Тёмный

I was shocked when my CFI showed me this | Stall Spin Avoidance 

FlightInsight
Подписаться 178 тыс.
Просмотров 34 тыс.
50% 1

Loss of control accidents, often caused by stalls followed by a spin, are a result of excessively loading the wing by pulling back on the stick, like we do trying to hold altitude in a banked turn. The antidote for so many stall spin scenarios is to keep the nose low, thus lowering angle of attack, decreasing stall speed, and unloading the wing. When you're low and slow in the traffic pattern alarm bells should be going off in your head when the nose is too high.
Become a safer pilot with FlightInsight online ground schools. Check it out at flight-insight.com

Опубликовано:

 

1 май 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 60   
@SoloRenegade
@SoloRenegade Год назад
I always stress the load factor curve ONLY applies to level flight, to my students. Definitely something I see taught wrong far too often.
@mrkc10
@mrkc10 8 месяцев назад
Expert explanation. This video should be mandatory viewing for every student pilot.
@g.tucker8682
@g.tucker8682 Год назад
Excellent discussion! My airline has an extensive training module on this subject that goes beyond the FAA-mandated training for upset recovery. Your teaching here is entirely consistent with our training.
@lelievre12
@lelievre12 6 месяцев назад
I know we are trying to keep this simple to understand but faster airspeeds allow for higher wing loading and more G. So what we are doing when we lower the nose in the pattern is unloading the wing AND we are also increasing airspeed which allows the wing now to sustain a higher loading before stall. Both are beneficial in avoiding stall/spin.
@flyinghighhorn
@flyinghighhorn 8 месяцев назад
caution on "nose-low" statement, "load" is the important part. Be mindful of back pressure and load on the airplane during all maneuvers. Remember you can still achieve an accelerated stall "nose low".
@global6000
@global6000 Год назад
I’ve done my UPRT course on a Pitts Special recently and it gave me so much knowledge about spin recovery and other recoveries
@Celtkin
@Celtkin Год назад
Awesome video and demo! We learned for our PPT, that on final, you can control pitch with prop. Every airman learns that but it does feel more natural to pull back on the yoke to control the nose and that can get us killed. Thanks for the refresher!.
@zarmril
@zarmril Год назад
underrated
@Keys879
@Keys879 Год назад
A skill that can be very effective and what will set you up for success during your IFR training as well is "Pitch for Airspeed, Power for Altitude" Meaning if you're slow, push the nose over. If you're low, add throttle. If you're low and slow, perhaps do both. This will making holding a stabilized approach on final tremendously easier and more smooth while also drilling in the concept of pushing that nose low when maneuvering and getting too slow.
@ATOMEK2025
@ATOMEK2025 Год назад
@@Keys879 This idea will get you in trouble during a real approach from FAF in IMC.
@Keys879
@Keys879 Год назад
@@ATOMEK2025 No. It won't. CFII. The technique can be used effectively in all phases of the approach when used properly. No one should be nosing to the ground when they are at MDA/DA to recapture airspeed. At that point you should have long ago elected for a Missed Approach due to an unstabilized approach. But if you are on the glideslope the technique can be used effectively to maintain a stabilized approach and makes flying it a breeze.
@ATOMEK2025
@ATOMEK2025 Год назад
@@Keys879 You are partially correct if you fly a small airplane . Try this technique in any airliner. Even autopilot is controlling pitch (elevator) to stay on the glide slop. Talk to any 10 pilots (IFR) and there will be 50/50 on this topic. This idea was ok. decades ago but now, flying an airplane with flight director, autopilot etc…….those airplanes “fly” pitch for altitude or simply simultaneously are doing both. But I totally agree that this is the safest way (pitch for airspeed) to train new pilots. This topic is similar to discussion about the lift:Bernoulli vs Newton. In FAA publications Bernoulli is “the guy” but NASA will say:No, it is Newton. Actually both guys are “causing” the lift.
@ahmadsamadzai8255
@ahmadsamadzai8255 Год назад
You are such a gift to all aviators out there. Thank you.
@IanHorsford
@IanHorsford Год назад
No lie bro, Dan makes me wanna revisit CFI. He’s awesome
@Jet-Pack
@Jet-Pack Год назад
Keep in mind that neither low airspeed nor high bank angle causes a stall.. Only a high angle of attack causes a stall an that is regardless if you are upside down, if you are at 2x the minimum speed shown on the airplane or if you are pulling up from a dive, wings level. The correct action is to unload the wing as shown in the video. At a load factor of 0g you continue flying just like a ball that you throw. You won't maintain altitude but you also don't stall and spin.
@pedropinho573
@pedropinho573 Год назад
This. Only angle of attack matters. You cannot stall a wing at zero g.
@aaronhammond7297
@aaronhammond7297 Год назад
People use 'stall speed' because its a number they can see on a gauge in the cockpit, but whats the indicator for angle of attack? Its not pitch or attitude. (Hint, the answer is the stick position)
@pedropinho573
@pedropinho573 Год назад
@@aaronhammond7297 speed is a good proxy for AoA. Stick position is true, but is not intuitive. An easier way is to understand that speed is energy, and if you have low energy it is easier to stall the wing. That keeps people out of trouble.
@pedropinho573
@pedropinho573 Год назад
@@aaronhammond7297 however I have read your other responses and completely agree with you on the reasons for the stall. 👍
@Jet-Pack
@Jet-Pack Год назад
@@aaronhammond7297 Yes, the position of the stick, but there are actual angle of attack indicators on the market as well. The stall warning is also an angle of attack indicator, though a very crude one at best
@jwj500
@jwj500 3 месяца назад
I've never flown but this makes perfect sense.
@alk672
@alk672 Год назад
I've always felt that a steep turn (the ACS maneuver) is a terrible influence on private pilots. It gives them an idea that the best way out of a tricky situation is to bank a lot and pull hard. Then we wonder why so many people die trying to turn their airplanes around. In reality, the best way out of almost any situation where you need to turn around is to bank and accept the altitude loss by not pulling. If you don't pull - not much can happen to you. This video demonstrates that point very well, thank you.
@peterellison2220
@peterellison2220 Год назад
Agreed, danger comes with the hand creeping back the control stick and pulling
@triboarder06
@triboarder06 Год назад
agree... as long as you have the altitude under you to do it....
@GA-in4mw
@GA-in4mw Год назад
My ground school instructor said years ago "we teach you bad habit by letting you stall the airplane, but I am asking you, once you get your pilot license, forget what we teach you to stall the airplane"
@pto200
@pto200 Год назад
I like your videos, they're well presented and good narration. I'm learning a lot. Thank you.
@dcxplant
@dcxplant Год назад
Descending turn stalls fully configured for landing should be practiced regularly.
@musoseven8218
@musoseven8218 Год назад
Excellent advice, beautifully explained too.
@zombieapocalipse2020
@zombieapocalipse2020 Год назад
Amazing advice. Love your videos!
@JabariHunt
@JabariHunt 3 месяца назад
Excellent video! Thank you!!!
@JackIanLin
@JackIanLin Год назад
When I was learning Basic Fighter Maneuvers for a in an old (late 90s) WW2 combat sim, i remember trying to read flight envelope charts that IAS requirements for certain amount of g’s, which was important to manage your turn rate and radius. In a way that introduced me to energy management, and in the plane had only two ways to keep the airspeed up in a maneuver: throttle up or descend. I still think about this all the time in civilian flight and sim.
@bitianx
@bitianx 11 месяцев назад
Brilliant explanation and thank you for this video
@monocogenit1
@monocogenit1 Год назад
great video and excellent topic to discuss.
@aaronhammond7297
@aaronhammond7297 Год назад
One more clarification: Instead of thinking about stall 'speeds' think about stall 'stick position' Stalls occur at a critical angle of attack - angle of attack is controlled by the stick/yoke position -> the stick position controls stall. You can remain unstalled in any aircraft even with the nose *high* and *low* airspeed, so long as you are not pulling the stick back past the stall stick position. This video hints at that, saying to lower the nose, which is akin to saying push the stick forward of the stall stick position, but any aerobatic pilot knows that you can stall even with 120kts and pointing directly at the ground - the stick position determines stall. I think this is an important video, I would have made it differently, but its closer to the truth. I tried to explain this in the mentour pilot discord, only to have 30 people gang up on me to tell me that 'they'll use the stall speeds that have kept people out of the dirt for the last 100 years', however, as you said in the video 'each year loss of control is cited as the number one cause of GA accidents'. Clearly its important to understand the true cause of stalls, and how to prevent it.
@PaulCrooks
@PaulCrooks 9 месяцев назад
Thanks again.. You are a blessing
@ibrahimabdulaziz7818
@ibrahimabdulaziz7818 Год назад
Amazing video and knowledge sir and am doing my A320 type rating soon
@FlywithMagnar
@FlywithMagnar Год назад
Bravo! You have a new subscriber!
@nea273
@nea273 Год назад
Excellent!
@leandrahill
@leandrahill 4 месяца назад
Great video! I want to make one comment...hopefully useful. The maneuver @3:10 performed at only 1,300 feet AGL??? Not much margin for error. I get that you weren't 'planning' on stall/spin (In fact demonstrating that it would not occur) but just in case something unexpected would happen...that's cutting a recovery very close. As student pilot, I was taught that 1,500 AGL as a minimum starting altitude for steep turn maneuvers is prudent. I add this comment for any student pilots watching this.
@CascadiaAviation
@CascadiaAviation Год назад
Every airplane has a built-in angle of attack indicator… it’s called the YOKE
@charlenekylebeatty
@charlenekylebeatty Год назад
Excellent! So we’ll stated
@Butlerfamily623
@Butlerfamily623 Год назад
Because you can’t stall if you don’t pull. It’s important to have that down deep in your head and your muscle memory.
@jaywung7616
@jaywung7616 Месяц назад
Pedantic alert! KEEPING the nose low does not unload the wing. If the nose is down 10 degrees with the wings level, the wings are loaded at exactly 1G, by definition. It's the DROPPING of the nose that unloads the wing. While the nose is dropping, you are at less than 1G, but once you hold the nose at any constant angle, you're back at 1G. In steeper climbs and dives, the pilot will feel a change in G's as the plane accelerates and decelerates, but that has nothing to do with G's in the plane of the wings. So if you want to unload the wing, let the nose continue to drop. Obviously, this is only useful for so long until you turn into a lawn dart :)
@baviation1631
@baviation1631 Год назад
Saving lives
@philiptong4978
@philiptong4978 Год назад
how does the load factor gauge measure? by wing flex displacement? or some kind of accelerometer and preset weight calculation?
@user-uc9ij5ub1q
@user-uc9ij5ub1q 2 месяца назад
I need a video on ' straight in landing
@lyntonblair9016
@lyntonblair9016 Год назад
correct me if i'm wrong ( I'm not a pilot). when banked at 90 degrees there can be no vertical lift from the wings, so pulling back on the stick will not hold altitude. But it will load the wings to go in a circle, slowing the plane at the same time. Meanwhile, the plane is falling due to no vertical lift. I suppose that at some point the forward speed could drop to the point that its not possible to recover - unless the plane is pointed towards the ground (left or right stick depending on which wing is lower ?). If in a flat spin ( and I don't know how this develops), I suppose there is not enough wind over the control surfaces to change anything?
@XPLAlN
@XPLAlN Год назад
In military flying training, aeros and spin recovery are introduced very early - before even going solo according to the syllabus I followed. More to the point, we did groundschool and passed our theory tests before starting in the airplane so nobody should have got flying with such a misconception, although it would not surprise if a few did.
@mbo9156
@mbo9156 Год назад
Good day Could you please make videos about Communication what to say and what to expect because there’s no such a content on YT
@petethecatable
@petethecatable Год назад
Really good advice. Every pilot should do spins with an instructor and practice them--they should be required for PPL and maybe in complex aircraft as they are for commercial. Also, I think practicing slips (without flaps--keep the nose down) is also great practice in an overshoot situation. We do this in taildraggers and it can be done with most GA aircraft (read the POH) . Seems much safer than trying to bank back into alignment on an overshoot. Not sure why this is not taught. 😂. Seems like it would save lives.
@kenkoh1724
@kenkoh1724 Год назад
I always shallow bank in the pattern with tiny extra speed
@mdsx01
@mdsx01 Год назад
Going to ask my CFI to demonstrate a spin next time we go up.
@flightinsight9111
@flightinsight9111 Год назад
Make sure they've done it before and are comfortable, that the aircraft is able to do it, you're in the utility category and the owner/flight school is ok with it, and that you do it on a calm day at least 5000 AGL!
@adrianotravis6833
@adrianotravis6833 Год назад
You can still do 60° steep turns guys and not stall if you use adequate power.
@chipcity3016
@chipcity3016 7 месяцев назад
I'm the luckiest pilot on earth, why? Because I was trained by an experienced ag pilot who shifted my learning towards understanding the relevance of the stick /yoke AOA and stall stick position. Since then, when flying slowly or manoeuvring hard i rarely concern myself with anything other than where is my stick in relation to the stall stick position, which never moves regardless of airspeed, bank angle, skidding , load, none of which alter the stall stick position. It's that simple.
@txkflier
@txkflier Год назад
Ok, the plane won’t stall in a 90 degree bank if you don’t pull on the elevator, but your passengers are going to kill you for scaring the crap out of them. If you don’t pull on the elevator in a steep bank, the plane will simply lose altitude and not turn, so why would you do that? Why not keep the bank angle reasonable and just say “Unload the wing by not pulling too hard on the elevator.”? I don’t see the point of making this video.
@Dub636
@Dub636 Год назад
It’s an illustration. He’s not saying to bank 90 degrees. He’s saying the increase in load factor is due to trying to maintain altitude in a banked turn. There are times such as a traffic pattern when you want to lose altitude so you can bank harder at times even with lower airspeed and not risk excessive load factor and high stall speed if you are losing altitude through out said bank
@txkflier
@txkflier Год назад
@@Dub636 It’s a poor illustration and can actually be considered an aerobatic maneuver. Why couldn’t he just say to unload the wing and it won’t stall or use DMMS and a reasonable bank angle?
Далее
Avoiding Stall and Spin Accidents
27:51
Просмотров 438 тыс.
How I Stalled on The Base Turn (And Got Away With It)
10:04
CFI Ground School // Stalls & Spins
12:35
Просмотров 21 тыс.
Oroville Stall/Spin Crash 2 June 2022
19:40
Просмотров 416 тыс.
Spin Awareness, Entry, and Recovery
7:06
Просмотров 5 тыс.
Vmc or Die
14:58
Просмотров 25 тыс.