you should put Bosnian church, (11.-15.century), those who believe that are like aryan christians.. orthodox church was establishted after ottomans came in Bosnia..
A fetish is something that is believed to give good luck, like a totem or a clover. Then the meaning extended to include sexual fetishes too, things that shouldn't be sexual that are regarded as such. For example, hands
@@osamatass1174 That is according to the abrahamic religions. Not according to the history or to the scientific findings so far. So it's nothing more than bs.
@@osamatass1174 Oh and if you still insist, spiritual satanism claims to having existed since the beginning. They also claim to be "real pagans". Considering legitimacy of satanism and abrahamic religions are same (which is non existent), you are wrong once again.
Colors have just been associated with maps for a long time. Even outside of paradox, Catholic has always been yellow/gold. I’m guessing a large part of it has to do with its association with Spain, who’s colors were gold and red
This is very well done. Just one small note. Catholicism and Orthodoxy didn't officially split from one another until 1054. Prior to this there *were* religious differences between the Western Christians who would eventually become Catholics and the Eastern Christians who would eventually become Orthodox Christians. But at this point they wouldn't have seen one another as belonging to separate branches of Christianity just yet. Other than that, great job!
@@gigachaduneli1121 present day yes but many muslims of georgian ancestry are there in Turkey and Iran their not georgian culturally but have that DNA, cause Georgia was part of both Ottoman and Iran many Pashas were of Akhbaz and georgian desent. but the georgian heartland remained othrodox
@@samet7422 Kotu bisey dememiş ak kemalizm gayrimüslimleri asimile etti doğruda yaptı sadece gayrimüslimlerlede kalmadı müslüman kürtleride asimile etti.
I found a mistake, since 1945 on polish part of Pomerania there is no protestants because after WW 2 all German (protestant) are replace by Polish people (Catholics)
@@HBGamingTD Jan Hus was a bohemian church reformer from 14./15. century. He was burned alive, but his teachings got wide support and his followers started a religious civil war, defeating even several catholic crusades. If you want to learn more, just seach for Jan Hus, Hussites or Hussite wars.
@Kirman Selçuklularının Haritasını Arayan Dost sürpriz ! Ama daha önce hiç yapılmamış zor bir video. Ha bide Rise Of The Atatürk atçam bitmek üzere video.
No it isn't,the way he portrays it makes it look like north Africa Iberia and Levant were 100% Muslim,he doesn't take in consideration the Christian pocket minorities in these regions
@@cv4809 In fact in some regions of Iberia, North Africa and Levant Christianism was a majority. This map shows the religion that is ruling in the region, not what's the religion of its people.
Felipe Correia Borges It wasn’t the only reason, but Christianity did a few things that destabilized the Empire First, it created a parallel power structure to the state, who would increasingly come to control it. (The church) Secondly it replaced the more or less toleration of Hellenism with the all or nothing doctrine of Christianity, causing religious tension as Christian Emperors sought to enforce the religion across the Empire. Third it was incredibly devisive, even among Christians. People were suddenly willing to kill and die over minor doctrinal differences. (And they did) religious violence and even riots became common, as did assassinations of Bishops by rival clergymen. Fourth it got the state involved in these politics. The Arian/Nicene conflict would cause a back and forth between the two sects, causing one to be deemed ‘heretical’ and doggedly persecuted by the state trying to enforce orthodoxy. Essentially it destroyed part of the social fabric of Roman society, and divided Romans at a time when they needed unity.
@@drulo1000 may Allah guide you who believe "Jesus is the son of god."may the Islamic empire rise again and our signs are so clear to the non believers
@@trippytubs8689 Jesus is LORD of lords and King of kings He is the Alpha and Omega The Beginning and the End The Lord is who he is He is Christ ..... Jesus
@@trippytubs8689 may the LORD JESUS Save you and you accept him for it is written He who has the son has life But he who is without the son is without life
There are 2 grave mistakes I encountered in this video: 1: the great schism was in 1054. Here it's depicted way too early 2:Ireland was christianized BEFORE southern germany. Southern germany got converted by the irish.
The "official" date may be 1054, that's because we have to put the limit somewhere. There have been differences since a couple centuries between western and eastern rites at that point. Charlemagne's coronation was one step in splitting the Church.
@@wizardsummoner9124 Well, a schism is demarcated by a formal (official) split in communion. Disputes over theological heresies generally take years, or possibly even decades, before the proclamation of a judgement, as it's rather dangerous to completely sever a heretic from the church, thus granting them their own autonomy, which can have destructive consequences. Hence, it's safer to attempt to reconcile said heretic to the truth by any means necessary before the finalization of a schism. There wasn't a formal split in communion between the Roman/Leonine and Greek/Cerularian Patriarchates Patriarchates until the mid-eleventh century, pertaining to controversies over the Filioque (a dispute over as to whether the Spirit also proceeds from the Son or not), unleavened bread, married clergy, etc. In fact, there are major events within the history of the Church that he left out. Events that were of a much more serious theological/philosophical nature than the petty coronation of Charlemagne, which was moreso of a political nature. The Monothelite Schism of the seventh century and the Iconoclastic Schism of the eigth century were both left out. Nevermind the Investiture Crisis of the West, beginning in the late eleventh century. The Holy Roman Emperor wasn't even in communion with Pope Gregory VII in the late eleventh century, and in fact, installed his own Pope, Clement III. Can't forget about the Avignon Papacy either.
@@somatia350 they don't !!!! muslims don't respect others religions !! they always say islam is the only true religion !! all non muslim will go to hell ! it's in the coran ! the most intolerant religion in the world !! if you are a non muslim and you want to marry a muslim woman you have to convert to Islam otherwise he does not accept marriage !!
Good concept but I find a bit inaccurate (especially in the Balkans and in the Caucasus.) but I find it hard to make a 100% percent accurate video though. but again a good concept and a nice video.
Yeah, for being such a wide scale, both in time and distance, it provides about an as accurate map as can be reasonably expected. Of course they’ll be inaccuracies, especially around the places that are a mess, but overall it is very well made, and considerable effort was made to be as accurate as possible
@@user-km8bu8cg1c And if you're not native African, American or Oceanian you also have turk or mongol dna. Judging by your attitude, probably your ancestors have had unwelcome turkic visitors at night.
Great video, nicely done! One major thing you left out though: the Hussites in 1400s Bohemia. It was basically Protestantism before Protestantism was a thing.
Mehmet Yilmaz my friend there is a minority but the most of them are orthodox. There’s some villages where Pomaks live but he needs to show the majority
This is really well done. Small quibble: Cathars, Bogomils, Paulicians and Tondrakians are missing. Ancient Gnostics are missing too, but not sure if they ever were the majority anywhere, it's hard to say. Cathars, Bogomils, Paulicians and Tondrakians certainly were the majority in certain areas for hundreds of years, and are certainly distinct religions. There was even a Paulician state (founded specifically on that basis) centered around Omeril/Amara and Tephrike/Divrigi in modern day Turkey, from 843 to 878. On the whole though, this is a very accurate and detailed video.
I noticed that the christian conversions of Scandinavia were shown too early. You showed Denmark as 899 when it should be 960. You showed Sweden as 960-1000 when it should be around 1050. And Smaland didn't convert until around 1120. Oh, and one more thing, you showed the Sami as having converted by 1640 when they didn't convert until around 1720.
@Youssef Muhammad إسلامbullshit :D do you think all Islamic states offered tax like Arab caliphates? Seljuks, Timurids, Ottomans, Qara and Aq Qoyunlus and Safavids?
@@messiah6670 it’s a fact that Zoroastrians, Jews and Christians were better off in Islamic lands. Many people emigrated from Georgia to the Ottoman Empire because of the opportunities there. Learn your history first.
@@lightscameras4166 Please stop teaching me my own history,MANY PEOPLE WERE ENSLAVED IN OTTOMAN EMPIRE, there was a slave trade in western george from 16th to 18 th century and almost 100 000 georgians were sold in Ottoman empire and same amount were enslaved in Persia from eastern Georgia
Christianity for Georgia was compared to nationality. That has always protected us from dissolving and disappearing, because we always had to fight against numerous enemies to survive.🇬🇪
@Marwan . B they used swords to convert Albanians and Bosnians the Caucasus never really was under the ottomans For a long period compared to the Balkans or the levant
beautiful attempt for religious map, but somewhat biased pro Islamic -Greek Thace is totally Ordotoxa is the green belt in the south of Bulgaria is much smaller Polish Pomerania turns overwhelming Catholics after 1945 -No Show the northern tip of Morocco as Catholics, Ceuta and Melilla are majority Catholics to this day "Where were the Alawites in Syria?" Islâm is not a single block all Irreligious spots must be larger in Scandinavia and East Germany Some Historical Mistakes -destined much more for Islamism to become majority in the south of Spain, Andaluza only became Islamic majority around the year 1000, in compensation some green spots must remain in Spain until 1600 Southern Italy has never been of the Islamic Majority, it should only have some green spots in Campania at most
Renato Campos Sicily was Muslim majority from the 10th to 11th centuries, also Ceuta and Melilla were not shown most likely due to their small size as they are just single cities
Jesus is also a prophet in islam. God sended many prophets to the humanity. The first human which is Adam was also a Prophet. Moses Jacob, Solomon, Jesus, Muhammed all are Prophets with the same message. Praying to One God with nothing in between. But people changed the messages of the Prophets in many religions and the books too. The only book that has not changed is the Quran. Im not telling to that the Muslims have not changed, yes they changed a lot mostly in a negative way but the message of God is still unchanged and written in the Quran. You will be shocked when you read there stories about Maria Yesus Moses and other Prophets. Prophet Mohammed is just mentioned 3 times in the book while there is a hole Chapter about Maria. Its a shame that nowadaya people see Islam just a Arabic religion.
Why only christians tho? Shouldnt god love everyone? I mean all u christians talk about is the fact that god and jesus loves everyone but u just said "bless all christians". Is that what god taught u?
@@_bruni_ this video is about religion so he had his mind only on his religion he forgot other's it's nothing to get shocked about God bless you you and all people in the world I hope it helps 🙏❤️
@Efe Alca they attacked him because many people converted to islam they knew it was right So the non believers like u feared him they attacked him and he win the war
@Efe Alca "In 628 the Meccan tribe of Quraysh and the Muslim community in Medina signed a 10-year truce called the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah. In 630, this truce was broken when the Banu Bakr, allies of the Quraysh, attacked the Banu Khuza'a, who had recently become allies of the Muslims. According to the terms of the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, the Arab tribes were given the option of joining either of the sides, the Muslims or Quraysh. Should any of these tribes face aggression, the party to which it was allied would have the right to retaliate. As a consequence, Banu Bakr joined Quraysh, and Khuza'ah joined the Muslims. They thus lived in peace for some time; but ulterior motives stretching back to the pre-Islamic period, ignited by unabated fire of revenge, triggered fresh hostilities. Banu Bakr, without concern for the provisions of the treaty, attacked Banu Khuza'a in a place called Al-Wateer in Sha'ban, in 8 AH. Quraysh helped Banu Bakr with men and arms, taking advantage of the dark night. Pressed by their enemies, the tribesmen of Khuza'ah sought the Holy Sanctuary, but here too, their lives were not spared, and, contrary to all accepted traditions, Nawfal, the chief of Banu Bakr, chased them in the sanctified area - where no blood should be shed - and massacred his adversaries. Khuza'ah at once sent a delegation to Medina to inform Mohammed of this breach of truce and to seek help from the Muslims of Medina being their allies."
AfghanHearts So what of the Muslims under Austro-Hungarian rule in Bosnia? If the Muslims didn’t persecute Christians in the Middle-East, they would still be around. You make it seem like it was just Christians that did it, but the Muslims committed scores of religious atrocities across Europe was well.
Well,since I am Albanian,I can assure you that northern Albania is Catholic.But seeing this video,makes me think the amount of time you needed to do this video,and i really appreciate your work,and you instantly got a like and a sub from me.Keep up the fantastic work bro.
@M D What do you mean by "Never!" Russia and Serbia will forever remain of the same ethnicity, and the same religion, Slavic and Orthodox. Both brothers forever. ❤
@@ptasznik5973 he is stole money from the people you pay and get in the heaven? Martin Luther did the right thing and tought the people to read the bible correctly
You splitted christianity into orthodox, catholic ect.Which is good cause it is more detailed but the fact that you didnt show sunni or shia makes this map a bit unproffesional.Other than that, great video mate.
Fair play, the map of Ireland is exceptionally accurate, I was watching to see if you were going to so the decline of Protestantism and the growth of Catholicism in the north.
Wrong. In the Transylvania-Romania area, the majority Walakians- Iflak in turk language (Romanians) were always Orthodox! Only the minority Hungarians and Germans were Catholic or Protestant!
Great job ! Btw, wasn't Arian christianity more present during 5th-6th century inside of Ostrogothic kingdom borders (nowadays Italy, Croatia, Bosnia)? Because on map, its clearly only present in nowadays Bosnia, but facts are that main Arian basilicas were in Ravenna too, as in its capital. (3:23 - 3:53) Also it would be interesting to add heretical movements, such as Catharism, Patharenism, Bosnian church, Bogomilism that were separate from official Orthodoxy and Catholicism.
@@kenansahbalayev534 Belki bilmediğimiz 1 milyon din var mesela yeni dünyanın dinlerinin geçmişine dair fikir edinmek çok zor daha adamların nerden geldiğini kesin bilmiyoruz.
Well sometimes is very hard to determine what do people actually believe in if there is the state religion but conquered/annexed/rebelling or lost areas with different traditions. But still, very nice work! I love "living maps" :-)
@@pedromain Monolothic religions are less tolerant to polytheistic religions you mean? Since Islam, Christianity and Judaism were respected in Europe and the Middle East. But if you were pagan you would face discrimination
@@mantea3481 yes! And against other monotheistic religions. Polytheists had easier to embrace and embody the gods of others. Monotheistic religions came to see other gods as false gods and something to be defeated.
Hello, Between the first years of the French Revolution, the religion was illegal in France but there was a revolutionnary cult called Cult of the Supreme Being.
@@plumebrisee6206 I said state atheism not secularism There is a difference between a state who purge religion and a state who separate it from it's policies In Europe the state is secular so it doesn't force people to follow religious laws but it doesn't persecute you for being Christian for example
@iLonghornful not necessarily. Other former communist countries like Poland and Romania are more religious than many Western European countries like France or Sweden.
Awesome! Though 1. Norse and Germanic are basically the same thing 2. You could have included the Jewish pockets along the Mosel, in the Netherlands and in Belorussia/ Ukraine 3. Eastern Germany is half and half atheist and Protestant today with a catholic pocket in upper Brandenburg 4. Paris, Berlin, Amsterdam and Major Cities in western Germany could have been in a lighter gold/ purple due to many atheists and Muslims living there
Why is anyone who is even slightly conservative considered a “fascist” or “nazi”? Also, usually conservatives look at the facts, while liberals look at feelings.
Great job! Just small mistakes and its happen everytime somebody trying to do so complicated job like you did. And without any help of lots of expert its almost impossible to do it perfect, i think. If you want to do it again and better, I have some tip for you. I missing the hussites after 1419 (pre-Protestant Christian movement) in Czechia. And than I am interested about protestants from Pyrenees in 2019. Who are they?
Thank you, I have been looking for a video on religons rather than political borders ever since mapping came on RU-vid. Keep up the good work, also... very nice that even tough you are a Turk, you made video which is neutral/no bias. This is true research, yearning for the truth.
The scythian and sarmatian tribes didn't practice tengriism. And also the pagan religions didn't have official names like norse or romuva,those were later adopted by neo-pagan groups, but I suppose it's for coordination. Other than that you've done a great job
I appreciate your work but there is a mistake and something is missing. Mistake is in the area of northwest Poland in years from about 1800 to 2019 (Prussia in XIX century). There was a big catholic minority along the Wisła river. The dominant religion in northern Poland (whole Poland...) after 1945 was and is catholicism. There was husitism in Czechia in XV century not mentioned on map. There was also huge jewish minority in eastern Polish Kingdom, also not mentioned on map. For dozens of years judasim was also the religion khazar's elites.
also catholicism and eastern churches divided finaly in 1052 officialy in 1054 in fact in 1052 not in 868 the paraschism off Focios was not made to clear fact and was quickly healed the schism off Cerularius and cardinal Humbert was a real schism in 1052
@@dpwXXIPolskaPolak I also see that Germanic paganism on this map replaced Slavic paganism which took place on the east of Laba (German Elbe) river in about 500-1100.
@@someoneonearth1617 But you can't argue with the Armenian lands. I mean on this map Christiantity vanishes in 1 second and then pops up a few centuries later. In reality the whole Armenia should be Christian (ofc until the genocide, then sadly the western part's missing)
@@user-cn5pm7zg1u yeah i was just about to comment about Thrace. There's no way Islam can be that dominant there now. The rest of the Balkans looks pretty accurate though.
@@duduchannel6729 orthodoxy IS the ancient Church, only the papist heretics have started diverging from the true faith as far back as the seventh century
@@milisavradovanovic9747On the 5, 6, and 7th centuries the Eastern Christians stilled obeying the pope, but with a bad translate of the filioque from latin to greek they believed that the Holy Spirit came only from the father and not from the son . Also, Saint Ignatius of Antioch who was disciple of Saint John and Saint Peter referred to the Church as CATHOLIC.
That began in 800, and until the late 11th century there were still a large number of pagans, though not the majority, so they still did raid. But the viking era came to an end around the time Christianity became huge in Scandinavia
Sorry to break it to ya despite your amazing work but in the Greek part of Thrace there are nowhere near as many Muslims as you portray in the map. There is a reason it is called Islamic minority and not majority.
![History of Religion in Europe [0-2019] Avrupa Din Tarihi](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
