During Disaster Averted, Barney needed to remove the ducky tie but couldnt. So, they made a deal that he could remove the tie for an extra 3 slaps for a total of 4. 2 was given in that episode, 1 was the three ladies and the tiger. And the final was during the wedding
Only 2 of Marshall's slaps were for the prematurity, yet Lily gave Barney 5X as many slaps for the same thing (well 2.5X because he took the second option). He should have appealed that to the Slapreme Court.
Ak'hasshativeritsol Yes, but Marshall’s premature slap was with permission of the slap bet commissioner, and due to a lie it seemed conclusive evidence that Marshall had won the bet. Barney slapped without enough information, and without the slap being granted by the slap bet commissioner. 2 slaps for being prematurely slapped, 3 slaps for slapping without enough information, and the slaps occurring at random times for slapping without permission of the slap bet commissioner.
Ak'hasshativeritsol they were without permission of a slap bet commissioner, meaning that it was a criminal slap and not a civil slap repayable by a 1:1 slap ratio (plus the slap that was given through the losing of the slap bet).
Ava Nicole but still the net was biased because of feelings, also marshal asked the commissioner to keep a secret, blackmailing her inconciously. He needed at least 10 slaps. In the end the real question is, why are arguing this? Is obvious that lily is incompetent as a ref.
Yes, she was. Marshall lied and slapped prematurely= 3 slaps immediately. Barney slapped prematurely = 10 slaps immediately or 5 slaps for eternity. At that point I would've had a serious problem with my friends.
You are both forgetting that the slap that was premature from marshal was done with lily permission therefore barney not only did a prematre slap but an unapproved slap that being said I feel like it should of just been like 5 slaps at once that's it however I don't c any reason why the time of the slaps had to be immediate should of been for eternity in all cases
Gee, calm down lol. Just make your own un-biased slap-bet with your friends. And, this is just a show after all. And Lily being biased is what makes it fun.
I always hated the way they treated Barney because he might be a player but in this group he's literally the light. He helped and gave them so many. and he brought all the fun. Without him this group would be boring af.
But it would've reached to the point when Barney and Robin where married/dating and she might be a little biased. But then again, it's ROBIN after all. She doesn't give a fucking shit turd because she still DOES want to see Barney get slapped.
The moment when you realize Barney choose Robin's idea(5 slaps) over Ted's(10 slaps) and it was the biggest mistake of his life. As he says, bros before hoes.
Well, Marshall slapped Barney when even the commissioner believed he Marshall was correct. The three Barney slaps were justified because Marshall didn't correct everyone when he should've. Then Barney, after learning of the dangers of Premature Slapulation salpped him before confirmation was received, therefore amping up the punishment. Slapsgiving came through because Barney was being a jerk about the previous verdict, and I believe thats the end of the potential bullshit ones.
JSmellerM one of the slaps was on no viable pretence, so it demands retribution, but a slap that was only given on a false pretence but was agreed upon by a slap bet commissioner only demands a payment of debts plus the rightfully owed slap for winning.
when he slapped him the 2nd time and said that's 2 I was laughing so hard as that was so many episodes later and I didn't think they would commit to that.
Watching this I just realized why I liked HIMYM so much more than Friends. It's cause they don't stand around awkwardly waiting for the laugh track to play out.
I've just reached the original slap bet episode but couldn't wait until I finish the whole series. Kinda love it when Marshal was about to break down in tears after three slaps. Wish he got more!
And this was before professional slapping took off. Imagine this happening now and Marshall training with like Vasily Kamotsky or their version of him.
The best slap was when he got another 5 as a trade for being allowed to take the duck tie off. "Wait, Ive changed my mind. I want to put the tie back on. Oh god why do I have to be Barney right now"
Am I the only one who think Lily should have never been the Slap commisioner.. as it later showed that she was biased af 😅.. I mean you can tell throughout the series that she had a hidden fetish about hurting Barney and Marshall on the other hand is literally her husband and better half
Tell you the truth this was the best part of the show is when Barney got the bitch slapped from hell and Barney was so paranoid each time because he didn't know when that bitch slap from hell was coming 😂
Barney needed a lawyer seeing as a premature slap only awarded him 2 slaps when Marshall got an additonal 9 had he asked for them then and there, moral of the story don't piss Lily off.
And watching the slap saga during my teenage years is how I became obsessed over slaps and my friends see me as some crazy, weird, sadistic barbarian 😂
marshall received 1 for lying and 2 for premature slapping barney received 5-10 for premature slapping lily violated her position as commissioner to favor marshall
Lilly was so unfair toward Barney. When Marshal broke the rules 3 slaps but when Barney broke them 10 slaps ... and it was not even his fault. As usual they fucked him good.
I GET IT!!! Marshall was dead set on Barney’s Slaps being brutal and epic is because after slapping Marshall 3 times in a row he made fun of him for crying. Wouldn’t you cry from getting slapped thrice? Marshall held a grudge and focused it into his slaps
Mooky Blaylock I hated the fact that Ted goes back to Robin after meeting the mother of his children. Also, the children were so enthusiastic. They shouldn't have divorced Robin and Barney and they shouldn't have killed the mother.
Well, to be fair, i think they wanted it to come full circle. They legit spent most of the entire show talking about his friends and not the mother. Hell, they focused thr pilot on robin, so it kinda works to come full circle. But yeah its a bit stupid imo.
the only thin I disliked was that in the future, barney and robin got divorced, and ted, like it was nothing (not to mention his wife was dead) just started dating robin again (I think it was this way I don't see this show for a long time)
