Тёмный

Here’s Why Elon Musk is Wrong About Hyperloop 

Interesting Engineering
Подписаться 1,5 млн
Просмотров 18 тыс.
50% 1

Elon Musk proposed the concept of a super-fast underground train system called Hyperloop in a 2013 white paper. The proposed system could potentially reach a maximum speed of 760 mph, cutting travel times drastically. However, the idea itself traces its origins back to 1799 when British engineer George Medhurst conceptualized a similar pressurized tube transport system, called Vactrain.
Two key factors could make the Hyperloop faster than any existing train. The first is the use of Maglev (magnetic levitation) technology that eliminates friction between the train and its tracks, allowing for much faster speeds. The second is vacuum tunnels that remove air resistance, resulting in higher speeds, lower energy consumption, and reduced maintenance costs.
Despite these technological possibilities, the financial feasibility of such a project is questionable. Elon Musk initially estimated the cost of a San Francisco-Los Angeles line at around $6 billion, but later evaluations have suggested significantly higher costs. For instance, Hyperloop One estimated a 107-mile line would cost nearly $13 billion. Maintenance costs have also been historically high for Maglev lines. These factors cast doubt on the affordability of tickets, initially projected to cost $20 but now estimated closer to $100.
As of now, more than 10 companies are developing Hyperloop technology, with limited progress. Hyperloop One did complete a passenger test, but the achieved speed was considerably lower than initially predicted. The project still seems ambitious, but companies continue to explore this potential future of transportation.
Join our RU-vid channel by clicking here: bit.ly/3asNo2n
Find us on Instagram: bit.ly/3PM21xW
Find us on Facebook: bit.ly/3t2Huvb
Find us on Twitter: bit.ly/3wQfXzA
Find us on TikTok: bit.ly/3wNsBOu
Get the latest stories: interestingengineering.com/
Support IE for high-quality journalism: interestingengineering.com/su...

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

11 авг 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 64   
@prabh8808
@prabh8808 11 месяцев назад
Atleast The death will instant
@mrm7058
@mrm7058 8 месяцев назад
One challenge I see is, how can we create and maintain a vacuum in such a long tube? IMHO even without accidents or deliberate sabotage that would be difficult.
@lionel9038
@lionel9038 6 месяцев назад
not that hard when you are an ingineur.
@joeybulford5266
@joeybulford5266 5 месяцев назад
No. We can’t. It’ll kill people.
@markharmon4963
@markharmon4963 4 месяца назад
Because vacuum pumps are not invented yet?
@joeybulford5266
@joeybulford5266 4 месяца назад
@@markharmon4963 Because atmospheric pressure will crumple the tubes when you suck all the air out
@markharmon4963
@markharmon4963 4 месяца назад
@joeybulford5266 So, there are no competent engineers that can calculate a sufficiently resilient structure? We don't have aircraft, dams, bridges, buildings and nuclear reactors? There is no way to rapidly and uniformly restore ambient air pressure within a few seconds? It's not made from sheet metal.
@buffdnet
@buffdnet 8 месяцев назад
gladly the test tube has been removed and sold as scrap.
@liamcollinson5695
@liamcollinson5695 8 месяцев назад
My main problem is if a train breaks down it will block the entire thing i also think engineers will probably have nervous breakdowns trying to keep the thing maintained it just sounds so impractical. Then they is cost both the UK's hs2 and California's high speed rail has cost well over 100 billion USD so this is certainly not going to be cheaper
@joeybulford5266
@joeybulford5266 5 месяцев назад
The biggest problem is that the tube will expand and contract with temperature changes throughout the day. And it’ll result in pressure fluctuations which will absolutely result in people dying. THAT’s the biggest problem.
@Nuhaantje
@Nuhaantje 11 месяцев назад
I think the 'under 500 miles' connections are generally better of with regular high-speed rail. Investments are way lower than a new unproven technologie. If (and that is a big IF) a hyperloop has a business case, in my opinion it must be oceanic crossings. For example, Paris to New York or Tokyo to Los Angeles....
@thedubwhisperer2157
@thedubwhisperer2157 10 месяцев назад
The most 'real' that Hype Loop will ever get is in the endless CGI we're all sick of...
@pbinnj3250
@pbinnj3250 3 месяца назад
The video neglects to mention some important things. 1) Maintaining a train sized vacuum tube is beyond current technology. 2) Any breach of the vacuum tube with a train inside would result in an implosion similar to the one suffered by the Titan submersible. Everyone would be dead in moments. 3) To reach the desired speeds, the tube would only be allowed a slight curve, requiring the actual course to be closer to a half parabola, if not completely straight. 4) Passengers could only exit the train after the section of the tunnel depressurized.
@TSERJI
@TSERJI 8 часов назад
1) the vacuum isn't a full vacuum, just a medium vacuum. So even if there was an air leak (or even many air leaks), it wouldn't affect the tunnel. 2) we have strong enough materials like cold-rolled steel that could easily hold up the pressure of the outside atmosphere without imploding. 3) the pod could slightly slow down at curves. It doesn't need to go 760mph for 100% of the journey lol. 4) not a big deal. Just put a pressurization/depressurization chamber at each station.
@randomuser2461
@randomuser2461 11 месяцев назад
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess this would be useful off earth in a zero or near zero environment and this is being done to pretest something for a colony concept. Most of spacex's stuff seems to be being done for this reason.
@joeybulford5266
@joeybulford5266 5 месяцев назад
Yep. It would work great on the moon. Wouldn’t even need the tube. It’d prbly just look like a train.
@TouchingSand
@TouchingSand 4 месяца назад
I’m not worried about getting to where I’m going 30-50 minutes faster than the next fastest option but more importantly is having more space to work while I’m travelling so the time I’m travelling can be used efficiently.
@Guesswhokk
@Guesswhokk 11 месяцев назад
Hyperloop was never intended for "mass transit", moving mass number of people in any given day. If you want "mass transit transport", go with trains
@markharmon4963
@markharmon4963 4 месяца назад
To much land, energy and structurally inefficient, noisy, creates slums, dirty, and dusty. Everybody loves a rail train. That is true enough. Nobody wants to live near one.
@TSERJI
@TSERJI 8 часов назад
@@markharmon4963 and too slow & expensive
@markharmon4963
@markharmon4963 3 часа назад
@@TSERJI Yeah, I was comparing to the possibilities of hyperloop. I hope that was understood.
@marzero116
@marzero116 9 месяцев назад
He should have just daid hes building a Stargate......itd have been as realistic
@pbinnj3250
@pbinnj3250 3 месяца назад
I thought Elon admitted that he brought up the hyperloop, whose concept is about a century old, to try and kill the rapid transit train being built between SF and LA.
@a.s.f.g.8345
@a.s.f.g.8345 11 месяцев назад
It will never happen, if it's actually built it will be extremely expensive and will not be widely used, just build normal trains and high speed rail and stop giving money and attention to billionaire's vanity projects
@widodoakrom3938
@widodoakrom3938 11 месяцев назад
True
@HablaCarnage63
@HablaCarnage63 9 месяцев назад
Except high speed rail won’t happen here either
@trucksanddirt1506
@trucksanddirt1506 6 месяцев назад
​@@HablaCarnage63it's happening. Miami - Orlando is operational. Vegas - LA in construction.
@stuboyd1194
@stuboyd1194 6 месяцев назад
1:35 why does the hypothetical hyperloop tunnel from LA to San Francisco appear as a perfectly straight line? No land based or underground route is ever perfectly straight.
@markharmon4963
@markharmon4963 4 месяца назад
Because it is a geographic lesson showing the scale and region of the problem.
@shancharan7834
@shancharan7834 7 месяцев назад
He must continue this project and fix those engineering and maintaining challenges, because it's the future. If Elon Musk is't gonna do it, some one will one day.
@RJ_MacReady
@RJ_MacReady 2 месяца назад
Elon isn't doing a thing lol
@janverbanck
@janverbanck 11 месяцев назад
Let's just reserve this for the connection between future Moon (no atmosphere) or Mars (little atmosphere) settlements. Yes folks, there the vacuum is virtually free of costs, nothing complicated about it and may also certainly be used and profitable for short trips.
@iddqd06
@iddqd06 11 месяцев назад
I thought we’ve moved past this hyperloop bs🤔🤔
@nioxic77
@nioxic77 11 месяцев назад
oh, dont worry. this will get a ton of views. hyperloop will never work in the real world, but... as a theoretical transportation mode, its fun
@cr10001
@cr10001 10 месяцев назад
@@nioxic77 Why not teleports? Even quicker and just precisely as realistic as hyperloop. (i.e. zero)
@trucksanddirt1506
@trucksanddirt1506 6 месяцев назад
Apparently not, my University still have a Hyperloop club
@GregoryJByrne
@GregoryJByrne 6 месяцев назад
We broke the sound barrier by getting up into the jet stream which is spun west to east by the earth's 1,000 mph west to east rotation. So instead of depressurizing the hyperloop pressurize it with 800 mph jet/slip stream air flow.
@joeybulford5266
@joeybulford5266 5 месяцев назад
What?
@markharmon4963
@markharmon4963 4 месяца назад
A chief benefit of creating a high elevation environment down low is saving all of the energy required to climb to that elevation and still having the benefit of low air resistance. By using a charge of air to blow the carriage down the pipe , you have to evacuate the system every time you send one down the line. Electric linear motors are more efficient and can be used for regenerative braking.
@markharmon4963
@markharmon4963 4 месяца назад
@@joeybulford5266 Good answer.
@user-me2dy6ct4z
@user-me2dy6ct4z 6 месяцев назад
China has succeeded the test last month, will make the first route from Shanghai to Hangzhou in 7 minutes.
@TonyStone3000
@TonyStone3000 6 месяцев назад
They are lying. Tech doesn't exist.
@borusa32
@borusa32 3 месяца назад
Elon needs to find inspiration in the wings of a butterfly and forget about rocket trains and space ships to Mars.
@SixSioux
@SixSioux 10 месяцев назад
Common people will never trust to travel in this closed claustrophobic moving tombs. This transportation system has ZERO appeal and is set to fail.
@liamkehoe5957
@liamkehoe5957 9 месяцев назад
The cost of having a Hyperloop in the UK between London and the North would be way more affordable that the current HS2 project that is close to £160bn. Hyperloop type projects will be necessary to transport large amounts of people in a quick low CO2 way.
@trucksanddirt1506
@trucksanddirt1506 6 месяцев назад
Hyperloop is vapor. What you have now is real. You can't compare vapor to reality.
@lexlayabout5757
@lexlayabout5757 5 месяцев назад
A railway (H-L is one, basically) in a massive tube with vacuum systems, maglev, and all that involves will be cheaper than a railway on wheels in the open? Musk dreamed his low cost by assuming H-L wouldn't need to buy the land beneath, and by making the tubes so small that passengers have to lie nearly flat. As for CO2 : HS2 is electric anyway. A lot of HS2's costs are planning and legal - for H-L it would be even higher.
@pbinnj3250
@pbinnj3250 3 месяца назад
Last point. The lesson we may all need to learn. Wealth is not a sign of intelligence, and we need to stop listening to the second biggest man-child in America.
@widodoakrom3938
@widodoakrom3938 11 месяцев назад
HSR is good enough maglev train still too expensive Hyperloop isn't realistic
@lexlayabout5757
@lexlayabout5757 5 месяцев назад
Musk did not propose H-L in tunnels, but raised on pylons; and he did not propose maglev, but an "air hockey table". He got the price cheap because the tube he proposed was small (passengers would nearly have to lie flat) and he assumed H-L would not need to pay for the ground underneath. All utter bullshit of course. BTW, Hyperloop One have gone bust since this video was made.
@gracemwende8054
@gracemwende8054 2 месяца назад
Congratulations my heart forever
@dougaldouglas8842
@dougaldouglas8842 11 месяцев назад
The engineering is prohibitive
@AncientRylanor69
@AncientRylanor69 11 месяцев назад
U
@entropyachieved750
@entropyachieved750 11 месяцев назад
It's not going to happen for a multitude of reasons most of which are technical and not feasible so let just move on shall we
@timothy4772
@timothy4772 8 месяцев назад
This is hilarious. On paper everything is simple. All it takes is an earthquake and the vacuum tube becomes an impenetrable tomb with one hundred people in a panic.
@supotsae-eung4806
@supotsae-eung4806 11 месяцев назад
ok dont with musk fan bye
@filmaker256
@filmaker256 11 месяцев назад
People would be injured going that fast lol
Далее
Bankrupt - Hyperloop One
14:45
Просмотров 722 тыс.
The Rise and Rule of Elon Musk
42:46
Просмотров 2,1 млн
НРАВИТСЯ ЭТОТ ФОРМАТ??
00:37
Просмотров 3,7 млн
QVZ PREMYER LIGA
00:18
Просмотров 701 тыс.
Why tech billionaires suck at fixing transport
13:50
Просмотров 426 тыс.
Biggest Megaprojects Under Construction in 2024
20:25
Просмотров 642 тыс.
How Tesla Reinvented The Electric Motor
15:11
Просмотров 289 тыс.
ROCKET that LITERALLY BURNS WATER as FUEL
19:00
Просмотров 1,5 млн
How SpaceX Reinvented The Rocket Engine!
16:44
Просмотров 582 тыс.
Hyperloop could revolutionise the way people travel
3:20
Incredible Road Technologies That Are Insanely Cool
30:17
Aura 879dsp новинка и хит
0:48
Просмотров 200 тыс.