For commentators. I looked at other "rankings". I will explain what you see here. 🔻 This person does not have a musical education like I do, and has never moved in these circles. It like he are kid in his 12. 🔻 He probably have some western shit like example, who are literally on the same level as they are. But impression what it have on him & screaming disgusting voice whatbhave dhat person - are just good on his opinion.) 🔻 For example Wendy must be on 1 (first) step & Seulgi with all my love to her, to ny favorite & beautiful woman - on one 2 step lover.)
Sorry, but no constructive criticism here.) I usually never praise anyone, and I even lower it to a lower level, so that the person who hates me should try better.) But this ranking does not make sense.)
@@PureHoneyBoo literally there are, most of aespa’s bside are also hard to sing, in their first album aenergy, I’ll make you cry, yeppi yeppi are difficult, in girls illusion is difficult, in my world salty and sweet
Not a fan of red velvet and I'm not that expert when it comes to vocal range but I also noticed that about each members. I think you put fair. To me wendy seems perfectionist, like how much gain weight to look healthy, dancing is very detailed (the expression is perfect, no cringe/lipbite, etc.) She can easily adjust, if the music is fun, her expression will become naturally sunshine energic vibe, if it's more serious, she will give the spicy expression that perfectly fit to the music, that makes her alluring and seductive. The very first time I saw her dance in psycho, eventho I watched it because of Irene, but she caught my attention, with her precise skills, she stretch her arms unlike other dancers who seem force to dance. She seem to enjoy dancing. Irene most of the time can be bland in some videos. While Wendy is very flexible. Similar to Fifty fifty Saena, they are very similar. And as for the vocal range, she had this ideal wide range, again she's very perfectionist and will focus on details. Her high note is beautiful especially in psycho, I also heard one of her video (I forgot what song, disney song I guess), she can sing deeply too. This video helps me correct myself when it comes to singing also.
honestly in my opinion think seulgi's ranking should not be such a far gap away from wendy's. seulgi definitely doesn't have that weak of a voice generally, and her vibrato is considerably stable (albeit not the most stable) and not forced (such as visible vibration of the jaw or similar actions), as well as the transitions being quite strong. she's quite versatile in most registers, (as shown in the clip). one of the things she's quite good at is vowel usage (such as opening O sounds in A to make it sound more open). yes, i definitely agree that nasalty is still present, as well as straining for notes above A4 or Bb4, and she is slightly more versatile and comfortable in lower registers (while being a soprano???). however, most critics purely mention ranges as for the higher, but being able to support stable notes with decent projection and tonality (down to even G3) is another part. her mix is a developed chesty mix, although lacking in tongue placement and projection.
@@Abbieh07CBkys, your fav can barely support Bb4, meanwhile, male K-pop vocalists also can go up to Bb4. And they’re MALES meaning they have a lower voice and already at a disadvantage as compared to Jihyo. Kim Sohyang >
This is actually so biased lol you didnt even judge joy based on her high note lol just based on hello. But when its wendy and seulgi you used their high note. Funny.
