the timing of Sister Location. The FNAF 3 minigames show William destroying the FNAF 1 animatronics and you claim this is so that they can be melted and turned into the funtimes. However, at the end of the FNAF 3 minigames, William dies and is locked away in the safe room. How and when does William find time to create the funtimes, start up Circus Baby's Pizza World, see his daughter die, store the funtimes away in an underground facility, and then eventually contact Michael and tell him to go put his sister back together? These events don't feel like they could all happen in the middle of those FNAF 3 minigame sequences.

Good lord this video is DENSE for 12 minutes. All killer no filler. Great stuff.

4:45 Well, if you take a look at Bonnie and Chica….the lights in them….Flash….On….Off….On….Off….This could be Jeremy and Susie trying to release themselves(or their souls) from the 2 costumes…..

This is pretty interesting to see. Awesome theory video.

yt sure took its time recommending me your vids but im glad it finally did because theyre quite good

1:24 And the truth goes unspoken, heck, the Crying Child has even forgotten his name. ... Please someone get this reference

this is the first theory I see that both makes sense and is interesting

Great Theory! Can't wait to see more!

I'd love to see a sequel to this with the context we have from Ruin

This is by far the most compelling and convincing version of this theory I've ever heard. Finally! And there's so much info packed into 12 minutes. Nice job.

9:57 I think the whole rest thing happens at the end of PQ 2 because he literally tells Cassidy to rest there

God I can't wait for matpats timeline soon a lot more stuff will make since after that for me.

why can’t they just ascend to haven already and let it go

The thumbnail made me think this was an Austin video (game theory)! lol

Amazing theory, the wrap up at the end left me with my eyes open xD The only thing that flew over me was Charlotte being Fredbear in FNaF World and 4. Can someone explain that to me?

Under score W theory

Andrew only appears in the Fazbear fright book series. Which means he is a counterpart to Cassidy. Like how Eleanor is a counterpart for Elizabeth and Jack is the counterpart for the still unnamed crying child. Plus I clearly remember Fazbear fright epilogues forms it’s own story separate from the games. Stitch wraith never appears in the games.

Me who knows that the pieces on the blob are from the suits but burnt and some are from fnaf AR:your right but also wrong

Charlotte/Charlie isn't in golden freddy/fredbear, right?, they're in the puppet, you even show the puppet on the screen. It'd be 'Cassidy' or 'the vengful spirit' in fredbear at that point.

But why would the Bite Victim’s memories be shattered across the the Missing Children? How did they get there? Why are they connected at all? If the BV died in 83, and the missing kids in 85, then why does his memories get hitched to the children that die years later?

i think the 40 may represent when happiest day took place in relation to the mci. To me it makes less sense for the happiest day representation to be celebrating 40 years of afton being spring locked (as well as there being debates around when william was spring locked, like him maybe needing to be alive when phone guy is, etc.), but I think it would make more sense if happiest day 40 representation means, 40 years have passed all the way leading up to the events of happiest day. Happiest day took place around fnaf 3 in 2023, and 40 years ago from 2023 was 1983, one of the presumed mci dates. Maybe 40 years means the kids waited 40 years to have a birthday party, instead of we have our happiest day because 40 years ago william died. (this is if the mci was in 83 which it may or may not be, and if that 40 thing represents the happiest day as it how or who could've set it up that way is strange and a mystery) I also never heard anyone talk about the implications of the kids also being connected to micheal by being injected, and the checkmate with the ar animatronics and blob not having the original parts blew my mind, its also nice to have other youtubers cover the security breach lore more, for poor people like me who can't go looking for clues in game, never knew about that 40 years happiest day arrangement thing either, 10/10 video, some tasty new points

“Princess quest is not the cannon end of security breach” This aged atrociously

Wasn’t is mentioned in the unused FNAF AR faz facts that the rockstar animatronics held parts of the FNAF 1 animatronics so that means the missing children’s incident spirits are split in three ways Michael Afton molten Freddy and the rockstar animatronics

What youve said is probably true, which really sucks for this series as a whole. Every "ending" or victory achieved up to this point has been for nothing. Williams still here, the kids are still here, elizabeth might even still be here. The story hasnt gone anywhere, it just keeps happening again. As much as i enjoy your theories and how youre able to stitch together loose threads, i cant fully accept them because they make the story so much more unenjoyable. Headcanon is the only thing that lets me enjoy this series at this point.

If I confused you about the comment I put 8 days ago I’m sorry….I meant to say In Fnaf 3 when looking through the camera if you take a look at the two rooms where the Chica and Bonnie costumes are….You can see The Lights in them flash……On…..Off….On….Off…On….Off….On….Off…. That’s what I was referring to about the costume.

My only problem about this theory is that it would be more thematicly. if the four in the happiest day minigame where from 1985. Since the way the story into the pit talks about that scene of the kids being dead. Makes it seem like it's about the happiest day minigame. Also I bet Oswald is Michael in this case. A kid who finds out about the murdered kids in a freddys and then finds his dad to be a monster. Also as backing to this claim. Please remember that in pizzeria simulator the scene of the puppets giving life has only four kids. The four that would help the other five that would set the clocks in motion. Which would only leave the missing children and Charlie by the time FNAF 3 ends. Also if the last of the remnant is in the FNAF 3 location it's safe to say the 1985 kids and the 5 from FNAF 2 are also at rest.

"I'm looking at you Mat Pat" XDXDXDXDXD

I love everything about this theory, the pieces fit so well together!

Bro got the matpat thumbnail on point

I can't lie as sad as it would be for them to be still trapped in the Suits well endos I still wouldn't want to see them go there's no really getting rid of those originals..... imagine how annoying it would be to be Charlie trying to protect them cuz they refuse to leave or can't

wasnt Andrew the Cassidy stand in for that one Fazbear Fright?

I haven't watched the video yet, but I can't imagine chrishian developer making a story where souls should rest still remaining even after the new Ikea dropped.

I am enjoying finding all of these theorist channels! I am collecting them all like Pokémon lol

It’s so cool to see the rise of fnaf again with so many new theorist it reminds me of the old times

This was surprisingly a great video! I think you solved half of the fnaf lore.

I thought it was a game theory video bc of the thumbnail lol

How have we confirmed that fredbear plush is charlie? That was just glossed over.

Hello! New subber here. Very interesting theory. I believe that the Happiest Day has not happened as of pre ruin sb. Excited to see new insight.

Matpat should really uh... watch these...

I kinda disagree, molten Freddy's remnant would still be around somewhere, since we now know fire powers remnant, and I like alot of people belive mike is still alive becuase of fnaf ar, I also believe happiest day takes place alot later in the timeline

I like your video. Thanks for sharing your ideas.

Imagine you find what's in the box and you open it and it's a picture of you've been trolled and it was all a waste of time.

i actually agree with a lot of this, except with he idae of Vanessa being theo ne trying to extend William's life; there have been CD's after all which hint that Vanny and Vanessa are not the same person, + that one ending where when Gregory unmasks Vanny after Glamrock Freddy jumped down with her she seemed to look like Vanessa, however... at the very end of that ending we get one final scene with the nightguard Vanessa looking down confused from the top of the building and either shocked or scared, or both; which together points out pretty clearly that Vanny and Vanessa are identical siblings, not the same person

This was a really solid video 👌

Also from my understanding, theres no confirmation that aftons hell in UCN is stopped when the circuits are scanned?, as glitchtrap and the princess quest stuff can both be considered copies of both aftons and cassidies conciousness. Also, isn't the virus just glitchtrap?, before glitchtrap changes themself to an integral system.

even if they are still around i honestly just choose to believe the core four were set free at the end of pizzeria simulator for the sake of my own well being 💀

Under_Score back at it again with another amazing theory.

Nice theory

If the funtimes contain the remnant from the original children, how can their ghosts show up in FNaF 3 separate from said soul metal?

I'm pretty sure that all of Springtrap was burnt away in the FNAF6 fire, if not then why would we have UCN? If he's not totally dead and in hell? The best way to put it is that the pieces of Springtrap later used for the programming of Help Wanted were cursed/infused with the agony William poured out of him during those 30+ years inside the suit. Glitchtrap is simply pure unadulterated evil, there's no more of the grieving father William would have been, just his pain and rage. Trying to corrupt everything it touches to grow stronger, so technically speaking, Glitchtrap isn't William, it's just his evil. PERHAPS PERHAPS, the UCN William is more innocent than Glitchtrap, because UCN William COULD just be what was left of him after being left without agony, just the husk of a father who lost his children and acted out in an irrational anger/ the genius engineer capable of constructing machines to keep the dead in our realm and possibly find a way to bring his son back.

Does the fact that the narrator in FNAF 6 and FNAF VR sound the same matter at all? I haven't seen anyone bring that up I think

For a moment i thought this was a matpay video

You deserve more subs

Bro is acting like Andrew is a character in the games Also happiest day was for crying child if i remember it right, the second soul in golden freddy along with cassidy, well before he is put to rest by the other souls Also i personally don't think ucn was on a circutboard but cassidy was definetly in williams circutboards, tho i think much like andrew in the BOOKS cassidy is keeping william alive to torture him in his mind, cassidy and afton were defo on a circutboard i don't think ucn itself was

Incredible video, thanks for your efforts! Cheers from Ukraine :D

You right

nice theory, I don't think this one is correct but we never really are when it comes to FNaF. still really like this one though and wouldn't be mad if it was real

Thought this was game theory so hard Thumbnails are no joke lmao

I LOVE that Molten Freddy design with Baby included. Did you make it? Where's it from if not. Well I guess it'd still be ennard, with his mask at that point? Dunno

8 bit fredbear is Charolette?? I thought it was cassidy...?

I have to say your theories are better than my matPat

yo your thumbnail looks like what mat pat would create.

This is underrated. New sub

Happiest Quest, very good

I thought this was a game theory video

whre is the spirit of the crying child? why wouldn't cassydy be the vengefull spirit?

Two questions. 1. What is your reasoning behind fnaf world still being canon? 2. If you say the animatronics in the blob are from AR, I then assume you are saying that the AR anims physically exist in the in game reality? So, clown springtrap, liberty chica and so on, do they all exist in this in game reality?

Nice GT thumbnail inspiration. You should do these thumbnails more often. Also awesome theory. One question, how do we know that charlie is in the Fredbear plush? This is the first theory by you I watched. I've heard this claim before, but what is the Evidence.

"princess quest isn't the canon ending of security breach" Welp

Hi Underscore :)). I like your theory a lot, it takes the view om the FNAF Lore in a whole new direction, which I like. However there are just a few things that I want to ask you about. Is it not an easier explanation that the blond kid in UCN, the vengeful spirit, is just Cassidy? Instead of bringing Andrew into this, which in itself brings a lot of complicated applications. Therefore would it not just be much easier to say that Cassidy is a boy? And if William were to use these MCI endoskeletons to use the remnant on the Funtime animatronics for experiments. Then why would it work on the endoskeletons, and give remnant to the Funtime animatronics, when you just said that all of the remnant was in the suits and not the endoskeletons later on in the video? Then it should have been the suits that William should had taken instead, right? Another thing is if William died in 1995, then that means the FNAF 1 location needs to be ruined as we see in the “Follow me” minigame in FNAF 3. And all of that needs to happen in only 2 years. That seems absurd. For example I don't think it will take 2 years for most of the color on the floor disappearing (The FNAF 1 location has white and black squares to decorate the floor normally) Will it not make more sense that the handwriting says 2045, meaning the building had 12 years to be this messed up as we see in the “FNAF Follow me minigame”. Another thing is that if The Puppet is speaking to CC in the 1983 minigame where he dies. Then Charlie can not have died in 1983 31st October, since the CC FNAF 4 1983 minigames are most likely in 1983 in the spring or in the summer. Meaning Charlie needed to have died on 31st October 1982. Which goes against what the novels tells us, which is that Charlie died on 31st October 1983. And the statement of Charlie dying on 31st October 1982 goes against your previous theories. But I know you did say that you changed your mind about some of your older theories, but I would like to mention it nonetheless. Another thing to mention is that the Pigtail girl in FNAF 4 1983 minigame says to CC that animatronics come to life at night, and hides your body and never tells anyone. We can go 2 ways with this: pigtail girl is talking about the missing children incident, which goes against what we know about in the books that MCI was in 1985. Or pigtail girl mentions rumors about kidnappings of children at night outside of the pizzaria. This could be Funtime Freddy burying himself in the day (like in the FNAF Novel “The Twisted Ones”) and kidnaps children from their homes at night. William then uses these children to experiment on remnant by for example the SCOOPer for a way to save his daughter Elizabeth's soul/remnant being trapped inside Baby, and use a humanoid robot to store her remnant, memories and emotions. For this plan to work correctly William needs a lot of test subjects. (Another thing William could use these children is to test his illusion desks.) So all of these test subjects must have been left behind in all the bidybabs and minireenas after being used (since we see a lot of them in sister location). And of course the Funtime animatronics are also from these test subjects (except Baby and maybe Ballora). But this explains why there are so much remnant in Molten Freddy in FNAF 6. Because it’s the remnant and agony of all the children William had experimented on. No need for them to be the MCI from 1983 or 1985. I’m sorry that I type so long messages, but I just really want us to see all of the perspectives possible, so we don't miss any important information that could solve FNAF. Have a great day Underscore :))

Bro either matpat gonna watch this video and point out things that you missed that matpat didn’t or he is going to support your theory lol. By the way in matpat’s video he talked about how the girl from sister location who got scooped by baby is the owner of the pizzaplex.

bro really got "inspired" by matpat's thumbnails 💀

I'm confused by what you mean by FNAF AR pieces being in Ennard. Is that game canon? And if so are those actually physical animatronics, or are they just virtual like they are in our world? Maybe I misunderstood what you meant

Hi uh, William died in 1993 because FNAF 3 takes place well, uh, next year lol- hold up

Under(Underscore)Score very nice name

what about puppet /charlet she not in the blob only her mask osow puppets not in fnaf ar meaning puppet is some wher and coming to help cassidy difet afton the vires and free the missing children sols

Of course they’re not how else are they gonna be able to make the next installment?

bro using the game theory font oh nah

This actually fits with what I said in my video about the box which I did a year ago