Gone With the Wind by Margaret Mitchell Book Review & Reaction | Still The Great American Novel? 

Thank you for defending this book. It's one of my favourites.

My dad gave me a copy when I was 10, back in 1972. I was too intimidated by the length to read it for 2 more years. I was hooked. My dad and I outlined our own sequel but because of copyright laws...it remained between us, our quality time together. I still reread every 2 or 3 years. Probably time to revisit my old friends Scarlett, Rhett and Melony.

I just got finished reading it a half an hour ago and I loved it. It was amazing. It took me about a week to read it all because I wanted to take my time reading it but I bought the Kindle book for $.99 and I don't regret it either. It was worth the buy.😊😊

Lonesome Dove and Gone with Wind….Killer Angels by Michael Shaara should be your next historical fiction. Love your content! Thanks for creating

This is a really good yarn of a book. Scarlett is fascinating...Rhett is such a sympathetic character...it really is his love story as we never really feel Scarlett's love for Ashley. Just a sort of emotional talisman she clings to out of habit and bitterness and a sort of pathetic vendetta. Backdrop is beautiful, chaotic, terrifying. Margaret Mitchell was a southern woman raised on the grief of the vanquished and the humiliation of what transpired post war. Great book and must be read through the lens of that era. 💚

I'm here for it! I love historical fiction, and civil war (and post war) fiction is my jam. I never read Gone with the Wind yet, but I got this thick-ass 1974 paperback edition with yellowing-brown pages and a cover ready to fall off. I cannot WAIT to dive in. Great review!

Great review Mike! I first read this book when I was about 12 years old It was an old crappy mass market version with Scarlett’s bosoms all over the cover and I was expected romance and boot knocking. Instead I had my mind blown by the most realistic and awe inspiring picture of a period of American history that I’d never imagined. In good and bad ways.

Can't wait to read this! Can only imagine how cool Rhett Butler is on page.

Just started this for August, you got me interested in this Mike, with your top 10 books of all-time. I'm a huge Dune fan, and did not think I would like Gone With The Wind, but I'm 523 pages in and I can't believe im saying this but im loving Gone With The Wind lol.

I love that you’ve reviewed both Gone With the Wind & Lonesome Dove! Two of my favorites. Great characters in both books!! Love historical fiction❤

Best review of this book that I have ever heard. Although, most reviewers don’t have the courage to even discuss it. Just discovered your channel and you are a stand out. Much respect, looking forward to diving into all of your past reviews.

Love this book! Read it when I was 13 in 1976 after seeing the movie.

Loved the review! Back in the 80's, I found a 1938 hardcover edition of this book inside an old desk that was being scrapped at work. Needless to say, I rescued it and love reading it - especially enjoying all the extra content the movie didn't include.

I lost track of how many times I have said GONE WITH THE WIND Is the perfect novel. Perfect story, perfect carachters. I have read it twice and I will read it again. Perfect book!

Finally decided at age 68 to take the plunge. Only 3 chapters in. Characterization unbelievable from the start. Will slow down and savor.

I’m presently reading Gone with the Wind at the age 65 for the first time, even though the film is one of my all time favourites and like you watched Zillions of times . About 3/4 of the way through loving it. So much more to it than the film. Touches a lot more on the reconstruction after the war than the film depicts. And as a uk subscriber didnt really know much about the history of that era. Obviously this is a fictional story from Margaret Mitchell view. But the book peeked my interest of that period that I’ve googled and learning the history of that time frame. Definitely can’t help rooting for Scarlet despite her bad traits. Gone with the Wind will be added to my top 10 favourite books.

Another fantastic video!!! Thank you!!! And it's important to learn from the truth of the past!

My Favorite videos from Mike are the ones where he talks about classics.believe it or not it’s how I started watching this channel.

I love this book. It's some of the best writing in the English Language. It's so special. Thanks for the great video.

My husband bought this for me as a birthday present, it's very hight on my TBR list. Last month I read Lonesome Dove because of your review. It was incredible! Can't wait to read Gone With the Wind now.❤

When I was 10 we moved from Atlanta to Copenhagen, Denmark. My Mom had picked up the book in the airport when we left. Since I couldn't read Danish yet, this book was all I had to read for an entire summer. I read it so many times that it fell apart and I had to tape it back together again. Being homesick in Europe meant something, I think. But as an avid reader, I also knew that this was just a good, good story. I loved it then and I love it now. Yes, there are questionable topics in it - I recognized this even in 1973. But I still love the story and the characters. An all time favorite for me. And it was my jumping-off spot to becoming a History buff.

Excellent review Mike. I think you nailed it very well. Both Scarlett and Rhett are "outliers" to the Old South. Rhett was pretty much disowned by his Family before the war started. He seems to have known the war was hopeless from the beginning, but when the war was truly in its last phases, quixotically, he enlists in the fight, proving, he's a true Southerner. Scarlett, a plantation princess outrages women of her class by not giving a damn about the proprieties. If Scarlett feels like doing something she does it. Neither one identifies with the norms of their society. But when it falls apart, perhaps because of their innate rejection of that society, their narcissism, and lack of moral scruples they are well equipped to survive the destruction. In a sense they represent the New South and it's not pretty. But it's very real, and very convincing. The funny part , I believe, is that the book was considered progressive when it was first published, It didn't uphold the prevailing Southern view that an age of chivalry and romance had been destroyed, but rather ridiculed that point of view, Scarlett and Rhett could care less about chivalry (except, of course, if they could use it to their advantage,) GWTW is also about a man and a woman who love each other very intensely but can't get along because of their similar but differing character traits. On the whole, I think Rhett behaves a lot better towards Scarlett than she does to him. He puts up with a lot, and only after she has driven him away, does Scarlett realize what a mess she has made of things, but still is convinced she'll get him back. I always thought Rhett would be better off with Belle than Scarlett. Rhett knows that Scarlett is a "little b-----" but is fascinated and thinks he'll win her over in the end. He does, but by then, he's lost his patience. I've often felt that Mitchell was onto something about American men and American women. Rhett and Scarlett are emblematic of a recognizable and repeatable pattern of the war of the sexes American style. GWTW is a great book and no amount of moral posturing and virtue signaling will change that. Those whose eyes are too sensitive and ears are too chaste to read this book or watch the movie can revel in their moral superiority and enjoy their fifteen minutes of fame, and be satisfied with that, since virtue is its own reward. Cheers !

Great Review! I went into this book completely blind other than knowing the names Scarlett and Rhett. What I found was one of the best (if not THE best) books I've ever read.

And this is why we shouldn't be canceling things. We need to remember the past even if it was ugly. Cancelling something only increases the possibility of it happening again. Great review ... Never read the book and not sure I ever will...maybe... Lol anyways keep up the good work.

It’s 12:54 am in NC and I just finished Gone With the Wind! Wow! Historical fiction is starting to work its magic on me. When I wake up later today I shall start on either Pillars of the Earth, or The Winter King. I love reading!

hey mike totally unrelated but I started reading like 3 months ago and currently im reading the red rising saga its so good i just started book 4 :- ). thanks for all the book recommendations

Well darn. I haven't read this book since I was 12. You've convinced me to give it a re-read. I have seen the movie many times. The first time was with my Mom when they re-released it into theaters I think it was back in the '70's.

I have watch the movie every year at new years eve since I was 7.

I love Gone with the Wind and want to reread, so listening to your review has reminded me of this. Scarlet is my girl. Melanie refused to believe anything bad about Scarlet and Ashley. The woman was a saint! The only reason I might not give a book a shot is because I have so many books I want to read or buy, so my thought is maybe someday.

I first read this novel as a teen and couldn't put it down! I still love it. Scarlett, perfect or not, is a vibrant ALIVE woman with determination and grit!

You single handedly put this book on my radar. It just never seemed interesting to me until I heard you talking about it

Outstanding analysis, Mike. First time I read GWTW was in '73 when I was 16. Love it to this day for all the compelling reasons you described. Initially, I was drawn in by the complex and fascinating characters, but later did a deep dive into the history of the Civil War, Reconstruction, Jim Crow and Civil Rights eras. Read "Memos of David O. Selznick" and saw how he grappled with both the concerns of black Americans and Southerners. Pretty sure there were some Confederate War veterans at the film's festivities. I was horrified when I read that Hattie McDaniel was excluded from the premiere and did not sit with the other stars of GWTW at the Academy Awards ceremony. I share your positive perspective that one's distaste of aspects of the book and film indicate the progress that has been made over time. There is still much human misery today as children and adults are being trafficked as I type this post. Wonder what people 100 years from now will think about our efforts to eradicate this and other problems. You have earned a new subscriber today!

The book was written by a Southern woman with a Southern bias. The characters are stereotypes, yet the book is supremely entertaining and well-written. The main flaw is that Mitchell tried to excuse slavery on the grounds that slaves were taken care of, ignoring the fact that slavery is a moral wrong, and an evil practice. Mitchell's bio THE ROAD TO TARA, is as fascinating as the novel itself.

Melanie annoyed me for a long time. But I came to adore her. This is a case where the movie helped me. Olivia de Havilland was wonderful in the role. She not only portrayed Melanie's goodness, but her intelligence, dignity, and strength. I used to think she was naive and utterly blind. I grew up with this book and movie at the same time. It's all mixed up in my mind, but in the best way. I've changed my view on Melanie through the years. She knew a whole lot more than she let on. In the movie, her interactions with Rhett after [insert horrible event spoiler] shatter me, every time. Ashley didn't deserve her.

Thanks for this. My favourite book, and probably among my favourite movies as well. Read it the first time when I was 13. Immediately hooked ❤

Thanks for this review. After finishing the book, I wanted to get a couple of reviews from different perspectives, so I listen to yours as well as the review by “Supposedly Fun”. he does a deeper dive, but both offer some interesting points. I recently read this book after people suggested not criticizing the movie until reading the book. I agree with some of your comments about the book being captivating, and that it is not a love story between Rhett and Scarlett. There are some troubling elements that were not mentioned in this review. I’m glad I read it and I would not recommend it as historical fiction as much as historical propaganda/fiction. The story had some accuracy with the timeline of events, but many inaccuracies regarding African-Americans and their viewpoints, treatment of the enslaved, Yankees, and anyone else seen as “perpetrators”. The love story is between Margaret Mitchell and the old South/confederacy. I can’t help but think that this book with all of it readers, was how people learned a false history of the Civil War, the reconstruction years, and slavery. That is probably the most troubling aspect of this book to me. I am not sure where the writing started to become cringy, but early enough on where I wondered if I could finish the book. I decided if I was going to be able to review it, I did need to complete it. Had she just kept with the characters and left out her overt racism, and hatred of the union/northerners, I think it could’ve been a much more beautiful story that did not need a further deep dive. Margaret Mitchell told the story as the narrator; it wasn’t Scarlett telling her view of things. If it had been Scarlett with her self-centered nature, it would’ve been more palatable when African-Americans were labeled as inferior, lazy, etc. It would’ve been understandable that she saw the KKK as heroes and necessary. In Scarlett’s experience, it would be understandable for her to resent the federal government/union soldiers. However, Margaret Mitchell tells these stories as if they are historical facts of the time versus the view of Scarlett. This is where it becomes dangerous propaganda that fed many peoples minds. Even Melanie, who is so “sweet”, knew her husband was in the KKK and didn’t seem bothered by the purpose of the group. I really liked the movie when I watched it several times many years ago, despite the more subtle racism. After reading the book and knowing more about the author and her views at the time, I don’t think the movie will seem quite as enjoyable. I would not ban this book, but I would not recommend it to anybody looking for a history of the Civil War and the aftermath. I think it could be a good book for a high school or college class to examine the writing, character development, and some of the more disturbing themes in this book, especially given the time frame when it was written.

I read this book when I was 14. Bought a book club edition that I have since given away to my sister. I really loved the book and the movie. I finally bought the 75 anniversary edition and am reading it for a second time.

I plan to make this my next classic read for 2024. The year before last was Leo Tolstoy's War and Peace, this year was my year of Jane Austen. Gone with the Wind is a favorite of my mums, and I grew up watching the movie at least once a year. I know my enjoyment of Historical Fiction comes from my mum. She prefers American history, but I am down with a mix of world regions. 🌎🥰📖 📚📚📚📚📚

Love your diversity Mike! Please include classics!!! Love this book- and I highly recommend to anybody interested in American history.

It’s one of the best of the 20th Century. Ashley represents the Old South that Scarlett is in love with. Rhett represents 1930s, post Depression US, where the winners were the unscrupulous industrialist mega tycoons. Not deliberately in the story itself but that was the culture this story fell into. In 1929 many Americans could absolutely identify with “I’ll never go hungry again!” In 1939 there would have been very few dry eyes in the theater when she declared that. The South of the 1930s disdained industrialism and held on to agrarianism to their detriment for far too long. I think this book also inadvertently served to inspire the Greatest Generation to persevere in the soon to come WWII.

Fiddle dee dee. Great balls of fire! It's an interesting reading of plantation life and slavery. It's written in the third person and there are times when you might wonder if the narrator feels the same way about slavery as Scarlet. Scarlet's so shallow she doesn't question it's morality. In fact she's pretty amoral herself. Now when I say 'narrator' I don't mean the author. In third person fiction the narrator is also a character. In the case of "Gone with the Wind" I believe the narrator is a Southern sympathizer.

Fantastic review! I watched part of the movie adaptation when it was airing on TV several years ago, but I need to watch it. I really, REALLY need to read the book, too! I just got a beautiful edition from my former piano teacher while she was getting ready to move, and it’s really been on my mind lately. Thanks for sharing this!

Hey Mike, if you haven't already, another excellent classic historical fiction epic I would be thrilled to see you review is War & Peace! I'll admit, when I started, I was fairly intimidated by both the length and sheer number of characters, but once I settled in, I could not stop.

2024 for me is the read of the Epic. Im reading a ton of books all over 600 pages that are staples in what they do. This is on the list!

You triggered my Alexa lol

You made me read lonesome dove, and now i want to read gone with the wind after your review!

Scarlett had two qualities: courage and family devotion. Scarlett did many things, but she never felt sorry for herself. Her courage was the main reason why readers admired her, despite her bad flaws.

This one is also in my top 10. I first read it at 18 and now at 33 I read not only Scarlett, but Ashley, on a much deeper level. Thanks for inspiring the re-read! I've also read Scarlett and Rhett Butler's People but they didn't come close to the greatness of the original.

Thank you for doing this review. My wife and I love reading Sanderson and Outlander together. We’ve had trouble with other books known for Romance because it gets overbearing really fast. It sounds like this book has great epic qualities and a romance so it’s right up our alley 😊

I have this on my reading list, just waiting on the B&N classic leather bound version.

This has been sitting on my shelf for a while and I do mean to get to it at some point. Great review, Mike!

I don't have my first copy anymore. It had alot of book fungi or whatever you call it but it smelled amazing 🤣 and I finished it in 24 hours! It was disintegrating and I threw it away after I read it after my end of highschool exams. [The warmth of june, the sunlight, the peace...That experience will be with me for a long time]

Great video, thank you for continuing to do book reviews. Top ten book of all time for me and a great movie.

When you said ‘’Alexa’’ you triggered my Alexa and she answered the question LOL

"Gone with the Wind" is the only book I've read that succeeds with character, setting, and dialogue.

My second favorite book of all time just behind Dune.

The strength of the story and why it's so re-readable is that the characters are so realistic. Magnified for fiction, sure. But they are complex. You may hate them one moment and root for them the next. Or if not root for them, at least understand why they acted as they did. You see them in horrible situations and wonder... what would I do? Would I always do the right thing? What even is the right thing in some circumstances? Argh! You are making me want to reread it and I can't right now!

It's one of the top 5 in my great American novels list (Grapes of Wrath, Lonesome Dove, The Last of the Mohicans, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn are the others for me, with To Kill a Mockingbird sometimes jumping in and out). I think it contains a great love story but in no way would I call it a romance. I love romances, and this isn't a romance novel. The focus of the story is on the change and the perseverance of one family through the major upheaval of the Civil War. They're not nice people- maybe that's why they survived. But survive they did and the story is fascinating.

Thank you for a nice review. Absolutely agree with you point of view! As a not native speeder, had to watch with a 0.75 speed to get everything you were saying haha Looking forward for your other reviews

You've definitely convinced me! Though there are many mammoths on the TBR ahead of it.

I have watched the movie adaptation so many times since I was 9 years old I might read the book if the library has a copy

I just picked this up today, along with Dracula and Frankenstein. Your recommendation was a deciding factor. Because of all the subversion in modern escapism, I decided to go back to the classics.

I always say Scarlett is one of the few true female antiheros. She's not going to change, and that's a lot more realistic than her growing a heart of gold. That's still a very rare type of female character. We may root for Walter White and Tony Soprano with all their flaws, but we still want our women to be sweet and soft underneath it all.

I read this book last year. EXCELLENT read. And yes, the racism was rough. BUT! My God I love/hate Scarlett! Her mindset actually helped me push through some rough patches myself. So yes, I can say this book has helped me personally.

Currently reading it, only on page 10, oh god It's gonna take me a lifetime to finish this book, but I love the movie so it inspired me to read it, I know it should be vise versa. I'm curious if you read all 14 Oz books and what you thought of them and Frank Baum writing style? Hope to find a video of that if you did one. Regardless, I'm liking the book so far, Scarlett seems the same in the book as she is in the movie lol. I'm reading a library book of it, it's so long that it was two months over due, they should give you six months to read a huge monster like this book. Granted I could have gotten further than 10 pages for two months worth, I took my sweet time of cracking it open and reading it.

Mitchell had a hell of a time writing the book - it took her ten years. When the book was finally finished she vowed she would never write another book again, and she never did.

Yes, Mike! Btw, when's the movie night?

Great review! Its one of my favorite books too. I agree with your sentiments regarding the book!

My wife and I watched the movie a few months ago and we loved it

Mike, I never read Gone With the Wind, but I’ve seen the movie many times. Your review has made me want to read the actual book. I never could figure out why Scarlet had such a thing for Ashley Wilkes. I guess because her and Rhett were so alike. So I’m going to have to check it out. Like you said the Southern people had their way of life ripped from them.

I love Gone With The Wind. It deserves all the accolades. Also, I'd like to make a suggestion- Holmes On The Range by Steve Hockensmith. This series is my new literary love. lol It's set in the 1800's Old West, focusing on an illiterate cowboy and his younger brother who try to fashion themselves into detectives, thanks to a campfire reading of The Red-Headed League. It has everything- mystery, action, humor, and some of the best characters and character development, in my opinion. If you love characters who work hard against impossible odds, you'll love this.

Mike this was a great review. Gone With the Wind was one of my mother's favorite movies. I have seen a lot and can quote most of the dialogue. After decades of watching it, I read the book in what seems like ages ago and enjoyed it as well, especially the parts left out of the movie. I did not like the sequel either. I am black and of a certain age. I may be offended by slavery and how it was in the south, but I chose to read it as a woman because I feel like Scarlett is a strong character. She does not faint or shy away from hardships. And she did some low down things to recreate the wealth she was born into. Her toughness and thick skin kept her from giving up. This book did not shy away from the horrors of war.

Should read this soon, haven't seencthe movie either. Thanks for a great review Mike!

IMHO you missed/didn't cover the DEPTH of Mitchell's characterizations Scarlett is strong, but her strength is one dimensional. It is usually with her but escapes her when she is vulnerable--like when she's crying to Rhett after Frank dies--glad her mother isn't alive to see her behavior and fearing going to Hell. Melanie is sweet and loyal--but underneath that she is just as strong as Scarlett. Strong enough to help Scarlett murder a man and then coolly lie about it. Again when Ashley is injured. Her strength never escapes her. It is the foundation of her sweetness. Ashley has all the gallantry of the old southern gentleman--but it is a veneer.. He can go to war, as society would dictate he would do. But underneath he's weak, and depends on Melanie for her strength. IMHO he knows his weakness and recognized the veneer, but doesn't have the strength to try and change. Rhett is a scallywag--on the surface tough and cynical. But it is a mask hiding his depth, his capacity and desire for love. He knowingly adopts the mask when he recognizes his vulnerability if he reveals that desire. He shows his full self to Melanie and Bonnie--he knows his vulnerability is safe. In the jail scene he starts to become vulnerable to Scarlett, then quickly pulls on the mask when he realizes what's happening.

This is a must-buy!

Please do a movie review?

Added to the reading list! Speaking of classics, you may want to try Crime and Punishment sometime.

There was a rumor that Gone With the Wind was a true story, but the author just changed the names of the characters. Have you heard anything about this?

So glad you did this review. I think this book is crucial for those interested in this time frame. Our presentation of the south is exclusively evil. This book shows the flaws and nuances of all parties involved in a really honest way

You don't need to apologize for bad things happening in books

I haven't read it (watched the movie several times), but I doubt that Gone with the Wind qualifies as one of the Great American Novels, which is not to say that it is bad or not a part of American history and culture, but not as sophisticated as something like Moby Dick. That's just a nitpick though. What makes me write a comment is the criticism that the movie and book get. It will forever be beyond me how some people are seemingly incapable or unwilling to see any kind of artistic work as a product of its time. I mostly read classic literature if I would let modern sensibilities decide whether to read or like something from the past I wouldn't be able to read and enjoy some/many of humanity's greatest achievements. The problem is not whether a work of art has elements that we do not agree with today but whether those are its sole purpose. I would have a tough time enjoying a ficitonal work that would try to convince me that a group of people are inherently inferior. Still, a movie like Birth of Nation can still have its value if for nothing else than it's historical importance. I guess Gone with the Wind does a have simple and romanticized idea of antebellum south and slavery, but I don't think that it ever is the main focus of the story in the book or the movie. The main focus is on the characters. Because of this video I read up on Margaret Mitchell and given her background, Gone with the End couldn't have turned any different. It would have been interesting to see what she might have had to say about it if she had lived longer. Since I mentioned the characters, Scarlett might be one of my favorite female characters. I often have the impression that when someone demands strong female characters in popular movies today that it mostly boils down to them being able to fight as well as the male characters (I am probably wrong on this, but that's the impression often get). Give me a strong (but still flawed) woman like Scarlett any day of the week. For some reason I always expect Gone of the Wind to not quite work for me anymore whenever I watch it, and am afterwards always amazed how easily it draws you into the story.

I'll give it another try.

Excellent review.

My original copy was a small paperback that was already old when I found it at a used bookstore. I'm 50+ and I've had it since 8th grade. I only know that because I had scrawled my classroom number in it. It's literally falling apart. I finally gave up trying to read from it. My eyesight was never great. It's obviously not getting any better as I age. The tiny print is no longer comfortable to read. I put it into a plastic bag for protection. I can't bear to part with it. What was difficult was trying to find a replacement with a cover that didn't look like a cheap romance. I usually don't pay much attention to covers. But the ones I was finding were awful. Any "romance" here was never my interest or focus. I love the full story and the characters. I think I found the one you were reading from. It was good, but the cover was a bit torn and it wasn't exactly what I wanted. I hit the jackpot and finally found The One. I think it was from Thriftbooks. It's green on top and bottom, with a drawing of Tara in the center. Simple and elegant. It's an ex-library hardcover with the plastic cover, so it should last me the rest of my life. It was in near new shape. I think it was something like $10.00, which was a steal! My sister is also a huge fan, so I gave your edition to her. We also adore the film. We had the opportunity to see it in theaters for the 70th or 75th anniversary. Something like that. It was wonderful!

Storm of Swords 😹 Because of you I am considering it!

In my top 10 of all time also! Maybe time for another read.

Frankly my dear,I dont give a ham,spam,ram,bam,Wham(Insert ,,Wake me up before you Go Go" Here) 🤩😂

I agree with this is a good book, but top ten seems a little nostalgia based😅

I’m halfway through I will say I think I enjoyed the first part of the story better than I am the second half but who knows that might change

🎉🎉🎉Yessss!!!!

Some additional thoughts about GWTW. GWTW is an American novel that in many ways is comparable to Tolstoi's War and Peace. It occupies roughly the same territory in Russian literary history that the Civil War does in American history, the impact of Napoleon's invasion of Russia and the human costs that invasion imposed on ordinary Russians at all social levels. I read both works around the same time. I saw the GWTW movie when I was 15, and I read War and Peace just after I turned 16. Within a year or so I read GWTW as a novel. Although I think War and Peace is the better novel, and Tolstoi's view more humane, I liked GWTW better. Why ? It's not just because I'm an American. It's because Scarlett and Rhett are the type of heroes I find it easy to accept. Pierre and Natasha are simply not strong people. For sure, Natasha is a lovely and decent young girl. No real problem with her, but she's no Scarlett O'Hara although she's far more likable. The problem is Pierre. Pierre is a brave and one feels a man of great potential. But Pierre dithers around he gives up a lot of liberal ideas and his admiration for Napoleon, but he doesn't know what to do. Finally, he decides to assassinate Napoleon but whatever his intent he doesn';t get very far before being caught by the French and narrowly escapes death. Prince Andre, who is a soldier does his duty and gets killed. No dithering in his case. But Pierre who is a better person than Rhett doesn't really do much. In Russian literature from my reading people wander around asking: What is to be done ? They just don't seem to know. Someone has to tell them. One Russian writer said of Russian Revolutionaries of the 1880's that there are men in Russia with the courage to walk through fire to right the wrongs of society, but they need direction. (I had the same problem with Doctor Zhivago who never really could seem to make up his mind what to do.) Of course, I concede that in upheavals like these finding the right course of action is not easy, but in fiction, at least, I like decisive individuals for heroes. That, of course, may simply be a cultural trait: Americans are used to making decisions for themselves, and seldom look around for someone to tell them what to do.

Yeah, it’s a Pulitzer Prize-winning novel. Just skip it and review the latest YA trash instead. 🙄 So over this era of denigrating those who actually have talent. The book is a brilliant character study of an antiheroine. You can’t stand her, but the brilliance of Mitchell’s writing makes you root for her anyway. I’ve never experienced anything else like it.

Thank you for reviewing this book, it’s one of my favorites as well and feel it gets written off too often today, also side note you set off my Alexa while I watched 😂

I really like the book, but I couldn't stand Rhett. I was waiting for him to get his comeuppance, but it never came.

Mike you’re making me want to go read gone with the wind. And that’s not something. I ever thought I’d say

I say if you love a book it doesn't have to be one kind of book. I don't read like that, and I know you don't either. A few summers back Mom read this one and all the sequels (by other authors) and had a ball with the whole thing. I'm a big fan of the movie. I read half the novel.

I really love your perspective on the controversy. I like hearing why people take issue with it, who should NOT read it, but then your rationale (perhaps because your thoughts align with mine lol)

If you were to review the telephone book, I’d watch it because from you it would be an interesting review. Love Gone with the wind - both book and movie. Such an interesting read. In U.K. in 2003, it was voted number 21 in BBC’s Top 200 reads

Any update on spoiler talk for Light Bringer?

Great review, Mike !!! Love the intro. I still reading it and enjoying a lot. I have some friends who dislike this book for the bad things you are mentioning but I’m a big fan of the movie I think I watched at least 30 times. I also have a magazine about the movie and I agreed Vivian Leigh did an amazing job as Scarlett.