Grading 4 Big Free Agent Signings One Year Later 

😅😅

Really? Made sense to me. I knew Jimmy wasn't as great as we wanted but I thought he was good enough to be a good option for the Raiders.

Facts, had me straight dumbfounded.

Everyone knew it was a terrible signing

Niner fan as well. I think Jimmy has been catching so many strays since Purdys accession. Jimmy was having his best season last year before going down. I’m not surprised a team saw that and hoped it would continue. Jimmy is not a great QB. But he’s also not terrible. He’s probably the most avg QB in the league

There is a lot of content coming out soon and a lot of the videos will discuss exactly this

Should do the Rams and Bucs at least. Going back and looking at all the predictions from before the season and NO ONE had these teams doing anything. I have seen quite a few that had Houston in 2nd place though not with a winning record. But almost all had the Bucs and Rams with double digit losses.

@@WillMunyI had a strong feeling my boy baker was gonna do real work w a full year w a team

Seahawks: Sack Head Coach, Draft a new QB. Saved you a video

I agree. McGlinchy was OK in SF because of the speed of Shanahan's offense. Quick, short drops by the QB and the ball constantly out of his hand quickly. Russell Wilson is the polar opposite of the type of QB that McGlinchy needs to be successful.

he did good in the run with SF but man on drop backs youd always be watching his side

There's a whole lowlight tape of every 49er QB getting hurt because of McGlinchey getting beat 😅 calling him "ok" is a massive compliment

1000% screwed themselves out of wildcard 😅

Thanks to dimb moves of Josh McDaniels

But that's the problem with carr he can lead you to a playoff appearance and nothing more I don't blame the raiders for wanting more carr was around for 9 years how many more years of mediocrity and hoping for a wild card must you have at some point you have to want more. The ultimate goal is a Lombardi trophy not hoping for a wild card every year. The raiders may have not been the best organization the car had 9 years to prove if he could be the guy do you suggest they stick with him for another 9 years and more wild card playoff appearances just to prove he's not the guy. When you play in a division with Patrick Mahomes and Justin Herbert you have to have elite quarterback play car was never going to be that even if you gave him another nine years at some point you have to want more this is what is pissing me off with my Vikings. They keep signing cousins to extension after extension because he puts up good numbers but he will never lead you to a super bowl. The raiders and Vikings are watching teams in their division ascend while they are stuck in perpetual mediocrity because they're scared to be irrelevant for two or three years and get a high draft pick to rebuild

Incredibly revisionist take lol. The Raiders were going nowhere with Carr, they went 6-11. Jimmy G was the wrong signing, but getting rid of Derek Carr made perfect sense and your comment is ridiculous

Carr stunk man and it was time to move on

I was hoping someone would catch that lol

​@@FootballAnalysis1 Salty Atlanta fan here : P

@@FootballAnalysis1you have a way of pissing us falcons fans off

@@arizonawildcat3821 his latest video is hyping ATL 💪🏻

Had a feeling that was going to happen right when they signed him

A stat-padding QB who had 9 years to prove how mid he was. By the way, this was the same guy who had Davante and Josh Jacobs and who couldn't get the ball past the 50 against, ironically, the Saints.

⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@jackbryan4676 I agree with you wholeheartedly but I still don’t understand why they have Jimmy the length of contract that they did Could’ve signed Mariota, Brissett, or even taken a flyer on someone like Darnold or Baker (worked for the Bucs)- or trading up to get their guy in the draft I’m just wondering how much influence JMD had on the decision

​@@jackbryan4676so they go out and sign a worse version of him? Lol

@@jackbryan4676 you forgot he was a 4x MVP candidate & record breaking QB & had historically the worst defenses of all time in his 9 years as a raider tho gang the only time he was an MVP candidate was with consistency at the coaching position if the raiders kept the same GM & staff after the Gruden scandal & resigning the defense improves left & right in the pass game & run game while having a top 10 offense that can throw the ball anywhere & run the ball against anyone the moves the raiders should’ve made that year was trade for Adams Keep Edwards keep Mullen keep Waller sign Chandler Jones as DE & sign Suh as DT then the raiders defense overall sits as bare minimum 14th in the NFL with a top 8 offense & top 3 special teams which then has Carr winning MVP & the raiders winning the division if not being tied with the chiefs for the division & we all would be seeing the raiders as the only true threat to the chiefs & we’d get the best of them in the playoffs because numbers wise Carr was the best QB outside of Stafford & Brady in the 4th all time wise 😂💯

Don’t pay rbs

I think they are glad you guys signed Russ to that contract

@@FootballAnalysis1 Mutually assured destruction

⁠@@FootballAnalysis1the whole division has qbs who didn’t perform up to their contract.

@@spidamitchell8311Yeah that’s crazy even Mahomes hasn’t lived up to his. Tay Tay be keeping the spotlight off it tho and his WRs are part of it

​@@BarcelonaBlitzerme and the rest of Chiefs Kingdom will cry over the two SB wins we got with Pat not playing up to the contract he signed to go with the one before he signed it.

He definitely deserves a F.. he had wayyy too much talent Over there in NO

It's funny how jimmy can be the reason the 49ers would win or lose and also be talked about as not being important and responsible for the teams success. By the way he's talked about he was the 49ers most valuable player. Player 1 plays good the team wins. Same player plays bad the team loses. Then player 1 might actually be pretty fkn valuable to the team.

Another thing I never hear anyone say is when jimmy played with the 49ers they were mid to bottom of the league in interceptions. Jimmy rarely had a short field. Enter Brock Purdy and not only is George Kittle finally healthy, which again never gets mentioned, but all of a sudden the defense is getting an interception and giving Purdy a short field in almost every single fkn game after that. You all go fkn check out the stats. Do a little research or actually try and remember what you saw if you actually fkn saw it and don't just watch highlights or simply repeat what others fkn say.

Thank you Angelo! I’m not going anywhere though lol I’ll still be around

No He is not You must be his mom or something

Okereke was already quietly good, it's just that only hardcore football fans noticed outside of Indy. They chose to keep E.J Speed instead (who's also solid). If you're gonna swing for an underrated linebacker, Indy's a good team to pick from.

I feel the same way. Our direction is frustrating

Saints fan here. Most of the problem starts at the top with Mickey Loomis. He refuses to put his ego aside and admit that he got it wrong by hiring Dennis Allen in the first place. Allen's coaching record is one of the worst in NFL history. Loomis is so insistent to prove that he can win without Sean Payton, it's pathetic. The Saints needed to tear it down and begin a rebuild the minute Brees retired. They kept kicking the can further down the road for the chance of a SB win, but the window closed in 2020. Now they are stuck with an old roster that is greatly aging, and a horrible head coach whom the players have proven they don't respect. Carr was a huge mistake, and him and DA are tied together. This year, you saw DA throw players under the bus and go out of his way to protect his mediocre QB. Next year will be more of the same. Carr's contract is a huge albatross around the team, combined with how horribly Loomis has put them in salary cap hell. I hope the bottom falls out and we fall in position to draft a QB. That's the only way going forward. Fire Loomis, fire DA, get rid of Carr and draft a QB.

@@mikemurdock7234 beautifully put. I 100% agree

@@mikemurdock7234 I agree with you 110 percent. Once I heard Mickey's comments about fan attendance I knew what his priorities were.

Start haner and rebuild

🦀+🏈

I was about to comment about his omission. He’s gotta be an A+ as he outshined the bigger splash signing of Edmunds and made the loss of Roquan Smith hurt a little less. Now if only their D was as stacked as Baltimore he would’ve gotten the recognition to be a Pro Bowler that Smith has now gotten in back to back years.

For the contract (which is insanely beneficial to the Bears) + the production that grade is an easy A+

@@FootballAnalysis1 I definitely agree

@@FootballAnalysis1when players sign those contracts it’s easier to grade them

you left out the part where Carrbage threw that pick 6 in Atlanta and that was the only TD he tossed that day..to the other team lmfao. We had 5 fgs in that game and Carrbage was O fer in the Red zone. Plus he started that bucs game where he should have sat his ass down after going all week on DNP all week. At least one other game we could have won if they started Winston. C minus is really too good of a grade. We ain't going nowhere with him, bank it

Carr is a good QB, just injury prone and not worth what they paid him.

My cousin is a die hard niners fan and he never liked Jimmy from the start. Always felt it was the system that won and he was right

@@whosaidthat84 Was a good decision for the 9ers to move on from Jimmy G. He was competent enough to run Shannies offense that he was able to win most games.

​@whosaidthat84 That's what it was to me. That whole team and system carried Jimmy G and people to thus day gave him too much credit, he's the main reason why the 49ers didn't win that Super Bowl against the Chiefs. Very mid QB that got bailed out too much by the Defense and the Weapons around him.

Kyle Shanahan’s system is to vanilla QBs who can play in structure what Pappy Shanahan’s system was to RBs.

If the 49ers system was everything then they would have fkn won each and every time Jimmy didn't play pre brock purdy era. The fact is they didnt. Kyle had more than enough chances to win without Jimmy before Purdy came along. People are dumb blind and forgetful of the facts and history.

amen brother..you nailed it..i give the signing an F minus

Pat Mahomes gotta come up off some of that money.. them giving him that damn contract is why this team sucks

@@DIRTYSOUTHSHINOBI Mahomes left money on table on his big contract so the Chiefs could sign CJ for $80 Mil, and then restructured it again this year...

@@HochgeborenKlownleft money? He got a pay raise.

My dad is a Vikings fan from Wisconsin. And yes, his favorite color is purple. I also have an uncle from the Bay Area who is a Cowboys fan.

Yes it is! Also, I was born into the Vikings fandom because my old man grew up during the heyday

Carr ain't never been in no discussions of top 10 QBs.. he had all that damn talent Round him in NO and still stunk it up... no he ain't solid he is a average QB bro

Did you watch him play the whole season?

Lmao 😂

he was known for his inability in the red zone up until the last few games when it really didn't matter. his stats are way out of sync due to Carrbage time stats when the game was already decided. He's a solid loser if that's what you mean

@@milesfromneworleans yes

swift was traded

@@EthanDephouse u right

Baker A Hopkins B Sanders F Geno C

As a Texans fan, no can do. At least Jimmy G is halfway competent when he's actually healthy. Never forget Brock Assweiler 😂😂😂

Idk man Daniel jones exists

Russ and Watson exist

@@marshallwhite3780People are to quick to forget about that horrid deal

@@xolgic9297 ☝️☝️☝️

LOL, mentor them in what? "Here's how you throw arm punts, just aim for your receiver, and throw it 10 yards past them!" ☠☠☠

All injuries aside Even when Jimmy was a healthy he was still trash bro.. He had one of the best offenses in the league on paper and was still mediocre.. yall be making excuses for these dudes when they be having All that damn talent around them.. he thrown 14 fucking PICKS h

@@DIRTYSOUTHSHINOBI The facts do not support your opinion.

@@DIRTYSOUTHSHINOBIjimmy has had some playoff success, he’s not elite, but he’s decent.

Best offenses in the league my ass. The offensive line fkn sucked dude. Are you blind? Any QB needs decent oline play in order to have a chance to succeed. Jimmy kept fkn getting hit and pressured almost every single drop back. Unless your Llamar or someone like that back there any QB was gonna struggle. Yea sure maybe not as bad but to put all the blame on Jimmy is bullshit.

This is just a crazy opinion, frankly. I don't see how you can look at 2022 Carr and 2023 Jimmy and think Jimmy comes away looking anything other than an overpaid backup. Carr was a pretty decent QB. Jimmy, well, isn't. He's basically a mid level backup QB that got way too much good press.

Good for him

Agreed, and I’ll add to that that Pete Carmichael is literally the worst offensive coordinator ever. Derek Carr isn’t so dissimilar to Stat Padford that putting him in a more modern McVay system wouldn’t yield similar results.

He's referring to NOLA media who hyped up Carr as a "massive upgrade". All summer, the local media talked about this being a SB team. The delusional homers ate it all up and were yelling at us when we tried to push back on that narrative.

roster not bad? We have one guy make the pro bowl, Shaheed...where's all the great players on this not bad roster?

he was saying that last year we should have started the rebuild cuz what have we accomplished this year other than miss the playoffs and still not get a good draft pick. You think we still have a playoff shot next year with a tougher schedule? is this Loomis' burner account. The purgatory of this franchise just got prolonged by the signing of a mediocre QB. When we go 5 and 12 next year you want to rebuild then? or say we still got talent. We need to a complete rebuild if we're going to succeed in the future

Jimmy started off solid

I agree we should’ve never hired him. We should’ve fired him last year after we loss to the Colts. But saying we shouldn’t have fired him in the middle of this season just to get a top pick is dumb

@@SteelKreel I mean I basically say that because rn they are stuck in the middle without any real shot at a really good QB. They pick at 13 and there are about 7 teams who should at least consider drafting a QB. With O’Connel or jimmy the won’t do much better than they did this season.

that's the problem he was playing hurt and when he played hurt he was a liabiltiy to the team. He only thinks of himself and afraid he's lose his starting job like Winston did last year if he missed time lmfao. I don't have to wait til next year he's just Carrbage and will always be Carrbage

Huge miss letting Jakobi go for JuJu

JuJu needs to go back to KC.

@@twoface9959 he needs to retire

C-

Gotta be a C -

C. I think everyone knew Odell wasn't who he previously was, but that didn't mean it was a bad pickup. He's a good secondary option and the team doesn't need him long term, they just needed a year or two of solid production to get to where they were going.

B because production hasnt been there but the effect he has had on Zay Flowers has been noticable, his signing also was a requirement to keep Lamar happy, any signing that keeps the MVP on your team is worth it

As a Ravens fan, I'd give a B- because we knew he wouldnt likely have another 1000 yd season but with just the moments he often showed up this season while being a mature veteran who brought Flowers, Bateman, etc along. Also Lamar wanted a veteran wr even before either of their signings. His price tag would be the only reason it's not a A grade but he's healthy and ready while the season hasn't ended yet!!

Jon Gruden 2024

not a trade, he was a FA. Read the title of the damned video. That grade is too generous tbh. The fact that he was injured and still played is an indictment on him and Allen. They both suck. The fact that they're even considering bringing Gruden to NOLA is a sign of desperation just like the Carr FA signing was. Luckily DeShawan Watson turned down Loomis' desperate offer or that'd be even 100 times worse. they paid him 100 million for what? so we miss the playoffs again..total rubbish

@@mythrapi73 it’s not even that much and it’s not 100 million a year it’s a 4 year deal he gets 30mil and he should get paid more than kamara or taysom he’s the ONLY quarterback that has accuracy on the saints you can complain but there’s a reason your not an owner or even a football coach for llfb