Тёмный

How do you know you exist? - James Zucker 

TED-Ed
Подписаться 20 млн
Просмотров 2,5 млн
50% 1

View full lesson: ed.ted.com/lessons/how-do-you-...
How do you know you’re real? Is existence all just a big dream? Has some mad scientist duped us into simply believing that we exist? James Zucker investigates all of these questions (and more) in this mind-boggling tribute to René Descartes’s "Meditations on First Philosophy."
Lesson by James Zucker, animation by Stretch Films, Inc.

Опубликовано:

 

13 авг 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,5 тыс.   
@salsabillaeh4973
@salsabillaeh4973 7 лет назад
Existential crisis and chill
@ichrisful
@ichrisful 7 лет назад
I live by this
@sapphiresprinkles2510
@sapphiresprinkles2510 7 лет назад
this went way to deep
@merilinalu143
@merilinalu143 7 лет назад
my life motto
@tetsudoyle4561
@tetsudoyle4561 7 лет назад
I knew this before watching in a matter of fact you're not deep enough
@Thehehebird
@Thehehebird 7 лет назад
same I've taken this thought process deeper
@hitrapperandartistdababy
@hitrapperandartistdababy 8 лет назад
Anyone who has had that feeling of looking into a mirror and just thinking. This is me, i am looking at a Living human like my family but it is myself, and the ponder about how you look and Sound and it feels...off?
@kraftp
@kraftp 8 лет назад
yes
@laurenlifke6981
@laurenlifke6981 8 лет назад
Sometimes in public I think about that, and I think about how weird it is that everybody else can see my face but I can't see my face because I'm me, and then I feel super exposed
@milo1842
@milo1842 7 лет назад
some times i look into the mirror and see a complete stranger. its weird.
@pinkguy5537
@pinkguy5537 7 лет назад
+Delia M-M sometimes i look into the mirror and see a...thing.
@hitrapperandartistdababy
@hitrapperandartistdababy 7 лет назад
+Pink Guy I see a sex god...
@hiiloveu1521
@hiiloveu1521 2 года назад
Sometimes when I'm in public I suddenly realise that every person that surrounds me right now has a life just as complex as my own, with thousands of events that led them to this very moment and will continue to lead them on to an unknown path no one can predict, and there are so many unpredictable paths like this. It freaks me out and fascinates me
@lowtuhigh
@lowtuhigh Год назад
the dictionary of obscure sorrows called this feeling "sonder"
@vibrationzzz
@vibrationzzz 10 месяцев назад
i am the same very interesting how different everyone is
@lheroinehannah2066
@lheroinehannah2066 2 месяца назад
It is called a destiny that we all don’t know nothing about it
@F1_letsgo
@F1_letsgo Месяц назад
ouch
@marcar19
@marcar19 7 лет назад
Every time I ask myself the question in the title I'm like "what if this is someone from the outside or my own unconscious self trying to wake me up?"
@ohiobrownie5891
@ohiobrownie5891 6 лет назад
i think that too! i thought i was weird...
@akashrathod595
@akashrathod595 3 года назад
underrated
@user-sy6er5tq2u
@user-sy6er5tq2u 8 лет назад
I'm over here thinking... " why tf do they blink one eye at a time??"
@samuelforgie2771
@samuelforgie2771 8 лет назад
Same here
@kmillegomes
@kmillegomes 7 лет назад
To make him look stupid, I guess
@frtard
@frtard 7 лет назад
Because it's animated by STRETCH FILMS! They did Courage the Cowardly Dog, and if you ever seen that, you know exactly where that goofy, one eye blink comes from. In some other TED-Ed animations they did, they used those playing-card-looking clubs for the hands; another Stretch Films hallmark. That's John Dilworth @ 1:39.
@chesseye9584
@chesseye9584 7 лет назад
ᴄʀʏsᴛᴀʟ • m.
@MrQuest0
@MrQuest0 7 лет назад
How do you know that they are animated? What if you are animated and they are REAL?
@ThomasRiver69
@ThomasRiver69 7 лет назад
This opened more questions than it answered!
@BeatlesLoveFrieden
@BeatlesLoveFrieden 7 лет назад
"Every answer generates further questions......."!
@zorilaz
@zorilaz 7 лет назад
stop asking questions to start living life
@GigaDarkness
@GigaDarkness 7 лет назад
How do I live life?
@AaronAlterman
@AaronAlterman 7 лет назад
DarkGiga by caring only about yourself and your happiness
@egoetabsolvo8844
@egoetabsolvo8844 5 лет назад
For me that's a good thing...
@iMilanSpinka
@iMilanSpinka 6 лет назад
"You can't be nothing if you think you're something, even if you think that something is nothing. Because no matter what you think, you're a thinking thing." 😂
@ekatasatya2995
@ekatasatya2995 10 месяцев назад
something is nothing only when you desire to experience confusion.
@Bob-qy5oc
@Bob-qy5oc 7 лет назад
"I doubt therefore I think. I think therefore I am." ~Rene Decartes
@IceFried
@IceFried 8 лет назад
How do i know i'm not dreaming? Simple. I get laid sometimes when i'm dreaming.
@stephencantnmbrs
@stephencantnmbrs 8 лет назад
XDXDXDXDXDXDXD
@GVMGVM-dl1iu
@GVMGVM-dl1iu 8 лет назад
+IceFried Only in your dreams-my bet-lol
@hellopaul7652
@hellopaul7652 8 лет назад
+IceFried XD story of my life!
@connorf8638
@connorf8638 8 лет назад
lol I'm gone
@OmegaF77
@OmegaF77 8 лет назад
+IceFried That's quite a rather depressing solution, but a rather effective one it is.
@humbertojimmy
@humbertojimmy 8 лет назад
When i was a kid i would always have a weird idea, a question that puzzled me: i wondered if there was a big secret about reality for me to find out, something that would shake the very way i perceived the world. I would often think about that, and get sad that, if such secret did exist, i had never discovered it. But then a doubt would come to my mind... What if i had already found that out, perhaps many times in fact, but everytime i did, wicked entities that controlled reality just erased it from my mind and replaced it with false memories of me doing something else except finding the truth (?) I just had no way of telling...
@elianherrera5322
@elianherrera5322 8 лет назад
same.
@ta0ji
@ta0ji 8 лет назад
Same here. I mean, exactly the same. ARE YOU MY LOST TWIN!?
@humbertojimmy
@humbertojimmy 8 лет назад
SphereTiger8 KiwiStudios Wow, i didn't know others shared the same bizarre thing. I guess it must be more common than i thought.
@ta0ji
@ta0ji 8 лет назад
+Jimmy David true ^-^
@neelanshguptaa1440
@neelanshguptaa1440 8 лет назад
I experienced something like that too. When I was about 5 I used to ask myself "why am I here?" and more importantly "Am I really here?" The more I thought about it the more I came up theories and the more I felt depressed. Not sad or worried just this depressing empty feeling.
@noor-hd9zd
@noor-hd9zd 4 года назад
Sometimes i look at something for a little while and start to think is this all real? I mean that all these memories and history in this one soul and it was all prewritten is honestly beautiful and scary at the same time.
@trinine3103
@trinine3103 3 года назад
had these thoughts too, yk 'what is real?' after several existential crisis sessions and coming up with various stories i noticed that it doesnt matter what is real or not. if i give something value, a thought, then it is real to me. and that is all that matters. i am right here and i cant change that. so i just do my best with what i have with me in this moment even if it were to change or leave my reality. it doesnt matter whats real because i am still experiencing it.
@aurus7245
@aurus7245 7 лет назад
What if everybody was just you from another timeline?
@BeatlesLoveFrieden
@BeatlesLoveFrieden 7 лет назад
>:D
@aurus7245
@aurus7245 7 лет назад
"Don't bully, it's only hurting yourself." "how do you know?" "Because I am you."
@aurus7245
@aurus7245 7 лет назад
+Your "Best Friend "I am your father." "No, I am your father, and his father before that. I will also be my son, and my daughter..."
@CookieeMonstarr666
@CookieeMonstarr666 7 лет назад
What if actually we're all in someone's dream? o.0 Or living in the mirror world and what's inside the mirror is actually the actual dimension of the reality world. o.0
@stars7710
@stars7710 7 лет назад
NONONONO STOP PLEASE
@tfoprincess
@tfoprincess 7 лет назад
Sometimes I talk to people and they ignore me so hard that I begin to legit doubt my existence! I'm not even joking. .-.
@lauraipsums
@lauraipsums 7 лет назад
same ;--;
@acidcitrus5143
@acidcitrus5143 6 лет назад
That was me yesterday! I honestly thought people couldn't see me and I was invisible and I was so confused
@jillandjack7631
@jillandjack7631 6 лет назад
OH me too. Even my friends ignore me :(
@EpicBananaGlasses
@EpicBananaGlasses 6 лет назад
Nyanna Ross one time I was yelling at somebody trying to get them to listen but they ignored me so much I asked myself, "am I invisible?"
@subsribetopewdiepie6673
@subsribetopewdiepie6673 6 лет назад
Nyanna Ross just tap them on the back
@juliannevogt8325
@juliannevogt8325 4 года назад
1:27 to 1:28 Me when I realize there’s homework due tomorrow
@mel-on5fg
@mel-on5fg 5 лет назад
Before watching this video i often think that i'm probably the only person who lives in this world and everybody is just illusions. That's why i don't really give a damn about what i do or what they think of me. Wait- i think i finally know why my life is so messed up
@gilangak4525
@gilangak4525 3 года назад
Huh, it's funny cuz i guess i'm the real one here and you guys are the simulated one.
@Mizraab2912
@Mizraab2912 3 года назад
solipsist
@Kindred...
@Kindred... 3 года назад
Not caring about others and not caring about their opinion about you is two different things
@bluendace
@bluendace 2 года назад
@@gilangak4525 haha life's amazing..
@chunkymonkey7983
@chunkymonkey7983 2 года назад
@@gilangak4525 Or I am the real one and you are simulated!
@bballClipss
@bballClipss 8 лет назад
I comment, therefore I am.
@Sander_Datema
@Sander_Datema 8 лет назад
commento ergo sum?
@Sander_Datema
@Sander_Datema 8 лет назад
commento ≠ Latin commentator = scientific writer commentor (1) = consider, describe commentor (2) = inventor, creator The content has.... degraded a little in the last 20 years.
@rajdeepvijayaraj4243
@rajdeepvijayaraj4243 8 лет назад
+kwwyy You can just be a computer which comments rather intelligently.
@EasaYahiya
@EasaYahiya 8 лет назад
You can be CLEVERBOT
@kamokwele12
@kamokwele12 8 лет назад
+kwwyy I reply, there for I am
@qaddams
@qaddams 8 лет назад
that pic of the scientist popping up scared the hell out of me.
@rebeccawarfield1032
@rebeccawarfield1032 8 лет назад
The picture popped up while I was reading your comment 😂
@baderbader7874
@baderbader7874 8 лет назад
Me too !!
@captainstorm4550
@captainstorm4550 8 лет назад
Same here shitt
@aggeblue8136
@aggeblue8136 8 лет назад
+Quinton Ayers same lol
@Mackeye_
@Mackeye_ 8 лет назад
ikr
@flor.a_qqq7697
@flor.a_qqq7697 7 лет назад
This is making my anxiety worse...probably shouldn't watch it 😂😂
@lairjuniortv
@lairjuniortv 3 года назад
When I have this doubt I just left one unpaid bill and someone will find me and let me know I exist. “I own, therefore I exist.”
@kylecampion93
@kylecampion93 8 лет назад
WTF IS WRONG WITH THERE EYELIDS WHEN THEY BLINK
@hani5885
@hani5885 8 лет назад
can you do better? Huh
@ProgrammedPersona
@ProgrammedPersona 8 лет назад
+Kyle Campion _yeah, seriously, what is the problem with people who think that there's something wrong with the animation? I agree; I also wonder if there is something wrong with the eyelids; even though there really isn't._
@maxhernandez7829
@maxhernandez7829 8 лет назад
+Kyle Campion their*
@ckipoo
@ckipoo 8 лет назад
the eyes dont blink at the same time. makes my brain freak out a bit aswell. realy anoying
@kylecampion93
@kylecampion93 8 лет назад
+Max Hernandez I didn't know the grammar police was in town
@ediable8309
@ediable8309 8 лет назад
I sometimes know when i'm dreaming, it's really fucking wierd though.
@MAllen-gm2zq
@MAllen-gm2zq 8 лет назад
+ediable It is called a "lucid dream", when lucid dreaming, you can control the realm of your dream.
@ediable8309
@ediable8309 8 лет назад
M. Allen Yeah, but that's only sometimes, but when i can control the dream it's even wierder. And also, i wreak havoc >:D
@MAllen-gm2zq
@MAllen-gm2zq 8 лет назад
Sometimes you become aware of the dream just as it ends, it is such a shame.
@ediable8309
@ediable8309 8 лет назад
M. Allen Yeah, that happened to me with my last wierd dream, i was chased by a crazy dog person with claws and shit and then i just suddenly stopped. I basicly let the fucker kill me so i could wake up.
@eggstronauts69
@eggstronauts69 8 лет назад
+ediable I literally thought I was dreaming inside a dream. I was just dreaming. It was so weird but I was like, "this is in a different language, does anyone know this language" then I thought , well if its foreign my brain couldn't make up what it is so I must be dreaming. then I "woke up" but I knew I was still dreaming.
@SuperTushar14
@SuperTushar14 4 года назад
Ever since I was a child, I just thought that the life I'm experiencing right now is me in the future writing an autobiography remembering each and every moment and one moment these memories would end and the book would be finished.
@avivastudios2311
@avivastudios2311 Год назад
This is the best way to explain Descartes' philosophy. So smooth and nice.
@bynnievee6362
@bynnievee6362 7 лет назад
if i had a dollar for every existential crisis this video caused, I would be rich af xD
@ruchikapoor264
@ruchikapoor264 3 года назад
but only in your dreams
@prakhar6334
@prakhar6334 3 года назад
Dude stop plz I'm already having a million existential crises. Plz don't start another one
@edholohan
@edholohan 3 года назад
No. You would have 4 dollars.
@Ghosteriz
@Ghosteriz 8 лет назад
Imagine when you grow old and is dying, after you close up your eyes and suddenly wake up and found out you are actually in school like around 8~9 years old and all the past & memories are just a long long dream~
@sadeem468
@sadeem468 2 года назад
I really wish that
@nigelnightmare4160
@nigelnightmare4160 Год назад
Who's to say it isn't like that, after all how long do you remember you dreams for? Most people's dreams fade quickly after 'waking up' no matter how real they felt.
@petergriffin9931
@petergriffin9931 Год назад
Going to end it, not doing this all over again
@k.m.1380
@k.m.1380 4 года назад
It took me huge effort to understand this book.but the overall result is wonderful. It is interesting, well written, and above all it makes you think in new way.
@oliviaaronson7589
@oliviaaronson7589 6 лет назад
wow. just wow. I will be mind boggled about this for weeks! good job ted ed! I love ur channel!
@HaagseDannyKalf
@HaagseDannyKalf 8 лет назад
This video made my head hurt, therefore I am.
@dyinglay5501
@dyinglay5501 8 лет назад
Hahahaha nice!!!
@theperpetual8348
@theperpetual8348 8 лет назад
Prove to me that you are real.
@HaagseDannyKalf
@HaagseDannyKalf 8 лет назад
Jacob Thomas Well, you know my comment is real, because you reacted on it. If I didn't write down that comment, who did?
@theperpetual8348
@theperpetual8348 8 лет назад
HaagseDannyKalf I Might have.
@HaagseDannyKalf
@HaagseDannyKalf 8 лет назад
Jacob Thomas You and I know for a fact that you didn't.
@carter5571
@carter5571 7 лет назад
Once I was dreaming and I thought that I was in front of a toilet and I had to pee...............so I peed in my bed😨
@vijeykrishnaa2230
@vijeykrishnaa2230 6 лет назад
Odd Rock44 that happens to many people
@oliviaaronson7589
@oliviaaronson7589 6 лет назад
I've done dat LOL
@jillandjack7631
@jillandjack7631 6 лет назад
Ugh I’ve done that twice and it’s so embarrassing but usually I wake up.....
@ueminem
@ueminem 5 лет назад
I am doing it at age of 35 .
@godzillafart6531
@godzillafart6531 5 лет назад
Hahahahah same omg we are buddies already im not even ashamed of it
@mohammedfazalurrahman9975
@mohammedfazalurrahman9975 7 лет назад
one of my favourite Ted . so much sense of humour in the animation .
@cherrkong
@cherrkong 4 года назад
When you’re in pain, you know you exist.
@enadegheeghaghe6369
@enadegheeghaghe6369 2 года назад
Nah, pain is nothing more than electrical signals travelling through nerves. It can be simulated /faked
@ajikishaya463
@ajikishaya463 Год назад
You can feel pain too in ur dream😂
@nigelnightmare4160
@nigelnightmare4160 Год назад
OK, now prove that your pain is real, because I can't feel it.
@prakritimoon
@prakritimoon Год назад
But sometimes it's hard to convince oneself,when all you feel is pain only.
@moonymilkt
@moonymilkt 7 лет назад
what if life is really just a simulation
@Succer
@Succer 7 лет назад
Ikr. It feels stupid typing this comment because if life really is just a simulation, then I'm just humoring myself.
@hannahdorothy7351
@hannahdorothy7351 7 лет назад
If been thinking of that since I was little
@Angelsxox
@Angelsxox 7 лет назад
Rick and morty anyone
@raffimolero64
@raffimolero64 7 лет назад
the matrix confirmed
@saragrimaldi8093
@saragrimaldi8093 7 лет назад
IF it was a simulation, someone wrote it for us; which prove that someone is NOT in the simulation. Why would we be in a simulation while others would write a simulation? Would not matter in the end, since we exist and disappear anyway, independently if we are in a simulation or not.
@pinkwig8303
@pinkwig8303 7 лет назад
Sometimes I wonder if creatures from other galaxies are using us for an experiment
@eshoo8000
@eshoo8000 3 года назад
Yes, they are monitoring our advancement in science, we are a “knowledge farm”. There are hundreds of farms like ours serving the master race of ancient aliens.
@vladimirputin2987
@vladimirputin2987 3 года назад
Yeah the Zoo hypothesis
@chunkymonkey7983
@chunkymonkey7983 2 года назад
Sup from 4 years into the future.
@pinkwig8303
@pinkwig8303 2 года назад
Chunky Monkey jeez i was 12
@prernashakya9502
@prernashakya9502 2 года назад
omg this thought came to my mind once
@rimshakhalid5037
@rimshakhalid5037 7 лет назад
2:45 I died laughing I love the animation
@abhishekanshuwali3808
@abhishekanshuwali3808 4 года назад
Finally the video I have been waiting to watch all my life.
@nschwartz311
@nschwartz311 7 лет назад
I love a good existential crisis in the morning
@Texplanations
@Texplanations 8 лет назад
Okay okay okay.... Let me get something straight. We create our dreams... our mind creates them to be precise. The y are more like unconscious imaginations. So ... if this whole world, My life, My family everything IS a dream... then all of it is created by my brain... so that would mean MY brain created.. Einstein's Laws, Newton's Laws, and every other scientists laws that my brain will create in the future... so this means I am the intelligence of Einstein, Newton, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, all youtubers , commentors AND everyone else in the world... not to mention all the great movies, games, musics and other stuff too. Nah I must be real cause I ain't that smart...
@nanismeelasla
@nanismeelasla 7 лет назад
LOL
@achilleasgeorgiou7853
@achilleasgeorgiou7853 7 лет назад
What If in reality everyone is that smart and even smarter? What if in reality everyone is 100 times smarter than everything you described and you are actually considered low intelligence even if you thought about Newton's laws all by yourself?
@locomojito0633
@locomojito0633 7 лет назад
this is cancer
@Texplanations
@Texplanations 7 лет назад
ShockGaming HD XD Subscribe :P XD
@emmajane-fandom
@emmajane-fandom 7 лет назад
And your comment was made up by my brain.
@SoulSeeker4
@SoulSeeker4 5 лет назад
Excellent analysis. Very well said.
@mahekpurohit7727
@mahekpurohit7727 3 года назад
What if we all are just sleepwalking rn and we are actually awake when we think we are sleeping. What if this is all just a realistic illusion?
@irrelevance3859
@irrelevance3859 7 лет назад
this video got me thinking hard
@mikegerfen85
@mikegerfen85 7 лет назад
it made my brain hurt. and then I got it and it made sense, so now I'm here to tell you about it, to sum it up, your something because you think you are, an only a something can think
@guillermorelobalopez7553
@guillermorelobalopez7553 7 лет назад
Okay so i'm here to screw your brain up again :P If you prove your existence by your thoughts(as Descartes did), you cannot prove the continuity of your existence, meaning that maybe anytime you stop thinking (eg sleeping, spacing out, etc) you may be stopping existing. Nothing is granting you that you are the same thing as the last time you thought.
@dixiescents
@dixiescents 3 года назад
This video could be fake because I am probably dreaming
@AbhipshaSahuCoPrezIOFA
@AbhipshaSahuCoPrezIOFA 8 лет назад
Existential crisis coming through
@allieclark475
@allieclark475 8 лет назад
Basically me every time I try to sleep
@pinkguy5537
@pinkguy5537 7 лет назад
+XxVaasyxX and i don't care if anything is real. just have fun with it
@darthmortus5702
@darthmortus5702 7 лет назад
My first existential crisis was when as a kid I became afraid that if I go to sleep I will die. Not that I won't wake up but that the person who wakes up will not be me but a copy of me with all of my experiences convinced that it is me. And that I of that day was the perfect copy of yesterday me also deluded that I have a history and was not created at the moment of waking. Technically speaking it's still not proven that this is not the case but after waking up many times and still being me the fear went away. Kinda weird because "waking up as me" does not disprove that yesterday's me hadn't died.
@AbhipshaSahuCoPrezIOFA
@AbhipshaSahuCoPrezIOFA 7 лет назад
...well I'm just gonna go question the meaning of existence now...
@sgshellfire5636
@sgshellfire5636 7 лет назад
this is what I have been wondering for years
@manjularathaur9712
@manjularathaur9712 2 года назад
I have to say this is the best Ted ed video I've ever seen
@benjaminw9704
@benjaminw9704 3 года назад
The stream of consciousness like narration made this video pure chaos and its incredible
@darthmortus5702
@darthmortus5702 7 лет назад
I kinda came to this on my own as a kid. I imagined that you could shrink the world down to a stage, that someone always sets up just ahead of you to convince you the world is real but in truth it is totally different or doesn't even exist outside the stage. And then inevitably the scary thought, does the world go away when you close your eyes?
@callistameyer5572
@callistameyer5572 9 месяцев назад
No ,because you still hear things around you and feel things and maby smell things
@terraleona334
@terraleona334 7 лет назад
When I was a kid (aka still am and still asking) I asked my self What if this is all just a story and I'm the main actor and everybody is a pupet and I'm the only person who can think except the person which is playing the pupets and the whole world us just playing with me and everybody knows everything I think and all the secrets that I keep and all the world secrets.What if other continents and states and countries are fake and only a cover and there is only one place (here) and everybody is lying about other places. They haven't even been there because they dont exist. Which is why my parents never go any where with me. One time my doctor said that I'm sick and cant go anywhere (cause the scene of the place I was going isnt ready so we couldnt go and somebody needed to stop us so they paid the doctor.)
@MrsRocketCat
@MrsRocketCat 7 лет назад
When I was a small child a thought that we are all puppets controlled by a little girl. The earth was her puppet house 😂
@adityasharma4040
@adityasharma4040 6 лет назад
Almost exclusively just what I think, except that other places do exist and the whole world is just watching me like I'm a science experiment for them or something😂
@spongebobbatteries
@spongebobbatteries 6 лет назад
@Tierra Leona Yooo you gotta watch "The Big O"
@jeevjatinsingh3402
@jeevjatinsingh3402 5 лет назад
@@terraleona334 Your premise is flawed...You say that we are energy that is making the shapes we percieve but even then we still exist right?
@lizzy6179
@lizzy6179 5 лет назад
I was up at 3 am and i wondered if we are all puppets and if life was a lie and we were controlled by a demonic entity.
@harryroadman1089
@harryroadman1089 5 лет назад
this was actually really relieving thanks :)
@somabanerjee3870
@somabanerjee3870 3 года назад
Love the music at the first and last
@EunisCheung
@EunisCheung 7 лет назад
why do they blink one eye at a time
@CookieeMonstarr666
@CookieeMonstarr666 7 лет назад
lol, because he can fly? Why ask what cartoon do? haha
@AnnebelBuntOnline
@AnnebelBuntOnline 7 лет назад
Eunis Cheung I don't know why they blink one eye at a time, I don't even know for sure if I exist or not. hahaha
@erutanevoli
@erutanevoli 3 года назад
To make the art style more unique and the animation kinda childish
@zeropulses9180
@zeropulses9180 8 лет назад
You always exist if you can exist. The question is a fallacy itself. How do you know you exist? Through your senses. How do you know your senses are real? It doesn't matter. They are as real as fake, even if they are fake. Confused? Look, let us say you are in a dream. That means your senses are part of the dream. Your body is part of the dream. The world, and universe is part of the dream. Thus, what you describe as a reality, is only a dream to someone observing you with senses outside of the dream. Inside the dream however, where you are forever trapped (or perhaps till death) it IS real. As real as reality is real, to YOU. No one can disprove it being real, because the definition of real is inside the dream. Thus, dream or not, it is real. Same thing with existence. Existence is defined within the senses that you have. It doesn't matter if they don't exist. If they don't exist, they don't exist to someone observing you, from some other reality. But for you, you exist, and your senses exists within this existence that defines it, so it is real, even if it isn't.
@alexbolog3635
@alexbolog3635 8 лет назад
+Peaceful Everafter Yes. I couldn't agree more. Everything you said is perfectly reasonable. Except one thing. It is deep inside my human condition to try to overcome the barriers, to go beyond the limitations of this real world, to continuously and restlessly search in this universe and try to find the other point of view, from the other reality, from the one that's , if you like. This is one of the fundamental human conditions. This is how we're all programmed. That is why we ask these questions. That is why it really matters if our senses exist or not, because we want the truth. We build LHC (and the whole world you see around you, for that matter) for this very reason: to find the truth. Therefore the question is not a fallacy at all.
@draevonmay7704
@draevonmay7704 8 лет назад
The question isn't a fallacy. It simply implies that the answer is yes. It would, however, by fallacious to answer the question negatively, due to the Law of Non Contradiction.
@snake698
@snake698 8 лет назад
+Peaceful Everafter Please first look up for philosophycal definitions of reality, because dreams aren't real. You're making the whole argument from wrong basics. What you get from your senses is a perception, not reality. But Descartes ends up answering his question thanks to that. Getting perceptions, thoughts must mean at least I am real. But no existence of anything else is proven real. In a dream, 100% are thoughts, so there is also no reality. If you say "reality to you" you're contradicting, then it's your perception of reality which skeptically could be completely false, your perception has nothing to do with reality for Descartes.
@zeropulses9180
@zeropulses9180 8 лет назад
Sorry, I made that post a long time ago, so I don't remember who this Descartes person is. snake698 My reasoning is simple. If you ever really do get asked "Do you know if you exist?" Then you know you exist. Something that does not exist cannot be asked that question to begin with. Illusions, dreams, mirages, fantasies, all of these things exist, in different realities. So why compare one reality to another? Perhaps we are in someone's head, just a long dream, but until he/she wakes up, we still exist.
@snake698
@snake698 8 лет назад
Peaceful Everafter In philosophy you can't talk about multiple realities, that is why I made a comment. You cannot be someone's thoughts if you can ask yourself if your existence is real, I tried to say the question is not a fallacy, it just answers itself (Descartes tried to doubt about the most obvious things to build something he could be sure of, even if he would not have any knowledge at all. There is the importance of the question
@soumyapandey8821
@soumyapandey8821 7 лет назад
This one was brilliant! Wow!
@benjaminbateman8808
@benjaminbateman8808 7 лет назад
I think about this all the freaking time. I am glad I am not alone on my theories!
@candyazz28
@candyazz28 10 лет назад
Just smack yourself in the face. There, you're real.
@Icariusnatarius
@Icariusnatarius 10 лет назад
Fundamentally flawed argument. "Your sentience and existence is proven by experiencing pain and your hand being stopped at the perceived space of you, that it hits." I'll let you think for a moment why that is flawed argument.
@candyazz28
@candyazz28 10 лет назад
Icariusnatarius Pain that is not instant will make you feel existence. Your mind is warped if you think that lasting pain won't put you into a reality state.
@Icariusnatarius
@Icariusnatarius 10 лет назад
Tyrone Bush It's possible to make person feel pain in left arm by using mirrors. It's also possible for person to feel pain in left arm, even though he hasn't one. Google Mirror box and phantom pain. My point is that pain is certainly not the best case for proving your existence. It's just lazy argument for people who are too lazy to think. I'd rather just say "I don't care" than make pointless arguments.
@candyazz28
@candyazz28 10 лет назад
Icariusnatarius Have you ever heard of the term"keep it simple stupid." Not calling you stupid but sometimes it applies. Some things you don't need to complicate like your existence. You can be sitting there thinking all day or you can move the fuck on.
@Icariusnatarius
@Icariusnatarius 10 лет назад
Tyrone Bush ;___; It doesn't follow that if you think about problems of existence, that you cannot go on with your life. Or that you have to give bad arguments for said problems.
@jayevans3124
@jayevans3124 10 лет назад
When i'm bored, i go to my garden, dig up a hole, burry myself, then i slowly coming out, and pretending i'm a carrot.
@ninja4life189
@ninja4life189 10 лет назад
Careful with the Easter Bunny he might eat you.
@BlackOpsMaster10263
@BlackOpsMaster10263 9 лет назад
well kakarot comes from carrot
@rajmohanveerabadran12
@rajmohanveerabadran12 3 года назад
Thank you for putting me into an existential crisis
@denisskenderovic3707
@denisskenderovic3707 4 года назад
The animator deserves high praise!
@Zenniverse
@Zenniverse 10 лет назад
If you lived in a virtual reality long enough, your mind would begin to consider it reality.
@Brice855464
@Brice855464 10 лет назад
That's the whole fucking plotline of The Matrix series.
@boughthawk7130
@boughthawk7130 10 лет назад
Why if you living in a dream.
@Gawillamon
@Gawillamon 10 лет назад
There's a video of a guy playing an Oculus Rift game. In the game, you're sitting on a couch playing a game, like a game-ception. So your body is doing what you would be if the game were real. As he's playing he starts describing how he's losing sense of reality and it starts to feel like he's really a part of the game. It makes a lot of sense if you imagine it.
@mintelladarling
@mintelladarling 9 лет назад
Gawillamon Do you happen to have a link to this video ? :)
@clintgolub1751
@clintgolub1751 9 лет назад
Leah Wall it's a PewDiePie video, one of his more famous uploads
@kristennewton178
@kristennewton178 8 лет назад
In the words of the immortal (literally) Bill Cipher, "THE UNIVERSE IS A HOLOGRAM THE GALAXY IS AN ILLUSION BUY GOLD BYEEEEE!"
@andrewpaul2716
@andrewpaul2716 8 лет назад
+Kristen Newton There's no reason to put the word literally.
@nicholaskeough9787
@nicholaskeough9787 8 лет назад
Ikr
@stephaniebuckler8375
@stephaniebuckler8375 8 лет назад
GRAVITY FALLER!!!!
@leelamh7768
@leelamh7768 8 лет назад
+Kristen Newton GRAVITY FALLS!!
@andrewpaul2716
@andrewpaul2716 8 лет назад
Leela MH no
@user-ne7zm8oz2z
@user-ne7zm8oz2z 6 лет назад
Love the animation!
@nameinvain6
@nameinvain6 3 года назад
dealing with depersonalization and derealization these feelings of not being real are intensified by a thousand. this video managed to bring it down to a more manageable 100 lol. thanks for this. gonna share with others who suffer from the same thing.
@AbelLawliet
@AbelLawliet 9 лет назад
That's really all it boils down to, we can imagine ourselves to be flying around a room with no body, but we can't imagine not having a mind. For all we know we could be a bunch of brains in jars connected to a virtual reality, and all of our senses are simulated. But questioning our existence gets us no where, and if it was true it's unlikely we brains in jars can change it. So go out and enjoy your imagined lives, before you're imagined out of it.
@lordjavathe3rd
@lordjavathe3rd 9 лет назад
Our skulls are jars. Our sense perception is virtual. The consistency of what we perceive is the only thing that keeps us from going insane.
@joebazooks
@joebazooks 9 лет назад
a/the 'mind' is just an abstraction. what does that, 'mind', even mean?
@AbelLawliet
@AbelLawliet 9 лет назад
tonyfalca It's the result of the brain's processes/functions that leads to consciousness/mind. So you can have a brain without a mind, but you can't have a mind without a brain. If you're talking about what makes you you such as a soul or the origins of consciousness, that's more of a religious/philosophical discussion. Even though this is also a philosophical topic, I and the video are mostly talking about how we can't TRULY trust our perceptions or test them, since they're the only way we naturally see the world. So if they're false or a simulation, how would we know?
@joebazooks
@joebazooks 9 лет назад
Abel Lawliet yes, okay, i would agree that the word 'mind' represents _cerebral activity;_ hence you can indeed imagine being brain-dead or not having a mind, although your imaginings would be entirely false, since imagining anything constitutes cerebral activity; in other words, doing so would be similar to imagining that one is not imagining.
@lordjavathe3rd
@lordjavathe3rd 9 лет назад
tonyfalca It's just a word that culture came up with to describe a persons individuality, presence, intelligence, and quirks. "a mind of his own" "great minds" and so on. Are you trying to say that the word "mind" has no basis in reality because the brain doesn't create a mind? That it's just an idea? Do you have a point? Where is it?
@mechanical_hexate
@mechanical_hexate 7 лет назад
1:06 to 1:14 actually happened to me once I spent the night normally, except for the fact that I was able to find a movie that I made up myself. The dream was actually so vivid, it even showed me getting ready for bed and dozing off..... I actually forgot what really happened the night before.
@avivastudios2311
@avivastudios2311 Год назад
It's happened once or twice that I imagined a book that I had made up myself.
@_nuevo_4528
@_nuevo_4528 7 лет назад
beautifully put
@samia9270
@samia9270 7 лет назад
I love these videos because they are so deep..
@mavila1368
@mavila1368 10 лет назад
Haven't watched the video but I have a feeling it's going to trigger my anxiety
@venomkingx1
@venomkingx1 10 лет назад
Isn't solipsism the belief that you are the only one who truly exists and no one else? So they don't question the existence of other things because they know that everything else is nonexistent.
@oddmenttweak7
@oddmenttweak7 10 лет назад
Red Pill Philosophy Hear hear!
@T00DEEPBLUE
@T00DEEPBLUE 10 лет назад
Red Pill Philosophy How does Solipsism disprove itself if hypothetically, nothing actually was real? The idea only exists as an abstract concept within the confines of reality as we know it, yes. I don't see how that disproves Solipsism's fidelity to the original idea. In such a 'truth', 'reality' and 'truth' become two different things. So Solipsism in such a 'truth' doesn't have to be 'real' to remain 'true'. I don't consider myself a Solipsist, because burden of proof, but I do think the jury is still out.
@ir0n2541
@ir0n2541 10 лет назад
I know i'm real because i have to pay Taxes and Bills.
@Nulibrium
@Nulibrium 10 лет назад
computer programs finalize your taxes and bills, doesn't mean they know they are real.:)
@HigherPlanes
@HigherPlanes 10 лет назад
No you don't wink wink. Your preception is your reality. And consciousness requires three things: an observer, the observed and a connection beteween the observer and the observed. Without the three, you have no consciousness.
@str8todamoney
@str8todamoney 10 лет назад
noe cruz How do you pronounce your name? I went to school with a Noe but I never learned how to pronounce it.
@cruvanel
@cruvanel 10 лет назад
HigherPlanes str8todamoney Well the correct way to spell it, is Noé. It's not pronounced "No" as I have heard before. The simplest example I know is "No-eh". Just say it quickly. You can always type it into Google translate. It'll give you the correct pronunciation. Also, Noé is just the Spanish version of Noah in case you didn't know.
@HigherPlanes
@HigherPlanes 10 лет назад
noe cruz That was someone else who asked :-), but thanks for the reply I was wondering myserlf.
@sarahparkhe8603
@sarahparkhe8603 6 лет назад
I have ALWAYS known that I am dreaming when I am dreaming. Never had to pinch myself in a dream to check, I just know. This benefits me to shape my dreams the way I want "while" dreaming as I have always been conscious of it.
@sb-lx2dt
@sb-lx2dt 7 лет назад
When I was little, I had these same doubts: is everything around me real? Am I the only thing that's real? Because I couldn't be thinking about this if I didn't exist, right? I told my dad about this, and he explained to me about Descartes and the same doubts he had. From then on, I started thinking that reality wasn't limited to our perception of it; it is far greater, but our perception is limited. That's what we live off: our perception of the world around us, even when it's not all there is. And knowing humanity, we will keep trying to push those limits further.
@eze2576
@eze2576 8 лет назад
This video does a terrible job of summarizing Descartes conclusion. Descartes concludes that even if he is being deceived, he must exist first before he can be deceived. "But surely I exist, if I am deceived. Let him deceive me all he can, he will never make it the case that I am nothing while I think that I am something."
@patelkrutika787
@patelkrutika787 6 лет назад
EZ E that's a smart quote
@Tran809
@Tran809 4 года назад
Well, they tried to make it so that others can understand better, by saying if you were persuaded, therefore, you exist. Being deceived and being persuaded are in general a type or form of thought. Which means that by thinking you exist. Descartes says it, you can't think you are not thinking if you are thinking. Hence, you can't doubt that you are not thinking, thus you do exist!!!
@okaybuddy.
@okaybuddy. 4 года назад
@@Tran809 Exactly.
@Gatekeeperaquatic
@Gatekeeperaquatic 8 лет назад
Courage the cowardly dog😍
@HeyWelcomeToMyWorld
@HeyWelcomeToMyWorld 8 лет назад
@angel-gx7zy
@angel-gx7zy 8 лет назад
IN THE MIDDLE OF NOWHERE
@joshkaplinger1382
@joshkaplinger1382 8 лет назад
I noticed the tooth
@MikhaelAhava
@MikhaelAhava 8 лет назад
Yeah
@technoshaman101
@technoshaman101 8 лет назад
+Julian M i noticed it too. ^ l it took me 2 minutes to write that sentence.
@lexi6079
@lexi6079 4 года назад
man idk why i searched this.. although this video is interesting, I feel sick to my stomach thinking about existence because some things you cannot answer..
@user-ni5ki8ee2u
@user-ni5ki8ee2u 3 года назад
welcome to exsitential crisis world
@komocity269
@komocity269 4 года назад
"Only insane people would deny they exists" Greek Philosophers : Am I crazy?
@evaristocarreon714
@evaristocarreon714 7 лет назад
anyone get a feeling of fearfulness that overpowers them once they realize theyre existing and freak out ?
@oliviabroughton9478
@oliviabroughton9478 2 года назад
So glad I'm not alone in this!
@shifaasyed839
@shifaasyed839 8 лет назад
I listened to the last part three times, and it actually makes sense. Wow, life seems so real all of a sudden.
@gudegudemeh5195
@gudegudemeh5195 3 года назад
When I was a child I would often think about how maybe nothing exist because I didn’t understand how anything would exist instead of just nothingness, and then I would feel really empty for a while. It’s such a deep sinking feeling that wiped out all thoughts and emotions. Life suddenly seemed weird and out of place. It’s so hard to explain but I’m sure a lot of people have experienced this? Not that I understand everything now. I just don’t care anymore lol.
@gowthamamg
@gowthamamg 4 года назад
When i saw the thumbnail. I thought “well. Existential crisis”
@GrizzlyFlyDesigns
@GrizzlyFlyDesigns 7 лет назад
you have the most interesting, informative video channel on RU-vid.
@babumadarasova5193
@babumadarasova5193 8 лет назад
Once my teacher told us that one of us is dreaming this whole worls . He was joking. He said that i am dreaming this. I was panicing so I started to cry.
@alisongold9448
@alisongold9448 8 лет назад
But think about it, maybe you are. Are you totally sure that everyone else on the planet is human? What if everyone is a hologram and you've just been living in a holographic world your whole life? What if every other person is fake but you? Are you 100% sure that all of these things aren't true???
@hitrapperandartistdababy
@hitrapperandartistdababy 8 лет назад
+Alison Gold one big thought is. Do we see Colors the same Way? What if my green is your red?
@MysticMadelaine05
@MysticMadelaine05 8 лет назад
Yeah. Me too. So, is it like I'm replying to this comment while dreaming? So, the people that commented here are just a part of my dream?, in my imagination?
@ObscurityIsBest
@ObscurityIsBest 8 лет назад
Vsauce.
@cris9796
@cris9796 7 лет назад
+Darkavenger_13 IVE ALWAYS THINK THAT
@pramodsurya4
@pramodsurya4 3 года назад
My brain literally stopped responding and crashed while watching this video.
@Hoanghai0369
@Hoanghai0369 2 года назад
so good!
@ks7485
@ks7485 7 лет назад
This is one of my worst fears. Not actually being alive. Maybe I'm dreaming. Maybe this is someone else's dream. Maybe one day I will wake up being 7 again and go through my whole life again. Maybe I'm in a coma...
@budgie0003
@budgie0003 7 лет назад
When you think about it, how can anything exist? The universe was created from nothing, but humans have decreed that you can't make something from nothing. So how did we go from nothingness to the entire universe? Furthermore, life. Life started (atleast on earth) as single cell organisms. But how did they come to exist? Why do atoms work the way they do? Why do/ did they form perfectly structured lifeforms? These are the questions I've been wondering since grade 7.
@em.the.awful.waffle
@em.the.awful.waffle 6 лет назад
Bridget You seem to be looking at life through the "God doesn't exist" glasses. Really nothing makes sense when you look through those glasses. You're not crazy for wondering how something came from nothing. When you put God (The Intelligent, Caring God described in the Bible) into the picture, it all makes sense, at least to me it does.
@spac18
@spac18 3 года назад
@@em.the.awful.waffle then who or what created god?
@em.the.awful.waffle
@em.the.awful.waffle 3 года назад
@@spac18 uh... nothing
@em.the.awful.waffle
@em.the.awful.waffle 3 года назад
@@spac18 lol this is wild cuz I completely forgot that I ever made this comment
@Brickyrox
@Brickyrox 3 года назад
@@spac18 nothing. He is infinite.
@massiex1872
@massiex1872 7 лет назад
Ted-Ed's philosophical videos give me an existential crisis
@user-jh9vs1dn6j
@user-jh9vs1dn6j 3 года назад
i was haunted by this question from when i was young... thanks for answering it.
@genericbearsounds5899
@genericbearsounds5899 8 лет назад
Well, I'll get the tinfoil hats...
@trronic
@trronic 8 лет назад
Grab me one.
@genericbearsounds5899
@genericbearsounds5899 8 лет назад
How do I know you're not one of the government-created tinfoil people?
@theporcupine9993
@theporcupine9993 8 лет назад
How do you know it's a thinfoil hat ? Maybe your senses are deceiving you and maybe it's an elephant.
@cheesewizard8943
@cheesewizard8943 7 лет назад
The Porcupine how do you know it's an elephant? Maybe it's a grenade in the shape of a parrot
@michaelbattle1871
@michaelbattle1871 7 лет назад
+PocketPlayer 101 how do u know it's a grenade in the shape of a parrot? Perhaps it's a bagel in a blue balloon
@DontreadPimpBoy
@DontreadPimpBoy 7 лет назад
I had this question, when i was 6-7 years old. Then i stumbled upon the matrix...then i went paranoid for a while.
@lfury1185
@lfury1185 Год назад
The end is really wholesome
@eshtiyak
@eshtiyak 5 лет назад
the only ted-ed video that created more questions without answering any
@aboyborninjune
@aboyborninjune 8 лет назад
Maybe even my thinking is part of the illusion?
@thrashkid665plus1
@thrashkid665plus1 8 лет назад
it could be. we think in our dreams, don't we?
@declan8577
@declan8577 8 лет назад
Yes but you have to BE to dream. I think so I exist. This is no proof to you that I exist but it is to myself.
@sknnr4869
@sknnr4869 8 лет назад
+De Clan I agree with you that's a great point
@stephenryan1732
@stephenryan1732 8 лет назад
That is a great point
@mkwarlock
@mkwarlock 8 лет назад
EXACTLY!
@superroydude
@superroydude 8 лет назад
This is really interesting. The brain is complex enough to create delusions so real that sometimes we can't tell the difference between them and real life; and we call these dreams. Even when 'awake' everything we experience is just the brain's way of interpreting its environment. We interpret vibrations in the air as sound, so we hear. We interpret electromagnetic radiation of certain wavelengths as light, so we see. If one brain alone can do this imagine what an even more advanced computer could do. It could simulate an entire world and run basic programs simultaneously (what we know as our minds)..... What I'm basically saying is that we're living in the MATRIX!!!
@johnnybecerra2647
@johnnybecerra2647 3 года назад
You don't know your in the matrix if you were born in it
@isimyok5848
@isimyok5848 3 года назад
but neuron >transistor
@dakissia
@dakissia 2 года назад
The answer is really simple If you can manage to keep your mind "still" as the yogis do, you will see the truth.
@OfficialDjVrans
@OfficialDjVrans 2 года назад
@@dakissia Share the truth if you managed to find it
@dakissia
@dakissia 2 года назад
​@@OfficialDjVrans you may experiment this by meditation or keeping your mind still; It can only be experienced by a thoughtless mind. it is not a belief, it is a simple experiment.
@MongoGamer
@MongoGamer 2 года назад
I think it's amazing the power of thought. I would love information on how the positive psychology started and with who
@greenegg6010
@greenegg6010 5 лет назад
Thanks dude this helped
@Succer
@Succer 7 лет назад
You can't prove that you're not going to wake up one day and be like, "Oh yeah, that was a cool dream." and only remember your "real" life AFTER you wake up. Similar to how you think your dream is real until you realize you're dreaming and wake up.
@eleazarm.902
@eleazarm.902 5 лет назад
why not? just curious.
@Chriswsm
@Chriswsm 10 лет назад
So I think therefore I am ...... What? What am I? A computer code? A rat in a coma? An energy based life form with a mental illness? What?
@HigherPlanes
@HigherPlanes 10 лет назад
awareness
@MorningDrool
@MorningDrool 10 лет назад
Everything and everyone is made of star dust?! D:
@aurorahh
@aurorahh 10 лет назад
a rat in a coma
@MrChadd990
@MrChadd990 10 лет назад
The universe is inside one of many atoms that make up the hemorrhoid of a 50 year old prostitute. Prove me wrong.
@issad9454
@issad9454 9 лет назад
I think therefore i am "a thinking being".
@lilian-gt1jf
@lilian-gt1jf 7 лет назад
sometimes when i look in the mirror it just hits me like i don't even feel like myself and i think "wow this human is really me" and my mind is blown like whaaat how is this even possible
@inquisitivewonderer3908
@inquisitivewonderer3908 7 лет назад
Watching this video with earphones and then 1:40 just shows up. My heart almost got out hahaha
@KwstasMode
@KwstasMode 7 лет назад
Sometimes when im dreaming..i know im dreaming..
@Thatguy-nh4by
@Thatguy-nh4by 7 лет назад
KwstasMode ikr!! So I came across this weird dream I don't remember, n I kinda got to know that I was dreaming. So I thought for a while and pinched myself n I cud not feel anything!!! So I tried real hard to wake up n wen I did, I realised that I'm in a dream again😕
@Abbs311
@Abbs311 7 лет назад
KwstasMode me too
@pharaoh5085
@pharaoh5085 7 лет назад
KwstasMode when I am dreaming..I always know that I'm dreaming...because everytime I dream something is wrong in the world I'm in..like in my bedroom there's a lamp..in the dream there isn't
@everneleh3609
@everneleh3609 6 лет назад
Lucid dreaming
@coolvideomagic
@coolvideomagic 6 лет назад
Same same.
@Toxstxr
@Toxstxr 7 лет назад
omg that picture of the evil doctor put the freak out of me
@mariavega2244
@mariavega2244 6 лет назад
Oh my god this is mind blowing!!!!!!
@masadda7
@masadda7 7 лет назад
this is really reliving:)
Далее
❤️My First Subscriber #shorts #thankyou
00:26
Просмотров 2,9 млн
Despicable Me Fart Blaster
00:51
Просмотров 7 млн
Who am I? A philosophical inquiry - Amy Adkins
4:59
Просмотров 3,6 млн
What Is consciousness? - Brian Cox Explains
0:56
Просмотров 294 тыс.
Plato’s Allegory of the Cave - Alex Gendler
4:33
Does time exist? - Andrew Zimmerman Jones
5:16
Просмотров 7 млн
How to make smart decisions more easily
5:16
Просмотров 1,2 млн
Is Anything Real?
11:32
Просмотров 21 млн
Proving God exists using Math
5:23
Просмотров 2 млн
"Nothing You See is Real" | Donald Hoffman
8:01
Просмотров 735 тыс.