Тёмный

Ibn Arabi - Negative Theology 

Perennial Wisdom
Подписаться 4,2 тыс.
Просмотров 3,1 тыс.
50% 1

Ibn Arabi as one the most controversial Sufis who is also well-known because of the notion of wahdat al-wujud (the Unity of Being) puts forward his original thought of negative theology. Ibn Arabi always warns, in many of his books, that God (or al-Haqq in his own term), on one hand, is always transcendent, and no one knows God except God.
Please support Perennial Wisdom's endeavour to increase Islamic literacy through educational content on RU-vid. Your support does make the channel keep alive.
Paypal: paypal.me/Angg...
On this video, I endeavour to re-present the notion of Ibn Arabi's apophatic in the history of Islamic philosophy and of Sufism, since many Muslims incorrectly consider Ibn Arabi kufr or a heretic or polytheist only by reason of their assumption concerning the notion of wahdat al-wujud ascribed to Ibn Arabi. This video helps clarify many misunderstandings in order to lie wrong accusation at the proper place. God according to Ibn Arabi is totally negative, or full of negativity (tanzih).
If you are interested in Islamic philosophy and Sufism, please subscribe this channel. You can follow me on my Instagram / angga_arifka for private conversation.
References:
A. E. Afifi, The Mystical Philosophy of Muhyiddin Ibn ‘Arabi (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1939).
A. E. Afifi, “Ibn Arabi”, in M. M. Sharif (ed.), A History of Muslim Philosophy, vol. 1 (Wiesbaden, 1963).
Binyamin Abrahamov, Ibn Arabi’s Fusus al-Hikam: An Annotated Translation of the Bezels of Wisdom (London: Routledge, 2015).
Ibn Arabi, The Bezels of Wisdom, trans. R. W. J. Austin (New York: Paulist, 1980).
Muhammad al-Fayyadl, Negative Theology of Ibn 'Arabi: The Critiques of the Divine Metaphysics (Yogyakarta: LKiS, 2012).
Sachiko Murata, The Tao of Islam: A Sourcebook of Gender Relationships in Islamic Thought (New York: SUNY Press, 1992).
Toshihiko Izutsu, Sufism and Taoism: A Comparative Study of Key Philosophical Concept (California: University of California Press, 1993).
William C. Chittick, The Sufi Path of Knowledge: Ibn al-Arabi’s Metaphysics of Imagination (New York: SUNY Press, 1989).
William C. Chittick, “Ibn Arabi”, in Seyyed Hossein Nasr and Oliver Leaman (eds.), History of Islamic Philosophy (London & New York: Routledge, 1996).
#IbnArabi #sufism #islamicphilosophy
Note:
ibn arabi, ibnu al arabi, ibnu arabi, ibnul arabi, ibn arabi english, ibn arabi controversy, ibn arabi and the unity of being, unity of being, wahdat al wujud, god ibn arabi, ibn arabi books, fusus al hikam ibn arabi, fusus al hikam, futuhat al makkiyyah, futuhat al makkiyah

Опубликовано:

 

10 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 55   
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
This small channel is NOT monetised, so all ads suddenly appearing aren't for me, but for RU-vid itself. Please support Perennial Wisdom's endeavour to increase Islamic literacy through educational content on RU-vid. Your monetary support does make the channel and the creator keep alive. Paypal: paypal.me/AnggaArifka?country.x=ID&locale.x=en_US Patreon: patreon.com/PerennialWisdom
@VithorCabral
@VithorCabral Год назад
St. Paul says in his epistle "All that we see, we see as in a mirror". Everything that man can understand about "divinity" is subordinated to the level of the similar, like the contemplation of a mirror. "...There will be a day that we will see face to face"
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom Год назад
Thank you for the sharing.
@johangoormans995
@johangoormans995 2 года назад
Keep making videos my brother. Alhamdulilah for everything ❤️💚🌹may Allah swt reward you with lots of Baraka ✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨🤲Amin
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Yes, I do. Many thanks :)
@LennerM123
@LennerM123 Год назад
Bro this is such an enriching channel. Ibn Arabi's philosophy usually went right over my head.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom Год назад
Thank you so much.
@bash936
@bash936 9 месяцев назад
How you are able to describe like this Stupendous effort Masha Allah God bless you
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 9 месяцев назад
Thank you!
@awakencitizen
@awakencitizen 2 года назад
Thank you Anna Arifka for your excellent channel. I loved all of your videos on Ibn Arabi.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
My pleasure :)
@zakyzayn5361
@zakyzayn5361 2 года назад
Great video unfortunately I was not able to understand what Ibn Arabi is saying in absolute sense
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Which part are you not able to understand? I'll try to help you understand it.
@LaurenBerns
@LaurenBerns 4 месяца назад
Excellent work. Thank you.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 3 месяца назад
Yeah thanks!
@bash936
@bash936 11 месяцев назад
Superb brother How you can elaborate this much
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 11 месяцев назад
Thanks very much for your appreciation.
@vital-nature
@vital-nature Год назад
موفق بإذن الله
@beingisthebestjoy
@beingisthebestjoy 2 года назад
Awesome video
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Many thanks :)
@applebuttertoast
@applebuttertoast 2 года назад
Buku terjemahan Sufi Path og Knowledge yang bahasa indonesia bagus gak ya mas terjemahannya?
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Seingatku dulu pernah baca lumayan. Kalau mau yang terjemahan lebih bagus lagi coba buku "Sufisme: Samudra Makrifat Ibn Arabi" karya Toshihiko Izutsu terjemahan Mizan.
@applebuttertoast
@applebuttertoast 2 года назад
@@PerennialWisdom wah ini aku udah punya! Tapi belum pernah baca. Terima kasih mas angga
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
@@applebuttertoast Iya sama-sama. Apakah kita kenal secara personal? :D
@tenteraeducation6578
@tenteraeducation6578 2 года назад
God has a quality. Its quality is unknown. Unknown in the sense that - Its just that if you live for 10 million light years, you will still feel thirsty after drinking. Pronounce of absence in absence of time is unable to be understood . Thati why God does not see with the eye or hears with the ear. Khanzan Makhfian is the well without a base. Example of his identity is given to some. Unfortunately, if the some tries to express or explain his experience, his reasoning is invalidated as he has and can never reach the base of the well. He can only self conclude that he has reached the base. Unless he is permitted to travel again in the unlimited, the last station will allow him to embark on a new mystic experience.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Thank you very much for having shared your insight!
@d96ju16
@d96ju16 2 года назад
what does determination refer to here as in “absolute in its determination”
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Do you mean "absolute" is God?
@d96ju16
@d96ju16 2 года назад
@@PerennialWisdom like you mentioned in the video, the word God doesnt refer to the absolute in its absoluteness, rather the absolute in its determination. What is meant by determination here?
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Determination pertains to God's relations. It is undeniable the existence of God must be defined by the existence of creation. Without the latter, the former is meaningless. God is also determined by the knowledge of God on one hand, and God Himself exists in His self-determination, for if He is absolute in His absoluteness, He is impossible to know. Self-determination for God is necessary in order to be known by others. And God as the Absolute in His absoluteness (even we cannot call 'it' God) is beyond any relation and qualification and He is the unconditional transcendence. On such a mysterious plane, actually we cannot say anything. Hence The Absolute Mystery manifests Himself on the second plane where we have been able to talk about Him. It's God (the Absolute) in His determination.
@syedzaidi718
@syedzaidi718 2 года назад
This has some serious problems in it. Ibn ‘Arabī was not the first person to put forth the term "wahdat al-wujud" (the Unity of Being). It was Ibn Sab‘īn. Ibn ‘Arabī does not even use the term.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Thank you :) Yes, I realise it. I'm now making video about it.
@esotericpilgrim548
@esotericpilgrim548 2 года назад
@@PerennialWisdom You are right 💯 but he Ibn Arabi himself never used that terminology but Ibn Sabin did. With lots of love 💕 from a Indian sufi student.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
@Esoteric Pilgrim I've made the video about it. You can check this ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-tmiAT6TMHQ0.html Thanks so much. Salam.
@amuthi1
@amuthi1 2 года назад
Seems like Ibn Arabi was familiar with the concept of Brahman. Therefore he must have been a philosophical sound thinker in contrast to sunni-mainstream-muslims.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Yep. Even if i'm totally not sure that Ibn Arabi really read such a matter, his thought sounds kind of the concept of Brahman.
@ultrasignificantfootnote3378
@ultrasignificantfootnote3378 2 года назад
"One denigrates the beliefs of others " The Quran denigrates the trinity . so Allah denigrates the beliefs of others.
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Pardon. What was your very point?
@ultrasignificantfootnote3378
@ultrasignificantfootnote3378 2 года назад
@@PerennialWisdom Religion is subjective , Christians ,Muslims ,Jews and Hindus perciece different Gods as the real one.They can all claim that their God is the real one.Is denigration of other beliefs something that should be done or not ?
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Denigrating other beliefs is ridiculous, because the very core all believers worship is the one.
@ultrasignificantfootnote3378
@ultrasignificantfootnote3378 2 года назад
@@PerennialWisdom But Quran and Muslims can denigrade the belief that Jesus is God or not ?
@PerennialWisdom
@PerennialWisdom 2 года назад
Just try to watch my other videos about transcendent unity of religions, on Ibn Arabi and Rumi playlists. Your comments were not hitting what this video meant.
Далее
Apophatic Theology | Dr  Tikhon Pino
14:47
Просмотров 8 тыс.
Ibn Arabi - Causality
15:56
Просмотров 2,2 тыс.
АХХАХАХАХАХАХАХАХ
00:16
Просмотров 170 тыс.
Talismanic Magic in the Islamicate World
18:35
Просмотров 392 тыс.
Ibn Arabi - The Substance of Everything
22:40
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.
Ibn Arabi - The Self-Manifestation of God (Tajalli)
18:13
Wittgenstein's Games by A. C. Grayling
1:01:26
Просмотров 54 тыс.
Ibn Arabi - Sainthood
16:54
Просмотров 565
Ibn Arabi - Imagination [Part 1]
22:57
Просмотров 18 тыс.