No video :(

Gravitas | Afghanistan exit: Soviets V/S America

Подписаться 9 млн

Просмотров 269 тыс.

50% 1

Experts say the Soviet Union's exit from Afghanistan was more orderly and professional than America's. What did the Soviets do right? How did America fail to learn from the defeat of two empires? Palki Sharma tells you.
#Gravitas #SovietUnion #Afghanistan
About Channel:
WION -The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNews...

Опубликовано:

29 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 1,3 тыс.

@black53342 3 года назад

Once a Russian commander said "How can you defeat an enemy who looks into the barrel of your gun and sees paradise."

@princemalviyaPM 3 года назад

I think by sending them to paradise... 🤔

@Deepak-gj4ni 3 года назад

Kuch nhi hona us Russia aur Islam k bich m china n sab loot lena h

@dragonlordplacidusax9413 3 года назад

nuke

@vanuCanCode 3 года назад

@@princemalviyaPM what about a kid running towards you from the crowd wearing a traditional vest.

@manishshah4220 3 года назад

@Hussain Ibn Ali Hahahahahahahah

@davidarmola6218 3 года назад

She hit it right on the head !!!! The best assessment of a failed organizational failure !!!!

@realtalk6195 3 года назад

It's a highly flawed analysis because it ignores the human cost of war. The US drawdawn as it happened is actually the best outcome possible: minimal bloodshed, no destruction of cities, even the electricity and internet works. The Soviet pullout started a new Civil War that killed tens of thousands more, millions displaced, and fractured the country between warlords. It failed to protect the Communist government but at the cost of more lives and suffering. A Civil War is what many in the West and India _wanted_ would happen, but all that does is make Afghanistan the haven for foreign fighters they keep fearmongering about. Any time a dirty war starts, foreign fighters pour in for the first decade but then get bored the next decade and pour in elsewhere.

@abcdefghijklmnopasd 3 года назад

@@realtalk6195 why would India want a civil war in Afghanistan ?

@Sunilkumar-wj3kb 3 года назад

Vietnam to Afghanistan ...lesson learnt is Zero. America spent billions of dollers, lost thousands of soldiers, but achievement made is ZERO.

@2011kok 3 года назад

what about that 20 years of Taliban free afghanisthan?

@solareclipse491 3 года назад

But American generate employment through manufacturing weapons and exporting to Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Pakistan .... Taliban got weapons from these nations.. In 20 years its loss for another nations not America's.

@briang.7206 3 года назад

Yes and now soldiers are crying....I came home and put it behind me.

@altcodex5625 3 года назад

@@2011kok what about 20 years of warzone?

@2011kok 3 года назад

@@altcodex5625 America wasn't fighting to wipe Taliban from the face of the planet.. that was never going to happen. Thier mission was to kill osama bin Laden , , give afghanisthan a fighting chance against the Taliban..then leave the country. America or UK or any allies for that matter never planned to colonize afganisthan and fight this war forever.

@wallflower1852 3 года назад

WION provides better and in-depth news compared to its Western counterparts. Kudos and love from The Philippines.

@francoislechanceux5818 3 года назад

WION also ''provides better and in-depth news compared to'' CGTN, RT and Sputnik News ?

@kapatidtomas 3 года назад

@@francoislechanceux5818 Because they are mostly owned by their authoritarian government counterparts lol, and obviously it's still even more biased than WION still. Stop saying that those are still better options, WION still is better

@kapatidtomas 3 года назад

True some facts man, They bring up the news quicker besides anything and smoother than any other Western news out there. How come is Eastern news better than Westerm frankly speaking?

@youssefcamara3916 3 года назад

@@kapatidtomas they are not. They are all opinions crap without any objectives perspectives.

@maggyfrog 3 года назад

@@youssefcamara3916 if it's hurting your feelings, you're the one who's not objective.

@abhinavpiyush3619 3 года назад

You can't blame a man of Biden's age for pulling out too early!

@ayseltoksoz5698 3 года назад

:)))))))))))))

@sunnykr9940 3 года назад

😂😂😂

@0anant0 3 года назад

and she mentioned 'pulling out at midnight'. Must have started at 11:59pm...

@arnabpersonal6729 3 года назад

Trump daddy would have performed better

@RajaSampathi7 3 года назад

😂

@MageBlackstone 3 года назад

Weren't Soviets invited by the Afghan government back then? So not quite "invaded"...

@porkysharma8423 3 года назад

True.

@grapeshot3462 3 года назад

If I remember right the Kremlin was actually very hesitant to go in there and they turned down earlier requests by the Kabul regime to do so.

@cbrtdgh4210 3 года назад

yes and they came and subsequently murdered the guy who asked for help! Literally raided and shot up his presidential palace!

@cbrtdgh4210 3 года назад

the Soviet "help" was so audacious that the Afghan president was in disbelief right up to the moment he was killed.

@grapeshot3462 3 года назад

@@cbrtdgh4210 They killed Amin because they thought he was too tyrannical and couldn't be reasoned with. His radical faction of the party had killed thousands of people within their own party, which is what Communists tend to do.

@livelikea 3 года назад

Afghanistan is not called "The graveyard of Empires" for nothing. Its been like this for centuries.

@kukulroukul4698 3 года назад

yes but FOR NOTHING

@rudratexfab2977 3 года назад

**Laughs in Mongolian **

@jackjack4168 3 года назад

Afghanistan itself is playing innocent but also terrorist

@thomasshepard6030 3 года назад

Genghis Khan was the only military force to defeat Afghanistan and the way he done it was to kill every single person they came across men women children dogs cats cows all the crops total war

@animedubbed7982 3 года назад

@@rudratexfab2977 the mongol invincibility was also broken by afghans at the battle of parwan.

@mayuri4184 3 года назад

Biden will be remembered for ever for this terrible blunder.

@megaotstoy 3 года назад

Biden has nothing to do with all this shit, just give this old fart a break, don't expect him making strong decisions while his ice cream is melting...

@Odoxis 3 года назад

Bro, not even Biden, the USA as a whole. Pathetic sovereignty if you ask me. USA has done nothing but brainwash it's citizens and further the divide within their own border. The world was idiotic as it stood by and watched the big baby USA wave it's toys around in Afghanistan just to whine and flee 20 years later.

@Islamisthecultofsin 3 года назад

This was planned. China got plenty for its billon and a half that they bought Biden with.

@Islamisthecultofsin 3 года назад

@@Odoxis We can wipe the Taliban out in no time at all.

@Odoxis 3 года назад

@@Islamisthecultofsin Trust me, I know what the world's empires are capable of, so I believe you. It's just sad to see the world stand by and allow them to continue hustling the human race.

@abhiview 3 года назад

The only empire which successfully captured and held Afghanistan in last 2 centuries was by Maharaja Ranjeet Singh of the Sikh empire.

@drone2u 3 года назад

Yes surprisingly many pushtoon Sikhs. .😯

@user-vb3br4xu2v 3 года назад

Hahahaha funny

@veerapandyan8403 3 года назад

Many have invaded Afganistan sucessfully,, Mauryan empire invaded it, Arabs invaded and converted to Islam,,, Sikhs invaded it...

@TRAINAlytics 3 года назад

@@coreytaylor447 Are you kidding me? The Romans never got past Iraq/Mesopotamia. They didn't even conquer Persia, how would they have gotten to Afghanistan?

@MdEmon-bc4ix 3 года назад

Lool Sikh went there the time when they had a civil war and yes Sikh survived 6 months and ended up with a massacre🤣🤣🤣

@iceman4660 3 года назад

The US also forgot about their own citizens in Afghanistan

@salesadmieze9049 3 года назад

Not the u.s. only joe biden

@thechosenone1533 3 года назад

@@salesadmieze9049 Joe Biden acts for the US. If Biden forgot them,it means the US forgot them.

@AbbasAli-yj3fg 3 года назад

Sad for the people of Afghanistan. they have been fighting for years and years but still stand in dark

@carljohnson2194 2 года назад

@Vipin Kumar and here comes involving Islam in what Muslims do by a typical Indian

@thebatman6235 2 года назад

@Vipin Kumar no this fight start after fall of ootomans ww1

@willmont8258 3 года назад

And just a few years later, the Russians were giving military aid to Massoud, someone they had fought against for ten years, because he was fighting the Taliban and was a moderate in comparison.

@oqqaynewaddingxtwjy7072 3 года назад

Wion Palki gives a inteliigent analyysi

@UCs8iLZnBS-BnCz3Fi6 3 года назад

That's right

@campbelltown3065 3 года назад

What a brilliant summation. Military cadets at all western military academies should watch this. Perhaps they could squeeze it in during a break in transgender diversity training.

@red8527 3 года назад

🤣🤣🤣

@realtalk6195 3 года назад

It's a highly flawed analysis because it ignores the human cost of war. The US drawdawn as it happened is actually the best outcome possible: minimal bloodshed, no destruction of cities, even the electricity and internet works. The Soviet pullout started a new Civil War that killed tens of thousands more, millions displaced, and fractured the country between warlords. It ultimately failed to protect the Communist government but at the cost of more lives and more suffering. A Civil War is what many in the West and India _wanted_ would happen, but all that does is make Afghanistan the haven for foreign fighters they keep fearmongering about. Any time a dirty war starts, foreign fighters pour in for the first decade but then get bored the next decade and go elsewhere.

@aakankshanegi6833 3 года назад

@@realtalk6195 the US withdrawn is the best outcome possible? Yes the world is already witnessing it... leaving thousands of afghans homeless and at the mercy of taliban brutes, very conveniently handing over the afghan government to taliban terrorists with their insurgent leader mullah biradar in power, along with your 3 years ammunition supply as a gift to them. Are you totally as dumb as your president biden... don't further make a mockery of yourselves!!! Around the world duffer...

@shiveshsingh3169 3 года назад

@@realtalk6195 Of course India would not like Taliban and other Islamist groups to be in control. It's fking obvious. Civil war? That's for the Afghans to decide. India never directly intervened there. The US left behind everything behind to make it even more easier for the Taliban to solidify their gains and also left behind crucial war gear. I don't think there was any reason at all to not account for your war weapons and gear. That kind of shit only happens when you are abandoning you posts in a hurry, not in a systematic and planned pull out.

@resireg 3 года назад

Or how displaying american flag is considered racist

@sachinbhardwaj1304 3 года назад

On all three ocasions afghans defeated any empire because every time the other empire was supporting them.

@taimurhashmi3616 3 года назад

I smell daal from this comment

@coxzcampz3001 3 года назад

The reality of war is all business

@carljohnson2194 2 года назад

Not only that but also due to guerilla warfare tactic

@AA-pp7kc 3 года назад

Bidens for MUSLIMS .....ha vaiii....aa gaya swad😂🤣

@Saad_768 3 года назад

Taliban to Biden ..... Ye swaad kbhi nhi bholo ge 😂

@arnabpersonal6729 3 года назад

Joe bin laden is poor old man

@pintcherputr239 3 года назад

Afghans are suffering Le paxitan wah kya scene 😃

@lambormcdonell3561 3 года назад

I remembered Rambo was fighting for Afghan against Russia.. 😆

@ranjithtp6204 3 года назад

🤣🤣

@Pradeep-ix6dj 3 года назад

It’s not graveyard of empires.. it’s going to be just graveyard. 😔

@ryusuf3409 3 года назад

It's a graveyard for all empire who goes to Afghanistan

@somecallmeelvis 2 года назад

China wants Afghanistan soon

@dronesoverme3330 3 года назад

Wow, real news? Real perspective? Can’t believe I’m just now finding this channel.

@valn_ilyo 3 года назад

Soviets were collapsing within, that's why they pulled out America however... Ughhh smh

@marekkolenda7061 3 года назад

Palki Sharma is the best journalist

@sharadjain2463 3 года назад

Soviets were not cruel and poked their noise into the internal matters of other countries like US does.

@francoislechanceux5818 3 года назад

Lol. The soviets poked their noses in the internal affairs of Hungary, chekoslovakia, angola, poland, eat-germany, cuba, nicaragua, syria, irak, lybia, romania, vietnam, north-korea, afghanistan etc...

@lordsullivan4368 3 года назад

You are very ill-informed bro !

@user-wp7os2ee5l 3 года назад

@@francoislechanceux5818 gay

@waiki8223 3 года назад

Well, that's the difference of the US from any reasonable country: they do not learn! They think highly (wrongfully) of themselves and believe they know how to solve world's problems, no analysis of previous experience, no real diplomacy. And yes, US is physically far from all the countries they brought down, while us, Russia, we did have common borders back then and even now remain dangerously close to Afghanistan so we do care what happens in there as it concerns and directly affects our close neighbors and us as a consequence!

@nicolaschophi4080 3 года назад

"They invaded without asking, they fled without asking!" 😂

@Deltajoey 3 года назад

Afghanistan would be better in the hands of Russia.

@Dangur2 3 года назад

Soviets had received 18 requests for the military help from the Afghan government, before they finally agreed. Although the decision was provoked by the association of Afghan leader Taraki by his prime minister Amin. Before that, military generals were against of sending troops, what is documented, but finally, KGB insisted on the intervention.

@GururajBN 3 года назад

There’s a key difference in the situation of the USSR and the US. The USSR had a direct border with Afghanistan and didn’t have to deal with a treacherous ally like Pakistan. So, the withdrawal was done at a convenient pace. The US had long standing enmity with Iran. It had no choice but to rely on Pakistan for transitioning its war material to Afghanistan. Pakistan exploited the dependence more than fully. The US had a mill stone around its neck for two decades. The US has been left enervated.

@hrclub4902 2 года назад

Thats true. We afghans will never forget the puppet pakistan letting america and nato come into our country trough their borders.

@ridealongwithharry6679 3 года назад

The issue here is corruption by the Gov’t of 🇦🇫 that caused low morale for their own army to defend their own country.

@Idly89 3 года назад

Gave all Weapons choppers trained them (Talibans..Al Qaeda..ISIS) and leaving 🤣 so Asia gets into War and Chaos prevails.Murica thinks People watching are fools. Their Right and Left both are Illuminati puppet govts and their country itself found by them who owns controls global money system and ones who control all religions.. Such terms killing messiahs prophets and twisting all they said.. And using against humanity. Inventing Religion.. Money system such terms..( Read history of Templars.. And societies which controlled world.. By Terms.. Grouped them with different terms and made slavery into humanity with lies.. False beliefs.. All over world...) Mind only. heartless terms to make Mind onyl Heartless Loop Programmed Rotten Purposeless Zombie Bots... And make existence sick.. Made music nature.. Love sex all as sin haram and all as born sinners made mind more and controlled humans brainwashing them with lies.. Fear. Making humans can't realise they are part of Almighty Eternal.. Entire conscious... And in them as Heart at Zero as at Orgasmic High Point Creation Creator in... Zero 0️⃣ Burning soul and Mind one with Greater entire conscious .. Indefinite magical eternal dancer ultimate experiencer.. In... ...

@pintcherputr239 3 года назад

Beggarnes is also a talent But only found in superpower pakistan

@bhalchandra13 3 года назад

But there were some significant differences: 1. When USSR was there, they faced Taliban built by us while US was facing it's own mistake and not made by others. 2. USSR was facing Chernobyl back lash while all these years US wasn't facing such high risk. (Chernobyl was the biggest reason behind USSR's fall). 3. USSR was on the brink of collapse while US is good in its conditions (covid pandemic affected every single nation). 4. Afghanistan was better in that USSR regime (9 yrs only but better yrs for afghans) while in US's regime it wasn't good for afghan people (fucking 20 yrs waste and only in 3-5 month the country collapsed)

@marekkolenda7061 3 года назад

Panjandrum region never be under Talibans control in Afghanistan

@marekkolenda7061 3 года назад

@Khaled Nawaz Religion war between Islam and Hinduism

@EILF7842 3 года назад

@Khaled Nawaz why can't pak army show some balls and fight themselves and looking towards Taliban to fight ? nevertheless send them if you can.

@narinderpalsingh6406 3 года назад

Had Soviet union and America not occupied Afghanistan history would have been different

@2011kok 3 года назад

yes there would have been way more terror attacks

@2011kok 3 года назад

@OneMuslim Ummah now there would be more terror attacks, but terrorism is an international problem..it not just affects America. A US soldier doesn't sign up to fight a war forever for a country he doesn't belong to ..so this "American betrayal" was inevitable.

@CeciliaPeng 3 года назад

Very well-researched newsreels. Much insight shown.

@masimasi5552 3 года назад

She is back ….👏🏻👏🏻

@marekkolenda7061 3 года назад

US military possible spend 350 millions $ per day in Afghanistan for last 20 years

@albertrancharan3517 3 года назад

They swim too far to drown. Doesn't make no sense.

@2011kok 3 года назад

@@albertrancharan3517 its ultimately upto the house owner to keep his/her house

@mercedesbenz3751 3 года назад

Families of US Army men should come onto the streets of America and questions their government, did the lives of their brothers, sons, children go in vein? What did we achieve in Afghanistan.

@2011kok 3 года назад

@@mercedesbenz3751 they stopped a terror organization for 20 years from taking a whole country and launching more terror attacks in that period of time.

@marekkolenda7061 3 года назад

@@mercedesbenz3751 Defense sectors industries must makes business humans victims and military personnel is not important

@cajnicfernandes1010 3 года назад

They fled with their tails between their legs, like abandoning Coyote's.

@boycottchina4543 3 года назад

If afghans are not willing fighting their war, why US should? Good they came out of the mess on time

@richardshort3914 3 года назад

In fairness to the Soviets, they were asked to support the government-of-the-day.

@northernwing 3 года назад

I can never see US as an ally. India has an old and gold ally that is Russia, they were always their for us when we were nothing. They supported us during our toughest times. We are always grateful to them. And a little fact from history for those who think Us is our true friend and praise US like nincompoops.. it is only in recent times Us has started favouring India before this Us was very close to Pakistan and was a major supplier of weapons and financial aid to Pakistan against India.

@royalvessels3633 3 года назад

" ...today you are our friend, tomorrow you are our enemy"

@Yk-if3ev 3 года назад

They were in their knees during Genghis Khan time. In any case, the commentary makes sense. I agree with many of the points. However, when you talk about that part of the world, you should not only talk about it as it is. There is this country that benefits from the chaos in that country. Meaning, for every war in the area, they benefit from it big time. Any guess?

@javiparanormalworld 3 года назад

Not many Americans died in a War that lasted for 20 years, she forget to talk about that,

@COD4JESSE 3 года назад

This whole time I've just been hoping that this whole withdrawal was a ploy. Pull the troops out. Let the Taliban think they can operate out in the open. Then MOAB their entire command structure during a Parliament session.

@reemakha8405 3 года назад

Very well detailed and described

@greatgalaxy2118 3 года назад

ABC: A:Accurate B: Balanced C: Credibility Thanks for ABC reprorting WION

@rohitgoyal7258 3 года назад

The American media won't show anything like this, they will even glorify the exit.😂

@donaldj3286 3 года назад

Much better give the 🇵🇭 that expenses to counter China. Than a coward Afghan Govt.

@dottedindia 3 года назад

Bro, u need to understand becoz of democrats no one believes in USA..

@surendramumgai631 3 года назад

Good analysis of the soviet and american withdrawals from Afghanistan , as rightly pointed out the soviets acted more professionally while the americans did not.

@dripplerIL 3 года назад

The Soviets: losses: 15k kills: over a million and left in a organized parade the US: losses: 73k kills: 51k left by shoving as many people into planes and GTFO yeah, the Soviet sure operated poorly....

@TriforceOfTheGods80 3 года назад

The US didn't lost 73 thousand, it was around 3 thousand.

@dripplerIL 3 года назад

@@TriforceOfTheGods80 and us and it's allies

@aloysiusprasetyo3737 3 года назад

USA never win anything after 1979 with Taliban. Russian win Crimea and Syrian war againts USA proxy

@dripplerIL 3 года назад

@@aloysiusprasetyo3737 they also destroyed ISIS in syria in less resources then the US

@pratikshasinghjadon8124 3 года назад

That's why Kachwah Rajput King Man Singh showed no mercy to those Afghans when he butchered them left & right & ruled through sword.

@bintyshreech5774 3 года назад

Biden has no mercy for Afghans..He is so cold. Missing Trump.

@hansb.8 3 года назад

One big question you avoid! Who has helped the Afghans fighting Russia? It was the USA who had armed the Muchahadeen with their newly developed Stinger Rockets. A shoulder based Rocket perfect to shoot down those clumsy Russian Helicopters. However, the rest they say is History.

@SM-ot5rv 3 года назад

Wow India want to mock America but will soon ask for help when Taliban take over india

@chaitanyasaikumarnimmala6392 3 года назад

Joke of the day😂

@ishwarraj6433 3 года назад

India has 1 billion hard core Hindu soldiers

@sharifraihan4860 3 года назад

Mujahideen in Afghanistan received Trainings & Modern Weapons as Stringer and every logistical support from the West. Thus they fought well & finally succeeded to expel the Soviet. In those days Soviets were facing internal Economic & Political troubles. So they were compelled to leave Afghanistan. But the Taliban did not receive Russian weapons or Chinese. They got no logistical support like Mujahideen. Nevertheless, the Invincible Western Army was finally defeated to a small group of barbarians, called Taliban.

@EILF7842 3 года назад

bruh Afghan army didn't fight at all. Taliban got a WALK OVER after USA left. There's a much bigger game or settlement between usa and Taliban Afghanistan behind the door.

@manishrao18 3 года назад

All i can do is 😅😅 I'm going to watch Rambo it's only where Uncle Sam won

@abdiweliyusuf3929 3 года назад

when america was there they were told to get out but when america left they were shamed. wasn't the world media the same media that was shaming america for staying in afghanistan. now they have left and they will suffer. people wondered why america didn leave afghanistan even though they defeated the taliban in 3-4 years its precisely because of this.

@kuyaerwin0507 3 года назад

We love you WION for giving us positive reports you really deserve a great break, especially Mr. Anas the brave and very nice reporter with face to face with Talibani, I believe Taliban has a great heart to the people of Afghanistan. Allah Bless Afghanistan country and the people.❤

@pradhumnrathore7602 3 года назад

What are you taking 😳

@rachunaa 3 года назад

I just love this channel a lot now.

@erickfragata7975 3 года назад

In the cat and mouse chase, most often, the mouse never gets eaten. Purpose makes the exertion of effort different. The cat runs to quell its hunger. the mouse runs, for its life.

@aarushtalwar1564 3 года назад

Atleast WION should see the real picture America has not failed it has succeeded. America has ensured unrest in EAST by resurrection of Taliban. With this Unrest the focus of Asian countries will shift from Prosperity to Undecisive War planning - Advantage to WEST. They expect India to do their Biding in South East Asia just like Israel is doing their Biding in Middle East.

@clashoflands 3 года назад

True,nice analysis.

@hotchihuahua1546 3 года назад

Jury is still out , you have a generation that had 20 years to learn under a protected US military , it may not show right away but it will show down the road .

@robertreyes6719 3 года назад

After 20 years of stay, another Saigon falls as Americans flee, it was sad. History repeats itself. =( 🇵🇭

@tejas2u 3 года назад

In My School Days ❗ Now I Wish... If Ever I Had a Teacher Like Palki Sharma .. . . . Things Would Have Been Certainly Different 🙏🏻😅🙏🏻

@mirrie7075 3 года назад

She's honestly my favourite reporter

@bansrajmattai4548 3 года назад

They were never interested in the welfare of the Afghan people, only in their resources. Power and money are of no avail without concern for the people. This is the bottom-line lesson for invading powers anywhere, and everywhere. The world has changed greatly since victorian times. Members of the military and the military industrial complex ought to find new day jobs. China and Russia are more than likely to see to it.

@pineapplesareyummy6352 3 года назад

It is also notable what supporters the Afghan Mujahideen had in the 1980s versus the Taliban today. The Afghan Mujahideen was backed by the US, UK, Pakistan, China and a number of Gulf Arab states. The Taliban had virtually no international support except maybe rogue elements within Pakistan' security apparatus, and possibly wealthy patrons from the Gulf smuggling money in. The Taliban certainly had no superpower backers. Yet, the Afghan government in 2021 collapsed far quicker.

@kievolga683 3 года назад

For the first time, the tone of the presenter, and perhaps the channel, describes the new Taliban rulers without mentioning that they are terrorists

@sauravghosh7064 3 года назад

But they are terrorist Thats hidden to no one

@kievolga683 3 года назад

@@sauravghosh7064 For now because there is no strong and valid alternative in Afghanistan to take over power at the present time, such as the Taliban It is funny for the first time The international community and governments will recognize their legitimacy even though most of their leaders have not been removed from the terrorist List

@sysbrixleathers3901 3 года назад

@@sauravghosh7064 Ofcourse RSS and affiliates are terrorists. Everyone knows that.

@officialtanuj 3 года назад

@@kievolga683 nothing is decided yet they have no future funding setup, if they take chinese money america will disturb again and china will try its best too this is a pit full of desires and conflicts

@ArrowBast 3 года назад

The world knows Indian Foreign policy how it failed in SRI LANKA - they trained LTTE , but then sent IPKF to fight them - its the same logic . Indian doublespeak at its finest on WION.

@mercedesbenz3751 3 года назад

Families of US Army men should come onto the streets of America and questions their government, did the lives of their brothers, sons, children go in vein? What did we achieve in Afghanistan. If we had achieved nothing then why so many of our troops had to die.

@jhumakansabanik7234 3 года назад

When they joined in USA military, they voluntarily become the catalyst of imperialistic plunders. Yours is a nation of modern Vikings. The grand salary that these armed ruffians get is stained with bloods of innocent whom you regard "big other" So why you need to feign or cheap sloganeering?

@briang.7206 3 года назад

@@jhumakansabanik7234 Yes I volunteered rather than be drafted into the Army. It was terrible as many came home injured. Many suffered from Agent Orange and the VA denied their claims. During the Vietnam war we were duped into believing we were fighting for a noble cause.

@leesteal4458 3 года назад

The US was foolish. They should have kept the contingent of forces they had in the US.

@kukulroukul4698 3 года назад

Sharma being STRAIGHT FORWARD but to NOWHERE ! how good is that :)

@saffron1977 3 года назад

While Indian king's forgave the enemies the Afghan kings and generals beheaded the enemy without mercy .

@ThDaniel 3 года назад

That green coat is just too good.

@rome316ae3 2 года назад

Difference is during ussr taliban didn't exist but during usa taliban existed

@DgurlSunshine 3 года назад

says the free woman not wearing an imposed burka

@Random_Name_07 2 года назад

I'll stand by our mujahideen brothers until the end.

@whoami9691 3 года назад

Classic reporting

@meyerduplessis1233 3 года назад

Can this channel say anything good about any country except India??? I experience some bias here Palki

@clashoflands 3 года назад

Every country has its mouth piece,nothing wrong with it.

@2011kok 3 года назад

but if America never went to participate in the civil war then taliban would have been taken control 2 decades ago.lmao

@willmont8258 3 года назад

The problems begin when you start nation building before you have defeated the enemy.

@kushagra9401 3 года назад

See who mad Taliban strong?? America supported (funded) them in order to defeat Soviet Union, This time Russia funded to Taliban and USA defeated Karma

@2011kok 3 года назад

@@willmont8258 tell me this, the task of defeating the enemies of your country belongs to your country or some other nation? Other nations can only arm you and give you resources..its ultimately upto you to protect yourself. why would other countries kill more of thier soldiers for your sake? lol

@willmont8258 3 года назад

@@2011kok The US didn't defeat their enemy, but started to nation build instead.

@RA-vg5jb 3 года назад

US President acted like the hero of the movie 'Indecent Proposal'. They were not interested in making a deal, rather than fighting terror.

@pintcherputr239 3 года назад

Katora utao chalo saudi Superpower pakistan 👈 😁 😁 😝

@sysbrixleathers3901 3 года назад

Half pant pehno chalo Israel and USA Gobar Power India 😂😂😂

@avishkumar8231 3 года назад

Imrand katora leke: arre bhai hum to phakir admi hai

@abakaparasatuwaya6936 3 года назад

during the soviet time, the afghan mujahideen were funded by the americans, but during the american time, no one funded the taliban, yet they still lose.

@mikevalentino2225 3 года назад

Well the difference is the united states was actually attacked on our soil so self defense was our cause for entering their country. But staying there for 20 years was a mistake it should have been 2 to 5 years.

@megaotstoy 3 года назад

as a matter of fact "the united states was actually attacked" by Saudi citizens, why you decided to invade Afghanistan instead?

@Kannot2023 3 года назад

@@megaotstoy because some Saudi citizens were on Afghanistan, like Osama

@megaotstoy 3 года назад

@@Kannot2023 eventually they found him in Pakistan, did they? why not invade Pakistan instead?

@mikevalentino2225 3 года назад

@@megaotstoy You are correct most of them were Saudi nationals that lived and trained in Afghanistan. There were 15 terrorist mostly trained in Afghanistan with al-Qaeda. But the financing I do believe had ties to Saudi Arabia as well. Now about 100,000 afghans are dead and an additional 5000 Americans. I think by giving the Taliban 80 billion dollars in weapons the world is now in worse shape than it was 20 years ago. I'm sure George Bush got rich with his entire cabinet from the venture. Meanwhile bled most of the American tax payers dry.

@ashapuhin9825 3 года назад

Anyone who binds themselves with thier own rules while figthing against an enemy who recognize no rules is bound to lose.

@gauravvvvv 3 года назад

Now USA AND RUSSIA SHOULD for once come together and sort out 🇦🇫

@SM-ol9nb 3 года назад

When the soviets were going through Germany and saw all the nice houses in indoor plumbing they asked “ what the hell did these people ever want with us”.

@waiki8223 3 года назад

To make us slaves... Never read about the Vermacht's plans for us, Slavic people?! We were meant to serve the Arian supremacy, surviving on a pound of bread a day...

@alikashif2907 3 года назад

I don't know why india is crying all the time ... Whatever is in best interest of 🇺🇸 USA they did exactly that ... India is scared and in panic and blaming 🇺🇸

@yusufkomehson5747 3 года назад

I like your presentation on the comparative analysis on the great nations that have made an attempt to annex Afghanistan 🇦🇫. Keep it up Plaki

@CheemaAMC1979 3 года назад

0:25 Palki says: "but they (USA) never learn, first British then in 80's the USSR both got defeated by Afghans" What Palki deliberately forgot to tell you that when USSR invaded Afghanistan India was supporting USSR and Pakistan supported Afghan Mujahideen, similarly when Americans invaded in 2001 India was supporting America and Pakistan supported Taliban. Pakistan ended up Victorious and INDIA is now considered an established PANOUTI.😂

@allhakafuddi9663 3 года назад

1971 India supported Mukti Bahini and ended up victorious and pukistan is considered an established PANOUTI😂. Did you conveniently and deliberately forget that?

@CheemaAMC1979 3 года назад

@@allhakafuddi9663 Sunna hai all consulates in Afghanistan including Indian embassy in Kabul have been shut off, with each and every indian back home, How's the Josh and where is Doval, that three feet tall indian James bond with his f*k face?

@sauravghosh7064 3 года назад

Pakistan did biggest surrender breaking guinness world record of surrenders in a war , Even after being help by america, Britain and china Now who is panuati ??😜

@officialtanuj 3 года назад

@@CheemaAMC1979 we never put any soldiers in afghanistan ,it was never our intention but jealousy mein phuki hui kya samjhe

@stans303 2 года назад

Ironic the Government the Soviets left in Afghanistan outlasted the Soviet Union itself

@Dr_Nomadic_India 3 года назад

Le Biden now : "Let's make China Great again!!"

@charakarasanga8465 3 года назад

Soviet took the Afganisthan into 20 century. Build roads, schools, universities, hospitals, and trained engineers, technicians, doctors. They even took Afgan scientists to space. USA fed to American war contractors while bombing schools, roads, hospitals, and bridges built by USSR.

@bobapbob5812 3 года назад

Watch the Russian film 9th Company (9 Рота) about the Soviet retreat. Also find the Russian monument to the fallen of Afghanistan (and Chechnya and other conflicts). It is in Ekaterinburg and is called "The Black Tulip" ("Чёрный Тюлпань").

@tonyso9637 3 года назад

Palki Sharma, thank you.

@khurmiful 3 года назад

This is comedy not a serious analysis.

@Matt-xj2bx 3 года назад

hey india, i am ashamed of the situation as a american, but i been watching your media since fall of afganistan, i can say you speek real tough for a country that does nothing to help panshjer.

@hudatuhin2621 3 года назад

Why don't you talk about the Afghan rulers who ruled India for nearly 500 years? Yes ,they were mostly from Afghanistan and Central Asia

@vilarmaloles7275 3 года назад

the Soviet's withdrawal is very systematic, while. . . . the American has no systems of withdrawal, the difference is stumblin' joe biden is brittle upstairs. speaking of bidens, whatever happened to hunter biden's investigations, there seems to be a news blockout on that matter.

@fancyflavour 3 года назад

Leaving weapons, helicopters to Taliban is like putting your head in Lion's mouth. They don't know when they gonna bite you. Thanks all out to Biden and America. What a self goal it is.

@hotrodprepper656 3 года назад

Biden is not our legal president, it was an illegal election, and since then he has done everything in his power to discredit and destroy America. Don't blame the American people for what he has done.