Respect Party leader George Galloway and former political adviser to Tony Blair, John McTernan discuss the anti-semitism crisis engulfing the Labour Party.
Europeans have always had a Jewish problem throughout history and have tried various forms of isolation and extermination, including ghetto settlements, programs, and the Holocaust. Muslims have never had that! Jews lived freely for centuries in Palestine, Egypt, Baghdad, Cairo, Morocco and other places. the actual flourishing in Islamic Spain. Then in the late century ideas such as separation of religion, nationalism, socialism, communism and others emerged. Zionism was their latest version. the same religious fanatics who have persecuted Jews throughout history began supporting Zionism. They do not want the Jew to live among them. Zionism led by Theodore Hertzel held their first Zionism Congress in Basel, Switzerland in 1897 and later British Foreign Secretary Balfoure made his infamous declaration in 1917, both with the same goal of solving this "Jewish problem." thus began this colonial imperialism and now apartheid enterprise
Jews are also safe in Iran. There are thousands of Jews living in Iran. Iranian council rescued many Jews during WW2 and brought them from Europe to Iran.
But he is a ignorent!!! Zionism is an ancient Jewish ideology and a biblical commandment that says Jews should be in Zion. Zion is the holiest place for Jews in the world and Zion is synonymous with Jerusalem. The best parallel to Zionism is the desire of the Muslims to rule and make a pilgrimage to Mecca, that's exactly it! Jews go to the holiest place for Jews in the world, which is Zion. To say that the aspiration of Jews to go to Zion has nothing to do with Judaism is like saying that the aspiration of Muslims to go to Mecca has nothing to do with Islam. Zionism has existed for over 3000 years. People get confused between the ancient Zionist ideology and Herzl's political Zionist movement, which are two completely different things.
I already commentethat on another comment but I'll do it here too: I find that most people who are anti zionist are anti semites. There is no issue if you disagree with an Israeli government position or law. There are thousands or millions in Israel who diagree with the government. The big issue I see is those who argue against Israels actions or even existance but never question the same action when it is done by someone else. If people get killed in an Arab country by their government or even a terrorist group, the story will probbably wind up on page six of the newspaper (I know who reads the paper) and that is about it. If however, Israel winds up killing a Palestinian even in self defense, it becomes top headlines and people on places like Facebok will discuss this and accuse Israel of being a Nazi state. If enough people die, it will be brought up to the UN. When Jews are involved, the magntude of the story increases ten fold. I am not blaming the news media, but how people process the news based on Jews being involved is anti-semitism. You may not like Israel because it supposedly occupies Palestine. Do you have the same issue with Turkey because it occupies Cyprus. Do you protest Russia taking over Crimea and East Ukraine. Do you care that China occupies Tibet. Most people who have an issue with Israel wont care about the other places. Why because there are no Jews involved. Lets go back to my original idea. In Syria, they have killed no less than 500,000 people and have made refugees of at least 1 million people. Compare that to Israel killing 1200 Gazans after Hamas started shooting rockets into Israel. Of the two, which country keeps having resolutions brought on them by the UN. Of those two, which country is singled out as being in the top five most dangerous countries in the world. Of those two, whose existance is often questioned. Anti zionist have no issue with Syria existing especially after killing 500,000 of their own people, sometimes using chemical weapons. Anti Zionist do to have issues with israel building condos.
@@Red-hx4xr , Israel intentionally attacked the USA numerous times. In fact the USA government and Israel jointly conspired in murdering over 3000 American civilians in the 911 attacks which was to push for Israel agendas in the middle East marking the start of their so called war on terror.
@David Miles that's what the Soviets thought when they built the Berlin wall and spread communism Look what happened to them Roman's thought they owned the world Where are they now Even the British empire Now it's just an island The Zionist state will fall eventually If not this century or the next but it will fall It's just a matter of time There is no such thing as an eternal empire
he is one of the few politicians these days that will be on their deathbed with a good conscience and knows he has left a remarkable spot in this darkk world
@allaamrauf8214 a counter argument? To what? To zionists worked with the nazis? No.. it didnt happen, lenni brenners work doesn't even lie on the fringes of academia.. his work is hailed by neo nazis and the far left.. every single point that he brings up in his book has been disproven, so much so that he has had to go back and change some of his writtings.. his work is very disingenuous, cherry picking quotations from meetings held between zionists and the nazis and framing it as collaboration when infact the outcome of said meetings ended in zionists realisation that they couldn't cooperate with an ideology that subjects its minorities to abuse.
That's because no one will stand against them and they use their fake chosen people status to manipulate people who think the jews are white. This is the down fall of white supremacist white washing history
Have you guys heard about the Apollo NUMEC Affair in 1965? Israel smuggled nuclear energy (enriched uraniam) from US so they can develope their own nukes. But that's anti-systematic, no one should criticize. 😊
@Dario Spirit I suppose you feel comfortable in the nice cozy blanket of jesuitism that you have wrapped around you? Suppose that you feel impervious to the justice that is about to come down on the Tyranny by minority.? Reception perception perception... You perceive to to be on the side that's winning. I can assure you you are a loser and a lazy researcher with misguided bad feelings and a truly paralytic confirmation bias if not the Jesuit Blood Oath itself? Google and read it and then tell me what you're defending exactly? Furthermore these are the people that control Israel. Not the normal Jews around the world who are not unlike normal Christians that aren't Jesuit Evangelical or Catholic... Or worshiping snakes. You don't have a firm grasp or understanding of history and you don't seem to understand simple facts like that Netanyahu is a very high degree Jesuit Mason. Israel was created and is still thoroughly controlled by the Jesuits. Congratulations I hope you can look in the mirror and see what a fool you have been. There is a whole Buffet of Humble Pie waiting for you... ignorance is so so pathetic. Especially if it's willful. And not just woeful? Are you ignorant or are you mean? Or both.? Repent
Our gran was opposed to Zionism/Communism/Israeli State.She came from a jewish Orthodox background.MOST people have no idea of the true meaning of Israel.
@@eoghainoneill7195 communism is anti-zionist,they been supporting the Arab nation and Palistine,do some research history who supported Egypt to fight Israel in late 40s through late 60s,then trained Palistine on terrorism
Zionism: a movement for (originally) the re-establishment and (now) the development and protection of a Jewish nation in what is now Israel. It was established as a POLITICAL ORGANIZATION in 1897 under Theodor Herzl, and was later led by Chaim Weizmann.
Failed BLIAR-ites like McTernan can't face the FACT. That anti social ZION-tards are TERRORISTS who have TERROR-BOMBED and MASS MURDERED Brits and native Levantines including innocent kids since 1946! en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_David_Hotel_bombing
You're a nutter just like him. If that is the case, go back and fight your war and stop enjoying what the west is offering you. Hypocrites like you are crying memes where the real people a staying sure and true and toiling for the country that you and this idiot and the rest of the cowards like you have abundant. Shame on you.
1) Krishnan Guru-Murthy interrupts George Galloway continuously but not McTernan. 2) Galloway's points are historically accurate and/or a matter of public record yet are still constantly questioned. 3) McTernan's points are purely supposition, fabrication or slander yet are given a free pass. Bravo Channel 4 News. Bravo.
@@81620 HE IS RIGTH. it is sad to say but the CHARDIM ARE RIGTH. i was shocked when I found who sells the CROP FAMILY STEEL. shocked to find magen david and nazi cross on the same coin and was shocked while I saw real estate records that clearly shows that most of the land of Israel was in private arab jews regardless to the state of Israel. all what they learn me at school was mislead.
@@81620 look up the genealogies of Hitler, Goering, Goebbels, Eichmann, Leni Riefenstahl etc. Come on...Rosenberg! They ALL have one thing in common...
This man should be remembered as a One-Man Army that stands/stood for human rights worldwide and speaks/spoke out against world oppressors straight to their face........Respect from Tanzania
He praised Assad calling him a "breath of fresh air". This is the same Assad that killed hundreds of thousands of Syrians and expelled all other Syrians. You sound ridiculous right now speaking in support of such a knobhead with no knowledge of history
@Popeye IF WAS NOT FOR MUSLIM NO JEW WAS LIVE IN MIDDLE EAST OR EUROPE, BY REASON OF old animosity jesus crucifixion, FOR THE SAME REASON , JEWS MUSLIM CHRISTIAN LIVE IN IRAN FOR 3 THOUSAND YEARS IN PEACE, ALSO JEWS OF IRAN SAID IF ISRAELI FIGHT THE IRAN THEY WILL BE IN FIRST OF THE LINE, ALSO WHEN MUSLIM LOST THE POWER, WORLD SAW WHAT HAPPENED TO THE JEWS , CALLED HOLOCAUST , ANDLATER BY EXCUSE GET RAID OF JEWS IN PALESTINE, OF COURSE FIRST WAS UGANDA IN AFRICA , BUT CHANGE THEIR MIND, LAER,TO PALESTINE,
Here in Russia, many Jews criticize Israel, including my relatives, and they cannot be called anti-Semites. Accordingly, to criticize Israel of course does not mean to be an anti-Semite, when the criticism comes from the best of intentions.. I will also talk about this topic on my channel. Should be interesting.
a Jew knows about German executioners, but ask a Jew about Jewish executioners if he knows any names of these people who killed millions of ethnic Eastern Europeans.
Russian jews are the first againts zionism. Probably because your unique position as eurasian. You see and trade in middle east the earliest before any european do. And you russian never tried to colonized us asian.
@@mersedmuratovic3819 Yes that's correct. The term "anti-Semite" has been coined to make it seem an eternal truth that to be anti-Jewish is a sin. It is manipulative - the product of wordsmiths. There is no reason they can't say "anti-Jewish" other than that they wish to elevate their position to an eternal truth. Very transparent, and easy to defeat in a debate.
@@kkm227 his real name is jacob or is it just an example? i got the example for sure XD but i was wondering if it has any meaning currently or in context
I wouldn't go that far but on this topic he's spot on. As for Ken Livingston if I recall he was a target of Combat 18, Britain's neo Nazi boot boys of the day, for his anti racist campaigning. To smear him as a racist is outrageous just as it was with Jeremy Corbyn.
@kbooax He had a charity that donated money to palestine that got to Hamas. Also he met with the leader of the Hsmas and has said on camera that he's friends with leaders of other brands of the muslim brotherhood. Whatever lies you believe about Israel, you need to oppose this man.
@@theendlesslights en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haavara_Agreement Well but he is factually correct. However its a bit disenginious to not offer detailed contexted as this agreement can be interpreted in a way - and is - that is completely deluded. The clear antisemitism here is a clear sign how history without understanding its details isnt wise to judge about.
Anybody who claims another should not be allowed to debate is attempting to censor an opposing idea. No one should ever be forbidden a platform of debate.
"Zionism and Nazism are two sides of the same coin, infact they minted a coin." "But won't be people take offence to that?" Yeah, idiots will. It's historical fact though, it's true.
@@thealligator918 Ashkenazi are the occupants of Israel. They're not real Jews, they have more white DNA than they do Arab. The Eagle (Enlil) is the cause of this, it destroys all of what's need to be known.
+TheDensley7 This is a video that Apollo liked "Yes, J-e-w-s are (ultimately) Responsible (for EVERYTHING)" Apollo hates Israel because he hates Jews like many other "Anti Zionists" here.
It's crazy to think that you can state facts and still be questioned like your a suspect. And even Netanyahu admitted he doesn't want a 2 state solution.
I'm writing this in 2024 7 years after this was uploaded and everything George said about the people running Isreal is spot on. Time has proven it. A lot of people owe Mr. Galloway a serious apology.
George is a voice of reason to be taken very seriously. He may not appeal to everyone....nobody does, but much of his thinking is extremely sound. His command of speech is superlative and he can debate with the best of them. I don't possess anything like his knowledge of middle eastern issues but know and trust him well enough to appreciate that what he says and his take on current affairs is solid. However, as with all things political, I don't just listen to the arguments from one source or one flavour. I seek out the views of many commentators in order to educate myself. Further to that, I look for the nuances in their language and in that of their interviewers to determine where their prejudices and bias lies. That often tells you more. George Galloway is a master in that field and very few, if any, can flummox him.
George Galloway literally just took a dump on John McTernan's head. 2:30 "This is a synthetic argument, it's a smoke screen", could not agree more with the man. Ken Livingstone an anti-semitic? Such a stupid stupid unnecessary turn of events.
During a ME history degree in the mid 90's, one of the modules I studied was called "The Palestine Mandate", covering British rule in Palestine post WW1. It is on public record that the Nazi Regime and Jewish leaders in Palestine co-operated to have German Jews emigrate to Palestine /Israel. Its on record... Its not an allegation, its fact.
It’s also a fact that blood thirsty Anglo kingdoms like England colonised the world through rape theft and murder. Hilarious that the ancestors of such a legacy would think they have the right to criticise israel and the Jews.
So they didn’t cooperate to have Jews killed, did they? In fact, the extent of the cooperation was the Zionists asking the Nazis to send their Jews to the Palestinian Mandate. At least you’re being somewhat more specific about the subject. Most anti-Jewish types will read “Nazis and Zionists collaborated” and immediately assume it means the Zionists supported the Holocaust or other atrocities.
You’re twisting the facts. A very tiny fringe group (not Jewish leaders), called Lehi presented a proposal to the Nazis that Jews would give up their homes, wealth, investments in return to let them leave Europe and make a home in Mandatory Palestine. This deal never came to fruition as it was rejected by the Nazis. The Lehi made a desperate attempt to save Jewish lives.
I just hope it's not too late because it was a Zionist named Barbara Roach who assisted Tony Blair in opening Britain's borders to the whole danged world and now the Brits are also being ethnically cleansed in their own home via mass immigration like the Palestinians via Zionism.
Notice how the semite directs the arguments to THE DESTRUCTION OF ISRAEL so that you cannot discuss any other critical issue. He jumps straight to the "Destruction of Israel" meme when challenged about touch subjects.
@@jordanthomas4379 : If anything, the recent events of the past 2 or more months have shown that it's no stretch to seriously consider that Zionism cooperated with Nazism. Such cooperation is being played out clear as day in the current battlefield of Eastern Europe, which has been laid to bare very clearly for all who wish to see this dynamic.
The host is so annoying and downright rude to interrupt George Galloway. Obviously told by his master to let the other guest speak and interject George Galloway.
john McTernan sounds like he is a bit player sent in to shut George up , but all he did was reinforce the point that he couldn't win an argument with himself .
