all rights to mnet and respective artists comment what u wanna see! lmk ur opinions! no hate intended towards ANY trainees and others opinions! these are just opinions :heart: Girls Planet 999 ガールズプラネット999 少女星球999
Hey all! Love the feedback. A couple of ppl reminded me i forgot the twinkle girls OMG. I DIDNT EVEN REALIZE THEY WERE NOT HERE. I MADE A GRADING AND EVERYTHING FOR THEM 😭😭😭 I gave YaLe a D and the others F but I don’t completely agree with my own rating
Also since no one mentioned it can we also appreciate the C and J trainees because they're legit singing a foreign language song that they might not truly understand and could affect their performance. That's amazing.
@@cloudchillx1552 oh yeah definitely, they also did so that one or two members outshine the others like they did for xiao ting and yurina, they gave them killing part and parts that suit them while for the others parts out of their range... I remember the twins saying that they wanted to show their dance skills better but mnet gave a cute and high pitched song
I agree with 90% of this list, few changes I would make is: Give chaehyun a B instead of C cause it was just one mistake and she still did very well for the rest of the performance And cho haeun an F, her vocals were pretty unstable and she definitely needs more training so I wouldn’t place her above bahiyyih and hyewon And most of these girls also didn’t do that well in the demo stage because mnet didn’t choose the right songs for them, I wish they got to choose their own songs to perform, xia yan absolutely slayed in HYLT and did so much better than violeta, xingqiao was done kinda dirty too, it’s obvious that her vocal range is not fit for doing a song like rumor
-Chaehyun got a C mostly because her performance was a bit underwhelming considering her training and her dance was off (the highnote was unoticeable to i kind of discounted it but since it was a big deal on the show - i factored it in) -Haeun: now that everyone's commenting, i'm kinda rethinking her grade -SAME. I wish they got to choose their songs :( They would shine more and obv do better.
Most of those song choices were terrible, I was wondering if Mnet chose the songs and groups because it seemed so weird that they would all choose mostly popular newer songs that is WAYYY out of their vocal range. Like you would usually find out what each member of your group can do and then pick a song that would complement everyone's abilities. (I will say that I thought it was possible that they chose the songs themselves, as a lot of the choices seemed like what kpop fans would pick if given the choice, but there was also something very off about the different choices.)
right, the judges were too stingy when they didn't give dayeon and yeyoung top9 sticker. it just annoys me and now yeyoung, who was a K02, got eliminated
@@starrbitz1229 I'm devastated bro, she was my no.1 pick, didn't really care if anyone else got eliminated as long as she got a chance for people to see her talent
@@smolpeepee245 idk like I quite believe most of trainees and idols just already get treatment like this, and lead them to anxious or other mental problem.
@@oceanhoon Not to mention they literally tried to get rid of C group's best vocalists by making them perform Twinkle. They didn't even get a close-up of Shiqi for her highnote in Pretty U
Yeah, and sadly this a tactic that is also used in talent shows like American Idol, the voice and X factor. The people don't even get to pic the audition song that we see on TV. It's sad and very unfair to the artists. But it seems like it's a common thing in music competitions. That's why we end up with so many bad performances with good singers.
I think this is more like Produce 48 standard as I can see you give Caibing an A. Just imagine if you’re judging as BoA like season 2 Produce 101 or even as a Bae Yoon Jeong. The ‘A’ trainees would be most likely to be dropped less than 10 especially if judging as BoA, as the standard is like 75% skill and the rest is personality and aura.
you’re spot on! there were sm factors to consider and esp with pd48 there was a huge focus on star ability but also since she got a top 9 i was like caibing is def an A. Also, they treat boys + girls a bit differently but even then, smo like cai bing is best a C in skills but the other factors gave her an A.
Bro what mistake? I just rewatch it and she was good? Is this mnet evil editing influencing y'all again.. like i just watched the clips and her aura was outta this world
pd101 s1 theme song is very simple and easy..there is no highnote and the dance is very easy to learn unlike pd48 theme song..the song is hard to sing while dancing because of the highnote and the choreography is more hard and so detailed + the japanese trainee need to sing the song in korean and some of them can't memorize the lyrics well
@@kamillesimsuangco6114 Her singing was good, but dancing a bit off and facials were stiff. Her singing is good but I think since she’s young she could use improvement
well, the reason why some did so good is because the producers choose the song, that's why some of them shined more than other's (like Xiaoting in Rumor or Yurina in fancy) and this is absolutely NOT hating towards them.
@@cantputashrugasausernameso5105 I literally thought that songs from demo stages were all picked by the trainees themselves. That's why I was wondering why some chose songs not suited for them or songs that were out if their comfort. Now I see its Msnake trying to make some of them look bad
@@KPOPTrashLyrics Yeah, gotta agree with this, they all looked dead tbh, if they got better facial expressions this perf of them wouldve exploded im telling u
Yeyoung received a high praised by the masters just to get eliminated makes it more painful 😣. I really thought she's at least gonna survive with the planet pass.
I'm glad that you're honest about Yaning's grade in here. It this was another yputuber, they would be biased and gave her a F- just coz she DISSED(?) Yujin.
@@masakazuhiruko550 She's always had a good attitude too. If you look at her in Youth With You, a Chinese idol producer show, she's a sweet and silly girl. YWY doesn't evil edit btw. Plus, I think even Mnet knew they fucked up, which is why more recent episodes show her true personality more. Also, it's kind of publicly known that she is evil edited now.
4:59 this performance was honestly amazing, i wished to see them debut, but now since Yeyoung is eliminated that cannot happen, please vote for Kim Suyeon and Kim Dayeon, they're really talented, Kim Suyeon really needs the votes rn
A bit of these are questionable. Nagomi and Mashiro deserve A. Their whole performance can be considered a perfect one. Hyewon and Bahiyyih definitely above Haeun as they were the only stable ones in their group
Imo Mashiro and Nagomi's performance is better than Yurina's so I think they would also get an A. And if it's like produce the theme song evaluation would be the next part and probably the K,C,J01-05 would be the A ranks.
My changes: Dumdi Dumdi; both in A. I feel like P101 valued "flawless performances" over "performances that are super highly impressive in one way but maybe had a few flaws" if that makes sense. So I could see them both getting A because 0 mistakes were made and they both danced/sung damn well the whole time. Black: at least B. Soloists are valued a lot in both shows and despite shaky vocals, I can see it being excused because of the shock of "Wow, she's doing a BoA song solo and actually did pretty well?" Paradise Lost: at least B. Similar point to Moana with Black; the coaches are aware how hard Paradise Lost is to perform solo, so the shock of that would offset some slightly shaky vocals. Maria: both C. Feels like a lot of the P101 coaches would have a problem with the vocals here (the technique is just outright wrong, they're trying to mimic the vocals of Hwasa and Wheein which means they have a ton of tension that I think would be commented on. Their dance was also out of sync at some parts, but got better as it went on). Siren: probably C. I love Ziyin SO much but Produce really highlights screwed up high notes, and she was off key a few times unfortunately. She's way more talented than she showcased here, so I think they'd give a C. Violeta: I don't see them all getting Fs at all. It wasn't a bad performance, just mediocre and boring (typically Ds with a few C ranks in P101). Crazy: Sein would probably get an A for pulling off the high note decently. If a participant does ONE thing notably well, they usually get a boosted rank. Helicopter: Cai Bing maybe moved lower with the P101 coaches as opposed to the GP999 ones. If we're being honest, she didn't sing or rap, her dancing was just okay and the GP999 coaches are a lot more focused on the whole "aura" thing. In a Produce show I think she would get a lower rank. Probably B, maybe even C. Maybe a hot take and don't take this as me hating her or "falling victim to evil editing" but Cai Bing is mostly a pretty face with pretty lacking skills. Her dancing is, again, just okay; rather stiff with weird placements and inconsistent timing. And we haven't heard her sing or rap. I dunno. She COULD be one of those participants that get an A but immediately move down to C/D because of their skills being showcased. I think Chang Ching could potentially get higher because her vocals were actually decent here but not at all noticed by the GP999 coaches. Not super likely though.
I agree with pretty much all of this, especially the cai bing point (no hate to her) but some of her dancing is sometimes too fast, too slow or the top of her body is disjointed from the bottom half
@@liquorice8449 oh yes, those vocal goodness in pd101 s1 were truly amazing. But the way I see it, the the vocal in gp are also no joke 🤣 There are many all rounded trainees too in gp
What I wanna know is if Mnet chose all the songs or if certain groups were allowed to choose their own... there's certain performances like Bounce Back that seem WAY better than the others because the song choice is better
I think she should've chosen a song that showed her vocals better. She had trouble singing some parts because of the choreography. She's definitely not a C but the performance she gave there was a C.
Not me only realizing now that Lim Chenhan performed Roly Poly in the demo stage. Gosh I literally hyped her SO MUCH in Mic Drop but never cross my mind that she is the same person with the girl who caught my attention doing Cheon Seojin's imitation in the first episode.
You can’t look me in the eye and say chaeyun (who was laughing multiple times during her performance and had un mstabke energy) did better than Sakurai Miu who carried her performance
hey, no need to bring other trainees down just bc of thIS persons opinion. although she was laughing, for a very good reason might i add, she didnt lose focus.
finaly someone appreciate jeong jiyoon's talent. like she was self-trained and still ate up bounce back performance. it's not only her vocals are on point, she was killing the dance too
@@hiyyih_lea The judges really enjoyed their performance and the circumstances were diff for other contestants. I feel if I was being tough and went along w the narrative the judges created that “oh u guys r good and top 9 worthy but we wanted more” then they would’ve gotten a B but i didn’t feel right doing that (but yeah A/B wouldve been their grade)
⚠️⚠️⚠️ Vote for talented, charming cutie SEO YOUNGEUN! Are you really gonna let such a gem get eliminated? Are we really gonna fail her too after we failed Jia!? Youngeun is a great singer, dancer and rapper she's also such a freaking adorable and lovable crackhead who deserves all the love in the world! VOTE HARDER for SEO YOUNGEUN!
@@Sanas_Shy_Language this is true^ at least she got to showcase more of her rap skills in uml :] but yes i was rly upset that reina didnt make it , i think both of them deserved to …
I think Okazaki Momoko from the 1000% performance atleast deserve a D grade. I mean if you listen close enough she's the only stable one in their group, and her dance is also clean. Wen Zhe atleast deserve a C. Seungeun deserves a B, i mean she got all what it takes, her vocals only shakes a bit but her performance is really good. Nagomi and Mashiro deserves an A, their performance is really stable so i think they deserve to be in A Edit: Xingqiao i think needs to be in F, her vocals is very unstable the whole performance so as her dance. Cai Bing, if only she's not a top 9 member, would atleast deserve a C. She's off beat a few times and looks kinda stiff.
Okazaki Momoko was my pick and she is a C in this presentation but if mnet wouldn't chose the song, she had could an A or a B. She is a full package, is so sad that she didn't make it
(I'll just talk about the ones I disagree) MY OPINION: [K] Kim Chaehyun - B [J] Sakamoto Mashiro - A [J] Nagai Manami - C [J] Kanno Miyu - D [J] Ikema Ruan - C [K] Huening Bahiyyih - C [K] Sin Seungeun - B [C] Gu Yizhou - D [K] Suh Jimin - D [J] Nakamura Kyara - F [C] Xu Ziyin - A [C] Zhang Luo Fei - C [C] Liang Qiao - D [C] Chiayi - A
remember, they said they'd also be taking into account the "star quality." although dumdi dumdi team did better in the technical aspect, both yurina and cai bing had exceeding auras and charisma. as absurd as this sounds, this was how it worked for produce101-for example, sakura miyawaki getting an A despite her decent performance. she just had that star quality and charm that was taken into consideration by the judges-and this youtuber did exactly that because that's the whole premise of this video in the first place. :)
I agree with most of your grades. I love the Ando Rinka appreciation, though I think she should be B grade imo. Also, I personally think Liu Shiqi's vocals were actually good. I would give her a C. And like what some people have said, Hyewon was the best in Mr Chu and I agree. I understand your opinion about her facials tho.
The A-F grading might varies depends on the judges/mentors. I think gp999 mentors cares a lot about 'aura/charisma' rather than skills where as pd101/pd48 strictly judging you based on skills alone (they values skills a lot rather than aura, maybe it was more like 90% skills and 10% aura). If these girls were judged by pd101/pd48 mentors such as Bae Yoonjung, Cheetah, Kahi, Soyou, Hongki, JeA maybe only 10 of them or less would get an A. Since we know that gp999 basically season 5 of produce, I wish they went with the classic A-F grading instead separating them with top9 candidate/not, because the A-F grading sets the consistency for comparison even though it's not a determine factor for debuting. The criteria for top9 candidate were vague and sometimes I can't understand the mentors decision, like leaving Kim Dayeon & Choi Yeyoung out from top9 candidate when imo both of them are better than some of the top9 candidate. And on the later episode the mentor told Dayeon that they kept her out of top9 on purpose because she will made it eventually, like??????? Overall, the trainees in this season are more talented than previous produce series but a lot of them can't fully show their potential esp the foreigner trainees since they have to sing in korean so a lot of them are getting eliminated too soon.
Someone watching this much later after the finals, I realize how much potential there is in these groups of girls. Especially seeing how not all the finalists would’ve started so high
I'm kind of annoyed with the Cai Bing slander. After her being mistranslated, everyone suddenly began discrediting literally everything that she has done and calling her just a pretty face. In that performance, she did have really good stage presence, and her vocal tone stood out a lot in contrast to the vocalists in the performance (Fu Yaning was also great). Cai Bing does struggle with consistency and rhythm, but she has very pretty dance lines that make her alluring, and there are times when her dance is actually really good technique-wise too. It's just that it fluctuates. Also, I think she does have a unique charisma that isn't easily found. What makes some idol groups more popular than others is not necessarily technique, as most idols have good technique, but some unique elements that make the members charismatic and stand out. To me, Cai Bing has that.
@@hernandeshwang1090 Yeah, I've seen that. It wasn't a biggie, and I literally just wrote why I like her in that long comment, so read it before you say that I only like her cat eyes or whatever.
Honestly im tired of ppl saying pretty privilege like isn't that realistically the most important thing for an idol to be pretty? Besides i understand all the comments saying she doesn't have rhythm etc. but they dont even judge the others that harshly so its really not fair even if they were right
And to everyone saying it wasn't evil edit because the reaction of the group members were really bad, HAVE YOU EVER HEARD OF SCRIPTS? Its literally a show you do realise the staff can tell her to say something to create drama right? Yall have so much trust towards reality shows i cant
My changes would be, Fancy; Kishida Ririka would get a D at most. Her singing was far from okay. She could have maybe been a C if she showed slightly better stage presence because the high note wasn't exactly a fail. Murakami Yume might have been C. Her dance skills are easily the best out of the group, not to mention she had pretty good stage presence. Her singing was almost on par with Kishida Ririka, so it could be a C but I'm not sure. Kitajima Yuna would get a D, not an F. Black Mamba; An Jeongmin would definetly get an A, her vocals were pretty good. She didn't have any mistakes either. Lee Yunji would easily get a B, maybe even an A. She easily showed the best stage presence out of the 3. She has idol-like facial expressions and she easily manages to catch the camera during the performance. Her vocals weren't bad either. Kim Chaehyun would get a B, not a C. She screwed up the high note and then lost concentration but she had really good vocals for the remaining parts of the song. Not to mention she sang like %80 of the song herself. Dumdi Dumdi; A for both of them. They managed to remain stable all throughout the song despite the restless choreography. Black / Paradise Lost; B for both. Hug U; Sakurai Miu would have been a B. Boombayah; Kamikura Rei might have been an A. Mr. Chu; Don't tell me you placed Haeun higher than Lee Hyewon and Bahiyyih. Haeun would have been an F, no doubt. Wow Thing; What in the world? Lee Sunwoo would obviously get an A. Whatta Man; Jiwon might have been an A, but not too sure. Violeta; Yang Zige would have easily been higher than a D. She would probably get a C. Same applies for Zhou Xinyu and Zhang Loufei. Crazy; Lee Chaeyun would have been a C. She literally laughed during the performance. Sein might have been an A, but not too sure. Helicopter; Cai Bing would be a B at most, maybe even a C. Chia Yi might have been an A. There is no way Chang Ching would have been a D, I think she would have been a B. I Can't Stop Me; C for Joung Min, D for Han Dana. Joung Min had really good stage presence.
I'm going to pass the defense list to Yaning in case something, so they don't start hating her. Well the case of my Yaning is complicated, I'm going to talk to see if I remove the blindfold from the haters. 1. She is forced to act like this, even one of the girls who has already left the show said that she got along very well with Yaning and said that it helped her to dance, sing and rap better and that she was one of the best partners. , Liang Qiao Also when she exposed Mnet she said that the Yujin and Yaning scene was forced, and that Yaning gets along very well with all the girls on the show. 2. For what she said about yujin she apologized, but that was a montage to attract more people to the program, which was confirmed by liang Jiao when she left the program, and if she says so, it is because she was there and so lived herself in person, (and in fact that explains why it was one of the only things that happened in the advance of the first chapter just for people to be interested in knowing what happened and going to see it is only to sell) They say that she is a "spoiled woman who disrespects her elders" Yujin and Yaning only have a year difference in age (and I know that Korea, even if you are only a month apart or something, is already your elder and you have to respect it, but for me it would have been worse if he had messed with a girl of 30 or more) And also Yaning did not say it in a bad mood, because after all Yujin did the dance and everyone laughed, and they were not enemies, at all , Yujin said that Yaning was amazing, and in chapter 5 when Yaning saved with her cell between Those who congratulated them was Yujin, showing that they do not have a bad friendship, in fact quite the opposite, Yujin was happy for her. 3. For those who blame Yaning that The Eve was not a true group and that they lost due to a bad leader, let me tell you that although they say that "the rule of a leader is: every mistake is your mistake, not the others "The Eve team did very well, but they were all so good that they did not work correctly in a group, it seemed like they only focused on getting their individual skills, for that reason, because they are all very good there , and I think that Yaning could not control it, (In fact I think she had the same error). 4. What happened to Dayeon is also not Yaning's fault. I think that Dayeon does not know how to work correctly in a group, that made her want to stand out alone and take the part that she wants regardless of whether the group likes it or not, I think Dayeon was very selfish and more so when he exposed his group in front of to the jurors, another thing she did not speak to the group what she felt, she just burst into tears and did not speak, if she had spoken maybe they would have given her another part or something ... But she did not, do not blame that on Yaning . 5. For those who say that Yaning wanted to stand out and others among all, let me tell you that Yaning is one of the best leaders on the show, and she cares a lot about others and helps them and wants them to be well so stop saying what They do not know. 6. What she said about the n word let me tell you that it is a separate case and she apologized, since she did not know what the word was and said that she would find out more so as not to make mistakes in the future, she apologized more than once . 7. For those who say that "she does not deserve to be in the group", that "nobody gets along with her" "that would create a bad atmosphere", let me tell you, Yaning if she deserves to be in that group, she is very talented as well as Being one of the most beautiful trainees on the show, she gets along well with most of the show, we know it thanks to the girl who came out and said it, plus we can see how well she gets along with her cellmate Suyeon, and with the other girls. 8. For those who say that Dayeon felt bad because of her or something or that a feud was generated between the two, let me tell you that Dayeon and Yaning as with Yujin I am also very good friends, in Chapter 5 we could see how Dayeon takes Yaning to hug when she is passing by with her cell. 9. Yaning is not selfish, she is not believed nor does she want to be the center of attention, quite the opposite, also for those who say that she always wants to be the leader, look at chapter 6, there you can see that she told Mashiro that She was the leader, since Yaning believes that she is a magnificent leader, and the group of three worked quite well, the three of them even seemed super good friends, they connected and planned everything well, and did an excellent performance, not to mention that in addition they won. Also in chapter 6 they replayed the part of chapter 1 when Yaning said that to Yujin, so I go back and say they do it to gain more fame, and to attract more people to see the program. 10. To those who are bothered because it is or seems very "conceited" or "what is believed of more" let me tell you that she is only a safe girl, and it is very good that it is like that, since an insecure girl is more difficult and I say it because I know, I think it is very good that she has confidence in herself and others, since when you are very insecure you do not usually do things well, since you are always type like "I am not going to achieve it" or "it I do it wrong "," I don't like the way I do it "etc, on the other hand when you feel more security you do better since you know what you are going for and therefore you do not lose, quite the opposite, so I think that is good in her. 11. I invite you to see Youth with You, the Chinese reality show in which she participated, there you can see her true personality, you can know her well and love her, of that I am sure, I invite you to do it so that erase that bad concept towards her, and for those who have not seen it and still criticize Yaning, let me tell you that in order to criticize her you have to have seen this program and met her there, and have seen her true personality, not the false one and faked personality that they make him demonstrate in GP999. 12. Yaning is superior I am sure you will love her, please believe me, listen to me and vote for her even once, please support her a lot, I ask you, help her this may be her last chance to debut because of her age. ... Thanks to those who read that I think there were few. 💖💕🙂
Please vote for Fu Ya Ning, She is very good, pretty and talented, she deserves a place in the group, please look at her in a positive light and read the full 12 points, thank you #Supportyaning 💕
@@tzuyuchou4292 I see you support Miu 🙂💕 .. She is an excellent vocal, it seemed to me from Hug U that she deserved to be among the most recognized, she seemed very visual and I think she is very talented, and that's not to mention how well she showed herself in the next two missions ... I'm very sorry That they have eliminated her, I honestly think that she should have reached much higher, but we hope to see her debut soon even if it is in another group, she deserves it 💕🙂
Su Rui Qi always does everything well. She sings well, dances well, raps well, has a very kind personality, she was voted the most popular by other trainees. If you see me commenting heavily on Rui Qi, I'm sorry if you're offended by it, but I can't bear to watch this amazing girl get rid of by the bad guys. I believe that there are still a lot of smart and kind people, they will be very fair to talented and hardworking people. Su Rui Qi always works hard and strives with her passion. She deserves to debut. It's sad that so many people want to trample on her dreams. I believe if you are a smart and fair person, Su Rui Qi deserves your vote! Bad things always exist, and good things always exist, it is we who will be the guardians of Rui Qi's dream. Vote for our girl, you will never be disappointed by that decision!
How could Seungeun got a C 😂 she's very stable while dancing laying here and there. The song is hard too and she's doing very well. I'd put her at least in B, but she deserves A.
@@MsEAVaxx her singing is very stable though, the song is originally like that. how do you expect people who lay down then getting up to sing? 😂 I recommend you to watch the full version. The master and knetz actually praises her for her performance, she even choreographed the whole thing by herself.
@@MsEAVaxx "for some" while the masters actually highly praised her for her stability on stage. people who barely know things just made up things to blame on her.
Anyone saying that seungeun's a bad singer should go watch any bvndit MV That particular song's melody didn't compliment her voice making people misunderstand that she was out of tune when she wasnt her vocals dance and stage presence is no joke she was definitely not a contestant that deserved the first round elimination
Really appreciated you giving Ayana an A. She received hate from many people because they thought she didn't deserve the initial top9 and tbh she deserved a lot better on this show overall
i think u can use the single ooo fancam to evaluate their class change whether uprgraded or downgraded, but i bet is not going to be accurate since we dont get to hear their ooo vocals tho
i was late seeing this. hopefully if they ever do a 2nd season of girls planet, they would use this grading system. this really help which trainee/contestants to look out for based on individual grade plus expectation of growth from low rank ones.
im so sad half these people couldve scored so much higher if mnet let them choose their own song so they could actually pick a song that suits their voice. multiple ex contestants mentioned how they werent allowed to pick the song themselves and had to sing things that were too difficult for them or didnt fit their vocal tone :/
Personally I feel like Lee Hyewon should get a C her vocals were pretty stable and I liked the way she ended her notes but with saying that non of them really had any facial expressions. (Also I’m so sad she got eliminated I loved her)
12:19 Yaning an A-student ik that's right... My girl slayed that helicopter performance, her rap part was just amazing. And the fact that she did it live and was so stable despise her being chinese
Yaning deserves the A. Tbh i love caibing but yaning definitely carried the helicopter performance she would've been way more popular if only mnet did not evil edit her
i haven't seen any of the stages or clips from gp999 yet, but damn some of the girlies were hella rough 😭 i'm trying my hardest to be nice but i just couldn't sit through some of the girls' performances
i just feel like things would've been so different if every group got to pick their own song. why are all these shows so against just having a genuine competition and having the trainees' talents and personalities speak for themselves😭
