Тёмный

In-Cylinder pressure - Pico WPS vs less expensive sensors. Also can a cheap 150 scope do the trick! 

siu automotive
Подписаться 33 тыс.
Просмотров 12 тыс.
50% 1

In this video I compare the "flagship" Pico WPS 500x to a few much less expensive pressure transducers. The sensors used in this video are around $150 or less (June 2022). I demonstrate the pattern with each sensor on a 2016 Chevrolet Silverado with a 5.3L engine. Also, while I have the sensors hooked up, I compared the pattern from a high-quality 12-bit Pico 4423 to a much less expensive 8-bit Pico 2204a ($150) to see if you can perform in-cylinder pressure testing with a less expensive scope AND a less expensive pressure sensor.

Опубликовано:

 

6 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 41   
@gerardocondoripariona1953
@gerardocondoripariona1953 2 года назад
im from peru...thanks...I am a student and an oscilloscope like picoscope is unattainable for me, with inflation in my country everything has become expensive.... I am going to do my best to make myself a pressure transducer with honeywell.... greetings and successes teacher..............saludos desde peru
@chrisreynolds5694
@chrisreynolds5694 2 года назад
Great video and comparison, Sean! I thank you for introducing me to this platform.
@billl7551
@billl7551 7 месяцев назад
Pretty power box!! No hot glue 🙂. RE: I just watched your $20 vibration analyzer it was fantastic too.
@DJ-tn7vj
@DJ-tn7vj 2 года назад
Thanks again for the break down. There is a Chinese version that works really well also. Similar to the WPS for about 300 bucks
@secretsquirrel9722
@secretsquirrel9722 2 года назад
I love to see him test that one.
@chandpriyankara
@chandpriyankara Год назад
JH APT-100
@DJ-tn7vj
@DJ-tn7vj Год назад
@@secretsquirrel9722 ill probably do one myself. Check out @dj mobile auto on RU-vid
@johnhnetkovsky8917
@johnhnetkovsky8917 Год назад
The higher compression pressure during snap throttle is from the ingestion of more air to the cylinder,it is not back pressure. With modern cylinder heads and intake manifolds flowing more air this is the result, more power.
@calholli
@calholli 2 года назад
Ivan, at "Pine Hollow Auto Diagnostics" --- sells his own little kit. I forget what sensors he uses.
@frmanuel83
@frmanuel83 Год назад
Great video !! Thanks for sharing mate!
@HS-fw2ed
@HS-fw2ed 7 месяцев назад
Thank you very much for this informative demonstration. I have some of these sensors and they are all 1/8'' NPT but in the market, I can't find any of the adaptors that you use in this demonstration. Can you please help me with this?
@timgroleau1612
@timgroleau1612 11 месяцев назад
Love comparison videos.
@HomemMagroide
@HomemMagroide 2 года назад
Hi, That was an interesting video in which different sensors and scopes are featured. However, I was wondering if you get hold of a sensor from ATS - Bernie Thompson- and compare its response and vertical resolution with Pico's WPS500.
@joemifsud2770
@joemifsud2770 9 месяцев назад
Excellent. Keep it up.
@IamReadyToRock
@IamReadyToRock Месяц назад
what type of voltage regulator are you using? I think it influences the waveform too much using an 8-bit oscilloscope. It would be very helpful. I have purchased the SSI 500 Absolute Sensor
@Eddiegrant69
@Eddiegrant69 2 года назад
BENXU-TECH make good sensors. Less stair stepping than my honeywell px3. $20 but there not absolute.
@BesprovolkiSvias
@BesprovolkiSvias Год назад
For those who read my reply about Rotkee transducers: they are bad, they brake after 10 uses: the black "ground" wire burns and melts. I checked the resistance of wires, check connections, checked clamps for power supply, etc, and established that transducer itself creates super-high current when pressure is 50 psi. As soon as pressure drops to zero, the burning stops. I posted reviews on Google sites about it.
@DAZ_SR
@DAZ_SR Год назад
How do you buy those in the US? Does the war affect the shipping? Thanks!
@BesprovolkiSvias
@BesprovolkiSvias Год назад
@@DAZ_SR I modify my comment (read my original comment which I modified).
@mandytuning
@mandytuning 10 месяцев назад
Vtc Cam advance increase compression.
@markjohnson8162
@markjohnson8162 7 месяцев назад
I want to get into in cylinder testing which one would you recommend?😊
@jamesrossmotors
@jamesrossmotors Год назад
I am just wondering if you use the same Pico sofrware for the 12 byte and 8 byte scopes. Great video. I have just purchased a cheap Rotkee sensor and look forward to seeing its performance
@siuautomotive
@siuautomotive Год назад
For the 8-bit scopes, you’ll need the non-automotive version of Pico. You can get it at picotech.com.
@siuautomotive
@siuautomotive Год назад
For the 8-bit scopes, you’ll need the non-automotive version of Pico. You can get it at picotech.com.
@jamesrossmotors
@jamesrossmotors Год назад
@@siuautomotive thanks
@jaguarsouzalive
@jaguarsouzalive Год назад
Exelente aula poderia falar. Pouco devagar difícil acompanhar a tradução! Por favor
@markmerrill794
@markmerrill794 Месяц назад
Is the shreader vave removed or does it stay in place?
@4YouWHOyou
@4YouWHOyou 5 месяцев назад
Hi my scope doesn't support rollers for in cylinder pressure, engine rotation. Is there any software that allow to overlay that pattern to my measurements?
@peugeotplanet7553
@peugeotplanet7553 4 месяца назад
Can you please compare the wps to rotkee p16?
@akdenyer
@akdenyer Год назад
Hi Why is the waveform different in the initial test before starting. Like the valves are not opening?
@howlinhog
@howlinhog 11 месяцев назад
Back when the vantage scope came out I bought all the pressure transducers and cables. Haven't used them in years since the Vantage died. not sure how to wire it. Do you have description of pin out for the connector
@siuautomotive
@siuautomotive 11 месяцев назад
I’m not sure the pin out. I’m pretty sure those snapon sensors alter amperage, not voltage. They likely switch between 5-20mA, which is a common range. With the pico, you can still use that setup, but you have to feed it 5v through 250 ohms. Then you can measure the voltage drop across the resistor and make either a math channel or create a “custom probe”. That sounds like a good project for another video!
@howlinhog
@howlinhog 11 месяцев назад
@@siuautomotive That does sound like a great subject for another video. The SSI transducers you are using look identical to the ones I have, round three pin connector, shape of the body, everything. Do the SnapOn transducers you're talking about meet that same description? I've got a range of transducers that go from reading vacuum and low pressure on up to 5000 lbs. It'd be nice to make use of them.
@zeusbaezagil4500
@zeusbaezagil4500 2 года назад
Muy buen video pero yo fabriqué uno y no logré q funcionara ni diera lectura
@zeusbaezagil4500
@zeusbaezagil4500 2 года назад
Veo q tú lo fabricaste sería x el sensor de precion
@solraccavalcante382
@solraccavalcante382 Год назад
Bom dia. Onde compro o sensor SSI P51-500-S-G-P
@siuautomotive
@siuautomotive Год назад
It not the same one, but it’ll work www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/amphenol-ssi-technologies/P51-500-A-B-I36-4-5OVP-000-000/1665820
@KeithHiebert
@KeithHiebert 2 года назад
Any chance of a comparison of the JH APT 100 clone of the WPS 500 tranducer? It comes with the adapters, and case. I have one, but haven't used it yet. Seems reasonably well built. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BbjAKlFnDBo.html
@siuautomotive
@siuautomotive 2 года назад
Hmmm, I’ll have to look into that. It really looks like a clone of the wps. For less than $300, it looks like a great deal. I do hate the fact that those China companies are cloning other companies great products though
@chekelley6861
@chekelley6861 2 года назад
I have one and it works exactly like the WPS 500. I even use the built in settings in Pico Automotive
@justinteller2184
@justinteller2184 Год назад
​@@chekelley6861 Your comment is the best, I was hoping for this answer. 🎉
Далее
In-cylinder pressure testing for less than $100
46:16
Automotive Diagnostic Pulse Sensor for 6 dollars?
31:45
Pressure Analysis for the Internal Combustion Engine
49:24
Picoscope Compression Test - Livestream test
37:41
Просмотров 5 тыс.
Engine Mechanical Testing with John Thornton
51:21
Просмотров 27 тыс.