Тёмный

Ilford FP4+ vs Kentmere 100: which is the better black and white film stock? 

Mark McMahon
Подписаться 1,8 тыс.
Просмотров 10 тыс.
50% 1

In which I visit Bunbury, Western Australia, for some coastline photography and very unscientifically pit two black and white films against each other in a duel to the death. Who will be victorious - the faithful classic that is Ilford FP4+ or its budget cousin, Kentmere 100?
Camera: Nikon N2020
Lenses: Sigma Super Wide II 24mm F/2.8; Nikon 50mm F/1.8 AF D; Nikon 28-85mm F3.5-4.5 AF.
Film: Ilford FP4+; Kentmere 100

Опубликовано:

 

21 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 54   
@AlexMakuch
@AlexMakuch Год назад
Thanks for the comparison! And lovely shots/drone footage :)
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Thanks, Alex!
@JFredick
@JFredick Год назад
Awesome video and great sarcasm to boot. I want to try Kentmere 100 in 120 format. Thank you for your refreshing insight.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Thanks, glad you found it useful!
@isabelcorazon3723
@isabelcorazon3723 2 года назад
Informative, cheeky, fun and well produced! More please :)
@devroombagchus7460
@devroombagchus7460 Год назад
Thanks! I have learned a lot. Also thanks for the wonderful images. One note. A trap I frequently fall into is that “which is the better…, cannot be answered. It should be followed by “for…”. Budget and subject play an important role. Especially when prices of film keep going up. Thanks to you, I know that probably Kentmere is the “better” film, now that I have retired.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Good point. What's better for one circumstance isn't true for another!
@mikhaillinberg9568
@mikhaillinberg9568 Год назад
Thanks for the review. It’s a pity that the same shots were not taken on different films. To make the comparison clearer. I would also like to add Delta 100 and Fomapan 200 here.👍
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Might have to do a follow-up review, though I've had a few bad experiences with Foma film and tend to leave that one alone/
@adamgabriel730
@adamgabriel730 2 года назад
Great videos!
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand 2 года назад
Thanks, Adam!
@marknicholson5293
@marknicholson5293 Год назад
Good to know. Thanks
@devroombagchus7460
@devroombagchus7460 Год назад
Thanks a lot. I use HP5, but I’ll try Kentmere 400. Why do you add “stock” after film. For me, it means that you have loads of it.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
I wish! Using 'stock' in terms of film that is readily available for sale :)
@Yosser70
@Yosser70 Год назад
“Film stock” is a term picked up from movie making, which just refers to what film is being used. It doesn’t really have anything to do with photography film but guess it means the same thing.
@CJBradley
@CJBradley 2 месяца назад
I'm waiting for some K100x36 to arrive in the post, it seemed like a good alternative to more expensive B&W films out there at £19.50 for a three pack and already I'm encouraged watching your video. Thank's / Subbded.!
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand 2 месяца назад
These days I only ever bother with FP4 if I can get it for the same price as K100.
@iainmc9859
@iainmc9859 Год назад
Okay, its running up to Christmas in Scotland, leaden skies, slushy ground with only my cat for company. You made me laugh, so I subscribed. I reckon I can't tell the difference between the two films as development and real world lighting conditions tend to negate out any other variables. I'm peed off because a photoshoot tomorrow has just been cancelled because people don't like getting cold (I blame digital photography) so I've got no plans until Christmas Day. Say hello to my cousins in Sydney, the Maguires, if you bump into them 😉
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Sounds like it could be a great opportunity for some indoor still life photography. 35 degrees here in Perth todat (yes, a different Perth). If I find myself 4000km away, on the other side of the continent and bump into the McGuires, I'll definitely say hello!
@FJWoods007
@FJWoods007 Год назад
Very nice video. Just ordered five boxes of Kentmere 100 in 120, and look forward to seeing how that holds up against Tri-X, as I'm done with Foma as well.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
I've hard some people say Foma is ok if you overexpose it but that doesn't help with some of the flaws and inconsistencies in the emulsion. I haven't used Tri-X in years. I remember it was easier to get a punchier print in the darkroom but these days I love the slightly flatter profile of Kentmere - gives a lot of flexibility in scanning. And it's a LOT cheaper!
@lelandfitz1762
@lelandfitz1762 7 месяцев назад
@@patternsinsand Any opinion on Agfa APX 100? Just asking because it really is a lot cheaper than Ilford.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand 7 месяцев назад
@@lelandfitz1762It's a great film. I've heard it's actually the same as Kentmere 100 and Rollei RPX 100. I'm not sure how true that is but it definitely has similar tonality, grain and flexibility. Definitely a step up from Fomapan in my experience - good quality control and consistent results.
@lelandfitz1762
@lelandfitz1762 7 месяцев назад
@@patternsinsand Thank you for the info and your quick response!
@danienelphoto
@danienelphoto 8 месяцев назад
Love FP4. I've never tried Kentmere, but I HATED Kentmere fibre based papers back in the days when I was still printing. It was flatter than a hunger striking prisoner's backside. I wouldn't mind giving a cheaper FP4 a go, though.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand 8 месяцев назад
Give the film a chance :) It stands up well and I have a roll of it in my bulk loader now.
@northof-62
@northof-62 Год назад
Just ordered 10 Kentmere 400s. Probably some more grains in them. Miss the Tri-X @200 ASA - Microdol-X combo.
@jbliborio
@jbliborio Год назад
I like Ilford FP4, it's one of my favorite but I'll try Kentmere.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
I'm sure you won't be disappointed. It has most of the benefits of FP4 - they just skimped a bit on the silver!
@WithCielo
@WithCielo Год назад
Thank you this was very helpful!
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
You're welcome. Happy new year!
@blazerbarrel2
@blazerbarrel2 Год назад
Fp4 for sure , doesn’t block up , white creamy skin tone if you want it , fine traditional grain , controllable gray scale !
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
FP4 is probably the most versatile, simply because it doesn't skimp on silver. I was positively surprised by Kentmere. All things being equal (cost) I'd still pick FP4 but I wouldn't be ashamed to run Kentmere through my camera for all but the most critical jobs!
@srdjanbasaric517
@srdjanbasaric517 Год назад
With this type of photography, you're always on the edge of knife. My recommendation is Agfapan 100 + Microdol x. The water for the developer must be ph7, the developer at 20 C. If you want more details, dilute the developer 1:4, then develop over 20 min. turn the dose gently 4 times every minute. I don't think that Microdol is made anymore, but there is a substitute for sure. Ilford's Perceptol, I don't know if it is still produced, is a bad substitute. If I make a mistake, I apologize in advance, all my knowledge is from more than 20 years ago.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Yes, I think Microdol is hard to find but I've seen Perceptol around and have heard it's great for fine grain development. Might have to compare it to Xtol some time!
@srdjanbasaric517
@srdjanbasaric517 Год назад
@@patternsinsand Try it, but don't dilute it. I tried and got nothing.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
@@srdjanbasaric517 Thanks for the advice. Obviously not a very forgiving developer!
@misterleary
@misterleary Год назад
Actually Agfapan 100 is nowadays Kentmere 100. Agfa doesn't produce films for years now. It's just the brand name.
@srdjanbasaric517
@srdjanbasaric517 Год назад
@@misterleary The only thing I know is that the entire Agfa line for the production of film and paper was bought by Cheks, that was almost 30 years ago. I don't know what happened next, I had a little break in photography. :)
@williamburkholder769
@williamburkholder769 Год назад
Very entertaining. Do you make silver prints, or do you scan your images with a scanner, or macro photograph them with a camera?
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Thanks, William. I have access to a film scanner which gives a great result. A bit slower than a flatbed or macro but macro photography is a bit fiddly to set up. I don't print enough, though I can print at work. That's just laziness.
@gavinjenkins899
@gavinjenkins899 8 месяцев назад
Although it would certainly be boring to do the whole video this way, I think you should still include an actual controlled example when doing head to heads. Surely you own two of at least some lens, like 2 nifty 50s or something, to slap on for one shot of the car before heading out to the real shoot or something, exactly the same.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand 8 месяцев назад
Recently got my hands on a second 50mm Nikon f/1.8 AFD that came with a camera body. Good idea!
@lesliewalters3896
@lesliewalters3896 Год назад
Yes ! Photograph loads of shit. I wish I had done this when I was twenty. Stuff that was commonplace then is worth gold now. Click it before you lose it !
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Thanks Leslie, I like to think I’m a consummate shit photographer
@50mmnikonainikkor55
@50mmnikonainikkor55 Год назад
Formapan 100 .Cheap and cheerful.
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
I've found foma to be a bit less reliable but any cheep and cheerful film is a blessing
@andyvan5692
@andyvan5692 Год назад
at 0:11 great joke, pun, whatever you call it; another one is: if you ate a dirty piece of chicken would it taste "fowl"?
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
You joke but I might end up using that!
@tazkforcealpha
@tazkforcealpha Год назад
But please, no more ass details comparisons
@YallaMoussa
@YallaMoussa Год назад
Great videos!
@patternsinsand
@patternsinsand Год назад
Thanks!
Далее
Is Film Expensive? What do you think? I say...
14:50
Просмотров 22 тыс.
Ребенок по калькуляции 😂
00:32
Шоколад приходит на Землю.
00:23
Просмотров 160 тыс.
Fp4 + vs Delta100: A Head-to-head Comparison
27:36
Просмотров 24 тыс.
Developing Your Film... Wrong!
27:52
Просмотров 111 тыс.
Cheapest film in the UK!
12:40
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.
Kentmere 120
13:23
Просмотров 114 тыс.
Kentmere 400 vs. HP5: DEEP DIVE film comparison!
29:14
Просмотров 2,4 тыс.
Ребенок по калькуляции 😂
00:32