No video :(

How did the Dwarves feed their Armies and People? | Lord of the Rings Lore | Middle-Earth

Подписаться 158 тыс.

Просмотров 54 тыс.

50% 1

How did the Dwarves of Middle-Earth feed their armies and people? Could their kingdoms such as Moria and Erebor grow and sustain enough food for their people, and could they even grow crops in these dark caverns? Or did they have to trade with and rely on other lands for supplies? These question and more as we explore how the armies of the Dwarves were sustained in the Lord of the Rings.
►Merch Link: teespring.com/...
Business inquiries: Geekzonemt@gmail.com
Affiliates:
► Unleash Your Inner Dark Lord!
Papillon9 Jewelry Store: papillon9.net/...
► Support us on Patreon! - / geek_zone
► Instagram - / geekzonemt
► Facebook - / geekzone-113587049285161
► Twitter - / geekzonemt
► Discord - / discord
================================================
In this series, we explore the history of places in Middle-Earth, Characters or events that took place.
The information is presented in an orderly easy to understand way so that it is friendly to people that are new to the Lord of the Rings Lore and Mythos.
Special thanks to our Valar-Tier Patrons:
Jacob Williams
T-Gorman
Michael Angel
Special thanks to our Wizard-Tier Patrons:
Mike Feeney
Roland Myrvold
James Stodgell
Jeremy Pontier
Big Boy
Andrew Boehmer
If I feature any of your artwork during this video, please drop a message or a comment and I can link your page in the description of my videos!
Thumbnail Artists:
Suzanne Helmigh
Shortbowshinnon
Artistic Credits:
Greg Rutkowski
Isural
Whatyoumaydo
Mariusbota
Todor Hristov
Suzanne-helmigh
Aleksander Karcz
Aleksander Karcz
Atilgan Asikuzun
Kaprriss
Ahmet Can Kahraman
ていくん
Jason Felix
Ralphdamiani
Wend Taylor
Samscrapbook
Aleksander Karcz
SaMo-art
Yang Zhao
Grzegorz Pedrycz
Ramiro Liquer
Steamey
Ivanstan13
Pinkhavok
Choe Heonhwa
Petrushka_petrushkov
~-~~-~~~-~~-~
Check out my latest video!: "The Life of Azaghâl the Dwarven King of Belegost | Lord of the Rings Lore | Middle-Earth"
• The Life of Azaghâl th...
#Dwarves
#Middle-Earth
#LordOfTheRings
#Armies
#LOTR
#Silmarillion
#Arda
#Moria
#Belegost
#Tolkien
#Morgoth

Опубликовано:

5 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 249

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

For those of you might have missed my community announcement, I'm currently working on a masters in Game Design and it's really taking up a lot of my free time. And so I'll be publishing once every 2 weeks for now until I catch up with my studies :) As always subtitles are available and feedback is welcome! I'd also love to hear your thoughts on this topic, especially if you can think of some other ways in which the Dwarves could have fed their people! :)

@shadowcloudspher5149 3 года назад

Dwarves need a beer and food. Maybe traveled to near by inns for food and drink.

@CaptainTeach1 3 года назад

Really good episode explaining how Dwarfs supply themselves with food I always wonder how they would supply themselves with food. Keep the episodes coming I love the channel. Big Fan🙋‍♂️

@isaiahwolftail867 3 года назад

I love your work and your voice. It's soothing especially when I'm away from home. It keeps me in the geek zone lol and it reminds me of home.

@DonMeaker 3 года назад

@@shadowcloudspher5149 Dwarves might sell their work product for others' work product.

@lordfrank8719 3 года назад

That's so amazing! I hope you do well and I wish you all the luck in the world.

@TheUncleRuckus 3 года назад

I guess I always figured they had a Mushroom heavy diet. The caves would made an excellent place for mushroom cultivation.

@Sobeewan 3 года назад

Algae as well.

@ericpowell96 3 года назад

Smart

@nickbrothers9155 3 года назад

they still do that but its to get high😂😂

@thats_corky 3 года назад

I was thinking mushrooms, and foraging. No reason they couldn't have gone out and picked berries and stuff like that. I also don't think they would have much meat in their diet at all. Dwarves were not very fast, and thus probably not the best hunters of game like deer and rabbits. I can see them fishing some, maybe, but I think it would be mostly plant based.

@jonahstirbis3408 3 года назад

That is true but not all mushrooms are safe to eat!

@dentongamble8150 3 года назад

“Aragorn, lets find some food.” Gimli

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

See, even Gimli made Aragorn find him some food 😂

@yourstruly4817 3 года назад

The Balrog provided them with malt beer and ripe meat off the bone

@dentongamble8150 3 года назад

Lol 😂

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

That would explain all the fire. He was just having a barbecue

@starlitshadows 3 года назад

Damn, the Balrog was just down there feasting the whole time. No wonder he stayed down there for so long.

@p_campbell 3 года назад

Fuc.ker was just waiting for someone with a large enough knife(sword) and fork(staff) .. ...then he could be contained.

@MasterMalrubius 3 года назад

I always felt that they had trade agreements with surrounding peoples. But it does bring into the discussion how they could go to war with these same people. The limited information on how many “people” lived where makes it difficult to really discuss at length. I’d say mostly it would be with Men and Hobbits. Elves were likely much less involved in food production except for specialty items. Dwarves were wealthy from gold, silver and gems. Then also the production of iron for arms or even mass sale. It’s the beauty and the curse that we only get tiny bits of information. It does not detract from the story but allows ample space for your imagination to wander.

@michaeljones9553 3 года назад

I can't believe Gimli actually thought Balin and his company were still alive and thriving with only the food that they took with them into Moria, how did they live for years in those grim mines.

@alex.ann_der 3 года назад

It's something from the movies. In the books, the only one who wanted to cross the Misty Mountains through Moria was Gandalf, Gloin said in the Council of Elrond that Balin's company went to Moria like 25 years before that, and kept sending messages until they recieved none sign of them, they thought the worst, and dare not enter the kingdom because they knew there was "Durin's bane".

@davidgoff1368 3 года назад

@@alex.ann_der Nah bro I literally just read that part again a couple days ago. Even though you are right gimli wasnt too keen on going to Moria, he did have hope they were still alive and was very upset when he discovered it was true.

@rambo-cambo3581 3 года назад

You're talking like Balin starved to death 🤣

@michaeljones9553 3 года назад

The lack of vitamin D must of been a factor too 😂

@MrBigCookieCrumble 3 года назад

I remember comments from Gimli that covered this briefly, but rather than saying that dwarves _never_ grew their own food, it much more implied that they _prefered_ other kinds of work over farming and would _rather_ just buy it from other races, _if_ they could. The sizes of dwarven cities and realms just doesnt seem plausible without their own food sources, they were very inventive, i imagine large undeground, semi-automated fish farms and green houses heated by geological hot springs and the like.

@cerberus6654 3 года назад

Greenhouses underground? Where does photosynthesis enter into that equation?

@7Coolpablo 3 года назад

@@cerberus6654 in LOTR online rpg they solve this problem with fluorescent crystals and reflecting mirrors enabling an underground greenhouse.

@cerberus6654 3 года назад

@@7Coolpablo They did? Well, maybe I'm being too real-world. The crystals don't convince and the reflected light... Seems dubious. But thanks for the lead.

@pedrolopez8057 3 года назад

The Joke was on the Dwarves. The Hobbits sold them an addictive drug called pipe weed. Cut off the supply and let them go into withdrawals then the Dwarves would be falling all over themselves to make a deal for more "nicotina".

@willc1294 3 года назад

Hobbits were basically drug barons on an Escobar level of villainy.

@p_campbell 3 года назад

I very much like this take on Hobbits? 🤔

@novaterra973 3 года назад

@@willc1294 Until the Gondorians figure out how to cultivate pipe weeds on their lands.

@phoule76 3 года назад

They can just eat all Bilbo's food; but careful with those plates!

@gm2407 3 года назад

Video was still shorter than that musical number.

@EdMcF1 3 года назад

The Balrog made sure that Dwarf bacon was 'crispy'.

@kaank5921 3 года назад

If the dwarves just spring out of stone, then it means that they eat precious ores!

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

No wonder they're so fabulous!

@nikolaosboukouvalas449 3 года назад

Isn't it obvious? Orcs! That's why abandoned Dwarven Holds are filled to the brim with Orcs: the Dwarves are farming them for food but when they are gone there is no one to cull the Orcs' numbers. That's also why Orcs hate Dwarves. Alright I am joking, but it could be a neat idea for a high fantasy parody.

@torianholt2752 3 года назад

So that's how Gimli knew what orc blood tasted like 😆

@nikolaosboukouvalas449 3 года назад

@@torianholt2752 R I P E M E A T O F F T H E B O N E!

@NexusDarkworld338 2 года назад

True Orcs were pig men in every other franchise so that works.

@MrHistory269 3 года назад

A random farmer lives in peace... The dwarves move into the mountains next to him... The Farmer: STONKS

@rkjjo 3 года назад

I would think they could grow mushrooms underground. You should do a video about how come the dwarves are not bothered by sunlight after living so many centuries underground.

@IalporVpaahi 3 года назад

They come out to trade, train, build, etc. with the other races. The ones that never come out, would probably have sunlight sensitivity.

@worldtraveler930 3 года назад

Yep, Shrooms and Taters are my beliefs regarding Dwarf chow.

@chessgoalsyt 3 года назад

I hear the salted pork is particularly good __

@RedneckRealist 3 года назад

Yes! And smoking!

@jek__ 2 года назад

Everyone knows that first thing you plant in your dwarf fortress is a nice indoor crop of mushrooms :P. Mushroom roasts, mushroom soup, mushroom brew not being able to make their own food is a very odd occurance. It can only really happen if two races are created out of nothing at once Lol, "forge a bond with your allies" is the perfect way to put it if youre trying to convince a dwarf to be cooperative, they cant resist a good forging :P

@shadowcloudspher5149 3 года назад

Dwarves are legendary in our hearts.

@tylersoto7465 2 года назад

I love the dwarves innovation and craftsmanship if the lonely mountain under king Diane's rule did it right the dwarves and men could live in a industrial revolution in a state of growth and progress the lonely mountain has the resources and tool machines to mass produce gold , silver gems for currency , iron hills for steel and iron mass production and the city of Dale producing food and trading goods, if they utilize the iron hills to mass produce iron railroads to expand to new areas and colonizing new empty lands building more cities and make railcars pulled by those big goats they have cuz those things are strong and fast and if pulling railcars on a track it would be easier and faster to trade and travel place to place , the dwarves could make musket guns sinse black powder exist in middle earth and just invent muskets and cannons and bombs and with a huge system if railroads everywhere the dwarves and men could be mechanicist infantry mobilizing faster to different parts of their empire , the dwarves can build more mountain cities connected by railroad and men build a city next to each dwarf city to accommodate each other , if they build it right a person in Dale or white city could take a train ride to one end of each land with in a day or so, lonely mountain could have a huge trade empire having tons of gold and silver to trade for goods etc and live in a advance revolution lol

@MisterDoomHimself 3 года назад

I was watching the Hobbit the desolation of smaug and wondered what dwarves ate and how they made food lmao, thanks for the vid!

@Sidewinder528 3 года назад

Dwarves ate the same thing men ate.

@T-REXMACHINEGUN 3 года назад

That first dwarf in the video is from a Magic the Gathering Card but he fits lotr dwarves quite well

@johncipolla8335 3 года назад

Of all the races in Middle Earth. I love the Dwarves most of all.

@tylersoto7465 2 года назад

Me too I love the dwarves innovation and craftsmanship if the lonely mountain under king Diane's rule did it right the dwarves and men could live in a industrial revolution in a state of growth and progress the lonely mountain has the resources and tool machines to mass produce gold , silver gems for currency , iron hills for steel and iron mass production and the city of Dale producing food and trading goods, if they utilize the iron hills to mass produce iron railroads to expand to new areas and colonizing new empty lands building more cities and make railcars pulled by those big goats they have cuz those things are strong and fast and if pulling railcars on a track it would be easier and faster to trade and travel place to place , the dwarves could make musket guns sinse black powder exist in middle earth and just invent muskets and cannons and bombs and with a huge system if railroads everywhere the dwarves and men could be mechanicist infantry mobilizing faster to different parts of their empire , the dwarves can build more mountain cities connected by railroad and men build a city next to each dwarf city to accommodate each other , if they build it right a person in Dale or white city could take a train ride to one end of each land with in a day or so, lonely mountain could have a huge trade empire having tons of gold and silver to trade for goods etc and live in a advance revolution lol

@EdMcF1 3 года назад

Like Singapore, trade treasure for food, like the mediaeval Swiss, trade warcraft for food.

@BlankName88 3 года назад

I like how you had torbran from mtg in the opening.

@stumpy244 3 года назад

The underground cave water system as seen in the hobbit with gollum could provide some fish/food

@Alucard6297 3 года назад

Under ground cavern fisheries! That be a great idea honestly!

@lassovandenbos677 3 года назад

I find it beautiful that this video has no dislikes, it is what a video like this truly deserves. Even tho in my eyes it deserves more views, the people that do see it appreciate it like it should be.

@sirquest66 3 года назад

How did you forget to mention "SALTED PORK"?

@dawndawnster 3 года назад

Carl, the art work is sensational 👏 WOW 👏 added with your wisdom love, love, love it! Great job my friend

@TigerlilyWarrior 3 года назад

How on earth does this video only have 4,800 views!?! Great video, GeekZone. Keep up the good work. I don't have any answers but I love these types of questions.

@byalmo91 3 года назад

Never knew about the root, that’s awesome! I also love how the background music is the background music in third age total war, miss playing that game.

@PhilBagels 3 года назад

Food is eaten once, but tools and weapons and armor and objets d'art last for a very long time. No society can last without producing its own food. They carved "windows" into some of their inner mountain chambers, so that natural sunlight could get in. So they may have had indoor "greenhouses" of a sort. They may have even had some outdoor farms and ranches in the valleys and canyons adjacent to their mountains. From there, they can easily retreat into the mountains when defense was needed. You could call these "backyard gardens".

@onatgz 3 года назад

-how did the dwarves feed their armies and people? -by having them eating rocks ofcourse. ROCK! AND. STONE!

@pachacutti1012 3 года назад

Wait I thought the dwarves just lived off of their love of gold and hate for elves and orcs with some acasional beer thrown in there

@tarasque01 3 года назад

Perhaps they could have used reflective mirrors to bounce sunlight into the caves and designate a concentrated sun reflect area to grow just about anything?

@thats_corky 3 года назад

The artwork in this video is 👌 *chefs kiss*

@legolasgreenleaf4989 3 года назад

Gimli would eat rocks and stones when he got hungry while searching for the hobbits, I thought just it was a weird quirk, but if he did it, then could all dwarves just eat rocks if they got hungry? Idk I’ll ask him sometime 🤷‍♂️

@faramirofgondor7358 3 года назад

Tell me when you find out.

@jacobhoover1654 3 года назад

Never trust an elf!

@legolasgreenleaf4989 3 года назад

@@faramirofgondor7358 I will

@legolasgreenleaf4989 3 года назад

@@jacobhoover1654 I can tell by your accent that your a dwarf, so I take no offense

@torianholt2752 3 года назад

Well, according to your people they are what they eat then.

@stevereed2472 3 года назад

So I always figured these roots to just be potatoes. Its never explicitly named, but with the way they were described it sounded like them

@skjold224 Год назад

Do you remember the quote about those roots or where I can find it? Also here is a quote where dwarves farm: "The Dwarves had an agriculture - which in early times they practiced when isolated and unable to buy grain etc. by barter. They had invented a “plough” of some sort - which they dragged as well as steered themselves: they were tough and strong - but they did not delight in such labour of necessity." - Nature of Middle-earth

@stevereed2472 Год назад

@Bewaids24 I believe it's in story of Hurin

@skjold224 Год назад

@@stevereed2472 Thanks I will take a look.

@stevereed2472 Год назад

@@skjold224 particularly when it comes to the sections with mim and the petty dwarfs

@skjold224 Год назад

@@stevereed2472" In the waning of the year Mîm the Dwarf and Ibun his son went out from Bar-en-Danwedh to gather roots in the wild for their winter store; " - Sil

@beltashazzar5277 3 года назад

Hello buddy! Today a nagging question started to bother me - what if the Fellowship never broke up? What if Gandalf didn't die and Boromir wasn't killed? What if they actually managed to get through the forests, down the river from Lothlorien and towards Mordor? What came to my mind was - where would they enter the dark lord's land? The black gate would be impassable and they certainly wouldn't take the route through Minas Morgul. Would they keep travelling North-east? Are there any other passages apart from the valleys in the far east? I would love a video on that :D

@worldtraveler930 3 года назад

Yep, Shrooms and Taters are my beliefs regarding Dwarf Chow.

@alexandersilady4751 3 года назад

It is clear that Dwarves don't need to eat... they only need to DRINK!

@garrettmccullough2249 3 года назад

I always figured it would be easy enough to grow crops underground with some kind of bioluminecent fungi that could imitate the sun's light. That or perhaps a magical stone or rune that could change the properties of certain gems to do the same.

@ets805 3 года назад

Just bought the Moria expansion for LOTRO and was literally asking myself this very question two days ago, so thanks for the timely upload Geekzone! (sidenote, pretty sure that's Geralt of Rivia @4:40 )?

@flatmat2844 3 года назад

Moria is one of my favorite parts of the game.

@arcusmc 3 года назад

I didn't know any of this and had always wondered. Great stuff.

@masseyfurguson8871 3 года назад

Dwarves needed the long bottom leaf from the hobbits.

@henry7001 3 года назад

I always look forward to these uploads, especially now that there are fewer of them. Just wanted to say that they are appreciated!

@JamesAnderson-dp1dt Год назад

I always figured dwarves would farm mushrooms, get food in trade as much as possible, also hunt, trap and gather in the forests. However, I also suspected that they'd terrace hidden folds in the mountains, and raise grain and vegetables there. Take a look at the old Inca terraces. Those things still have dirt and drainage centuries after they were built. And some areas of terrace are extremely inaccessible to an invading army. Anyway, this is how I've rationalized it.

@rushthezeppelin 3 года назад

This video brought to you by My Patriot Supply, official supplier of emergency food for the dwarven kingdoms.

@magua9563 3 года назад

I always thought dwarves would be decent huntsman and have large fields of fungus farms. Also, they make ale and beer so I'd imagine either they found some way to do it with mushrooms or had hop farms somewhere.

@jonystyles9473 3 года назад

i think its like in the games... Dwarfs loved pork so they had lots of pigs taking care of, aside from trading with the Northmen also, in the North they had goats, porks, fish... lot of eatble stuff seems legit

@ilias8972 3 года назад

Please, make a video about the strength of the dwarves. Are they stronger than a man? What advantages and disadvantages do they have? Their proportions and body.

@zachall101 2 года назад

Here’s a question… how did the haradrim get their war elephants… were they gifted them because they served Sauron ( did Sauron make them or did they already exist) or did they have them long before that… and how/what did they feed them

@cerberus6654 3 года назад

Well, I had brought up this issue last year - perhaps a bit sarcastically - but you have answered the question with complete authority and success! Though mushrooms have no nutritional vale. Also, Carl, I've always wondered why there are no Half-Dwarven of any kind.

@anapoda3081 3 года назад

they eat rocks of course. ;) man, those arts in your video are freaking great. kudos to whoever made them. but back on topic, you do can grow rice in mountains. lot of work, and it has to be a rainy area but it is possible.

@timmeh006 3 года назад

I have a question that i can't seem to find an answer to. Who's playing the drums in the deep? When the Balrog of Moria fell, the drums still played in the deep. So who played them?

@FernandoGarcia-tf1gn 3 года назад

Great video! I love them all!! And If I can just throw in my two cents here, I think they may have had some kind of huge oil supply too, to keep the lights on. Other way that occurred to me was of they may have developed some sort of mirror system so they could have a reflection of the sunlight, if not mirrors maybe gems or metals, and maybe just maybe they could have had the sunlight needed necessary to allow them to have a maybe small fields where they could grew some crops so they wouldn't rely solely on their allies bonds. I mean hey, deep underground they may have had a better soil quality, and for the water I understand there are underground natural water sources from which they could have taken advantage of.

@jacktribble5253 3 года назад

Mushrooms tend to have very little nutritional value, a good supplement, but hardly a staple. I imagine they would have entrances to their halls in areas where they could deploy hunting and gathering parties above ground. In times of war, you can always eat the enemy...

@sledgehammer9966 3 года назад

I think they eat all the funny mushrooms. Thats the reason they go crazy in craftsmenship.

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

*Mirkwood Flashbacks*

@dylantorres2496 3 года назад

I’ve missed this! Great video! Thank you for another great video! Can’t wait for the next one.

@spartavis8904 3 года назад

I was just thinking about this!

@lordfrank8719 3 года назад

Amazing job! I love the content and thank you for expanding my knowledge of the lord of the rings world.

@PleaseNThankYou 3 года назад

Hey Karl, Gigi here!

@p_campbell 3 года назад

Since there were instances of great skylights; It us more than likely possible that the Dwarves had gardens in a very specific area of the halls. 🤔

@andrewhead1840 3 года назад

No, I didn’t know some of this fascinating. Where did you get the information about the dwarves and Hoberts trading?

@shanenolan8252 3 года назад

Thanks mate. Hope your Christmas and new year went well . Great work as usual karl

@phoenixmilburn8759 2 года назад

I always figured Moria atleast used the water works to push water to the Upper Deeps of the 7 levels going up using sun light cut through the rock it would make sense keep it warm with blaring fires on the middle levels

@feuerzorn7014 3 года назад

Great video! Could you make a video where you actually compare the power of Sauron and Voldemort? I had this idea because of your merch. Or would that differ too much from your normal content?

@Corkest 3 года назад

Hey man really love you content

@EveryoneElseIsWeirdImNormal 3 года назад

This can actually help us establish how the governments of middle earth work because in the past nearly all of the populus were farmers because of the heavy food taxation the royals placed upon them however since there aren't that many farmers that we know of most people in Gondor seem to be soldiers forge workers ect so they produce enough food to sustain a population of a million or something but also have enough to trade with dwarves so the government would have to tax the populus of something else possibly even service in the army

@MasterBombadillo 3 года назад

We only see Minas Tirith is a time of war so many people left - naturally soldiers and smiths will stay behind - but even then we read descriptions about the farms and orchards of the Pelennor Fields to feed the city. Even Mordor had an enormous agricultural economy around the Sea of Nurn to feed their armies. So when reading that, I don't think you can claim most Men weren't farmers. We just don't see the most populated areas.

@EveryoneElseIsWeirdImNormal 3 года назад

@@MasterBombadillo the type of farms those would be are wheat farms or other cereal crops which can be produced in mass quantities very easily for farms of that scale if it took the majority of minus tirth to farm that would just be pitiful

@coolbanana165 Год назад

I kind of assumed that if beings are made to live in an environment, then it must be possible for them to find food there without trade. For example, farming large mushrooms with more diversity and nutrients. Or other underground foods which don't exist on Earth.

@steyn1775 3 года назад

Finally A real question

@NexusDarkworld338 3 года назад

Fish from underground rivers, mushrooms which grow in the dark and damp, goats and other wild animals that live on mountain ranges, and growing hardy root vegetables in small patches of flat ground where possible.

@seanrea550 3 года назад

Terrace farms on the mountainsides are possible as well. No evedince but possible.

@eklypse21 3 года назад

Like first, then watch

@magecraft2 3 года назад

My view is that the Dwarves where self contained with underground food source (mushrooms and fungi) but traded for better tasting / interesting foodstuff. I couple this with the belief that goblins and orcs also had access to these underground food sources. Maybe even animals that graze on these. After all the Dwarves had to have food before trade with the other races.

@sampetrie340 3 года назад

Did they drink mushroom beer? To borrow from Spartan lore, that would explain why they didn’t fear death.

@morinehtarromestamo6548 3 года назад

I was looking forward to your next video, thanks! :)

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

You're welcome buddy, I hope you enjoy it :)

@kaank5921 3 года назад

Even more Cram! 1 Month just on Cram! Couldn’t the lake men make some tastier food?

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

It doesn't sound very appetising either :)

@Lars951 3 года назад

I always imagined they could use terraced gardens--like having a garden on their roof.

@JacobSmith-rh2sr 3 года назад

Hey Carl, I'm confused on which race is better at smithing... There seems to be a lot of contradictory evidence in the books where the elves are given credit for being the better Craftsmen, but then sometimes the dwarves are given credit for being the better Craftsmen. What's your take on this? I'm assuming that the dwarves are better at blacksmithing and elves are better at making things of beauty like jewelry.

@GeekZoneMT 3 года назад

Hmm that's hard to say. My impression is that the Dwarves were definitely the greatest masons and builders and the average Dwarf was a more talented craftsman than the average Elf (excluding the Noldor perhaps). I think that both of their races were capable of coming up with incredible artisans and so it would be impossible to say that one was definitely better than the other. :)

@LeopoldNZ 3 года назад

In 1697 SA when the Dwarves of Moria shut their gates and cut themselves off from the outside world for roughly 3,724+ years. There's no way they would have or could have stocked up that much grain and food through trade and stockpile. So they would have been living "off the grid" and been more self sustainable. Like you said, roots, mushrooms, fish and other methods never written down would be required.

@BrianEthridge-wk6hz Год назад

My guess was right and they did have some sort of magic food or root you could say! Or something specialized to them. Like a route that was start you like a potato and easy to store and prepare! Lucky guess

@chrisamon4551 3 года назад

Idk dude. I think dwarves involved in food production were probably shepherds, tending flocks of sheep and goats and cows in protected mountain dales and valleys. I can imagine great flocks covering all of Dimrill Dale during the height of Khazad-Dum’s power and that’s where they’re getting the red meat off the bone! Idk, Maybe they hired human shepherds, but I don’t see why. There must have been poor or outcast dwarves who could not dwell for one reason or another in dwarf holds. I imagine they could bamboozle some humans out of some sheep in exchange for a trinket or two and make a decent living out of being a shepherd, feeding the mansions of their more well to do kin.

@boxicool 3 года назад

I think fed up those dwarven kingdoms only with trade would be impossible. I think they had something like mushrooms or other type of food. Maybe even they fed animals like pigs with plants that could grow in caves.

@efaristi9737 3 года назад

I think the Dwarves knew the common speech before the the Second Age, i mean, they were already trading with elves and humans during the First Age. I'm sure you're right about the mushrooms, the fishes and the roots (i think i even remember it being mentioned but i don't remember where) but that shouldn't have been great food or not very varied since the Dwarves always prefered the food of the outside world.

@MrFreed0m 3 года назад

Goats , lots of goats , cheese milk, and meat. Especially because the dwarves are derived from Nordic mythology which is filled though old goats

@francescobruno6172 3 года назад

My dear fellow, I have to say that this video was excellent. I wanted to ask, which Tolkien works did you use for references? Did you look into any of the histories of middle earth?

@brianhelmick1105 3 года назад

You gave away your spark, red. Torbran has no place in the Misty Mountains....

@waywardanarchist 3 года назад

a video on athelas or kingsfoil would be cool..

@ilanrohm88 3 года назад

What if gandolf went to meet the company instead of going to dol goldur and went into the mountain to fight Smaug? Who was stronger or more feared the balrog or Smaug? Differences?

@zehaha111 3 года назад

I think they got a lot of food through trade, but i don't think they'd be dependant on other races for that. Don't forget, Khazad Dum in the Second Age closed their gates for a looooooong time. We also know that the Alliance between the Dwarves and the Northmen in the dark years when Sauron ruled most of Middle Earth. Now if we think about how good dwarves are in construction and architecture, i'm sure they're skilled enough to bring light into their halls from the outside. Glass and mirror should be something they can create. With wholes in the mountainsides, which they could create from within, they could bring light through mirrors into the mountain. If you have soil and earth and water there, you can hold farm animals and crops. You would actually better off than outside probably, because you could hold the place at a good temperature all year long. So actually, if the Dwarves would do something like this, they could sell food to others, especially in autumn and winter times. Something like this can and is done on our world in structures beneath the earth as well.

@Davidh41690 3 года назад

Best merchants of middle earth

@BrokenSofa Год назад

Cool accent man, are you from Malta or have you moved there?

@brianwatts25 3 года назад

What about hydroponics? There would be a problem with light but they could reflect it from the surface if they couldn’t find anything better.

@aashirazeem5465 3 года назад

I love dwarves

@TetsuShima 3 года назад

Knowing that the dwarves were created because Illúvatar wanted to come true Aulë's desire to create a new life form feels like if a father gave life to his son's toys

@bennruda11 3 года назад

Dwarven crafts, straight from Orzammar

@ManDuderGuy 3 года назад

Egads I remember this

@bennruda11 3 года назад

@@ManDuderGuy best game ever lol

@Paul-ng3xn 3 года назад

I suspect that next to growing mushrooms and having fish from underground lakes, they could have made greenhouses inside the mountain, being lit with shafts in the mountain and special mirrors. To lock themself out of the world for years, they would need sustainable foodsources inside their mountain homes. So growing mushrooms, breeding fish and greenhouses seem the way to go. Another option is breeding animals in highup pastures, that are not reachable from lower down.

@BrokenSofa Год назад

Mushrooms in caves? Nah that doesn't work. They grow where there are dead things to grow on, i.e. the woods and grasslands.

@mcsmash4905 3 года назад

for me it was always utterly baffling how armies marched from lets say italy all the way up to the english channel , which kinda ties into the whole food and provision thing

@MasterMalrubius 3 года назад

They sent foragers out to collect food. From stores kept by farmers if possible or from fields or wild grain. Berries and nuts and a lot of things we don’t normally think of eating. But it is incredible how they could support even a few thousand soldiers much less 10,000+