This may also be one of the Last Major projects as YT is killing channels with high creativity and quality content, not a joke. These conditions, we're getting pushed into, make it very challenging to operate full-time for a stable living, and invest time and funds into these next-level big videos, you see nowhere else. Best,
Yes, youtube does not show the necessary attention to the channels that work, Shorts and Tiktok have officially finished Quality content. On the one hand, we have difficulty in producing content while dealing with our own life, and when we find time and prepare content, we do not get fair paid for our efforts.
I do have the feeling they might start seeking attention to videos that don't necessarily violat anything it's just they don't understand what they are mostly thinking
Thank you for all your dedication and hard work over the years, your videos have always been the best of the best. Would be a major bummer to see you stop making content like this. Hope you have a great holiday season.
Не скажу, что мне не понравилось Но в ролике мало достоверности. Так, во первых, большинство Фердинандов было потеряно уже на первой линии обороны русских, так как плотность минирования была очень высокой, а Фердинанды часто сбивались с проходов между минными полями и подрывались. Во вторых, да, советские танкисты на Т-34-76 отправлялись массово против Тигров и Пантер. Но данные эпизоды были всего два раза, на разных участках Курского выступа, и произошли они почти в самом начале немецкого наступления. Так как советское командование ничего не могло противопоставить броне новых немецких танков, а положение было тяжёлое. В третьих, на Курской дуге явно обозначалось превосходство советской авиации, что также поддерживалось советскими ПВО Здесь же мы видим, как тяжёлые немецкие истребители почти до конца ролика безнаказанно сбрасывают бомбы на советские позиции. И последнее. На Курской дуге была применена новая тактика расстановки противотанковых орудий. Вместо стандартного построения в линию была изобретена тактика противотанковых районов. Орудия ставились на небольших подготовленных позициях по 4-6 штук, каждое из которых смотрело в разную сторону фронта. Получался некий полукруглый клин. С такой позиции расчеты пошли вести обстрел прямой наводкой на 180-240 градусов сразу. Ах да, и ещё одно. Советское командование знало о предстоящей атаке нацистов, поэтому предприняло превентивные артобстрелы предполагаемых мест средоточения техники противника, которые начались за несколько часов до начала операции Цитадель. Это позволило уничтожить большое количество техники и живой силы противника, а также ввести его в состояние шока
The Germans essentially won this battle, but due to the fact that Russia had no problem taking the losses that it took during the multiple days of fighting. It didn’t really matter.
мой дед бился в этой битве .подбил 3 танка 2 пазика 3 и 1 пантеру которая потеряла ход подорващий на мине . награжден за эту битву орденом красной звезды и медалью за отвагу .автор ролика не показал рассвет имено на рассвете советская артилерия и авиация нанесла упреждающий удар по района сосредотачения противника . не показал что многии пантеры и тигры подрывались на минах . а чтоб взять ПтОпы .пришлось поднимать авиацию . из 65 укрепрайнов в первой полосе снесли 56. во 2 полосе из 125 снесли 70 . до 3 не дошли . мой дед находился во 2 полосе ему повезло так как перед его позициями был овраг . те кто был в первой полосе почти все погибли . за 3 дня боев из 137 человек в его роте осталось в строю 16 человек . 56 раненых . дед за время боев сменил 3 орудия одно раздили у 2 кончились снаряды . как он говорил это был суший ад . на той земле еще долго не расло ни чего из за разлитого топлива оставшийся мин снарядо и железа . сейчас там памятник и растет пщеница и подсолнухи .Вечная память павщим .
Russians hid a lot that they won this war. in fact, the Kremlin caught up with 1500 t-34s against 600 German leopards and tigers, no one won this battle, the battle took place only 50 km along the front line. Almost all Russian tanks were destroyed, the Germans lost 400 tanks, 1300 Russian tanks were destroyed, as a result, the Germans withdrew, they realized that there was no point in going further, and the Russians were demoralized.
@@danikworld26 хорошо, давайте так,флаг СССР поднят над Рейхстагом.. цель достигнута пусть даже большими потерями. А подсчёт был разный безвозвратный и произведён ремонт. СССР было проще собрать танк, чем его ремонтировать
Це тобі німці таке розказали? В жодних мемуарах такого нема, тільки командуючий 48-м корпусом Кемпф згадав що совєти лупанули з арти "в молоко" - 2 години довбали поля.
Dude your videos are always awesome! For me your art deserves to be created into a movie! It's a shame that RU-vid are suppressing quality content like yours
Смотрю ваши ролики постоянно уже 3 года, не перестаю удивляться роликам такого моштаба это же сколько сил нужно потратить в такой качественный контент) Привет из России 🇷🇺 🙂
если вам этот ролик зашёл, то советую так же заценить видео "Освобождение: Огненная дуга ". Не смотря на то, что намного старее, но там не хуже по масштабом и деталям, при этом разрешение намного лучше! вот прям намного намного.
You certainly pick nice shots, it showed the Carnage and desperation on both sides well. Also the Prokhorovka clash where the first lines of tanks drove diagonally through eachother, according to the stories
The Germans actually won that clash. They destroyed the Russian strategic reserve, the Steppe Front. They withdrew because Hitler ordered the Panzer Corp in that area to transferred to Italy to meet the Allied landing on Sciliy.
Here a answer. It because of hitler order “no retreat” you should blame him. Most of the German high commands want to withdraw entire Wehrmacht out of Russia and use Ukraine and Poland as massive defense line against counter attack Soviet army but hitler ruined it.
Yes, it was a real hell. The most epic yet Soviet feature film "Liberation. The arc of Fire." Most likely, it is also available with English subtitles. I am convinced that the authors of the game have watched it and, apparently, more than once. There will be no more such epic films using full-scale technology - now everything is drawn by a computer.
немцам капут. СССР (Россия) войны не начинает, а заканчивает. Россия - великая страна - поставившая себя вопреки однополярному миру американцев. И сейчас Россия борется за мир и равное сосуществование разных стран
Смотрел как о видео о семье, которая держит приют для животных, и вот там женщина сказала - "Это видимо традиция такая, раз в сто лет на Россию нападать и каждый раз получать по роже." Ничему их история не учит... А за ролик спасибо, было интересно. Не совсем информативно, но всё же.
If the Soviets were Yanks the Battle of Kursk would have been lost by the Allies. There's no way the crappy Americans could have handled a huge scale German offensive like Kursk.
I'm amazed...I think all the time for me making maps together isn't even a quarter of the time and patience it took for you to make this map,keep it up! you are one of the only youtubers and creators to keep these strategy games alive longer!,It's thanks to you if today I'm playing the men of war series, a call to arms and so on!! long life to you and be proud of your creations!!! ❤❤❤🇫🇷🇫🇷(from french GOH and men of war community)🇫🇷🇫🇷❤❤
This is one of the best CTA GOH: Ostfront Editor battles I've ever watched. Its so Damn Accurate to the real thing. The shear amount of machinery and men on the field would have been Epic, but terrifying to see.
It were a few regiments in the Red Army equiped with the British Mk IV "Churchill" heavy tanks taken under the Lend-Lease programme that took part in the Battle of Kursk.
I can't say that I didn't like it. But there is little credibility in the video. So, firstly, most of the Ferdinands were already lost on the first line of Russian defense, since the mining density was very high, and the Ferdinands often strayed from the passages between the minefields and were blown up. Secondly, yes, Soviet tankers on the T-34-76 went en masse against Tigers and Panthers. But these episodes occurred only twice, in different sections of the Kursk salient, and they occurred almost at the very beginning of the German offensive. Since the Soviet command could not oppose anything to the armor of the new German tanks, and the situation was difficult. Thirdly, the superiority of Soviet aviation was clearly indicated on the Kursk Bulge, which was also supported by Soviet air defenses Here we also see how heavy German fighters almost to the end of the video drop bombs on Soviet positions with impunity. And the last thing. A new tactic for the placement of anti-tank guns was applied on the Kursk Bulge. Instead of the standard line formation, the tactics of anti-tank areas were invented. The guns were placed in small prepared positions of 4-6 pieces, each of which faced a different side of the front. It turned out to be a kind of semicircular wedge. From this position, the calculations went to direct fire at 180-240 degrees at once. Oh, and one more thing. The Soviet command was aware of the upcoming Nazi attack, therefore, it undertook preventive shelling of the alleged concentration sites of enemy equipment, which began a few hours before the start of Operation Citadel. This made it possible to destroy a large number of equipment and manpower of the enemy, as well as put him into a state of shock
It's a pity, that this battle is not represented enough in games. And I always wondered, why it is less interesting for western audiences, than battle of Stalingrad. They both are very important for the tide of war and very massive, but Kursk is almost forgotten. Waves of the newest german havy tanks against well-prepared and deep soviet defense with a lot of reserves - isn't it epic?
The limitations of the graphic is understandable, but it is amazingly true to the event actually. It really was that level of brutish carnage. And it cost the Germans a lot more than just one battle. This was on par with the Battle of the Bulge for squandering resources they couldn't afford to lose.
Арденны ни в какое сравнение не идут. Все битвы на Западе - жалкая тень того, что было по масштабам на Востоке. Кроме, разве что, высадки в Нормандии, и нескольких битв в Северной Африке
@@AleksandrSimonov-w2l Я имел в виду, что во время обоих сражений Гитлер тратил впустую ресурсы, которые он не мог позволить себе тратить в тот момент войны. В 43 году Курская битва наверное сократила войну. Вероятно, то же самое произошло и с ним в битве за Арденну.
Saya suka sejarah, terutama sejarah saat perang dunia ke 2 terjadi. Pertempuran Kursk adalah pertempuran tank paling epic dan terbaik menurut saya. Maaf, saya dari Indonesia. Jadi saya menggunakan bahasa Indonesia. Tetapi saya menyukai jiwa patriotisme bangsa Rusia. Mereka tidak ingin wilayahnya dikuasai Jerman, tentu itu sama seperti negara kami. Meskipun saya keturunan Chinese, tapi saya sangat mencintai Indonesia. Kami orang Indonesia juga sama, tidak ingin negeri kami kembali di jajah. Kalian orang Rusia punya jiwa petarung yang tangguh, pertempuran sudah menjadi pengalaman bagi kalian. Dalam pertempuran Kursk, kalian mengorbankan banyak sekali unit tempur seperti tank. Selain itu, korban jiwa dari pejuang kalian sangat banyak. Perang lainnya yang saya tahu adalah Battle of Stalingrad, Kiev, dan Leningrad. Kalian mampu mendesak Jerman hingga kembali ke negara asalnya, itu sangat mengesankan. Sangat jarang ada pertempuran yang dapat mencapai titik balik seperti itu. Saya hanya ingin memberitahu kalian, jarak antara Rusia menuju Berlin itu bukanlah jarak yang dekat. Kalian harus melalui Polandia, dan tentu di Polandia, Jerman sudah membangun pertahanan yang kuat. Namun pasukkan merah Uni Soviet mampu menembusnya dan terus masuk sampai wilayah Jerman. Itu sangat mengesankan. Ditambah lagi, dengan memukul pasukkan Rumania, itu sangat bagus. Mengingat Rumania memang agak lemah pada saat itu. Saya juga kagum dan salut dengan Jerman yang mau bertahan sampai akhir. Meskipun pada akhirnya terpaksa menyerah, tetapi bertahan sampai akhir itu luar biasa. Bahkan bukan perkara mudah bagi Jerman yang awalnya tangguh dan kuat diawal serangan, namun justru gagal di akhir. Jerman telah menunjukkan pada dunia, betapa tangguhnya mesin perang mereka. Rusia dan Amerika tentu belajar banyak dari perang tersebut. Tetapi peperangan itu menghasilkan teknologi baru dan mengubah teknologi tempur masa depan. Sekarang, dunia sudah berbeda, dan pertempuran dizaman modern ini lebih mematikan dari zaman dulu. Tetapi kita harus belajar dari sejarah, tiap peperangan pasti akan ada banyak hal yang harus dikorbankan. Orang yang dicintai, ekonomi, makanan, sumber daya, tempat tinggal, hingga sahabat. Saya berharap tidak ada lagi perang berikutnya. Damai jauh lebih indah, dan jika memang harus berperang, sekarang adalah saatnya perang melawan kemiskinan dan kelaparan. Perang melawan perubahan iklim, dan perang melawan kesombongan dan keegoisan diri.
Very well done!! The only thing missing is that Soviet intelligence knew the time the attack was planned to start and unleashed a massive artillery barrage just as the Nazis were grouping to attack.
It make me cry what a useless bleeding war so much death on both sides 😥 ours children should learn about this past and hoped for a peaceful future live together with your buddy's don't matter where it coming from 🤝❤
This is great. Well done! The camera work is well thought out and chosen, and your editing ability on each scene is commendable! Soldiers blown to pieces. Tanks in single combat. A battle between large tank armies. I thought your composition was great in that you did not show the battle scenes randomly, but gave the viewer a sense of dramatic development. By the way, I do not speak English. So I am sorry if I did not convey what I thought correctly (;^_^A
Вообще не разу ни Курская дуга. Где минные поля? Где обстрел немецких солдат из артиллерии перед самым наступлением? И обороны не так выглядела в этом сражении. Начали использовать опорные пункты, где скапливалась противотанковая артиллерия и растреливала танки с боку In general, never the Kursk Bulge. Where are the minefields? Where is the shelling of German soldiers from artillery just before the offensive? And the defense did not look like this in this battle. They began to use strongholds, where anti-tank artillery accumulated and shot tanks from the side. it's just the execution of Soviet troops by German
You want an interesting fact about this battle? The Soviets have turned the entire Kursk Salient into one massive fortress, with the total length of Trenches alone being 4200 kilometers. That is longer distance between Moscow and Lisbon, and they did it in close to three months.
Well done. You captured Operation Zitadelle (Citadel) perfectly. The "Death ride of the Panzers". The destruction of Germany's panzer reserves meant that the Russians, from 1943 onward, now controlled the offensive operations to the end. The Blitzkrieg (lightning war) was defeated by a defense in depth, with hundreds of antitank guns, dug in artillery and supported by tanks. Despite the Fourth Panzer Army's best efforts, with the 48th Panzer Korps, 3rd Panzer Corps and the SS panzer divisions they could not break through. You captured the Russian T-34's closing the gap and engaging the Tigers at point blank range and nullified the long range gunnery of German guns. I hope this is not your last great project but it is certainly your best!!
I love these types of videos, if a series like this kinda stuff was on Netflix, it would be popular to a decent audience I think. Maybe need a bit of character a story line but it would work.
I have loved your videos since years ago they are great the storytelling and battle are very cinematic like a movie I hope you can keep up the good work bro
The Germans' mistake was delaying the attack until July. They should've attacked in May when they originally intended. Delaying just gave the Russians times to fortify the hell out of the place. Also, they also made a mistake by rushing the Panther tanks into battle, because they still plagued by mechanical problems, causing many to break down in the middle of battle. And the Elefant tank wasn't used the right way as it was meant to be used defensively, not on the offensive.
july or not, the Germans still won't turn the tide. Even if they break into open country past Kursk and back to Stalingrad, they will still run out of steam and there shall be another encirclement of German armies somewhere.
@@mcbrians.8508 I agree that the Germans couldn't really WIN the war at this point, but a stalemate, and a negotiated peace I think was still possible. That being said, the Germans would've had to do a lot of things right to make it happen. Here's a possible scenario: the Germans win at Kursk, then go on the defensive in the east to bleed the Russians dry. Meanwhile, the Axis manage to prevent the Allies from getting a toehold in Sicily, or at least Italy itself. Then, if the Germans could defeat the Allied invasion of Normandy, MAYBE they could force the Allies to the negotiating table. But like I said, it would take quite a bit to make that happen. And then there's the issue of getting Hitler himself to go along with it.
@@sgauden02 the thing about German festung doctrine was that it was useless on a wide Russian countryside, the Russians will still surround them with hordes of armies. from what I’ve read, the Red Army have 107 divisions facing the Germans alone and every hour there’s a T-34 tank rolling out of a war factory. These murdering tuetonic knights stood no chance. they might kill a lot but they will still die. A negotiation on the part of the Allies is viewed as a cowardice by many.
@@mcbrians.8508 True. Attacking Russia in the first place was a bad idea, especially since Germany was still fighting Britain. Then Hitler was stupid enough to declare war on America, which destroyed any chance of success.
People need to find differences between this 2 picture Battle of Prohorovka Aftermath of me remembering teacher about history test IT IS THE SAME PICTURE 6:53 siuuuu the music dropped again
Grazie millle! I sincerely Hope u can make a video related about Soviet invasion of Manchuria in 1945. I know It Is a Matter of time, but i really cannot wait for It . Please ,please , please !!!
Thank you, sir! You are right, just a matter of time. I can't give any promise when exactly it's going to happen but I believe we can make it happen within the following 5 months. Could happen literally in 3 weeks, but also could be in 3 months, I don't know that yet. Once again Thanks for your support.
Тебе нужно учить историю а не слушать своих рассказчиков которые только могут нож в спину воткнуть! Но наши прадеды все делали по совести и красиво вас нагнули не фига было мирных безоружных людей в Маньчжурии трогать припрётесь еще пизды получите!!! С уважением Россия!
the problem of this game is that is nothing on edge of map, at horizont, it's just empty space which kills the immersion of the map. I don't understand why the developers didn't take care to put mapped horizon - clouds, hills, anything else, not just an empty space which looks silly. Great video overall!
Felicitaciones, felicitaciones !!!! Los que diseñaron esta recreación de la batalla de Kursk son unos genios, sinceramente, recrear ese infierno habrá llevado mucho análisis y trabajo, muchas gracias por enseñarnoslo, Saludos desde Lima PERÚ.
What game is this? Is it animation? It's such an amazing job. seriously impressive either way. I wish there was more I could do than like or subscribe.
Thank you. This was done in a game Gates of Hell Ostfront. If you wish to contribute more, you can check out the benefits of the channel membership program (bit.ly/2Ztf7c9)
Nah, the first is that germany lost this battle, and the second this is just a animation, and it was strong from 1939-1942 and than the rest of the war it was weak.
And somehow the war ended in Berlin. There is no denial that the Wehrmacht was the strongest and most experienced force at the beginning of the war. But after Stalingrad and Kursk the Wehrmacht 's neck was brocken by the red army. Look up operation Bagration and what it did to army group center and how much territory was lost by the Germans.
russians hid a lot that they won this war. in fact, the Kremlin caught up with 1500 t-34s against 600 German leopards and tigers, no one won this battle, the battle took place only 50 km along the front line. Almost all Russian tanks were destroyed, the Germans lost 400 tanks, 1300 Russian tanks were destroyed, as a result, the Germans withdrew, they realized that there was no point in going further, and the Russians were demoralized.
Can you research what both sides had where if Hitler hadn’t postponed the attack all those weeks for Panthers etc. Zhukov caught shit for interview with BBC that time gave us victory. Had Manstein launched as planned we would have lost. Did we complete even one circle of fortifications? Minefields, numbers and type?
Miles de minas. Hasta 4 lineas defensivas. Batallones de Infanteria. Con fusiles anti.carro. cañones y nidos de Ametralladoras. Morteros. Cada varios km. O incluso menos distancia. Cuando. Estaban en peligro recibian varios Regimientos de Infanteria y varias Brigadas acorazadas.
Yes Germans are far more superior than red army troops in 1941 but as the war progress the Russians developed more strong tanks than Germans and Germans developed more strong tanks than Russian during 1945 Russians have the largest army and the and the strongest tanks in the world
