Тёмный

Historian Raul Hilberg: The fascist bureaucrats 

Matthijs Coevert
Подписаться 1,6 тыс.
Просмотров 24 тыс.
50% 1

Big questions like 'how was the holocaust possible' are often best answered by looking at history in detail, examining the minute. Than we find that de fascist bureaucrats where not that innovative. They did not have to invent much but could base their actions on presidents, a reservoir of experience build up over more than a thousand years. From the 4th century the Christian missionaries told the Jews "you may not live among us as Jews". The Secular governments who followed them from the late middle-aged decided "you may not live among us" and de Nazis finely decreed "you may not live". This suggest a natural progression leading to the extermination; from conversion to expulsion, to a territorial solution (final solution).
This reservoir of experience, this memory, remains with us today. For perhaps the fascist bureaucracy and its Endlösung der Judenfrage (Final Solution of the Jewish question) can't be separated from present-day policy on minorities in Europe.
From the documentary: Shoah
Interviewer: Claude Lanzmann

Опубликовано:

 

12 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 36   
@Overlorddz
@Overlorddz 2 года назад
Hilbergs explanation of this changed my whole understanding of what had happened. I am not jewish, but my family was persecuted in western europe and in south east asia during WW2 and the chance of their survival, especially considering their testimonies of how little life was worth back then, astonishes me. I can very much recommend his writings and references, also he primarily sticks to the German documentation from the Nazi era to follow his research.
@israelheller7524
@israelheller7524 2 года назад
I showed this to my fifth/sixth grade class. long story short, they got a near infinite amount out of it. from the severity and ingenuity or lack thereof that went into the holocaust, to the care and secret pains etched onto the careful historian’s face as he practices his vocation on camera. just… timeless commentary by a master engendered by a fellow master
@tomtrinchera8405
@tomtrinchera8405 3 года назад
How cool would it have been to take a class taught by Hilberg at his university in VT?
@OnePost909
@OnePost909 6 лет назад
Hilberg is one of the great historians of our time - learned, careful, subtle, driven to find the truth. You will read, in the comments section here, a lot of idiocy written by ignorant pigs. The world has always had, and will always have, ignorant pigs spouting their ideas. If you are a young person reading these words, I say this to you: learn to differentiate between wisdom and pig-stupidity, and you will go far.
@vinzelrato
@vinzelrato 3 года назад
"People who are converted can still be in secret Jews, people who have been expelled can yet return. But people who are dead will not return. Final Solution" Those words still haunt me to this very day...
@guybrush__threepwood
@guybrush__threepwood 5 лет назад
After watching this excerpt several times, I believe that much of what Hilberg says is a subtle comment on Lanzmann's endeavour - big questions, small answers.
@jandekker6008
@jandekker6008 3 года назад
Lanzmann gives him so much time in the film precisely because he wants to emulate his approach. The accretion of detail upon detail, rather than asking big questions. Lanzmann includes this very passage because it voices his own ambition. If Hilberg had any doubts about Lanzmann's aims, he wouldn't have taken part.
@tomhardy1856
@tomhardy1856 2 года назад
Absolutely not
@georgelino1609
@georgelino1609 Год назад
Everytime I read some paragraphs of his book: I came here to watch, one more time, this video. Everytime...
@tommyt1971
@tommyt1971 3 года назад
Just got a copy of Hilberg's Destruction of the European Jews -- it's 800 plus pages and it's the *shorter* version, which was orig 3 thick vols. Can't wait to tear into it.
@jesselopes5196
@jesselopes5196 3 года назад
Me too - it's highly descriptive - no explanations
@milk-it
@milk-it Год назад
I studied his work at university alongside many other holocaust historians. Hilberg is regarded as one of the most respected historians on the holocaust, because he’s empirical. Despite the subject matter, it was a pleasure to study such a historian.
@Rnr196970
@Rnr196970 Год назад
His words and his books. which I am now reading, are blessings. We are fortunate to have such study resources at our fingertips. Can you imagine the physical and instituitonal obtsacles he had to face?
@ellierose6
@ellierose6 4 года назад
Nothing can be changed until it is faced. History is not the past. It is the present. If we pretend otherwise, we literally are criminals. --James Baldwin
@MindbodyMedic
@MindbodyMedic 4 года назад
I can't say whether revisionists or orthodox historians are correct but the Zundel trial exposed a lack of hard documentary evidence. Hilberg is considered one of the top experts and he was taken to task by a skillful lawyer. Doesn't prove anything but the transcript makes for interesting reading
@jesselopes5196
@jesselopes5196 3 года назад
The dramatic crescendo of his thinking process here!
@nedimselmanovic9970
@nedimselmanovic9970 3 года назад
This man has history in his little finger
@tomhardy1856
@tomhardy1856 2 года назад
On the other hand your little brain has achieved absolutely vacuity and nothingness
@tb8865
@tb8865 6 лет назад
Jews frequently lived among European Christians at various points for over 1000 years. That was part of the origin of their conflict.
@aaroncalgary
@aaroncalgary 8 лет назад
Kicked out of over 100 countries. Always because people are mean to jews. That's bad luck.
@aaroncalgary
@aaroncalgary 8 лет назад
Aaron Richards no, jews aren;t white
@pasisovi
@pasisovi 5 лет назад
He admits his hypocrisy and bias, producing a distorted work, on his very first paragraph of this interview.
@tomhardy1856
@tomhardy1856 2 года назад
Totally false, like every fascist pig you are just a functional illiterate who can"t understand texts of barely higher complexity.
@harbinger6753
@harbinger6753 2 года назад
Imagine believing in this nonsense
@crane1735
@crane1735 2 года назад
Imagine believing in God
@tomhardy1856
@tomhardy1856 2 года назад
Imagine being a shithead like you
@pkdick1
@pkdick1 Год назад
Imagine being someone who would leave a comment like that after listening to Hilberg.
Далее
Liberators and Survivors: The First Moments
15:27
Просмотров 6 млн
Ethics after the Holocaust | 6 of 9
1:02:10
Просмотров 16 тыс.
УДОЧКА ЗА 1$ VS 10$ VS 100$!
22:41
Просмотров 364 тыс.
Claude Lanzmann on Shoah
4:53
Просмотров 69 тыс.
Noam Chomsky - The Crimes of U.S. Presidents
11:35
How Did Ordinary Citizens Become Murderers?
1:29:22
Просмотров 1,6 млн
Interview in Treblinka
23:35
Просмотров 48 тыс.