In this video, we compare The Witcher 3 Vs Elden Ring Vs Assassin's Creed Odyssey. As it is a mega comparison video where we talk about physics, combat, graphics and more. #MadOGs #EldenRing #acodyssey #witcher3
@@justlegitguy odyssey feel more unfinished than Valhalla. Odyssey has a better story but that’s it. The gameplay mechanics are clumsy compared to Valhalla. Same for combat and graphics. Odyssey was supposed to be an upgrade from origins but origins is better. How Ms that supposed to work
All 3 are really great games. I can recommend them all. Especially Odyssey is kind of a hidden gem. People judge it because its from ubisoft 😂 Storywise its Witcher 3 for me. Combatwise its Elden Ring. Movement clearly goes to AC.
I really don’t care about most of the video but the reasoning for giving witcher the combat point was stylish animation and better hack&slash? I love the game to death(talking about witcher) but one cast meteorite of astell or starcaller cry and the witcher just can’t compare with animation and the “sharpness” of the sword? Really? It’s a universally hated mechanic in the witcher game, when you’re in the middle of the fight and your sword breaks if you’re in the minority of people who likes the mechanic fine but don’t use “sharpnesses of the sword” as an excuse for bias, and one more thing you’re playing as a mage in er and talking about hack&slash? At least use a build that uses hack&slash or a melee build in general when talking about it.
No game since Skyrim has managed to create a total sense of freedom and to explore the interactive open world and characters. But the voice acting is terrible compared to Witcher 3, Elden Ring, Assassins Creed Origins-Valhalla and many other high production games. And the followers are also lackluster compared to Dragon Age Origins or inquisition. No rpg elements also excludes Skyrim from being both a A-Tier or S-Tier/ masterpiece. The perfect Open world rpg game has not yet been released, because Elden Ring is too combat focused like the Souls series and Demon Souls/Bloodborne.
Skyrim wasn't really Bethesda's best game, most popular but not the best. And I wouldn't compare it to these three games, Witcher 3 was a story driven RPG, Assassin's Creed open world games became flat for me, and Elden Ring was an open world Dark Souls. For me Bethesda's greatest game is Morrowind, it has a lots of dated mechanics, but otherwise more of a polished Open World RPG than a sanbox game like Skyrim. Don't missunderstand me, I play Skyrim even today, but Morrowind still the pinnacle that Bethesda made.
@@PeterPauls I agree like most hardcore Elder scrolls fans, that Morrowind has a better magicsystem, rpg elements and unique dreamlike alien world that stands out from the generic typical lotr fantasy world. The reason i didnt mention Morrowind, is because of how dated it is. Some TES fans even still thinks that Daggerfall is the best Elder scrolls games, but it has too many flaws to make it an enjoyable experience, with all the random procedural generated areas, useless skills and combat system etc.
@@Hear.myvoiceVery Uneducated comment we have here. Elden Ring Still has an additional DLC called "Shadow Of The Erdtree" and thus the story is not completed yet, and here some idiot making guesses over something that he does not even know very well, very befitting of the the low IQ that you are.
Bro if you say that you havent played it... It defenetly can compete with these two other titles Just because some youtubers say its bad doesnt mean its bad. Its a stunning RPG game, i recommend you actually play it cuz its great! 👍👍
@@NickiRruhland if you want to play that average game go and play it... its your choice and your happiness no issue but don't recommend a stranger a game as stunning when its really a mediocre, you like RPG games that why you accept this game as well. Everything great is comes from its predecessor Ac origins, people feels wow because of that huge map and variety of landscape but after few hours the freshness is lost, repetitive, grinding, less interesting missions...sure some point for combat, Greece... other than that what else it have ? choices and decisions ? like trying to be a wannabe as Witcher or mass effect ? what logic where a predestined game were the history is already written have to do with decision making whatever the option you take it all will be non canon.. I don't make statements based on some random youtubers I make them with my own experience
@@Mohgenstein not really. Both have outstanding reviews, between 9 and 10/10. The reality is that witcher 3 surpasses Elden Ring in all areas except combat. I cried several times during the brilliant story of witcher 3. Can't say the same about elden ring.
@@Max-px5ym Ok u crying doesn’t change the reality that Elden Ring has a higher aggregate score. 96 compared to the 93. Saying it doesn’t hold a candle is funny.
@@Mohgenstein aggregate scores are meaningless on their own. On metacritic Witcher 3 has 94, elden ring 96 and guess who has 98? Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2. Yet this game doesn't hold a candle to either W3 or ER...
@@Max-px5ym That game has less than 30 reviews and was from two decades ago, both Witcher and Elden Ring are modern games and have 100+ scores. They are comparable.
no Elden Ring is better even in the Water Effect. you just haven't played Elden Ring the Whole Map yet. Elden Ring is the best, this is proven by the selling of the game itself.
The selling (sales) of the game is irrelevant in terms of graphics lol. Minecraft is one of the best selling games of all time and it looks like utter shit.
