Maybe because 4 member group is actually easy to maintain like they can save money for makeup costume and other stuff and by my side it's easy to remember their name and fanchant unlike nct..
tho blackpink was supposed to be a 9 member group!!! but trainees started to leave the company until the members of blackpink are the only ones left...
0:08 Im Sooah (now Im Youha) - currently a soloist under the name Youha 0:10 Lee Seoyeon - currently in fromis_9 0:12 Moon Sua - currently in Billlie 0:14 Park Seoyoung - currently a soloist under the name Roya
I don't wanna sound mean and ahead of myself but with the unnecessarily long amount of free time I have I can do actually a majority of this and I feel like I am being rude sorry 🥺☹
@@sophiareis2237 Park Seoyoung chose Roya as her artistic name. She is now a soloist. Im Sooah chose Youha as her artistic name. She is now a soloist. Lee Seoyeon debuted in Fromis_9 Moon Sua debuted in Billlie Truth be told things didn't go very well for Seoyoung, she only released one song, three years ago and it has less than 18k views. I couldn't find anything recent, I think she retired. Sooah's career went better. She has been releasing songs for over 3 years and some have over 1 million views. Not great, but she is still active as an idol. Fromis_9 doesn't get the best treatment from Pledis or Hybe and has been a bit mismanaged, but they have a loyal fanbase and are definitely a well-known group. Billlie came from a small company, which makes their success very impressive. They are not huge, but they bring in good numbers.
For those who wonder why Jisoo, Jennie, Rose and Lisa debuted instead of any of these other girls......YG held monthly recitals for all the trainees(which is probably what this video is) and would try them out in all sorts of combinations. They found that the four who wound up in Blackpink had an unbeatable chemistry and charisma that wasn't matched in any other combination. On another note, young Jisoo was such a cutey!
Actually no. This was the "future 2NE1" original lineup at the time. Jisoo, Jennie, Rosé and Lisa weren't a part of it, they were in "Pink Punk" lineup wich had 9 members back in 2012 (they even had a logo that same year and did some promos), but ended up being scrapped, shortened and it's now what we know as BLACKPINK with just 4 members.
I don't know much about BP. But they were going to be 9 girls and the group name was pink punk. And the girls from the original line up left the agency (one of them was Miyeon who is currently in Gidle) Then just the 4 girls (current BP) had to debut as BlackPink
Because there were actually gonna be 2 groups by YG future2NE1 and YG's take on SNSD but then YG dropped the idea of future 2NE1 and tried focusing on the other GG but then 5 more trainees quit or didn't make it and it ended with 4 members AKA BLACKPINK
YGE !!! just tell me how much perfection you expected from these girls that you didn't let them debut ? Exactly how much ? They're more talented than most girl groups these days
The Pinks are all actually there! 😁 Rosé's sitting next to jisoo, lisa's next to the girl beside rosé, and jennie's next to the girl beside lisa. rosé, lisa and jennie is sitting one seat apart to each other. i can tell it' s really rosé because her face is clearer here than lisa and jennie. lisa is the one wearing light jeans. i can tell it's her because I know that's lisa's legs 😂 and as for jennie, she's the one with the two-toned hair. if you've watched her trainee days performances, you can see one where she has a two-toned hair-black for the above part of her hair and gold/blonde for the lower and inner part. 😊
@@kisikisi4766 no actually its not rose, because that was filmed in 2010 and posted in 2012, rose joigned the company witch 2NE1 debuted at that time 1 year ago, but the 5 other members (including the two from gidle who supposed to debut with bp) are the only who were trainees when 2NE1 were also trainees, hahah did you got something ?😂😂☹️ that one who looked like rose is from gidle right now you can check her you will notice that she look like rosé
One of the members that was going to be a part of this group left, so BP ended up debuting while they reshuffled and replanned the new group. In between that, another member left after her contract ran out. It’s not rocket science, it’s just business. They had a group planned and it fell through. BP debut got pushed back because they weren’t as prepared to be debuting as soon as they did. Things change in business and to continue to make money they have to make changes. YG is a business - not an amateur dance and singing studio.... They do have to put the business first to keep going. No different than any other business
Everyone talking about BP meanwhile I'm feeling sad for these hard working girls that never got to debut. Edit: Dang thanks for 22k likes and explanations in the comments
That's how life is.. This is all about business.. Yg didn't make the debut maybe for some reasons, we don't know.. So don't came up with conclusion.. If you watch YGTB then you will know how he choose the trainer.. We should be thankful.. if BLACKPINK have nine members, it's not blackpink anymore.. And look at how they successful now.. YG knows what he do.. Like what I said this is all about business..
After 10 years,this 4 girls are already successful,SEOYOUNG as independent solo singer,SUA as a Billlie member,SOOAH as soloist and producer and SEOYEON as a Fromis_9 member
3 of them are solo artists now,1 got to debut in a new group called fromis_9(The girl with the white shirt and long hair,name Seoyeon),so they all got to debut 💕💕💕
@@alexismecha3766 I'm glad all their hard works and long training paid off So I'm happy for them By the way I'm a Flover (Fromis_9 fan) Seoyeon is amazing
@@InfectiousCheese the one with an 'H' on her shirt. Moon Sua:- rapper, writes lyrics, ranked 3rd on unpretty rapstar vol.2, Astro's Moonbin little sis....
the girl in white tee and black shorts is lee seoyeon !!! she debuted in fromis_9 in 2018 !!! she’s an amazing singer, rapper, dancer and she also composes and produces !!! her group fromis_9 just had a comeback with the album unlock my world and title track #menow !!!!! :)
You speak like BP members and other trainees didn't do all of this as well? This is one group of trainees they shared with the world, they have tapes of every trainee working their ass off as well
Blackpink was bashed for no reason , because these are the 4 girls who were meant to replace 2ne1 , and pinkpunk was similar to snsd. From that blackpink was formed.
Jisoo sitting and watching those girls without knowing she’ll be a member of biggest girl group,Visual Goddess, Lead Actress, Debuting as Soloist, Debuting as Actress and the girl that people will love and support. Edit: she was even smiling at them while performing and her chubby cheeks showing up
One thing I absolutely loved about this video was not only the talent displayed by the girls, but how Jisso was right behind them sitting on the side continuously smiling, clapping, and saying "wow" when the girls were doing hair flips and on the ground!
@@aismanueljr.2484 for now, but maybe 10 years later they will join their sunbaenims to be called LEGENDS as they broke a lot of records. We all know YG artists are for the LEGENDS
어릴때부터 이렇게 훈련되어지면 얻는것도 있겠지만 잃는것도 있겠죠... 하지만 어릴때부터 꿈과 목표가 있다는것이 얼마나 큰 차이를 만들어내는지 세상을 43년이나 살아보니 알겠더라구요.. 전 우리 동생들 나이때 뭘 보았고 뭘 했나를 생각해보면 우리동생들 너무 자랑스러워요 끝까지 포기하지 않고 힘내길 바랍니다
Yeah that's for sure. Out of topic but I just want to share that this made me realize something so important about life that even if they're good and labeled as future 2ne1, the end of the training process can change anytime. Even if you're the number 1 now it can change the last minute of the decision so don't brag and be humble. Like life. Look at blackpink sitting and being amazed by them without knowing they'll go bigger than the word "2ne1". Just a thought hehe.
@@maxenfer4267 That is how life works. However, I disagree with your last sentence, which states that BP is larger than their seniors. Again, YT views are not success indicators. 2NE1 had only been active for 5 years, but they made such a huge impact in the industry that they coined the term "Monster Rookies," and being labeled as "IDOLS of all IDOLS" and "KPOP Queens" is insane. Remember that the Internet and music streaming platforms were not as popular during the second generation, but 2NE1 made it all possible for them to be at the top. 2NE1 WILL BE THE BLUEPRINT FOREVER.
@@hello_bomin Scheme 2nei were never queen of kpop they were snsd instead blackpink if they were and not only of kpop if not of the world something that 2nei1 never achieved
@@pheoespiritu8684 too I like 2ne1 but I love bp But for example if you ask me "2ne1 or Blackpink?" I would certainly choose 2ne1 because I respect them a lot the same goes for Bigbang + another boy group I would always choose Bigbang no matter what
by now, all 4 girls have left yg and debuted at other agencies (two of them as soloists, seoyeon in fromis9 and moon sua in billlie) and im honestly glad they left
adila hanani no 2ne1 renewed their contract and wanted to keep the group but ygent disbanded them after 6months when they were preparing their new album
Park Jinny is finally debuting as a main rapper of their girl group namely Secret Number. . we all know that she is a pinkpunk member please support here as u support them as nine. KEEP FIGHTING PARK JINNY!!
BLACKPINK: Kim Jennie, Kim Jisoo, Park Chaeyoung, Lalisa Manoban 2NE1: Lee Chaerin, Park Bom, Park Sandara, Gong Minzy Pink Punk: Kim Jennie, Kim Jisoo, Park Chaeyoung, Lalisa Manoban, Park Jinny, Kim Euna, Kim Eunbi, Cho Miyeon, Jang Hanna Future 2NE1: Im Suah, Lee Chaeyoung, Lee Seoyeon, Moon Suah, Park Seoyoung Pink Punk Trainees Now: Cho Miyeon: (G)-Idle. Park Jinny: Secret Number. Kim Eunbi: Soloist. Jang Hanna: Soloist. Future 2NE1 Trainees Now: Lee Seoyeon: fromis_9. Moon Suah: MYSTIC rookies
Destiny well it's true yg wasted them. These girls should have gone to school instead training in this shitty company and didn't even get the chance to debut
@@baepinkobsession These girls came to YG willingly knowing the consequences. No one held a gun to their head. No one forced them. YG isn't "wasting" them. Plus Michaeng's Daughter (the person who wrote this post) keeps editing her words. She initially said "destroying." That was what I was responding to.
sameee something is wrong with my RU-vid since this evening. I am getting frequent recommendations of videos uploaded 10/12/15....yrs ago!and some ore even from channels or video topics I've never watched
imagine this 4 named future 2ne1 but the 4 girls sitting anonymously on the right reflection of mirror debuted and now known as biggest girl group in the world.
@@appreciatedyousee5915 girl f2ne1 was supposed to be the debut group but instead jisoo rosé jennie and lisa were the picked f2ne1 and were debuted we have every right to talk about BP
came here to tell y'all that after 12 yrs of training, moon sua (girl in the black shirt) finally debuted in a girl group named "Billlie" just a few days ago under mystic story and they're all amazing 😭
I'm really surprised I was born in this year when they were only 12 years old and 13 years old damnn I wish I had born before they debuted so i can stan them
I like how YG said "4 years later" in this video's title, making everyone think it would be this girl group who'd debut, but he was really referring to BLACKPINK sitting at the corner in this video. 😂 what a TROLL, YG, pls.
9 years later 00:09 Im Youha 임유하, solo artist who released single ICE-T 08/24 00:10 Lee Seoyeon 이서연, member of Fromis_9 who released single Talk&Talk 09/01 (song was co-written by Youha!!) 00:12 Moon Sua 문수아, member of BILLLIE who released comeback song Snowy Night 11/10 00:14 Park Seoyoung 박서영 • Roya 로야, solo artist who was featured on single Betting by Velowci as released on 11/15
@@lunarsolar777 that is Byun Seoyoung born in 2007~ Park Seoyoung born in 1999 was recently on the reality TV show Love&Joy plus is going to be feat in new song by IndEgo Aid along w Deepflow and other artists
This was in 2012, the year my baby Roseanne start her trainee life in YG. The year she start her "fighting for her life" everyday, every minutes, every seconds. Finding her sitting on the side in this video made me so proud of her now 😭🤧
Why drag blackpink everywhere?? Can’t you just appreciate these 4 beautiful and talented girls who weren’t lucky enough to become big as they deserve??This ain’t a blackpink mv or whatever and it’s rude of you to comment about other artist under their contents. Also based on their performance blackpink was probably created by favourism. Imagine being on their place and Yg decided to let Jisoo (who still doesn’t even compare to half of their dance and vocal skills) debute instead of them💀
@@lilly.kaitlyn but they aren’t the star here…and ya’ll just be like ‘poor jisoo poor rose…they didn’t know they would be this successful this and that’ when there are these girls who weren’t even appreciated enough.
2NE1: yg said: they are ugly Blackpink : yg said: better and beautiful version of 2NE1 This group: yg said: future 2NE1 Just give these girls some respect and their own identity.😐
@@user-dl7jb6bc1l I don't want to compare them bcoz this both grps have their own uniqueness they both are iconic in their way so stop comparing both of them
@@user-dl7jb6bc1l Yes, 2NE1 is iconic. We can't deny that. But you can't also deny that BLACKPINK became successful in the era where the competition is tougher. Yes, competition in this current generation is tougher than before, and kudos to BLACKPINK for that.
Lmao yall talking about how only yg is wasting talent, ALL companies do that. That's the harsh reality of the trainee life, it's survival of the fittest. Despite years of effort not everyone's going to debut
@@hungryhippo8772 all of them. All kpop idols go through training before debuting, in fact SM is the one that created this training system, thats why theyre known as the foundation of kpop. And other companies followed
nct jaehyun's wife 2012 + 4 = 2016 which they were supposed to start the same year as Blackpink, and Blackpink was supposed to start before 2016 but their debut was postponed
For people who are confused: YG had plans to debut 2 girl groups - Future 2NE1 & Pink Punk (who YG media played as his version of SNSD). Pink Punk was supposed to debut back in 2012 with all the Who's That Girl/The Girls Are Coming teasers. Back in 2012, YG already revealed Jennie (through pictures and her rapping), Lisa (dance practice video) and Jisoo (through pictures). YG also revealed Kim Eunbi and Euna Kim (through videos of them rapping)... PinkPunk at the time had like 7 members, but because of the constant delays, members left (eg Cho Miyeon, Kim Eunbi & Euna Kim etc.)..... (Also as a side note, Jinny who was originally part of the Pink Punk line up was moved to the Future 2NE1 line up) 3-4 years laters, PinkPunk was left with 4 members... Jisoo, Jennie, Lisa and Rose (as a side note, although Rose wasn't revealed back in 2012, she was featured in GD's album as "?"). YG then officially named them BlackPink and that's how BlackPink was formed..... At the moment, there are no news of Future 2NE1 members, but I'm pretty sure Jinny Park, Moon Sua, and Jang Hanna are part of the line up. A few months ago, there was a rumour saying that YG will debut another girl group (Future 2NE1) straight after BlackPink, but after all the horrible reaction to those rumours, YG denied it... But after BlackPink's REALLY successful debut, who knows when YG will debut Future 2NE1. But considering how BlackPink's debut was delayed for 4 years, we'll probably see Future 2NE1 in 2020 😂 EDIT: also you can see the Pink Punk girls sitting on the left hand side of the room in this video. I can spot Jisoo, Rose, Lisa and Jennie on the far left xD and if you pause at 1:28, you can see there's about 7-8 girls sitting down
local psycho __ yeah...like you could’ve stuck with 2NE1 instead of disbanding them...imagine how the blackjacks feel...seeing their fav girls get replaced...
@@iaa5656 wdym? future 2ne1 (F21) were actually revealed wayyyy before 2ne1 disband thou :0 they're disbandment have nothing to do with these girl since way back in 2011 yg revealed that he has 2 new girl group that's probably supposed to debut around 2012-13. but yeah the name is disrespectful since it's like the 'upgrade' version of 2ne1 :")
Blythe Rinne you probably don’t get what I’m saying.....I’m saying they shouldn’t have done that and made a new group instead of saying the future 2NE1 :3 now don’t respond to this because there gonna be a ton of fighting once this keeps up
everyone is talking about BLACKPINK, but I feel awful for these girls. They gave up their childhoods to debut and then were tossed to the side like trash. edit: yes i am aware this is the reality of things, just trying to keep a little bit of attention on the girls who were future 2ne1. edit 2: ok i still get notifs from this comment. i am well aware that some debuted, and that’s amazing! i support them, and i love them. HOWEVER, my comment here was just me feeling sorry for what they endured only to end up in groups that will most likely never compare to what their popularity could’ve been.
