Its not good, but it had good ideas and even better designs. If the film had better explained aspects of the plot, removed the blatant plot holes, and had a longer run time, it probably would have done very well and we would have gotten a sequel. Edit: one of the main problems I myself have with the movie is that it turned away from the darker and grittier tone that AOE and DOTM had established in favor of a more "action for the sake of action" kind of tone that the first 2 TF films had. They stopped taking the conflict seriously which I believe was a big mistake.