Fans rating chart should be split into two categories. One with scoop (includes intake and exhaust) and one without. All the ones with scoop, should have gasket installed for fairness. I'm all for best fan design, but having the scoop changes it from something I can print and replace on my stock fan, to something that needs serious case modification to actually be used.
It should be standard policy to include these TPU gaskets unless the design conflicts with their use. PLA isnt great as a seal…Even with the flat design, the TPU was able to seal better. TPU for all!
Tpu is great for noise too. I switched to it on my laptop cooling thingy and it enabled using a far noisier squirrel cage fan on it without being too loud. I did also make an intake muffler out of it. (It's basically just a duct that holds the 100mm squirrel cage fan and goes straight to gpu cooler intake.)
I think we don't really need to custom print a gasket here. Every A12x25 fan comes with a seal for a radiator. I think he should have enough of these to use
Negative... It should be standard practice to apply fluid dynamics to the best of *YOUR* knowledge. Not, him cover for your lack of attention to detail.
@@DJBillionator it’s not a lack of knowledge when build surfaces and how the design is mounted can have a significant impact… as shown in this video. Two actually flat surfaces mounted well together should provide enough resistance against leaks under these test conditions, yet it didn’t work. FDM printing isn’t perfect. So a consistent application of this gasket would create an even playing field for the designs that have shrouds/exhaust/etc.
I think the seals against the noctua fan body should be standard practice going forward. If users want additional seals or a seal of a specific size/shape, then they should provide their own schematics for them.
@@Pystro it's like you didn't even read what I said. He'd still have the "standard seal" on the fan body. But since people submit fans of all shapes and sizes, there's not gonna be a one size fits all seal. In a situation where a user submits a fan that is either oddly shaped or has multiple stacking parts, then he/she should also provide files for a seal that would fit their design. If not, then only use the standard seal and nothing else.
Negative... The objective of this channel is it is the users responsibility to apply fluid dynamics to the best of their knowledge. This, would include seals... Stop promoting laziness.
I cant wait for mine to arrive! 3D Printers Workshop is giving away free filament when you purchase the V400 from them. This will be my first 3D Printer. Cant wait to apart of the maker community!!!
I also ordered from 3D Printers Workshop. From what I can tell they are a legit outfit and have a good rating with the BBB. I was a little hesitant because of the false claim of ordering within the next 9 hours and get it in less than a week although below it showed the actual shipping times. Other than that we'll see how it goes. I used paypal in case of any trouble.
@@SkillisForNoobs Noctua includes a full rubber gasket for the boxed versions of the A12x25 which are really useful: they fully cover one side of the fan, not just the corners. Just have to swap the corners for it. At the sides it a bit thin so placement can be finicky but worth it.
Not really the cheater didn't have any visible leak in the smoke test it's the first time a leak is apparent in the test So it more this particular print that is to blame (not flat)
If you want to throw the air out the side, sure go with a turbo type blade... Wheel to be precise, they aren't made to throw air through them, without the housing, the wheel is useless, extended tip or not.
@@meanman6992 The extended tip technology maximise the air flow IN THE HOUSING. It's useless on a fan that isn't a turbo wheel, wich is useless outside of the housing, ya understand ?
YES! GASKETS! It doesn't seem like it would have a big effect but imagine air flows like water, even a tiny hole matters if you are creating pressure. Great work 👍
Just want to say thanks for all the awesome 3D printing content. I ordered the Q5 over a year ago and had a really hard time getting it to work right, and after a week or two of trying to figure it out I gave up, but kept watching your fan showcase videos. This very week though I have gotten back into it and have gotten some good prints. in that year I managed to learn a lot about blender and 3D modeling so it's all falling into place. :D
The Q5 can be amazing but like all can be finicky and at times disastrous. I’ve gone for a couple months without touching it from issues I couldn’t figure out.
@@jdizzforyou agreed. Above anything it's a great starting point. Mine stopped leveling properly at some point, but you can easily replace the board, extruder, hotend, servos etc over time. Getting that good sturdy base and compact footprint is the true appeal of the at.
@@Charky_Creations and the price I got it at… 159 shipped during a Christmas sale on gearbest 2 years ago 😂 Stock board running marlin with the only upgrade being capricorn tubing.
Suggestion: Use the gaskets for all interfaces to the front or back of the A12x25 frame from now on. This would free us up from having to design our own gaskets, and it frees James up from having to print them. (printing TPU is a real pain… you have to dry it out and slow the print speed waaaay down.) Also, test the Cheater with the gaskets, to make it fair.
Just wanted to say that you are really enjoyable to watch. Your overall video quality is always very consistent, good audio, and great clarity. You are really good at listening to your subscribers and very thoughtful and fairly thorough in your videos. THANK YOU for all you do. Thank you.
Love your channel. Super chill host. A dude in his man cave lab with his dog. Interacts with the community better than if they were real life friends. Listens to suggestions and shoots new videos fast. Finger licking good quality, lighting, music, smoke teeeeeeests. Thank you so much for the free (to view) contents.
We had a fan beat the cheater and it wasn't even on an episode of fan showdown. This feels like needing to to read a comic book to get all the story for your favorite movie series.
For my smaller fans at home I have also found that just adding a spacer (like that gasket) greatly helps with reducing turbulence and improving airflow. I added mine specifically to cut down on the noise of the fans on my 3D printer whose fan grills were all very close to the fan itself.
Them using Klipper is for some reason genius, the number of times companies tried doing their own thing and falling miserably... This printer changed the my perception of Delta printers, which I didn't like before.
You should use the seals from now on for future showdowns, it'll make the results more fair cus it'll remove the variable of leaks from the tests. We're trying to determine what fan shape (and sometimes guides) work best, and removing anything else that could cause an issue from the equation will make results more consistent and precise.
This is a very tempting looking printer and I have closer 2,000 hours runtime on my poor SR pushing it to 220 mm/s with the only upgrade being 5015 cooling fans
I converted my Ender 3 to a direct drive with a $35 kit and never looked back. The almost complete lack of stringing easily makes up for the need to slow down the outer-most wall to avoid ringing. Plus I can just crank up the print speed for the inner walls to make up for it, since the direct drive's material-extruded-vs-estop curve is far flatter.
I converted one of my E3s to direct drive with a printed polycarbonate bracket a good quality titan clone and a spare stepper i had. Works fantastic even for tpu.
I bought the Q5 mainly after seeing your review of it. I had considered the SR or V400 as a 2nd printer, but went with the Anycubic Kobra Plus instead. My only real issue with the Delta-style is the round bed. The Q5 at a diameter of 200mm equates to a square area of approx. 141x141mm. So you're basically sacrificing up to 30% of the bed the closer you get to a square print. Don't get me wrong, I love my Q5 and it is great for smaller prints, but I am finding the square build plate easier to work with for modeling.
For high print speeds you also need to increase your nozzle temps. Filament can only flow so much at ~200. CNC Kitchen did a great breakdown of temperature vs flow rate.
I'm so jealous. I just bought a Sherpa direct extruder and mounted it on my SR, and I installed Klipper with a touchscreen running mainsail. They did everything I did, plus they beefed up the arms and increased the build volume. I want it so bad.
@@Oblithian Hey, I have space for two deltas in my life, the kids should be moving out soon. If the salesman talks to his manager, do you think he could get me a free undercoating? I heard it really helps these printers stand up to puddles and rock salt.
Maj. Hardware, you should get a small articulating arm to put that monitor on. Then you can attach it to the machine itself and still view it from any angle. A good brand I've found is called SmallRig (typically for camera or audio use)
On the suction side of fans a seal for the vacuum is very important just like intakes on cars, any kind of small leak that disturbs the smooth flow will affect performance pretty heavily for suck a small leak
Gasket up the Cheater and lets see who the real champion is. The Unswirler IS the leader now. The design is perfectly fine. You not mounting it well is user error imo.
I have the SR. My only gripe with it is the original hot-end for whatever reason had blockage issues. Both nozzles failed within the first few prints. After rebuilding/upgrading the break, nozzle, and block, everything worked great. Seeing the upgrades on the newer version... Very nice.
You should use those gaskets on all frame type fans for the gasket comparison to count IMO, including the Cheater. Gaskets seal everything, not just the Unswirler.
I CALL SHENANIGANS !! Run the Cheater again with gaskets, and then put the real winner at the No1 spot for a fair comparison, Also every fan from now you need to use the gasket personally since you can re use this same one for all builds
I know you're used to prusa slicer, but the real 400mm test is to use cura with the cura profile they provided. They have might have already done all the fine tuning you were talking about.
With the vast diversity of fan designs you get and test, why is there never an airflow vs. static pressure vs. obstruction test? You would only need a 3D-printed set of obstruction plates for your wind tunnel (with holes in them) and a differential air pressure sensor.
Why ? it did not taken in account the results with gasket the cheater is still no1 And in the cheater test there was no visible leak it's the first time a leak is visible in the smoke test And a need to rewatch the video but it looked like he used only 2 tie rap to hold the part to the fan and it was leaking by the corner with no tie rap
I still remember my first FLSUN printer. In the first days of home 3D printers they had basic kits. I got them right between supply chain changes for safer stuff. I got the manual for the wrong power supply, and one that was set to the wrong voltage. Needless to say, the wire exploded and connected my arm to mains electricity. shocker. still, it's because of that I was a very early adoper of creality. still using it, too, after most of a decade now.
A screen shot or two of the webui over wifi would really sell this, it's amazing looking and something people are just not familiar with in the product line.
The V400 looks like the go-to answer for what to do if I give up trying to make my Predator reliable for long prints. My Prusa has definitely sold me on direct extruders.
Dude…I’ve been watching your videos for a while. You’re so smooth and natural. You could get away with doing some story telling vids. Love what you do.
Your right the q5 is a great printer. It has a ton of potential for upgrades. I have mine upgraded decently *don't have a video on latest mods* it can print stupid fast in comparison to stock. (Benchy in ~13min) I have a BMG extruder, chc pro(115w ceramic heater,volcano nozzle), mks robin v3.1 W/marlin, 2209 drivers, touch screen,5015 fan, upgraded arms(SR style) magnetic PEI build plate, bi-metal heatbreak. Now I have as much in it as i would buying a higher end printer and I have linear rails coming. My q5 also now has USB and wifi with the robin board. I do still however have a bowden tube. That v400 needs to find its way into my "fleet" in the semi-near future.
Love your channel, inspiring people to just try stuff and then implementing their ideas just to see what happens, you are an enabler of stuff. A legend.
I bet you could make some fan screw sized bolts and wingnuts super easy now rather than waste zipties if you decide to go further than this with gaskets. I still really want to see that conglomeration of air systems you rigged up for the bladeless sealed like that!
Ugh, Delta printers are cute. But, way to large for the build print size that you get simply by design. Also too finicky to get quality prints out of for most users. They are fun to watch, and that's about it.
WOW. EPIC !! I've been preaching Delta's sicne 2015. Direct Drive + those speeds= OMG !!!!!! That might literally be a perfect printer. Well, I guess if it had side panels for heated enclosure, then it would literally do everything a single extruder could possibly do. I've printed polycarbonate on my delta before(open enclosure.) That was not easy, but it did happen. Man Congrats on that printer !! My favorite thing about a delta is that you can save a print >> you can flatten bad layers by hand with the spudger/spatula. You can literally hold the print upright. You can use the spudger/spatula as impromptu support support material. The support spatula.
@@stevenbmw850 Well, I watched some reviews... The machine is still pre-order ? I'd be cautious with this machine/company. I'm curious >> Why do you want me to check out this printer ? I already have a printer ...
@@tdtrecordsmusic well all the things you listed a core xy has, this also has a sealed enclosure, with the added benefit of active vibration cancellation. Seems like something you might be interested in if/when looking for a new one.
you mentioned your prusa being loud, a drop in mod is to use RJZM 02-08 IGUS bearings. It is eerie how much quieter this made my prusa. I think that vibrations rattling the ball bearings in the stock setup causes the majority of the noise. These Igus bearings are just one piece.
Man I have been wanting a delta. I was looking at the SR but really wanted direct drive for TPU so I got the QIDI and love it. Butttttt Damn now to tell the wife I need this
damn, I never knew you could print flexible materials with these things, that changes things. and 800 is a lot less than I expected to pay for one too.
I can't remember the channel, but I watched a random video of a guy that made some carb gaskets for his lawnmower to test the longevity. At least in the short term, they seem to be impervious to gas and oil. TPU can be a game changer for folks with old and obscure vehicles and engines and need gaskets or dampeners made.
I have the v400. It is a great machine, but it still lacks some profiles in Cura, except for PLA. The PLA profile is extremely good. If you want to print flexible parts, a simpler model will do fine. I use my old AnyCubic for TPU. Recently found a 85A filament which is a lot softer than 95A. It printed fine. Very clean results. I have repaired so many things just using 3d printed parts. From wheelbarrows to furniture, camera mounts, garden fence etc. Not to mention things I printed to tinker with. Wind generators, rain collectors, housings for outdoor electronics. I am not sure I am breaking even, or ever will, but the stuff is just a great hobby for me.
noooo it beat the cheater! one must automatically assume that the surfaces are sealed unless specifically designed that way. the fact it was designed flat means it should have sealed and any warpage from printing MUST be disregarded..... the cheater has officially been beaten
I agree, the intended design did not contain any leakages and the design is shown to be better in this test, I am not sure why it would not be allowed to become first place.
@@madmechanic7_797 probly because when u make stuff u need to take a count of things that could be going wrong and if u need additives it means u had fault in the way u made it compared to the way it was suppose to how it actualy did
@@StoryMode180 agreed if the cheater does better with the gaskets then it deserves the top spot. and the top 10 need to be retested with gaskets, future tests must be done with gaskets to ensure fair testing
Dual rails with internally running wheels are stiffer when it comes to twisting(and side-load is definitively a thing with this printer) and this also make the rails far less likely to develop slop over time.
How dare you not show us the smoke test with the tpu seals on the fan? How dare? You know we want it! lol Looking forward to seeing how this revelation influences the future of fan design!
Looks great, doesn't cost too too much, and definitely an option instead of Prusa. Only downside is sheer physical size, that thing is a behemoth. Also, not sure what the situation is with regards to getting a Revo nozzle system on this one - have it on my Prusa and you'll pry it out of my cold dead hands, never going back to old style nozzles.
I'm all about resin printers. The detail quality is crazy in comparison. Yes there are advantages of filament printers, like the ability to run 2+ colors or 2+ types of filaments. They are also typically faster and ca print far larger items... but they just do not come even close to the print quality. That huge bust I could print 1" tall and it would still likley have more details that they huge print.
5:20 those carbon tubes are overkill haha, we use similar if not thinner tubes for suspension in our race car, they are probably not as thick in terms of wall thickness on the printer just found it curious
Gaskets or buffer removed should be standard anyway. Cheater dethroned (till further tested with gasket). Imho Also that v400 looks sweet and performs pretty well.
Buyers, beware, do not buy into the hype and free printers that are given to reviewers. I can tell you you will be lucky to get your order the way most customers have to order in one to two months with tons of excuses. Not the type of company I would want to do business with, and if you did I could imagine the type of support you would get and time delays.
I think it's a bit premature to say "it beat the cheater" until you also test the cheater with those gaskets, because it was probably suffering from similar leaks.
Well they read my mind also then, I have a FLSUN QQ-S PRO I love it BUT I've broken prints trying to get them off the build plate and was wanting to put lights on the head, I'm definitely getting a V400, That plus my QQ-S PRO and once I finish my Voron I'll be set for making the things I want in less time, I don't like leaving the house with them running until I come up with some fire proof enclosures and fire suppression, yes I'm a worry wart because it's the only house I have and my philosophy is never say it will never happen
I bought the whambam spring steel PEX bed upgrade for my SR, and I'm looking into converting it to a direct drive with either a Sherpa Mini or Orbiter 2.0 I've ordered a bi-metal heat break for it, too.
Maybe it aint about about the gaskets itself, but about the plenum (the added space between the fan and the aligned parts). To proof that, just print your gaskets from PLA and try again! Regarding the FLSUN V400: I am not shure if it is twice as good as the QQ-S pro... but it seems pretty nice though!
Looking at a 1st printer for work and wondering if this one is beginner friendly. I like the build volume and a lot of the features. Is this one too much printer or would it be skipping over some of the headaches of a cheaper entry level printer.
Would be cool to see some 200mm fans for a season. I know they're obviously not used for CPU cooling, but maybe have a case with one exhaust fan and the submitted 200mm fan for an intake, with a passive cooler on the CPU? It'd also be neat to see how the air flows through a case with the smoke machine.
Hello! Always love your content! I just pre-ordered the V400 last week and was curious if you can provide your filament types (Material and Brand) and settings you use in your slicer? Just want to be ready as soon as possible once I get it!
Hey Thomas, wouldn't a polar 3D printer be better for fans? Meaning something that has a turntable for the base. This way, the fan blades could be more similar than when using a delta.