You what amazing, this sounds exactly like how our how the small sermon is said on Friday Jummah prayer for us Muslims and yes we also say amen outloud and hand our hand out the same way and fold to our face and kiss. Amazing the similarities. Also the reading in Hebrew sounds identical to the Arabic .
Aren't the Karaite supposed to reject the Oral Torah? Everything here is from the Oral Torah. The Havdalah ceremony itself is not explicitly prescribed in Scripture, and the blessings and their wording were rabbinically ordained. Can someone please explain?
Karaites reject the Oral Law as having been whispered into Moshe's ear by Hashem. They accept it as a man-made document. So they will accept some views of Talmud as persuasive and some not
I believe that there is a little confusion here. It is not that Karaites reject the whole idea of Oral law- As someone in the replies has already observed- they also have Oral traditions. What they are opposed to is placing Oral law (specifically the Talmud) on a par with the Torah. Customs may develop and be observed which are not contrary to the Torah.
@@reuelmelville5232 that's right! You explained that well. The karaites in Israel would explain it that way too. The recent converts to karaism, however, protestantize it.
@@MitzvosGolem1 Why don't you stop yapping with your Sin'at Ḥinam and answer my damned question already? It's high time you realized you must be honest about the sources of your Judaism before you demand others defend themselevs. And after that, you really should reply to your own question about the Talmudim, if you insist your "oral" torah is Sinaitic.
Havdalah, kippah, blessings with the nusach baruch atah hashem, communal prayers with the answeting of amen, etc. Its all bootleg Judaism. None of them have an actual uninterupted historical connection to any Karite. And Karaisim is illegitimate anyway.
That's your opinion at most, riddled with unproven hogwash. The formulation "Barukh Ata YHWH" was already in the Miqra. You can find a reference to a form of communal prayer in King Shelomo's speech at the First Temple's dedication event. You have it reversed -- "bootleg Judaism" is what the Pharisees created and the rabbis developed. Are we to understand you know the personal genealogies of those Jews better than they do and have performed DNA studies on them that enable you to determine they have no actual uninterrupted historical connection to any past Qaraites? Any sane reader will dismiss your assertions about them as tripe.