Тёмный

Four Hours in MY LAI, anatomy of a massacre 

Kosmonooit
Подписаться 461
Просмотров 189 тыс.
50% 1

"The true story of what happened in MY LAI has never been told before .. This video explores how a group of ordinary young Americans could perpetrate such atrocities and details the extent of the cover-up"
(1989)
Full Cap of VHS Tape in my collection,

Опубликовано:

 

22 фев 2015

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 687   
@jamesaymann735
@jamesaymann735 6 лет назад
I'm a combat veteran of the Vietnam War. I served with the 60th infantry brigade in the Mekong Delta and with the 196 light infantry brigade near Chu Lai. Westmoreland initiated the use of search and destroy operations while I was in Vietnam. What did the U.S.. Army think was going to happen when they included villagers in these search and destroy operations? When I was in the Mekong Delta I personally went to JAG at MACV and formally complained about the killing of innocent unarmed villagers. No action was taken and I was transferred to the 196th. I became a team leader and we went on patrols in the jungle every other day and ambushes in the rice patties every other night. We took our assignments seriously but we treated the villagers with kindness and respect. From personal experience I can testify that the Mt Lai atrocity was not an isolated incident. Reuters has determined that over 4 million Cambodians, Laotians and Vietnamese were killed in this war. Two thirds of these victims were unarmed civilians. To be blunt, this was a genocidal war perpetrated by the greed of the military-iindustrial complex. From personal experience I can testify that the My Lai massacre was not an isolated incident. Like everyone else I discovered the facts involving this massacre in Time magazine eight months after it went down. That's how long the U.S. Army and the US government successfully covered it up. This incident occurred 50 years ago. I was in Vietnam 50 years ago and if I had been there on that date I would've simultaneously cut into the scumbags. We carried a lot of ammo and we had what we aimed at. The perpetrators of this atrocity all took the fifth. Callie served three years under house arrest and then was pardoned by tricky Dick. Killing innocent and unarmed civilians is illegal and the scumbags involved in this massacre have been summarily executed. This country is plagued by gun violence and routine mass shootings! Is anyone surprised?
@jamesaymann735
@jamesaymann735 6 лет назад
Error. I meant to say that, "killing innocent and unarmed civilians is illegal and the scumbags involved in this massacre should have been summarily executed."
@jamesaymann735
@jamesaymann735 6 лет назад
I mistakenly typed, "the scumbags involved in this massacre have been summarily executed." That was a mistake on my part. In fact like I stated earlier, Calley served three years under house arrest and then was pardoned by Nixon. Every member of that platoon regardless of their participation or non-participation should have been summarily executed. Like I stated earlier I was a team leader and my men and I were on the same page. Had we run into any platoon that was conducting mass executions of innocent unarmed civilians to include infants,, we would have blown them away! The scumbags in this interview have the temerity to smile while they are relating their complete lack of humanity! This massacre occurred 50 years ago and when you look at the level of gun violence and mass shootings in this country, the blatant reality is obvious. The USA is by far the most dysfunctional country on planet Earth! We are not satisfied with blowing each other away, we actually spend trillions of dollars so that we can export this level of violence to other countries. The fact that these scumbags wore the same uniform that my comrades and I wore is disgusting!
@mingosutu
@mingosutu 6 лет назад
My Lai is the clearest answer to George Bush's question: "Why do they hate us?"!
@mingosutu
@mingosutu 6 лет назад
Now all the American veterans say the same thing even the murderers including Callie: "We treated the Iraqis at Abu Gireb kindly"!! "We treated the Afghans humanely, just like we treated the Vietnamese before them". I only wish to see you guys all paid in the same way you treat other nations.
@TheJohhnyrotten
@TheJohhnyrotten 5 лет назад
He didn't have a choice but to be there. Conscription, remember it?
@Kelly14UK
@Kelly14UK 7 лет назад
They didn't just kill "civilians suspected of helping the enemy". They raped and mutilated, too. And the youngest of those kids would have grown up to be my age. They didn't have a chance.
@jules3135
@jules3135 2 года назад
How old are you if you don’t mind me asking??
@PronatorTendon
@PronatorTendon 2 года назад
The difference in how one soldier will bend over backwards to justify atrocity while another will refuse such orders proves that we all have a choice.
@jamesburke9865
@jamesburke9865 7 лет назад
It's crazy that a large section of the American public held up a 5'5 crumb like kally and ignored Hugh Thompson who was a million times the man.
@eyechiteenmahand
@eyechiteenmahand 7 лет назад
Jimmy Two Times #callie. Enjoy the illusion you live in.
@emmaduncan2991
@emmaduncan2991 5 лет назад
It was a very weird time in America. And at least Simpson had some guilt over what he did. and of course the guys doing the killing, were just boys themselves.
@ladysheba4318
@ladysheba4318 7 лет назад
Harry Stanley was clearly a hero too, along with those who stood against their brothers for the sake of civility and standing for what is morally sound, at the risk of being killed themselves!! Mr. Stanley and those who shared his actions, are truly MEN OF HONOR! Kenneth Hodges, I am amazed that you can sit and say that killing babies is a moral act! But then again, you were brought up on charges for rape and murder, to which you kept claiming it was ordered! God help you! Calley....a 7 month old baby IS NOT THE ENEMY!!! It amazes me how some of them are trying to EXCUSE their behavior, their criminal acts by calling unarmed civilians the enemy! The enemy is that demon that you carry around excusing your immoral acts! RAPE is not a defense mechanism! So, what about that!!! NO EXCUSE! ONLY EVIL!
@user-ei1pb3di5z
@user-ei1pb3di5z Месяц назад
Thank you Dear Precious One,for speaking GOD'S TRUTH!!!!
@kimberlymoore9844
@kimberlymoore9844 5 лет назад
Thompson and his crew proved that day that angels walk among us. Such a sad day for humanity.
@GudJonnyCakes
@GudJonnyCakes 3 года назад
He wasn't nan Angel he was a man with a heart
@intelchip_x86
@intelchip_x86 Год назад
among us
@kincaidwolf5184
@kincaidwolf5184 6 дней назад
Angles? Hardly lmao
@RustedTelevisione
@RustedTelevisione 6 лет назад
Ms Pham Thi Trinh recalling how her family of 11 members, including a 7-month old baby brother, was completely wiped out is just so heartbreaking. Does anyone know her whereabouts today? Hopefully she found peace in life.
@littleblackfox1
@littleblackfox1 6 лет назад
RustedTelevisione Same here... The sadness on her face is heartbreaking. And then hearing her talk about how she watched her 14year old sister getting raped, and how the american then just gets off her and shoots her like she was just a worthless object that he had finished using, that shit made me rage cry.
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
littleblackfox, now you know how all Ted Kennedy's dates felt. Those that were wearing life preservers.
@RustedTelevisione
@RustedTelevisione 2 года назад
@Mary Goodday how thoughtful of you
@Berniewahlbrinck
@Berniewahlbrinck Год назад
I sure hope so too.
@USMCLP
@USMCLP 5 лет назад
Hearing Hugh Thompson speak about that child in the ditch brought tears to my eyes. So horrible what happened there.
@apocalypznow
@apocalypznow 6 лет назад
It's been over 3 years since this was posted, and only 48,825 views. This should've had 20 million views by now, compared the garbage on RU-vid that's had 20 million views in only one year. The film was very very sad, but what makes it worse is that almost nobody cares to know the tragedy.
@jimmymoledigital
@jimmymoledigital 6 лет назад
Well said brother.The human race dont deserve this earth. RIP the victims of Vietnam
@jdessell
@jdessell 7 лет назад
Hugh Thompson lived in my hometown. I just found out about the My Lai Massacre. If I would have known sooner I sure would have liked to meet him and talk to him.
@user-yx8bh9gu4t
@user-yx8bh9gu4t 7 лет назад
You mean you would've liked to have met him and talked to him when he was living. FYI, he died in 2006 at a VA hospital in Pineville, Louisiana after an extensive bout with cancer. He's buried in Lafayette, LA.
@raphmaster23
@raphmaster23 5 лет назад
The gross irony is the all of the helicopter crew is no longer with us, meanwhile Calley is still alive and well living in Georgia or Florida...
@neemperiod
@neemperiod 4 года назад
Sometimes, bad men die in their sleep.
@beardedloon77
@beardedloon77 11 месяцев назад
@@user-yx8bh9gu4t grammar police.
@KateRambo
@KateRambo 7 дней назад
@@raphmaster23not anymore, it was just reported that he died back in April at 80 years young which is older than anyone here got a chance at.
@doberman1ism
@doberman1ism 5 лет назад
Old men send young men to war. I was a young teenager when this happened. I could not believe what I was hearing. The stories from the men of Charlie Company pierced my heart. The tragedy of turning young innocent boys into professional killers is reprehensible and vile. Their lives are the casualties of war. The description of killing 500 villagers made me gasp for air and I found myself holding my breath in disbelief and horror. I am a Vietnam era Navy WAVE veteran. I served at Philadelphia Naval Hospital. I saw what the war brought home. The broken bodies and the broken minds of young boys who had no choice but to serve. We thought we are all grown up then but we were just kids. Only now am I coming to terms with what I saw, heard and experienced. It has been very difficult and very sad to remember the damaged lives of the men and women who served during Vietnam. When my time was up and I returned to the civilian world I never told anyone that I have been in the service until now.
@isabellac5669
@isabellac5669 5 лет назад
Aidah Di Leoni I believe you should write a book!
@anRoisinDubh
@anRoisinDubh 2 года назад
Every time we send young men to kill, this is the result. Iraq and Afghanistan, the same. Apart from the murdered innocent in those countries, there is generational trauma visited on the veterans and their families also. It's like one massive psy-op, to destroy the good character and resilience if young people. Don't tell me any different. War is always wrong.
@marija.maravic
@marija.maravic 4 года назад
I come from Serbia and same horrible things happend during the civil war back in the 90's when Yugoslavia fell apart. It makes me sad that hero Thompson died at 62 of cancer and that demon Calley is still alive. There is no justice in this world of ours. Sad but true.
@komradepistoff6584
@komradepistoff6584 2 года назад
There's no argument that prosecutions for My Lai should have gone higher. For one thing, Medina should have been sentenced harshly for the way he incited this rampage. But that does NOT nullify the fact that accountability extends to ALL levels. If you witness a fellow soldier raping and butchering a young girl or shooting unarmed civilians, infants amongst them, your duty - as an American, as a soldier, as a human - is to defend the innocent, not to turn away, and DEFINITELY not to participate. The only people who acted with honor on the US side that day were Andreotta, Colburn and Thompson - heroes to a man, make no mistake. Had they not intervened, many more may have died. It's just a shameful wonder that at least some of that murderous mob didn't follow their example, and do what they could to stop the slaughter. And in case you're silly enough to have swallowed all the bleating from Calley, Hodges, and others about 'following orders' as a justification for such actions, remember this: the Nazis were tried and executed at Nuremberg for such crimes, despite pleading the same spineless excuse.
@Berniewahlbrinck
@Berniewahlbrinck Год назад
I agree - except there was another one you should have mentioned: Harry Stanley!
@conquistador-7526
@conquistador-7526 8 месяцев назад
You weren't there kid, you can run your mouth all you want on what you would and wouldn't do, but until you're in that situation in the heat of the moment you might surprise yourself for the better or worse. And a lot of those "civilians" were VC (not the innocent children obviously) farmers during the day soldiers at night; reality is not so black and white.
@komradepistoff6584
@komradepistoff6584 7 месяцев назад
Yeh, those evil old women, young women, children, babies - all VC (and perhaps a few NVA regulars thrown in) armed to the teeth with -------------- what? The photos taken by AMERICAN photographers on the ground tell the real story: rape, torture and murder. And that was backed up by US airmen who rescued innocents from the fray. It's obvious YOU weren't there.
@shawn092182
@shawn092182 6 месяцев назад
​​ There's no evidence that a lot of THOSE civilians were VCs.
@littleblackfox1
@littleblackfox1 6 лет назад
My god! hearing Calley lie about being attacked first, and saying that he was "only protecting his troops" is one of the most infuriating things I've ever heard. The craziest thing is that just one year before all this, most of these soldiers were living as normal people in society, and in less than 12 months, such a large percentage of them become these mass murdering sadistic rapists!? That just seems way too easy.. So easy that its terrifying, and gives me even more of a reason to have literally no hope for the human species.
@bryanbaker5942
@bryanbaker5942 3 года назад
Calley lied so much he could be a reporter for CNN.
@bonegrubber
@bonegrubber 6 лет назад
Today I was talking to my neighbor who is a vietnam vet. I do what I usually do and asked if he saw any action. He quietly said yes and mentioned he'd seen a lot of dead bodies. I asked if he'd heard about My Lai and he started to choke up and mentioned he was nearby. He said his group was responsible for at least 7 civilian kills. He said he knew it was wrong and that he complained to his superiors but was told to shut up. I got the impression that he hadn't personally killed anyone but had definitely witnessed the deaths. He told me he doesn't like talking about it because of the dreams that tend to come at night. I told him sorry. I told him the war was a raw deal for everyone involved. He said after the war he drank a lot. He knew of a lot other war vets who turned to drinking and drugs. I can't possible imagine the horrific scene that must of been to witness. And all those poor innocent souls who perished at the hand of our great government.
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
I feel the same way every time I drive by an abortion clinic. 50 million souls lost since 1973,,wow!
@jules3135
@jules3135 2 года назад
We would ask My grandpa all the time about stories. And he could never talk about it. In fact me and my cousins would be talking nonsense making up our own jibber ish and our grandma would tell us not to talk like that because of gramps and it could flip something in him. I never understood, we were so young at the time. But seeing this I now under why.
@jules3135
@jules3135 2 года назад
Thank you for your service sir.
@Berniewahlbrinck
@Berniewahlbrinck Год назад
Thank you for your thoughts, Matt!
@MargaritaMagdalena
@MargaritaMagdalena 2 года назад
At first the Vietcong were blamed for this massacre and it was called "terrorism". When it turned out to be the US military, it was no longer "terrorism".
@ViETxSOULJAx
@ViETxSOULJAx 5 лет назад
I’m an American born Vietnamese but most of my family are from Vietnam. Last summer I went on a vacation there for three weeks. My family told me they were going to take me to the beach, so I fell asleep in the van. I woke up at the stop and we ended up here at the My Lai museum where the massacre took place... I had no idea what was going on. It was definitely a rude awakening. The foot prints of American soldier’s boots are still there, forever engraved in the dirt roads. There is a monument of all the names of the villagers thatve lost their lives that day. Far too many were under the age of 15... The vibes there was eerie and the locals say that they see ghost and hear wailing at night.
@gs-nq6mw
@gs-nq6mw 3 года назад
You can't just rape a girl,kill her then multilate her body,then stack up all her family in a bunker and throw 5 granades at them and say "Hey,i was just following an order" and then not punish those soldiers+try to hide the massacre from american citiziens,that's some scary psychopathical behavior.The minimum americans should do is teach this at school instead of ignoring it ps:my lai may just be the tip of the iceberg,imagine how much we will never know about
@357-swagnumultramagax9
@357-swagnumultramagax9 3 года назад
Some places are haunted asf with tormented souls .
@ff441980fredcrowe
@ff441980fredcrowe 3 года назад
The Devil’s business was done that day.
@celticbastardson2599
@celticbastardson2599 3 года назад
@@gs-nq6mw Agree. Also, America should not be the World's police force for Capitalism-because that's the real underlying problem. In order for Capitalism to thrive, someone's life, in another place must be terrible, so that diabetic Americans can have big SUVs, and McMansions, and cheaply made Nike shoes, made by Asian children who can't afford shoes. I was a soldier, 30 years ago, and my father was very high up in the DOD, with a big office in the Pentagon. I learned a few things that made me sick.
@jimmymoledigital
@jimmymoledigital 2 года назад
I’ve been there myself. I love Vietnam 🇻🇳
@davidcaldwell4586
@davidcaldwell4586 7 лет назад
I heard a Vietnam Veteran say "things like My Lai happened all the time." I guess President Johnson and President Nixon were legally war criminals. Even if one brings death and destruction with good intentions, it is still death and destruction. South Korean Army soldiers also served in served in Veitnam and were said to have been as bad as Nazis, yet, the United States had them in Vietnam. Lt. Colonel Anthony Herbert fought in Vietnam without being a butcher, and the Army forced him out when he tried to "rock the boat." This does not say much for the United States.
@saucejohnson9862
@saucejohnson9862 5 лет назад
"A bunch of isolated incidents" is how Oliver Stone explained it. If someone thinks My Lai happened every week even is a fucking idiot who needs to get off their computer and get some fresh air.
@petrokrasnov2967
@petrokrasnov2967 4 года назад
Chloe wilson correction on Katyn massacre. It was in The neighborhood of 20,000!
@phungo1658
@phungo1658 2 года назад
My grandma said that the Korean soldiers was one of the most feared during that time. Not only they did all the horrible things to innocent villagers, women, children, even infants, they were also cannibalism and collecting their victim’s ear as trophy
@Roscoe.P.Coldchain
@Roscoe.P.Coldchain 2 года назад
The VC also committed these atrocities so they do it as tit for tat, if you really look into what was going on out there then you might be able to understand better
@Wristwatchme
@Wristwatchme 3 месяца назад
@@phungo1658there was a rough American unit who also collected those items from people…
@TomRivieremusic
@TomRivieremusic 6 лет назад
These guys should all been in jail.They were murders and cowards.
@Mububban23
@Mububban23 Год назад
It's been 30 years since I watched this in high school, but I never forgot that black soldier sitting there constantly shaking and saying "This is my life." This definitely had an impact on me as a teenager. Watching this and World War 2 documentaries really highlights how nearly any of us "ordinary" folk could potentially take part in something like this. We all like to think we'd be heroes like Hugh Thompson, but the frightening reality is, more of us are likely to be lost in the moment like Varnado Simpson 😢
@ksdtzfir
@ksdtzfir 5 лет назад
1945 - Nürnberg. War crimes tribunal for German war criminals. 1968 - My Lai and 2003 - Iraq. Where is the war crimes tribunal for American war criminals? _Where?_
@MrAquinas1
@MrAquinas1 3 года назад
@Laika24102007 There were several dozen, not a couple.
@OliBeck-vs3mn
@OliBeck-vs3mn 3 месяца назад
It’s a great question and I wish I could give a definite response.
@scottrussell2281
@scottrussell2281 7 лет назад
That war should never have happened in the first place. So many lives needlessly lost or destroyed, and for what?
@sittingbull1858
@sittingbull1858 7 лет назад
+Scott Rusell. So true. The same thing happened about 60 years earlier than Mai Lai. Check out the Bud Dajo Massacre or AMERICA APOLOGIZE---A Plea of Justice for the Filipino People. It's mind boggling how long these kinds of atrocities have been occurring.
@spacedoginnebraska
@spacedoginnebraska 7 лет назад
Look no further than right here, with the systematic dissolution of the native people. Under the flag of manifest destiny. This country was created by the blood of innocent people.
@MrSchmolko
@MrSchmolko 7 лет назад
for profit, to name one...the arms industry and manufacturers of choppers, jeeps, agent orange, catering etc. made billions
@cliffwebb1621
@cliffwebb1621 6 лет назад
Scott Russell Jews didn't want to give up those Michelin rubber plantations in French colonial Vietnam...
@VodkaUSMC
@VodkaUSMC 5 лет назад
Blame the French for starting it.
@jackringo9878
@jackringo9878 5 лет назад
This Kenneth Hodge would have made an excellent Nazi. No remorse, at one point he says the order was to kill everybody, because they were all enemies, even the babies. Unreal, disgusting is an understatement for such monsters. And the they are hiding behind orders. And then all the people who were demanding "free Calley" absolutely unbelievable. Sickening. In WW 2 such soldiers were court martialed and executed. Can't believe nobody none of these monsters were held responsible for their war crimes. Shocking how "normal people" can demand "Free Calley". Thompson is the hero, he behaved like a human being. 120 monsters who were following orders. Just wondering how many other war crimes the military was able to keep secret?
@kathychapman3038
@kathychapman3038 2 года назад
Hodge needs to remember what goes around comes around and the audacity of calling a baby "the enemy' is unbelievable! If he truly feels like this he is a monster!
@lilzp9106
@lilzp9106 11 месяцев назад
Not to shit on your point but in WW2 america most likely committed similar atrocities.
@beardedloon77
@beardedloon77 11 месяцев назад
Even in his most recent interviews he shows absolutely no remorse.
@WerewolfReaper
@WerewolfReaper Месяц назад
I also heard in books that he and his cronies raped women
@salamanca1954
@salamanca1954 2 года назад
A former colleague of mine in the newspaper business told the story, before he came to work at our paper, when, as a reporter up in Wisconsin, he was covering some routine Junior Chamber of Commerce event, and the people he knew there wanted to introduce him to a new member, a great guy, in real estate. Ernie Medina. As they shook hands, my friend said, "Captain Medina?" My friend said Medina's hand slid out of his as though it were a fish, and Medina turned on his heel without a word and walked rapidly out of the venue, leaving his companions stunned and mystified. They did not know who he had been. I don't remember whether my friend told them.
@buurmedia
@buurmedia 2 года назад
incredible story, I hope it haunts him to the grave
@fuzzydunlop7928
@fuzzydunlop7928 7 лет назад
The most disgusting thing to me is the way the public perception swung in the favor of the murderers. What was once a perfectly persecutable offense ("just following orders") became a fucking battle-cry for an ignorant public who knew little of the actual day-to-day of the war, who considered all Vietnamese enemies and condones slaughters. The killers themselves have concrete, if inexcusable, reasons for why they did what they did. Conditioning, fatigue, anxiety, grief, malice, what reasons did the public have for supporting them? Beyond the massacre itself, THAT is the biggest blemish it's left on our society. On the way our country is perceived on a whole. The facade of "humanitarians" which we had cultivated since 1776 came crashing down, finally. We were no better than the other murderous nations, in fact, in many ways we were and are still worse.
@Wristwatchme
@Wristwatchme 3 месяца назад
Well said.
@bluesow
@bluesow 2 года назад
Captain Medina was also responsible for giving the order to shoot. Everyone focusses on Valley,but Medina should be mentioned too.
@lindaraymond1293
@lindaraymond1293 7 лет назад
Shame on America.
@slapshot6ful
@slapshot6ful 6 лет назад
Linda Raymond shame on everyone. War is hell. Every soldier that dies is someone's child also.
@slapshot6ful
@slapshot6ful 6 лет назад
Agreed though, this is clearly criminal.... but i think they (the men on the ground) were accomplices. Everyone who sent them there should have been hanged. Many people voicing their disdain for their actions would have done the same. Again, War is hell. And it's preventable. Unfortunately it's also profitable. I like to think I'd make better choices, but luckily I've never been to hell.
@99txgh
@99txgh 2 года назад
American involvement in the Vietnam and Korean Wars were some of the most stupid things that ever happened, it had nothing to do with them and the fact that they used mandatory service to force US civilians to fight a war across the world that had nothing to do with them is sick. What do you even tell them? You're protecting your country?? How? The pure fear they had for communism to the extent that they would draft US civilians as if the war was on their doorstep or actually involved them. Led to so many Vietnemese civilian deaths, to the point even South Vietnamese civilians were seen celebrating the end so US soldiers could leave their soil. Proud US veterans of Vietnam always make me feel sick. The West needs to learn to stay out of issues that don't involve them/isn't caused by them.
@buurmedia
@buurmedia 2 года назад
well said
@jstinstinny8909
@jstinstinny8909 4 года назад
If Harry Stanley and the other soldier refused to kill innocent people and they weren't shot on sight then that tells you the rest could have done the same. Also tells you the ones that did the shooting wanted to do it because again, they could have refused like the other 2 soldiers and they could have stopped it. Remember, terrorists are not always foreign.
@lienvu55
@lienvu55 7 лет назад
Here's what was cut off from the translation of what the lady said at 21:24 "I FEEL DEEP HATRED FOR AMERICAN INVADERS"
@tonisams6902
@tonisams6902 7 лет назад
Lien Vu, I am sure thy did and do have a deep hatred for Americans but many Americans who fought that filthy manipulative war hate them too along with the Chinese. For the record we never invaded. We were forced into that shit hole of a country without any say so.
@solodiamante
@solodiamante 6 лет назад
Lien Vu I don't blame her.
@laurischoolmarm
@laurischoolmarm 5 лет назад
I'm so desperately sorry, both for the innocents dead and the men who must pay more dearly than any of us know. I cannot judge, but my heart breaks for all of us who bear witness to the tragedies we inflict on each other when we see our sisters and brothers as "other."
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
I get the feeling that you'd be speaking german w/o us though.
@LisaMarie51968
@LisaMarie51968 5 лет назад
I would die before I killed women and kids!!! There’s no excuse for that Amerikkka!!!!
@silversobe
@silversobe 6 лет назад
"War is a racket. It always has been. It is possibly the oldest, easily the most profitable, surely the most vicious. It is the only one international in scope. It is the only one in which the profits are reckoned in dollars and the losses in lives. It is conducted for the benefit of the very few, at the expense of the very many. Out of war a few people make huge fortunes." - (Two-time Congressional Medal of Honor recipient) ~ Smedley D. Butler
@obotish1981
@obotish1981 5 лет назад
one of the darkest video on youtube
@greatwarriorstruggler9447
@greatwarriorstruggler9447 4 года назад
One of the darkest moments in the history of the us military as well.
@garyheiden3120
@garyheiden3120 4 года назад
Thompson should have been given the medal of honor. he recognized Charlie co. had turned into a bunch of Nazi's. many US war criminals went unpunished. A very dark episode and just one of many. we lost our soul as a nation in Vietnam. I met the woman taking water out of the well when I went to pay my respects at My Lai in 2003. R.I.P. McNamara & Gen. Westmoreland were Nazi like in their concept of the war.
@trendzoned
@trendzoned 4 месяца назад
After watching this, it brought me back to the raw brutality of the My Lai Massacre. The film doesn't pull any punches, showing the harsh realities of war that I experienced firsthand. It's a gritty reminder of the darkness and tough decisions we faced in combat. As a veteran, it hits hard, but it's essential for everyone to see. This film is a no-holds-barred portrayal of the true cost of war.
@Wristwatchme
@Wristwatchme 3 месяца назад
You can always make a decision. It’s not the tough ones, it’s what is the right ones.
@vipersb1
@vipersb1 2 года назад
"I was just following orders". Ugh. Thompson is a hero, as are those who refused. Listening to the others try to justify it is sickening.
@mynameisnotimportant2854
@mynameisnotimportant2854 7 лет назад
@21:15 seeing that woman cry is gut wrenching...she loss her kids and her mother
@joegamble328
@joegamble328 6 лет назад
ChocolateBunny Dba UrbanEssence no words
@nicolasvillamil7523
@nicolasvillamil7523 5 лет назад
"As a professional soldier I was taught to carry out orders without question" There's nothing professional about you, bum.
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
AMEN
@thegreatnessoftheraiders4948
@thegreatnessoftheraiders4948 3 года назад
His comment made me angry too...
@marcnews75
@marcnews75 8 лет назад
w/o thompson was a hero that day
@iby914
@iby914 6 лет назад
A man of distinction and honour.
@TheChiefEng
@TheChiefEng 5 лет назад
What Charlie Company did that day was no better than what the Nazi Einsatzgruppen did on the eastern front in WWII. Every last SOB of Charlie Company who killed innocent people that day should have been put up against a wall and shot. I hope every last person in Charlie Company will rot in hell for eternity.
@Berniewahlbrinck
@Berniewahlbrinck Год назад
Still is.
@Maximus-sm4ue
@Maximus-sm4ue Месяц назад
The black guy in his living room with the picture book had a sense of accountability that shows me his remorse is truly genuine
@_essence_07
@_essence_07 28 дней назад
There is an interview of him shortly after getting out of the war where he is more neutral about it. Crazy to see the guilt eat away at him years later. He later took his own life as well. Tragic stuff.
@Shy-xm4kn
@Shy-xm4kn 2 года назад
Thompson is a good person with heart, the world needs more people like him! This was extremely brutal and disgusting. The pictures of the victims made me cry.
@greencase
@greencase 7 лет назад
the nazis also did what they told. how is this different?
@Paul47Tat
@Paul47Tat 6 лет назад
Oh, you know the answer to that one- because they're Americans! Isnt that the answer to every piece of hell America launches on the world??
@altareggo
@altareggo 6 лет назад
No difference... nearly everyone involved in horrendous war atrocities was "just following orders" - which seems to be something our species is VERY good at doing, given the proper conditions.
@cryora
@cryora 6 лет назад
There have been psychology experiments that confirm that people are more likely to do horrible things if they can outsource the responsibility to authorities. In other words, people will do terrible things if they can get away with it.
@michaelconey5968
@michaelconey5968 6 лет назад
The Nazis might also have been a little peeved over your horrible use of grammar, being as they are, you know, Nazis. The Nazis did what they were told out of hatred, ideological bent, or fear. American soldiers did this for what?
@lindareynolds2431
@lindareynolds2431 6 лет назад
We dropped a bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki....killing hundreds of thousands of civilians....how was that different?
@TomRivieremusic
@TomRivieremusic 6 лет назад
Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities. -Voltaire
@pizdanpula223
@pizdanpula223 4 года назад
This killer blew his head off in the end .. couldn't live with the guilt ! Others didn't have the same decency and were never punished by US !
@stacymorris9652
@stacymorris9652 6 лет назад
As I watch this, my heart breaks terribly! All those babies, women, elderly, people!!!! Its really the Killing Fields!!
@toernebohmite
@toernebohmite 6 лет назад
Kenneth Hodges. The guy in the white shirt was responsible for the murder of dozens of civilians on that day. When one of his men refused to open fire on unarmed civilians right at the start of the massacre, Hodges banished the soldier to the edge of the skirmish line.
@ajosephcirene
@ajosephcirene 8 лет назад
The guilt hung so heavily over Varnado Simpson (the black fellow) that he suffered severe PTSD after the massacre. years later and 3 unsuccessful attempted suicides he finally succeeded by shooting himself in the head. That was on May 4th, 1997. He was 48 years old. Such a tragic story.
@kamhertzmartialacademy9832
@kamhertzmartialacademy9832 8 лет назад
he deserved much more than that
@ajosephcirene
@ajosephcirene 8 лет назад
+muachi do What about that piece of sh*t Lt William Calley who ordered the mass killings at My Lai? At least Simpson had a conscience which led him to commit suicide whereas Calley had none imo.
@ajosephcirene
@ajosephcirene 8 лет назад
Levine Levine Very well said. People who never served are quick to judge. To this day, Calley hasn't shown any sincere remorse. His apology was like reading from a Hollywood Script. I agree with you that Vernando showed himself to be the better man. He suffered so much guilt and remorse for what he did for so many years after the incidebt that he couldm't livre with himself.
@kamhertzmartialacademy9832
@kamhertzmartialacademy9832 8 лет назад
There are the horrors of war that not all have experienced. And so are the many social and peer pressures that we all faced in our lifetimes. But that doesn't give us the excuse to do, not minor, but immense harm to others. Vernando is the much better person compared to calley, but that doesn't take his sins away. You are only looking at his sufferings, but what about the innocent lives he personally took? He did something wrong and felt guilty and died for it. But those innocent people did nothing wrong, and lost their lives because of him. Being remorseful doesn't wash your sins away because the harm you did cannot be undone. So what if calley is remorseful? he still deserve hell and eternal suffering after death.
@ajosephcirene
@ajosephcirene 8 лет назад
muachi do I understand he took a lot of innocent lives. Maybe I was thinking you would read between the lines of my post? Sorry I some of my thoughts out of my post.
@phoenixflying2191
@phoenixflying2191 8 месяцев назад
This is beyond horrific! My heart absolutely breaks for all of the victims and their loved ones who are generationally traumatized by this. I can’t imagine that level of suffering and pain. Every soldier involved should have went to prison! My prayers are with the families of all victims. I need to say though , that not all veterans are capable of such atrocities. I worked in a group home for Vietnam era veterans. They were almost entirely draftees, not cut out for the military, let alone hurting others, war or not. They mentally broke from the things that happened on both sides, including a 3 year POW. He was so traumatized that he wouldn’t look people in the eyes and almost entirely mute except for short whispering answers. He was over 6’5” and had a very large build, but he made himself as small as possible and stayed in his room and kept to himself except for meals, meds, hygiene, and medical appointments. It broke my heart. After I worked with him for a year, he looked me in the eye. All I could see was the 18 year old draftee, who was thrown into a jungle, captured, thrown in a hole, and you can guess the rest. I can’t imagine what that would be like. Another vet would come to me periodically and ask if he would be sent back to Vietnam and he would try to trust my reassurance that he’ll never have to go back. I could go on, but you get the idea. How any of humanity can think that war is a solution when it only equals trauma and harm to all involved is beyond me. There are the victims, the ones who break, the evil, and also the heros. I’ve seen other interviews with Ty Mai soldiers, and some laugh and state that they have no remorse. It’s sickening! Some seemed still programmed and robotic. That was from videos long before this film. The soldier who had the “book of his life” in this film , seemed like he was broken but still a bit robotic in his first interview. In this interview, he is completely consumed by what he’s done and just wants to end it (and did just a few years after this interview). Losing both of his own children must have made him feel cursed for what he’d done. He obviously lived with the ghosts of his victims for the rest of his life. He also lived in fear that he would hurt someone and became a shut-in. According to what I’ve read, he had no criminal record and never hurt anyone again. Nothing excuses what he did, but I actually believe him that he snapped after the woman and baby and that he didn’t know that was inside of him until he did it. I can’t help but wonder, would he have ever harmed anyone if he’d never joined the military? Above all, I pray for the victims and their families, and for peace 🙏
@earthlycolorbrown6246
@earthlycolorbrown6246 6 лет назад
Thank Thompson for his Bravery in responding to the plight of 12 human beings under fire! Thank Universe for the few men who refused to murder!
@geraldtamaca116
@geraldtamaca116 6 лет назад
The victims in my lai don't deserved this...
@robertmitchell8728
@robertmitchell8728 6 лет назад
I can't say how things are now, but when I was in (much later) we were taught what a lawful order was, and what an unlawful order was. We were taught NOT to follow an unlawful order, and it was your duty to report, and stop an unlawful order from being carried out with what ever force was necessary. We were taught military laws/rules, U.S. laws, and Geneva convention rules of war. My understanding was that this was always the case, even back in WWII. I would doubt this if I didn't hear it from the horses mouth. 1 person, a fire team sure, but a company!
@maggiegeorgianayoung3456
@maggiegeorgianayoung3456 Месяц назад
Every American war is unlawful. America's existence is unlawful.
@kramnesnay
@kramnesnay Год назад
I remember almost 30 years ago seeing this in a psychology class in college. I never forgot about that black soldier who was wracked with guilt because of the atrocities he and others were made to commit. He said it was the programming that kicked in that made them act the way they did. I lived in Japan and met a Vietnam vet who spent all night telling me of the horrors of what he'd done during the war. He said the government fucked him and others over when they came back and weren't interested in helping them. He was trained to be a killing machine, now that the war was over, he can only survive with alcohol. Interestingly enough, my big brother fought in the British army and saw fucked up shit and killed people in Iraq supporting the US. The only way he copes nowadays is with alcohol. It shows how crazy war is and that it has no winners. My heart goes out to all those young men who're are programmed to kill which irrevocably changes a person's life. That's why we need to love each other. With love from England. 😍🙏
@lindareynolds2431
@lindareynolds2431 6 лет назад
In 1985 Richard Nixon recalled discussing the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki with MacArthur: "MacArthur once spoke to me very eloquently about it, pacing the floor of his apartment in the Waldorf. He thought it a tragedy the bomb was ever exploded. MacArthur believed that the same restrictions ought to apply to atomic weapons as to conventional weapons, that the military objective should always be limited damage to noncombatants... MacArthur, you see, was a soldier. He believed in using force only against military targets, and that is why the nuclear thing turned him off, which I think speaks well of him."
@maggiegeorgianayoung3456
@maggiegeorgianayoung3456 Месяц назад
MacArthur was a racist and a genocidal maniac. "It was my plan as our amphibious forces moved South to spread behind us-from the Sea of Japan to the Yellow Sea-a belt of radioactive cobalt. It could have been spread from wagons, carts, trucks and planes. It is not an expensive material. It has an active life of between 60 and 120 years." -Douglas MacArthur
@kimberlyguyton9130
@kimberlyguyton9130 7 лет назад
I am starting to believe that we are the baddies
@MrSchmolko
@MrSchmolko 7 лет назад
brutal awakening, isnt it. as long as the majority of americans still falls for the brainwashing propaganda that tells people that the troops fight to defend america and sacrifice so much to bring liberty and democracy to the opressed, things wont change.
@casbah1982
@casbah1982 6 лет назад
Kimberly, if you believe that; then you are free to leave the US at anytime. I'm sure Russia would love to have you, or you can marry an ISIS rebel. The kicker is...you will no long have access to the US and you will not ever be able to contact your family again. MrSchmolko is free to leave also! Many Americans will be happy to purchase a *ONE WAY* ticket to Russia for any Americans who want to leave this great country! If you think European countries want Americans to move there.....unless you got A LOT of money, think again!
@demywesup5099
@demywesup5099 6 лет назад
joe strummer you are just a brainwashed conservative nationalist who believes our country can do no wrong. Joe that is dangerous. We definitely were the “bad guys” in this war please do some research before blasting nationalist propaganda
@RB-pl5pg
@RB-pl5pg 6 лет назад
joe strummer I think you should leave.
@silentwolve
@silentwolve 6 лет назад
Lets all understand that in war terrible things happen. The USA has the ideals of a good people. We are a good people. There are good and bad from every nation. Nazi Germany furthered medical and non medical science by hundreds of years during WWII, just don't ask how that pill your taking to alleviate pain was invented.
@pjokkenroll
@pjokkenroll 6 лет назад
Hugh Thompson Jr. RESPECT!
@rogerwilco4397
@rogerwilco4397 9 лет назад
Vanardo Simpson did, in fact, succeed in killing himself, in 1997. He shot himself to put an end to his misery in this horrific, tragic story. He was 48.
@garrybaldy327
@garrybaldy327 Год назад
This doc has stayed with me since I first saw it 35yrs ago. Simpson's shaking hand was something I never forgot, but it wasn't until recently I found out he shot himself in 1997.
@videomaniac108
@videomaniac108 6 лет назад
People might be interested in researching Gen. Colin Powell's involvement in this incident. I believe he was a Major, working as a staff officer in the Americal(23rd) Div. at this time.
@cidcampeador7922
@cidcampeador7922 2 года назад
He arrived after the incident.
@videomaniac108
@videomaniac108 2 года назад
@@cidcampeador7922 I believe that he did handle the initial investigation for the division, Americal, and essentially told the brass what they wanted to hear.
@andyandtheotherone
@andyandtheotherone 3 года назад
Absolutely excellent Documentary. We must Never Forget!
@stevenbartolini
@stevenbartolini 6 лет назад
We as a country never learned any lessons from this war crime. Right now, today on the 50th anniversary of My-li, we are involved in 7 wars. And I can say with full confidence that "good red-blooded American boys" are murdering civilians. I can only say to the world, stay away from us. When an empire starts to totter and fall it flails away at any hint of loss of respect. The last war where we did anything good was WW2, everything since has been war for profit. The American empire has decided that if the world won't respect us they will surely fear us. An empire found on nothing but genocide and slavery is lucky to have lasted as long as it has, our values are now a blood drenched joke. And we are not going to stop our wars anytime soon. The military is our jobs program. Other countries are pursuing new, green, technologies. We promise our working class that the old jobs are coming back and out of desperation they choose to believe and elect liars that keep sending their children to war.
@1moonwitch
@1moonwitch 6 лет назад
stephen roth You are so correct!
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
You are so not informed. Ignorant of the job figures already in. Thousands of jobs have returned. We have more job openings now than bodies to fill them. People like you murder the truth which is far more dangerous than what you may think.
@christopherallen8930
@christopherallen8930 Год назад
Easy to judge war and soldiers from the comfort of a couch behind a computer screen. What experience do you have to say such a ugly broad statement. Watching youtube videos does not make you a expert. How do you know anything if you have never worn those boots let alone walked a few thousand miles in them?
@vanillagorilla8438
@vanillagorilla8438 6 лет назад
Mr. Harry Stanley and Michael Bernhardt... Much Respect! And I'm sorry that I'm ignorant of and couldn't find his name but the black man w/the book who has clearly been what appears to be Nothing but Honest, both with us as well as himself, I must say that I appreciate your accountability and your honesty about the whole thing, I can Respect that! But I couldn't understand that he was still a believer after such Immoral acts, and if one is a believer in "Heaven" then they must believe in "Hell" and I gotta believe he then must know what side of that coin he'd fall upon...
@i.mar.6563
@i.mar.6563 7 лет назад
Varnado Simpson passed away in 1997 ,I think he shot himself ,he did show true remorse unlike some who believed babies were a legit target and old men and young mothers. I wonder how many My Lai's have happened in Iraq and Afghanistan??
@Galimah
@Galimah 6 лет назад
Haditha massacre 2005.... Iraq
@Galimah
@Galimah 5 лет назад
@ Skrooge Lantay i have no idea. it was the first that came to my mind from watching the movie Battle for Haditha about the massacre
@jond2458
@jond2458 5 лет назад
No, it was not private contractors it was marines in Haditha. People judge a situation they've got no fucking clue about. Those marines in Haditha had been blown up by ied's left and right while those people just watched and waited. Does it make what they did right? No, it doesn't. But unless you've seen your friends taken out like that on a regular basis you have no right to judge because you don't know how you might react either. Not that any of the murders were justified but the numbers in a Haditha in comparison to my lai isn't even close.....
@ryanmarquez9404
@ryanmarquez9404 5 лет назад
He's a chicken shit, and I was in Afghanistan we didn't do shit to civilians. You have choices even in the military, his was to commit murder. It's unfortunate that he brought shame and embarrassment to my country and my uniform. Fucking disgusting human being, too bad the victims couldnt feel bad about the masaacare, seeing they are all dead.... You know about 500 of them.
@nikkiarankin880
@nikkiarankin880 5 лет назад
Jon D. Yeah it was another My Lai then
@tmise50
@tmise50 4 года назад
I hope all those involved in the killings that day, have suffered everyday since.
@josephodonoghue3581
@josephodonoghue3581 2 года назад
Why aren’t all of these Charlie Company troops now not locked up? There should be retrial.
@OliBeck-vs3mn
@OliBeck-vs3mn 3 месяца назад
Bingo, today I found out William Calley is alive and well, 80 years old, living peacefully in Gainesville, Florida. Nuremberg trials anyone?
@MrOkami75
@MrOkami75 5 лет назад
'...we did not violate any moral standards'. Is this guy for real? I've just watched a doc about the recent Marine A case in the UK army. This is like a whole different galaxy of wrong.
@kevenappleyard9813
@kevenappleyard9813 Год назад
You can't think that the journalists interviewing the unit members asked themselves later..."Am I capable of this?"
@dudley5658
@dudley5658 5 лет назад
So many RU-vid armchair heroes. Truth is no one knows how they would react given the exact same circumstances. I like to think there is no way I could have contributes to this atrocity but thank God I wasn't put in this situation. Especially at 18 years old.
@abby.kingston.author
@abby.kingston.author 5 лет назад
Thank you Dudley. This comment feed needed your comment so much. So many people sitting at home happy to pass judgement. So many people thinking they would do differently in the same situation. Hasn't anyone here ever heard of the Stanford Prison Experiment? Or the Milgram Experiments? We are all capable of things we never imagined doing, terrible things, given the right conditions. Some people have the strength of mind to do the right and moral thing in circumstances like this. BUT they are the minority. A fact made so clearly obvious by the horrific events at My Lai. Has no one asked themselves why the vast majority of the company joined in the horrendous killings? Do you think these kids were all just evil bastards, the whole lot of them? And why there were comparatively so few "heroes" in the situation? My Lai was a classic example of human psychology in action. The very same psychology that has been studied by people like Milgram and Zimbado. I'm not saying that what happened was okay. Not even close. My Lai was an utterly horrific and tragic event. But I am saying that people should educate themselves before being so ready to pass judgement. And that My Lai was a tragedy for everyone involved. Everyone. Compassion is what is needed here.
@mookie2637
@mookie2637 2 года назад
@@abby.kingston.author I suspect it was slightly more of a tragedy if you were raped, or murdered, or mutilated than it was if you were one of the perpetrators. The problem with the "compassion for all" point of view is that you are on a slippery slope towards not being able to judge, try or convict those perpetrators.
@sharonrigs7999
@sharonrigs7999 Год назад
Just look at Germany, Japan or Stalin's USSR Huge numbers of people were actively engaged in horrific acts of brutality. Were these people truly evil? Some were. Psychopaths prosper where there is no accountability.
@thoroughbred21
@thoroughbred21 2 года назад
Not enough discussion of the rapes.
@user-us5pv8zw3z
@user-us5pv8zw3z 5 месяцев назад
I want to know what my brother did when he was there. I could never get him to talk about it.
@joe_8699
@joe_8699 5 лет назад
So dam heart breaking.
@GenXstacker
@GenXstacker 2 года назад
Varnado Simpson, although a perpetrator, was also a victim. Easy to say you would have refused orders. Much harder in real life. How many of us at the age of 18 or 19 would have had that sort of courage and conviction to refuse a direct order? These young men were put in a virtually impossible situation: "After three unsuccessful attempts, Simpson took his own life in his home on Sunday, May 4, 1997, at the age of 48, with a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head."
@elim9054
@elim9054 Год назад
The Nuremberg defense. Never gets old!
@GenXstacker
@GenXstacker Год назад
@@elim9054 Most of the people who rattle off "Nuremberg defense" from their school lessons or book knowledge would probably not pass the test in real life. It's a minority who have that sort of moral compass in a war to disobey orders and disregard the collective decision of their comrades. I know a guy who is the sweetest guy you would ever want to meet. Nice to everybody, goes out of his way to be kind. He was over there as a kid and told me that at that time he hated all those people. Said he was part of a group whose job was to go in and mop up villages after battles. You can use your imagination as to what that involved. I think this sort of stuff goes on all the time in wars and 99% of it just never comes to light.
@MarjorieNardini
@MarjorieNardini 6 лет назад
War is death and carnage. War gives permission to take a life, what is considered a crime under any other circumstance, what is considered a sin by most faiths. War is determined by men sitting safely in an office ( whomever declares war should have to walk point. ) What meets the criteria to consider lives expendable? I have always felt that our duty is to protect our country, our shores and yet we have been involved in wars for other, at times, not so noble reasons. I understand helping the persecuted, but at what cost? And our men, not only risk their lives, but often are treated with scorn and distaine at home, especially with Vietnam . I will never condone their actions, but understand many of the extensive circumstances. I can never forgive the actions, but I can forgive the man. My brother served in Nam, but because of his post never saw combat. But he still felt the effects of war when his barracks were bombed taking the lives of friends and his health. My tears are for the victims, the innocents of My Lai, and for the men who must live with choices made. The only way for man to survive is with peace, yet here we are, in a world of conflict and war...
@ManuelBTC21
@ManuelBTC21 2 года назад
42:00 Absolutely chilling exchange. Just following orders.
@mynameisnotimportant2854
@mynameisnotimportant2854 7 лет назад
Hugh Thompson = Oskar Schindler
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
Former soldier's statement in the film was that he killed about 25 and he scalped them, cut their hands off, cut their tongues out, etc. He said his "programming" kicked in. Is he talking about his training? I trained in the Army for 14 yrs. Served time overseas in war. I seemed to have missed those training sessions. What the hell is he talking about?!
@Idalych
@Idalych 5 лет назад
parker5511 did you serve in Vietnam? Lol
@Vinegarissweet
@Vinegarissweet 5 лет назад
Clearly it wasn't the same during that time.
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
@@Vinegarissweet I wouldn't be so quick to believe these loose cannons that say they were "trained" or "made" to do it. At any time in America's history. No doubt you will have anti-american types that think we do. The bottom line is the world is better off with our past help. The boat people from Vietnam understood that. That's why they fled. Look at all the people fleeing Central and South America trying to get here. Consider what they have considered.
@ryanmarquez9404
@ryanmarquez9404 5 лет назад
I know I love these bullshit excuses these guys are giving, it might fool the civilians, but I served too assholes. I was just following orders is complete bullshit, blame the leadership all you want, but fucking grunts pulled the triggers.
@bradleymcwilliams2629
@bradleymcwilliams2629 4 года назад
It's pretty obvious what hes talking about u clown! Hes recounting his experience,knowing full well it was awful!....these kind of RU-vid vids are full of people commenting about their service!...I did this and that and blah blah to help so and so!....this guy had the balls to admit to an.evil act! Are you immaculate? Have you never even thought of an evil act, less been in the u fortunate position of committing something so vile? It's great to write your righteousness on a website comments section....I wonder how virtuous u really are!
@rekunta
@rekunta 6 лет назад
I feel sympathy for Varnado. Yes he killed so many, but he apparently endured a living hell of guilt after. Shows that he had a conscience. I can't bring myself to condemn him as much as I'd like to. He comes off as a good man put into the worst of circumstances.
@fukuu7998
@fukuu7998 6 лет назад
at this point he was heavily medicated and had had his own son die in his arms from a shooting he suffered severe ptsd and began claiming much higher numbers in his own personal killings and completely changing some aspects, he also began claiming he talked to people who were miles away from him in another part of the village. originally he claimed he had killed less than ten and that his point guard was forcing him to with the threat of shooting him.
@LeotheOrangeCat
@LeotheOrangeCat 6 лет назад
killing 10 is enough
@littleblackfox1
@littleblackfox1 6 лет назад
I felt some pity for him..fleetingly.. and yeah acknowledging his crime makes him 100 times better than that piece of shit Calley, who thought he was actually justified to do what he did.. But at the end of the day, he still slaughtered at least 10 innocent, clearly unarmed people, as they cowered and begged for their lives.. and for all we know raped some of them too.. no amount of being sorry can make a even a dint in rectifying that.
@Kelly14UK
@Kelly14UK 6 лет назад
Sometimes you can just see complete remorse in a person.
@lindareynolds2431
@lindareynolds2431 6 лет назад
borh
@tyson6819
@tyson6819 2 года назад
Hugh Thompson Junior was a real hero!
@thechicco0s
@thechicco0s 3 года назад
Such a powerful documentary.
@austinguy32
@austinguy32 4 года назад
I watched this in history class 10 years ago I still think about it
@Berniewahlbrinck
@Berniewahlbrinck Год назад
You must have had a good teacher.
@austinguy32
@austinguy32 Год назад
@@Berniewahlbrinck mr heacok. I'll never forget him or my literature teacher mrs Erickson 💯
@TheRetiredVeteran
@TheRetiredVeteran 8 лет назад
In the UK they are called "Leftenant," but in the USA they are called Lieutenant.
@russellmoxham5625
@russellmoxham5625 7 лет назад
Same spelling, mind
@colinwoods9601
@colinwoods9601 6 лет назад
It’s probably safe to assume that before this day these “men” (in life experience were essentially kids) weren’t all murderous monsters. They were all put into a position that helped facilitate these barbarous actions. They were led to believe that anyone who wasn’t one of them was the enemy, that these were the people responsible for their brothers’ deaths. I’m by no means excusing their actions, every single one of them deserves prison at a minimum-I just would never presume to understand all of the factors that led to these young men to behave like such savages. A horrible tragedy for everyone involved.
@unfortunately_fortunate2000
@unfortunately_fortunate2000 5 лет назад
43:44 now that's a stunning example of cognitive dissonance, fucking textbook example..
@Berniewahlbrinck
@Berniewahlbrinck Год назад
Exaxtly!
@johnadams9505
@johnadams9505 3 года назад
"After three unsuccessful attempts, Varnado Simpson took his own life in his home on Sunday, May 4, 1997, at the age of 48, with a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head" (from his wiki page).
@Napoleon1323
@Napoleon1323 6 месяцев назад
Varnado Simpson committed suicide in 1997. Rip
@user-us5pv8zw3z
@user-us5pv8zw3z 5 месяцев назад
That poor man. I don’t condone his actions by any means, but he surely suffered for them.
@T171OO
@T171OO 4 месяца назад
It’s interesting how much information he was willing to divulge about his actions, maybe that was his way of repenting for the evil he had done.
@Wristwatchme
@Wristwatchme 3 месяца назад
I think you meant to say, Rest in Pits. The same ones he threw bodies into. Let that sink in,
@Vij3eth
@Vij3eth 15 дней назад
RIP you wish, I hope his spirit never finds peace
@hauptmannnn
@hauptmannnn 4 месяца назад
Where is nunerberg trial
@Wristwatchme
@Wristwatchme 3 месяца назад
What’s the statue of limitations on this? Today I found out where William Calley lives and confirmed it. I would love to put up $10k to start a go fund me so that 80 year old fool can finally be put on trial. Hard to believe one of americas worst murder criminals was give 3 years then house arrest and pardoned.
@jimbobhk2009
@jimbobhk2009 2 месяца назад
Nunerberg
@PawsonPatriota
@PawsonPatriota 7 лет назад
I've seen older Documentary about My Lai and there was also Mr Simpson (May God forgives his lost Soul) in an interview. He was in his early twentys then but I didnt seen him in that bad nervous condition like in this video. He was rather calm when talking about the killings in the first years after his homecoming. Seems his PTSD became stronger over the years. After I read about his suicide i felt really sorry for him. Almost same feeling i feel about his victims in the vietnamese village. If someone is looking for the real guilty and responsible ones, he should be searching for those who pushed and started that war. And not for the small draftees, who gone threw Hell like their victims.
@tommyvinson6
@tommyvinson6 6 лет назад
Exactley right
@Affenhirte
@Affenhirte 6 лет назад
Of course it is true that the soldiers (most of them very young/underclass/maybe picked fighting over prison) wouldn't have found themselves in such situations in the first place, without manipulative politicians and ruthless leaders. Yet still, in the end, it is every man's very personal decision whether to follow or refuse any given order. We have to assume that people who would execute an order to kill innocent people, would - on the other hand - refuse to execute an order to take their own lives. So there is a limit and you are the one to define it for yourself. You can not hide behind the order, you can not hide behind the commander, you can not hand over responsibility.
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
Yeah and all the boat people that fled after the fall of saigon were really off looking to get even with Lt. Calley, right?
@Affenhirte
@Affenhirte 5 лет назад
@Laika24102007 Bullshit.
@pizdanpula223
@pizdanpula223 4 года назад
It's justice , too bad the others didn't get any ..mabey in hell
@MrPearlsareforever
@MrPearlsareforever 9 лет назад
This can almost leave someone speechless very sad I wish sometimes that older men were in charge closely with the soldiers who are in the thick of war youth can sometimes cause poor choices when you of 2nd LT's being 19 years old!? Come on.
@brb8407
@brb8407 6 лет назад
IR Old men are the ones who make the orders.
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
Yeah, Demoncrats!
@susanborkenhagen58
@susanborkenhagen58 5 лет назад
Jimmy Carter wanted Calley freed and now Trump is considering pardoning him. What is wrong with our leaders in this country?!
@francesd2913
@francesd2913 5 лет назад
I am very proud of Mr Stanley, he was one of the intelligent people there to refuse this insane order to kill babies.
@mickymcstitch7960
@mickymcstitch7960 6 лет назад
I've seen some bad stuff here in Ireland. But seeing the picture of the women and children that were later shot broke my heart
@bertcandela9250
@bertcandela9250 6 лет назад
Micky Mcstitch A huge salute to my Irish brothers. In 1846-1848, the Irish soldiers in the U S Army saw the same atrocities being committed on the Mexican population in Mexico and what is now the Southwest U S. The Irish realized that they had more in common with the 'enemy' and defected to the Mexican side. They became known as the San Patricios or the Saint Patrick Batallion. I as an American Chicano am forever grateful to these brave men.
@bertcandela9250
@bertcandela9250 6 лет назад
Amen to that brother, I still get chills when I decide to play Sunday Bloody Sunday by U2. Good hearted people world wide will never forget.
@mickymcstitch7960
@mickymcstitch7960 6 лет назад
Bert Candela: a shame the British army's still here, I was shot in the ass and in prison for 3 and a half years, every day we were beaten and starved, Tiocfaidh ar la, mo chara ✌️ ✌️ ✌️
@mickymcstitch7960
@mickymcstitch7960 6 лет назад
Snake Plisskin: your a laugh 😂
@SWALAguangzhou
@SWALAguangzhou 7 лет назад
This is how war makes people,whenever you hear your country waging a war,u should cringe, remember what happened in Iraq ,haditha massacre....war makes even this young soldiers do something they will not wish to do, they suffer after the war alone,war dehumanizes this young souls
@Michaelmouse23
@Michaelmouse23 6 лет назад
37.00 just breaks your heart. awful
@seanschultz2875
@seanschultz2875 6 лет назад
THAT ONE SON OF A BITCH WITH THE WHITE POLO SHIRT ON IS A REAL PIECE OF WORK
@charlesmelonson8049
@charlesmelonson8049 6 лет назад
I was there fighting in Vietnam at this time,i was fighting at a different place on the DMV
@charlesmelonson8049
@charlesmelonson8049 6 лет назад
DMZ,excuse me i just took my DMV test,hahaha
@katrig6295
@katrig6295 4 года назад
Who is the man talking at around 52mins ?
@judithfx1843
@judithfx1843 4 года назад
General Kenneth hodson former US army chief prosecutor
@holly9096
@holly9096 6 лет назад
Now Im coming to understand that the soldiers were suffering too. We’re learning about this in High School US history and even though I felt great anger towards the Americans, I now understand that they were following orders. They were _drafted_, told to do it because it was for the pride of the USA, to combat the evil communists. When the vets came back American citizens spat at their feet. It’s a shame. And it’s alright to feel anger at America, too, because we were the ones who got involved anyway.
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
This is why i don't support public school education. They teach "hate america" philosophy.
@nemesisg.5348
@nemesisg.5348 Год назад
This is a rather weak defense for the rather evil nature of what happened in My L'ai. Yes soldiers suffered and were fed on some lies but you have to be seriously deranged to kill children and rape women, in what world is that even something akin to fighting an enemy? Misguided as it could be
@beardedloon77
@beardedloon77 11 месяцев назад
@nemesisg.5348 I think you have to try and understand the mindset of these young draftees, the average age of a grunt in Charlie company when this happened was 20, now please imagine you're a 20 old lad from averageville usa, you're sleep deprived, constantly in fear of death because you have seen 28 of your unit die in awful ways from booby traps, mines, etc. You are then told the regiment responsible for all your dead friends is within reach, but you gotta go in an show no mercy, the whole village is a v.c stronghold hiding the 48th army v.c, orders given in the field are harder to ignore because of the risk of being shot for disobeying an order, or just shot an they use your body as evidence that they took enemy fire. Justifying things further in a court martial.
@Cadfael007
@Cadfael007 7 лет назад
One of the best US documentaries ever - besides "The Civil War" by Ken Burns (both broadcasted in Germany). I think Jay Ungar's "Ashokan Farewell" reflects / sets to music both catastrophies of US history. They were all loosers (civilians and "simple soldiers") ...
@KOHF34
@KOHF34 5 лет назад
I do feel sympathy for Varnado Simpson. He clearly is exhibiting PTSD symptoms in this interview. I genuinely believe he was sorry for what he did. In case anyone was wondering, he ended his life eight years after this interview. He had been in and out of psychiatric hospitals during that time.
@RaiderRSupastar
@RaiderRSupastar 5 лет назад
He had a lot of prescription on the table. Sad.
@chewey
@chewey 2 года назад
Well, there's no undoing mass murder. He ought to have offered the My Lai villagers catharsis by letting them blow his brains out, but unfortunately he beat them to it.
@KingHayabusa384
@KingHayabusa384 Год назад
I have zero sympathy for him. He doesn't deserve any.
@KOHF34
@KOHF34 Год назад
@@KingHayabusa384 What he did was wrong. I’m not refuting it, but if he wasn’t sincere in how sorry he was, he deserved an Oscar.
@thomas-rs1vb
@thomas-rs1vb 5 лет назад
There's a documentary in 1970 with some of these guys in your movie..This is not the first
@RELopez-mk4ic
@RELopez-mk4ic 5 лет назад
Why?
@claytonmoura4577
@claytonmoura4577 7 лет назад
Gezz Just like those Nazi pogroms in WW2
@parker5511
@parker5511 5 лет назад
Like watching ANTIFA in Portland. That's the way the Nazi brownshirts started too.
@aadrianlee
@aadrianlee 2 года назад
The Lesson left hear is never go to war for no reason at all. Stay home on the farm with you loved ones. ( ;
Далее
The lightweights ended Round One with a BANG 💪
00:10
Китайка Шрек поймал Зайца😂😆
00:20
Symmetrical face⁉️🤔 #beauty
00:15
Просмотров 3,6 млн
Murder and Manhunts | "48 Hours" Full Episodes
2:05:54
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Ron Ridenhour’s Last Talk: My Lai and Why it Matters
1:17:19
DEVASTATED  Colorado's Fentanyl Disaster
1:28:15
Просмотров 625 тыс.
Assignment in Vietnam BBC 1969
1:04:57
Просмотров 762 тыс.
The lightweights ended Round One with a BANG 💪
00:10