0:00 Introduction
0:32 Someone reuploaded one of my videos, I filed a DMCA takedown.
1:43 How I became aware of ChudLogic's reaction.
2:27 ChudLogic admits his reaction isn't fair use.
3:28 My main issue with reaction content is that it is immoral and unethical.
3:33 There are situations where I think react content is fine. This is not one of them.
3:59 Filing the DMCA takedown notices.
4:32 I did not file the DMCA due to ChudLogic's criticisms.
5:55 I only care that he reuploaded my video in full.
6:22 I was surprised that RU-vid didn't accept the DMCA claim.
7:30 While trying to contact a law firm, a deranged shitstorm was unfolding on RU-vid and Twitter.
8:00 ChudLogic is still mad about this, and even my lawyers think this situation is stupid.
9:13 Some people were confused why I didn't say anything publicly.
9:58 My lawyers agreed I had a case, but received the same automated responses from RU-vid.
10:29 It took a long time to get through to a real person.
11:18 What can be learned from all of this?
11:35 Despite having a valid reason to file a takedown, you still risk backlash for doing so.
12:14 TurkeyTom / TomDark's video covering these events.
13:22 I have a problem with the market impact of react videos. My issue is not about how much they "add" to the video.
14:06 Reactors take value from creators far more than they ever give back.
14:40 Tom was confused why I struck such a small channel.
14:57 Addition is not the same as transformation.
16:13 A fair use case made it to the Supreme Court in 2022.
16:55 People seem to believe that adding something to someone else's work immediately makes it fair use.
17:22 Right now, there is no legal support for 'watch parties' being fair use.
17:45 No one actually cares about how fair use is written in law.
18:26 I fundamentally disagree with Tom's opinion of reuploading entire videos.
18:55 If copying has no cost, then creating will always be worse off.
19:19 Reviewing songs / albums is different, because you can listen to the same song for years.
20:11 The idea that three paragraphs of text is 'massive' is depressing.
21:11 It is fine to use clips of me for context in a larger work or memes.
22:22 I am still the rights holder to these original clips. Uploading a clip and doing nothing else doesn't transform it.
22:44 Again, I see using this clip for context in a larger body of work as fair.
23:15 Bowblax's "Twitter vs." video.
23:31 The negative response Bowblax received was enough to be convinced to make a second part.
24:06 The difference between Bowblax and Tom's coverage is immediately apparent.
26:36 Bowblax claims that I DMCA clip usage if it's negative, but I never filed anything against him.
27:48 The amount of old drama these people tried to dig up is insane.
29:49 WillyMacShow's tweet shows that these people aren't interested in my viewpoints.
30:43 They don't think the copyright system works, but when it agrees with them, RU-vid must be correct.
31:23 Bowblax never actually argues why my claims would be false.
32:02 Bowblax's second video.
32:28 When filing a DMCA claim, you must affirm that you are willing to go to court.
34:26 Bowblax actively ignored people defending me in his first video.
34:49 Optimus' video.
35:11 My DMCA takedown was specifically for copyright-related issues.
36:29 Optimus says that I struck the video for being negative while making a negative video.
37:11 Optimus says he watches my stuff but also believes I would use the DMCA system maliciously.
38:21 Explaining why I made the SA analogy in my original essay.
38:48 Hasan Piker's statements about consent are disgusting and fucked up, which is why I made the analogy.
39:36 Mocking people ignoring consent is not the same as calling reactors rapists.
40:13 When people make a video critiquing me, I respond to their arguments. I don't strike them.
40:42 ChudLogic would've been fine if he watched the video in his own time and then discussed it on stream.
41:12 Optimus' reasons for believing ChudLogic's video was fair use contradict fair use guidelines.
43:18 The amount of work used does affect fair use guidelines. It's one of the main factors.
44:24 Ethan (H3H3)'s court ruling specifically states that a watch party would have lost.
44:56 Conclusion
✔Twitch Channel ~ / darkviperau
✔Rambles Podcast ~ / @viperrambles
✔VOD Channel ~ / channel
✔Shorts Channel ~ / @darkviperaushorts416
✔My Discord ~ / discord
✔Subreddit ~ / darkviperau
✔Twitter ~ / darkviperau
✔Instagram ~ / darkviperau
✔TikTok ~ / darkviperau
✔Facebook ~ / 61554548326574
✔GTA 5 Speedrun Discord ~ / discord
✔Business Email ~ darkviperau@mgmtexe.com
29 июн 2024
