Тёмный

How Bad Plane Maintenance Can Lead To A Disaster | FULL EPISODE | Mayday: Air Disaster 

Curious?: Science and Engineering
Подписаться 53 тыс.
Просмотров 74 тыс.
50% 1

When the instruments set off multiple alarms, pilots are confused about why it happened just after take-off. All three altimeters seem to be damaged, but after contacting Air Traffic Control, the pilot makes a series of mistakes that turn out fatal.
Do you trust pilot judgement, or would you fully trust technology?
Want to see more Mayday full episodes? Watch them here: bit.ly/3vYH6wJ
Watch more aviation disaster videos here: bit.ly/3KKZLDk
Mayday: Air Disaster - From Season 1 Episode 4 "Flying Blind": For flight crews, computerized systems like those on the Boeing 757 have introduced a new way of flying. Pilots are trained to fly the computer and the computer flies the plane. Conventional instruments are only used as back up. As long as the computer is working, the planes are simpler to operate. This is the story of what happens when the computers fail, and the pilots are left Flying Blind in the dark. It reveals crucial flaws in the computer systems that had remained hidden throughout the aircraft’s history. And it shows how a simple error and a lack of flight crew training can bring a giant, complex airliner to a deadly end.
Aeroperu Flight 603 bound from Lima, Peru to Santiago, Chile is a lightly loaded night flight. Captain Eric Schreiber and First Officer David Fernandez are highly experienced ex-Peruvian air force pilots with distinguished flying records for the national airline. Their 757 has been out of service and has just been brought back after a thorough clean.
All is normal as they leave the runway, but immediately after take off, the pilots begin to experience a confusing set of alarms and instrument indications. The 757 is equipped with three altimeters to give the plane its correct altitude reading. But all three now appear to have failed. The pilots ask the tower for their altitude, but the air traffic controller’s information comes from the on-board computer, making all his information wrong, too. Next, the error message “Mach Trim rudder ratio” comes up. This means that the airspeed indicators are also false, but the pilots can’t find this in the manuals.
Now the computer sounds an overspeed warning - the plane is flying too fast. Then there is a stall warning saying the plane is going too slow. The pilots struggle to understand what’s happening. It’s night and they don’t know how high or how fast they’re flying. They are flying blind, heading for disaster.
Now the crew is so confident of the tower’s altitude readings that they ignore the ground proximity warning when it starts up again. Fooled by the false confirmation of their altitude and unable to see in the dark, the crew crashes the plane into the ocean.
A massive salvage operation and investigation gets underway. Ten months earlier NTSB investigator Dick Rodriguez had investigated another 757 accident. The problem had been a blockage in the pitot static ports, which supply vital flight altitude and speed information to the computers. Was this crash due to similar causes?
The pitot static ports are small holes at the front of the wings. If they are blocked or impeded the computers will receive false information.
When the wreckage of Flight 603 was retrieved from the ocean, the piece of fuselage with the static ports revealed the terrible truth. The static ports were covered up with duct tape that had been put on to prevent water getting in during the cleaning - and it hadn’t been removed before flight. As a result, the computers were receiving false information.
Welcome to the OFFICIAL Curious? Science and Engineering RU-vid Channel.
Be inspired and take an exciting leap into the world of science and engineering!
We've got wacky experiments, magnificent creations and special moments that will change people's lives forever. Feeling curious? Good, we've got just the channel you're looking for.
Subscribe to the OFFICIAL Curious? Science and Engineering channel here: bit.ly/2Ygq8yx
#CuriousScienceandEngineering #ScienceandEngineering #24HourBabyHospital #BigAustralia #BiggerBetterFasterStronger #ExperiMental #HowBritainBridgesTheWorld #TheUltimates #Mayday #MaydayAirDisaster

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 91   
@CuriousScienceandEngineering
@CuriousScienceandEngineering 2 года назад
Do you trust pilot judgement, or would you fully trust technology? Want to see more Mayday full episodes? Watch them here: bit.ly/3vYH6wJ
@peterolsen269
@peterolsen269 2 года назад
Technology cannot account for mother nature. Flying a plane is like racing a car, you have to feel it.
@brandy192
@brandy192 Год назад
Yes and no to that question. I can't fully trust neither one of them, and nor would I want to be in any situation where I must have a choice between one or the other.
@eveethetabby_cat
@eveethetabby_cat Год назад
3:41 it is showing a Lockheed 1011-1(not a DC-10).it also showed the Lockheed 1011-1 in Swissair 111
@eveethetabby_cat
@eveethetabby_cat Год назад
5:00 that part also shows in Swissair flight 111 and in United airlines 811
@amberkat8147
@amberkat8147 Год назад
I would not fully trust technology. Nor pilots. People are faulty- so too are things made by people. But at least with the human there's the chance they will have a gut feeling and do exactly what's needed to avert disaster in time. With machines, they have no gut feeling, if their input and processes says a certain thing, they will do it or try. It for some reason it doesn't work they generally have no back-up but to signal an alarm. And that's because programming the possible actions for all possible emergencies, and all the tests and things to try in each one, would probably be too difficult. Computers can't second guess themselves or have a gut feeling something's wrong. Also, planes have a lot of interconnected systems- one time a pilot who could no longer use the normal stuff to steer was able to use power to the engines to steer. Even if a computer could control both of those systems, would it occur to it to do that? I doubt it.
@sploosh578
@sploosh578 2 года назад
Why is there no narration? Did somebody accidentally upload the file with the wrong audio track or something?
@brennangomolka22
@brennangomolka22 2 года назад
lol this is amazing actually LOL
@elcarmi
@elcarmi 2 года назад
Actually better without narration.
@anonymousadult
@anonymousadult 2 года назад
I need narration.
@111danish111
@111danish111 2 года назад
it's like fill in the blanks !
@christophermercado5466
@christophermercado5466 Год назад
I was "curious" about that myself 😂😂😂
@peterbiltguy4311
@peterbiltguy4311 Год назад
4:24 *So accurate were not even swiss 🤣*
@FirePrincess2008
@FirePrincess2008 2 года назад
Love the series!! Keep em coming!!!!
@christophercarrera2005
@christophercarrera2005 2 года назад
Without narrator
@Jetup24
@Jetup24 2 года назад
Why wasnt the worker who left the tape on the pitot tubes charged with involuntary manslaughter?
@StephenLuke
@StephenLuke 7 месяцев назад
RIP To the passengers and crew of Aeroperú Flight 603
@John-ww3ji
@John-ww3ji 2 года назад
Synopsis Probable causes 1. Pitot tube blockage 2. Financial crisis faced by the Airline thus cutting costs and cutting corners by the Management and staff. Amicable solution Enhance safety by a Thorough HOW!/TOW and TOW /HOW procedure. At least 60 minutes briefing time. Pay your Engineering maintenance crew especially the Lame or approval or certifying engineers same pay as the Pilots pay for the aircraft type. The players involved. 1.Flight crew 2.Maintenance crew 3.Ground handlers. 4.Air traffic Controllers Upon taking over watch the Pilot in Command is the last line of preventing the fatal crash.
@michigangirl5072
@michigangirl5072 8 месяцев назад
And they're still cutting corners til this day.
@elcarmi
@elcarmi 2 года назад
GPWRS is a different system and the one you have to obey in a situation like this, especially when airspeed/altitude is unreliable.
@samuelosei-somuah3072
@samuelosei-somuah3072 2 года назад
Many plane disasters have occured too soon after so called Maintenace works no matter how minor
@Jetup24
@Jetup24 2 года назад
The maintenance worker who left the tape on the pitot tubes should of been charged with involuntary manslaughter and sent to prison for life
@davido3026
@davido3026 4 месяца назад
Negligence!!!
@dentonboothe5322
@dentonboothe5322 2 года назад
They take too long to try to return
@alechamid235
@alechamid235 2 года назад
I agree, at first sign of an issue they should have made u turn while still on land.
@R.DeMora
@R.DeMora 2 года назад
@@alechamid235 You can get fired for doing that.
@alechamid235
@alechamid235 2 года назад
@@R.DeMora better to get fired than getting killed
@R.DeMora
@R.DeMora 2 года назад
@@alechamid235 It's not that black and white. The vast majority of issues during a flight, from takeoff to landing, don't equate to a death sentence. Most of the times they can be solved by following procedure, so turning a plane around and wasting tons of money in fuel, delays, passenger accommodation and time over a NON issue can end a career. Don't get me wrong, security should always be a priority in aviation, but there wouldn't even BE an aviation industry if it hit the panic button at the slightest hint of trouble.
@likkerland
@likkerland Год назад
@Alec Hamid These are split second to minute decisions, it's not that easy
@nathanaelgonzalez8303
@nathanaelgonzalez8303 2 года назад
AeroPeru Flight 603 2 de octubre 1996
@weonedirection8205
@weonedirection8205 Год назад
5:19 *Landing Gear Up, The Scene Starts Here! :]*
@kungpaopizza2126
@kungpaopizza2126 Год назад
I initially watched this on other computer-animated versions & they do very little mentioning of the passengers.It’s not till I saw _this_ reenactment here and I could 😢actually be reminded that there was way more people in that plane there than just the two frightened pilots
@gofast3209
@gofast3209 2 года назад
No narration???
@MichalDeKoning3336
@MichalDeKoning3336 Год назад
19:25 that stall alarm sound ringer sounded like from Airbus
@planck39
@planck39 Год назад
Good to see whole sequens
@peterolsen269
@peterolsen269 Год назад
There is a lot of confusion here, let me help. If you know how your systems work IE. where these magical computers get their information, then you have some insight as to what has gone wrong with your aircraft. Someone said, oh without daylight they could not level the aircraft and all their instruments are unreliable. This statement is not true and not well informed; all of the failures that they were experiencing were based on data collected from the Pitot Static System. Gyros and Engine instruments would continue to work fine. So, trust your Artificial Horizon, Turn & Bank and your Engine Settings and IGNORE Airspeed, Vertical Velocity and Altitude. Who was thinking that the guy in the tower has some magical way to tell how high they were? REALLY? Fly PItch and Power as has already been mentioned, In other words set a standard power setting used below 10k feet and keep the horizons level, begin a slow turn back to the city lights to verify your position. Second level of confusion seems to come from who is "Maintenance" and who is just ground service? I am a Commercial Pilot as well as a Licensed A&P Mechanic, my two licenses look identical except for the fine print. I don't wash or fuel the aircraft and I don't load baggage. If anyone including pilots put any tape on my aircraft while on the ground and didn't make a logbook entry, they could be summarily dismissed. With an open logbook entry, the pilots would have seen there was tape on the aircraft because I am the only one that can sign it off, meaning "close it". Open entry means no departure, which means no accident. Standard Operating Procedures mean everything in this business, and also to call things by the English names to indicate what you really mean, Period. Last I will mention Avianca Flight 052 from Columbia to New York. They circled the airport and remained in holding for so long they simply ran out of gas. You can look up the episode for yourselves here on RU-vid. The Captain of 20 years with Avianca was so bad with his English that he had to have the First Officer communicate with Approach. This is not conversational English but a code of English that means certain definite procedures will be followed. Some examples are Initial Approach Fix, Short Final, Go Around, Pan Pan and of course Declaring an Emergency or Mayday. One of the survivors of this crash (who speaks Spanish as a principal language) when interviewed said, " The captain asked for priority and where I come from when we say priority that means we should be put to the front". What she is not realizing is that if you go to Japan or Hong Kong or South Africa and say "Priority" they will say HUH? The only word that the crew on Avianca Flt. 052 had to say was "EMERGENCY" and then explain what happened when they got parked at the gate. In closing I would say that the words we use, the procedures we follow and responsibilities that we assume in aviation have certain specific meanings and redundant safety implications not related to common life outside of our business. If you are going to become a Pilot, Engineer or ATC, you need to know these "code words", what they mean and understand how following proper paperwork and knowing procedures will keep you out of these deadly situations.
@michigangirl5072
@michigangirl5072 8 месяцев назад
Let me make it clear to you on your third point. 1. No one is DISAGREEING with you on the fact that they should use these codes. I agree with you. 2. I also agree that they should have went to an alternative airport in Boston. Pilots are to blame. But 3. So are the ATC. Running out of fuel also means an emergency. And 4. If you wanna talk about confusion, you're commenting on the wrong episode.
@LouisGedo
@LouisGedo 2 года назад
I love this series ............ the investigation part is as awesome as the tragedy part. Thank you for continuing this epic series!
@Jetup24
@Jetup24 2 года назад
How is the tragedy awesome?
@LouisGedo
@LouisGedo 2 года назад
@@Jetup24 The recreation is awesome is what I meant
@dlvox5222
@dlvox5222 2 года назад
I remember this was a case of a taped over pitot tube I believe. Pitot tubes measure all the critical airspeed indicators. I always thought the Doppler radar measures altitude bouncing signals to the earth surface. But IDK. Not a pilot. Was a aircrew in helicopters in the Navy.
@tylerbrass4002
@tylerbrass4002 2 года назад
I believe you are correct about the radar, but the ATC had access to that information, and therefore could relay accurate ground speed info to the pilots, but the altitude information was not accurate, but they thought both were accurate. The terrain alarm was based on a system separate from the pitot tubes, I believe it was based on radio altimeter, and maybe stick shaker is separate from the pitot system as well, but I'm not sure. Had they known all of this information at the time, they probably could have worked the problem. That's my understanding of this accident anyway.
@edwardrichardson5567
@edwardrichardson5567 2 года назад
You have a transponder that sends Altitude, Airspeed & Heading. Onboard Radio Altimeter operates within 2500 ft above ground.
@edwardrichardson5567
@edwardrichardson5567 2 года назад
@@tylerbrass4002 GPWS gets its info from the on-board radio altimeter which reads actual Altitude above ground. GPWS does not read from the Barometric Altitude which computes static pressure against the ram pressure entering the pitot tube.
@longdongvondiqenbaum
@longdongvondiqenbaum 2 года назад
There's a reason why we have a warning sign on MH60R aircraft saying don't cover or plug the static port with anything, the pitot and static ports are part of the same system that feeds you air pressure which is used for altitude.
@ionutturcutvoda3545
@ionutturcutvoda3545 Год назад
I don`t know what year was this was but in situations like this they should have used a gps based phone app like waze or iGo as soon as they saw that their instruments weren`t working
@ericbuzzard2041
@ericbuzzard2041 Год назад
😄😄😄😂 smdh
@kmnormal629
@kmnormal629 Год назад
What?
@robinstewart6510
@robinstewart6510 2 года назад
🔥 The aircraft industry needs to redesign the pitot tubes to automatically clear any obstruction before takeoff. Another, perhaps better, option is completely retracting the pitot tubes between flights, preventing anything or anyone from even touching them. At the very least, design a test before takeoff to detect any erratic behavior.
@campkohler9131
@campkohler9131 2 года назад
The test idea is the answer. A pump should pressurize the various lines and either sensors check the results or the crew follows along to verify that the pitot system is responding properly. This kind of test would have also prevented a similar problem from crashing that charter aircraft that had it's pilot tubes blocked by insects because it sat parked without pilot tube covers installed. You would think that clever pilots would carry on board their own altimiters to compare with the cockpit instruments for the first few minutes of flight, and if anything is odd, land immediately and figure it out. Anything is better than crashing.
@robinstewart6510
@robinstewart6510 2 года назад
@@campkohler9131 .. The test would have to be conducted before takeoff. After takeoff, especially at night or increment weather, the crew would be in serious trouble.
@rosemarietacba720
@rosemarietacba720 Год назад
Bcbdjcbsknxnzncnznxjbfhdbcbbsjz xbz xbxbzbxinxbxbbxbznznznznnzbxbbxbxvxbbxbzbzbxbxncbxjbxbxbxbxbxbbxbzbbxbznxbbxbxbxbdbdbxhxhhdhbdbdbdbdb
@hartmutschon1190
@hartmutschon1190 2 года назад
The terrain warning is an independent system. They knew, that the altitude meter was defective, so there was no reason that the terrain warning was a false alarm. I'm not an expert, but every flight controller has to know, if the on the radar indicated altitude comes from the transponder of the plane and is faulty. Why isn't there a red plug or better a slider with position switch and indication in the cockpit or a valve or flap to close the static holes during the cleaning of an plane. Using tape for a standard cleaning procedure of an million dollar airplane ... had no engineer in our world a more reliable idea?
@katrinarucker2326
@katrinarucker2326 9 месяцев назад
It's quite strange to watch this episode without the narrator. 😮
@danahsutton101
@danahsutton101 2 года назад
Ten cents in tape brought the plane down. The cleaner should have remove it and the pilots should have made sure it was removed.
@peterolsen269
@peterolsen269 2 года назад
You are getting closer all the time.
@raymondcole5068
@raymondcole5068 2 года назад
radar should have been able to tell them the speed ,direction, and altitude of the airplane accurately
@Operngeist1
@Operngeist1 2 года назад
depends on the style of radar, the one they were using only showed the information the plane was sending them, known as secondary radar. With primary radar they would have had that information.
@carloscortes5570
@carloscortes5570 2 года назад
Radars are all different styles.this one is bullshit in,bullshit out
@peterbiltguy4311
@peterbiltguy4311 Год назад
7:40 *I am up, but the speed!*
@michigangirl5072
@michigangirl5072 8 месяцев назад
The co-pilot says that a lot. The speed indicator stops working, that's understandable.
@gameplaysgabyturismosereag4035
28:32 😳and 28:27
@gameplaysgabyturismosereag4035
aeroperu flight 603 crash
@ultrajd
@ultrajd Год назад
I understand the need for accountability but throwing the maintenance worker in jail seems a little extreme. Also No disrespect intended for the flight crew but I feel that as soon as they started seeing that their flight instruments were malfunctioning they should have turned around and gone back to Lima.
@katrinarucker2326
@katrinarucker2326 9 месяцев назад
Sadly, they've wondered away from the city lights before they could even do that. That's when they started to fly blind. It must've happened so quickly before they realize what's going on.
@ultrajd
@ultrajd 9 месяцев назад
@@katrinarucker2326 So it would seem.
@michigangirl5072
@michigangirl5072 8 месяцев назад
The maintenance crew really fouled up on this one. The pilots never ask for much. All the crew had to do is remove the damn tape. It's not like the pilots tricked him into solving a difficult puzzle or something.
@Carols-we8mi
@Carols-we8mi 3 месяца назад
Yet again maintenance are responsible for more carnage. Maintenance should be supervised and team led so that they fully understand the consequences of poor maintenance work. Death, disaster, destruction and carnage. So many lost souls. And poor maintenance with shoddy workmanship. Maintenance workers need to understand the importance of precision work and the consequences for passengers and crews, DEATH.
@mariojellyrideselevators6087
17 center is the ai is broken
@edsonlucas8717
@edsonlucas8717 Год назад
Flight 603
@sandrakiefler4649
@sandrakiefler4649 5 месяцев назад
Wtf is happening!?
@mawj09eas4
@mawj09eas4 Год назад
Interesting, no narration.
@mauriciolavanderos2872
@mauriciolavanderos2872 2 года назад
1954-1996 end Time of alliance judeo-aleman
@davewilliams1719
@davewilliams1719 2 года назад
I thought pilots were suppose to be trained on cockpit scenarios and faults I believe it was a maintenance gross maintenance error however I'm a mechanic pilots should have been able to get back to the airport the pilots were not effectively working together sad all the way around 🙈😭😭
@ANGELSURS
@ANGELSURS 2 года назад
I was on this flight and survived. I drifted towards an island and still there to this day.
@kristinekhan8465
@kristinekhan8465 2 года назад
Wow with internet connection.... Amazing
@jstevinik3261
@jstevinik3261 2 года назад
@@kristinekhan8465 That is a troll. No one survived.
@boost1606
@boost1606 2 года назад
Oh really is the island called Pen Island?
@ANGELSURS
@ANGELSURS 2 года назад
@@kristinekhan8465 I had a wifi extender
@ANGELSURS
@ANGELSURS 2 года назад
@@jstevinik3261 no troll here as I survived
@sbolden123
@sbolden123 2 года назад
😭🙏
@samm928
@samm928 2 года назад
Poor painter is not responsible .. it's Air Peru that should go to jail.
@Jetup24
@Jetup24 2 года назад
Whoever put the tape on the pitot tubes should of taken the tape off after cleaning/painting/maintenance. Whoever left the tape should of been charged with involuntary manslaughter and sent to prison
Далее
Out of Fuel at 39,000 Feet! | Mayday Air Disaster
52:00
The Mystery of Flight 603 | Mayday Air Disaster
52:01
Просмотров 265 тыс.
EVERYTHING We Know About The Brazil Air Crash
18:09
Просмотров 1,5 млн
The Greatest Legal Casino Heist in History
1:15:14
Просмотров 1,6 млн
Shocking Avianca Flight 052 Crash | Mayday Air Disaster
52:01
Lost in the Dark: The Crash of Aeroperu 603
26:18
Просмотров 616 тыс.