Hear woman’s account of her capture by Hamas and escape 

Almost every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They were treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas. Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.

Could you elaborate on that

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=hPfG_P02zw16c10F

LIAR. youre a paid bot

your heart breaks listening to this...?? good, now try and find stories of how the palestinians have been living under the occupation for decades.

Therein lies the problem. We must be able to decry injustice wherever we see it without fear of of being told what to say or not say. Last time I checked all nationalities are "human" and that's what I spoke about objectively@@isuriadireja91

❤

@isuriadireja91 How dare you sympathize with terrorists!!!

​​@@erikstone2321They're just showing you who they really are inside. Full of hatred, bred into them from birth. Only freedom can prevent this kind of sickness. Pray for the freedom of Palestine from Hamas.

She seems like a strong women and processing the situation fine. The middle east is not like the west.

Doesn't matter how strong you are, all people are still just people. Look at the emergency staff in gaza, they are weeping and working. Strong, but still have emotions. No human is supposed to experience such horrific loss, so frequently with such intensity. Israeli, Palestinian, or anyone else.@@Adam-rt7lp

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=1QbuyL2LWJlFMUL4

She is not telling the original story that she told in her interviewed on Israeli state broadcaster Kan's Haboker Hazeh radio program on 15 October 2023. In that interview she said 10 other hostages with her were killed by Israeli cross fire, not by Hamas. And that Hamas did not abuse them and treated them humanely. That full interview which is in Hebrew is available with English titles on Electronic Intifada’s RU-vid channel.

@@anaesthesia1549 You see her speaking here on this video vs a video without her appearance and only voice in a language you don't understand and only believe a SUBTITLE, written by a pro palestinian media ?

It's good journalism to see those images. You can sometimes take peoples' word for it, but still better to verify and see the video and photographic evidence

@ohdear8888 I understand the importance and significance of the journalists viewing and getting the facts correct especially with many channels just running with rumour, unverified figures and false information. I am just saddened, probably more so at the fact people would say its fake, they are actors or VILE things on some videos of the survivors.

They didn't "save her life" they just didn't take it, don't act like these assholes aren't monsters.

His giving up was more about saving his own life, but that at least saved her life as well. So, it was the presence of the soldiers what saved her more than anything. Otherwise, she could've been taken hostage with a wound.

@user You couldn't be more wrong, watch it and watch it again! As the Israeli government and iarmy say " do not turn away but look and bear witness to this evil barbarity" It's the least we can do...but yes as you sound a decent caring person it will be heart breaking to do so but unfortunately necessary!

Absolutely ! - I would be interested to read the autopsy reports but I don't think there will be any.

@@johnweir1217 if they can lie about the already refuted beheadings u cant trust them on the 1400 killed by "hamas"...its been done multiple times by idf, its called the hannibal directive...n these nazis have shot 8 year old paletinians in the head, u think they would shit themselves n go trigger happy on their own in a crossfire to save their a$s

I was just looking for this comment. I'm sure the Department of israels marketing agency told her not to lose a word about this fact!

This video has been HEAVILY edited, the cuts and jumps in the story are crazy

This video is highly edited, and she may have been directed not to speak about what I think is called the Hannibal protocol, where IDF rather kill Israelis rather than allow Palestinians to have hostages. I don't think this is speculative, as we can see this wanton disregard for Israeli life, given the indiscriminate bombing of "Hamas", despite the possibility of killing their own.

Hannibal Directive never ended.

Was probably fake

Yet none of you freaks can find the actual interview

​@adayinforever hannibal directive hasn't been in affect for decades and it's for soldiers, not civilians

@@replicxnt so the 3 hostages that were offered by the IDF were soldiers?

If this happened in Palestine you'd have absolutely believed it was happening but the terrorists would have been the IDF and it would have been just another tuesday.

Your government is committing war crimes

You have only your govt and Jewish European settlers to blame.

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=1QbuyL2LWJlFMUL4

Why would the police shoot the place if they didn't believe there were terrorists there?

"I didn’t realize this terrorist was arrested; I hope they are gaining valuable information on what’s going on." Depends on who gets a hold of them. The IDF engages in torture of its captives, which even the US admitted after ten years provided nothing but false intelligence and nothing actionable while eventually becoming useless for intelligence gathering. Shin Bet (Military Intelligence) might get useful information if they can get to them first -- but the head of Shin Bet has already spoken out against the government's policies and they're probably cutting him out of the circle (which is also why they probably formed a new War Cabinet that doesn't have to answer to Parliament and outside politicians).

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=1QbuyL2LWJlFMUL4

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=hPfG_P02zw16c10F

​@@MrBazBakeWhat makes you the expert, Mr know-it-all?

@@MrBazBake Interesting…

How true.

Yes if she let's it truly get in she will break 😢

I have the same question

No one really knows the details at this point. Those questions will be asked later. But there was a huge, unprecedented amount of terrorists that infiltrated essentially taking everyone in the kibbutz as hostages so it was a very delicate situation to say the least. Not only that but it was happening in many other towns at the same time and had to be dealt with there simultaneously.

Because the Hamas terrorists attacked the guard outposts first killing everyone that would have been able to respond quickly. Other law enforcement had to first understand what was happening then travel all the way to another city to try to help.

Communications were taken down at the onset ... and it was a holy day, both Shabbat and Simchat Torah. On days like these, phones are turned off. There will be an investigation.

In this interview she says that israeli forces shot their own civilians: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=K7X2k5dTzR6gD5lT

Also the interview is obviously altered @CNN why not just give us the real and full interview ?

Because it wss a set up!

The bigger question is How come the journalist there from the very beginning before the military or police

Hamas had no intention of killing them? I think she made it clear that some or in particular this one was less radical. We know that the militants were told to go to ISRAEL and intentionally seek out CIVILIANS and KILL civilians. So if the IDF hadn't returned fire? Then all the IDF soldiers would have died and the hostages taken to gaza anyway? Do you understand that ISRAEL was attacked and not by a military but by terrorists who were given instructions to kill as many civilians as they could.

Men do have mandatory conscription, they have sense to protect, even if have no jobs related with the army. ..and I think the men were the main target, even for the rapes of women and kids, or their butchering and killing. ..the fathers and husbands were meant to suffer. Same was done by the russians in Ukraine...looked for men, police or the veterans , for relatives of soldiers..barbarians. I could not read the reports of ICC from Ukraine. I don't want to know how is to live through this. She must grieve ,must give herself time for it, accept the reality, as sooner or later will be affected by depression.

please provide links, if you would...

@@leahnewyork ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=hPfG_P02zw16c10F

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=hPfG_P02zw16c10F

@aum966 That they were attacked on day one by vicious antisemitic Muslims? Yes that is an important history to discuss!!! They defeated them and they’ve been bitter and hateful ever since, hellbent on the eradication of Israel!

Yep. It's called the Hannibal Directive.

@@adayinforever i saw a video of her in a radio interview confirming that israeli forces were shooting everyone including the hostages. this is a thing she did not mention here because it is not live so they can edit whatever they want... but i want to ask you what is Hannibal directive ??

@user-li9vt8qv3x I tried to explain but ot censored my comment, Google it.

Yes very different to this one

A Jew?

Maybe you are white !

Whites a bad thing@@osamasarhan6151

@@christopherjavens3438lol

Maybe a Buddhist?

alot of the Hamas fighters probably didn't want to be there, but where commanded to, but others were just psycopaths. luckiy she got a person who just as scared to be there.

Please clarify- who are you referring to as “they”

@@maryellen5842 yea which they is she referring to because for sure, these Hamas are not humans

She’s experiencing Stockholm syndrome as well as grief and deep sorrow

Are you showing sympathy for the Hamas people who 'only' wanted to kidnap her instead of shooting her dead? Maybe I misunderstood your comment, but otherwise this is absurd.

They killed 1400 others, took her for leverage. Yes great humanitarians indeed. Are you for real????

I stand against capslock...

@@gazmothedamaja your reply is so effn HILARIOUS! thank you for the laugh 😂

Her boyfriend was killed by the IDF when they arrived and shot everything that moved. That bit was edited out!!

In this interview she says that israeli forces shot their own civilians: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=K7X2k5dTzR6gD5lT

When years go by and maybe not even years, you'll find out that you were standing on the wrong side of history.

God made this single terrorist to give up so the lady is saved. Even in the worst situation, there is always a miracle. This to me is like a real movie, unbelievable and very unfortunate. Imagine to have escaped the music festival terror and to die here? My heart goes to the boyfriend. And goodness, the old couple saved them, but ended up dying too instead. It's so crazy about life and hard to understand how things play out. This stories are so many and they are chilling and almost hard to believe this happened which actually did. My heart goes out to the people of Israel and the innocent civilians of Palestinians. I'm crying to God everyday for all the men, women and children suffering on both sides. I don't know any of them but I believe they are my sisters and brothers as I feel their pain and wish I can hug each and everyone of them. May our good lord take over this war which is no bigger than him. Jesus please remember your children 😢😢. Amen Amen 🙏. 🫂 ❤️.

​@@unknownandmysticalI'm confused, are you saying OP should be on the side of murder rather than condemning it?

Надо определиться с понитием Террорист. Как могут быть террористами люди, которые защищают свои земли и семьи от израильских оккупантов?!

These terrorists were there to kill. I really don't think this was a normal "hostage" situation that you see in the movies. These people are the kind that can be suicide bombers. I don't think the "police" had time to make choices- it was like a war situation. This woman's story was just mind-blowing. I felt shocked just listening.

Erin is not wearing black today Have you noticed?

Hardly. She smiles throughout.

​@@davidhutton5306because the other lady was smiling, she was just mirroring her, it's one way to empathize with someone in shock

Yes, it is 100% authentic and this is why people don’t behave like they behave in Hollywood movies. In your life you have seen hundreds of thousands of “reactions to violent death” *acted* by actors who have never experienced such a thing, acting scripts written by people who have never experienced such a thing, directed by directors with no experience of such a thing - all basing the performance on previous acting and imagination. And people who are not very experienced with these things either, and who forget that the hundred thousand examples they have WERE ALL IMAGINARY think that people are acting (!) unconvincingly or inappropriateky.

It creeps through my heart aches for what they went through ..for their losses ..

It’s amazing that some people don’t realize that facial expressions seemingly inappropriate for the situation, such as smiles, can be caused by stress and shock. Such as witnessing terrorists murder her neighbors and family members, being kidnapped by terrorists, and escaping. Each situation should be evaluated on its own merits. Good thing you are not an ignorant, judgmental dunce like those people!

@@sallymj8957 Biologically, smiles and laughter are modified fear responses. The wide-grin expression in wild chimps is fear and placating. Humor is often called “the juxtaposition of incongruities”. Putting side by side things that mismatch, that surprise, or that just don’t compute. And those are common in extremis: in your kitchen stand four armed men who just hacked your neighbour apart; it’s crucial to act as normal and civilised and low key as possible. Without even thinking about it, you smile. You ask if they are hungry. A tsunami washes away your whole street. Standing watching on the hill you say, “Hey, there’s my house - what do you know, it’s floating!”

You all forget, this is the battle that Israeli's face almost day to day. Who else lives under near constant rocket fire? Who else has to bury relatives too often killed by hi-jacks, bus bombs and so on? They live with this constantly and they have all had military training, they are self disciplined!

IDF wasn't there

yes IDF was there coz at that time they were referred as terrorist oringiaztions b International community back then @@matteroffact1

​@@matteroffact1yes I could not believe but it is true look for the interview. She said they were treated well by Hamas and the IDF shoot everyone unconditionally 😮

​@@matteroffact1she said they were and they opened fired against Israeli hostages.

@@matteroffact1Lulz you obviously wouldn’t believe anything but what trump feeds you

In this interview she says that israeli forces shot their own civilians: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=K7X2k5dTzR6gD5lT

Can you name a single politician who is defending Hamas or has defended them in the past? It feels like your comment is nonsensical. Defending the population that has been suppressed, and made to suffer for literally decades... Is different. Israel is doing to the Palestinians what was done unto them by the world close to over a hundred years ago.

Trump said they where smart.

No one is defending Hamas. Many are defending the Palestinian people.

@@IcariumGamingI can and have seen it. That’s what “The Squad” does in a regular basis. Rashida just did that and pushed the fake hospital bombing story after the entire world learned it was fake. It’s outrageous

@@Muttinchopsforeverandalwaystell me you don’t know the difference between groups without telling me you don’t know the difference…

With all the IDF air strikes.. hostages are probably under the rubble.

NO THANKS TO THE ISRAELI POLICE WHO TOOK HOURS TO SHOW UP.

This is the initial interview ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=1-IILi85ItiMHjgA

It's almost like all the good things a group does can not erase all the bad things a group does.

It's almost like there is no proof. Surely someone screenshot the 'previous interview'. Careful what you believe.@@Mike_Jones281

I'm from Israel, and this is definitely Not what she said!

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rTQcjyhPOIk.htmlsi=bmr7g2K0_whwSb0X What is said here? Is the translation not correct?

@@nanon8501 - Prove it !