If understanding Quranic Arabic is your goal then do not waste time with dialects. Start learning classical arabic or Fusha. The one source I can recommend is from Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan. Just search in youtube 'Dream Big by Bayyinahtv' Insha Allah you may learn from there for free.
@@Musa_Nilالسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته Akhi uns ist es nicht erlaubt inshaAllah nach einem dua zu sagen Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 6338, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2678
@@sarah..3000what does ikwahnis have to do with speaking amiyya? Fusha is only used in books and the news, outside of that literally no one speaks it Even if you studying from a sheikh In Arabic he’s going to revert back to amiyya when explaining the subject so learning a dialect is essential
@Clear4TheSincere Ameen Waiyyak JazakAllahu Khairan Akhi May Allah gather you and your beloved ones along with great companions on the Day of Judgment Ameen
@@ansma1877 I think you are a just a ignorant kid. In that case I take my dua back. May Allah not gather you with this puppet "scholars" of evil slaves of the allies of shaytan and dajjal and show you the truth and it's people.
@@ansma1877 You probably still a kid. The dua I made was not good I take it back. You don't want to be gathered with these "scholars" of evil puppets of the allies of shaytan and dajjal. May Allah show you the truth and it's people.
If you call this a scholar Ur probably only started praying few weeks or months ago and most likely was a failed gangster Allah swt never guides you to a fake scholar unless you are sick who will end in jahanam with his likes May Allah destroy him and his paymasters who r plotting on Islam and spreading falsehood
As a child, i was taught to speak one dialect. Everyone else id come across would speak another dialect. i was unable to keep up conversation and discouraged to keep speaking arabic and since i was born in a western country even the arabic dialect i learned to speak was gone in favor of ease of communication in english. I am trying to learn proper fusha arabic now but this is all just to say that if all the nations were to speak one proper arabic we would be in true solidarity.
It was an important goal for the English and the French to dilute the language and render it less potent, well, at the English colonialism. The French wanted to completely erase the language. Im not saying it's not our fault, but rather that language is so important, that they really cared and directed resources just to hurt it.
Honestly a balance is needed, study fusha to understand Quran and access religious books Study a dialect to speak to normal people in the Arab world. Outside of academic settings, no one speaks fusha, from my experience the only ones who speak fusha are non Arabs who are still learning the Arabic language. Imagine only knowing fusha but then you go to a class and the teacher is using amiyya to explain (which is very commonly) to teach the class. If you go to Yemen for example to study the deen and don’t speak amiyya, you won’t understand what the teacher is even saying, learning a dialect is very important
@@Dhaifaalmansurah This is just false. I can give you many examples where a classical word has a completely different meaning in colloquial Arabic For example the root word for Go in many dialects is روح If you only studied fusha you would think someone is talking about the soul while in everyday reality they’re talking about going to the shop…. Study fusha as a foundation, learn a dialect to be able to actually speak to people in the language
@@Dhaifaalmansurah What I said was false was your claim of only needing to understand root letters. It just doesn’t work like that I myself switch between MSA and amiyya but when it comes to conversational Arabic you’re really at the mercy of the person you’re speaking with. Most people will understand you, but you won’t understand them. If they choose to engage with you in fusha then that’s great, but if they speak amiyya and you only know fusha then good luck trying to understand them Brother I will give you a good example, Abu Taymiyyah went to study in Yemen. He knew fusha, he’s a student of knowledge but he couldn’t understand what the teachers were saying cause they were speaking amiyya, he was lost, then went to Egypt to study amiyya This was after he had been to Yemen and Saudi Arabia to seek knowledge. He still don’t know what they were saying cause he only knew how to speak fusha. The scholars themselves speak amiyya when teaching
May Allah preserve you sheikh, I’m a revert and I’m learning fusha, and my only concern is to understand the Quran and the Hadith books or the books of the scholars, but many people who speak dialects, don’t like that non Arabs speak fusha. That might be pressuring some to adapt to the dialects of the countries they go to.
You usually get laughed at if you go to an Arab country and try to speak Fusha. This is why non-arab speakers rather learn the local dialect to avoid mockery by the locals
@@yossefgamerr3813I agree to a certain extent. I wouldn’t say mocking but you will definitely get funny looks and unless someone has had an Islamic or secular education, they wouldn’t be comfortable responding in fusha. Learn fusha to understand Quran and access religious texts, learn amiyya to speak in daily life. This is a good balance
What he said is true. Just like how most people speak the American English, it is a dialect from foreign people. Americans are foreigners to England and this is not their mother language
I speak the lebanese dialect, which is close to fousha but also deviates a lot due to french being used in practically every sentence and words from aramaic and turkish. Despite this we learn fousha during school and alhamdoulilah we can all read and write with it for seeking knowledge and reading Coran. Personally it is important to have both, and I refuse to leave either one of them.
Yes I agree both are very important. Dialect should be used in normal day to day stuff but professionally I believe fusha should be used as it is formal and beautiful way of speaking. I speak Egyptian with natives but I also learnt fusha quite well so I use that when i need to.
@@obeybruhs inchaallah, cheikh wasioullah abbas, a salafi scholar who teaches in madinah has given a statement regarding him, that he belongs to the deobandi sect
@@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi I have heard several refutations of that person. I do not watch their content anymore. I stick to channels with straight aqeeda that adhere to Quran and Sunnah.
Sadly most Arab and Arabic teacher don't speak speak proper Arabic (fusha) , they speak their own dialect. They put off non arab to learn Arabic, no wonder many Muslim can't be bothered to learn Arabic. Unlike English language, whatever you learn, you will practise in conversation
The English language itself has numerous dialects, but the 'neutral' dialect used internationally is no doubt inspired by the Americans. In regards to speaking Arabic in Fusha, the best way is to find righteous Muslims who regularly speak Fusha Arabic and start from there. May Allah make it easy upon the beginner students of knowledge in this path.
The presence of Arabic dialects is natural, as the Arabic language is 1,400 years old, and had it not been for its connection to Islam and learning the Qur’an, it would have disappeared and Arabic dialects would have turned into local languages.... Whoever speaks English cannot understand an English text 100 years ago because their language changes and changes, while the Arabs understand a text that is 1,400 years old.. Yes, they do not use it in their daily lives, but they learn it in schools and use it in official matters
@@okflyaway99Because no Arab countries really practice arabic fusha except in universities. And when foreign student speak fusha in social settings while they.are studying there, all those Arabs will either dont understand or laugh at them. And now ask yourself O' Arab, the non-atab students caome to your countires from thousands of miles to seeks islamic knowledge with already strong fusha arabic but when arrived in Arabic countries, they are being laugh at by the Arab JUST BECAUSE they speak fusha.
It’s like speaking YOUR OWN language from 1400 years ago. You wouldn’t even be able to do that. Most people don’t. Go search up “Old English” that’s 1000 years old. It’s NOTHING compared to current modern english
@@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi reading Quran doesn’t mean you understand Quran even people who call themselves mufti and qazi or moulvi they are top jhahil who only wants to enjoy charity public donations and state government taxes exemption. They are responsible for sectarianism.
explanation to the simplest scheme of the Universe for humankind manusia di lahirkan di dalam diri mereka dengan 2 unsur. Air Mani yang hina dan Ruh. Air Mani yang hina ini datangnya dari Api. manakala Ruh datangnya dari sisi Allah. Air Mani - Syaitan Ruh - Malaikat. dan apabila tibanya kematian, masing masing Syaitan dan Malaikat akan kembali ke tempat asal mereka masing masing. membawa 'beban' yang mereka diami. maka di dalam The simplest explanation of the Universe for Mankind, ini Where would you like to be? salamun alaikum
Aren't the dialects natural, ancient in some respects and useful? I am not arguing just seriously considering. Didn't the ancient people of Arabia speak dialects; thus the Quran was revealed, recited and written containing elements of those dialects?
The quraan and sunnah are in fusha. The differences in dialects at the time are all from fusha. The dialects now are not. Meaning if you are a student of knowledge learning other than fusha arabic, you are holding your progress back
@@markward3981 ofcourse not. They are all rooted in fusha but have differences due to many factors. Mixing with different languages, simplification of the language for non arabs and languages naturally evolving through time. Take the english from 500 years ago and now and you will find great differences. Even now: in england say pants and people will understand underwear but in america it is the word for trousers etc.
@@Ibnmehmedit depends on your goals and on your environment . If your teacher is teaching in English then just learning fusha to understand Quran and access religious books will be enough Let’s say you are studying in an Arab country though, you will need amiyya to get through daily life, you will struggle with just fusha, also many teachers will even revert back to amiyya when teaching subjects so if you don’t understand amiyya you won’t understand what the teacher is even saying. Abu Taymiyyah had a similar experience when he went to Yemen to study
Not arab can speak good English or other language... similarly non arab naturally can't speak good Arabic but instead of wasting time on dialect try to understand empathy & love for that language the other have and trying to communicate in easiest possible way to come on same level of understanding..his efforts r more important not dielect..
Because no Arab countries really practice arabic fusha except in universities. And when foreign student speak fusha in social settings while they are studying there, all those Arabs will either dont understand or laugh at them. And now ask yourself O' Arab, the non-arab students came to your countries from thousands of miles away, spending tens of thousands of dollars just to seeks islamic knowledge and with already strong fusha arabic foundatiin back home but when arrived in Arabic countries, they are being laugh at by the Arabs JUST BECAUSE they speak fusha.
easy they learn msa but when they visit a place they use the living language of that place it more useful spain doesn't use latin anymore so are the arab countries fos'ha was never a spoken language it not a grimm depressing reality it how language work
I mean you really don’t have to speak Fusha, it’s amazing that we have preserved the original Arabic of when Rasulallah spoke it but language over time change anyway. So when learning Arabic it should only be done first to learn the Deen, understand and comprehend the Quran and Sunnah and not about speaking eloquently, so people think your an amazing speaker
Basically there are dialects and Fusha Arabic. Dialects are the way Arabs in different countries use arabic. Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Morocco etc. But Fusha is the classic and standart Arabic which is the language used in The Quran and the books of the scholars.
Assalam Alaykum wa rahmatullah. If a layman ask: Can I be a Salafi and then declare Palestinians Mushriks, be against anyone who disagrees with my views and declare them Kharij and new jahmiyah, because I'm a Noble Salafi brother who is upon Haqq?? And why?
@@ismaiilbozz6798 first, you didn't respond to the greeting of peace and no one has, second you haven't answered my 2 questions, third you provided a vague explanation. Follow up questions: What do you mean they? [Or are there any 'Salafis' who commit distortions] and are you implying that there are some statements that can be distorted to promote arrogance or massive Takfeeri??
@@Irfan__ Still no response in the greeting of peace. Nope Sheikh Ar-ruhayli (Hafidhahullah) didn't say that. This is an external question from the context, I Ask it because I know most of the watchers of this video are Salafis. What I'm asking are ideologies that are common within the Salafi circles, so I wanted to know what is your take on this as Salafis. That is my whole point.
