@@cosmic.kiwi.2140 But Demons also tell the truth (even if it's not wholly) because they have access to the memory of their vessel and especially when that truth is hurtful enough to play mind games with. Demons aside, I do not see any point in Lisa lying if she wanted Dean to stay anyways and saying that Ben is his son would have given him a reason to stay but she did not say it because it is not the truth; the first time they met in the show after Lisa had Ben, Dean was the one who did not want to stay whilst Lisa wanted him to. I think the show poked around the possibility of Ben being Dean's son to make him leaving them after erasing their memories more impactful. I would not say it is for a fact that he is not their father because I don't think the showmakers confirmed it, but mostly everything suggests that Dean is not his father.
Maybe he could have had a career in movies. It's too late now. Once Supernatural ends next year, I'm going to have trouble relating to him as any other character.
@@mundobostal8530 I would say he was tormented but accepted his fate and made the most of it especially as the show went on. He was funny in the beginning seasons but by the end he slowly died inside.
Dean really loved Lisa!during a year he was with no other women and also during season 6!but she was far from perfect match and his appearance nearly ruined her life so he had to leave her with no memories!that's what a hero does!to not cause someone he loves pain even it means he had to handle it!
Lisa and Ben was the best thing to happen Dean. Too bad he could never go back and lived with them. This probably most heart breaking moment that I have seen for him.
Taylor T The reason why he did it is because he still hunter. As long has he hunter and with them.. He going put them in danger with any monster, angel or demon. I mean to be honest with you this was the best situation for them.
Hello, guy from the future here lol jk So, now that the series is almost over, I do hope they give Dean the opportunity to go back to Lisa and Ben. We'll see what happens, but I sure hope they do.
The fact that Lisa and Ben are literally never mentioned, brought up or anything after this always kills me. Like Sam never used Ben and Lisa as an argument for when he didn’t look for Dean while he was in purgatory. They never show anything of them again not memories not pictures. Dean may have wiped their memories but not his. And the only thing he has left of them now is the pain of losing them
He brought Lisa up just once after this. In 9x13 The Purge, he mentions "You're not the only person who's dated someone bendy" (because dean tells Sam "bendiest weekend of my life" about Lisa.) Which makes sense for their strain of relationship at that time
This episode makes me choke up every time I’ve seen it. Lisa and Ben were Dean’s one and only way out of hunting and his true happiness, he loved both of them deeply. In the end he knew it was for the best that they not remember him so they couldn’t be used or hurt again, but the pain was killing him knowing he would never see either of them again.
I absolutely loved Dean, Lisa and Ben together - seeing them as a family and their relationship is one of my favourite Supernatural highlights! This scene was so sad but so incredible that Dean cared for them so much - that's true love! 😢💖
There was a fan theory that Misha Collins had cleared up that basically said "what if Ben comes back and says that he remembers Dean and that he is Dean's legitimate child. Then he tells Dean that he has become a hunter and his mom is in danger" or something like that. it's in a video called "castiel answers crazy fan theories" I think
I read a fanfiction about this scene and what happened after they drove away from the hospital. It was a long drive, but then Sam noticed Dean was crying (tears running down his cheeks) and he asked him to stop for a while. Dean parked the car by the road and walked out. Sam followed, they stood in front of the car and Dean couldnt stop crying, he was really broken. Then Sam finally dared to hug Dean and Dean didnt protest, he just hugged Sam back and let himself cry for a while. It loved the fanfiction but I cant find it again! It was really good.. And I kind of wishd that something like that happened on the show.
Aaarh it stills bother me so much that Dean didnt even let himself grieve! I just want to jump into the screen and hug him so badly. The fanficiton I wrote about over here wouldve been the perfect end of the episode.
Kyle Fancher What if that's why Cas isn't there now: because he's going around and making sure that all traces of Dean being connected to Lisa are eradicated
This is the only episode in the series that really broke my heart. It still does for the love I need to see them happy or see dean checking in on them even just from a distance
I always hoped that like even tho their memory of dean was gone, that maybe Ben still faintly remembered Deans mannerisms and lessons, and carried them through his life, so that way he still carried all the lessons of how to be a good man from a faint memory of a father he can’t remember
What got me was Sam couldn't understand where Dean was coming from. Sam you really thought Dean WANTED to take their memories?? He did it as a last resort to protect them from himself and his life because they mean EVERYTHING to him.
It was not the time for him to say these things, he was insensitive. Sam was not seeing how Dean was suffering from this decision, he was almost crying. How painful it was.
Not really. He understands Dean was trying to protect them. But he also doesn't want Dean to suffer or sacrifice for them, that's why he tried to change his mind.
@@amberxv4777 but he knows that as long dean is living he will always suffer because " when something bad happens he feels responsible for it " its just who he is
The metaphorical in this scene is just great and amazing. Been said that they are having a car crash and Dean said he "crashed" into her car, just like he "crashed" into her life in before the series, season 3 and in the end of season 5. He truly is sorry for everything that has happened to her and Ben ever since he entered their life. So heartbreaking moment.
the most heartbreaking thing about this is the fact that Dean will still always remember them, and live with knowing they don’t remember him. a couple of the only people who loved him out there no longer do because they don’t know him. his whole life has been dedicated to others - from his dad and brother to the world. this was up there with the most selfless things he’s ever done. sometimes I wish I had the option to erase memories, so I can imagine how he felt. in a happier reality, Cass reversed it and they got to live the life they wanted when it was safe to do so.
Dean already got over them sorry. In the finale, both wasn't even mentioned by Dean. It seems like Dean got in touch with the Harvelles more. Given the first scene in heaven where Dean and Bobby met again. They were sitting outside of the Harvelle's roadhouse.
Part of me wishes Dean could have gone back to Ben and Lisa again instead of what we got for the series finale. Did anyone ever think of the aftermath what it means to have all of your friends and family know that you're in the ground 6' under. To have people that were close to them mourn them?
watching through the whole series again but with my mom this time and damn, i completely forgot about this scene... definitely had an onion under my eye for this one.
This is the saddest scene he loves her why he did what he did & the fact tha sam didn't get it made it harder which is why he threatened to break his nose
I always imagined them getting back home and smells sulfur, seeing the wreck the demons left behind and then Ben starting to put pieces together and ends up getting obsessed with hunting the demons and happens to cross paths with Dean again in the future while hunting but not knowing who he is :(
the next is the last season of supernatural and I hope dean and sam find their life partners who will love them and live a normal and happy life together
I came up with a story in my head where Lisa and Ben remember Dean, but only in dreams. Then, Lisa and Dean reunite through a series of events, and Lisa recognizes Dean from her dreams, and Ben tells her they have been having the same dreams. In the end Lisa and Ben realize that it wasn't just dreams, but it really happened. I LOVE Lisa and Ben and wish they would have came back in one of the last seasons because the times spent with them were some of the best times of Dean's life.
Looking back, Sam clearly didn't realize exactly how bad this hurt dean. And I think that's why she stopped. Because he could see in his eyes that Dean was in pain. This hurt dean more than anything. Because he would have given anything to be with them but he couldn't.
Yes it's a sad scene, yes the perfect acting tugs at the heart strings. But the true saddest part? It takes practice to stifle your urge to cry to that extent, to barely a voice crack. It takes more practice than everything we've seen Dean do, and with who he's close to? to affect him enough to cry? Three people. Sam. Bobby. John. Dean is the epitome of a broken man, so broken he doesn't even know it or show it. Dean deserves so much more. Now that the sad little rant is over, a little fun fact, to try and lift some spirirts (poor wording there). Heart strings do actually exist. They're the reason your heart beats, they open and close the valves of your heart.
Welcome to Supernatural Today in crying with the Winchesters we have the worst pain for Dean and Sam knows it.. I swear I was fine couple seconds ago😭😭 Jensen’s Fudging acting skills man😍😭
I would have loved if in the episode 14x10 Dean would be with Lisa, Ben and their second little child instead of that Bar with Pamela. And then Sam and Cas would enter his mind and it hurts them to take his family away from him because they know he is happy with them and it's all he ever wanted.
I really want Ben to come back as a hunter, like when Lisa and ben went back home after their memories where erased and found all of the pictures of dean and the neighbors asking about him, Ben started to look for dean out of curiosity wanting to remember who dean was and got into hunting along the way (maybe because some monsters knew who he was looking for and assumed ben was already a hunter and he gets saved by another hunter and told that this was dean's job) and as he hunts he's looking for dean you know what I mean
