Nah Seulgi got a more developed lower range than Winter. Mixed range wise they both have hella problems with nasality but Seulgi is still a bit more developed
What’s crazy is they ARE still in the game. Taeyeon is still literally one of the best vocalists and singers in kpop, and Hyoyeon still one of the greatest dancers. SNSD crumbled apart many times (Jessica, SeoTifSoo, and now basically everyone is on their own) but their talent never fails, and everytime they separate, their bonds grow stronger, too. New kpop fans missed a lot.
@@NoctLightCloud I disagree. YoonA is still THE Visual of Kpop, not just 2nd gen... She never ages and she’s still in the game. I don’t think there is or will be any visual that could be as memorable as Yoong. Juxtapose Yoona to anyone and she’ll outshine them.
So basically vocal Monsters with 6 of 7 members having support. Can we all agree that they are the strongest vocal group of third and fourth generation?
Mamamoo could still take then in terms of overall vocals: Taeyeon> Wendy> Wheein> Solar > Hwasa>=BoA. Mamamoo still beats thier other members besides the top 2 by a pretty fair margin.
@@pauloamaro7207 guessing you’re not familiar with Hyoyeon then LOL. the only female dancers in kpop even coming close to touching Hyoyeon are BoA and Minzy
@@pauloamaro7207 clearly you don't know Hyoyeon's dancing abilities. When she was a trainee, she had to train with the Male Trainees because she was too good for just the female training
@@AngelAreAngela omg sones r so delusional 🤣🤣🤣🤣 and who determines the facts? You? Your friends? SNSD is a legendary group but the members aren't the best in everything. Taeyeon isn't best vocal, Hyoyeon isn't the best dancer and Yoona isn't the biggest visual. Accepted the facts and go out of your paralell reality, Wanda.
@@akollenn03 pardon? BoA might stay pretty the same since long ago but she's consistent. She supports her low, belt, and head voice equaly. She has F3/F#3-B4/C5-E5 since back then, her biggest problem is her nasality. Seulgi is nasal too, she's pretty decent on her level but not stronger than BoA. She supports G3/G#3-Bb4, her supports pretty much like Tiffany. BoA might not belt really high in this song doesnt mean she cant or she's weak
But BoA being 3rd and 2nd!?? She is probably the most complete idol to ever exist. No wonder why she is still a well known 1st gen recognised artist and a living legend.
@@ggstan2439 Unpretty rapstar was a joke sorry. The level or rap there was bellow average so not a good point, also she isn't close to be a good dancer as Boa or Hyo
Truth be said, BoA is the only one who can perform a 2 hour long concert completely live and outdance her amazing dancers effortlessly. Others are great, it's SM after all, but BoA's talent and stamina is in a completely different level and it has never been matched in K-Pop history.
Taeyeon - Main Vocalist Wendy - Main Vocalist Boa - Main Vocalist, Main Dancer, Leader Winter - Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Sub Rapper Seulgi - Lead Vocalist, Main Dancer Karina - Main/Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub Vocalist Hyoyeon - Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Sub Vocalist
@@Idk-kj9ke Wendy and Taeyeon are exceptions. But apart from Seulgi, nobody’s coming close to (especially these two) Wheein and Solar, Hwasa, Tiffany, Seohyun, Sunny and even Jessica.
@@taeslilclown9801 apart from seulgi ? Seulgi is the weakest lead vocalist of this lineup lol. Boa and winter are better even tho they are all pretty close , nah sorry dawg but u wrong on this one. The fact that aside from One member, all of them can support at least B4 shows u how good they are
@@alifiyey4975 mamamoo vocal line is 7/10 , this lineup is a 7.7/10 ( a 10/10 out of ten would be a group full of singers like sohyang just to give u some perspective )
BoA is definitely an overall Queen. It's hard to use ONE song full of more or less the same high notes to compare these stars. They are all amazing. Do some of them have awesome qualities that BoA may not possess? Sure! Doesn't make them the best. Also vocal range =/= quality, control, or versatility. I love Taeyoens voice, and Hyoyeon's rapping. The other girls are still great and deserve love too. BoA however, is the only one who has been a solo artist for as long as she has been, and has performed entire 2hr long live shows while singing AND dancing live. FOR YEARS. She through and through has been an idol for so many younger artists. Artistry should not be limited to 10 second clips and high notes lol.
I might be bias, but Taeyeon’s high note is the only one that doesn’t hurt my ears in the song, on my first listen. Could be the editing and production tho. It doesn’t have that sharp piercing sound but rather very wholesome. I suck at describing but yeah #믿듣탱 indeed. All of the members are amazing, i especially love that Wendy is there ;)
I think it's because of her resonance. Tbh, my bias is Wendy, but when she belt, it goes pitchy. It's not that I don't like it, but I prefer Taeyon's belt more.
same! their techniques can be determined even through untrained ears, simply from whether they sound tight and whiny or not. and i must say Taeyeon sounds the most effortless and comfortable reaching the F5 note in "level~" among those 4. The other three sound kinda tight and whiny, especially Winter. Wendy is definitely 2nd, Seulgi's "level~" is a bit whiny too. all of them are great though.
Hyoyeon isn't the worst vocalist here tho. Hyoyeon vocals bring a beautiful contrast to other vocals that it make this song more interesting. And Taeyeon isn't the worst dancer either. Her dance moves aren't as big as other, but she has unique fluidity that it makes her dance look elegant.
@@randompotassium1111 ik she isn't the worst, but she's definitely the weakest. i mean, i havent heard karina singing live yet but from what ive heard in savage, she definitely sounds like a better vocalist. im sorry, but in such a lineup, hyoyeon is definitely in bottom two.
BoA is a double threat. Seulgi's presence though! Woo! Really a light fan of RV, but she blew me out the water. All of these ladies are phenomenal and really compliment each other. I think that by being in a different group, or in a new circumstance in BoA's case, these girls can see their strengths and bring that forward. I hope they have another comeback.
I think Karina has better rapping tone than Hyoyeon but I don't think it's necessary if we're talking about rap. Well tbh, Karina's tone is a bit similar to Hyuna or even Soyeon for me. If SM actually know what they're doing with their rapper, Karina would become a decent idol rapper in general
I don't know if this is going to start a fight but why Seulgi is on 5th place? Yeah, she has tongue tension, yes, she has a unstable vibrato, yes, she has nasality issues and yes, she has issues with her upper register, but still Seulgi looks better than Winter for me I don't like comparing old idols to new ones, but I have seen that Seulgi's B4s are getting better and more open, but still, although she uses more of a weak and disconnected falsetto, she knows to bring her cords together to make a true head voice that doesn't strain until E5/F5, and besides that, Seulgi lower register is great, she supports down to G3/G#3 but Seulgi can sing as low as E3 without losing tonality, and at that point support is lost, but she never sounds quiet or tense on his lower notes at least down to F3/F#3, Winter lower register is very average due to her lighter tone supporting just down to A3/Bb3, although her mix is more "healthy" than seulgi because she supports up to Bb4/B4, does that make her better than seulgi? Just Hitting high notes doesn't make you a better vocalist that others I don't pretend to offend anyone, but Seulgi is better than Winter, but that's is just my opinion And for the record I didn't mention that Aespa rarely sings on live, which I think that is a good fact to take in county but still, that's company's fault not the girl's fault Still seulgi is 4th for me 4 - Seulgi [G3/G#3 ~ A4/Bb4 (B4)] (1 octave and 1.5 notes) 5 - Winter [A3/Bb3 ~ Bb4/B4] (1 octave and 1 note) But again, is just my opinion
Boa: Main dancer, Main vocalist, Sub-rapper, Center, Leader Taeyeon: Main vocalist Hyoyeon: Main Dancer, Main Rapper, Sub-vocalist Seulgi: Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist Wendy: Main Vocalist Karina: Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub-vocalist, Visual Winter: Lead Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Maknae, Visual
@@leuvsemats i mean to be fair, taeyeon is considered one of the least attractive members of SNSD. So even though in my opinion she’s prettier than everyone in aespa and RV, I don’t think they’d give her a visual position since she’s still in SNSD with yoona, seohyun, yuri, sunny, and Tiffany who are all widely regarded as nearly flawless in Kpop.
@@caiovinicius5204 1. taeyeon wants herself to be called king since a king is powerful than a queen. 2. taeyeon is way prettier (and natural) than karina
@Đoàn Đức Anh are we serious right now? theres no way Karina AND Hyo are on main vocalist level lmfao and i would even argue not even lead vocalist level
@@γινομαιενα No, if karina were in YG her vocal technique would be worse than she is now 😩. But you're right if she were in YG group with her current vocal technique she can be a lead vocalist
BoA: Leader, Main Dancer, 1st Lead Vocalist, Center Taeyeon: Main Vocalist, Visual Hyoyeon: Main Dancer, Main Rapper Seulgi: 1st Lead Dancer, 2nd Lead Vocalist Wendy: Main Vocalist, 2nd Sub Rapper Karina: Face of The Group, Lead Rapper, 2nd Lead Dancer Winter: Maknae, Visual, 3rd Lead Vocalist, 1st Sub Rapper
@@sweetbaebae8244 sis lmaooo BoA was THE ONE got me into Kpop, but i gotta be fair. Wendy and Taeyeon are by far the strongest vocalists in the group (and some of the strongest in the entire Kpop), BoA is extremely well rounded as a whole packaged soloist, but vocally she’s not on pair with these two ladies
Both are my biases but I think Taeyeon's dance is just the more or so somilar to wendy's they are not the best dancers but nowhere near bad aswell. I think they deserve the same spot, at 6
@@eyebrowstj i'm Sones, ReVeLuv, and My. I have to say that winter is better at dancing compared to both wendy and taeyeon. Also, taeyeon and wendy is actually just equal as a dancer. This is my opinion though, I respect yours.
@@greenpotatoes2825 I'm not sure about Winter since she is actually a lead dancer and has great body control, but I definitely agree that Wendy is stronger than Taeyeon, we can see it in the pre-chorus, she has better footwork than her, in this song anyways. But yeah, she's sharp and has good coordination
@@greenpotatoes2825 Tae danced to way harder choreo than Wendy ever did (in snsd or as solo), in this video her upper body and footwork are better than Wendy and Winter. People overestimate Wendy dance abilities since she's over dance all the time, very similar to Sunny tbh. Over dancing isn't a plus, but it seems like a good thing when performing.
@@timorcohen4641 nah wendy definitely out danced just compare the prechorus choreo they both do and wendy’s center part. ops original ranking is right.
@@timorcohen4641 Wendy doesn't over dance that much. She's in a group where her members aren't as energetic and charismatic. Seulgi is the only one that consistently performs with the same energy and charisma as Wendy. No one said Wendy over danced when she performed with the 4th generation recently. In fact most of the comments were about Wendy for her vocals and dance. Imagine that. Stop the madness. Wendy danced better than Tae and Winter here. Wendy is much better at dancing than some of you think.
They are pretty much interchangeable….each has there strengths and weaknesses and are better than each other in different areas. Taeyeon is more experienced and has better resonance while Wendy has the better head voice and lower register. Their level of vocal technique is NOT far from each other at all.
It's debatable tbh, Wendy has better head voice and a slight edge in lower register (tho tae also has F#3 now) but Taeyeon is wayyyyy more consistent in resonance and openness in general in mixed register
Didn’t Wendy go through a surgery and learn how to sing again last year? I definitely felt that her voice and technique kinda changed since then but she’s of course still great.
you know snsd is THE girl group when their main dancer and main vocal still hold their respective title despite being re-debuted in a so-called avenger group. truly SM's main weapon
I organized the general ranking like that (based on mean scores of each member, closest to 1 is better): 1. BoA (2.5 mean score) 2. Seulgi (4 mean score) 3. Wendy (4 mean score but with medium discrepancy from her vocal and dance ranking) 4. Taeyeon (4 mean score but with high discrepancy from her vocal and dance ranking) 5. Hyoyeon (4 mean score but with high discrepancy from her vocal and dance ranking) 6. Winter (4.5 mean score) 7. Karina (5 mean score) I believe if we had a rap ranking in this video, we would have a bigger picture My rap ranking would be like that: 1. Hyoyeon 2. Karina 3. BoA (even though she's not known for being a rapper I think she does a really great job. Go listen to her rap in Happiness, is one of my favorites) 4. Wendy (she doesn't rap here, but we all know she's a BEAST) 5. Taeyeon (MY GIRL AAAAA, her rapping journey is so beautiful, in a while her rapping skills will be enough for a lead rap) 6. Winter (it's ok for a sub-rapper) 7. Seulgi (girl you're my ultimate, but just sing and dance please) Then, the general score would be: 1. BoA (2.6 mean score, the true SM ace, 4th gen kpop fans sleep on her so much) 2. Wendy (4 mean score, if only my girl could dance better) 3. Taeyeon (4.2 mean score, an icon will always be an icon) 4. Karina (4.4 mean score, with a little improvement, she could definitely be this generation ace) 5. Hyoyeon (4.6 mean score, my girl's so underrated) 6. Seulgi (4.6 mean score, dropped you from 2nd place, sorry my love) 7. Winter (4.8 mean score, people say she's aespa's all-rounder--which she is-- but I see more potential in Karina) All girls are insane all-rounders, it's so annoying. These rankings are just for fun, 5 out of 7 girls in this group are my bias, if I (or the numbers) ranked them lower it doesn't mean anything, they're still some of the best in the entire kpop industry
I really like rankings, so here are my rankings for singing and dancing: singing: 1. Wendy (I like her riffs and falsetto more than Tae's) 2. Taeyeon (I like her belting more tho) 3. Boa 4. Seulgi (I think she's more mature and has better technique than Winter) 5. Winter 6. Karina 7. Hyoyeon dancing: 1. BoA (not only the talent but she's influenced basically every female AND male kpop dancer, a lot of things we know today about kpop dance, she created. She might not be your favorite, but you can bet she's your favorite's favorite) 2. Hyoyeon (if only SM managed her better.... She's still a queeeeeen, but she had potential to be much more) 3. Seulgi (not me becoming a dancer because of her..... she's my ultimate since I was in middle school, I'm going to dance college in august and she's still the number 1 on my heart) 4. Karina (I love her technique) 5. Winter (I love her style) 6. Wendy (her improvement is huuuge from debut days) 7. Taeyeon (definitely not a bad dancer)
I think you miscalculated, because Hyoyeon would have a mean score of 3, not 4.6, including rap. I agree on the rap ranking, but I was so confused as to how an extra #1 would rank Hyo lower somehow
@@sokumachi729 I used weighted average, 2 for dance and singing (since it's considered more """necessary""" for girl groups, especially in SM groups) and 1 for rap (also because there is more singing than rapping in this song)
@@juliaaaaa1917 I see. I disagree for this specific song since there is actually a decent amount of rap (of course more singing but there's 2 rappers vs 5 vocalists). But on average, singing is more needed for gg's yeah
my personal ranking(also considering their performances in each group) vocal 1.Taeyeon/Boa/Wendy 2.Winter 3.Seulgi 4.Karina 5.Hyoyeon rap 1.Hyoyeon/Karina 2.Wendy 3.Winter/Seulgi 4.Boa/Taeyeon dance 1.Hyoyeon/Seulgi/Boa 2.Karina 3.Winter 4.Wendy 5.Taeyeon but after all, they are all beyond average!!
Seulgi, a better dancer than BoA? Mmm... I don't think so. Have you seen BoA in The Face tour? Woman? The Shadow? Only One? Better? Seulgi is good, but BoA is on another level.
In my opinion: Leader: Taeyeon Main vocalists: Taeyeon, Wendy Lead vocalist: BoA, Winter Main rapper: Hyoyeon Lead rapper: Karina Main Dancer: Hyoyeon Lead dancer: BoA, Seulgi Visual: Wendy, Winter Face of the group: Karina
@@cosmicalsims I get that, he is my second pick, but she's a soloist, yet Taeyeon is a 9 member girl group leader. And they are nearly the same age. This is why I would pick Taeyeon
Being the leader of a 9-member group doesn't mean that's her role in this group. Back then, she was the leader because she was the oldest. She's not in this group. They are around the same age, and yet BoA has been in the industry years before, and probably inspired Taeyeon to get into the industry. There wouldn't be SM without BoA. I would say Taeyeon could be the lead vocalist, but the whole group is named after a BoA song "Girls on Top". I think it's pretty clear who the leader is meant to be. In line distribution, if you look on RU-vid, BoA got the most lines and dance breaks. BoA is also the oldest, and in South Korea, particularly SM, the oldest is often times the leader. Lastly, BoA is the only one capable of helping all girls out in ALL areas, vocals, dance, rapping, performance charisma, etc, as she's done it all in one body. Whereas Taeyeon could mostly coach and help younger vocalists, but not so much dancers and rappers, as she's never had to fill those shoes for 2hr sets.
Idc these people in the comment section throwing "opinion" and change the position on this video cause of their fave💀. Overall the position of GOT based on this video is really accurate.
idk but this is just my opinion, i felt like i have to rank Wendy higher than Winter on dancing. i know Wendy got this 'energetic' image but she has improved a lot, she can control her moves now and is very precise. what also makes her better is that she always give her 100% and she is always committed even when she's just doing a dance challenge or what.
As much as I would love for BoA to be there, I've got to admit that Taeyeon and Hyoyeon are masters at their craft. BoA is still a well-rounded performer, though.
I totally agree ! Hyoyeon is really the best dancer, I was expecting more from boa because I've never seen her dance with hyo before but we understand why they say hyoyeon should always dance with boys . Also Boa's bridge was just BRILLIANT, I can definitely feel her vibe in the song ( especially in the part when winter starts singing, the ohhhhh) Taeyeon is ofcouuurse the ace vocalist no one can deny that and i have no comment. Wendy's ( he's sick and tired before the bridge) was something only she can master. Seulgi is so beautiful i can't stop looking at her Karina being an ae here too The group is perfect please make them official
the dance and vocal ranking is almost mirrored. which shows that no one can excel in everything individually, but together they can become a fine unit.
I think aside from maybe karina and BOA, they all have a noticeable lack of technique in something. Who cares tho, these women are some of the best idols in the industry
@@NoctLightCloud well I feel like all tho seulgi is a better vocalist and dancer , the gap is not that big. And aside from that , karina is an amazing rapper. I mean honestly , if u gave me Giselle and karina and asked me who was the main rapper , I would not be able to give u an answer cuz in my opinion they’re both really solid. So seulgi and karina have both amazing dance skills with seulgi being slightly better. They both have great vocals as well, seulgi again is a bit better but honestly the gap is small( a bit bigger than their dancing skills but still , seulgi can like support one note higher than karina I think but that’s about it) And while I’m sure seulgi could hold a rapping part just fine on her own. Karina has a distinct sound , tone and flow when rapping which is why I think she’s an ace
@@slehbencheikh2950 I see! I always had the image of Seulgi being significantly better at singing than Karina. Maybe I need to check out Karina's singing more. Her voice definitely can't shine in aespa's songs so far (except for Dreams Come True), that's for sure.
@@NoctLightCloud me too actually! Both karina and Giselle i always saw as like u know just ur average sub vocalist like yeri and Irene but not at all! i saw some clips of her in where I thinks she was in school ? and she had this beautiful jazzy type thing going on in her voice , she was so vibrant. just think her part in savage( I’m a savage OOOooWOooOO) but like all the time, like that kind of tone. I live for her voice.
i'll make some changes n the possible positions. imo Boa - main dancer, lead vocalist Taeyeon - leader, main vocalist Hyo - main dancer, main rapper Seulgi - Lead dancer, lead vocalist Wendy - main vocalist Karina - Main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist Winter - lead vocalist, dancer
@@aing9329 Karina is the main rapper. Hyo doesn’t have good flow and good tone to be a rapper. Karina has more rap parts than Hyo in the song for reasons.
Taeyeon, the leader? Nah, bruh. BoA is pretty much set up to be the leader. The whole name of the girl group is after her song "Girls on Top", she has more lines in the line distribution (which you can see in many videos about it), and the oldest is usually always the leader in SM.
@@GenerationNextNextNext just because the group is named after her song and because she has the most lines doesn't mean she'll be the leader? Taeyeon has 15 years of experience as a leader, she fits perfectly for the role. Oh and Taeyong and suho beg to differ :)
To be honest if you look closely at the ranges there aren't much difference to start with . These are my personal rankings based on what I SAW, I will not include rap since hyoyeon and Karina already dominated that field. Vocal: 1. Taeyeon- Has the widest range 1.2. Wendy- Impeccable lungs plus almost close to the range of taeyeon 1.3 BoA- She was a legend for having both a wide vocal range and dance at the same time, LIVE. 2. Seulgi- Can easily belt and hit those high notes. A main vocal material unique to this generation. 2.1. Winter- in a young age she can already be a main Vocalist if she want to. she is one of the aces of 4th gen. 3. Karina- She may have one of the shortest range in this group but I can tell you she is already a powerful lead vocal material. 4. Hyoyeon- She has a unique voice but her support is unknown. DANCING- 1. Hyoyeon- Her dancing style is something I cant EXPLAIN. It is sharp but it is also smooth. Her confidence is literally to the NEXT LEVEL when she is dancing. She has this vibe that makes the audience want to dance but is afraid at the same TIME. She can make 2 opposite poles collide. 2. BoA - The legend herself, she has this fierce, sharp and smooth transitions between her moves. The moves she create and the aura she created is almost unbeatable. 3. Karina- She has this teen pop and bubbly style but in the performance you can see how she is literally the bubble with fire inside. Her moves are precise and bouncy. 3.1 Seulgi- She is a chameleon when it comes to dancing, she can adapt and improve on all dancing styles there is. 4. Winter- "Inner pop" this is her style from what I have seen from their debut until now. If you watch closely her moves are satisfying but also LACKING. If she released that "pop" she can improve fast. 5. WENDY/Taeyeon- They both lack is precision and they tend to have this vibe that they want to improve, which is GOOD. Their style are completely the same. Edit: For those wondering why I chose to put Karina over seulgi. It is because of their video dancing Together and many other videos like dance performances of both of their groups, music shows and many more. In the video they were both dancing GOT 'Step Back' and I noticed that seulgi go all the angles correct, all in all it was precise. When you look at Karina, it is the same but I see and feel it is more alive, she have this attention to detail. I am not saying seulgi does not have attention to details but it is sometimes lacking. I am not bashing seulgi or karina, I am a multi-Stan that stans over 15 GROUPS that includes Red Velvet and aespa. But if we are talking about who is the better performer I can say it is seulgi.
I would put Seulgi above Karina in dance, but other than that, I agree. Also range isn't everything. There are still things such as vocal agility that a singer has to master imo. It is not all about being able to hit high notes...
I found Seulgi to be the stronger dancer than Karina... Hmm, maybe just perception? Or maybe just her magnetic stage presence hypnotizing me. I don't know.
@@Areana17 i think he/she is refering to the supported range, but even so, compared to the others, who except Hyoyeon and Boa all belted F5, she has with an E5 one of the shortest range IN THIS GROUP. That's what the original commentor wrote. It was never said that Karina's range is generally small, just that it's one of the smallest in this group, which isn't really difficult with Wendy and Taeyeon in the same group.
Maybe Winter could be better overall than BoA, but in this song, BoA showed more control with her lower notes than Winter did with her high notes. Winter's notes in this song came out a bit screechy. She seemed nervous.
@@GenerationNextNextNext oh yea i can definitely see what you mean. i was judging the vocals overall, as winter demonstrates strong vocals in aespa. and boa's vocals are amazing too
The only thing I’m surprised by is that Winter’s ranked higher than Seulgi when it comes to vocals. But I’m no expert when it comes to technique, supported range, etc. So, I’m definitely not questioning it and think that it’s awesome that Aespa’s living up to SME’s reputation for debuting vocally capable groups!
BoA said in the all-rounder hahaha jk, honestly all of them at great at both, but when you have the best dancers and vocalist one will be better in certain trait. In this case is not a rank of who's worsy but who's better.
I don't think they highlighted her dancing as much as they could have. Hopefully, the next comeback, her dancing is shown more. I hope all of them end up at #1 with everything!
I think Wendy must be put higher than Winter in Dancing here. Winter is a lead dancer but ngl her performance here and in live is a bit underwhelming and off unlike Wendy's stage presence. Still, winter is an ace and nobody can deny that.
Seulgi main dancer she dance with taeyon SM only gives these moves to the main dancer and seulgi and boa were close to the center, so they can dance because they are the pillar
imo: i won’t put visual or the extra stuff for them. boa - lead vocal , main dancer. taeyeon - leader , main vocal. hyoyeon - main rapper , main dancer. seulgi - lead vocal , main dancer. wendy - main vocal. karina - lead rapper , lead dancer. winter - lead vocal , lead dancer , maknae. idk why but winter’s dance skills weren’t shown off as much as when she’s with aespa but i think she still has enough stability to be lead dancer imo.
I think it's pretty obvious BoA is being set up to be the leader. She got the most in the line distribution and the whole group is named after her song. She's also the oldest, which in SM Entertainment means "leader". In most of their groups, the leader is always the oldest.
@@GenerationNextNextNext leader isn’t always the oldest just most of the time i feel like taeyeon seems more like the leader type and BoA was never in a gg so i don’t think she would act the part so i feel like taeyeon is more leader type than BoA.
