Тёмный

How I Almost Made Top 16 With Etali | cEDH Tournament Recap | ComedIan MTG 

ComedIan MTG
Подписаться 18 тыс.
Просмотров 14 тыс.
50% 1

Hey RU-vid!
Today I recap my experience at Ka0s Tournament 5. This is the story of how I took Etali, Primal Conqueror and almost made Top 16 at this cEDH tournament.
Today's Decklist:
www.moxfield.c...
Patreon:
/ comedianmtg
ComedIan Discord:
/ discord
Twitter:
www.Twitter.com/ComedIanMTG
Dragonshield:
US www.dragonshie...
EU www.dragonshie...
Monarch:
/ monarchmediatw
www.monarch.ca...

Опубликовано:

 

21 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 86   
@WorldlyTutor
@WorldlyTutor Год назад
I played Kenrith in your second game and I certainly did not play the game out greedily. The variants you mentioned omitted the fact that you cast a board clear and removed my orcish bowmasters which was deployed to keep Gitrog in check. The purpose of my keep was to wheel on turn three, but of course rogsi flipped the naus. In fourth position I can't afford to mulligan to play table police in a pod going fourth with only one other blue deck.
@martynass
@martynass Год назад
Give this man a spotlight, please. Thank you for additional insight on the game and it’s details! 👏
@PubStompMTG
@PubStompMTG Год назад
Wow, that was an incredible win on that round 4. As an etali pilot myself, you gave me inspiration to run delayed fireball, blasphemous act, and craterhoof. Well deserved win as a gruul player playing against 3 sans red decks!
@johnweinhandl8890
@johnweinhandl8890 Год назад
Nice channel I watched your zacama video good content. Still my favorite commander of all time. Had a zacama deck for 4 years now
@PubStompMTG
@PubStompMTG Год назад
@@johnweinhandl8890 it's always good to see the chonky dinosaurs do good! Thanks!
@TemKhan
@TemKhan Год назад
Very late in the day. Mistakes were made for sure and wish I shook myself a little and rethought my decision. Good game either way. Hope to play with you again! The power of TIVIT will continue 😄
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
Same man GG
@lvletal
@lvletal Год назад
Last round ending sounds super sus in so many ways i have to respect your ability to talk about it without spewing distaste on top of other errors you’d already had to deal with that day
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
I made a longer comment above. The way he presents what happened isn't great, there's a lot more context to what happened that basically rules out the possibility of cheating
@lvletal
@lvletal Год назад
@@GaneshahaxI wasn’t meaning to imply any known quantity of your actions, just the judges detouring policies. Was a lot of thoughts I just didn’t want to wall of words in the middle of the night.
@xGranmargx
@xGranmargx Год назад
The mistake sounds even worse considering Shuana bounced a permanent previously in the game that went to the owner's hand. Then that player tried to bounce a permanent that wasn't his to his own hand.
@andrewajumper2
@andrewajumper2 Год назад
Agreed. But there is also a certain muscle memory associated with linear wincons such as hullbreaker+0 cmc artifacts that tends to replace critical thinking. The fact that nobody noticed it really speaks to that tendency. The best we can do as players is just what Ian said: don’t turn off that critical thinking, even when it seems ok. Make players play out their wincons and resolve the stack normally.
@Egovinco98
@Egovinco98 Год назад
That last round sounds so weird with this, especially when there's such a clear rule (Tournament specific) for how to proceed after disconnects and whatnot
@matthewbell4897
@matthewbell4897 Год назад
You’ve been killing it, love the recap. Have you ever thought about/tried the RCQ grind and getting to the pro tour? I feel like you would kill 60 and 40 card magic as well, and trying your hand and the pro tour would be a fun arc to watch. Curious your thoughts and thanks for the content!!
@Iguanazilla69
@Iguanazilla69 Год назад
Love etali getting some love!
@kingcherubix7064
@kingcherubix7064 Год назад
Love to see my main deck being played and people respecting the big dino :)
@arosesthrone6420
@arosesthrone6420 Год назад
Super excited to see you drop this video, I've just recently been experimenting with Etali myself the last few weeks, and its been so much fun to play
@austinmayer8647
@austinmayer8647 Год назад
Hey love the content! Since you cover a lot of tournament results I was wondering if you could do a basic video on how they work? What someone entering their first tournament should expect and anything else. I have never entered and I feel the biggest reason is I just don’t know! Thanks!
@CharlotteMimic
@CharlotteMimic Год назад
Tournament recaps make me happy :)
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
Hey blue farm player here, it was a t1 mystic remora, not rhystic. Also something to note is my camera was down for about 1 minute, not 3. The judges looked at the stream before and after the disconnect and stated my graveyard and library had not moved at all (no foul play). The reason I asked to keep playing is because I likely would not have made top 16 based on my tiebreakers if we drew that game. While it's true i did win after the windfall resolved, what happened specifically is I praetors grasped dihadas underworld breach, which has a decent chance of failure if that player had drawn it or d. Swat etc. I imagine someone stacking their deck would go for a more consistent line like their own underworld breach or tutor.
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
My criticism was with the call given the tournament policy. That being said your points are very heard :)
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
​​​@@ComedIanMTGthink the call was fine given the circumstances. Even if the judges made me throw away my hand, the chances of me wheeling into a win would be virtually the same, in which case it matters less what I draw and more if the table drew into interaction (outside my control). This was my first tournament, so definitely a learning experience, next time I'll make sure to record my games so there aren't further problems.
@mrpleb123
@mrpleb123 Год назад
@@Ganeshahax You could have stacked your deck for the wheel while the camera is down, definitely bad judge call
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
​​​​​@@mrpleb123uld have been impossible to do that in one minute while repeatedly reconnecting to the game, and have the deck/graveyard not move at all. One other thing I'd like to mention, Spell table is notoriously unreliable and in the other games I played, other players had similar issues multiple times. I also offered to stream my screen through discord, which for some reason the pod declined. In hindsight I should have just streamed it anyway so there wouldn't be any bad feelings.
@mrpleb123
@mrpleb123 Год назад
@@Ganeshahax I'm not saying you did do that, but you wouldn't need to touch your gy at all, you could just pick up the top half of your deck skim through and stack 7 cards in a minute then put the half of the deck back on.
@itsnova504
@itsnova504 Год назад
Great content as always brotha !
@munsulight721
@munsulight721 Год назад
Etali remind me so much of a Pako but with a Way to win in a infinite way. Like You can get so much advantage but also have a way to push damage. It could be interesting to at least try to put more ways to copy etali or some of the ETB creature in the deck, if they are "good enough" cards. I feel like you could churn through so much stuff
@jorjor500
@jorjor500 Год назад
Blas act is one of the best sans black Boardclears. Many people don’t run it, and it’s basically a 1-2 mana clear a lot of the time in most metas
@Mad_Goblin_Engineer
@Mad_Goblin_Engineer Год назад
I put the cards that draw cards equal to creature power in my build. So far it’s been pretty good to hit those/cast them at instant speed. Momentous fall, return of the wild speaker,
@Egovinco98
@Egovinco98 Год назад
Played 3 or 4 games yesterday was fun. Best was T2 Food chain loop 🔥
@notasas9882
@notasas9882 Год назад
Where do people find all these cEDH Tournaments? Is there like a comprehensive list somewhere online that I can’t seem to find?
@shaded3313
@shaded3313 Год назад
This is my favorite deck I currently play. I play it with Aetherflux resovoir as one of the few in cons
@thanatoscharun
@thanatoscharun Год назад
Love it! Been looking for a fun build
@quantumlandbooks4005
@quantumlandbooks4005 8 месяцев назад
Round 4 sounds amazing. Sorry to hear about round 5. That sounds really shady.
@catman08724
@catman08724 Год назад
Such a meme that round 3 ended that way considering the whole "bounced things go back to their owners hands" thing was caught just prior to this lol, and holy shit the anime ending on round 4 was very unexpected
@VtroboguycEDH
@VtroboguycEDH Год назад
Would love to talk in detail on Etali - been running cEDH for a while and started Etali cEDH discord. Maybe I’ll reach out on socials!
@coffeedudeable
@coffeedudeable Год назад
Thats round 5 situation sounds so freaking sketch man. Like wow.
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
I made a longer comment above. The way he presents what happened isn't great, there's a lot more context to what happened that basically rules out the possibility of cheating.
@coffeedudeable
@coffeedudeable Год назад
@Ganeshahax even if it does rule out the possibility of cheating. It's super weird for the first player to push the judges into his terrible play especially when it was directly against the standard practice of the event. It's also super sketch that the second player didn't want to draw anymore given that he was one of the 3 that did want a draw at the start of the match and that he immediately won off the cards he drew from the wheel after not shuffling his deck
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
@@coffeedudeable I was the blue farm player, the reason I didn't want a draw is because I wouldn't have made top 16 if we drew that game. I wanted to play it out if I had some chance of winning and making top16. I did ask about how drawing worked because it was my first tournament, I assumed I would make t16 but the other players informed me I probably wouldn't make it based on the bracket, which caused me to change my mind.
@coffeedudeable
@coffeedudeable Год назад
​@Ganeshahax that would have been a fine argument for the pregame talk if you were the one who disagreed then. But you weren't. You agreed to draw before the game started then after you disconnected and got an incorrect judge call that heavily favors you all of a sudden you no longer want to draw. No matter how you slice that it looks bad.
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
@@coffeedudeable it was my first tournament and I didn't understand how cutting to top 16 worked until someone explained it to me later
@VampiricGamess
@VampiricGamess 8 месяцев назад
Mons has been pushing sissay for years too
@TripsAhoy
@TripsAhoy Год назад
Very surprised you guys missed that bounce play! It happens I guess lol.
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
Same :/ it was a rough realization especially given how much the two of us compete in cEDH 🙃
@trashygob
@trashygob Год назад
epic shirt
@FRODE12
@FRODE12 Год назад
i really wanna see ethan build Raggadragga, goreguts boss
@lucasc9142
@lucasc9142 Год назад
Okay… hear me out. I know this isn’t as good as a tide spout or a Sphinx of the second sun since you can’t neoform but how fun would it be to play etali in a temur deck like thrasios dargo that already runs kitten. You can eldritch for it. Displacer bounces etali each time you cast a non creature and odds are pretty good you get a non creature off 4 triggers (assuming all players on the game still). I know it’s not optimal but i thought of this interaction the other day and I think it would be so fun to pull off.
@flameberga
@flameberga Год назад
Just play rog thras with divergent transformation
@lucasc9142
@lucasc9142 Год назад
@@flameberga rog thras with divergent would be cool but also fragile. I’m looking to grind thrasios activations with seed borne and then neoform or eldritch into a kitten combo later while having backup dockside combos with temur sabertooth type cards. This would probably work better in a thrasios Kraum build although early game deflecting swat and fierce are appealing in rog thrasios it also prevents me from going the layered creature combo route. I could also add other hits for neoform abs eldritch like hullbreaker horror and consecrated Sphinx.
@frago321
@frago321 Год назад
Not long agonin a tournament i has a miss trigger of a Karmic Guide, i had justo draw My card and eas going yo cast a Felidar Guardian with 9 mana. Judge decided My Karmic Guide died and that Lost me the Game. After they Match the judge realizado his mistake on how he rules the miss trigger
@OODZUTSU
@OODZUTSU 11 месяцев назад
What do you like about Etali over something similar (like Maelstrom Wanderer) who can put you in better colors and have an easier time finding food chain?
@phoenix8071
@phoenix8071 Год назад
No recap on Fish Bowl II? It was an in person event that had like over 70 entrants!
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
There are only so many hours in the day 😅 I can do my best to find a place to squeeze it in
@discobiscuits4251
@discobiscuits4251 Год назад
Why does it say arbor elf is $16 ? I thought I was suddenly in possession of a gold mine
@mathewdebol923
@mathewdebol923 10 месяцев назад
Any chance testing out Hunting Velociraptor? Seems powerful to be able to prowl out Etali for 3 mana
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG 10 месяцев назад
Absolutely!
@mathewdebol923
@mathewdebol923 10 месяцев назад
@@ComedIanMTGoh awesome! How’s the list going? I’ve been playing Selvala Brostorm but I’m thinking I want to shift it into Etali
@fienddube
@fienddube Год назад
So the Blue Farm player’s screen just happened to freeze at this critical moment if the game? And the judge didn’t make them shuffle or anything? Highly suspicious. Huge judge punt.
@tylercraig5633
@tylercraig5633 Год назад
Unrelated but are you considering The One Ring in your Dawnwaker list?
@jarrodfoster7101
@jarrodfoster7101 Год назад
Whom are the tattoo artists that will be at the LotusCon convention?
@TurtleJack07
@TurtleJack07 Год назад
(SEED TIME) FOR THE CHEESE!!!
@shhinysilver1720
@shhinysilver1720 2 месяца назад
i'm basing my etali deck a lot more off of copying etali. things like the blade of selves, mirror box, helm of hosts, "orthion, hero of lavabrink", flameshadow conjuring, and a few others.
@fluffylegend294
@fluffylegend294 Год назад
I really wanna get involved in the Khaos tournaments, but I don’t have a desktop 😭
@philippophantastisch2310
@philippophantastisch2310 Год назад
I'm feelin' with ya, man! That judge's decision totally sucks! Honestly I don't get his reasoning at all.
@theratboy_
@theratboy_ Год назад
Hey! Do you proxy your cards? If so what method do you do?
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
Printer 😎
@surreal382
@surreal382 Год назад
Beep beep.
@iansamuel1811
@iansamuel1811 Год назад
Ya picked the wrong Gruul deck haha should have been on Erenis, Gloom Stalker // Street Urchin. Easy top 16
@MosesSuppose
@MosesSuppose Год назад
Totally unrelated but I love your shirt, where did you get it?
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
Magic and the Trevor project worked together during June but I think they're still for sale
@TheAmbientPulse
@TheAmbientPulse Год назад
Wait can’t you not win with someone else’s planeswalker combo just like they can’t win with a Mox opal that isn’t theirs? Aminatou only flickers stuff you own…
@jorjor500
@jorjor500 Год назад
It depends on the flicker effect. Some say under its owners control which would give it to the player, and some say under your control which would allow you to keep it, so it depends on a case by case basis.
@argonnas2
@argonnas2 Год назад
I was casting the game for your first round. Do you have the biggest balls just put down the food chain and said do something
@nickdemichele5269
@nickdemichele5269 Год назад
Are you playing Columbus scg tournament?
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
Hopefully!
@pabis6817
@pabis6817 Год назад
As a fellow blue farmer… super disappointed to hear this player didn’t agree to a draw in that moment. Idk seems super sketchy.
@Ganeshahax
@Ganeshahax Год назад
I made a longer post above, the tldr is I probably would not have made top16 if we drew that game, but some of the other players probably would have. There's a legitimate reason they wanted a draw and I didn't. Also, I came in 2nd in that tournament, and that was the only match I had any sort of technical difficulties in, plus my camera was down for a very short amount of time. I offered to stream on discord while we waited for Spell table to start working again also. 😊Spell table's reliability is completely outside of my control.
@AtlRopeGuy
@AtlRopeGuy Год назад
As an Atlanta native, the cookout was so not promoted. I have literally hundreds of friends who would have went if it had been promoted well. Lol
@AtlRopeGuy
@AtlRopeGuy Год назад
After listening to the video, the “judge call” was complete BS. That was wrong in every way, and at worst should have dq’d the blue farm player. Absolutely should never have been able to move that boardstate forward, and if it was a sanctioned event (which this obviously was not), I would appeal that decision all the way to the top. As a L3, it happens.
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
The Cookout sold out in a day so they really didn't need to promote it 🤷
@AngoDecay
@AngoDecay Год назад
Dang cheating sounds so easy in online Tournaments.
@definitelynotmany4972
@definitelynotmany4972 Год назад
Dislike for the Kira slander :v
@ComedIanMTG
@ComedIanMTG Год назад
?
@definitelynotmany4972
@definitelynotmany4972 Год назад
@@ComedIanMTGHe is the one who drew the Craterhoof Behemoth
Далее