Тёмный

From Pixels To Perception: Linux's X11 vs Wayland in Great Details! 

Oddstone Games
Подписаться 482
Просмотров 26 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

29 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 62   
@sacredbanana
@sacredbanana 14 дней назад
Apparently there's a primitive version of X11 for Commodore Amiga to ease porting UNIX applications to AmigaOS, though I know nothing about it
@MrCWoodhouse
@MrCWoodhouse 11 месяцев назад
Thanks. Helped me a lot to understand. X11 has been such a mystery to me my whole life. Time to learn.
@oddstonegames
@oddstonegames 11 месяцев назад
I am glad it helped you!
@lealcy
@lealcy 7 месяцев назад
The display manager (KDM, GDM, XDM) loads after X11 or Wayland. The DM is just a graphical program to manage the login to the desktop and need a graphical server to load on.
@neamupanselutelor7309
@neamupanselutelor7309 4 месяца назад
How does the DM choose whether to load X11 or Wayland on the first boot?
@lealcy
@lealcy 4 месяца назад
@@neamupanselutelor7309 it depends on how the distro is configured on install
@yusefaslam9675
@yusefaslam9675 2 месяца назад
In GDM (GNOME Display Manager), there is an option called "WaylandEnable", if that is set to true, GDM uses Wayland, if it is false or commented out it uses X11.
@yusefaslam9675
@yusefaslam9675 2 месяца назад
Sorry, I meant to say in GDM's configuration file.
@anonymouscommentator
@anonymouscommentator 5 месяцев назад
loved the video, thank you very much!
@twachl8039
@twachl8039 8 месяцев назад
great video, thumbs up my friend
@methos1024
@methos1024 8 месяцев назад
I Like this explanation, but it ist not 100% correct :-) still good for understanding some things especially about X11
@methos1024
@methos1024 8 месяцев назад
Wayland is not a Display Server that first statement is alredy wrong. It is a Protocol and the actual Desktops have to program thyr Display managers etc. around that protocol for compatibility.
@whoman0385
@whoman0385 4 месяца назад
same with X11, just a protocol and there are display servers that implement it like xorg and xfree86
@methos1024
@methos1024 4 месяца назад
@@whoman0385 Yeah, that should be correct. So i should Frame what i want to say a bit different so everyone gets what i really want to say.
@ClintAnderson808
@ClintAnderson808 5 месяцев назад
this was nice to find after watching several videos that were just people reading web pages or spouting off opinions, thanks for this
@iamwatchingthisvid.7682
@iamwatchingthisvid.7682 3 месяца назад
I ran into problems with wayland being unable to drag and drop archive contents to my file explorer when extracting... but on x11 worked just fine... wayland is much responsive tho and I use gnome desktop.... if this problem in wayland is fixed then I might use it again
@akashashen
@akashashen Месяц назад
Minor note, over a year later, initramfs loads the root file system. It loads first in case a problem disrupts that sequence (that's why it has itsown mini-toolkit/environment.
@PoeLemic
@PoeLemic 4 месяца назад
Thank you for explaining this -- thru showing us an example. It makes total sense. I had basic idea of how X worked, but I'm coming from Windows. And, I want to understand Linux better.
@sweetlaura7316
@sweetlaura7316 Год назад
Roses are red, violets are blue, your pixel knowledge is on point, and your humor is too! 😂
@oddstonegames
@oddstonegames Год назад
AAHHAHAHHA! Thank you so much!
@HikaruAkitsuki
@HikaruAkitsuki 8 месяцев назад
If you running Linux in VM which is the host is also Linux, X11 version of your DE is work better than Wayland's DE
@kienhwengtai8113
@kienhwengtai8113 3 месяца назад
There's zero benefit using Wayland on VM because the underlying GPU is a virtual GPU anyway.
@methos1024
@methos1024 8 месяцев назад
Wayland does NOT handle User input. Things like libinput is used for user inputs
@dragos-andreirotaru2316
@dragos-andreirotaru2316 8 месяцев назад
Hyprland dev commented :))
@oddstonegames
@oddstonegames 8 месяцев назад
Oh wow! I am glad you watched it. 😄
@wile123456
@wile123456 2 месяца назад
The only annoying thing in wayland is vsync is forced on for everything, so the vsync setting in video games litterally does nothing. Vsync should be enabled for windows and desktop applications, but its annoying it doesnt allow easy changing of vsync of games or 3D applications
@xXaymanXxBG
@xXaymanXxBG Месяц назад
Dawg now i understand why since i stopped using wayland my pc stopped freezing forcing me to cut off electricity on the entire pc just to reboot...
@RishiYT-is1ld
@RishiYT-is1ld Месяц назад
thank you
@meqdadfn
@meqdadfn 28 дней назад
This is the best explanation of display servers and windows managers I’ve watched! Great video.
@AnnatarTheMaia
@AnnatarTheMaia 5 месяцев назад
Boy am I glad we don't have "Weyland" on Solaris! Good old X11R6 (Solaris 10) and X11R7 (Solaris 11 / illumos) and driiivvveee....
@JacksonNick-j6i
@JacksonNick-j6i 4 месяца назад
Using Solaris is even more funny than using BSD OSes as a desktop. At least FreeBSD and OpenBSD are good for servers. Who tf uses Solaris in 2024?
@NitroNilz
@NitroNilz 4 месяца назад
That's very "racist" in terms of OS'es. (Does it have a term? OS-ist?). I would also suggest jumping to open source like an illumos distribution, but still respect people who'd stay on proprietary shit.
@AnnatarTheMaia
@AnnatarTheMaia 4 месяца назад
@@NitroNilz the word you are looking for is "elitist", and yes it is, and so what? Enough with mediocrity!
@NitroNilz
@NitroNilz 4 месяца назад
@@AnnatarTheMaia I was referring to "who […] uses Solaris in 2024?" as elitist. Thank you for the word! Down with mediocracy!
@aka6double0
@aka6double0 6 месяцев назад
Wow, thank you. Very well said my friend.
@oglothenerd
@oglothenerd 4 месяца назад
Why hello there! :)
@gamedevmode
@gamedevmode Год назад
thank you for explaining in such great details!
@oddstonegames
@oddstonegames Год назад
You are welcome!
@malborocomun
@malborocomun 4 месяца назад
X11 makes more sense
@GnuChanOS
@GnuChanOS 4 месяца назад
I tried Wayland before in Manjaro, but it only showed a cursor and a black screen, so I gave up. Xorg works fine for me.
@NKG416
@NKG416 2 месяца назад
so what's the different between linux and windows in these area?
@methos1024
@methos1024 8 месяцев назад
There is not really a question whether to go with wayland or X11. its more like have you an nvidia Graphics card oder an AMD/Intel graphics card. With the first one you have no real choice. witch the others the best option for many usecases ist the not deprecated standard - wayland. But you also may have A workload that does currently not support wwayland - so again no choice..
@1pcfred
@1pcfred 3 месяца назад
I use X.0rg but I have used X11 in the past. X11R6
@miku
@miku 8 месяцев назад
god is happy
@SlinkyD
@SlinkyD 5 месяцев назад
Wayland is X12.
@1pcfred
@1pcfred 3 месяца назад
Wayland is X0
@ToyKeeper
@ToyKeeper 2 месяца назад
I use X11 because network transparency and accessibility and automation are important, and Wayland sacrificed those things to solve problems I don't have. I could list many examples if youtube's filter would let me, but it blocks long comments... so I'll try to describe just one. I have a bunch of computers, including desktops, notebooks, and servers. I rely on being able to use all of them regardless of where I am or which hardware is in front of me. With X11 I can mix and match freely, but Wayland is designed to prevent that because it's considered unnecessary and a security risk. Like, if I'm at my desk I have a desktop and two notebooks, so I use the desktop's mouse and keyboard for all three, simply moving the cursor off the edge of one screen and onto the next, using a trivial little program called x2x. But frequently I'll grab a notebook to go elsewhere, like a cafe or the loo or a client meeting or even just the living room couch. I can still use every computer, either by exporting a running session as a remote desktop, or running individual programs over the network for remote display, or simply moving the cursor to any screens which happen to be nearby. It all "just works" easily and reliably, even for servers with no screen or keyboard attached. When doing local stuff it's a smooth 60fps with no perceptible lag, and when remote, things are slower but still very usable. But Wayland doesn't do that. In a time when nearly everything in computing is getting more flexible, more interoperable, and more network-transparent... Wayland strives to go in the opposite direction. With Wayland, I can't even use my notebooks while I'm at my desk.
@gustavojoaquin_arch
@gustavojoaquin_arch 7 месяцев назад
Imagine using winbugs
@harshpandey703
@harshpandey703 Год назад
thanks!
@silver-zero
@silver-zero Год назад
thank you so much!
@oddstonegames
@oddstonegames Год назад
no worries!
@garolstipock
@garolstipock Год назад
this was superb!
@oddstonegames
@oddstonegames Год назад
I am glad you liked it!
@vaxryy
@vaxryy 8 месяцев назад
22 seconds in an you already have made a considerable mistake. That's quite fast. Neither X11 nor Wayland are display servers.
@dragos-andreirotaru2316
@dragos-andreirotaru2316 8 месяцев назад
Display protocol?
@oddstonegames
@oddstonegames 8 месяцев назад
Ok, I did my research when i made this video but found that the two terms were used interchangeably, I don't have any kind of experience with wayland or x11, i did it only for a month or two and decided to make a video about it. If you can explain in detail it will be of help to anyone reading :)
@slycordinator
@slycordinator 6 месяцев назад
​@@oddstonegames As alluded to, X11 is a windowing system and protocol. A big component of it is the server, but X11 itself isn't the server. Though, the distinction can be confusing, given that X11's canonical implementation is XOrg Server.
@khaled-0
@khaled-0 3 месяца назад
🤓
@wildwestrom
@wildwestrom 3 месяца назад
​@@oddstonegames You just admitted you haven't even used the software you're talking about and made a video about them?
@CocolinoFan
@CocolinoFan 5 месяцев назад
Wasteland is not a display server, is a protocol
Далее
Showdown 2024: X11 vs Wayland
41:17
Просмотров 34 тыс.
Wayland vs X11
19:05
Просмотров 151 тыс.
Watermelon magic box! #shorts by Leisi Crazy
00:20
Просмотров 16 млн
The History of X11
58:19
Просмотров 257 тыс.
This Could Be Bad ...
8:47
Просмотров 34 тыс.
How A Steam Bug Deleted Someone’s Entire PC
11:49
Nix explained from the ground up
23:39
Просмотров 33 тыс.
Hyprland Revisited
1:57:45
Просмотров 38 тыс.
Networking - Lecture 2B
41:29
Просмотров 20
Wayland vs Xorg in 2024
6:45
Просмотров 39 тыс.