"If Celtic go trophyless, does Rodgers get the sack?" - The Patreon Mailbag 

"Bring in a good manager and hope everything falls in to place, it doesn't work like that" - Well sometimes it does work like that, Ange Postecoglu being a prime example. The issue is, what happens when that manager leaves? There is a high probability that it will all fall apart very quickly

Re Mikey Johnston Could be various reasons as to why he's doing well at WBA - He's not under as much pressure to perform from the fans or even from himself. He's not a boyhood WBA fan and so won't feel that added burden that goes with playing for the club that you also support. All the off field shite that goes with playing with Celtic will be reduced dramatically at WBA. For example Won't be many friends & family texting him for tickets to the Preston game or whatever... - WBA will very rarely face teams who "park the bus" and double up on their wingers etc... So more space for MJ to play in and more 1 v 1 situations with defenders There's also the fresh start factor that can do a person good in any walk of life

On Ange great points.. Ange was a one off miracle type...picked us up from the deck n delivered 5 trophies ....Big Up......Hail Hail

The issue with Celtic and what happens goes on deeper than the manager.

I keep hearing about celtics injury problems but we've have had to deal with even worse injury problems including right now with half our team out injured. We've also had to deal with the micheal beale fiasco. Celtic and rogers have zero excuses if they don't win the league, tbh all things considered, it will be embarrassing if you don't. If you can't beat an injury ravaged/micheal beale nuked rangers to the title, you never win.

3 God fearing Tim malloys keeping it real with the realest questions 🍀

We have been really unlucky with injuries this season. Rogers isn't the problem. The board are. No excuse for us having such a shite Jan window when we are rolling in Dosh to the extent we are.

My gut feeling if we escape Ibrox without a defeat we will win the league, a defeat will put us realistically 5 points behind and I don’t see us being able to recover this, great show as always guys HH

The problem with winning the league is,will the board bk Rodgers,a very strange situation,can just see Lawell patting himself on the bk,what a weird season

Hey Stephen, that “it’s just a ballsack trimmer” comment nearly had me choking on my Horlicks. 😂😂. Fair play 👌

Top mailbag :)

If he wins the double will doubters get off his back?

I think Rodgers should go even if we DO win the league and/or the cup. If we win either of those, it’s not because we’ve been playing well, but because we’ll get lucky. Celtic are shocking under Rodgers and his “style” of football is atrocious to watch. But I also think “The Board” should go, specifically Lawwell and Nicholson, but others, too. I’m at the stage where getting those old galoots out of Celtic is my priority as a Celtic fan-not titles, trophies or Europe, but a complete overhaul of how Celtic is run and by whom.

Regarding Idah vs Kyogo I think it depends on what kind of team were facing. Kyogo has mostly been struggling this season when hes up against 10 men behind the ball who are all a head taller and Idah has been amazing at breaking through that kind of defence. I would love to see some kind of triop at the top w Kyogo Idah and Maeda being played.

Weve been 3-4 players away from having a couple great sides in last 15 year and every time tk steps backwards..insted of paying 4-6 million on quality always try to mk money instead of progress on tbe grass ..sick of it and think of do it another year fans have to do something to remove board

For the blown point advantage yes the responsibility goes to Rodgers, quick to be praised, the players have been woeful most of the season though. Either way players need moved on if there's a new manager or not.

Spot on Jamie, top manager but best players unavailable so keep Brendan next season ☘️

Hail Hail hoops troops super show lads as always

Ange played Ralston and Bernabei at times and strolled it up here. BR had a big points advantage in the league and blew it. The buck stops with him. If we finish trophy-less he has to go.

Did Jamie get a sweet new Jacket?!

In relation to what you guys said about as a fan base are we too quick to judge . My opinion is yes far too quick to rush to judgement

He at very minimum wins the cup and I think we get a double but if not I still think Rodger’s stays but if not we get Keane.i know that’s a lot of guesses though 😂😂

for me Rodgers gets another season. let the manager pick 4 players at £6m instead of 10 or 11 players and we will see the difference. quality players over quantity

Rockie baffles me.. not had a run in team and spent fair bit on him .not played alongside ccv enough to see what hes like..surely cant be that bad

Yes of course he should!

If this was a good rangers team and they were to end up with in the high 90s or 100 points and were convincingly the better team then no, he shouldn't go but in reality to throw away the points we have done against lower level teams at home and we win nothing then yes, no coming back from that

Aaah toothpaste, the best condiment

I am turning of all social media if Rangers win the treble 😢

For Jamie to say br should stay on if they don’t win any trophies , against a the worst competition in Scotland for 30 years is a disgrace and part of the problem with our fan base willing to accept mediocrity, we are at the end of the season and his decion making has been shocking , and we have next to no completion even the huns are dog 💩 , who ever wins the league will be worst winner for decades but to keep somebody that have regressed a full team , pop shotted fans , embarrassed in europe , performances have been woeful , terrible take

Yir man Jamie’s take on rodgers is incredible by the way! A guy on 3 million a year to manage in the SPL, that has pissed away an 8 point lead that was gifted to him! But it’s harsh sacking him if we watch that lot win a treble 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆 any other diddy manager in this league could have us finish 2nd and out of both cups ffs! Fuck me we could literally bring them all in at the same time and still have change from Rodgers wages! And stop this injuries and poor players pish tae! The Huns manager has inherited some amount of dross and has major injuries to contend with! A guy on 3 million a season to manage in Scotland should not lose every trophy available!! And especially after having been gifted a massive lead in the league! Any other manager who wasn’t called Rodgers would be hounded!

Kyogo and scales strikers in a 4 4 2

Will we sake the board

And the rogers debate ..i would get new manager in even if win leauge..dont like his tactics and dont want to sit through another season tbh its boring and there always seems to be a lot of politics going on when hes in charge ...even going bk to demble🙄

Jamie talking absolute shite about data driven recruitment ffs “football has caught up” well apparently not Celtic…

HH BHOYS BOTH OF THEM IDAH BIGGER STRONGER FOR ME KYOGO WILL SCORE :IDAH ONLY THING ABOUT IDAH IS DON'T WANT HIM TO GET INVOLVED WITH SEVCO PLAYERS WHO IS THE HARDEST THAT'S NOT WHAT'S IT'S ALL ABOUT GOALS FOR US HH KTF

HH OH the Forgotten man he would be dangerous oh that is hh ktf

Rodgers should be shown the door no matter what happens. A big mistake bringing him back in the first place. There’s a stink around the place on and off the pitch and when two of your best players O’Reilly and Kyogo have regressed it’s plain to see BR is an over rated manager. On the fan base, it’s hard when a chunk of your fans (GB) are a highly politicised protest group with a tiny interest on what goes on on the pitch. That inevitably spreads throughout the clubs fans - hence the cynicism and over the top criticism when things go slightly tits up.

We cant imagine not winning anything this season.....it would be a total disaster

HH Jamie rubbish what u said no disrespect another season before we get BR OUT A LOT OF MONEY WEASTED ON Players who are not good after all only a game of football our players win trebles. it's BR's job to get players motivated. Listen fed up hearing about Celtic were after big name TALK IS CHEAP IIF they wanted these guys in they would be in all talk with no ACTION HH KTF

brendan rodgers has done a great job considering it's a rigged title that crawford allan has already awarded to the rangers

HH BHOYS HOW LONG FOR US TO WAKE UP BR HAS FAILED MOANING BLAMING PLAYERS WHEN BR SUPPOSE TO BE A GREAT MAN MANAGER NOT TRUE, HE SHOULD BE OFF A LOT SOONER NO EXCITEMENT IN THE TEAM HH KTF

Tell me yous are joking 😬 Taylor is mince 😵‍💫 He can’t win a header 🤷‍♂️ causes us to loss goals almost every match 🤔 sometimes can’t even play a ball down the wing and is injury prone 🤯 he is at best a back up for me. Do yous 3 really think we should be starting a 3rd champions league campaign with Taylor at rb 🤔 when we have plenty of money to go buy a decent starter in that position? Taylor is about the same size an width of one of AJ legs lol Aj is built to play our game an although he isn’t great in the air he stops crosses, gets assists, battles for the team, shows for the ball and he inverts/ over laps all game 🤔 I’m thinking this episode has an element of invasion of the body snatchers because I’m pretty sure I’ve heard all of you berate Taylor an rightfully lol every Celtic fan for a good while now has said we need a LB what’s all of a sudden changed now with yous has Taylor or big Pete paid for good publicity 😮🤣

First

Disagree our team is away better than The Rangers ....issue is our quality players were injured for long spells and new players in werent good enough to go straight in and win!!

Why isnt your pod on this week bhoys ?