0:14 Dust flow back issue ? 1:45 Why 3 TTC antenna ? 2:52 Lupex and CY3 roadmap 4:16 Soviet / chinese approach to reach on far side of moon ? 5:18 CY3's laser dopler velocity meter and why it wasnt use in cy2? 6:17 comments on Fuel delta, and survivability of rover 7:15 Propulsion module comments 7:45 various Lifecycle comments 8:28 design changes of rover comments 9:10 Lander to rover range related discussion 9:49 Camera fixtures related discussion 10:11 will there be FSE brief on CY2 ? 11:42 experience gain from cy2 applied on cy3 !? 12:05 why there are checker marks on the ramp? 13:06 whats ISRO's stance on water discovery of moon? 14:20 Out reach of ISRO, remarks by GS. 15:58 Reason why GS' insta story outrage on isro imposter account on insta. 17:27 CY3 wild speculations and rumours related comment / isro pr function 19:44 ISRO taking quiet approach for CY3 ? 21:09 GS cencern on AI image generator, generating NASA stuffs 24:23 Aditya L1 mission remarks / issue with corona graph (rumour) 25:35 Speculations on launch window 25:55 Shukrayan status /mission to venus 27:04 Lander for Shukrayan ? 27:40 Mangalyan 2 possibilities? 28:52 comments on some association and mars mission by Smt. Megala 30:10 how far NGLV implementation? 32:26 latest update on Admire ? 33:59 L40 experience ? 34:47 time spent in dev. vs. Usage years of nglv and se2 / too early to obsolete 38:11 performance delta in nglv can be utilize in docking features? 39:19 Update on future missions 40:11 will TDS have RTG ? 41:05 final request on out reach / human naming of NGLV 😅
उन्होंने पृथ्वी पर रोवर का रियल टाइम लैंडिंग टेस्ट क्यों नहीं किया. केवल सिम्युलेटर पर निर्भर डेटा चंद्रमा पर सॉफ्ट लैंडिंग के लिए पर्याप्त नहीं होगा। Why they didn't carried out real time landing test of rover on the earth. Only depends on Simulator data wouldn't be enough for soft landing on moon.
man taking probabiliy the biggest interview of his life and yet..... - no intro - no stupid talking - no beating around the bush straight to the business!!! this man is real OG sci-tech youtuber!!!❤
Really nice interview. I believe could be improved with intros and some contexts. Some homour and jokes here and there. Lex fridman does this really well, may be some inspirations.
Somanath Sir put up with all the questions GAREEB SCIENTIST had for so long, right before the launch....he could have waited until the mission was successfully executed. People must appreciate him for being so open..... I love this interview
@@GareebScientist hey thanks for the reply, by the way you talked about not being enough content about ISRO on Twitter /Insta. The content problem can be easily solved if you start a community where people do open source contribution in the form of simulations/pics/news which can be verified and then shared with general public. I think people only reach out to ISRO when there is a lauch, it is upto us to keep requesting them for Info, i dont think they will deny our request. thanks
@@mayurbhurle7675 bloody good idea, and could be an example of our how proactive ethusiastic people can be. However, once the bureaucratic loops are jumped through, the renders might not be so useful.
thats what i thought the same 😅 he has pretty well knowledge about the system and ofcourse he is well experienced as for the outreach context ,,acc to me if someone who can do this job greatly, i can say he is perfect for it
I applaud you for pushing back that there is a lack of technical depth without release of FAC for CH-2. I am also glad that you asked about CHACE vs M3. I felt he was unaware of M3/CHACE situation. However his response is reasonable, can't expect ISRO to wade into a controversy.
@@HrithikSD4368 And that is what I don't get. Why can't they release the FAC report when it is available? I still don't know for example, what impact the last minute changes to CH-2 had on its testing and why those changes were even made. In one interview that I remember, then ISRO Chairman was very dismissive about the original design. Now we are back to something very close to that original design. What possibly can ISRO and India gain by not publishing the FAC report?
21:09 This is what Prashant Sir from World Affairs was talking about. The Ai like Chat gpt shows the world through American perspective. We need to develop our own Ai system otherwise these countries will control the narrative
@@prash96 I don't do it because I'm from biology background. I don't have the resources. But the people who DO have resources should start ASAP And yes, you need large servers and huge GPU systems to train the ai which normal people like us don't have
00:00 CY3 and Lupex(Dust flow issue TTC antenna?) 4:14 doing work like Russia and China to go far side of Luna(चांद) 5:26 LDV on CY2? 6:14 if rover doesn't survived and the lander survived 7:17 propulsion module about it's life and more 8:30 any changes to rover and lander 9:09 can lander go further and faster? 9:59 adding two new small camera in rear 10:15 FAC report of CY2 15:00 PR and Outreach (why AI generating NASA rocket in the name of ISRO rockets Somnath sir be like when question about Social media: we were doing great in Facebook then people shifted to Instagram They don't visit our website It's not ISRO problem 😂 So we mostly announce in Twitter And deep things about ISRO missions and our work are in our website) 24:20 Aditya L1 26:00 Mission to Venus 27:40 possibility of Mission to Mars 2 or Mangalyaan 2 29:06 Mars landing mission? (Futuristic ISRO mission like space station First Indian on moon) NGLV We working on engine we completed engine design ❤ Rocket part is much simpler (Landing may not be) 34:47 SCE 200 38:11 NGLV purpose 39:21 future mission of ISRO 40:11 will TDS have rtg 41:04 request on outreach and pr Why GSLV MK3 renamed into LVM3? Please Dont call it Bahubali ❤ Thank You GS You always has been my inspiration as a science communicator❤
13:00 I was lucky enough to talk to Dr. Syed M Maqbool. He came to my college, to give a presentation on Cube Sats and also Inaugurated the College Telescope brought by Space Club. He also worked briefly in NASA before joining ISRO for the CY-1 program.
Well done mate .. perhaps your questions could have been framed better ...there were few uncomfortable moments throughout the interview...but many important questions were asked ...kudos to you ! I'm sure your interviewing skills will improve along the way ...
NASA has excellent branding, marketing and mechandise-ecosystem. I wish ISRO could have a great PR team. Look at Indian brands like Zomato, Lenskart, Swiggy etc they have excellent marketing teams.
@@kindofanmolwhat's the point of being a brand, I am being honest. Nasa was branded as such due to cold war dynamics where they had to portray NASA as superior
NASA has excellent branding, marketing and mechandise-ecosystem. I wish ISRO could have a great PR team. Look at Indian brands like Zomato, Lenskart, Swiggy etc they have excellent marketing teams.
I know right! Its sad that we have high tech studio rooms with elaborate discussions and Ultra detailed high quality visual, audio and animation coverage for a Silly Cricket tournament like IPL and Nothing and even worse coverage for historic events like these that defines the capability and technological demonstration missions of an Entire Nation! Which are way more important than anything else at this point of time! ISRO is very old school and doesn't care about public outreach, which is important to inspire young minds and make them more interested towards science!
Sorry to bulge in just a thought, maybe read it and reply with your views😅.. Why is isro avoiding marketing on scale, 2 reasons I could think of.. 1) NASA is a large part of us ecosystem where in even after ossification till this day every common citizen and members of Congress criticise NASA for their spendings which are aggravated on their failures and my heart pains to say that some mistakes could make a history out of isro's many ambitious missions. So it is a smart move like Chinese to focus on your work, be specialised in it and let the world know only if confronted which challenged national security (This point because more marketing will make isro more visible and the subject of discussion often and not all discussion are of your point of view **POSITIVE** for isro..humans😢) 2) NASA is pioneer in space research and has a strong military arm too.nasa has been successful in getting funds in the name of research but for isro I guess main discussion with goi is much on national security for the country so objective move should be of abstraction which isro does great, releasing only required minimum info
What I deduced from this interview is that ISRO doesn't have the necessary resources to do something like that, and the PR we are getting is wholly voluntary. I don't see it changing till the budget gets increased somehow. The space culture we want in india will be given to us by private firms. Soon enough don't worry.
I think Somnath sir also enjoyed this interview....finally he got someone who talks about such technical things, I had watched so much interview of somnath sir and always he forced to answer nonsensical question of media like what is PSLV, what is GSLV, what is the working life of Lander and Rovar etc etc etc....now he talks about the real mechanisms, the antennas, doubler velocimeter, fuel delta, re-hovering possibility etc.
WOW GS bhai, what a video!!!! Beyond my expectations! More than to congratulate, I'd like to thank you for this interview. We now have a good perspective on how ISRO thinks, and now are getting a slight knowledge on how ISRO aims to function.
Such an important question about CY2 report. Further, a much needed interview by one of if not the only YT who could talk about such a technical topic. Great job. Maybe a follow up video on this from your side breaking the interview down would be appreciated
Zero time is wasted on intro or outro, what a great science and technology dedicated guy we have..... Keep it up buddy you are serving the mankind for no return in demand. Will definitely buy your subscription from my first salary ❤
Woaahh!! This interview is goldmine. The questions you asked and information Somnath Sir put out, is something any media house would never ask, as they are just concerned about the number game n race, and not about the actual science n effort which goes behind it. Thanks a lot @GareebScientist bro Proud of being a member to this channel and being connected with you.
So brilliantly done. Amazing how you stood your ground and yet were respectful. And such technical questions from a media outlet - that too a so called social media outlet. Proud of you brother ! Will definitely support you and your channel.
🙌 bro forget about P.R i think you should learn how to approach the answers for your questions, don't take it in a negative way, rather improve your way of talking and questioning, that other person should feel ease and normal to answer even if it is a tricky question. But if we ask whatever we feel or think then we it's obvious to get similar style of reply. Anyways congrats that you did your interview, that is a big celebration thing for you, and don't worry things change they are not permanent. 👍🏻🔥
I think Mr. Somnath would have answered the same way regardless of the way the question was asked. In India, even mildly questioning authority is scoffed at. All things considered it was a solid interview.
@@bharatpenumutchu6487no I have seen his Malayalam interviews talking about aliens, space x etc. He become really enthusiastic when the interviewer has a good energy.
This was amazing (a bit weird) interview. It was unpolished and maybe not a perfect BUT it was filled with some intresting information and moments. Proud of you GS bro
Congratulations to you for getting this opportunity! At large it is good to see technical discussions, but I feel interview could have been better. Instead of direct questions and direct answers in response, questions could have been kept generic to have more discussion like there was good discussion on PR and outreach.
I was going to say that it'd have resulted in short and non-descriptive responses from his end but after watching more of it, it does feel like that they are way _too_ specific. For instance, here at 8:27 (THE question I was looking forward to), he asks in the context of lifespan / durability which could've easily been an open ended question : "What changes compared to before to lander / rover?". You can see that the chief took it upon himself to add to it, which shows that he'd have responded with breadth as well if prompted correctly
Well, you are being very kind to ISRO with the "really underwhelming" bit on the public outreach front. :) For such a senior official to say things like "you guys keep shifting social media platforms", "we don't have an Instagram account or a Twitter account" sounded like the lamest of excuses. I think he nailed the problem when he answered that the Outreach team consists of 2 or 3 ISRO scientists dedicating some of their (possibly personal) time in contributing to the public outreach....therein lies the problem....the Outreach Team ought to be a dedicated team whose raison d'etre must be to simplify the technical content of the past, ongoing and upcoming missions into bite-sized nuggets that can be digested easily by the masses of all ages.... ideally in atleast English and Hindi, to begin with. IMHO, we don't need scientists to create such content; what we really need dedicated social-media-savvy content creators employed by ISRO and scientists to only review the content for correctness before it is published. Any excuse implying "Oh, we are a scientific and engineering organization and therefore we don't feel the need to do an outreach to the country..." is rather condescending! At the end of the day, while we are all extremely proud of the ISRO scientists, the organization must not forget that it was started with and continues to be supported by the Indian taxpayer's money, especially in the pure science mission front. Therefore, public outreach must be a part of the objectives of ISRO....not necessarily a primary level objective, I agree, but atleast a close secondary one. ISRO definitely owes it to the nation!
@@skailajeYeah the chief did get a little defensive but I guess his main concern is making the shoestring budget go the distance on stuff that actually matters.Tbf NASA's budget dwarfs ISRO by a lot.
@@skailaje ISRO needs to do a lot of work to approve every project and proposal and our budgets are dismal as we are a developing country. If you have expectations of NASA from ISRO than better we tame down.
Yeah, i also thought why midjourney didn't replace with Chinese or Russian rockets, they also have great image database. The thing is these AI is trained through American perspective/data. India should build it's own alternatives like china otherwise we will face it more in future.
@@HrithikSD4368 our ministers and businessman our just idiots and the good engineer don't get funds for it, training big models require millions of dollars and a lot lot of time
First off,Congratulations to all my Fellow Gareeb Scientists.We could learn from errors and get better just like ISRO does all the time.We shall relentlessly push for better PR from ISRO until it gets addressed.But we shall make a strong case with ISRO next time. S.Somanth has been very kind and patient in taking questions beyond CY3.I am sure it speaks volumes about his sincere intentions in encouraging the curiosity built around ISRO among the youth of this country. He might have come across a bit sharp but I am sure it's just a knee jerk reaction. GS has uncovered a wide spectrum of things for us with this interview.Cant appreciate him enough. I could see brighter things on the horizon for us as a community. Just keep feeding your curiosity as always and best things will follow.
Very interesting aspect he mentioned is about secrecy on few matters. As responsible citizens when we push for better PR we also need to make sure we ain't creating security challenges for ISRO where they think it could be
Kudos to Dr.Somnath. Never seen any Chairman of any agency talk so detailed to an outsider. Please understand his limitations of NDAs that come with his job.
I never expected this interview.Great job .Eagerly waiting for more interviews like this. So much technical things got to know and their updates. Keep going ❤️
Wow ! What a great interview . No Diplomatic BS , simple straightforward question. I must say , some answers were very discouraging. These guys seems out of Touch .
I am so happy to watch u interview the ISRO chairman...it really shows how enthusiastic today's generation is about our Scientific studies in space and I loved how well researched you were going into that interview..all the best for the future bro 🙌
This is another a milestone india achieved . Congratulations. Many people don't talk about the scientific achievement done by ISRO and other organisations. S. Somnathan is more like K siwan, i didn't intially thought. He is smart and intelligent and more open. Interviewer was so on the mark. No gibberish, straight to point.
Loved the format. Great interview! Thank you for the questions, they were specific and covered a good range of projects. Also loved the patience and williness of Dr Somnath to answer those in as much details as he did. Really appreciate it! 🙏
Mission first makes sense but giving technically deeper information to the enthusiast audience between scientist and laymen will increase scientific temperament in the society and generate better outcomes for all science related fields and even industries. Though it could be sad that viewers of such content is less, such interactions over sustained time is the antidote to hyper sensationalism and knee jerk reactions. Thank you both and hoping for status updates turning into defined projects
Awesome interview!! Deeply disappointed with ISRO chief's responses on general PR outreach and greater voluntary disclosures. Perhaps we will have to wait for the next generation before we get an ISRO chief who "gets it" as APJ Kalam Sir used to.
Absolutely loved the interview. I couldn't make sense of the technical parts but enjoyed the openness of our guest. As much sir is focusing on engg instead of PR, you too have focused on tech and not on courtesies. Even sir could feel your passion and gleefully accepted your observations. Thanks for sharing this. ❤
OMG I Loved this interview i felt like two knowledgeable people talking like friends with a coffee. His transperency is so amazing Thank you for reaching out and showing us this side of ISRO
Bro the Interview was Fire man🔥🔥the way u asked to improve the camera and the reply of somnath sir,,crazy bro and asking sir to improve Social Media Presence(Somnath sir reply:people switihing from Facebook etc)😄😄 and most of the question didnt get in my ear but kuddos A GREAT CONVERSATION🚀🚀🚀🚀
Also seems like a very uncomfortable one. Absolutely loved the fact that you went behind and kept challenging him on outreach. And I still feel ISRO is doing a terrible job with its PR. 1 or 2 people is all you need for decent PR these days.
I think you don't understand the point... They are not interested in more pr or their budget won't justify to spend on pr more and basically and finally it's the govt job to do it and it's not isro business
@@VALAR_Morgulis.Not really, how much will it take to add few more pictures than they already do, Post few more posts than they already do, tag the accounts on the pictures instead of spamming on tweets, release some footage that they already film etc etc
@@VALAR_Morgulis. I do. My point is if they have 1 or 2 people in pr. They are all they need for some good outreach (even though that is not the primary objective of ISRO) provided they somewhat understand the social media landscape. It's not their job, I get it. And I'm not asking them (as in the actual core org) to specifically do it. And so whatever their "PR" organization is, or whoever it's under, should either be replaced with someone who actually goes around doing some work, or remove the post entirely and let whatever govt organization handle it. As far as the papers or research material and data is considered. That could be (and is) managed by scientist anyways. Poor allocation of resources is how I'd put it. Further, this gives them a good excuse to selectively talk about failures and or missions in general. Which kinda is against the whole transperency thing.
@@babayada2015 don't assume it's easy job in a country where people are not generally interested in modern day space and scientific research Look at usa their is culture is very different than India Interstellar is science fiction but these type of movies tell how their society thinks and how they perceive space exploration In India we have this mission Mangal i mean wtf Still rocket boys save the day But I am not talking about achievements and contribution type of movies where are science fiction Countries who do extensive pr on space exploration are the same who have media and cinema making good sci fi content I am not saying that isro is doing good but still I will not ask them to increase pr rather I want space community to grow in India so that we don't need isro to do pr But I want isro to release more info so that it can spread in community faster
The discussion was good overall in terms of questions asked, but it could have been more inclusive and not kind of hostile, particularly on PR questions. Also I think we should appreciate Somnath sir for sticking up with rather aggressive questioning and taking the whole conversation amicably. Just one note, when such senior person is on camera it is expected that we show ourselves on camera which definately changes the conversation tone.
फार छान आणी poignant प्रश्न विचारले तू त्यांना|Some of the lingering chasms were answered today,so thank you ❤ My two bits - त्यांना obviously तू आता आवडतोस, so try to avoid abrasive questions going forward. You see, in space exploration there is an element of secrecy that is required,and he was doing his job in trying not to divulge state secrets for stuff in the works,which is understandable and I'm sure you would agree as well. Super proud of you to pull this interview off, and have the balls to ask those pointed questions that you did. Looking forward to getting more updates from ISRO about our ambitious space endeavours through your channel. My best wishes always! Jai Hind 🇮🇳🙏🏼
1st of all I am very much enjoy the this meeting.. Its a very much informative video.. Thank u gareeb scientist for making the video... Lots of questions clarify and so much expected answers.. Hope isro successfully completed there target about Cy3✔️..and it's very much clearer about that they're not think about big deal about the mission.. There 1st this as usual a Save landing that's more important.. Hope isro are doing well... Once again thakur you @gareebScientist
Good interview 🎉. One thing you had put before the ISRO, that PR. Not as much as quality for our new generation which creates an intrest or a dream to be a part of ISRO. Our school children are to an astronaut in NASA not a vyomonaut in ISRO. Dear Somnath Sir, this is not your duty or job. Basically you are scientist you have no time to do this. But being a Director of ISRO, you should assigned someone for this. People must be aware about the achievements through your official social media handle. We have 1.4bln minds but only a few in numbers in space science, we are lagging behind becoz of poor PR and authority/ies. Please change the mindset.
Amazing interview, please ignore the morons who make silly comments and political comments even on a highly technical interview 😂 . This is one of the best technical interview related to space science I have seen in India. Kudos to you, please bring more of such high quality videos❤
Can we not convey our concerns about the PR to government through some way. I am quite sure,if the need is conveyed and especially how it'll help the younger generation,they might act on it. Is there a way to do so?
