That's not the point no matter how much u try rivers can't be cleaned till we are a developing country To clean the rivers we need to put better waste management system in cities and towns The money spent on river cleaning could have been utilised for purposes like these , instead they chose to spend it down a drain , at this point river cleaning projects are just a pr project
@@oreki8707 well various STP have been commissioned under namami gamage project and it has shown it's result at different pockets of the river but yes directly cleaning the river will not do anything.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
No, the quality of Ganga water has increased significantly. This project is a success. Dolphins population have started to increase. Many studies & documentaries are available for same
My friend now you can say that the project is success but you know what the amount of money which should be spent on these is much more so just saying the water is drinkable is not enough overall it is not really a profitable project !
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
Cleaning rivers is definitely possible but for that we need to change the whole soroundings of both sides of Rivers , planting trees and no direct emition of Water. Come to North Bengal here or North-east India , you will see river so much clean and Turquoise it seems like lakes of Europe.
Main reason for lack of pollution in North Bengal is lack of Industries, there is no major industry operating in Bengal, and the ones who try are kicked out due to unfriendly policies, and by certain leaders -ahmm.
@@vaibhavebhatnagar Your reason is correct but it does not justifies river pollution problem, Government of India have to take neccessary steps which I am frankly saying they have failed to take in 9+years of governance
@@philosopherfrombed Not 9 yeas, at least they are making an attempt. I think for past 20 odd years there was nothing done. Also, pollution is accumulated for past several century, wrong to blame a single government for it.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
I am from Patna and I am seeing road and sewers being reconstructed under the name of 'Namami Ganga', I was really shocked tbh, anyone from Patna also watching these constructions ? i saw them in Rajeev Nagar, AG colony and Ashiana Road
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
Varnasi is so much more cleaner . So are the Ghats & the river. Patna too work is ongoing. Only people shld be careful of the use of plastic & not throw trash in the river n public areas. People should also generate less waste. Adults esp should set an example of clean habits & civic sense for the next generation so that children grow up learning good habits
River Thames was filled with sewage once amd the UK parliament had deemed it a gone case with no hopes of reviving it. But here we are. With a clean river.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
Don't choose the easy way out and claim it to be impossible, definitely it's a very tough job but many countries have achieved it in past, we will do as well, maybe we just need a little more time being a lower middle income country!
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
@@shaktimaan1064 the solution isn't that hard to be honest. We just have to stop adding more pollutants in water. It might hurt some industries who try to save money by releasing their waste into the river but after that nature will make everything right within a few years. And with swach Bharat project getting bigger allocation in coming years (normal for a growing economy) plastic & wastage problem will eventually ease with time (there is no shortcut in these process,it will take time).
This what happened with me, in Lucknow last year, the government had dug ditches besides the river for Ganesh idol visharjan, but most orthodox old style thinking public would like to do visharjan in the river Gomati tus polluting it heavily. Mostly people think river will carry away everything it's not an issue, and it's tradition. The topic of pollution is well taught in our syllabus but most Indians don't care , mug up education and superstitious and over religious acts will never make us responsible citizens of India.
@Laxman Rawat With time and education, they will learn discipline. We are a couple of decades behind in these matters as the vast majority of our population is poor and undisciplined.
Clean water is priceless. Life can't go on without clean, unpolluted water. Treated water apparently can be sold to industries reducing load on water resources. Biofuels can be generated from solid, liquid and gaseous waste materials. If this is done it can generate employment and energy for the nation and reduce imports of the same. As per Nitin Gadkari jis statements large number of STPs are being built in Northern States to clean up sewage water being let into main rivers or their tributaries. Such cleanups have happened in Western countries as well so it's definitely not impossible. It's very much possible esp if it's made into a recycling business run by private players. Lots of jobs. Raddi business may be among the most profitable businesses as their input cost is very low and profit margin is very high (waste to wealth).
On an individual level, also, one must act in a more responsible manner. For example not throwing any plastic or waste even in the drains as it may flow to the rivers. Like throwing in the empty frooti packet or plastic bottles after drinking of it.
Rather than cleaning rivers, government should give training lessons to people about environment and civic sense. Darwin's evolution is not just walking on 2 legs but also having basic civic sense. In Europe, they are introducing green knowledge exam as compulsory subject without which one can't get any degree even if he or she is Einstein 2
Impossible - I m possible So our govt. is in right direction toward this Ganga River Cleaning project, the only thing is it will take time as this huge river passes from so many states, cities and villages of India. So this is challenging but as the time passes this project will shows the change in cleanliness of river.
Please everyone take up the campaign to save the rivers and help save the rivers by making people hundred percent aware and save the rivers if you have to go to any extent to 'save the rivers'. If the rivers are saved then the country will be saved and our coming generations will be safe and remember us everyday and those who made the rivers safe will be worshiped, and if the rivers are not saved then the living creatures will not be saved either, so be aware and fulfill your own responsibility. Please 🙏
Im from coastal city at beach ⛱️.. 1 day Central govt along wid colleges students & NGO s made beach cleanup .. sone foreign delegate s visited after dat ppl thrown waste in beach ⛱️, on roads , inside sea 😔 So its not govt it's India ppl mentality should change..
I disagree with the point that all wastes thrown by ppl in the rivers do no harm as they are biodegradable. That's totally wrong, high amounts of biodegradable waste is harmful to the rivers as it messes with their ph level. Many flower sellers have chemicals in their flowers which pollute the river. So, dumping of flowers and more religious waste does have an effect on the river.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
STP is standard practice .In European countries and US sewage is never discharged to river without treatment .please do research don’t misguide.if untreated sewage is discharged into river then irreparable damage to flora and fauna of river system will occur like Yamuna in Delhi.
Strange pehle duniya bhar ke example diye jate the ki Nadiya saf hai bahar dekho unki government kitna Kam kr rhi hai and when we are trying we get such criticism!! Also, ganga me after multiple plans Dolphins wapas a gyi hai who live in clean water so please focus on your content... Sabarmati is a perfect example of suc great work!!
It is definitely possible . Anyone saying otherwise should be put in jail or just come with me once to Hyderabad and I’ll make you swim in these rivers . You’ll understand .
These herculion cleaning effort never seen before...all praise to concern authorities n citizens residing near to river bank.All possible..positive mindset all required.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
I was just watching the great Pacific Garbage patch and kitna tareef ho rha the us project ka...fir soche ki ek baar Indian government dwara river cleaning wali project ko dekhte hn...and Jo umeed Kia tha wahi nikla....har koi ninda kr rha....matlab India me logon ko outcome se matlab nhi h...unko bas humare leader ki ninda krni h.....lockdown me puri duniya ne taliyan bajai apne COVID warriors k lie...lekin jab humne Kia toh logon ne ninda krni shuru kardi...
NOTHING is impossible... what is required is education, focus, respect, need, and genuine desire ... And environment ministry should take river cleaning and beautification projects , including banning dumping and plastic usage , water treatment plants rollout and mass scale education and fines ... These prijects needs to be monetised so that they fund themselves while they become beautiful spots of tourism and environmental support injection
States have too much power in India. Indian Constitution needs to be updates. And the centre should order all the states to have one large sweage treatment plant for every city inside the state. And also give a time frame by excercising emergency powers of the centre because states just wont listen. To reduce cost the govt. can develop a single design for a sewage plant and build it all over India. The sewage plants should be massive and treat water like Japan's sewage treatment plan does. So clean that the country allows its children to play in the treated water during summers.
I am from Varanasi and i challange kejriwal and delhi people in term of ganga and yamuna water quality.Jabki wahi yamuna ganga me ake praygraj me mil bhi jati hai
धार्मिक अनुष्ठान में जैविक पूजा सामग्री व प्राकृतिक रंग ही प्रयोग हो मूर्ति निर्माण में । सूती या पटसन के चुन्नी-कपड़े ही प्रयोग हों तो हम थोड़ा और सुधार कर सकते हैं
🙏🏻Ek Solution hai ❣️Nadi k Kinare se 500ft dur Ek bada sewage canal aur har 5km me ek bada sewage plant ,jiska paani treatment hone k baad nadi me choda jaye ,,Jitna paise government ab tak kharch kar chuke hai uska sirf 10 se 20 percent cost pe permanent Solution nikal jata aur toh aur paani bhi direct clean source organic agriculture aur peene layak hojata jisse future health problems wahan k gaav ya city me kum hojata .
There are lakes and water bodies in northern most part of India related to Buddhism which are considered so sacred that you can’t even touch the water. The water bodies are just beautiful to look at. I know one can’t compare a lake and a river which travels across Half the country. But what I’m trying to say is all this talk abt Ganga being a holy river and mother blah blah is just pure bullshit. Coz if ppl really had that sentiment, they won’t let literal shit flow into thr river untreated
@@AnkitSinghAnarchoAtheist drainage of 1.3 billion going in ganga ?😂 Only North rivers like Ganga and Yamuna worst polluted all other parts river are ok. Go and clean those rivers first. And what about china ? They also have similar population.
@@santhoshv3028 Chinese Rivers were the most polluted in the 2000's... So were the Thames in 1800's England. Ganges will get clean once India crosses a certain GDP per capita, then we could support Sewage treatment plants in every town. It's not all that simple.
@@santhoshv3028 I clicked on your dp.... It shows recent comment. And in every comment you dragged North and South. Idiot the most polluted river in India is Chennai's Cooum. Now keep rocking on South-North drift until it reaches your centre.
1 I fully disagree with this narrative that it’s impossible to clean the rivers of India. All these developed countries, in spite of much more higher level of industrialisation and developed chemical, fertiliser, textile and construction industries have successfully kept their rivers super clean, even when one river passes through a number of countries. Here what we have to understand is right efforts with right intensity has not been applied in India. Whatever river cleaning projects we have observed was and utterly insufficient and most of them were engulfed in corruption. A few thousand crore is not sufficient amount to handle Waste generated bye population of 30/40 cr people. Apart from large scale water recycling plants and sewage treatment plants at all villages and all city’s with target of covering complete water recycling, we have to integrate complete drip irrigation wherever applicable in entire agricultural sector along with solid waste management program also. This has not happened in India resulting in less effectiveness and that’s why it appears near to impossible. 2 as far as money spending is concerned. This entire master integrated water recycling, mandatory drip irrigation,STPs and solid waste management plan may take around 10-15 lakh cr. From where this amount will come? Government by deficit financing had additionally spent six lakh cr during two years of Covid period. We will have to continue that kind of deficit financing for around seven years to meet that expense. Even the salary hikes of nearly 2% of population who are government employees, in one pay commission enhances the expense by lakhs of crores rupees during half a decade. Then why not to spend on such greatly greatly needed plan that will so positively affect the lives of almost entire population.The additional debt creation may fetch around 1.5 lakh cr off tax burden if the total expense is envisaged to be 20 lakh cr and Interest is considered at 7%. Here it is pertinent to note that Indians are creating almost 10 lakh cr of debt every year to buy cars which is actually not the need of Indian society and Indian conditions. And these car buyers spend almost average minimum 1.25 to 1.5 lakh rupees every year in just EMIs if we yconsider average car pricey between 5 to 10 lakh. Further, it should also be noted that most of these developed countries created debt much higher than their GDP even up to 5 times of their GDP to fulfil their needs and to become developed. Then why shouldn’t we spend some money by creation of debt to fulfil our basic need? 3what we need to understand is, most of the countries who are developed today, first managed their water resources. Water is first need of life. However great resources we would have, but if we don’t manage the water resources properly, we would remain under developed only. There are many countries like Israel who developed actually because of single biggest tool-water management. We may also understand that proper water management would lead to substantial increase in food production, which will enhance the supply elasticity of food leading to ease of food inflation. Ease in food inflation will increase the roam for higher deficit financing to be used for development of infrastructure/secondary/tertiary sectors without increasing the inflation, The model of development which was typically used by western countries that has been hidden from us.
I don't agree at all.....I have seen many rivers and lakes that were once so dirty are today very very clean. You can swim in that. Regarding plastic cleaning, look at many beaches in India, what they hv done...very clean.....May be slow , but not impossible. We ourselves cleaned a stream in Karnataka.....and some rules were set -- now that river is clean.....
dude traditionally oil kab se biodegradable ho gaya.. aur plastic bags mai dalte hai uska.. cloth dalte hai jo najane konse konse material ke mix se bana hua hai.. it is a big amount plz stop making it look small.. CONCLUSION Hum individual level pe hamare rituals ke bases pe kachra dalange bhale hum bhagwan mane wale nadi ko hi kyu na kharab kare..
Waste ko treat karke hi rivers me milaya jaay. direct factory ke waste ko rivers me nahi milana chahiye. Factories ke upar heavy fine lagani chahiye. Sevage treatment plant honi chahiye.
title of the video is misleading. in video he explains the reasons why rivers are still dirty despite government's river cleaning projects. rivers can be cleaned. we just have to address the source of the pollution
