Тёмный

I Challenge GR-Research To Blind Test His Own Audiophile Speaker Cables On Camera. 

Подписаться
Просмотров 85 тыс.
% 2 378

I ask a HiFi manufacturer GR-Research to blind test his own speaker cables that they sell. Danny Richie, the founder gladly accepts. Do Audiophile Cables matter? Is it going to work for everyone?
GR Research Cables: gr-research.com/cables/
Related Videos:
Insider Look at The GR-Research Factory - DIY Audiophile Speaker Haven: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-d6m2jJRcq3A.html
Full 2+ hr video of Danny Doing the blind test: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-bh_m3CRwwM0.html
Support on Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayiyagi
follow on Instagram: jays_iyagi
follow on Facebook: jayiyagiofficial
Follow soundstage take 2 reviews: ru-vid.com/group/PLPOzvlhtSqn5xdc__ftuSt4Rxy_wm5Af0
Speaker stands: amzn.to/3ssRhI3
Better speaker stands: solidsteel.it/my-product/ss-7-vintage-hi-fi-speaker-stands/
acoustic panels I use: ua-acoustics.com/
acoustic curtain: amzn.to/31d1zAM
BDI Cabinet I use: bit.ly/2OJRwQQ
amzn.to/3chBuFZ
other BDI Cabinets: bit.ly/3ctxXV1
amzn.to/30bsUCH
my fav hifi tweaks: (Isoacoustics devices) amzn.to/3j5FGvM
0:00 Backstory
1:47 Was Danny Able To Tell A Difference?
12:59 Why is the GR-Research HiFi Cable Better?
16:21 Is There Measurements For Better HiFi Cables?
18:00 How do you design Better HiFi Cables?
19:35 Should You Get GR-Research Cables?
#hifi #audiophile #homeaudio

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

23 мар 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 551   
@Jayiyagi
@Jayiyagi Год назад
*Hey guys. Thank you for stopping by. If the video was helpful or entertaining to you, please consider clicking the like button on the video* *NOTE 1 (RE: BLIND AB Protocals): as with any cable video or blind tests, people like to comment with how they "think" the test should have been conducted. Please keep note that this test was done with limited resources, time and flaws and therefore is not a perfect blind test. I still think it was better than nothing and entertaining/fun, you may think otherwise and that is fine. Some are asking for my credentials, which is fair. I won't put my entire resume here but I currently work as a researcher (scientist) managing 3 different teams in the field of neuroscience and cognition but that isn't to persuade you into thinking that the blind test I did with Danny is perfect because it is not. I did what I can with time, resources and my own funding available to do it. It's just a matter of people pointing out the obvious flaws (which sure, that is fine) but if some are going to go far as to "tell me how do it right and how I should have done it" - well then, I naturally challenge them to do it themselves and show that it can be done with limited resources and time. Show me how it's done! If I can learn from it, I will. Far as I know, I don't see much blind AB attempts or discussions on youtube* *NOTE 2 (RE: CABLES USED): Some are commenting that I should have used a similar gauge cable while some are commenting that I should have tested Danny with the Aliexpress cable. I will explain why I did neither of those things. Firstly, there was limited time and resource and so while these tests would have been interesting, I went for the broader topic of "does a generic cable sound different from an audiophile cable and can the manufactures of those cables tell the difference from a "stock cable" or 16awg zip cord which is the most common. If I was testing the same gauge cable as the GR-Research cable, then I'd have to find an 8AWG cable which is not as common and this would also mean that we are totally ignoring and skipping the fact that many cable measurement gurus say that the 16awg zip cord is just as good with no difference in the application of home audio where cable lengths are not terribly long. Some said there was an obvious difference between them because of the differences in the gauges (thickness) of the cables, which may or may not be true but measurement wise, it is not true that there is an obvious difference and so with anything there is a step 1, 2 and 3. I can't skip to step 2 and assume gauges make a difference when measurements do not support that. Hence I went with the very basic step first, which is to test STOCK vs NON-Stock cables. As for the aliexpress cable, again, the comments vary from asking why I didn't take the aliexpress cable to why I didn't modify the aliexpress cable in a similar way to GR-Research's cable and then test it with Danny. To put it simply, again it was skipping to step 3 before even addressing the simpler questions and steps. The title of the video wasn't "can the aliexpress cable be modified to be as a good as the GR-Research cable" - although an interesting topic that I might pursue later, it isn't the topic in this video. Aliexpress cable was simply not brought with me because I quite frankly thought it sounded terrible even compared to other normal generic cables I have at home that I have tested. Quite frankly, I can attest that the generic 16 awg we used in this video was much better than the aliexpress cable. Hopefully this clears up some confusion or questions some of you guys have.* GR Research Cables: gr-research.com/cables/ Related Videos: Insider Look at The GR-Research Factory - DIY Audiophile Speaker Haven: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-d6m2jJRcq3A.html Full 2+ hr video of Danny Doing the blind test: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-bh_m3CRwwM0.html Support on Patreon: www.patreon.com/jayiyagi follow on Instagram: instagram.com/jays_iyagi/ follow on Facebook: facebook.com/jayiyagiofficial Follow soundstage take 2 reviews: ru-vid.com/group/PLPOzvlhtSqn5xdc__ftuSt4Rxy_wm5Af0 Speaker stands: amzn.to/3ssRhI3 Better speaker stands: solidsteel.it/my-product/ss-7-vintage-hi-fi-speaker-stands/ acoustic panels I use: ua-acoustics.com/ acoustic curtain: amzn.to/31d1zAM BDI Cabinet I use: bit.ly/2OJRwQQ amzn.to/3chBuFZ other BDI Cabinets: bit.ly/3ctxXV1 amzn.to/30bsUCH my fav hifi tweaks: (Isoacoustics devices) amzn.to/3j5FGvM 0:00 Backstory 1:47 Was Danny Able To Tell A Difference? 12:59 Why is the GR-Research HiFi Cable Better? 16:21 Is There Measurements For Better HiFi Cables? 18:00 How do you design Better HiFi Cables? 19:35 Should You Get GR-Research Cables? #hifi #audiophile #homeaudio
@stasis2007
@stasis2007 Год назад
What a load. Why didn't you bring your Aliexpress cables? Comparing to Walmart cables was not what we wanted to see. I guess Danny wouldn't let you do that A/B test as it would reveal what his cables really are. FAIL.
@Jayiyagi
@Jayiyagi Год назад
@@stasis2007 Can't please everyone. As I said in the video, me and my cameraman compared the aliexpress cable and found the differences huge so I wasn't interested in Danny doing the easy comparison. I think the "Walmart cable" was a harder one
@stasis2007
@stasis2007 Год назад
@@Jayiyagi Did you stuff the Aliexpress cable with cotton rope and terminate them the same? Did you do equal burn-in so the comparison is equal? I can take a high end cable and put crap banana or spades on them and it will impact the sound from the original. I do not think this was an unbiased test at all. I'd even wager the bare cable on both is the same, just the rope and termination is different.
@Jayiyagi
@Jayiyagi Год назад
@@stasis2007 Can a modified Aliexpress cable sound as good as the GR-Research cable? - A cool video idea but not the subject of this video nor the point of this test
@stasis2007
@stasis2007 Год назад
@@Jayiyagi I appreciate your response Jay. The problem a lot of people have with Danny is that he always comes off as kind of scammy and a bit disingenuous. He buys his cable from China, yet insists that nobody can possibly buy what he has. There are only so many sources for this Kimber knock-off cable. If you ask for any details on the cable, he refuses to respond, says it's a trade secret or simply blocks you. I tend to never trust anyone that silences people for questioning. Again, good job on the video and sorry you had to explain yourself to others. Did you every get his banana plugs tested for copper content like you said you were going to do?
@scottbayne5710
@scottbayne5710 Год назад
This says ALOT about Danny. Name ONE other industry person who would allow this to happen and be videoed real-time! Bravo Danny!
@r423sdex
@r423sdex Год назад
Was it real time ! Now let’s do it fair.
@richh650
@richh650 Год назад
100% agree. Danny seems to be one of the very few, who even though is a manufacturer, backs up his thoughts with reasoning.
@wicomms
@wicomms 9 месяцев назад
Scott see what I wrote to Jay. What do you think? I am the latest to ask...Sept 2023
@nellyt2807
@nellyt2807 6 месяцев назад
Comedy gold
@matth9359
@matth9359 4 месяца назад
What does it say about the industry? That people are susceptible to marketing. Period.
@bearclaw5115
@bearclaw5115 Год назад
Good on Danny to put himself on the line and he came out on top! Thanks to Jay for putting in some serious effort to answer the question "Do cables make a difference?".
@franciscoortiz6980
@franciscoortiz6980 Год назад
Thanks for honesty. Dannys cable is kinda reasonable. But in the end one has to decide. 1000/pr + $30 speaker cable vs $800/pr + $230 speaker cable. To this day... better speaker with cheaper cable always wins.
@JurMalafi
@JurMalafi Год назад
Your example makes your chances of being correct better, but mostly would be incorrect as the price of the speakers is increased from your example. Price does not necessarily determine the quality of the cable and the speakers. One day when you have good speakers( maybe you do have good speakers) you will become familiar of all the qualities of playback that can be affected by cables. Some speakers destroy the differences when the designer has not paid attention to the details (no matter the price). Having started my speaker journey with speakers from Thiel, Magnepan and Dynaudio, all speakers paying a great deal of attention to phase and a linear amplitude response. When I finally found a great speaker cable the less expensive speaker and the more expensive speaker both improved in a significant way. The Cable Company will send you cables for a percentage of the cost of the cables you want to try to expand your cable experience. I tried 4 cables much more expensive than my twisted double 16 guage radio shack wire that failed to make a difference, the 5th cable which were wound in such a way that my Thiels would not sit flat on the floor (so I hated them) made all the difference in my system (Sonagraphe SD-22, Motif MC-7, CJ MV-75A, Sota/Premiere/Grado, Thiel CS1.2 & Dynaudio Twynn kit) So since 1995 I discovered not all cables make a difference, but some do..TARA Labs Quantum III was the difference making cable. It removed a glare and a hash the other cables left on the sound of my system and that helped my system define the spaces around and in between instruments on the $1250 speakers and the $2500 speakers. My RS $30 cables and the 4 other cables degraded the sound comparatively and the "noise" that remained over the music degraded the $2500 speakers below the $1250 speakers.
@johnbravo7542
@johnbravo7542 7 месяцев назад
@@JurMalafi you dreaming!
@miquifaye
@miquifaye 4 месяца назад
Total B.S . Cool story though 👍🏻
@Reyfox1
@Reyfox1 Год назад
So glad you made the trip and are reporting what you experienced, heard and saw. This should be the norm in the industry, where people can get together and challenge manufacturers on their equipment. Well done Jay and Danny!
@sloboat55
@sloboat55 Год назад
I hope you two do more of this. It was excellent.
@Venus_Isle
@Venus_Isle Год назад
You two lads should hook up together more often. It would be for the greater good in this audiophile world...
@kraig7777
@kraig7777 10 месяцев назад
This was one of the most educational videos I've seen a while. And just when he has me sold on the cables and tube connectors he brings me back down to earth with speakers and room treatment. I like my speakers now but my room is horrible.
@howardskeivys4184
@howardskeivys4184 2 месяца назад
I recently took my 17 year old amp to my local dealer to have them return it to the manufacturer to be refurbished. When I purchased that amp 17 years ago, it was the manufacturer’s flagship model. It is still in production, but now is a MK3 and sports a remote control. Mine is a MK1 and doesn’t sport a remote. When my refurbished MK1 came back into the store, the staff talked me into auditioning the 2 new amps now above mine in that manufacturer’s range, but, I insisted it be done, blind. No, I didn’t were a blindfold or mask. All 3 amps were in a rack well behind the listening chair. The set up was totally different to my set up at home. Different cables, different speakers, different cd transport, different dac and vastly different room. As soon as the 1st track was played through the 1st amp, i knew immediately, beyond question that, that amp was my trusty 17 year old MK1. When the staff member switched to the 2nd amp, I momentarily questioned my 1st decision. The 2nd amp sounded remarkably similar to the 1st. 2 or 3 tracks later I could pick out that the 2nd amp had fractionally tighter bass control. When the staff member switched to the 3rd amp, the sonic signature was very different, much more resolving! I had the amps 100% correct. Amp 1 was my MK1. Amp 2 was the next up in the range, costing twice as much. Amp 3 was the top of the range, 3 times the price. That experiment was repeated multiple times, using alternative speakers. I correctly identified all 3 amps 100% of the time. That MK1 amp was the beating heart of my system for 17 years. Thousands of hours of attentive listening. I knew it well. As should Danny know his speaker cable well. I would have thought that his 80% success rate was the very least that should be expected, especially as the comparison was against such a basic, unassuming cable. Prices weren’t mentioned here, but I’d bet Danny’s cable was way more than 80% higher than the Amazan basic?
@freone111
@freone111 Год назад
8 out of 10 with non-audiophile recordings is very impressive. Thank you for taking time to do this. All my music is in crappy recordings and I can relate to this experience.
@vdochev
@vdochev Год назад
What is an "audiophile" recording?
@aceofspades6667
@aceofspades6667 Год назад
@@vdochev Diana krall vs AC/DC … IYKYK
@freone111
@freone111 Год назад
@@vdochev 😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄
@freone111
@freone111 Год назад
@@vdochev I apologize you are clueless
@secretsimon1897
@secretsimon1897 Год назад
It's not impressive, it's stupid.
@CristhianSerrano
@CristhianSerrano Год назад
Jay and Dani giving the internet a lesson of how to go about controversies and disagreements, dialogue and conversation will Always be the answer kudos to you guys really fun video
@leoanthony7281
@leoanthony7281 Год назад
Excellent interview, Jay. and Danny. This is the kind of content I love informative and without bias. I believe Danny has proven himself quite a few times now to be a straight shooter.
@badgermike1231
@badgermike1231 Год назад
I think it's pretty awesome that you two were able to get together and discuss audio gear, and even do a blind cable test, without acrimony or even a hint of tension. Great series of videos.
@zizendorf
@zizendorf Год назад
Wow! First time I've ever heard anyone reference Vienna Teng! She's fantastic - her writing and performing. She's also a warm, kind, and compassionate human being - met her prior to a show for a Q&A session. She's got a lot of great stuff out there!
@BadMonkeyFinger_Audio
@BadMonkeyFinger_Audio Год назад
So, now that I'm done watching this vid in its entirety, I have to say - this was a very entertaining and much-needed open discussion on the topic. Job well done.
@eightrodway
@eightrodway Год назад
Good on you Jay, for keeping an open mind and trusting your ears.
@dextermorgan1
@dextermorgan1 Год назад
I really enjoy listening to two people talk shop, when they really know what they're talking about. This was a good video.
@adamjj85
@adamjj85 Год назад
Props to Danny for agreeing to do this and also getting 8/10, very impressive! Also, I totally agree with your statements on the frustration about not being able to measure the differences. It would be a lot easier to communicate the benefits of things like this if there was a scientific way to detect and show the differences.
@AT-wl9yq
@AT-wl9yq 10 месяцев назад
"It would be a lot easier to communicate the benefits of things like this if there was a scientific way to detect and show the differences. " There is a scientific way to show differences. Everyone seems to think some kind of measurements need to be done to achieve scientifically valid results. That's not true. To start with, you need to test for something objective. What sounds better or worse is irrelevant. That's personal preference. Can't go by price either. If a $500 cable goes on sale for $300, the cable doesn't sound any different. For example, "is there a difference between cable A and cable B?". That's it. You need to test for something like that. The solution is this. If you set up a blind listening test going by the principals listed in the scientific method, you will have scientifically valid results so long as you consider all relevant variables. For example, if you are testing 2 pairs of cables to find audible differences between them, as long as your test accounts for all variables so that when you AB the cables, any differences in sound has to be due to the cables, and nothing else. And if you get all of that right, your results will be every bit as valid as a measurement. You have to do a listening test because we don't know how to measure everything we hear. And yes, I know doing a test like this is a pain in the ass, but you really have no choice. In the future, we may figure out how to explain more with measurements, but until that happens, you need a well conducted listening test. Null testing also looks very promising.
@DrGonzo-it1fi
@DrGonzo-it1fi Год назад
Respect to GR Research for admitting to getting some wrong. And explaining that differences are subtle but evident in better recordings
@r423sdex
@r423sdex Год назад
He had to, otherwise you would not have been convinced. Maybe you need to buy some of his cables, but don't expect the effect to last that long.
@stephenyoud6125
@stephenyoud6125 Год назад
Nicely done and thanks for sharing. Looks like a very worthwhile and hugely enjoyable trip. I'm very jealous
@sgreenfield4
@sgreenfield4 Год назад
I bought the GR KEF Q100 upgrade and 16 wire speaker wire kit and tube connectors to the speaker. It's made such a difference it knocked down the brightness of the tweeter and now the music is spacious and images even better than before the upgrades now it just needs a subwoofer. Hopefully, I can get room treatment and buy a GR speaker kit soon. I love the direction your channel has been taking; thanks for more great content worth watching Jay!
@charlesclifton1006
@charlesclifton1006 Год назад
80% accuracy is pretty darn good - especially considering the material selected. I would need very high quality recordings wherein I was familiar with every nuance both engineered and presented by the raw talent of the musicians. The fact that Danny chose to challenge himself demonstrates the level of confidence he has in his products.
@howardskeivys4184
@howardskeivys4184 Год назад
To make that challenge more accurate, a placebo should have been introduced.
@poturbg8698
@poturbg8698 Год назад
@@howardskeivys4184 I don't understand your question. The "placebo" was actually the generic cable.
@roofpizza1250
@roofpizza1250 Год назад
Yeah, no. LOLZ.
@banginga3468
@banginga3468 Год назад
@@poturbg8698 No that's not the placebo. You could still hit 80% just by chance, its not a high chance but still there. To demonstrate, flip a coin 10 times, getting 10 heads in a row is a really small chance. Flip that coin 1000 times, and getting 10 heads in a row becomes a lot more statistically possible. So if there was a 3rd cable, or he was told there was a 3rd cable but not what it is and could then say to that same level, "that one is mine, that one is the other, but theres something different here, it doesn't sound like the other's etc." He said it himself there, to paraphrase "I could hear a difference but couldn't tell", if I'm paying several thousand for a cable (I have no idea how much it actually costs) I'd want to not have to guess if its the cheap or old, it would have to leave me with 0 chance of not being able to tell.
@drewpknutz1410
@drewpknutz1410 Год назад
@@banginga3468 Too bad this experiment didn't meet your exacting criteria. I think itd be best if you just stuck with the cheapest cables you can find so you can be secure in the fact that there is no difference.
@richh650
@richh650 Год назад
Great job Jay. I very, very much enjoyed this meeting with Danny. Placement, placement, placement, first! I have really loved watching you both on your respective channels and will continue to do so.
@alford35
@alford35 Год назад
Great job guys!!! Never gonna satisfy those that refuse to “LISTEN” for the differences though.
@greenbeginner3353
@greenbeginner3353 Год назад
Thanks to you both for using your time and resources for this.
@martinclift3843
@martinclift3843 Год назад
Kudos to you for doing it! Too many shy away from these kind of tests. Great video.
@archerlink3
@archerlink3 Год назад
Love Danny and Jay. I'm glad this video and Randy's recent video on cables came out. I've always noticed differences in cables, but it was always such a taboo subject :P
@jeffsloane8628
@jeffsloane8628 Год назад
Thank you both for putting this video together.
@m.9243
@m.9243 Год назад
Well done with the test! There should be more tests like this even with amplifiers and sources. One thing I have found in my setup, eliminating banana / spade termination and using just bare wire directly on the speaker terminals has a very positive effect on sound.
@JR-ho5qm
@JR-ho5qm Год назад
Fantastic! Looking forward to more videos from Texas. Thanks for making the trip Jay!
@felipeneri3364
@felipeneri3364 Год назад
Thanks Jay, by the way, how that open baffles sounds?
@trevorcrowe7571
@trevorcrowe7571 Год назад
This is a long overdue discussion that I will be sharing quite often. There are so many important nuanced aspects of this discussion that seem to go over peoples heads. These things are argued “to death” on forums and FB discussions. Every discussion seems to inevitably distill down to arguments about the ability to hear differences. I get so tired of people with desktop systems who cannot hear a difference TELLING others who CAN hear differences in their treated rooms, that they “shouldn’t hear a difference because it cannot be measured” or it’s “just your bias” or some “psychoacoustic placebo effect”. Thank you guys for doing this.
@Robinsteen99
@Robinsteen99 Год назад
Thanks Jay for spending time with Danny.
@pkats9093
@pkats9093 Год назад
Very cool. What what about the speakers?! Do you have another video coming with your overall impressions?
@trucchuong1726
@trucchuong1726 Год назад
Thank you so much Guys for all of your hard work, and I have learned a lot from this video! I totally agree with you that we can't do measurements on harmonics. It's similar to vinyl/analog vs. digital sources.
@randallcollura
@randallcollura Год назад
I have GR X-Statik speakers (which I love btw) but my room is far from ideal. I am very skeptical of claims about speaker wires but this kind of video is honest and appreciated. Danny is clearly a very talented designer.
@iBeaver1973
@iBeaver1973 Год назад
i just went through this same experience last week... I purchased 5m kimber cable 8PR.... to replace inakustik Excellence 2x4mm cables.... about 4 times the price difference. no other change (except the banana plugs, i needed to use a different brand that could take the quantity of the 8PRs to terminate....) summary, the kimber cables were pretty easy to hear the difference. it was like I had not really heard cymbals before, which I can not explain easily why that it the case. the cymbals were now more than just a tsss tsss, they were musical. And then, another difference, i could hear better the width of the keyboard of the piano between the speakers.... danny called that the spatial cues. anyhow, I am happy to have upgraded.
@jmitchell3
@jmitchell3 Год назад
I think cables likely do make a difference but so many of us are living in subpar listening environments that we really can’t tell the difference. I’ve been to Danny’s listening room and it is amazing. (I have the XStatiks also but at Danny’s with the open baffle subs they are amazing!)
@ChonkTek
@ChonkTek 11 месяцев назад
​@@jmitchell3no, you'll be able to hear the difference. First, listen to both directions/orientations. There's one way that's far superior ;) This is heard no matter the listening environment. One orientation annoys everyone, the other more smooth and natural with a holographic presentation.
@listeningto8371
@listeningto8371 4 месяца назад
@@ChonkTek Direction? What are you on about?
@tallpaull9367
@tallpaull9367 Год назад
Good job Jay, good to see you make the trip to visit Danny. Entertaining for us, hope there’s more content from the trip.
@christian2123
@christian2123 Год назад
Very fun to watch! Thanks for making the trip Jay and Danny is a great sport to do this test. Watching him beat himself up on getting the last one wrong is too much! Not an easy thing to do. Like you said, it's one thing to hear a difference but a next level thing to connect that difference back to the particular cable used. Love this series!
@TheEvolvingAudioNut
@TheEvolvingAudioNut Год назад
Great collaboration. I appreciate the candor.
@gotchagoing4905
@gotchagoing4905 Год назад
This was very informative on a somewhat controversial subject. Jay, ya done good. That shows me you are a man of good character and are open and honest. I think we ALL learned something here, and for that I will also say, thank you.
@trevorcrowe7571
@trevorcrowe7571 Год назад
Somewhat controversial is an understatement!
@djphat1736
@djphat1736 Год назад
This is awesome. I love this video. Thank you BOTH!
@scottbaylor6215
@scottbaylor6215 Год назад
Awesome job. I like it when channel creators get together and make good content. Keep rocking! 🤘🏼🎸🤘🏼
@FOH3663
@FOH3663 Год назад
Even more compelling to me, is the anticipation of your impression of Danny's reference rig.
@phillipmorris9847
@phillipmorris9847 Год назад
Thanks Jay, look forward to your listening impressions
@bigblueocean
@bigblueocean Год назад
That distant noise is the sound of Amir's head exploding. 😮
@abelabner
@abelabner 7 месяцев назад
As a Telecom worker for years originally working on Copper Cable runs (now mainly Fiber Optic Cable) we use diagnostic testing machines that you can physically graph the signal and glean much data, including RF interference. You just need a multi-thousand dollar tool that is precisely engineered with physical graphing ability among many other measurements you can take.
@YallDotBiz
@YallDotBiz 3 месяца назад
When that is done there is no difference
@bobb.9917
@bobb.9917 Год назад
Very Brave of both Jay and Danny! That said..I am a #10 solid copper lamp cord guy. 🙂 (I do not have a system like Danny's). I did just remove all the cheap electrolytic-film capacitors and cheap resistors in the tube stage of my Schiit Freya+ Preamp and soldered in $600 worth of V-Cap oil-damped metallized capacitors and Audio Note audiophile resistors. I was extremely pleased with the time and financial investment that truly improved the sound in my system & room. Plus…IT WAS FUN! 😀
@perlman7376
@perlman7376 Год назад
“Comparison is the thief of joy”. Doesn't matter who said it. More importantly, just something to consider.
@joelbangayan1443
@joelbangayan1443 Год назад
Just so nice to see you two together 😊
@BadMonkeyFinger_Audio
@BadMonkeyFinger_Audio Год назад
OMG , the 'Hey ev'rryybuddeh' from Jay had me howling! lmao! Good show!
@rainier939
@rainier939 Год назад
And again the room and setup are the glass ceiling. Great video
@dtracy03ss
@dtracy03ss Год назад
I give him credit for taking the challenge, guaranteed you couldn't find many if any manufacturers that would do that especially on Camera
@Jazzskill
@Jazzskill Год назад
This is awesome, guys. I really enjoyed the video.
@alexmacdonald2644
@alexmacdonald2644 Год назад
Lovely, open and honest chewing the fat. And Danny’s place is NOT the kind of home-spun garage set up his videos reflect. Very, very impressive.
@xxsauron007xx
@xxsauron007xx Год назад
Thank you for doing this, it's really interesting to watch something like this so I can get my own opinion. So far I think that cables do make a difference, but of all the things one could upgrade, they are the least bang for buck. I think most other components would make a greater differences in different price classes. But I'm always free to be convinced otherwise.
@DougMen1
@DougMen1 Год назад
From my experience, going from a $20 Amazon or Monster cable to a good $50-100 Audioquest or Straightwire cable can make a significant difference in the sound quality of your system. But, that's interconnects that I'm talking about. I've never really felt the same when it comes to $100-200 speaker cables from those two or from Kimber. I actually prefer Audioquest's 14 ga. two conductor in-wall speaker wire, terminated with simple banana plugs. It's 2 14 ga. wires, one in a red jacket and one in a black one, with a white outer jacket.
@matthewtaylor7355
@matthewtaylor7355 Год назад
It makes more difference if u can avoid mains cable in the wall... I have a female mains plug very close t my mains.. Avoiding 15 metres of mains makes a big difference and it is free.. I have not spent 2 grand on audiograde in wall cable
@zeppelin2900
@zeppelin2900 Год назад
What tube amplifiers were used? Thanks ,great video
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
Dodd Audio.
@bartbarelds8454
@bartbarelds8454 Год назад
Thnx guys, learned allot!
@normrubio
@normrubio Год назад
Can the connectors and unfamiliarity with the test cable be the difference? Usually you’re swapping out your own cables for an upgrade, after having listening time with it, it should be easy to hear differences. Second, can the connectors limit transmission?
@markconner5569
@markconner5569 Год назад
Ah, the Tube Connector conundrum!
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
We've compared each and every aspect individually. Everything matters.
@davidbee8178
@davidbee8178 Год назад
3 F's for this video - Fantastic - Fun - Frank :-) Two great guys having fun with a frank discussion about cables and the limitations of certain tracks in order to discern one cable from the next - as in if there is no "air" in a recording it's not all that easy to hear "air' when comparing cables ! Please do more of this guys if you can !! And OH Danny - I do love your reviews and "fix-its" for various speakers - for example the Totem - I was always wondering why I didn't like their sound and your video clearly illustrated the stridency on their top end . . . I really love what you're doing and you too Jay - with YOUR RU-vid productions !! Carry ON!!
@dandebaca6661
@dandebaca6661 Год назад
Cool vid Jay. Where does one get the Harp device Danny mentioned he attaches to his speaker cable. Do you have any experience with that product? Thanks.
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
It is only available on Shunyata Research products.
@deniz1180
@deniz1180 10 месяцев назад
If anyone has a link, that'd be fantastic. I'm searching all over their website and can't find a stand-alone product.
@jamestorres4705
@jamestorres4705 Год назад
Jay I recently purchased the Wilsenton R8 based on your recommendation. It’s been a great amp. Which speakers would pair better with this amplifier, the Tekton Double impact or the Arendal 1723 speakers?
@Jayiyagi
@Jayiyagi Год назад
Both good choices. Subjectively I'd choose the Arendal
@allseeingeye1
@allseeingeye1 2 месяца назад
8/10 = v. Impressive. However, just goes to show, for most people, good standard cables are more than good enough.
@diamondbracelette
@diamondbracelette Год назад
Good lord, the story arc!
@createachanneltopost
@createachanneltopost Год назад
that is an impressive result!
@CaptainJamesTKirk-en4kt
@CaptainJamesTKirk-en4kt Год назад
Danny brings up a great point, "you get lost in the music" you really don't give a crap what type of cable you're using. LOL Funny on how Jay and Danny where hitting heads a few years ago now they are friends, which is a good thing. The problem with that it makes reviewers biased in the long run... ;)
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
Actually, I never had Jay in mind when I threw a broad blanket over the young RU-vid reviewers.
@joenovak6393
@joenovak6393 Год назад
Thank You Jay as your content has been fantastic. You are blooming as a content producer and also keep your mind open and ask questions. Enjoy you travels with your Audio Journey and looking forward to 100K.
@rvaillant
@rvaillant Год назад
Great stuff. I was waiting for the question if Danny’s cables are Ally Express, but modded.
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
They are not.
@jjs71072
@jjs71072 Год назад
Great video, Thanks!!
@Robert_hill
@Robert_hill Год назад
Love the collaboration
@bencarignan2711
@bencarignan2711 Год назад
Great collaboration Jay. See if Danny will send you a pair of the new Brute 3 way retro speaker for review!
@amanieux
@amanieux Год назад
interesting it goes against the conclusion of the "coat hanger" tests will this noticeable difference still be noticed on cheap (sub $500) speakers+amp combo ?
@drewpknutz1410
@drewpknutz1410 Год назад
No. These are trained ears listening on $50k systems and still batting 80%. There is ZERO chance you'd tell any difference on a $500 system.
@elgingaragegym
@elgingaragegym Год назад
Awesome video... Highly entertaining.
@chebrubin
@chebrubin Год назад
This is nice RU-vid "beer summit".
@markg4331
@markg4331 Год назад
I really appreciate the work and integrity here, thank you. I have noticed an audible differences (with good systems playing quality recordings) between generic 16 awg and 12 awg OF copper cables. A better reference for the comparison with the GRR cables would be properly terminated generic OF copper of the same gauge as the GRR (8 awg)?
@Jayiyagi
@Jayiyagi Год назад
please read the pinned comment for clarification. Thanks !
@markg4331
@markg4331 Год назад
@@Jayiyagi Thanks Jay...missed the comment...late at night. The cable thing is a big deal to many. The testing stands on it own and is greatly appreciated. The matter is further complicated by the possibility that the best cable for a system is one that has an optimal impedance match with the amp, rather than the exotic and expensive build. The fact that the "cable debate" persists is evidence that the differences between properly constructed, but affordable, cable and exotic expensive cable are small. If the differences were robust, the matter would have long ago been put to rest with a mass of consistent empirical findings. The advice that the two of you provide is spot on. Many thanks for what you do!
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
Wire gauge had nothing to do with the audible differences. The only area that lower resistance can make a difference in output is in the first octave and the first octave was being filtered out by the pre-amp. So levels were the same all the way across.
@jah5035
@jah5035 Год назад
@@dannyrichie9743 Are you saying that your speaker’s exhibit a constant impedance across the entire frequency spectrum being fed to them? Unless you’re feeding a purely noninductive load, wire gauge will certainly have an influence on speaker’s sound, albeit small. As the speaker’s impedance changes with frequency (and they all do, some dramatically), the voltage drop across the cable will change, (simple voltage divider here), effectively changing the frequency response of the speaker. A larger diameter cable, with a lower series resistance, will experience less voltage fluctuation, therefore have less effect on the speaker’s response.
@rgrosset
@rgrosset Год назад
It's a US$ 10,00 speaker cable versus a US$ 140,00 one (for a 10 ft cable), tested with his own speakers, in his own treated room, with the songs he chose, and he guessed it 8 out of 10 (when 5 in 10 would be considered sheer luck). We should also consider the possibility that, having built the cable, he would know the sonic signature of the material, and was able to pick up the differences, not necessarily the BETTER one. Congratulations on the courage and honesty of trying your own products on a blind test (God knows that most hifi manufacturers wouldn't do that to not risk embarrasing themselves), but as Danny himself points out at the end of the video, you must have excellent speakers, properly set up on a proper room, with the right equipment, with excellent recordings, in order to start picking up the differences between 2 cables.
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
A super high end and perfectly set up system is not necessary to hear the differences. What I was pointing out in the end is that it is more important to take care of those areas first so that the differences that cable can bring to the table can be fully realized.
@kirkcunningham6146
@kirkcunningham6146 Год назад
Using some AC/DC albums is good for testing because the recordings are very raw such as the "Ballbreaker" album that was used. I use their "Stiff Upper Lip" album for midrange and kick drum testing. AC/DC is a good choice. Great video, thank you!
@ChonkTek
@ChonkTek 11 месяцев назад
At 20:33, a comparison is made between two different environments with the same gear, and in the 2nd environment it sounded flat. This difference often be the changes between power receptacles and power/signal/speaker wire and their orientations. It also can be the difference between the Romex cable gauge and direction within the walls. It's especially dependant on the breaker box parts! Sometimes the power foundation can trump other changes down the line. We experienced this when moving familiar equipment with exacting configurations and parts from an older house to a newer one. The newer house had a completely different breaker box, and very different outlets. I went to the old house and removed some of the outlets to bring to the new house. It was a night and day difference when listening to the same setup at the new house with the old outlets. This got me into searching for better outlets, and I've found some very special sounding ones which remove a serious amount of "veil" and grain/harshness from ANY hifi or guitar amp I plug into them. Every tiny part from power distribution matters. Tone starts at the wall.
@jamestindle2077
@jamestindle2077 3 месяца назад
I very much enjoyed this, and trial and error is part of science. After all, what is an experiment, but trial and error.
@paulmelendez2834
@paulmelendez2834 5 месяцев назад
I have blue Jean speaker cables. Wonder if I’d hear a difference if I switch to these. (My room is well treated)
@dominicdiclemente8877
@dominicdiclemente8877 Год назад
How do you mount a tube connector to an amp's chassis ?
@G3rain1
@G3rain1 Год назад
Just need to drill a hole in the back platte .They'll mount to anything, regardless of thickness if you have the right size hole drilled. I forget the exact diameter though.
@jaghifi
@jaghifi 9 месяцев назад
awesome video, love both your videos.
@simonirvine1628
@simonirvine1628 Год назад
The item on the rear of Danny's speaker connections that was removed for the test am I right to say that device is to effect and change the dampening factor ?
@deniz1180
@deniz1180 10 месяцев назад
I'm looking everywhere for more information about this. Shunyata Harp device is what he says but all I find anywhere are Shunyata cables which I would LOVE to be able to afford and at least try. The quick shot of the device in the video though looks more homemade.
@matytinman
@matytinman Год назад
Many years ago, with the second audio equipment sounding much worse than now, I appreciated the difference between the typical/cheap OFC audio cable and the current Kimber Kable 8PR (interleaved like GR-Research's): more detail and, very noticeably, more bass. Now I also notice the difference in the connectors but it is more subtle. The sound improvement after changing tweeter filter components was spectacular. Finally, the quality of the electrical grid is essential, which is getting louder every day. The difference can also be spectacular, at least in my house. If you notice, Danny has a couple of car batteries for the little amps.
@DrBroncanuus
@DrBroncanuus Год назад
Jay finally meets his real father Danny....moving magnet moment
@paulkelleway8032
@paulkelleway8032 Год назад
What was the length of both cables? I think if you had used a slightly better (low end) cable it would be much harder to tell the difference, especially for lengths under 3 meters.
@LovelyDoetje
@LovelyDoetje Год назад
I liked the video. Liked the way it doesn't come across as a commercial just to sell something. I appreciated the moment you tell us not to spend money on the cables unless you did everything else. Good point. But 10 blind tests ain't something to draw a conclusion on. If you want results you need to repeat the test with mutiple people everyday for a year. The results could be very different then. Still I myself heard differences between cables. I must say I only heard differences with speaker cables. Never with other cables used in my system. And I have tried different brands and priceranges and most cables are still in use because none of them were bad. Well 1 was badly build and fell apart while unplugging (not the cheapest one).
@vwestlife
@vwestlife Год назад
If this was a sponsored video, then you legally need to click on the "Yes, it includes paid promotion" option.
@Jayiyagi
@Jayiyagi Год назад
It is not a sponsored video
@angelheart1129
@angelheart1129 Год назад
Danny changed my audio life with his open baffle design videos They enabled me to trial and error design and build killer alnico/neodymium driver open baffles that are my end game sound! no insertion losses soldered direct 🙏❤
@jebo4jc
@jebo4jc Год назад
Good work. Although, comparing a $400 cable to a $4 cable, I would hope we all would hear a difference! I'd like to see this test done again with a $40 cable compared to the $400 cable.
@WigandKleine
@WigandKleine Год назад
Hey Jay; have you thought about reviewing the 2TD-X? Thinking about buying those :)
@patrickmeylemans9627
@patrickmeylemans9627 Год назад
Good one can hear things for the price they pay for cables, I did some testing with two types of cables and my ears did not hear any difference… saved me lots of money. 👍
@pacificateur3630
@pacificateur3630 Год назад
You could have waited after the Montreal Audio Show…Best show in a long time and no coverage 🥲 Nevertheless, very cool video.
@anthonycody4095
@anthonycody4095 Год назад
Hi Jay, interesting clip, on your point about how a cable improves sound stage or bass or air, etc... I believe that high-quality cables aren't improving the sound they are allowing "more" of the signal to come through to the speakers. So you hear, closer to 100% of the sound quality that your components are capable of delivering. I think this is why there is a lot of disagreement about cables, people aren't understanding what's going on. So it comes down to what their system is capable of delivering and how much of the sound quality is making to their speakers. This is where well-made cables can really ensure you hear everything your system is doing. Cables unlock the full potential of your system
@SahinurUK
@SahinurUK Год назад
Agree with you.
@franciscorompana2985
@franciscorompana2985 Год назад
Ha, ha. Great. Kudus for both, and for the cables. They must be really good.😅
@IliyaOsnovikov
@IliyaOsnovikov Год назад
Jay, you should compare cables with the same cross section. Let's say one 4 mm2 cable to another 4 mm2 cable of the same length.
@netnakul
@netnakul Год назад
Wish you did a test of his power cables as well
@dannyrichie9743
@dannyrichie9743 Год назад
He has some of them, so maybe he will.
@aussie_philosopher8079
@aussie_philosopher8079 Год назад
I'd like to buy and try Dannys cables. He is a very experienced guy. Currently I use the thin analysis plus cables which are extremely efficient and sound great. But gr research know their stuff so I will try.
@joewhite396
@joewhite396 Год назад
Great! I watched both videos released urn. I work out of a corner for my room. Unreal experience. Let’s stop being in doubt. I don’t need to pull it out far away so it’s not too close. Goodness gets the job done. It not the placement of your ocean, it’s the power of your tower. Boys..to..men. Much love!
@Shalmaneser1
@Shalmaneser1 5 месяцев назад
We have choices to make. When I began chasing recordings, I realized that my system was now more revealing than fun.
@kevinp4323
@kevinp4323 Год назад
My Wharfedale EVO 4.2 bass is gone when i put the sepaker way out in the room. Can anyone tell me why that happen?
@PlatypusPerspective
@PlatypusPerspective Год назад
The EVO 4.2 is designated as a bookshelf speaker. If a bookshelf speaker is correctly designed, it will have its design target bass response when it is positioned in close proximity to a wall behind the cabinet, as the name suggests; equivalent to sitting on a shelf attached to the wall. At low frequencies, energy is reflected from the wall (close to) in phase with the direct sound from the driver/port, and adds together. The bass heard in the room will reduce proportionally to the degree that the speaker loses this bass reinforcement due to separation from the reflective surface. This effect occurs with all speakers placed in a (normal) room, but since most other speakers are not specifically designed to be placed close to surfaces, and are not normally positioned that way, the effect of moving the speaker around in the room is more subtle. (Floorstanding speakers are of course designed to be standing on the floor, a surface, but their relation to the floor does not normally change if they are repositioned in the room.) What you would notice though, is if you moved speakers closer to a wall or walls than would be expected (e.g. towards a corner) the perceived bass level from that speaker would rise - the reverse effect to what you're hearing when you move your Wharfedales further from walls.