Тёмный

Germany vs. UK: How Brexit Changed Everything 

EconomyTalk
Подписаться 26 тыс.
Просмотров 15 тыс.
50% 1

The UK's withdrawal from the European Union was supposed to open a new chapter of economic success for Britain, but did it? Germany, Europe's largest economy, played a critical role in warning the UK about Brexit’s consequences, even telling Britain to "stop playing games" during negotiations. In this video, we dive deep into how Germany and the rest of Europe dealt with Brexit and what it has meant for the UK's economy, workforce, and global standing. From the controversial Northern Ireland Protocol to the breakdown of EU-UK trade relations, we explore what really happened behind closed doors and whether Brexit was worth the price Britain paid.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this video is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered professional financial, investment, or legal advice. We shall not be held responsible for any errors or omissions in the content. Any action the viewer takes based on the information provided in this video is solely at their own risk.

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 313   
@Peter_Cetera
@Peter_Cetera День назад
Britain had overplayed its hand. No other country received so many concessions. No other country claimed as many special privileges. I find Brexit extremely regrettable, but in the end, I was also fed up with the constant new demands from London
@robertbaltha3371
@robertbaltha3371 День назад
Right, you wanted to profit from the EU without any of the cost, but that's just not how it works. Why would the EU swallow that bs?
@nikolaslarson6891
@nikolaslarson6891 3 дня назад
I'm sorry, the Brits are out and remain out! One troublemaker less. There is simply no confidence left and it will take about two generations to regain some of that confidence, if ever...
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
good. Never was a fan of unelected bureaucrats
@user-wc9eh6se5p
@user-wc9eh6se5p День назад
Each of our family's members is entitled to make a referendum in case UK want to rejoin and it is almost impossible that all members will agree. Just one veto...
@nettcologne9186
@nettcologne9186 3 дня назад
Who lost? Well, the people of Britain.
@evie1915
@evie1915 3 дня назад
We expected to lose
@paullarne
@paullarne 3 дня назад
And the EU. This is a Lose-Lose Brexit because the EU didn't want us to get any benefit from leaving in case others did likewise. It is the EU that needs to stop playing games.
@Toddel1234567
@Toddel1234567 3 дня назад
@@paullarne May I ask what games you mean?!. GB is no longer part of the EU and is therefore excluded. GB is a third country. It's exactly what the Brexteers wanted. They got what they wanted. Just because you are British, the rules should suddenly no longer apply to GB. The British want to have an extra sausage once again.
@paullarne
@paullarne 3 дня назад
@@Toddel1234567 Well I live in NI and I'm well aware that the EU attempted to over-implement the NIP in order to control the UK via NI and when the UK insisted that ti should be implemented as agreed and no more there were veiled threats to restart the Troubles and a threat which they exercised to exclude the UK from Horizion in breach of the TCA. There is no such thing as a straight deal with the EU and the World can see it clearly.
@Esemptius
@Esemptius 3 дня назад
@@paullarne Hilarious stuff pathetic little Englishman 🤣
@etiennedubois4050
@etiennedubois4050 3 дня назад
Still not able or (more probable) not willing to face reality. Visiting Paris, Berlin or even Rome is not the answer to little england's problems. Still playing games like the good old days of the lost empire, divide & rule, is not the answer. It's really hard for little englanders to understand that Brussels is the place to be. Whether con or labour, little england's politicians keep mistaking Berlin (or Paris or Rome) for Brussels.
@barnbersonol
@barnbersonol 3 дня назад
Why are europhiles so obsessed with the Brit Emp? Nobody else even mentions it.
@johndevoy5792
@johndevoy5792 2 дня назад
or indeed, Dublin!!
@paullarne
@paullarne 2 дня назад
Brussels was chosed to be a neutral city in between the power bases of Paris and what was then Bonn, now Berlin. France and germany make all the decisions in the EU and the rest are expected to follow and if they don't they get treated like Hungary. hre was only ever so long the UK was going to go along with that.
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet 2 дня назад
Minor correction: it's still little brexitannia, but sooner or later it will be little england, of course. Greetings from Bavaria 🇪🇺
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet 2 дня назад
​@@paullarneChosen, gammonato, *chosen* - not 'chosed'. Greetings from civilization 🇪🇺
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 дня назад
0:47 no, at the time of the UK exit the EU consisted of 28 members. After brexit there are 27.
@paologat
@paologat 3 дня назад
The EU is not a “coalition”. Coalitions are by their own nature temporary, whereas the EU aims at the permanent political unification of Europe through peaceful means. Of course, UK always treated the EU as if it were merely a coalition - a means for UK to enrich itself on an opportunistic basis.
@RealMash
@RealMash 2 дня назад
And they expect it to dissolve-any minute now, as they are saying for thirty years. "Learning impaired" might be the most polite term to describe them.
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
@@RealMash have you not seen the rising right? If current trends continue other countries will exit (well only the rich ones)
@maybenations
@maybenations День назад
@@x-LINX-x As a right-centerd country, only the furthest fringe of parties want to leave here, and they really avoid mentioning it publicly, only railing against EU when its convenient. I suspect that the rising right in the rest of Europe will soon split on these part, as most of the EU countries don't have laws that favours a two party system like UK, where Tories were internally split on Brexit, but still worked as one to push the referendum, cause the Brexit parties (Ukip, Bxparty) were killing them in a 2party system
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
@@maybenations shame, i don't get why a 'centre right' country would want to be governed by a leftist union
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
@@maybenations what use does a centre right country get from following edict from a leftist union?
@frankoneill5675
@frankoneill5675 3 дня назад
''The (Internal Market) Bill was eventually withdrawn in an act of good faith by the UK' Saying you are not going to break international law is not an act of good faith. The UK faced sanctions if it didn't withdraw the bill.
@paullarne
@paullarne 3 дня назад
Exercising sovereignty is explicitly not a breach of International Law.
@Harry-tb8yo
@Harry-tb8yo 3 дня назад
@@paullarne Breaking international law is not exercising sovereignty.
@Harry-tb8yo
@Harry-tb8yo 3 дня назад
In fact the UK never negotiated and acted in good faith during Brexit negotiations and afterwards. Even now with Labour in government it doesn't look like they want to honor their obligations from WA and TCA.
@paullarne
@paullarne 3 дня назад
@@Harry-tb8yo The EU always tries to over-implement agreements in their favour. The UK is having none of it.
@Esemptius
@Esemptius 3 дня назад
@@paullarneMy god you sound like an English child 🤣 "Over-implement" lol. No lying Enlishman. You dishonest English renege on what you sign up for.
@sofialadune9351
@sofialadune9351 3 дня назад
Pauvre peuple anglais, on vous avait prévenu pourtant, say thanks to Farage the deavil...
@Esemptius
@Esemptius 3 дня назад
Je suis content qu'ils soient partis. Good riddance comme ils disent.
@sofialadune9351
@sofialadune9351 3 дня назад
@@Esemptius Parti? tu es content que les anglais soient partis?
@Esemptius
@Esemptius 3 дня назад
@@sofialadune9351 Oui. Ils n'ont jamais mérité être membre a cause de leur comportement pour 47 années.
@sofialadune9351
@sofialadune9351 3 дня назад
@@Esemptius De quaule aussi n en voulait pas ...il avait donc raison....
@Esemptius
@Esemptius 3 дня назад
@@sofialadune9351 Il avait bien raison!
@RazorMouth
@RazorMouth 3 дня назад
7 to 8 billion net contributions from the UK after rebates and other returns. Not 10 to 12 billion.
@paullarne
@paullarne 3 дня назад
12 billion net, 20 billion gross, plus £100bn/year trade deficit - the real cost of being in the Single Market.
@Harry-tb8yo
@Harry-tb8yo 3 дня назад
@@paullarne And now you are losing even more. Congratulations. You are not missed.
@paullarne
@paullarne 3 дня назад
@@Harry-tb8yo No we're not. The overall cost is down from £120bn/year to £80bn and trade outside the EU is ramping up. We should never, ever have joined.
@user-wc9eh6se5p
@user-wc9eh6se5p 3 дня назад
@paullarne you search all brexit videos and comment in order to persuade yourself you was right and spread hate to EU. You already said that the target for your weapons should be the EU not Russia. You are wonderful. Go on
@daanwolters3751
@daanwolters3751 3 дня назад
True, you shouldnt have joined. We spoiled you guys with favourable treatment for far too long. Ah well, enjoy your 15 pount fish and chips. While cod prices are lower than before in the netherlands
@marcelpenuelatraub2343
@marcelpenuelatraub2343 2 дня назад
Actually, with the UK, it had 28 members!!!
@Anastasis-is-here
@Anastasis-is-here 2 дня назад
What is really good about the EU is the Schengen agreement. Something the UK never experienced. It is easier to travel within Schengen than it is traveling in your home country, making tourism bloom and a lot of money going to middle class people. The rest is politics that don't affect the common people, so i don't blame the English for wanting to get out, granding that i do believe they were racists towards Europeans and now that these Europeans left and got replaced by Asians, their value is shown but it's too late.
@Arltratlo
@Arltratlo 4 часа назад
i went in September to 5 EU countries, no stops, no fuzz, no UK citizen!
@fcassmann
@fcassmann 3 дня назад
Out means out. Stay out! Rot In Peace. 🇪🇺🇳🇱
@e1woqf
@e1woqf 3 дня назад
👍 from 🇩🇪
@robinmangala3536
@robinmangala3536 3 дня назад
Indeed, from 🇧🇪 we have other concerns instead of dealing with British indecisive antics
@bluerisk
@bluerisk 2 дня назад
I hope we are next to leave the EU.
@TimGrad
@TimGrad 2 дня назад
​@@bluerisk100 rubles for Ivan from Saint-Petersburg.
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
@@bluerisk join the darkside 😁👌
@Subjuga
@Subjuga 2 дня назад
Brexit always felt weird to me cause I remember vividly watching a mini documentary on all potential consequences leaving the EU would have for my country in the mid 2000s and thinking noone would ever be so brazen to want to deal with the fallout such a decision would bring...
@tomasgrimm3086
@tomasgrimm3086 2 дня назад
If part of the UK politics and people didn´t want the EU they should have made more effort to build alliances inside the EU to make the changes they needed to stay in instead of playing the empire game, there are no more empires in Europe, even the EU can´t be an empire even if allowed to.
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
nah, they run things like an empire. They're currently imposing (or trying to impose) sanctions on poland and hungary for not following edicts
@mysticalmaid
@mysticalmaid День назад
They didn't want alliances. The forces driving Brexit are powerful, influential people who wanted to break up the E.U.. Everyone seems to have forgotten about Cambridge Analytica and links to Farage, Putin, Trump, Brexit.
@tomasgrimm3086
@tomasgrimm3086 День назад
​@@x-LINX-x that´s not an empire, it´s rules enforcement, every association has rules, if everybody is allowed to do whatever they please the result is chaos
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
@@tomasgrimm3086 they are an unelected body giving orders to involved states, england did the exact same 'rule enforcement' to govern its empire. Same as france, spain and portugal. Sanctions are best non militaristic way to throw around unwanted power plays
@x-LINX-x
@x-LINX-x День назад
@@tomasgrimm3086 economic unions don't require every nation involved to agree on every social/environmental policy in lockstep
@jansix4287
@jansix4287 День назад
Brexit is god's way of teaching the Brits, what the EU has ever done for them?
@louis-philippearnhem6959
@louis-philippearnhem6959 11 часов назад
7:50 The Russia economy is worth $1.4 trillion, making it the 12th largest in the world. Roughly equivalent to the GDPs of the Netherlands ($824 billion), Belgium ($492 billion) and Luxembourg ($64 billion) combined.
@Arltratlo
@Arltratlo 4 часа назад
a country of 150 million to how many European, 25 million!
@GazilionPT
@GazilionPT 3 дня назад
7:54 Why was Austria left out on this map?
@RazorMouth
@RazorMouth 3 дня назад
Mistake obviously
@MangoFIlms_CH
@MangoFIlms_CH 3 дня назад
think its a nato map maybe
@RazorMouth
@RazorMouth 3 дня назад
@@MangoFIlms_CH no Ireland aren't in NATO and Norway is.
@GazilionPT
@GazilionPT 3 дня назад
@@MangoFIlms_CH No. Ireland is not in NATO but is in EU, as shown on that map. Norway is in NATO but not in EU, also as shown on that map. They just forgot Austria, I guess.
@MeinenNamenSagIchNicht
@MeinenNamenSagIchNicht День назад
Maybe they are trying the Auxit/Öxit ;)
@evie1915
@evie1915 3 дня назад
Russia gate crashed the eu referremendum
@batcollins3714
@batcollins3714 3 дня назад
Russia had no votes but the uneducated racist British did.
@paullarne
@paullarne 3 дня назад
ROFL, you don't still believe it was the Russians? How did they do it? Aliens? Fact is, there was no Golden Age of EU membership. 52% of us hated it.
@TimGrad
@TimGrad 2 дня назад
Here it's full of Russian fake accounts from Russian troll factories
@be12
@be12 День назад
Check the space between your ears
@barnbersonol
@barnbersonol 3 дня назад
I work for German company in the uk (mollertech) and if brexit wasnt mentioned in the media every 5 minutes i wouldnt even know it happened.
@nicolass7102
@nicolass7102 3 дня назад
Brexit disaster
3 дня назад
God this is a poor video
@norwegianzound
@norwegianzound 2 дня назад
Wow! Ireland is in the top 10 contributors. Little Ireland with only a population of 5 million. Should make other countries ashamed. Proportionally the Netherlands gives much less. Payback time I suppose.
@uhwake
@uhwake День назад
ireland became rich because of the eu!
@Apollorion
@Apollorion 15 часов назад
@@uhwake And low taxes.. => Big international companies that wanted to be in the EU's single market but not pay much taxes settled in Ireland.
@Bucefal76
@Bucefal76 3 дня назад
Change always causes temporary downfall. Question is how the GB will look in next 10 years.
@shrimp8545
@shrimp8545 3 дня назад
I can't immagine it looking good, theres no hope in sight at least from what I can tell.
@RazorMouth
@RazorMouth 3 дня назад
Putting trade, regulatory and cultural barriers between you and "all" of your neighbors is never going to provide a positive result. 10, 20 years won't make any difference.
@franswiggers601
@franswiggers601 3 дня назад
The old Brexit mantra of Failure.
@Bucefal76
@Bucefal76 3 дня назад
@@RazorMouth ... yes ..., considering that, if the end globalization is true (see P. Zeihan), then offshore partners may not balance lack of EU market. I know that EU market is still open for UK companies but only middle and big can afford to deal with all paper job and troubles. Small may give up.
@ab-ym3bf
@ab-ym3bf 3 дня назад
​@@Bucefal76small and partly medium have already given up, as was noted in recent months when export statistics came out wrt not just volume but also the range of products.
@peterwhimster
@peterwhimster 3 дня назад
Was Brexot really what people of GB wanted? Perhaps better to be out of the EC before it disintegrates. The UK must join NAFTA.
@dantownsend4246
@dantownsend4246 3 дня назад
NAFTA doesn’t exist anymore it’s has been replaced by USMCA . Canada USA trade is $2.5 billion a DAY. It’s best if you trade with Australia . Besides you are not in North America. Also Canada had a huge coast line on the pacific .
@euroteng2905
@euroteng2905 3 дня назад
@peterwhimster, you are a stupid mate. Greeting from AU
@boxsterman77
@boxsterman77 3 дня назад
Because everyone is so clamoring for Britain to join their trade pact? When is Britain going to get over itself? What does she have to trade that cannot be satisfied easily and less expensively from somewhere else? NAFTA is not in need of agricultural products. Finished goods. Can the UK beat the labor costs of Mexico.
@paologat
@paologat 3 дня назад
Indeed it’s better that UK is out of the EU (not EC) before UK disintegrates. Although leaving the EU is one of the key factors driving UK to self-inflicted dissolution.
@robtyman4281
@robtyman4281 3 дня назад
​@@paologat Agree 💯
@Curryking32000
@Curryking32000 3 дня назад
Thank god we left the eu. Look at the state of Germany right now economically and politically and what a mess they're in compared to us. Germany is meant to be the 'economic powerhouse' of the EU as well. We definitely are better off outside the eu that there is no doubt. When it comes to breaking international law, every country does this all the time, its no big deal and that includes Spain, France, Germany etc.
@k.schmidt2740
@k.schmidt2740 3 дня назад
Have you been to Germany lately? I am there all day, every day - and there is no economical "mess". Politically, we have the same problems as GB (s. Farage etc.) in that we have to save our democracy from the radical right. Up until now, our radicals haven't been able to ruin much of anything for us - in contrast to your fate under Brexit. So all in all, we're doing OK and you are not.
@roccosilverstar
@roccosilverstar 3 дня назад
I moved to Germany before brexit and Germany is in a much better place than the UK is. I can see a doctor or dentist when I need to! Only the thick would still think Brexit is a good idea.
@Curryking32000
@Curryking32000 3 дня назад
@@k.schmidt2740 I go to Germany regularly, thats why i'm up to date with the state of the German economy....and it isn't good is it. Economically Germany is struggling as well you know, plus they have problems with far right parties taking power, the UK doesn't.
@MrGieltedze
@MrGieltedze 3 дня назад
@@Curryking32000 So where did they take power? If you are so well informed on Germany you musy be able to tell.
@evie1915
@evie1915 3 дня назад
Numpty
@Alcani81
@Alcani81 3 дня назад
It is also not as easy as it is being set up, Denmark, and other countries were in the process of making bilateral agreements with England, but the EU got angry about that, so they were shut down. The fools in Brussels wanted to make it as difficult as possible for England as they could. They were the angry wife who wanted both the house, the car and the children, And at the same time child support and spousal support.
@boxsterman77
@boxsterman77 3 дня назад
You don’t understand trade pacts obviously. It isn’t helpful to compare them to your own fraught-filled domestic existence.
@andreepeterpasche1895
@andreepeterpasche1895 3 дня назад
Sie haben wohl die Seiten vertauscht! Die Brexitbefüworter glaubten Sie könnten bestimmen was passiert. Aber als Aussenseiter und Aussenstehender haben Sie kein Mitspracherecht mehr! Das können die Inselbewohner aber verstehen. Alles was Sie jetzt als negativ empfinden, haben die Briten selber von der EU verlangt, und BEKOMMEN! Und sind jetzt total erstaunt, das es von der anderen Seite schlechter aussieht. Ich hätte alles auch in Oxford English schreiben können, aber für weinerliche Brexiter? Nein!
@Just_another_Euro_dude
@Just_another_Euro_dude 3 дня назад
Why are you describing the UK and then calling it the EU and Brussels? 😂 Go away crazy wife. This ain't your house anymore. Oh, and no delicious drinks and cookies here for you anymore.
@augustiner3821
@augustiner3821 3 дня назад
you have no understanding, how the club rules are.
@AxGerm756
@AxGerm756 3 дня назад
NO. Bilateral treatments outside of EU treaties. Period. No. Little exceptionalist Britain will NOT weasel it's way back into the single market by trying to get treaties with the member states separately. Negotiate with Brussels or p*ss off. 🤷🏻‍♂️
Далее
How the UK is becoming a ‘third-world’ economy
15:36
Egypt's Massive Potential, Wasted
15:46
Просмотров 170 тыс.
Why Brussels Is ‘Lukewarm’ About UK-EU Relations
8:15
This Week In Brexit: The Bad News Never Stops
9:05
Просмотров 79 тыс.
How the EU Won Brexit
6:22
Просмотров 641 тыс.
Douglas Murray: A Time of War
1:05:45
Просмотров 462 тыс.