Im owning rdr2 this week. Now im playing gta5 first time ever. Unforgettable experience, i dont know how i missed gta 5 for so long game is masterpiece
Yeah for real. I’d argue Gta 5 was about just as much ahead of its time as RDR2 was for its own time. Not sure why you’d be comparing two Rockstar games from different time periods and expect the older one to win.
@@Vegetalegoformyou must not have played red dead online recently good luck trying join without getting insta killed immediately, the game has ran out of content for high rank player so killing other about all they got left
online is a tie, along with acting. the voices of GTA 5 including ned luke, steven ogg bring it out. it was a amazing game and i loved GTA 5 and RDR2, besides that this is fax, i also loved the clip of trevor sitting down you used for GTA 5, brilliant edit.
@@Durzeo i agree they are both fun and i love rdr more than gta but gta online has new heists cars skins but rdr stays still they're even giving the same pass for Halloween for two years
@@reqwill5380 i meant online ties between substance, GTA Online does indeed get updates, including the contract which gives it a slight edge over RDR2 because the contract is fucking gold
GTA 5 wins I have played both the games and rdr2 is a slow paced open world game with a slow storyline. On the other hand GTA 5 is a action packed story game with lots of side missions and it is open world. And with GTA 6 coming next year it is a great game to replay or play anyway this took me a long time to write so please like my comment.
i like RD online because everyone is equal. no oppressors or drones or any of that. everyone is a cowboy with horses and guns. whoever is the better gunslinger wins
I'm 26 and i played every Rockstar game since Gta 3, RDR2 is easily the biggest Rockstar's masterpiece, way more depth and better story, same with almost every characters, only kids would prefer GTA 5
Kids? KIDS! There is a whole fucking mission where u have to go to stripclub and if u do, u can get a lap dance while the women are naked. Tell me that’s for kids
@@pancakecooked because is less realistic, easier, funnier, with vehicles, and a totally different game concept, that Hollywood type of story is nothing special and something already seen, even the 4, SA and VC stories are all better
@@Bluemagic692 Yeah it depends upon preference different people have different taste some like it and some don't .Also what about your thoughts on gta 6 do you think it will be better than the before gta/rdr games?
@@pancakecooked storywise gta 6 wont be better than rdr games because as we all know those are very different, so i would compare 6 with the other GTAs, and hopefully would be better with a great gameplay, it would be nice to have 2 characters a male and female like a rumor said, and one thing i would absolutely love is the interactive open world (like rdr2 where npcs arent dead like older gta) and more cities like liberty, vice etc not just one
it had potential to be the best game ever, rockstar rushed it towards the end and i think that's part of why they abandoned it, they were sick of the game after multiple 100 plus hour work weeks and i get that the same things happen to us at our jobs.
bro i feel like gta 5 is just better not gta 5 fan boy, i just love it more bcuz the game itself is practically a fortune for me its just my childhood, just like gta 4, rdr2 has a deeper plot fr
I crashed a car In GTA V, no biggie My lack luster horse died in RDR2 and I cried. Only games that made me cry was this game, the Witcher 3, and Arma 3 when I planned an assault for 5 hours and we got pushed back
Pearson owns the general store in rhodes, Tilly is married, Mary-Beth is a writer, Trelawny is living with his family in Saint Denis, Sadie went to South America, Charles went to canada, Bill is starting a powerful gang in New Austin, and Javier is in Mexico.
@@megalodonyasiyor5321it sold more because of little kids who are stupid and just because the game sold more doesn’t mean it’s better, that’s like saying china is a better country than America because it has more people, congrats, you played yourself
Idk what i like more rdr2 or gta 5 they are so great and butiful in there own ways rd has more animals and you can ride a horse gta has far more i like both like twin brother
*rdr2 in chapter 1 everything seems normal untill….the ending the saddest ending that will make u make a pool of tears….😔😣 it was just the saddest ending in the game arthur saying his last words then lies down on the rock and watches the setting sun before 2 mins of death 😢😔
