Тёмный

I asked the Civ 7 team some hard questions... 

PotatoMcWhiskey
Подписаться 477 тыс.
Просмотров 56 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

19 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 491   
@FiraxisGames
@FiraxisGames 8 часов назад
ALWAYS a good time to sit and chat, Potato -- thanks for the great questions!
@tritan3900
@tritan3900 7 часов назад
❤ Love civ ❤
@zeytelaloi
@zeytelaloi 7 часов назад
What will happen to TSL games? True Starting Locations. Will we still be able to play on Earth? And what about preserving your civ?
@konstantinbreen
@konstantinbreen 7 часов назад
super happy for you Carl grats for baby!
@wxcvbndu51
@wxcvbndu51 7 часов назад
Whatever just remove Denuvo
@ZzolllozZ
@ZzolllozZ 7 часов назад
I have a guestion, too Can you mod DIZ NUTS ON YOUR CHIN ? HUH, GOT'EM!
@ExamplePrime
@ExamplePrime 7 часов назад
"Before we ask any questions I have a question" Found this funnier than I should have
@nitehawk86
@nitehawk86 6 часов назад
yo dawg, I heard you like questions...
@CaptainHandsome
@CaptainHandsome 6 часов назад
Imagining Potato nervously eyeing his wallet when they talk about fixing the map generation system to always give good start locations
@PotatoMcWhiskey
@PotatoMcWhiskey 4 часа назад
Unironically
@woodysmith2681
@woodysmith2681 7 часов назад
Biggest news was actually that Age 2 will be naval warfare/exploration and religious expansion. I think that might address the underlying weakness of naval gameplay in previous civs, by making an Age dedicated to it. Because the Renascence Period was a period dominated by naval warfare over land-based warfare. [Apologies to Potato, but yes, the fact that England was an island played heavily into it.]
@wifeofanacrobat3654
@wifeofanacrobat3654 7 часов назад
i'm 100 sure that medieval and more ages will be added in future expansions
@Sondrebol
@Sondrebol 7 часов назад
@@wifeofanacrobat3654 i'm not sure. Considering how vastly the game will change between ages, having more than 3 ages sounds like it could be a bit tiresome.
@Kuddochan
@Kuddochan 7 часов назад
@@wifeofanacrobat3654 More ages doesn't make the game better, in fact it was one of the biggest problems with Humankind's version of it. You need enough time per era to properly be able to settle in with your current civ and get to use their unique things to the fullest before you move on to the next one. If you add in more eras you either need to reduce the timespan of each of them, or extend the whole duration of the game significantly, neither of which are probably desirable.
@cinattra
@cinattra 6 часов назад
​@@SondrebolWell, hopefully in a future dlc they will have an option for how many ages you want in your game. I love long games. I would love 4 or 5 ages with the 5th age being a future age.
@Shidan174
@Shidan174 5 часов назад
I don't see any chance of there being new ages introduced in the middle of the timeline. The stuff from those eras is not missing, so it would involve a massive restructuring of the current ages to rework another into the middle. Medieval is already covered by the late Antiquity and early Exploration eras. Seems like a lot of wasted effort imo. Though I personally think I would have like a separate Medieval age. If they added any new ages, it would on the ends imo. So some sort of prehistoric age, or a future age. Or they could copy their competitors' ideas again implement alternate age variants like Millennia did. None of this is likely imo though, outside of maybe a future/information age, as truly modern technology has been seemingly absent from everything we've seen.
@DarthDre
@DarthDre 7 часов назад
*I asked Civ 7 team some hard questions* ❌️ *I spoke with the Civ 7 team and had questions to Aksum* ✅️
@TheW83
@TheW83 4 часа назад
Yeah pretty bad title and I probably wouldn’t have watched without that word. I guess that makes it clickbait?
@Flipflopskipskop
@Flipflopskipskop 4 часа назад
​@@TheW83 100% click bait. Unsubscribed
@justsomeperson8806
@justsomeperson8806 3 часа назад
@@Flipflopskipskop lol
@deerdren
@deerdren 7 часов назад
The hardest hitting question: will the game have a functional multiplayer? 😂
@joshuasimmons512
@joshuasimmons512 5 часов назад
True
@mwm776
@mwm776 4 часа назад
Really wish he asked some multiplayer questions. It’s the most loyal part of the community
@calamity916
@calamity916 3 часа назад
You are hitting up the wrong youtuber. Potato has stated many times he doesn't care about multiplayer.
@moonverine
@moonverine 7 часов назад
I imagine Sid's office as featuring at least one huge model railroad.
@elutes215
@elutes215 8 часов назад
The game never feels complete until an expansion or two. I know there are economic reasons for this, but it would be nice to see a complete game at launch.
@etienne8110
@etienne8110 8 часов назад
There are so many dlcs now that the expansion model feels far away.
@LoganChristianson
@LoganChristianson 8 часов назад
Part of it is also that players getting their hands on the game shapes its trajectory. It doesn't feel "complete" on launch because the last 3 civ games have had core parts of the game overhauled in DLC as a result of player feedback (well, maybe not Beyond Earth). That and mods. I think it "not feeling complete" is something that you impose on the game, not the other way around.
@Jack_Rakan
@Jack_Rakan 7 часов назад
@@LoganChristianson True, for me getting directly into Civ 6 at launch definitely felt like a complete game. I liked the changes added in the expansions, and if I went back to do a game without the expansions it probably would feel incomplete, but it definitely didn't feel like it at the time.
@Sandman10032
@Sandman10032 7 часов назад
@@LoganChristiansonciv 6 was a buggy mess at launch as well as missing key features. Religious and diplo victories weren’t in the game and now that they are they’re the least liked. Combine that with gathering storm’s hated global warming mechanic. So I don’t really see it as “player input” in how the game is developed. As well as asking for $70 upfront when the games have a history of launching incomplete and buggy I can see why people are passing on it
@apeflight5553
@apeflight5553 7 часов назад
"complete game" is a pretty meaningless phrase, really. You can say you want a game with more stuff. But "complete" or "incomplete" is just nonsense
@LandBark
@LandBark 8 часов назад
"I asked the Civ 7 team some hard questions..." Press x to doubt.
@corphish8
@corphish8 7 часов назад
the nice 'will there be mod support' softball opener
@peterpantoffel727
@peterpantoffel727 7 часов назад
"I spiked the ball for the Civ 7 teams a few times and here is what they planned to tell you" lol
@hanksoandso8778
@hanksoandso8778 7 часов назад
Like: "Did you get any meaningful input from the competitive players, or fans with thousands of hours in Civ 6, before making foundational and game breaking changes to the Civilization formula?" I didn't think so.
@TheSilentScreamX
@TheSilentScreamX 7 часов назад
@@hanksoandso8778 Didn't realise you'd played it. Tell us more about how the game is broken.
@TheCube2424
@TheCube2424 7 часов назад
⁠​⁠@@hanksoandso8778 you haven’t even played the game, it might be a little early to be confidently talking about “game breaking” changes
@RogerMacCallum
@RogerMacCallum 7 часов назад
Poor Ed was under the weather…
@Tentacl
@Tentacl 7 часов назад
I know those guys don' control this, but the high prices alongside no regionalized monetization made this game completely impossible to buy in Brazil. The base version costs R$ 350, meaning it's almost double other AAA games (many cost R$ 200,00) and the complete one cost R$ 650,00 - our monthly minimum wage is R$ 1.412,00. This is based on a 44h week work hours, or aprox. 132 montly hours. For reference, this is worth USD 260.03 with today's currency conversion. In the US, the mimnimum wage it USD 7.25 per hour, so considering the same work hours, UDS 957 per month. So yeah, no more 2K games here.
@CarKiller92
@CarKiller92 7 часов назад
if u are working for minimum wage, maybe you could find better stuff to do than civ.
@NunyaBizness-gn1lp
@NunyaBizness-gn1lp 7 часов назад
You can thank US minimum wage workers for that. They don’t understand economics and vote/pressure government to mandate pay raises without any accountability from them. They overestimate their value causing more harm than good.
@Tentacl
@Tentacl 7 часов назад
@@CarKiller92 I'm a lawyer smartass. I'm just trying to show a comparison of economy scale and currency value.
@Whynot-yu2tt
@Whynot-yu2tt 7 часов назад
@@CarKiller92 Yeah man, minimum wage workers don't deserve to be happy or have fun.
@Voron_Aggrav
@Voron_Aggrav 7 часов назад
@@CarKiller92 anyone, no matter how much they earn, or where they live should have the right to spend time with Hobbies, and have ways to deal with stress and have fun with their time,
@cinnamonbeardstud
@cinnamonbeardstud 2 часа назад
This wasn't a hard question interview, spuddy. It was more game detail minutae, which is of course very fun and interesting and valid in its own right, but the actual hard questions weren't brought up. People have important issues about the packaging surrounding the game (modes and compatibility, denuvo, pricing structures, and so on). Of course there is still a litany of questions about the gameplay, style, and the nuts and bolts of it, those of which can be hyped or debated about forever as with any other new game, but they aren't what's pressing to the community at the moment. Again I fully recognize that these guys don't make the decisions regarding these big questions, but the damage from dodging them still effects them and the perception of the game itself as negatively as much as it does 2K and the archetypal "out if touch ceos in suits". This whole launch campaign looks incredibly sus when it very likely does not need to be, and I can't for the life of me figure out why there is so much opacity about this game. Potato please blink twice if they're holding you hostage!
@JJV7243
@JJV7243 8 часов назад
Big question - can you play a game (and win) in a single age by multiple victory types? Like can you set the game to be ONLY a single age and somehow get a science/culture/domination victory within that era?
@subsonicsubway8894
@subsonicsubway8894 7 часов назад
@@JJV7243 Pretty sure they mentioned you could play a single-age-only game before.
@Nothing2150
@Nothing2150 6 часов назад
Yes, they said all ages are playable completely separately as a self contained game
@kristianvincentzrygaard3767
@kristianvincentzrygaard3767 5 часов назад
Poor Sound died 22:41
@dennyahh
@dennyahh 7 часов назад
happy about the "less monolithic" comment regarding designing mods that want to affect certain eras or specific systems.
@JMSouchak
@JMSouchak 7 часов назад
It always seemed to me that rainforests shouldn't generate science until the modern era. 😅
@joelquinn5347
@joelquinn5347 6 часов назад
You need to see it this way; the people living there saw a new animal every other day. Or they died by something new each other day, hence learned quite a bit.
@danieleads1266
@danieleads1266 8 часов назад
My one question. If I missed it I am sorry. Do they add an “undo last click” option?
@michaelbeale559
@michaelbeale559 8 часов назад
I sure if they added that, it would've been featured in the stuff they've showcased by this point.
@hanksoandso8778
@hanksoandso8778 7 часов назад
You mean for Civ 7 entirely? Sadly no.
@erikhudepohl754
@erikhudepohl754 6 часов назад
it would be to overpowered. Eg scout in one direction, then undo and scout the other direction
@manuelkumli5393
@manuelkumli5393 6 часов назад
That would be cheating
@danieleads1266
@danieleads1266 5 часов назад
@@erikhudepohl754 yes I see that, but I hate when I misclick, they could maybe make it an option for those of us that aren’t using it for advantage and just are playing it drunk at night and misclick a movement.
@marekkos3513
@marekkos3513 7 часов назад
They have balls , thats for sure !
@VanBradley
@VanBradley 7 часов назад
This was a super fun video! Fantastic work from all involved. Would love to see more of these in the future 🎉
@Kjotleik
@Kjotleik 4 часа назад
I heard no hard questions here... only placating Firaxis people. It basically crossed the line from interview over to commercial spot.
@chrisslaughter8448
@chrisslaughter8448 7 часов назад
i love developers who are open with the modding community but i can’t stand a developer placing faith in modders to fix their mistakes and balance issues instead of just taking time to make it good themselves
@runescapevsminecraft
@runescapevsminecraft 6 часов назад
You should reframe how you look at the modder/dev symbiosis. Think of the devs like chipotle, they hire all the workers, buy and prepare all the ingredients, run all the background logistics etc. You get to enjoy their product how you like. For civ it’s Single player, multiplayer, early game, late game: think of it like rice, beans, protein, toppings. You then have the freedom to go home and add whatever else you want to your bowl they even give you the tools to do it. So you can go home and “mod” your chipotle bowl and add Oreos and pickles and whatever weird shit you like. It makes zero financial or logistical sense for chipotle to stock every store with Oreos and pickles for the niche community that wants that esp when you can just do that at home. Same thing with game dev, it doesn’t make sense to try and balance your game to try and serve every niche cub community. Especially when you know that community is just going to regulate itself anyway. It makes far more sense to give them the freedom and tools to cater to their specific need rather than wasting time and energy trying to add Oreos and pickles to your game just for them.
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
They are expecting mods to fill the gap of missing civs, not balance and mistakes, at least from this interview, it is obvious with eras split the game will lack content. Expect MANY leader pack DLCs too.
@jaspervanheycop9722
@jaspervanheycop9722 5 часов назад
I'm glad to hear about adressing map balance and start bias! That's one of my biggest frustrations with civ 6, a bad spawn (i.e. neighbours like 5 tiles from your capital, barbarian insanity or just desert/tundra iceball with a civ that has zero bonus to it) can ruin your game, and a godly spawn can ruin it as well, where you blast past everyone in the Classical Era and are hopelessly running away without any hope of challenge or intrigue. I've abandoned so many games because I got ganked in the first ~20 turns or where by turn 100 I'm already "done" and the next 200 are just a formality to click through.
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
I wish balanced spawns are a togglable option, because I kind of hate where everyone has the same power level and all civs are equal it's more fun and realistic to have some outliers.
Час назад
but that's what I like about civ. that's how history was, the vikings were forced to raid because their soil and resources were horrid. if you get a bad spawn, go military, your civ wants to take others lands. then your crappy spawn city can be purely for encampment/military spawning. The land you take can be for food and resources. civs are not meant to be equal, and you are supposed to try and adapt, thats the fun. just choose the mirrored competitive maps if you want perfectly balanced spawn..
@PhoenixStriker1
@PhoenixStriker1 3 часа назад
This entire interview felt like a waste of time. If I wanted to have the devs promote their game at me I’d just go rewatch their company’s promotional content. A hard question might’ve been something along the lines of asking them about recent games that inspired them and how they intend to truly differentiate their work. Potato even vaguely referenced Endless Legend’s and Endless Space’s staple Civs with his “always at war” civ comment. Those conversations would’ve been interesting and worthwhile, much more so than “Let’s reiterate everything said in the announcement stream but with no visuals and less cohesion.” Missed opportunity, alas.
@gokuchickengirl
@gokuchickengirl 7 часов назад
audio seems to be broken at 22:40 for a few seconds
@Joe-qn3dk
@Joe-qn3dk 7 часов назад
And at 16:50 maybe said something juicey ? I cant work it out
@Ganjena2k
@Ganjena2k 5 часов назад
@@Joe-qn3dk came to the comments to see if anyone else noticed!
@Creddz69
@Creddz69 5 часов назад
Lip readers go!!!!
@PotatoMcWhiskey
@PotatoMcWhiskey 4 часа назад
Just me fucking upr somewhere in the edit probably
@ancientideas
@ancientideas 3 часа назад
They confessed that humankind was better than civ 6
@Drago02129
@Drago02129 5 часов назад
If you get a second interview, can you ask them to explain what the “opening up the map further in the second age” means exactly? Obviously it means they’re going to add the tech to cross deep water but what if you pick a pangaea type of map where you don’t worry about that? Will certain areas be prohibited for you to access until then?
@vrubim
@vrubim 2 часа назад
I don't care what others think. I'm hyped. Been playing since Civ 2. Great interview, Potato!
@sncy5303
@sncy5303 8 часов назад
The biggest question for me is if they really plan to release the game with the denuvo malware. If so, that would be a no-go for me, and I won't buy it.
@christophstahl8169
@christophstahl8169 7 часов назад
same
@inmanis2924
@inmanis2924 7 часов назад
yup pretty much. was rocky with the midge civ change stuff, and then denuvo on lunch sealed the coffin
@TheSilentScreamX
@TheSilentScreamX 7 часов назад
Of course you will, and they know it.
@kire5991
@kire5991 7 часов назад
@@TheSilentScreamX not everyone is weak like you, unable to stand for their values and giving in because they want to play the game
@luke1119411
@luke1119411 6 часов назад
​@@kire5991 Or some people just don't really care about Denuvo.
@JorisQC
@JorisQC 6 часов назад
Very cool! I met Carl very shortly at Gamescom! He seems like a very passionate guy and I'm looking forward to Civ 7! :D
@briankelly1240
@briankelly1240 7 часов назад
'hard question' 'were you inspired by human kind'?
@DigitalDeath88
@DigitalDeath88 6 часов назад
Humankind was not the first game of that style...
@jameshealey6121
@jameshealey6121 6 часов назад
​@@DigitalDeath88 Woooosh! Right over your head
@DigitalDeath88
@DigitalDeath88 5 часов назад
@@jameshealey6121 Zero whoosh, people keep saying this like humankind made something new.
@michaelmoran2125
@michaelmoran2125 4 часа назад
Hey bud calm down... noones ever heard of the game you failed to mention and these guys are the only 2 in this entire comment section asking the only pertinent question. ​@DigitalDeath88
@DigitalDeath88
@DigitalDeath88 4 часа назад
@@michaelmoran2125 Because it's not singular at all. There are hundreds of games that came before humankind with the same mechanics. It's part of the entire genre. Stop flailing.
@wxcvbndu51
@wxcvbndu51 7 часов назад
"Yes, we made a love letter to fans by making you unable to play the offline game if you don't connect to the internet every now and then to make sure you actually love us" Ah yes, I know people with similar definition of love, sounds pretty toxic to me tho
@TheSjuris
@TheSjuris 7 часов назад
Single player is 100% offline. Oops.
@hikariluanGC
@hikariluanGC 6 часов назад
@@TheSjuris He's talking about the denuvo anti-piracy system which is considered a malware. The game will come with it as they announced it would. And, in order to repel piracy, it has to connect to the internet periodically to check your game version which literally destroys the game performance in many systems including older computers. Therefore, in CIV VII, even the single player mode is not 100% off line. As a matter of fact, it will need connection for you to even be able to play it.
@TheSjuris
@TheSjuris 6 часов назад
@@hikariluanGC you’re thinking about anti-cheat which would also eliminate modding. The game is verified to be 100% offline with modding ability. Again don’t like it, get rid of the pirates which have been a problem for millennia. It’s a one time check.
@hikariluanGC
@hikariluanGC 6 часов назад
​@@TheSjuris Well, as per what I know how it does work is that it needs to be checked periodically with denuvo which is the system that they are using and it is not anti cheating, it is anti hacking for anti piracy issues. It is not a one time check at all and you're not getting it. Also, I don't know if I will play civ vii or not. I will probably wait a few years since the game is always a mess on launch and needs dlc to actually start being a game. Firaxis and their fans are delusional about what the company is actually able to churn out. I'm not that big of a fan of the genre and there are more games to explore which are way more worth of my time and money. I'm not worried one bit about if CIV VII will be a success or badly fail, that is not my problem at all. It is a huge nope for me as long as they have denuvo. As for me commenting, I was just trying to explain how denuvo works to you and seems like you're either not getting it or trying to twist the truth to make Firaxis look more competent than they actually are.
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
@@TheSjuris millenia? Are you seriously comparing people downloading games to like, Barbary pirates raiding settlements and selling slaves lmao? And are you seriously telling people who BUY games to "get rid of piracy", like how, if they're ALREADY buying? If anything, Denuvo always hurts suckers who PAY for a virus on their PC. It's SecuROM all over again. I used to install noCD patches for games I owned discs for just to remove the DRM.
@JefeBoss
@JefeBoss 7 часов назад
As usual, I'll start playing it when all the expansions have been released.
@marko93ns
@marko93ns 6 часов назад
Really lovely of the devs engaging with the community. I am looking forward to more!
@Skyblade12
@Skyblade12 6 часов назад
I am a bit disappointed in these questions. There were not any that I would consider "hard". You didn't even ask about what was, supposedly, the absolute "I will never stop complaining about this if it isn't changed" point of the two leaders facing each other instead of talking to the player.
@Nothing2150
@Nothing2150 6 часов назад
That's not a question. That's just a complaint, he would say I don't like this and they would say "okay, I'm sorry"
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 2 часа назад
@@Nothing2150 "We are taking on all feedback as we release information. We love what our design team have done with the leaders and think it adds immersion" And then they will probably change it for beta ha
@longdeadchannel8311
@longdeadchannel8311 6 часов назад
I really enjoy your content and thoughts in a lot of cases, and make sure I watch your videos on Civ - you're really the only Civ RU-vidr I watch - but nothing about these questions were 'hard'. They were the very definition of softballs, and I honestly wouldn't care too much if you didn't clickbait and say that these were hard questions. Not going to be one of those 'I unsubscribe >:(((' commenters or whatever, I generally like your content (you expressing honest opinions is refreshing) but I do hope that you represent yourself more truthfully in the future to your audience.
@theunwelcome
@theunwelcome 3 часа назад
yeah, when he says "hard questions" I want to hear pointed discussion about things people have been worried about, like the insane prices being thrown around, and the denuvo spyware
@CrazyMiner12
@CrazyMiner12 41 минуту назад
civ youtuber that doesnt drop civ videos lol
@Roxas1639
@Roxas1639 9 минут назад
Well put
@brynley
@brynley 4 часа назад
They gave a bunch of Civ creators a promo interview well before they've released most of the info about the game. Potato did well.
@RedOctober6374
@RedOctober6374 Час назад
This was pretty disappointing. You didn't ask about Denuvo, why multiplayer is limited, if they plan on reworking the leader models, if they plan on selling leader skins as the reason why they face each other, or why they're rehashing old mechanics and passing them off as new. This was just an ad with one worthwhile question about mod capability. Nice clickbait.
@randomizednamme
@randomizednamme 7 часов назад
Hard questions? These are all softballs
@zacharykusztos
@zacharykusztos 7 часов назад
yeah why didn't he ask we the leader models look so outdated
@europaisch2109
@europaisch2109 7 часов назад
@@zacharykusztos came here for this question, thanks for saving my time
@Kenraali
@Kenraali 6 часов назад
@@zacharykusztos And why they have been "unpersonalizing" leaders since V. I miss my Montezuma II's altar room with all the boos and cheers in the background. 7 leader scenes look super fucking LAME.
@mort-m5b
@mort-m5b 6 часов назад
No word on asset limit, even though it's the most atrocious thing everyone had to deal with when using mods :')
@majdees
@majdees 6 часов назад
@@zacharykusztos because they will cut his funding lol
@woodysmith2681
@woodysmith2681 7 часов назад
Commander Types: Think in terms of an Age/Era-based structure. Ancient commanders were Very Important People with either a military background or a military role in government that grabbed up troops to deal with problems or launch wars. They also served as their own Field Commanders, essentially, or All-in-One leaders. Middle Ages, you had permanent/standing military persons under the King/Queen or central government but who had to levy troops as needed when the central government required a task. Less a Field Commander now and more of a Rallying Point Recruiter. It would also fit with Exploration as Cortez recruited discontent rebels to take on the Aztecs, Pizzaro the same against Incas, long naval trips required persuading/coercing random island inhabitants to give over supplies, etc. Modern Era, you had both a standing military chain of command and a professional army. The commander type now became Logistics Leaders and Strategic Commander. Field command was delegated, homefront officials handled recruitment, but doing the Grand Chessboard with armies and generals was the primary goal. They turn mobile forces, artillery pieces, and infantry into a Combined Army.
@Marshal_Dunnik
@Marshal_Dunnik 7 часов назад
So you just know that every new strategic resource that appears once the Age changes will spawn right underneath your well-developed city and wonder tiles.
@James_Haskell
@James_Haskell 7 часов назад
Since certain civs might need certain start positions e.g. Egypt and navigable rivers - maybe they should just add spawns next to a navigable river into the civs description
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 2 часа назад
You might pick a leader for that civ with a contrary start bias so it cannot be blanket I would imagine. It does sound like the bias is pretty strong for something that important though, from their comments on Hatshepsut
@logixindie
@logixindie 32 минуты назад
I'm lowkey happy to hear they are into slay the spire and balatro, these are examples of the best rougelikes and great sources of inspiration for civ.
@deinonychus6860
@deinonychus6860 6 часов назад
I can’t believe we got a Beyond Earth shoutout! I love that game, but it is effectively unplayable because it was abandoned in 32 bit.
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
What do you mean? I can still play ancient games like Fallout 1/2 or Baldur's Gate 1/2 on Windows 11, you don't need a 64 bit .exe to make game playable on newer systems.
@deinonychus6860
@deinonychus6860 3 часа назад
@@KasumiRINA The game loses its video and sound effects, especially after a few turns, because it can’t handle as much as it wants to. It asks for 64, but only can output 32, in simple terms.
@richchappell
@richchappell 5 часов назад
Regarding movement... I didn't have much of a problem with the unit having movement points left but needing more in order to actually move to surrounding terrain. What I did have a problem with is air units like observation balloons and drones moving like land units, where it cost extra movement points to go from plains to hills or to cross a river or go from land to sea.
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
Oh, also helicopters and drones being unable to fly over water and embarking is ridiculous!
@MadMage86
@MadMage86 6 часов назад
I feel like the modding question was too glossed over and 'soft'. You should have lead into it by asking about plans for additional content and pricing, THEN asking about if they felt modding would 'muscle in' on potential profits from possible microtransaction-based content.
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 2 часа назад
That's not a hard question lol "We do have a post-release plan for additional content but we cannot talk about that yet". "We have always believed in modding and love what the community creates. The community makes amazing content and that sometimes inspires us for additional content but we are of the firm belief that the more content the better and we will always support modding". What else are they going to say really?
@marklentz1095
@marklentz1095 41 минуту назад
Excellent that you got this interview, Potato. Super excited for Civ 7. Obviously you can't ask every question but I would like to hear from the devs on why they've moved away from a one on one perspective on the leader interaction screens.
@folicious6654
@folicious6654 2 часа назад
Idk if “love letter” is a good term to use since that’s what Dice said about Battlefield 2042 and look how that turned out
@JamethielKnorth
@JamethielKnorth 3 часа назад
I love the distinction - Navigable River implies that there are also unnavigable rivers. And expanding the roll of ships. Yay!
@db6842
@db6842 3 часа назад
I know Potato isn’t a huge gameplay Mod guy for Civ so I REALLY appreciate you hitting them with a question about mods right off the bat. Thanks
@Kazihirom
@Kazihirom 7 часов назад
Adjusting the yield to make all the tiles the same sounds dumb. That said I’m gonna play the game.
@Z0eff
@Z0eff Час назад
Timestamps! Note that the answers in brackets are high level overviews, click the timestamp for the full detailed answer. 0:02 What is your favorite civ pun? (Carl mentioned the phrase "The rest is history" being used earlier today.) 0:22 Modding capability of Civ 7? (It's a foundational part. Modding system is similar to Civ 6.) 1:39 Modding on platforms other than PC? (PC is easier, no news about other platforms.) 2:14 Are there features or systems you're excited to see modders make use of? (Ages system and modders adding new Civs.) 3:54 Does the gameplay also expand in Era 2 and Era 3? Are there new layers of gameplay that weren't there previously? (Unique gameplay systems in each age. Distant lands, naval gameplay, and religion in Exploration age. Legacy paths tailored for each age.) 5:55 Potato asks a question about worries players will have with a sequel. (Ed Beach takes the answer in a different direction: How they're trying not to be too predictable in their marketing and DLCs.) 9:11 Unnecessary micro looks to be reduced in places. Which of these changes do you feel haven't gotten the attention from the community that they deserved? (Depth not complexity is one of the design pillars. Terrain yields redone. Each biome has it's own flavor yield. Player positions determined before (some?) of the map generation happens.) 15:49 Was there a feature or change that you had to walk back? (Diplomacy took 4 tries before they were satisfied. The various civs had boosts for everything, they had to make them more specialized.) 19:53 What is the strangest or most unlikely place that inspiration came from for a feature/civ/ability/anything? (Nothing is unlikely, inspiration taken from books/films/videogames/history/etc. High res images of inscriptions on rock faces being strangest.) 21:14 How involved is Sid Meier in the game's production? (Answer is about Sid designing how movement points work. They didn't want a Civ 6 situation of having movement left but being unable to move.) 25:40 What's your go-to game when you're not thinking of Civ 7 and why is it Balatro? (Carl answers with Assassins Creed, Ed answers with Slay the Spire) 27:28 What is the most interesting answer you had in previous interviews you can add to my video as well? (Cheeky haha! Answer is about each age having a different commander "Type".) 28:36 What if we had a space force? No it's only to the modern era. There's no space. Maybe there is space? IS THERE SPACE? (Ed mentions he was a contractor for NASA) 29:01 Anything you want to say to the community before the video ends? (Engaging with the community, journey to launch together is exciting.)
@Z0eff
@Z0eff Час назад
The part about tile yields around your start location being less random and the map generation being done after positioning the player is very interesting! This gives me hope multiplayer might not need a Lekmap or BBS equivalent.
@dylanrawlings5105
@dylanrawlings5105 32 минуты назад
Man, it seemed like Potato was stumbling all over the place and didn't come well-prepared. Still great to have him as an interviewer, but I wish he was more on his A-game. I'm sure there'll be another opportunity for Potato to knock it out of the park
@Cryten0
@Cryten0 4 часа назад
Has the light touch of sponsored content. Naturally enough of course.
@PotatoMcWhiskey
@PotatoMcWhiskey 4 часа назад
I was not paid for this interview
@Cryten0
@Cryten0 4 часа назад
Shame they didnt give you money for the promotional effort. At least you got the prestige of insider access.
@blzdCoockie
@blzdCoockie 8 часов назад
Love letter to fans? Denuvo getting added to any game is a fuck you to all people who buys it.
@LNER985
@LNER985 7 часов назад
No, it isn't.
@Lunaboops
@Lunaboops 7 часов назад
@@LNER985 Kernel-Level anticheat is a massive middlefinger to any legitimate purchases of the game as it means those who pirate it will have a much better, and more playable experience Denuvo does not stop cheating, it does not stop Piracy, all it does is make the game laggier for those who actually bought it. All Kernel level anti-cheats are terrible, but Denuvo takes the cake in that regard.
@benoitlabrecque4513
@benoitlabrecque4513 7 часов назад
Do you actually think the Devs are the one who made that corporate choice?
@ArseniyShved
@ArseniyShved 5 часов назад
that is on the publisher, not the devs
@blzdCoockie
@blzdCoockie 5 часов назад
@@ArseniyShved Doesnt make it any less of a fuck you though does it? The fans still suffer
@josuecallejero9864
@josuecallejero9864 8 часов назад
Maybe builders/workers could be locked to antiquity, and later ages use the building system. I just miss my little guys so much!
@NunyaBizness-gn1lp
@NunyaBizness-gn1lp 7 часов назад
@@josuecallejero9864 You’ve played the game?
@peterpantoffel727
@peterpantoffel727 7 часов назад
this would be nice
@rohangondor6250
@rohangondor6250 6 часов назад
Yeah, I feel like we’ll miss out on a lot of interactivity with the map without them
@AliasAerius
@AliasAerius 3 часа назад
Just because the game launches with only three ages, doesn't mean that they can't add in more ages later on. I can definitely see Firaxis adding in a Space Age in a DLC.
@rlmush
@rlmush Час назад
never thought I’d be this excited about BRIDGES
@benabaxter
@benabaxter 4 часа назад
This is the exclusive content that is good for devs and fans and content creators. Well-done by everyone involved.
@flyingtoastr
@flyingtoastr 5 часов назад
The meltdown in these comments is pretty wild. Really brings back fond memories of the people screaming about how shifting to hexes from squares was also game ending and that Civ V was going to be the worst in the series and how dare Firaxis make such changes to the very core of the game. Good times.
@FormerlyDuck2
@FormerlyDuck2 5 часов назад
It's so much more fun to be optimistic about the game
@mattanthony2277
@mattanthony2277 5 часов назад
It does seem a bit warm in here, I'm starting to enjoy the thought of civ 7, the changes sound good with more options rather than simply learning patterns. I liked the hex change, I never understood all the fuss.
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
@@mattanthony2277 hex change was easily the best thing they did, now far easier to surround a hex, that and removing stacks of doom. Units fighting to death for minutes was also bad in older games. BUT even then, people said that Civ 3 ruined everything lol. there always will be unhappy people, it's like you have crowd hating on Baldur's Gate 3, but if you looked up old posts, original BG was already accuses of casualizing D&D.
@noahlederer8587
@noahlederer8587 6 часов назад
Ed liking slay the spire is the most based thing i have ever heard. This is what i imagine lead game designers are like! i love him now
@BouBou536
@BouBou536 2 часа назад
I really would have enjoyed hearing them talk about the leader models, and reassure the community that they would be revisiting them, but I guess we can't have them all. I don't want them to go back to the drawing board, but oh boy would I enjoy some modifications to the models so they feel better
@paximo2
@paximo2 4 часа назад
The only question I would ask is "how far are you away from switching the leader UI back to first person?" and be relentless with follow-ups.
@IIIIIVEERATIIIII
@IIIIIVEERATIIIII 7 часов назад
I do think this will be a fun game and I'm sure lots of effort was spent on it and the team is listening to the community, but I can't express how disappointing it is that Denuvo is a part of it. Besides all the privacy concerns, Civ is already a big game to run and with Denuvo on top of that I don't think I can. I have to wait a whole year or however long it takes for them to remove Denuvo before I can even buy the game.
@Real-cq1wj
@Real-cq1wj 2 часа назад
I think i am starting to understand where firaxis is trying to go with this. I think that the framework they are going for will be a good structure for the future of civ, gathering storm, heros and secret societies ect from civ 6 changed the flow quite a lot. I look forward to seeing what kind of directions they can take this more "focused in" approach to civs. Honestly i feel like they are deliberately holding back all the juicy stuff. Modern day geo politics and trade is very complicated. Maybe the modern age holds entire gameplay sytems like trade sanctions, deeper espionage, more fine tuning to government ect. Honestly i would love to drop spies and special forces into enemy territory only to be on the world stage denying the entire thing 😂😂😂😂 Also: i get that having some of the systems micromanagement condensed and simplified may feel like taking alot of controls out of the game, but sometimes when im playing civs i find myself creating little stories in my head about how the cultural alliance i have stopping loyalty pressure on my citys is the population accepting each others differences and becoming friends during the mediaeval era for example. I would like to think that firaxas is trying to explore this kind of thing while keeping the game as interactive as possible. I feel like some of the sacrifices might actually be justified. Playing as teddy Roosevelt and playing for 3hrs waiting for fighter jets and film studios feels like a drag when Alexander is slapping me around, and having a Babylon player or sometimes even a Australia or korea player flying bombers over my corner of the world where its all horse and swords juggling for control of the city states in my area just seems a bit disjointed. I think there is a way to make the world more immersive without taking the fun out of it while also celebration the people of my empire not just the units buildings and territories. I have faith that firaxis will pull this off. May a 1000 year flood and category 5 cyclone strike down this comment if i am wrong. 5+ era score for having faith in civilization 7 pre launch 🎉
@chessguy99
@chessguy99 7 часов назад
This is same format as Ursa Ryan's video posted earlier today. Wonder how many others of these will pop-up on the RU-vid feed.
@Veterans_for_Harris
@Veterans_for_Harris 45 минут назад
The first Civilization was awesome. I'm ready for Civilization VII. I'm old.
@bwpitlik1290
@bwpitlik1290 3 часа назад
I wonder what movie Pedro Pascal has coming up that requires him to method act as an Australian Civilization RU-vidr.
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 2 часа назад
He's Irish....
@mattanthony2277
@mattanthony2277 5 часов назад
More choices, more ways to react to "not quite winning so far" will always be good. As long as there aren't a few paths that will always win it should make the game more fun. The best mods are the ones that make the interaction easier, hopefuly some of the civ 6 mods have been incorporated.
@Ixarus6713
@Ixarus6713 5 часов назад
I think a neat feature for me would be to remove micromanagement to a degree. Well, not remove, more automate. E.g: Add a setting or use advisors to automatically manage cities and their production. Maybe enhance the range of advisors while nerfing their effects slightly, or add a new type of character devoted to managing micro city-scale decisions. So people who want to micromanage can, and those who don't, don't have to. These people would then progress and upgrade cities automatically, using a percentage of your per-turn income, and you could tell them what game route you are taking so they can optimise each city individually e.g: religion, military, financial, science, tourism etc etc.. This would allow beginners to get a grasp of the major mechanics and be able to somewhat compete against older players, whilst allowing growth and skill gaps to remain. They could focus on learning to macro manage before diving on after they have a grip of the basics. The skill gap potential is obvious, as these would not be optimised cities, only mathematically optimised cities that may not evenly spread efficiency. E.g: One city may soak up money while another is left deprived until you're making enough gold to purchase the very expensive limiting building, while an expert player will know to focus something cheaper for early play and will have a more dynamic city layout. Really looking forward to Civ 7 as it's looking to be my first real Civ game. Good luck to the devs, and I have to say I'm impressed with their communication. Most devs nowadays are miles worse than them, and it shows through the passion in the community. Thanks Potato!
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
They already let you focus city on production, food, or science etc. AND have advisors suggest you what to build for this or that, might as well code an option to automate that, not even for new players but for late game where you found cities for a new resource or conquer a huge enemy and now have to manually build 6 granaries and 8 lighthouses.
@tjpatton8562
@tjpatton8562 3 часа назад
Please tell the devs to add a click counter stat 😂
@feanor5037
@feanor5037 4 часа назад
A hard question would have been about this controversial DRM they're apparently going to use ;)
@PotatoMcWhiskey
@PotatoMcWhiskey 4 часа назад
Why would I ask them about Denuvo when I don't know what it is? I'm asking them about gameplay
@feanor5037
@feanor5037 4 часа назад
@@PotatoMcWhiskey Lots of people think it'll ruin the gameplay experience 🤷🏻‍♂️ I don't know so just hope it doesn't! Good questions though, I liked that you got them to flesh out more about their thought processes and what they're hoping to achieve
@grishy8203
@grishy8203 47 минут назад
@@PotatoMcWhiskeyWhen you don’t know what something is, it’s very reasonable to ask questions about it to learn more!
@zjsz4954
@zjsz4954 4 часа назад
Oh yeah rivers will be an obstacle now, you’ll have to walk around or build a bridge overtop
@luizm.1549
@luizm.1549 6 часов назад
Man, CIV in space expansion would be great!!!
@MrDraehl
@MrDraehl 6 часов назад
Glad to see Ed plays Slay The Spire. One of the best releases since Civ6 came out. Curious if they take any Roguelike/Roguelite influences beyond maybe the new goodie hut choice system.
@ExamplePrime
@ExamplePrime 6 часов назад
Him saying that makes sense for all the progression systems that are now in Civ VII
@tcr7
@tcr7 Час назад
Here my poor ass is watching this video as if I'd be able to both buy a new PC and a copy of this game within 2 years of it being released. lol
@YAH2121
@YAH2121 7 часов назад
get rid of denuvo and my hype for this game goes up by 5x. The "divisive" changes dont bother me much since the previous games still exist
@LNER985
@LNER985 7 часов назад
How can you be a gamer and support stealing games?
@honkinhonk3454
@honkinhonk3454 7 часов назад
@@LNER985 professional bot comment
@coolmamo
@coolmamo 8 часов назад
Waiting on that Ara video 🤤
@bryanmoraski7005
@bryanmoraski7005 3 часа назад
As an old man I am more concerned about single player. But love playing multi with my son. Thanks for the input. PS Not concerned but excited !!!!!!
@Arjay404
@Arjay404 6 часов назад
I really want to know how the map expansion works on Pangea map. Obviously on Pangea there is no New World, so what happens there? What I think would be cool and would keep the to theme of map expansion is that on Pangea map when you hit Exploration Age that the map would break apart and no longer be one massive landmass. It could break apart and some parts of it still be connected, some parts of it will be disconnected and even some new landmasses rises up from the ocean or breaks off from the Pangea map and floats off and creates bigger land masses. If non of this happens then it seems like there won't be any change to Pangea map (which I think is one of the more popular map types.).
@dutyfreeadventures5924
@dutyfreeadventures5924 Час назад
I am hoping there is a secret "Spage Age" they'll surprise us with the month before
@marekkos3513
@marekkos3513 7 часов назад
Is it that hard , to make an option to add what ever civilization I can play in the first era to the end ?
@TheSjuris
@TheSjuris 7 часов назад
Yes and heard that you will be required to use those technologies for the entire game without ever getting an upgrade. So go attack my tank with your slinger.
@marcusviniciusmenezesdossa5734
@marcusviniciusmenezesdossa5734 7 часов назад
I was thinking about the possibility of modders adding new ages and things like that, I think would be cool
@ryandelaune139
@ryandelaune139 8 часов назад
Your mom got me alone and asked me questions last night
@ryandelaune139
@ryandelaune139 8 часов назад
Rip title change
@douglasvan4848
@douglasvan4848 3 часа назад
Great interview! Any chance we will get the chance to play any Roman republicans this time around? Tiberius Gracchus or Lucius Junius Brutus?
@iptf
@iptf 7 часов назад
Ed's poor sinuses.
@iamspamus8784
@iamspamus8784 Час назад
I miss the awesome scenarios from Civ IV and V.
@Bez00
@Bez00 3 часа назад
I'm torn. While it's positive that they support mods in the game rather than fighting against it, developers shouldn't be relying on modders to essentially do a lot of the work for them for free.
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 2 часа назад
What was the indication they were relying on mods to do the work for them? They spoke about Reddit posts of 100s of civs for just European locations. Would you ever expect them to develop that content themselves to that level? I didn't get the sense they were leaving features out with the expectation someone would mod it in.
@dach829
@dach829 3 часа назад
we should celebrate creators more than their creation.
@karinlindblom2934
@karinlindblom2934 6 часов назад
Thanks. This was interesting to listen to and I'm definitly more interested in the game now than I was earlier :)
@Isengardtom
@Isengardtom 7 часов назад
I’m definitely excited about this game. Map looks amazing
@aaronhedgesmusic
@aaronhedgesmusic 3 часа назад
This is the second interview I’ve watched but I get the feeling that there’s some sort of rules about what you can ask. For example, they interviewers never ask if a competing game influence civ7. Which is a bit of a disappointment not to hear about. The idea of changing civs is very humankind. The ages part as is quite similar to another 4x game which came out earlier this year. I’d love to know more about this but it feels like this is a no go area for firaxis
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 Час назад
For sure the questions are pre-approved in this format. They did say they were inspired by other games though. Considering Civ is the original in the format, the iteration is a circle. I'm not really sure why it matters where the inspiration lies, more what they do with it right? Not for nothing, it is clear Ed Beach has been into the idea of rising and falling civs through the ages for a long time now, considering they released rise and fall DLC in 2018. And their division of 3 ages seems to have more gameplay mechanics tied to it than other games.
@carlosnavarrete1094
@carlosnavarrete1094 6 часов назад
"Now any leader can go with any civilization" - As someone that resonated with the comment early in the video where it said "The rest is history", that decision is definitely not something I would call an improvement
@DirectorHatman
@DirectorHatman 4 часа назад
Wait if Carl has a child on the way, does that make them... Carl's Jr.?
@DasIstDerMars
@DasIstDerMars 2 часа назад
"A loveletter to the people who love civ" Dude, I play the game since 1991 and the terrible changes concerning the areas and their wish to destroy the game in favour of generation tiktok is the opposite of a loveletter. You might need to change "hard question" to "fanboyism".
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 2 часа назад
What the actual does TikTok have to do with anything 😂 I think you only have to listen to the devs for 2 minutes to know they are incredibly passionate about their game and their choices. If it's not for you then oh well I guess
@DasIstDerMars
@DasIstDerMars 34 минуты назад
@@rexanael243 You are aware that they are trying to sell the game and everything they say is part of the advertisment, right? That is not an accusation, it's just how it works. It is PR, mate. Them breaking down the game into three short games with the explicit invitation to not play the whole game but just one of the small and short three games (not being able to keep a civ throughout the whole game is basically forcing the short games on the players) is rooted in the believe that younger audiences are not capable of keeping up their attention span long enough. The whole three short games in a row instead of a long one schtick is based on that believe. They killed immersion for that.
@andrew6815
@andrew6815 6 часов назад
Great interview. Well done
@todangtall
@todangtall 7 часов назад
Potato must be sweaty af, the way his hair is sticking up. Edit: As a filthy casual (almost as filthy as your mom) who recently started dipping his toes in deity. I would appreciate the need to not constantly reroll so I don't immediately get bum rushed by a war happy civ or a horde of barbarians.
@colep715
@colep715 4 часа назад
Jeez, he obviously didn't watch the last AC trailer. It was a train wreck.
@seanbirt1745
@seanbirt1745 7 часов назад
so these really was not the questions ive seen the community worried about. My biggest issue is so much is changing is this going to feel like civ. They sounded like in the beginning they were saying they changed things to change things so im worried that is just a new game IP almost and not really Civ 7
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 4 часа назад
That's literally what they did in Civ 3, Civ 5, and Civ 6, and everybody always complained. I am more worried about limited civs and waiting for expansions to fix stuff: Civ 6 was pretty much feature complete from the start, but 5 without expansions was painful.
@seanbirt1745
@seanbirt1745 4 часа назад
I didn't play anything before 5 so can't speak to that but I didn't feel 5 to 6 felt like a different game just steps forwards or changes in direction. I'm worried they have changed alot just for the sake of changing it and it seems like in this interview they said they went out of thier way to change things so hopefully they knock it out and its amazing. I'm just worried it will be mid and not feel like civ. And totally agree civ 5 was rough in launch compared to where it got after expansions. 6 did that alot better. ​@@KasumiRINA
@rexanael243
@rexanael243 2 часа назад
They addressed this exact point so I'm not sure what question you still want answered. They felt they were predictable and wanted to make some BIG swings. They have tried to stay true to what they believe is 'core' Civ, but I think at this point it is reasonable to assume this will feel like a very different game. Now it will be up to you whether that interests you or not and, as they release more info, you will have a better idea. But it will be a big change from Civ 5 and 6.
@szurketaltos2693
@szurketaltos2693 Час назад
If you don't end up liking it, you can stick to the civ that you're used to. No shame in that.
@seanbirt1745
@seanbirt1745 Час назад
@rexanael243 that's what worried me though from what they said they changed alot because they felt it became predictable but that doesn't mean it's for the best. It could be great and I hope it is but you don't change what isn't broke.
@adventurer6352
@adventurer6352 7 часов назад
I have started to play civ 6. This my first civ game and also first in the genre. I have never won a single match and i play in settler mode, continent and duel. Its is very addictive and fun to play even if i dont win. It is fun do better each time i play, i just need one win to understand how the game works.
@TylerAndToast
@TylerAndToast 7 часов назад
I have hundreds of hours, watched a ton of content, and still learn something new every time I play.
@StaalBurgher0
@StaalBurgher0 7 часов назад
Not the best player myself but surely on Settler you win by default?
@TylerAndToast
@TylerAndToast 7 часов назад
@@StaalBurgher0 if you don't understand the wincons i could see it being tough. Or if you get beat down early. But I'm sure someone new to 4x may have a tough time
@leech204
@leech204 6 часов назад
PLEASE, Civ Beyond Earth 2. I LOVE SPACE
@stnylan
@stnylan 7 часов назад
Predictability is not necessarily a flaw. And the more they speak the less Civilization (as I have played since the first) it sounds.
@loran1212
@loran1212 7 часов назад
True, but the older Civ games still exist. Why make the same game again?
@stnylan
@stnylan 6 часов назад
​@@loran1212 Because you can still improve and iterate, whilst retaining the core gameplay experience of having a single civ stand the test of time. Civ 7 explicitly is about leaders first, and Civs not standing the test of time. But you know, if you want the experience Civ 7 seems to be offering, you can go and play Humankind. I tootled around in that a bit. Decided it wasn't for me, but perhaps it will be for you.
@rohangondor6250
@rohangondor6250 6 часов назад
Facts
@masterofzero1
@masterofzero1 4 часа назад
I want more potato civ multi-player streams/videos.
Далее
연준 (YEONJUN) ‘GGUM’ Official MV
02:44
Просмотров 3,2 млн
Magnus Carlsen Sacrificed THE ROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOK
29:45
What Is Reality?
2:32:23
Просмотров 2 млн
Linux from Scratch
2:35:42
Просмотров 174 тыс.
The 100 Games That Taught Me Game Design
2:13:14
Просмотров 1,3 млн
Questions to ask at the End of an Interview
7:19
Просмотров 2,2 млн