GAME SINS | Everything Wrong With The Wolf Among Us 

Everything wrong with The Wolf Among Us: there isn't a sequel

For 79, It actually makes sense. Hans is from the story Clever Hans, Which is an ironic title. His fable is all about him being a clueless idiot and messing up directions, So it'd make sense for him to misinterpert the situation and actually just be trying to help. To sum it up, He stabs himself in the arm, Suffocates a donkey, And ties his wife up in a stable all because he misunderstands directions repeatedly...So it isn't out of character.

Bigby doesn't like woman being insulted.

Maybe Bibgy's getting annoyed by people saying Bitch because they're using it incorrectly.

"Bigby keeps getting blamed for things he was never even aware of because the crime was never reported to him." This entire series would have been solved in episode one if Fables actually reported crimes to the police, lol.

Biggest sin: Beast and Beauty are voiced by Kenny and Clementine. You can even hear older clemtine in Beauty.

Another sin would be is Beauty and Beast are Kenny and Clementine (awkward)

The differing vulnerability is actually explained in the comics. It depends on the popularity of the individual fable in the human world. This is why Prince Lawrence or Georgie are easy to kill and Bigby or Snow White are almost invulnerable and can even recover from total mutilation. But because this is not explained in the game (at least I assume, haven't played it since it's release) the sins are still valid. Good video, as always.

Overall, the video's sins are correct, but there are a couple things wrong here This comment seems very long, but is actually a quick read. Please do; 00:40 Fables were created by humans. Both their stories, and their dimension. Humans know of the stories, but they didn't know that they created actual beings in another world. 00:52 Yes, but that's not really the sole concept of Fables. It's fairy tale beings living together in the modern human world. Shrek is just a fairy tale story that involves other fairy tale characters. 1:10 Bigby actually can't drive. 1:21 Just because no one has seen Toad doesn't mean it will never happen. It's still a risk regardless. I mean, it doesn't matter how many times you play Russian Roulette. Do it enough times, and you're gonna die eventually. 1:40 Mundies knowing stories and mundies knowing that the Fables actually exist and have their own government aren't the same thing. At all. 2:27 Bitch is a derogatory term used by humans to refer to women. Bigby's mother is literally a bitch, so using the nomenclature of his species as an insult would probably be offensive. I think it's a greater sin that Bigby wouldn't have thicker skin. 4:16 If a pig was walking around New York, someone would probably call some kind of animal control, and Colin would be captured. 5:05 Yes. And he's dulled his senses by smoking. Meaning that the trail, that's already gone cold mind you, wouldn't be very noticeable by his dumbed-down senses. 7:07 This one, I can't give you too much grief for because it isn't explained in the choice you made, but if you go to Lawrence first, he reveals that he cut both wrists, overdosed on sleeping pills, shot himself in the heart, then the head. That's much different than a simple axe. That's 3 more fatal wounds than Woody had. Not to mention, the Woodsman is one of the old manly men fables who have supernatural strength and vitality. His survival isn't based solely on his popularity. Edit; Also, you saying that the Woodsman "shook off" the axe strike is an extreme overstatement. The Woodsman, after getting hit, fell to the ground and laid motionless and presumably lost consciousness for some time. Until Bigby pulled the axe out from his skull, Woody wasn't even able to move. Even after it was taken out, he was still inert for a bit before he stumbled away. He didn't tank it. It fucked him up. And it takes him two full episodes to fully recover, shown after he had no bandage at the end of episode 3. 7:21 Yes, it does. The bullet in the wall is from the gunshot wound to his chest, which does in fact, have an exit wound. 8:15 Bluebeard is not the only violent fable, you are right. However, Bluebeard is one of the few that specifically decapitate women. 9:05 That's one detail and event in Bigby's long life. The likelihood that Bigby would be so self-absorbed that he'd know exactly what story made him popular is low. 10:10 Bigby is a Sheriff because he is cunning, observant, and powerful. Has nothing to do with his compassion or empathy. If you're going to have a person who has to enforce rules, you might want to get the biggest and scariest guy you know. 10:15 Blood already was on its way down her face, and she's sitting a foot away from a wolf. It's not hard to belief he'd smell it before it became visible. 13:27 Hans is a stereotypical big dumb guy. He didn't understand what Georgie was trying to do. 14:00 Frank Miler? Lmao 14:30 They lived in America for centuries. The accent probably faded with time. 15:16 Beast being human comes from the intimacy of his and Beauty's relationship. If they get into a lover's spat, Beast slowly transforms back into a beast. And Beast is MUCH more monstrous if the fight gets intense enough. 17:55 Flycatcher isn't going to have the balls to tell Bigby to piss off. He's a timid fellow. Not to mention (although poorly conveyed in the game), he and Bigby are friends. And Bigby doesn't need a warrant or anything. That's not how Fabletown works. If Flycatcher said "no", Bigby would just kick the door down. 20:26 Just because a shotgun blast wouldn't kill Bigby doesn't mean it wouldn't fuck his shit up. He feels pain the same way you and I do, he's just much more durable. 20:54 Bigby Wolf is a Werewolf. Just instead of being a human that can turn into a wolf, he's a wolf that can turn into a human. Bigby's ability to transform into a human is literally because he was cut with a knife that had the werewolf curse on it. Therefore, he's weak to fire and silver the same way any other werewolf is. 21:31 You can if you're a magical werewolf with a healing factor. As long as Bigby connects the damaged pieces to himself, he can heal the bits back together. Doesn't matter if it's bone, cartilage, entire limbs, or even organs. He can't regrow entire parts like Deadpool, but he can fuse the separate pieces together. He's a werewolf, dude. He can heal any wound not caused by fire or silver. 23:40 They literally just explained why they won't do that; they are materialistic people that need to feel as though they live like royalty. 24:09 The hell? Toad is CLEARLY not 5 foot. He looks more like two, and in the first episode, Bigby says he's 3 foot. I know this seems nitpicky, but I mean, 5 foot is an extremely unrealistic estimate of how tall he is. 26:48 Georgie isn't popular, nor is he some brutish or monstrous fable. Not to mention, he lived much longer than any human would after a stab wound like that. He survived massive bleeding for a good thirty minutes, and still didn't technically die on screen, meaning we have no idea how long it took him to kick the bucket. 27:09 Because turning into a gigantic wolf is usually too inconvenient to do indoors, or in public places. Also, it'd be a serious misapplication of power to turn into his true form if he isn't fighting someone that powerful. Bigby literally turned into a giant wolf because he had no choice. He didn't need to on anyone else. It would be like Goku turning Super Saiyan 3 to fight Krillen; it isn't necessary. 27:30 Crooked man has a chance to explain himself. If he just shot Bigby, it would be too indefensible, and they'd eventually send someone to apprehend him. 27:37 The Crooked man had his hand into every aspect of Fable life, and MOST Fables were affected by him. It'd be hard to find someone who was impartial. Not to mention, this way, the people who were wronged get to see the justice first hand. 28:51 The entire woodland is blocked off by a magic barrier. Humans are oblivious to it in a certain range. In the comics, Fabletown literally had a war on Bullfinch street, and the mundies hardly noticed. 29:59 Nerissa never claimed, nor was it stated anywhere they she left Lily's head at the steps. Only Faith's.

Best Telltale game so far

The Wolf Among Us is one of my favorite games and you ain't seeing me dislike. These videos are made for fun stop taking it so seriously.

6:30 You do know that the word Grim Tales comes from the name Grimm, because they were the one who gathered them and wrote them down. It doesn't have anything to do with the adjective grim.

I actually liked this game. There are a lot of Telltale games i skipped or didn't care about, but this one, Walking Dead Seasons 1-2, and the Borderlands one i really liked.

Maybe the reason why Georgie died so easily is because nobody real knows of his fable that much and since this series follows the Greek god rules of power (the more people believe in you the stronger you are) snow white, the little mermaid, and beauty and the beast should be freakin immortal because of disney.

The Beast with the horns sin is a bit of a stretch since you know Bigby has different phases of his transformation, like the Wolverine with yellow eyes one in the first fight to the giant wolf. So i guess that wasn't even Beast's final form.

I'll never understand who EVER thinks 'Glass him' means anything less than what it does, ESPECIALLY given the context of the scene. It's an old term, old as noir itself. Also, how is there not multiple sins off for Bloody Mary, I mean...DAMN.

Most of these sins are explained in the comics. The street Toad is on is hidden itself because only Fables live their. Also, Miss Totenkinder is responcible for many spells around the city which would make normal people forget about stuff like a Werwolf on the street and a Toad getting into a car. Beast allways transformes as much into his Beast-Form as his wife is angry about him, which makes sence regarding the nature of his curse. They all lived for hundreds of years in Amerika, ofcourse they picked up an accent. Also, non of them told their stories to the normal people, they just appeard in their heads. It's a riddle the Fables themselves don't know much about. Only Fables with a story would survive that long, which is why everyone in Fabletown has one. And Bigby is only half Wolf. He is mostly a shapeshifter, but he allways loved his mother more and thats why he lived as a Wolf. He later learned to transform into a human. Silver is used against all kinds of Shapeshifters, also Bigby might be responsible for the Werwolf-legend all by himself in the first place.

3:34 actually Faith was dead before Bigby even knew who she was. The Faith he met was Nerissa in a glamour. So yes, she actually did have a reason to talk about the ribbon. Nerissa was trying to make Bigby investigate the ribbon even though she couldn't talk about it.

also the sins about bigby's left hand wasent fair. it just works that way because he is a fable and they heal fast as fuck

You already mentioned why. Do enough people know the donkey skin girls tale well enough to make the Prince, Bigby or Woodsman levels of invincible? I never heard that story until I played this game.

Im saving this for tonight Fuck!!!

eh, people catch feelings easily. it's nothing to take seriously, game is still great

I ain't got no legs.

lol, I guess Telltale has a lot of fans who can't take a joke?

"Glass him" was a choice I will forever regret picking...

One sin that I've never heard talked about is that when they find Lily's head and think it's Snow's, Bigby falls for it when he should have taken one whiff and recognized that it wasn't Snow at all. Heck, within the first three chapters of a 150 chapter comic series it's explained that Bigby is incapable of blocking out Snow's scent despite him smoking to dull his senses. He can even pinpoint her exact location within a 20 mile radius based on scent alone! So why does the glamoured head thing work? And no, it's not her perfume. It's also stated that Bigby can tell it's her by her natural musk, no matter what kind of artificial scent she wears. So why does this work?

3:34, Faith knows the ribbon stops her from speaking, and highlights it to Bigby in the hope that maybe he will later figure this out. If you subscribe to the likely theory the Faith survives the whole game and sets the whole series of events in action to earn her freedom, this line makes a lot of sense

That Bigby VS Beast fight was so badass to me. Especially when they both started to transform 👏😙!

i hope in TWAU 2 they keep the same graphic style.. the thick line comic illustration fits this game satisfyingly

I think we need a sins video for Metro: Last Light, haha. I find it amusing that Dartigan always references that game when talking about "boob-rendering technology".

Why so many dislikes? You can't even watch half the video yet...

20:27 actually that scene still works, it was a funeral and Bigby getting shot would only make a bigger scene than what happened and he didn’t want to ruin the funeral.

30:12 This could also imply, that we never met Faith, but Nerissa glamoured as Faith to get bigbys attention to the case. Because she thaught bigby would not care that much about a dead prostitude, if he never met her.

13:33 actually if you read his bio, you find out Hans is actually quite simple minded and easy to confuse. He actually throws goats eyes at his wife as stated in the bio. So maybe it’s not too far fetched he thought Georgie was confused

This easily one my favourite TellTale games and one of their best games to date whether you think it's overrated or not. But that doesn't mean that the game has sins or that you should dislike the video, just try to enjoy it and not get salty lol.

I literally just screamed "HELL YEAH" when I got this notification!!

#18 - He put his hands on her so he owes her the money. That he decided to beat her instead of getting sex is his own fault. #24 - This always REALLY bugged me. Also, if he's managing to sneak off the farm and get to Biby's place without a problem, doesn't that also prove he doesn't need a glamour? #42 - Maybe not enough people know about his story? Also, what's up with the game not explaining that's where their immortality comes from? I didn't know that until I watched this video. #81 - I'm missing some important context for this one. #158 - The game ends up with the same problem the later Harry Potter movies have where they want their super cool set piece more than they want internal consistency with the rules of their universe. "We can't let muggles see us and we have to move you in secret so Voldemort doesn't know where you are...let's fly around London at street level!" #164 - Telltale refuses to understand how any job in existence works. #29, #30, #41, #48, #64, #71, #130, #161, #170, #178 thru #182 - Points so excellent I need to point out how excellent they are.

Wow, no sins removed? Kind of shocked by that. Ah well, another awesome video (despite a couple of issues syncing up audio)! Gotta be honest, did not see those options coming for the next video, & I feel pretty equal about them...oh, Dead Space 2, why not.

Me: Finishes the game and watches the second game's trailer Me: Laughing at everybody who said it was a bait

I don’t care about anything wrong with the game, no matter how many flaws you point out, I will always love this game, plus you can’t make a game perfect

5:04 Is that really why he smokes? That's kind of awesome. I wonder how he's got such good lungs though, to blow that much wind. 21:46 Also, hard shell, but soft in the middle.

This is my favourite game, despite its faults. Thanks for making the video!

7:07 not many people know about that fable so he can die easily

Did all the telltale fanboys instinctively hit dislike without watching the video? It's a lot better now but the video had 100 dislikes within 15 minutes of it being posted, it was pretty silly.

Holy shit that dislike bar, I know you're probably okay Dart but don't let this discourage you, your stuff is great.

9:11 I actually thought the same when I played this for the first time. I'm sorry for breaking a glass in your face, Woody 😂

Dead Space 2 please. Also, great video. I haven't said "That's good point" so many times in my life before today.

Why does everyone just call beauty "beauty" she has a real name and its belle.

The #59 to #60 is not really accurate because the tell tale version is VERY loosely based off the comics. There are characters in the tell tale version that aren't even on the comic. Only certain characters and aspects of them are brought over to the game.

Amogus

great video as always and I enjoyed watching stream can't wait until the next stream!

Doing a great job! You're my fave game sins channel; Ive watched all your vids like 100 times. ( your asm voice helps me sleep). Keep up the great work!

Season 2 is coming people 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

I can already see it: "Wolf Among Us 2: The Wrath of Mickey Mouse"

1:10 Nope. Fabletown doesn't have many resources to begin with, and Bigby is not exactly beloved by the other Fables to begin with. That's a plotpoint, not a sin.

Well now you HAVE to do Metro Last light.

Dartigan, Linkara would be so proud of you. Nice jab with Miller.

"The story of donkeyskin isn't that bad. She lives happily ever after." Oh so because she find a loving husband that erases the fact that her father tried to sexually assault her and she had to flee everything she ever knew because she realized the one parent she had alive wanted to have sex with her? And that's "not that bad?" Bruh.... wtf

If I remember correctly the part with immortality as long people remember them, was unclear in the comics. Jack (???) learned that when he went to Hollywood

When your in the room when the glamour maker is still a child, you can see the glamour container behind her back

to be fair at least where I am in the comic that thing about getting power from humans knowing there story is just a rumor

It's a shame that we'll never get a season 2 to this game. R.I.P Telltale

Glad I wasn't the only one surprised by the glass him moment. Though it is quite hilarious when you expect to touch glasses and instead smash a glass into his face.

Faith has a Narissa glamour because it's mentioned the girls glamour each other to cover shifts.

I'd imagine he hates the word b***h for the same reason anyone would hate the use of a racial slur.

Okay, I can see this guy didn't do enough research on the Fables comics. I know this is mostly humor and nitpicking, but I got a little ticked off at the "HBO Shrek" thing, so here we go: - Bigby doesn't drive car, becouse he doesn't know how to drive (he tells this to Snow White in comics) - What the hell is this guy even saying? Of course its a problem Toad doesn't look human. Yeah yeah, most of the mundies have wooden eyes for not noticing a talking frog and a wolfman, but thats just bad writing - Yeah, and what do you think would happen when humans find out about near immortal magical beings? - From what I understand, The Literals are responsible for existence of Fables and the spread of their stories in mundy world - Yeah, you have a point, I wondered that too later on why Bigby couldn't just find the bleeding person with his sense of smell - I don't know about Bigby caring about the b-word, but offending Snow WOULD make him mad sense he is in love with her - Its already implicated in almost the first pages of the first comic that Beast may start to turn if Belle's has negative feeling towards him, like them having a fight or seeing him being violent - That "important information in the middle of the book" is pretty repeating and funny/dumb - Its stated in the comics that silver DOES hurt Bigby. Why? I don't know, it just is like that. Perhaps its wolf thing. He even tell a person who shot him that they shoul've used silver. - I think Georgie died becouse he just isn't that well known. I mean I never even heard of Georgie Porgie before this game becouse the his fable is just a rhyme and every country has very different nursery rhymes with select few common ones, when fables like Snow and Bigby who are known through-out the whole world and are becouse of that so hard to kill

It's the other way around - their worlds and existence came into being from the Mundies' stories. It's an essential part of the plot. They even try to use it later in the story to fight Mr. Dark, or later when the world itself tries to force Snow and Rose to fight each other to recreate a old story.

2:33 um...no, you mean the right eye has a shiner.

What was the subreddit born by the safe key

when the impostor is sus ämong us reference

7:55 ah yes the off-screen cutscene sucker punch,every protagonist greatest weakness,even though technically this game is one giant cutscene beside the investigation

I think he gets offended by the word bitch because his mother died and that was kind of his only comfort as a child.

I’m depressed there’ll never be a 2

I'm surprised that nobody pointed out what Beast was doing at open arms.

10:35 Crane said that the spell will make the entire station FORGET the last 24 hours, not making them sleep for 24 hours. So they will still be able to help people when they wake up.

This ain't my kinda of game, but I watched your streams and it was entertaining as hell. I'm looking forward for more of those streams.

Pretty please Dead Space 2. Pretty please with sugar on top. :)

AMONG US

8:07 You can read information on BigB's desk about bluebeard. And BigB says "I don't trust him"

Nerissa mentions the ribbon several times before the end.

Woah, why is the like-dislike ratio equal ?

How the fuck did you get so many dislikes for this????????

9:10, My thoughts exactly! I was actually so surprised I instantly brought the game back to the previous checkpoint so that I could change my choice.

Additional sin around the 146-sins mark: Jersey is supposed to be the Jersey Devil, which was described as a winged beast with a horse's head, or, "a kangaroo-like or wyvern-like creature with the head of a goat, leathery bat-like wings, horns, small arms with clawed hands, cloven hooves and a forked tail. It has been reported to move quickly and often is described as emitting a 'blood-curdling scream.'" Yet the creature Jersey is actually depicted to be is not the Jersey Devil, but much more resembling the cannibalistic Wendigo of Algonquian Native folklore.

Alien isolation

"To glass" someone is a British term, the British use glass as a verb lol

Even though I really love this game it was really fun to see you tear it apart :)

This was a fun ride, thanks for this.

Mate, do Dead Space 2 next. Alien Isolation is really boring, trust me. People just want to see you being scared, but I know you don't get scared. Besides Dead Space is creepier and scarier.

the last really good Telltale game

Ah... I see you chose to tore that guy's hand and yell: "go fetch, lap dog" At him. Lmao that's cruel I had to replay through that lolol

Thank god a season 2 is in the making

WELP, NO SEQUEL FOR US ANYMORE

Amogus😕

"My lips are sealed"

about that thing at 6:32.. The word grim is actually "Grimm" wich was the surname of the brothers who collected and wrote down those storrys. So no relaton to the english word "grim".

13:47 what subreddit is he talking about?

I’m going to miss this game. Wish it had it’s sequel before the company ended. At least we have the comic book

Bricklebit! Also, Telltale Games doesn’t sell Wolf Among Us prints. One sin! I’d love to get prints of the title cards and openings. Those backgrounds are gorgeous.

i ,for one, hope that they will make a sequel out of this game. this is my favorite of the telltale games so far