Тёмный

HDZero vs DJI | FPV Freestyle back-to-back flights 

GeKo
Подписаться 1,3 тыс.
Просмотров 12 тыс.
50% 1

#drone #digitalfpv
I built two of almost the same 5 inch freestyle quad for the summer. One with the HDZero Freestyle V2 and one with a DJI Caddx Vista. I started FPV with the DJI Vista system and have more recently been flying a lot of analog and HDZero. Even though this type of comparison has been done before (and way better) I wanted to fly these back to back and see if I can feel any difference.
So this is not even close to an exhaustive or controlled test, its just my first impressions as someone who used to fly a lot of DJI and now flies a lot more analog. You can probably see that I am more comfortable now with the better latency of HDZero and analog, but its probably just a matter of getting used to it for either system ;-)
Hope its useful for someone!
Chapters
00:00 Intro
00:57 HDZero (540p 90 FPS)
03:00 DJI Caddx Vista (720p 120 FPS)
05:04 Oops
05:29 HDZero again (540p 90 FPS)
07:17 Some ripping with HDZero Quad - Action 2 footage
Quad setup HDZero
Frame: Piratframes Hook V2
Props: HQprop J37
ESC: Foxeer Reaper 65a
FC: Kiss Ultra V2. FW: B57
Motors: RCinpower Smoox 2306.5 1880kv
Battery: Tattu Rline 1300 mah 6s
RX: ELRS 2.4 250hz
VTX: HDZero Freestyle V2 with nano 90 cam
Quad DJI
Frame: Piratframes Hook V2
Props: HQprop J37
ESC: Foxeer Reaper 65a
FC: Kiss Ultra V2. FW: B57
Motors: FPVcycle 22.6mm 1920kv
Battery: Tattu Rline 1300 mah 6s
RX: ELRS 2.4 250hz
VTX: Caddx Vista with Caddx Nebula Pro
thumbnail art by pngtree

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

1 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 62   
@saucyfpv8928
@saucyfpv8928 Месяц назад
you can definitely see DJI just looks so dang good but the way you fly on HD zero shows you have confidence and fun.
@babyzeefpv9887
@babyzeefpv9887 2 месяца назад
The quads you just featured in the video look like absolute boss Hogs! They are absolutely beautiful. I’m sure you’re gonna get a lot of good videos this summer.
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
Thanks! I built them for some Bando events, so they are supposed to be able to take a beating. Lets see - they are still quite light with the action 2
@lukaFPV
@lukaFPV 2 месяца назад
I n0w fly exclusively HDZero. I tried Walksnail, but will sell my WS stuff. Have Mobula 7 whoop upgraded with nano v3, MrCroc 5" with freestyle V1 and Micro V2, Hook V2 with freestyle V2 and Micro V3, and AOS 3.5 with race V3 and Nano90. Havent tried DJI, but I guess experience is similar to WS.
@babyzeefpv9887
@babyzeefpv9887 2 месяца назад
Thank you for doing this test. This really helps me to understand RF a little bit better. I still haven’t gone out to do any of the ridgebacks or cliffs that I talked crap about lol. It’s been snow or crowds on the trails that have stopped me lol.
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
thanks for checking it out :) Yea its nice to have a 'test' spot like this dead end logging road that nobody ever uses on a sunday
@squiddah
@squiddah 2 месяца назад
I have always had a hard time understanding latency. I get it from an intellectual perspective, but the “how does it make a difference?” part has not been easy to see when someone else is flying. It was interesting to see that the dji video was much better, but your flying was much better with the hdzero. You could almost feel the difference in your confidence. I get it now. Thanks.
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
yea this is what I felt. But have to note that I am currently way more used to analog/hdzero latency than DJI latency, so that is mainly why I think. I am sure that if I spent a whole day flying DJI it would be fine again
@miquelmarti6537
@miquelmarti6537 2 месяца назад
Having a variable latency link feels like if the controller did break up instead of the image.
@fpvkevlar8101
@fpvkevlar8101 2 месяца назад
Great video.
@TheLostSquadron
@TheLostSquadron 2 месяца назад
Excellent comparison! Something about HDZero just bothers me. The goggle image soft, and I don't love the way it seems to go from solid to unflyable without a lot of warning. I've been flying DJI since the V2's were released, and I'm so torn on going to Walksnail for it's small VTX's. The DJI O3's are expensive but also seem good enough to let you get by without a separate camera. Ditching weight does wonders for responsiveness.
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
I had the same impression a while ago. I was using HDZero goggles mostly for analog (which I love weirdly enough). I only had the small 200 mW HDZero VTXes and the breakup was really pretty annoying. Ever since this freestyle VTX and the nano 90 cam though, I have fallen in love with it. Something about the feeling of flying this cam really does it.
@justkillen07
@justkillen07 2 месяца назад
if its any help i have a couple quads with 03s 6in which carries a full sized gp12 for long range, never used the 03 to recored until yesterday with my 3in cinewhoop. used to get around 8 mins of flight with a caddx vista (not recording) after upgrading the the 03 i'm now getting just over 5 mins while recording with the 03 using 1100 and 1380 lipos. just got a 2s acrobee75 with an 03 that i haven't had the time to test
@TheLostSquadron
@TheLostSquadron 2 месяца назад
@@justkillen07 Thanks very much!
@bluefpv3263
@bluefpv3263 2 месяца назад
great comparison im flying hdzero for freestyle and its feels so nice to fly i got the micro v3 cam which ist a pretty big quality boost compared to the nano 90 for freestyle i like it more than the nano 90 although you get a little bit more latency its still way better latency wise than other digital systems
@lynxfpv
@lynxfpv 2 месяца назад
I bet if you used the Fpvcycle 25mm smooth ones would be of a better comparison with the rcinpower on 6s. Just my opinion, was a great comparison video. After flying analog for the past 6 years and only now diving into DJI digital set up. Analog is still extremely fun, yet digital FPV systems with the crystal clear video signal is just WOW 😳
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
Yeaa the two quads didnt have identical motors thats true. But they are pretty close. FPVcycle 22.6 vs RCinpower 2306.5, KV is also quite close. As far as I know RCinpower makes the FPVcycle motors also... thanks!
@asheseven
@asheseven 2 месяца назад
Nice vid could you make one with the goggles and antennae’s your using for both. Would be great to know what to order 😂😂😂
@hyunglau
@hyunglau 2 месяца назад
Did you set the cam to 540 and change to low band. I guess that helps with penetration at the cost of some resolution
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
ah true, I have not tried that yet, thanks. So far have been using only the 90 fps mode
@Dorff_Meister
@Dorff_Meister 2 месяца назад
I've been flying for 7 or 9 months. I'd like to spend some time flying HDZero. On first impression, I hate the they don't have on-board DVR and I hate the digital snow. I primarily fly DJI Goggles 2 O3 and Cobra X w/Analog. I have one Vista quad that I fly the least. Maybe I'll decide on another HD goggle before end of year, but I'm pushing it off for now.
@Sun_Rider_FPV
@Sun_Rider_FPV 2 месяца назад
🔥
@deroskar
@deroskar 2 месяца назад
Nice realistische comparison.
@Dorff_Meister
@Dorff_Meister 2 месяца назад
Fun tree tickling... I'd just hate to crash it up there :)
@lalojr76ify
@lalojr76ify 2 месяца назад
I kind of wish I would have gone a different route then DJI because it’s getting very expensive! The 03 air units aren’t cheap and I can’t just buy a small tiny whoop to mess with because my Goggles 2 won’t work with the analog cameras! Yet I do get very good quality when flying my DJI 03 quads.
@GekkoFPV
@GekkoFPV 2 месяца назад
Found you recently. Didn’t realize there was a Geko already in FPV. You kill it bro. Keep it up.
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
haha cool, thanks!
@spartan3299
@spartan3299 2 месяца назад
Nice trees for frees stylin. I'd try 200/500mw and compare to see if you need full power.
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
thanks, yea anything above 25mw would do fine here I think
@s52ft
@s52ft 2 месяца назад
Like for you to put both on the same RF power output.
@vadimus2007
@vadimus2007 2 месяца назад
If only you watched the video...
@s52ft
@s52ft 2 месяца назад
@@vadimus2007 I did :) that is the reason I like it!
@austinspired
@austinspired 2 месяца назад
Spots like this you can get by with hdz but it just straight up doesn't work in bandos
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
yea I can imagine, sadly I dont really have bandos around here to try. However will take both these quads to rampage and see how it goes haha. I wouldnt be surprised if a powerful analog vtx like rush tank solo would do OK in a bando / better than HDzero. The breakup is more gradual on analog. Otherwise just DJI for concrete stuff.
@austinspired
@austinspired 2 месяца назад
@@GeKoFPV yes I have flown rush solos and rush tanks in bandos they do fine. It's actually what Pablo Flor aka Fenix runs and he does fine in bandos. And awesome man I'll see you there! I have dji g2 with 03s and the goggles X and the walksnail pro and moonlight is on the way we could make a video covering alllll of them
@rotorfpvstef3313
@rotorfpvstef3313 2 месяца назад
vive hd zero
@mattalford3932
@mattalford3932 2 месяца назад
The 03 air unit is definitely better than HD zero.
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
Yea image quality for sure - I also have a O3 quad. But I dont like the camera very much, it keeps shadows too dark for my taste in freestyle (speaking as a FPV cam, its great for nice looking footage). Vista is more fun to fly for me, but just personal taste :)
@xano7858
@xano7858 Месяц назад
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
@nucleo1772
@nucleo1772 2 месяца назад
so you compared 25mw hdzero with Dji 1000mw ://
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
I left in the 25mw 'mistake' since it shows really how HDZero breaks up worst case. Later in the video I compare it with full power :)
@Anzeigenobermeister-vz2qm
@Anzeigenobermeister-vz2qm 2 месяца назад
Anzeige ist raus wegen Fliegen ohne Spotter und mit 1000mW.
@mattalford3932
@mattalford3932 2 месяца назад
HD zero is just pretty anolog. Dji is the true digital system. But it's expensive in comparison.
@stickboyfpv4742
@stickboyfpv4742 2 месяца назад
Thise were my thoughts too😂.... Im startinngg to think otherwiisse though...!
@lordjeffery10
@lordjeffery10 2 месяца назад
HD zero breakup is static in the image that you can see through. DJI breakup just drops frames (fps) not as good for FPV but for slow camera drones it's good
@Jettmain8735
@Jettmain8735 2 месяца назад
@@lordjeffery10 yes but dji still has way more penetration and its way more reliable. theres a difference in getting blurry image or getting your screen completely static. i have both and use hdzero only for racing, not even freestyle. the breakups are crazy and not predictable, unlike dji. plus if u already have dji goggles u can get a runcam wasp for better framerate
@KOrnhOliO1
@KOrnhOliO1 2 месяца назад
Hmmm, you do realize that just to get the HDZero goggles it's $600 + about $100 for antennas + about $25 for a battery + the analog adapter, etc. Around $800 just for goggles! Most can't afford that! Or, don't want to, because the video quality is so close to the VERY BEST analog! Now, don't go comparing to the cheap analog gear - there's a huge difference between a top of the line Caddx Ratel and RushFPV top VTX, and low end analog gear for $10 - $20 each piece. Probably why HDZero only has about 10% market share - Too expensive for the slight extra sharpness you get over Analog. DJI, brand new, can be had for $349 for the DJI Integra goggles with antennas and a battery built in - Complete! DJI V2 goggles, that also do a fantastic analog with a simple URUAV metal adapter, can be purchased in Like New, near perfect condition for under $300. A Caddx Vista with the Wasp 120fps camera is $139.99, So, even if you want to buy all brand new gear, $349 goggles + $140 Wasp VTX + $140 Wasp VTX + $140 Wasp VTX = $769 and you've equipped THREE of your quads to go fly far with crystal clear video! Much farther - By many, Many times, and without all that Analog2 snow and Rainbow Screen of Death! Fly up into thick tree canopies and out the other side, fly into a thick forest - seeing every little bit of scraggle, and back out, and around any and all objects like a building, which Analog2 (HDZero) can't even fly 50ft. past the first corner of a building without DEATH! The penetration difference is the Maximum spread possible! Least penetration with Analog2 and most (by far) with DJI. There's really no comparison!... Especially when it comes to durability! DJI is almost bulletproof, with many never having a single defective or burnout. I haven't. Analog2 has VTX's fail so often some have reported having to give up on it all together because they've spent so much on VTX's they can't afford to buy anymore - burnout after burnout! Terrible durability! If you are on tight budget just stay with Analog and go with the GREAT GEAR instead of the bargain basement analog gear! Go try it - Buy a top of the line Ratel and a top of the line RushFPV VTX with high power and then compare it to many Analog2 (HDZero) videos available. You'll see that Analog is 90% as good as Analog2, but a Gigantic amount cheaper and more durable! Sure, Analog2 is slightly sharper, but for ALL THAT MONEY? No way, Jose! :( I think it's the worst VALUE in all of FPV because you get so little improvement in performance over plain ole Analog, for ALL THAT MONEY, it's simply not worth it! 🤷‍♂
@lordjeffery10
@lordjeffery10 2 месяца назад
@@KOrnhOliO1 Cool. Anyways I'm going to get HD zero... Would you like an apology for not wanting DJI?
@jakeeames725
@jakeeames725 2 месяца назад
Hdzero is for builders and racers and pilots who can fly. DJI is for bind and fly bought not built jeets and influencers. Go to any real race. Not going to find dji. Also why support a company who sells your info and tracks your every step.
@sligit
@sligit 2 месяца назад
Oh please. They both have advantages and disadvantages. For flying at range DJI has better penetration for example, as well as the general improvement in image quality. I don't like DJI as a company but however much I liked the relatively open source nature of HDZero, DJI was a better choice for my medium range mountain surfing builds. I've been building my own quads since 2016 btw.
@BenDover-ot1kk
@BenDover-ot1kk 2 месяца назад
@@sligitjust wish they were compatable with other types of transmission. I’ve already got an hdzero and analog drone, with an skyzone goggles and hdzero receiver. So much money 🥲 and to get into dji would be such an add on
@sligit
@sligit 2 месяца назад
@@BenDover-ot1kk yeah same. OpenIPC is looking very promising but there's no digital in on the DJI so I'd have to get new goggles.
@ricoshumpert5135
@ricoshumpert5135 2 месяца назад
So you don't have google😢, Facebook Instagram, Twitter. Cause thats what they all do.
@califpv
@califpv 2 месяца назад
Lol, while your using RU-vid and your info is being tracked and sold to 3rd parties. Fly what you enjoy
@ConjoFPV
@ConjoFPV 2 месяца назад
Nice eipping! The wway you reach for them high treetops... youre ready to take one down if needed i see hahah ..I so want a hdzero vrx for my tinywhoops and from there see where it takes me. F.. yeah kiss ultra v2 and reaper for the win❤🔥🫡
@GeKoFPV
@GeKoFPV 2 месяца назад
Thanks man! so far havn't had to get up there haha, luckily. But I have a very long rope with me usually :p
Далее
Switching to 6s in 2023?
16:45
Просмотров 31 тыс.
I Found The ULTIMATE FPV Drone Simulator In 2024
21:37
Просмотров 203 тыс.
And the BEST FPV GOGGLES in 2024 are
10:57
Просмотров 12 тыс.
The DJI FPV Drone - 3 Years Later - 2024
17:52
Просмотров 43 тыс.
2 MILE DRONE DRAG RACE!!!!
14:48
Просмотров 49 тыс.
Только девушки так умеют😂
0:59