"Hindi Imposition" Row Still Simmering In Tamil Nadu? 

Tamil should be made compulsory in cow belt as many north Indians are nowadays entering TN for jobs and business.

Believe us, When Hindi imposed on Tamilnadu - We will make Our own Independent Country called "The Republic of Tamilnadu".

Hindi in the Computer Age!

Dr. Kasthurirangan is here because of science and whatever he learnt he could have thought about it is in his mother tongue why so much emphasis in Language which can be learnt in GOOGLE TRANSLATE Artificial INTELLIGENCE IN HINDI

Who is Kasturirangan? He is a fanatical brahmin and not a Dravidian. So a dravidian should be chairing the NEP.

NEVER HINDI!

Policy is cunningly introducing Hindi under 3 language formula and removed the word imposition. But 3 language formula eventually does that !!

Now it looks so ackward that both the anchor and the other participant shows their anger the moment Mr kasthuri rangan said Hindi is not mandatory shows how chaluvanist

If 22 languages is burden for students then better to have only 2 languages.

Don't impose any language on the any person who don't want to learn. We must be learn how Pakistan get devide due to impose urdu on bangali speakers. Let him to choose his /her own choice.

How come learning hindi...a disrespect to any other regional language dear

Separate TN, WB and J&K from India. India will be peaceful. They are nuisance elements, always fearful of Aryan-Dravidian conflict (as staged by Britishers).

In order to stay unite and become one india they need to follow like how china did between 1949 to 1979. Many people were opposed to unite, although the leader was evil and never give up, too many people killed in the process but it all paid off in the end. Democracy is the biggest problem in india. The leader have to follow whatever people want. 😂😂😂

If hindi is an official language of india then United states of south india(USSI) will raise.. Be careful..

Since every school in India teaches English, why can't it be our link language? Why do Tamils have to study English for communication with the world and Hindi for communications within India? Do we need a big door for the big dog and a small door for the small dog? I say, let the small dog use the big door too! C. N. Annadurai

No need of Hindi language in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. If they impose Hindi on us then it will be a stepping stone of dividing India into pieces.

Bye bye hindi

No need hindi in tamilnadu tamil, and English enough

I'm suggesting Tamils to learn Germans ... So many jobs in germany they will accept with open hand if you know German which is modern and scientific. Instead of learning panipuri language

Dont try to impose Hindi on non-hindi speaker, if you do, non hindi speaker states will be seperated from india and the remaining india will be a landlock country

Even though I am from North, just coz of the music of A R Rahman, I would rather learn Tamil and not hindi. 😊 and of course the treasure of complex and blissful Carnatic music

Malayalam & english only,

Dont try to impose hindi language in WestBengal, if you do West Bengal will be seperated from INDIA like Bangladesh, English and Bengali language is enough for Bengali people

Telugu states doesn't accept Hindi imposition.. It's better to have local language(Telugu, Tamil, Malayalam, Kannada) and English which helps to communicate with the world..

India has 23 national languages. Central Govt Should give equal importance for all languages not for Hindi and Sanscrit( Dead language). Our Govt try to Strengthen our Unity and Diversity insted of spoiling.

English is superior language and hindi is inferior language. It is Better to talk in english

English is enough.

Free Dravida Nadu, Free Kashmir, Free Arunachal Pradesh!!!

Dr. Kasturirangan can speak Hindi. Great! I’d be interested to know if the hosts can speak another language besides Hindi and English?

What social change they are talking about from North India???

We South Indians not accept imposing hindi on us. We love our Mother tongue.. No need of Hindi.. If they want hindi we want our Seperate South India as a Country.. Be careful when it comes to Mothers tongue we fight for Seperate country

what is so good about hindi. why shd we learn a dead language where english is the common language and international language. do u know that yr north indians are strugglisng to speak english when they travel to abroad???.

Two language policy is enough for us TN. if the central try to imposition, it's causes maybe 1938,1964...who knows 2019.. Tamilian

The day Hindi speakers learn a South Indian or any other non Hindi language , you can impose this Hindi on others. Right now as 80% of Hindi speakers are uneducated and don't speak any other languages. So it's easy to tell other to learn Hindi practice what you preach to. others first you Hindiwalla Get educated , then learn another Indian language.

Hi Third language will be Chinese or Spanish

2 language policy is ok , so that in schools students can focus on other important subjects like maths ,physics and etc

Even i married nepali girl who raised in Delhi she never forced me to learn Hindi we always speak in English and everything going fine what's the m f reason you guys forcing us to learn the dead language?

If it all the states implement non-mandatory 3 language policy, will all the schools facilitate for requisite language teachers to teach the 3rd language opted by each student (like marathi, telugu, kannada, malayalam, bengali etc.) which is highly impractical. Also why should one restrict to 3 languages? the ultimate motive is to impose Hindi. When India doesn't have a national language then why are you trying to make one? accept & glorify what you have (22 major languages).

A Hindi regional language graduate gets 7000/- rs and a English graduate gets 15000+ per month salary.

kasthoori why dont north indian learn tamil and make it as national language and tamil is alreay a old ancient language. dont tell us what to do tamils know what language to adopt. u are adment . u have already set in yr mind to bull doze through. sorry babe. it wont happen in tamil nadoo. go and play with other states. we have already seen 3 demonstration for hindi protest from 1947 till now.

If u all want hindi in india fine we tamils will go out from india. U talk hindi in north we talk tamil in south.

Who is that guy with specs and grey shirt.his mannerism sucks.your TrP will go down.he is a horrible find

This is an absolutely ridiculous proposition and it is a great waste of time. Why should the third language even be Indian? Our future generations need to be global to grow our global footprint. English, State language and any other language of one's choice.

18.30 - 18:35 Kasthuri Rangan was dead inside 😂😂

Hindi is not a National language. Just because 40% people are speaking and just by one vote difference become official language with English. Hindi neither a lerature language nor a technical language to study for years. For If I need to learn Hindi all facilities are available and can be learnt in 30 days for communication nothing more to spend time in it. English no more a colonial language but become International language worth to study. Hence don't impose Hindi and Tamil is an ancient high literature language to cherish with.

Dear Friends and Family members, Can we learn Medicine and Engineering in Hindi ? Why our kids should waste their 60 % of their learning time in learning languages ? Give more importance to science and Technology. I prefer English which is mandatory ( IELTS ) to work in US, Australia, Singapore, Canada, UK ...where the unemployment rate is lesser than North India. Most of the Forward Communities learn English and Earn good salary in US. We know what is good for our children's future. BJP wants to make Tamils underdeveloped and poor. If amithsha cares about Nation let him concentrate on economy and creation of more Job opportunities.

Which Hindi you guys are talking? One Hindi which one corner to another corner people understand or the official Hindi which even Hindi doesn’t understand and speak. Question is just for my knowledge. I read ,write and speak Hindi but official Hindi is alien for me.

Only a person with a stupid ideology can ask everyone in India to accept Hindi. Jo saccha desh bhakt hai woh sabhi bhashao ko barabar ka darja dega.

Will India remain as a Union of states ???

If all north Indians speak English, then why should a south Indian study Hindi. Its an unnecessary waste of time, money and effort. Please don't put that burden on kids.

Make pani puri and gutka as national food.

Am an Indian My Mother Toung is TAMIL

Make Every State languages (14) Official. Then TN may think about hindi. Union govt exams and services were given in Hindi/ English only. iitjee ibps ssc iocl etc. So we prefer english only.

Why is Education even in concurrent list , it should be in state list

People who wrote the draft didn't look in to the available infrastructure, number of faculty members, the quality of the available faculty before coming up with a plan. State governments barely have any money to pay the salaries of the teachers and most of them are substitute teachers! I thought a scientist would have enough sense to look at resources at hand before jumping into a plan. First make sure every poor kid have access to good education. Look to improve the quality of education. Have enough funds and resources to achieve objectives that are realistic. This draft education is just a fantasy book.

Third language should be optional and hindi speaking states should learn one south indian language and south should learn one north

EINSTEIN STORY 💯 One day Einstein Makes the large hole in door for mother cat 😺 In few days, next to the large hole, he makes small hole for kitten 🐈 Then only he realised, large hole itself enough for both kitten and cat That small hole is Hindi That large hole is English English is enough to connect peoples in All over world🌍 assuming North India part of world

Bad to impose hindi, that result from PM/administration, capital city location and common language all are hindi centric, which is the reason create ego and advantage to hindi natives to bully other Indians. Research shows there are other Indian languages more original, qualified and older compare to hindi. Where is the separation of power and justice? All language Indians fight for independance not to make it as hindi centric. All non hindi speakers should unite against this hindi colonization before they lose their identity and treated as second class citizen in their own country. India need to kick out the few hindi centric states and politicians if they fail to adapt and respect the India's rich diversity and exploit other states money. Boycot all things hindi till International language english is the only common language and all major indian languages are given equal importance in the central, for unity, progress and peace. United Nation should help against this injustice. India should have a strong non hindi centric political party to defend against this bullying.

What languages is Hindi speaking north Indians will learn?

Make tamil as the third official language of india. MK stalin's political career will fuckin end as he will have nothing left to crib about. This language fanaticism is keeping people distracted from real issues.

This man telling at 8 age of children can learn more then 4 language it is stupid mental thinking to put more pressure on child at 8 of age kids if we adopt his useless policy then all kids' life get collapsed .

Any one south Indian languages should be made compulsory to learn in North India because many Northis are moving to South India (Bangalore Hyderabad, Chennai)

Let us not get swayed away by random emotions but rather have the discussion or debate based on 'facts' and 'ethics': (1) Based on discrimination: The attempt from any Indian national Government of the day to declare Hindi as the 'national language' will make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-speaking people as 'second-class citizens' in their own country. Hindi is NOT the mother tongue of the majority of Indians. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is a foreign language to all Indians - it is foreign both to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi-speaking people and so, everyone gets an equal opportunity to compete at anything. Replacing English with Hindi will give a massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi-speaking people. English is a neutral language and avoids caste/race discrimination that happens in Indian languages. (2) Based on practicality: Hindi practically has NO use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor/engineer/technician etc by just knowing Hindi. Hindi is just for entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on the global level and has more value to science, technology, communication, etc than any other language. English works as a link language practically. I have typed this comment on RU-vid entirely in English and people all over the world on social media communicate mostly in English. (3) Based on uniqueness: If the number of speakers is the main criterion for the greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be designated as the national bird of India and not the peacock or the 'dog' should be made the national animal of India and not the tiger. It is the uniqueness of a language that makes it great and not some population factor. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of some 40% of speakers then he/she fails to look the other way the majority of Indians (60%) don't communicate in Hindi. Hindi can mostly be read and understood only in North India, and probably in Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, is already official in Tamil Nadu, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and to some extent in South Africa. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history way before Hindi. (4) Based on imposition: After independence, the states in India were formed on a linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people, and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have many states even when they say that they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajasthani, Awadhi, Maithili, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. Marathi used to be written in Mudy lipi (script) in the past but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for a set of languages like Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi, Konkani, Nepali lost their influences. The only vague defense BJP gives is the mudy script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is an irrational argument because the same press could typewrite all the other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and somehow just could not do the same thing for Marathi? Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own official use and the average Hindi person thinks that Marathi is some kind of a 'dialect' of Hindi. How ridiculous! Marathi historically came into existence way before Hindi was 'formed'. (5) Based on the two v/s three language formula: The two-language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to be selfish to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can try to understand basic English? English is sufficiently practical as a secondary language. (6) Based on the existing concept of India: Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, and the 1960s, and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language, etc. all this oneness stems from the BJP's RSS ideology which was inspired in turn by Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic, and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality. (7) Based on statistics: Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt. Non-Hindi speakers' tax money is taken to promote Hindi and a less or negligible amount is spent on other languages. Also, why is the taxpayer's money spent more on the promotion of Hindi and less or negligible for other non-Hindi languages? 60% of the budget is spent on Hindi, 20% on Urdu; for Tamil, it is 0, Bangla it is 0, for other languages it is 0; why? This is an utter disgrace! (8) Based on pride and politics: Pride goes before a fall and the average Indian is somehow blind to this and ironically remains to be. It makes Indians not only hypocrites but also narcissistic to its own neighbors. This is because the current BJP government is systematically trying to keep brainwashing the mass illiterate Indians on the internet through the IT cell and in the open rallies. The current BJP government is heavily influenced by the RSS. Before World War II, the RSS leaders admired Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Golwalkar took inspiration from Hitler's ideology of racial purity. The RSS since its formation opposed joining the independence movement against the British rule of India. Excessive pride will cause India's downfall. No wonder the RSS had its roots in Nagpur within Maharashtra (Golwalkar, Savarkar, Godse, Hegdewar, etc. were Marathis) and is now making the average Maharashtrian behave diplomatically two-faced as some kind of an illogical balance in the policy of appeasement for vote bank politics. Donald Trump in the USA, Scott Morrison in Australia, and Boris Johnson in the UK caused a lot of problems due to right-winged politics. People over there realized the mistake of voting for them and then overthrew the governments and brought center-left progressive governments back to power. In India, it is a big shame that people here are still mostly illiterate, blindly religious, and emotional. (9) Based on nationalism: India as a nation is different in concept compared to European nationalism. Nations in Europe have their own national languages because the influence of other languages in their own countries was moved down by a single language when the boundaries were drawn. In the European Parliament, they still have English as a practical link language. Some people state that China, Russia, Japan, etc. take pride in having their own national languages and not English and rely on translations all the time in dealing with other countries and not using English. But the communist crazy countries or the workaholic nations treat their own people in their own countries in un-democratic ways just to somehow economically prosper by degrading human rights. One-China policy is degrading Tibet, Taiwan, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. Japan's workaholic culture is straining the working-class people in the name of pride. Germany was the victim of Nazi ideology in the past. People all the time cannot rely on memory or machine translations/translators and waste time when the same would come naturally in simple communication by knowing basic English. Even the Chinese have started to aggressively teach their citizens English. India had prospered before on global level only because of English and now we are going back. (10) Based on globalization: Once upon a time, there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. The English people are called 'gentlemen' for a reason - although colonial they were not as racist as Germans. The British Empire in the 1920s was the largest empire in the world at any point in history. Whether you like it or not like it - it happened and people all over the world were either directly or indirectly influenced by it. The UK, the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand have the English Anglosphere with more geographical areas for economic opportunities. The USA is still the major global power and the internet in the 1990s popularized English even more leading to an increase in the demand for globalization. Nationalism has become useless in the sense that no country can be self-dependent now and the 'Athmanirbhar Bharat' strategy of the BJP government is notorious in the sense that being self-dependent will first hypocritically rely on Russia, USA, etc. for defense from China OR it will replenish the resources of the non-Hindi states to feed the needs of the impoverished Hindi states.

The NEP IS BULLSHIT POLICY AND DESTRUCTIVE PLOICY LIKE THE UNTOUCHABILITY OF SANATANA BARBARISM.. These incompetent bureaucrats must accept full responsibility for the poor status of hindi belt compared to Derabidian land

Polarization by govt either by Religion or by Language!! Ashamed to have been wasted a vote now!!

Shut your Hindi mouth in English debate. Every language has their own beauty. Keep our mother tongue, because that is our identity. Don’t push any languages into other language people.

Yes, 3 language policy must be scrapped and I still don't understand the necessity for 3 language formula when every single children could have the access to learn English and the respective mother language it becomes very fair and easy to make 2 language formula with the mother language plus English is just enough to every single citizen of our country and the union Government must make all languages study center around the country that must have all the 22 official languages

In this age of tech advancement , I believe one must have the freedom to choose a language and not forced. I see in g20 and g8's , the representatives speak their own language and the "translators" help with translation.I dont remember Putin speaking english neither Merkel..India should embrace every culture and the language...rather imposing. doesnt help sorry. Perhaps, educating , creating awareness and promoting language classes online ( via govt websites) may actually help reducing the language barrier.

CENTRAL GOVT., OFFICES., SHOULD BE DIVIDED INTO ZONES., AS H.Q., IN RESPECTIVE STATES, AND MAINTAIN DOCS., IN ENGLISH AND STATE LANGUAGE. IT IS ENOUGH. LET THE CENTRE MAINTAIN ONLY ARMY. LET THE STATES DECIDE ALL THE LAWS AND POLICIES.

Mr.Anchor why can't you another language than Hindi and English in the national media and you are intentionally imposing Hindi Please speak Hindi in your house but not in the English news channel for your good

mr. kasturirangan, you have failed the nation and students by not having the spine and courage to say NO to your govt. bosses on their wanting you to have the three language formula. the three language formula is stupid and unnecessary and burdens the student unnecessarily. no doubt this stupid formula will not be implemented and accepted by the wise states.

I can understand your facial expression is so angry when Mr Ram was high lighting the pitting reply for Hindi imposition

Mr. kasturirangan says that hindi is not mandatory and that students are free to select any language for their three languages. can anyone sane believe this to be practical ? Will one or two students of a class in say U.P. be able to learn tamil even if they want to ? - where will such a school in U.P. get a tamil teacher to teach these one or two students ? Can a student in Orissa learn marathi if he wants to ? where will the Orissa school find a marathi teacher to teach one or two such students ? is this three language formula practical? this three language formula is highly deplorable and the statements being given by the govt. ministers and mr. kasturirangan that hindi is not being imposed and that students are free to choose their language is a fraud. The central govt. wants to bring hindi through the sly as the third language because only that language teacher can be made available prcatically. My advise to all the states is just follow the T.N. govt methodology of having only two language policy in your respective states.

Everyone can see the intellectual gap between Mr Ram and the so called "rocket scientist"

When the name of hindi and sanskrit languages are referred why the union Government didn't mention the names of other Indian languages by name and this clearly revealed the idiotic attitude of the union Government to promote hindi at the cost of non hindi languages people and it is nothing but cheating

Fraudulent anchor supporting paani poori walaa language 🔥

If you want united India respect indian Constitution that Hindi is one among national language but not the only national language. Hindi is not the only official language English language also an official language. For if you say Hindi is required to communicate it can be learnt in 30 days nothing to waste years to learn it as it doesn't has high literature or technical source to learn for self development to get world knowledge. Such being the case don't impose it by law. English is no more a colonial language but it's an International language and tamil is a world's ancient language to cherish with it for us. Tamil is our Identity.

As a non-Hindi speaking East Indian, I don't think anyone is trying to impose anything on us. Well then again, my braincells are working properly & I'm not falling for any agendas.

Hindi imposition is no less than apartiedd policy adopted by Britishers in south Africa why to impose anything in democracy

Manu 💐wonderful💐

muraleedharan is not a Tamil man

Mota bhai has lost it

We can solve our problems peacefully. But don't divide our country India. I am from West Bengal and I don't want to division of our country. Our neighbours enemy countries actually want this. So please don't divide our country for any problem. We can solve all the problem.

The anchor looks very angry against Mr ram for his perfect Hindi against talks Great Mr.Ram👍💐

Why these ppl beg others to learn their language?? If ppl want they learn depending on the requirement. Simple.

So you people are saying north india will choose Sanskrit as 3rd language and south should choose Hindi as 3rd. So the north never ready to learn south Indian languages right? Ridiculous...

Build statue on patel using your state money

The knowledge is from local environment. Local language and its written form make the children think and analyse the learning better. Unfortunately our children are become book knowledge or book worms. Hindi is no difference of English. Students can take as subject but main stream of teaching should be mother tongue. If you do not respect the co habbitance people of Tamil Nadu with rest of India will separate. Tamils will consider this as an invasion. Tamils do give first place to language then only religion etc. There are 100 million Tamils all over the world looking this seriously. Singapore ,Sri Lanka & several other countries its is official language. Tamil is from Indus civilization. India should announce Tamil as the Official national language of India for its history.

we should look what the best left by our seniors as busienss as gdp, failures languages itself turning a greatest disaster in each state coordination of taking up indian langagues in the best busienss for basic livilyhood itself stopped failures to accept corporate , company , internship, intreapreneur, entrepreneur technolgy obsolute , programs turning outdate when it reaches each state district do we ever think about failures so for best literature studies , best libraries in india what else under employment , empolyablity what so on GDP zero level how long the govt acting to promote pledging of GOLD and loan they give this all the said when comes to reality every dispose batch suffers more as underemployment a state sharing that there willingness to languages itself a greatest failure because they cannot offord renumeration for indian lanaguges in govt school and govt aided school then how possible that we fight that mulitple lanaguages as growth a school fail to bring what best source of learning ,languages are more important parents are jumping to cbse y , y not languages should be more , national lanaguage , regional language other state regional lanaguage of india is the necessity for basic lively hood

Hindi is a politician's tool in T.N.!Beyond Gudur the two language formula may not help! North Indians even if they know English do not speak it !

Forget about hindi just learn english and java it will help some resources: for non-hindi students

All a joke karunanidi familystudied Hindu and became ministers his son runs a school where Hindi is compulsory even fined ifTamil is used .. all a drama

Learning Hindi is useless.. Tamil and English enough

If Tamilians don't want Hindi imposed on them, then a good place to start would be to not impose Tamil, actively or passively, on those who are not interested. Like the saying goes, as you sow, so you reap.

Where is the three language policy in UP or Bihar ?

Insted of focusing on language, can we focus on women and education of children?

The common man struggle to learn two language, what is the need for three language

Read my papers on language dynamics

I think this is English channel

Don't try to impose