omg so relate-able, I also gave a BUNCH of 5 stars when I first started reading 😂 But now they're a little less. However I feel like I'm an easier reviewer? It's pretty easy to get 4 or 5 out of me unless the book is reaaaaally lackluster. Similar to you 1 stars are usually dedicated to DNFs 🥴 I wish goodreads will add ability for us to write half or quarter stars! Would make my rating more accurate -- part of the reason I track my reads on my Google Sheet too 😅 This is such a good tag, I'll probably do it because I need to think about more about how I rate my books 😂the stars are sometimes vibes and vibes alone. Adding the review on your goodreads is so smart so I might add it as well once I flesh out my thoughts!