Infantry & Cavalry Han Dao by LK Chen - Pros & Cons...

Подписаться 1,6 млн

Просмотров 108 тыс.

50% 1

These two were interesting to test out. Surprisingly mixed bag... So far I've seen very good quality from LK Chen, but there were some odd flaws with the fit and finish that I didn't expect. The blades are great and can cut very well (although they aren't the most forgiving with regards to edge alignment).
In the video I do testing cutting on tatami and a ballistic gel torso, as well as harder testing on branches and particle board, to figure out how sturdy the construction is. I also talk a bit about their historical background. I hope you find the review interesting and informative.
The Royal Arsenal infantry dao:
lkchensword.com/shop/ols/prod...
The Heavenly Horse cavalry dao:
lkchensword.com/shop/ols/prod...
** Support the channel **
Help fund future videos, get bonus content and other rewards:
/ skallagrim
www.subscribestar.com/skallagrim
/ @skallagrim
Books about history and/or martial arts, swords, knives, video/audio equipment, and other stuff I recommend (as an Amazon Affiliate I earn commission through these links):
US - www.amazon.com/shop/skallagri...
Canada - amzn.to/2HeOCMA
Other ways to support the channel by shopping through affiliate links:
Kult of Athena, my favorite online store for reproductions of historical arms and armor, fantasy swords, etc:
ww4.aitsafe.com/go.htm?go=kult...
Where to get HEMA gear and practice swords:
www.woodenswords.com/?Click=1799
** Social media & merch **
How to contact me:
/ skallagrimnilsson
See a list of my video uploads:
/ _skallagrim_
/ skallagrimyt
Channel-related shirts and other merch:
skallagrim.spreadshirt.com/
teespring.com/stores/skallagrim
My side channel (for rambles, vlogs, opinions, gaming, etc):
/ @skallhalla
** Music **
Intro song:
"Illuminate" by Vindsvept
vindsvept.bandcamp.com/track/...
Outro:
"Highland Storm" by The Slanted Room Records
theslantedroom.weebly.com/

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

31 июл 2020

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 678

@rajamicitrenti1374 3 года назад

The loose brass fitting isn't a flaw, it's a feature! With the right motion, it becomes a projectile in a sort of modified "end him rightly"!

@FENomadtrooper 3 года назад

A front pommel? Tell me more.

@crossbowboltlaunchers2456 3 года назад

I am rolling on the floor. This joke ages really well

@thearcanehunter2736 3 года назад

That would make the weapon the most OP of them all. The actual back pommel is lacking, but that can be fixed.

@reeso7539 3 года назад

Looks like the chinese invented the prototype of ending someone rightly

@normang3668 3 года назад

End him rightry.

@jiamingzhang147 3 года назад

Couple history tips: 1, the ring pommel was designed to tie a rope around it and your wrist so you don’t loose your blade on horse back or cut your finger when thrusting. 2, the major enemy of the Han army was always the Xiongnu people, which are nomadic tribesmen from the north, since iron mines are lacking there and many raiders don’t have the money to afford armor, (many still use stone arrowheads) armor piercing isn’t really needed for most part. Nice video tho!

@burnzy2639 3 года назад

The rope with the ring is an interesting way of preventing thrusts from hurting the user. Cheaper too.

@jessieguo7823 3 года назад

Using ring and rope to prevent slippery hands is always the thing I heard from Chinese weapon community, but I do question whether it was true. To me it really looks like an explanation people come up with later, trying to tie the Kongfu performance with military martial art together. I do think the cloth tied on the ring of Dadao (said to be a symbolic representation of this rope and ring thing) is for performance aesthetic purpose, and even if it's true, it doesn't solve the problem of risking injuring your finger when thrusting.

@jiamingzhang147 3 года назад

Jessie Guo The cloth on Dadao is for decoration and performance (and good luck) purposes, since it is a double handed weapon, it doesn’t make sense to tie it to one hand. In my opinion Kongfu performance could be compared with western dueling instead of military martial arts. I see your point tho, too many inaccurate movies blurs the true way of fighting.

@jessieguo7823 3 года назад

@@jiamingzhang147 Oh I see! That makes so much sense now.

@jxmai7687 3 года назад

kknews.cc/zh-hk/culture/r85k3x.html Check this out in Chinese, but lots pictures and details. also the cloth could be use as warning of danger. In Dao technique, stabbing is not easy to protect yourself, it may not be recommended at all.

@JamesBiggar 3 года назад

Surface prep is everything when gluing anything together with any type of glue. Clean, but somewhat rough. Smooth is bad. Glue needs something to bond to. My guess is they didn't prep the brass fittings properly and that's why most of the glue is stuck to the fibers of the wood and not the brass. Clean off the old glue then hit the surfaces of both the wood and inside faces of the brass with 120 grit sandpaper to rough them up a bit (without ruining the fit) then clean with alcohol. The more edges for the glue to bond to, the better.

@Landogarner83 3 года назад

Actually that is not true. If surface prep and glue choice are right, it makes no difference if the surface is polished or rough. (source: adhesives seminary by the Fraunhofer Institute) Actually a rough surface can be worse if the glue is too thick. The really important part is that both surfaces are completely clean and you choose a glue that can adhere to both materials. I found that often the easiest way to get metal surfaces clean is to remove the old surface by grinding. Higher grit sandpaper works better and faster for metals. The problem in this case is that the fittings are brass. Brass is notoriously difficult to glue because very few glues will hold on to it securely. Also most copper alloys will oxidize quickly which is bad for adhesives. To glue brass you should use 2K glues like epoxy or PU and prepare the brass surface immediatly before glueing. Preparation is: general cleaning -> degreasing -> grinding -> degreasing and then gluing.

@Vivi2372 3 года назад

@@Landogarner83 bingo, at least where gluing wood is concerned (I've never glued metal myself). People often think you need a rough surface because there's more surface area for the glue to adhere to but you're really just creating small gaps that aren't as well joined. Clean and smooth with no more glue than needed to do the job is a lot better and you get joints that are stronger than the surrounding wood when you do it right.

@user-dm1mm6ou1c 3 года назад

i thought its kinda the same when you put locktide on screw. Clean the screw first with something like acetone or ethyl

@Dennis-vh8tz 3 года назад

With ebony and other oily tropical hardwoods, the natural oils can prevent glue from bonding, it's often recommended to clean the area to be glued with alcohol or another organic solvent, then wait just long enough for the solvent to evaporate before applying glue.

@appa609 3 года назад

Aladine might also help. Get that surface chemically activated

@Intranetusa 3 года назад

In regards to "armor penetration" abilities of this infantry sword, I'm reading a lot of assumptions from people who claim this Han infantry dao was designed to fight unarmored opponents. First, swords are very rarely meant to be used against armor anyways - even later era European swords are meant to avoid armor and attack unarmored parts of the soldier. You get much more armor penetrating abilities with ranged weapons and polearms than you do with a single handed sword. Second, the dao was a secondary/backup weapon and not the primary weapon to fight the Xiongnu. Crossbows, bows, and polearm weapons were all much more important than the dao in fighting the Xiongnu, and all of them had armor penetration potential. If you read about the major battles against the Xiongnu, the Han era writers talks about the importance of crossbows and polearms (eg. ji-halberds) and I haven't really read any accounts that mention the importance of the dao in these battles.

@xiuyuan6607 3 года назад

Crossb and pole arms have always dominated ancient battle field. They were the AK 47 and mortar. Swords and Dao were like pistol. They are always auxiliary weapons.

@choiettech 3 года назад

Considering that the armour of this era weren't like European or later styles in Chinese history, you could very well stab through the armour and penetrate it.

@Intranetusa 3 года назад

@@choiettech No, armor of this period included lamellar and scale made of iron, steel, bronze, and rawhide...which isn't that different from armor of later periods. Swords aren't going to stab through any of those types of small-plate armor. Swords even have a difficult time stabbing through chainmail, as Skallagrim's earlier videos show that the vast majority of sword stabs, even with swords with thin points, are stopped by chainmail. Swords are even often stopped by padded cloth or glued cloth armor (eg. gambeson and linothorax) too, so most swords in general perform pretty poorly against even lighter armors. Swords would be used against unarmored vulnerable parts of the body and not really used against armor.

@choiettech 3 года назад

@@Intranetusa ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-jz9bnH_YOxg.html I'm pretty sure if spears can break through armour like this, it wouldn't be too impossible. Plus chainmail is different to lamellar armour. It would certainly protect you from cuts but a thrust would more powerful to penetrate the armour.

@Intranetusa 3 года назад

@@choiettech First, spears are very different from swords because spears are rigid (and thus better at penetration) while swords are more flexible. Skallagrim actually does armor tests with spears and swords against riveted chainmail where the rigid spear is effective at penetration but the swords do little to nothing: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ydjdBTV8ZbY.html Second, chainmail and lamellar will both protect against any cuts from swords, but lamellar armor is far superior to chainmail in protection against stabbing. You can see this by watching Skallagrim and other videos on lamellar armor tests against arrows and crossbow bolts. Skallagrim's cheap lamellar armor stops a ~976lb draw weight, low powerstroke crossbow bolt, but these crossbow bolts penetrates deep into riveted chainmail armor with padding: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-XMT6hjwY8NQ.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-O4sNcozOrkU.html Finally, the link you provided is a low quality Chinese entertainment show that doesn't use historically accurate armor, weapons, etc. If you read the comments, I actually posted a comment on that video a few years ago about how bad the reproduction is. The armor they use is inaccurate leather (when it should be rawhide, bronze, iron, etc) and the people using the weapons seem to be acrobatics wushu practitioners (which is not for combat and is more of a performance art). There are other comments about how bad the show is and how clueless the people are sometimes.

@mayz-7822 3 года назад

This is basically the most primitive Chinese Dao you can get. At this stage, Dao was just separated from Jian (double-edged sword), and became a massive-produced side weapon for normal soldier s. So, its design was similar to Jian in many ways (straight, extremely light-weight and flexible).

@DarkwarriorJ 3 года назад

This is primitive, but, perhaps just being biased towards straight swords here, but I sorta like this design better. What disadvantages does it have vis a vis later daos? Edit: It's a shame it doesn't have a guard. That's, like, the one thing it needs to be just as cool as the average straight-sword to me, precisely for the thrusting performance.

@markuskristensen2433 3 года назад

@098765 Craper the sword is not curved my friend

@DarkwarriorJ 3 года назад

@098765 Craper Hmmm... True, that is a serious consideration, especially when dealing with more than one enemy at a time, and with the fact that people don't die nearly as fast as in Hollywood.

@DarkwarriorJ 3 года назад

@098765 Craper Or his shield, or his armor, or a tree that got in the way xD

@mayz-7822 3 года назад

@@DarkwarriorJ Later Dao were more rigid and relative heavier, but still relative lighter than many medieval swords. Too much flexibility is a big problem for the cutting-predominant blade. The Infantry Dao is relatively good for cutting, since it's short. but the much longer Cavalry Han Dao is too flexible. In the video, Skallagrim couldn't get a very good cut because it‘s hard to line-up. But to be fair, I think it might have something to do with the steel LK Chen used: since the smelting technology wasn't so good back then, the blade might be more rigid than the modern reproduction Interestingly, staight blade didn't seemed to be a very big problem for ancient Chinese. Until Tang dynasty (618 to 907, around 400-700 years after Han dynasty), most of Dao were still straight blade, though the slighlty curved Dao gradually became prevalent in later period. As for the guard, some argue that it might have some sort of small stopper made by organic materials (such as the materials used for warpping the hilt) to prevent soldiers to cut their hands, not a guard, but at least served some purposes. I think that it's mainly because it was way easier to produce without a metal guard. the excavated Han Dao was basically just a piece of sharpened metal (us.v-cdn.net/5022456/uploads/editor/o6/uw3erawkn0vy.jpg). It was very easy to massive produce, an very important factor if you want to arm ten thousands of soldiers. And soldiers could make some customizations themselves to make them more usable.

@fgg4136 3 года назад

I'd love to see you test wavy flamberge/kris type blades... It'd be interesting to see how more surface area per length and the uneven wave of the edge affects cuts and thrusts

@nimbusws5946 3 года назад

He has an old video testing a kris but that was years ago. Agree, would love to see him make another or similar video.

@opdz000 3 года назад

The arsenal ledger he mentioned at 1:01 is a document written on wooden slips that records the number of various weapons stored in a Jun (an administrative division of the Han dynasty, its area is anywhere between a modern-day China's province and a city) level arsenal in 13 BCE. The full name of the ledger is 武库永始四年兵车器集簿, which translates to Weapons and Chariot Registry (of) Arsenal Warehouse (in) Year Yongshi 4 (13 BCE). Here are some of the weapons listed in the registry and their numbers: 537707 Crossbows, 11181 of which belongs to the royalty. 11458424 Arrows for Crossbows, 34265 of which belongs to the royalty. 77521 Bows. 1199316 Arrows for Bows. 142701 Leather Armours, 379 of which belongs to the royalty. 587299 Iron Lamellar Armours. 98226 Leather Helmets, 678 of which belongs to the royalty. 102551 Shields, 2650 of which belongs to the royalty. 615416 Various Forms of Spear and Lance. 99905 Jians, 24804 Daggers, 156135 Daos. 7174 Various Forms of Chariots.

@ModernKnight 3 года назад

nice video. I might have to get one of those cavalry swords and try it out. It's a very different design that I'm used to.

@wor575 3 года назад

I left the same comments in Scholagladiatoria's video as well, basically: The Han switched to the dao because it's more more efficient (easier to make, easier to train, easier to maintain) for a large infantry force. The infantry at the time was also awfully under-armored, making a slashing weapon viable. If you dig around, you'll find that the lowest of the Han infantry were not armored, and if a foot soldier was lucky, he would get a very modest chest piece that only covered the torso from below the shoulders (granted infantry were given shields).

@hwasiaqhan8923 3 года назад

That is the case in the early Han dynasty where average soldiers were lightly armoured, the crossbow and bow infantry were likely unarmored.

@Zander10102 3 года назад

Were they really that hard up on resources that they couldn't afford to provide armor? Or was it a result of the military doctrine of the time?

@lairdcummings9092 3 года назад

"Tactical" isn't the word you want. "Logistically efficient" is where you want to go. Possibly even 'strategic.'

@lairdcummings9092 3 года назад

@@Zander10102 cutting corners on equipping soldiers is as old as armies. Even cheap equipment begins to add up when you're talking about thousands of soldiers. Considering these were intended for low-status troops, there's not much purpose to spending more.

@wor575 3 года назад

@@Zander10102 such was the case with a lot of ancient civilizations where the non-elite infantry were either unarmored or armored with the bare minimum. such units were commonly referred as "light infantry", although the term is not official. in most cases their main protection comes from a shield and some sort of head covering, either a skull cap or a legitimate helmet. even the Greeks and Romans had those, with the hoplite and legionary being more of elite/heavy infantry. even during the middle ages you have foot soldiers who can only afford a gambeson

@squaidsareus3237 3 года назад

LK Chen himself made a video talking about the overwhelming number of orders and issues caused by the pandemic so that might be the cause of the quality drop. You can find the video by looking up Reflections in times of a Pandemic on RU-vid by kkcheungus1it should be about 12 minutes long.

@Hephera 3 года назад

not really an excuse unless they drop the price...

@franknbeanz147 3 года назад

yeah if quality is dropping that bad drop the price as well if your gettin sloppy on your work

@lkchensword2276 3 года назад

In fact this is an early prototype we submit to Mr. Skallagrim early this year for review. For current version please see ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-soKp1t3bdIg.html This current version use cotton cord wrapping for better grip and solve the bronze wood bonding issue with an alternative glue.

@The_Judge300 3 года назад

@@lkchensword2276 The swords are still garbage. Specially the "cavalry sword". There would hardly be anyone that could use such a flexible sword from a horseback in a good way. That flexibilty would make it close to impossible to make a clean cut from a moving horse. And the average foot soldier would have huge problems using the shorter sword well too, because it is to flexible and to unforgiving. You should make them both stiffer and not rip off people with the 2 "rubber" swords you make and sell now. Have pride in what you do and don't just focus on fast and easy money. I don't even understand why you sent something of such poor quality for a review.

@Intranetusa 3 года назад

@@The_Judge300 You should do more research before calling these swords garbage simply for being thin and somewhat flexible. These swords are thin because they are based off of historical examples, not because the maker is trying to save a few pennies by using less steel (which is extremely cheap nowadays). The Han Dao is almost the same price as their Han era jians ($40 difference), and their Han jians are excellent and have gotten great ratings from Skallagrim and Scholagladitoria's review videos. The fact that the swords are made of the more expensive process of being pattern welded high carbon spring-steel that allows them to be flexible yet retain its straightness under stress means they are not simply trying to make a quick buck. If the maker was really trying to make an easy buck, they would have made these swords out of thick mild steel like mall ninja swords, and they would just bend and stay bent without springing back to true. Maybe the maker got the carbon proportion incorrect and the blades really should have had higher levels of carbon (which would make them stiffer and less flexible), but that's not a quality issue and more of a historical interpretation issue.

@gremlon111 3 года назад

"I'll take about that later" face expression is so good xD

@viki9641 3 года назад

This knife, ancient Chinese name: huan shou dao its ring object is used to wrap half a meter long square scarf, usually this scarf tied around the neck, when used with a scarf wrapped around the hand, so that the user's hand, with the handle of the knife fixed. That's why all huanshoudao sno.s a hand guard. With a scarf through the iron ring handle and weapon fixed, chopping time will not be caused by violent vibration caused by loose hands, this is an extremely simple method of profiteering, born in China's Spring and Autumn Period cruel siege war. My English is not good, I hope you don't care

@peterm4675 3 года назад

could you write the explaination in Chinese?

@rotoruaboy 3 года назад

@@peterm4675 I think he was trying to say that back in the days the common infantry practice is to tie a piece of fabric on the ring at the end of the handle and then wrap the rest of the fabric tightly around one's hand, this helps to properly affix the weapon to the user's hand (the blade truly becomes an extension of one's arm), thus a handguard was not required for thrusting attacks. From a manufacturing/logistics point of view, this approach saves precious metal and shortens the time required for swordsmiths to produce such weapons. From a usability aspect, this also prevents the user from losing his weapon in the heat of battle, especially when they are exhausted and lost the ability for fine motor control with their hands and fingers, having one's hand tightly tied to the weapon's handle can guarantee a certain degree of control even when their fingers are fatigued.

@viki9641 3 года назад

You are quite right.

@GenericHandle01 3 года назад

@@rotoruaboy @VIKI thank you both for your explanations. I have seen this technique before but never thought of it as a general practice. (to be fair I saw it in a movie called "The Grey" with Liam Neeson)

@viki9641 3 года назад

The mobilization of ancient China depends more on the tricks. This determines that the ordinary soldiers are not professional soldiers, they do not have sophisticated equipment, but the scale of the war is very large, often with the nomadic people for decades of tug-of-war, which means huge equipment consumption, so the birth of huanshoudao is the inevitable result of large-scale war in ancient China, winding fixed hands, so that the liberation of the other hand, so ordinary untrained people, relying on the combination of shields and huanshoudao can still be effective combat.

@cubancigarman2687 3 года назад

These swords were manufactured for peasant conscripts. It was basically a long knife with no user considerations. Only families with wealth could afford swords with embellishments and a jeweled guard and scabbard. As per your instructions, we should all hold off from purchasing these two a mentioned in this review. Glad to see a new video post regardless! :)

@twisted_oddball 3 года назад

Your best review yet. Informative and no low brow hyperbole, just very thorough and well versed.

@MrJakobMovies 3 года назад

Perticulary good video, it feels like youve gotten better at constructing the video, the format is perfect. I enjoyed it greatly, keep it up!!

@JuanJaramillo25 3 года назад

I've bought the infantry dao as my first sword recently and had a similar problem with the guard. I've only cut with it twice and its already come loose. When I messaged LK Chen about it he was very kind about it and suggested to add more glue to it. Still enjoy it just didnt expect it to get loose so quickly

@DatBoiOrly 3 года назад

The dao needs some brass dowels to stop things falling off.

@johnproctor6438 3 года назад

The insight you offer is amazing, sir. Very appreciated.

@lvcsslacker 3 года назад

I'm glad to see you doing so many different types of swords

@peterfinland1370 3 года назад

I once had a nightmare about ridiculously flexible blade. It was a jian sword, and I was supposed to be fighting with it, but it started flexing like it was made of paper. It just didn't hold still or stiff at all. It reminded me of those Indian blades that are more like whips. It still made some cuts, but was difficult to use. Well it was only a dream, but a really weird one... That long Dao in that slow motion reminded me of that.

@angeliquewu8318 Год назад

There are flexible Jian that cut extremely well though. Idk if this is on the Western internet, but there’s a sword called the Tangxi Treasure Jian, it is one of the 8 great mythical swords of China. The way to make it was lost, but since there are some records about it, this one Chinese sword hobbyist spent half a century (literally 50 years) trying to recreate that specific sword, and he succeeded in making a sword that fit all of the descriptions/requirements. It can slit through a metal stick, cut through bamboo, stab cleanly through a metal drum, and cut a stack of coins in half. All the while, it is extremely flexible, able to bend 50 degrees. However, just because it is flexible doesn’t mean that it flops around. It is still a proper sword.

@shaidrim 3 года назад

Great Review as always. Good job!

@martytu20 3 года назад

Thanks for the review, your testing has just shown why the dao got stiffer over time.

@jackwriter1908 3 года назад

I always ask myself why isn't there a sword that looks this way or that way... Skallagrim shows me every time, that it actually existed.

@50StichesSteel 3 года назад

I have bought a long Katana from them and couldn't be happier with the value I got for the money..The steel is excellent pattern welded steel, scabbard is beautiful and well done. Sharpness is cutting competition ready right out out the box. Details are mostly spot on. I could easily see that sword going for 1,000's from a custom maker. They offer it for under 500$ if I remember correctly.

@FenrirFire18 3 года назад

Sick choices! Have a great day, Skall!!

@ryarth23 3 года назад

Mmm nothing better than waking up and drinking coffee to Skal talk about... Well, anything.

@lukedogwalker 3 года назад

8:01 I want that hat! 10 year old me is jumping up and down chanting "Can I? Can I? Can I? Can I?"

@johndododoe1411 3 года назад

Looks like a bicycle helmet...

@Disasterclese 3 года назад

I'd like to commend you on the skill inherent in detecting the slip of your hand on that thrust, and having the reaction speed to unclench your fingers and avoid cutting yourself. I'm not any kind of swordsman, but to me that seems like something that would be very difficult to pull off instead of instinctively doubling down and trying to tighten your grip. Excellent video, as always!

@F1ghteR41 3 года назад

I feel like the Heavenly Horse Dao would greatly benefit from harder steel and different heat treatment to get the proper hardness to be usable. If one was not bound by the limitations of replicating the original, I would simply suggest widening the blade by a centimetre or so and reprofiling the distal taper so as to make it more rigid while also enhacing its cutting potential.

@ieatcaribou7852 3 года назад

Honest as always, thanks!

@krownedkhaos4281 3 года назад

For thrusts you can palm the pommel to drive in the thrust and use it as the primary force for the thrust instead of using just hand grip, which protects your hands from slipping and just grip to guide and swing the sword.

@TheArthurkan 3 года назад

LK Chen must be crammed with order, the details are drastically different from their older swords

@hanliu3707 3 года назад

I brought his phoenix jian a few yeards ago, the scabbard have the same issue, I heard it's fixed now. I hope he would improve the crafts on these dao.

@crawlFace 3 года назад

@@hanliu3707 Sorry to confirm... nope, not for me. My phoenix is actually shocking in bad quality. Truth is it's "hit or miss" at that relatively cheap price range.

@Wingzero90939 3 года назад

crawlFace Did you get the updated version?

@crawlFace 3 года назад

@@Wingzero90939 My Phoenix came a couple if weeks ago :( I was pretty heart broken over it.

@Wingzero90939 3 года назад

crawlFace Wow I wish they would establish at least a waiting period like Albion Swords or Lockwood Swords.... also maybe require a deposit. At least some form of quality control otherwise it just goes downhill pretty fast. You might want to try emailing them back and see if they can send you a replacement depending how banged up yours is... they did that with A few other people who got messed up swords.

@aur-1998 2 года назад

Thanks for the information

@ryebur7625 3 года назад

You wearing your knitted helm was adorable.

@junemoeggenborg1873 3 года назад

Just recieved my own infantry dao! Can confirm they've upped most of the things Skall pointed out here. From a first impressions standpoint, the only things I see are some minor gapping in the brass fitting on the tip of the scabbard and a noticeable glue residue around some of the fittings,.which shows they've added more glue lol. But the belt attachment is now attached using cord as well as glue and it seems super secure! And the handle is a bit more polished! Only actual complaint is the belt attachment is too small for any of my belts!

@StryderK 3 года назад

Man! I musta been early! Catching a Skallagrim review only 23 minutes after he posted it.

@jasonkeating9958 Год назад

I'm sure im not the only one who would like to see these properly sharpened for testing, Even though they have a good profile manufacturers seem to air on the side of caution when it comes to sharpness, These light nimble swords live and die by the sharpness of the blade, Would be excellent to see a test with the blade sharpened to terrifying level.

@Handsy_McGee 3 года назад

My name is Han Dao, and I'm the fastest sword in the world.

@user-ho4ko2iu8o 3 года назад

汉道？😂

@liaoh1661 3 года назад

this is 环首刀（ huan shou dao 。and（han jian）is wrong name ，That sword in history is called “jian” （剑）mean sword，no special name

@omariscovoador7486 3 года назад

After the rapier of course 😂👌

@Aldersees75 3 года назад

Rin best girl

@boo5214 3 года назад

@@Aldersees75 simp

@iseektheholygrail2055 3 года назад

I really dont want to be the 70th commenter, but i must still say this: Yet another good content skall

@jdaraero 3 года назад

Love your vids

@senyaborovikov1015 3 года назад

Hey, Skall, that's some really cool stuff. I was wondering if you would look into possibly reviewing some Eastern European swords? Maybe a shashka? If not, that's alright too. Love your content, been here since forever.

@StevenHouse1980 3 года назад

To prevent the hand sliping on to the blade, perhaps thay used a cloth loop from the ring pumel to go around the wrist.

@sinosparo 2 года назад

I just received the new versions and everything seems much better. I'll give an update after I get some cutting time with them

@Wyrsa 3 года назад

I love that royal armory dao.

@silverjohn6037 3 года назад

For thrusts you could tie a hand loop to the ring and hold the loop between the thumb and the index finger and grip it along the hilt. If that description makes sense to you.

@VikingAlec 3 года назад

Do we know of any cases of people tying strings from the ring on the bottom to the index finger (kind of like a bow sling) in order to prevent slippage and give more leverage?

@Skallagrim 3 года назад

I don't know, but that's an interesting idea.

@Estalarki 3 года назад

Good stuff

@chenyangli1154 3 года назад

I picked up the Tang dao I ordered last night. Personally I prefer the Tang dao design. (Actually despite being called the “Tang” dao this particular form of Chinese sword first emerged in the 5th century CE during the Northern Wei Dynasty) Historically speaking the Tang dao is based on and derived from the Han infantry and cavalry dao design, with a blade length that is intermediate between the two and hence a more general-purpose sword weapon that can be used both on foot and on horseback. The Tang dao has 2 design and 1 material improvements compared with the Han dao. It has a hand guard which makes it more useful as a thrusting weapon. It also has a longer sword hilt but is still relatively light so potentially can be used either one-handed or two-handed. When people make replica Han Dynasty swords today, generally the same quality of steel is used, but historically Han swords had a lower carbon content than Tang swords and the quality of the blade was not as advanced. So the Tang dao basically has all the advantages of the Han infantry/cavalry dao as well as the Han jian but virtually none of their drawbacks. The Tang dao is a very versatile general-purpose sword weapon, it is effective at both slashing and thrusting, it can be used either one-handed or two-handed, and it can be wielded both on foot and on horseback. It is an improvement upon the basic Han sword design. One could even argue that ancient Chinese sword design never really surpassed the Tang dao.

@chenyangli1154 3 года назад

Ok just an update: since making the last comment here I have learned more into this topic. While it is certainly true that the dao was generally more effective on the battlefield and the Tang dao was an upgraded version of the Han dao, the Han jian (double-edged sword) remains very important in Chinese culture for ceremonial purposes and martial arts. In fact, the Chinese People's Liberation Army today still uses Han jian for certain formal ceremonial settings. Most Chinese martial artists, historians, hobbyists and collectors would agree that both the Han jian and the Tang dao are the two most prominent and famous hand weapon designs from ancient China. This is partly why after getting the Tang dao from the Swords of Northshire, I have also ordered a Han jian from LK Chen to add to my Chinese swords collection.

@DarkwarriorJ Год назад

The main drawback of the Tang dao compared to the Han one that I can think of is weight. Tang dao have a normal weight compared to other swords of their size, whilst Han dao are wtf levels of minimalist and light at a glance. The Tang dao generally looks like the perfect kind of dao to replace the jian, whilst the Han infantry Dao looks like a 'I want my sidearm to be as encumbering as a glock even though I could be carrying a SMG' type of weapon xD

@jameskazd9951 3 года назад

still loving my lk chen white arc

@DoomOfConviction 3 года назад

Your arguments for a quick mass production of swords all fit too for the Katana, specially because it didn’t even have a ring pummel at the end.;)

@donmac7780 3 года назад

Ni hao Skallagrim 😁 Is it possible that with all of the interest in their products lately that they are just speeding up production to the point where it has outrun their quality control? I certainly hope not. I was seriously considering getting one of their jians. Seriously , you will be wearing hanfu in your next video😁

@lairdcummings9092 3 года назад

Right up there with the Uruk-Hai mass-produced cannon-fodder blades, when it comes to equipping the masses.

@hidnkage9923 3 года назад

You should do a review of the “Chinese Han Dynasty Folded Steel Jian” from kultofathena. I want to see the test cuts and quality of blade.

@GeneralAwesome1204 3 года назад

Left a like for a not “it’s awesome” review of anything!

@sttonep242 3 года назад

Very interesting

@yokai333 3 года назад

I like the grain pattern, but I can see your point

@markfergerson2145 3 года назад

I just saw Scholagladiatoria's reviews of the same swords. He had no problems with bits falling off and his scabbards were solid. His only real beef was thinking the brass bits were too square and sharp to be user-friendly but after some cutting tests he said that was not a real problem. I'm thinking the whole "current world situation" is impacting quality control- some will be fine, others not so much, and you got some of the "not so much" ones

@lkchensword2276 3 года назад

@erichusayn 3 года назад

Looks like they perform very well. Sucks about the pieces falling off.

@TommyRepulsed 3 года назад

I´ve went over some of your older videos, and I must say your beard got a lot better looking. Do you take better care of it or does the density improve with age? Looks more dense, and it has a better shape. 10/10 Beard points for you sir.

@mzc_crazy3769 3 года назад

Hey Skallagrim, been a fan of the channel for a long time, love your work. Was wondering, could you do a fight scene analization for some of the scenes in the two Zorro movies, especially the first one?

@M.M.83-U 3 года назад

The double draw of terror!

@MikaelKKarlsson 3 года назад

Perfect for the Bear Cavalry.

@roderickballance6960 3 года назад

Just an opinion on my part; No guard and a ring pommel, attach a braided cord to wrap around my hand to keep said hand from sliding.

@rajenderchhetri2051 3 года назад

Mr. Skall make a Video about the Razmafzar Team and have interviews with them.

@daleshirley1207 3 года назад

I would try gluing with JB Weld. I've had good results with adhesion under those conditions.

@user-bv5ck4qu6o 3 года назад

又是我最愛的中國刀劍系列！

@custodianvrael6471 3 года назад

3:15, Damn that's a nice looking cut

@426mak 3 года назад

The old saying is Han Jian-Tang Dao. The pinnacle of this type of Dao was reached in the 6/7th century. Here's hoping LK Chen will start do Tang Dynasty weapons as well.

@icyrazor 3 года назад

It's strange because Matt Easton had zero issues with the blades he was sent by LK Chen. Seriously, everything was tight and Matt even chopped some fairly thick branches with his. Skal definitely got sent a bad batch. Even Matt's White Arc remained absolutely fine after chopping thick branches And now YT comments are being vile as per usual and talking all kinds of shit about the country of origin and its peoples

@kylestanley7843 3 года назад

I've yet to see any such bigotry.

@icyrazor 3 года назад

@@kylestanley7843 Just read through some of the comments.

@jonahnicholas7373 3 года назад

I haven't seen any of the comments you're referring to, but in regards to the varying quality between these and the swords Matt Easton reviewed, it's worth noting that Skal has also reviewed other LK Chen products with no issues. The problems may be specific to the particular blade design or he may have gotten a bad batch, but it definitely can't be completely dismissed.

@kylestanley7843 3 года назад

@@xPumaFangx WOAH there buddy. "China" and "cheap" are not always synonymous.

@clothar23 3 года назад

@@kylestanley7843 It makes a certain amount of sense though. As a mass produced and mass issued weapon I would expect a few flaws you know. After all when you're arming hundreds of thousands of illiterate peasants who have only received the most basic of training quality in manufacturing is bound to take a dip. So really a bit of historical accuracy really. Besides it's nothing a bit of smoothing down and proper glue can't fix.

@kleinjahr 3 года назад

Should be possible to fix. A better glue up with a bit of roughening on the inside of the bolster should do. Use a center punch to dimple the bolster a few times will help it hold to the wood. If you're not worried about historical accuracy then a bit of brass plate, or even rod, brazed to the bolster should work has a guard.

@50StichesSteel 3 года назад

Seems to be machete like in its preformance. Tie a lynard on the ring to keep your hand from sliding up and it could be a great bush wacker

@FrozenCoolSolid 3 года назад

next time you have a bad day..watch some samuria cut kubuki....never forget there is a zen..this is why waaaaayy back in the day i was little upset you didn't like katanas...you've sure come along way since then...and got me into chinese blades and well all sort of blades you've really peaked my interest in your videos....hey use the right tool for the right job...no country for old men...when i stab without a hand guard i'd put my off hand on the hilt and push..even just a hard tap ...but i wouldn't play with that.skill the comments below have more understanding of the weapon than me

@eatmelon2316 3 года назад

The handao is simple,cheap and cruel which can made large of soldier equipped.I like it.

@richardmcginnis5344 3 года назад

the short one really reminds me of my type 30 bayonet just a little longer and no guard

@TF_NowWithExtraCharacters 3 года назад

Hey Skall, maybe you can chat with Swordsage about the flexibility of the cavalry sword? It seems strange that something mass-produced for field use would be that flimsy (esp when such equipment would typically be made more robust to stand up to abuse and lower need for maintenance). Matt Easton was reviewing this and he mentioned the overlap in time period with thrust-centric swords, so it's not like the historical folk didn't know about the value of a stiff blade. There might be some obscure way they use it that makes a flexible blade desirable.

@kumakuma3335 3 года назад

Finally!

@SkyTowerKurogane 3 года назад

Just looking at those makes me scared of thrusting into something. Looks really dangerous for your fingers. Edit:YIKES. Yup...

@InsufficientGravitas Год назад

The flexibility of the LK Chen blades has me rather intrigued as to how the traditional alloys differed and whether they might be stiffer (if less springy)

@ReviveHF 3 года назад

This is basically the most primitive Chinese Dao and the most authentic one. The anachronistic ones we often seen in movies such as Ox Tail sword（牛尾刀）and big sword（大刀） were actually used by the law enforcement officer from the late Qing/early Republican era and the Nationalist troops during WW2.

@coemhain9835 3 года назад

Hope they will sent a guan dao next. That weapon is actually more impressive i think than a jian

@olegkrikunov5218 3 года назад

I think in the ring on the back of the handle passed a piece of silk or a loop of rope that served as a stop and protected the hand from slipping.

@ryanmukoon8402 3 года назад

As an infantry soldier, you would mosr likely be issued a polearm as well as a sword. In a large battle the polearm obviously takes priority over the sword,so the sword has to be quite light since it will spend hours unused

@Paul_Sergeyev 3 года назад

Great video! We need more chinese swords!

@AngooseTheMoose 3 года назад

The Cavalry sword reminded me of Bayonetes and I'd be interested in seeing a review from you on a Bayonette and maybe think of a new way to use them

@clothar23 3 года назад

Bayonet = A military knife intended to turn a rifle into a ad hoc spear. Bayonetta = A okay action RPG that is often compared to Devil May Cry.

@StryderK 3 года назад

Purge Blade #231 Bayonetta is not an RPG. If you say hack and slash, then you got something.

@kaaajeee 3 года назад

what a coincidence that Matt Easton just dropped a dao video three days ago.

@andresperez8658 3 года назад

Its crazy how the cavarlry sword flexes.

@ManiacallySmithing 3 года назад

I would imagine that exploiting the ring for some leveraging lanyard would help pull the blade forward when thrusting, as well as keep fingers away form the edge

@jacktheleon 3 года назад

The proper way to hold the sword is hold on the end parts and put the little finger into the ring. That you don't need the guard to counter the resistance. Is light enought to swing on the horse back. Use the bow and leave the blade hang on your hand. Use both hand to grab on handle if need.

@VeridianHerald 3 года назад

Excellent review as always. While historically accurate, I am surprised they went with such early dao designs. Simply put, why reproduce, especially from such a premium company, something that was, honestly, munitions grade during it's day? Now, if they had gone with later Oxtail or Willowleaf styles, those have a lot more room for both being historically accurate and high quality. But in the Han period... a tall order. What a paradox, when one wants to make a high quality reproduction of something that wasn't high quality...

@georgepapadopoulos3734 3 года назад

More European weapons please.Medieval ,Renaissance or even Victorian but most people came here for European swords and armour and i'm sure the vast majority of them are still to be presented and tested by your channel.I would very much like to see budget weapons that are new to the market,like Cold Steel's Competition cutting sword...

@Ash_Blackwind 3 года назад

Considering that it's cheap and the quality is low, you could customize it to your liking. I'm guessing adding a minimal guard the very least so you can thrust with it although its super flexibility would probably make it not that effective anyways. Still, it makes a good practice for crafting.

@ScottKenny1978 3 года назад

LKChen swords are not low quality. The blades are pattern welded 1065/T8 tool steel, can flex quite a bit and return to true. Inexpensive? Relatively so.

@Ash_Blackwind 3 года назад

@@ScottKenny1978 Yes, that's true. The blade itself is pretty good in the review but the rest isn't of the same standard since some are an issue so that was just my personal overall verdict for the product. But your wording (inexpensive) is much better than what I've used (low quality) since mine sounded very harsh, my apologies.

@Wingzero90939 3 года назад

I mean to be fair they could charge more and use better quality stuff. They should just have a waiting period like Albion or Lockwood swords and focus on cranking a good quality stuff. Even if they make everyone do a deposit that’s fine. You can’t really return stuff to the peoples Republic of China it’s quite tedious to do so, it has to be good off the bat.

@LazerBlade-yp1lf 3 года назад

I like these 2 swords. Just wanted to say something short but sweet. No big reason and its not my favorite. But I do like them

@RyzawaVT 3 года назад

I'm definitely curious to buy one of these, but I'll have to give it a wait regardless since it's hard to rationalize buying a sword in College.

@ScottKenny1978 3 года назад

Your sanity is a perfectly reasonable use of student loan money.

@lokiii3507 3 года назад

Back, back in the day... The crucible steel they were making in S and SE Asia must have been superb for these slick blades. Superplacticity at its finest.

@papercat2599 3 года назад

This is used for Han xiongnu battle during Han Dynasty. They switch to huang shou dao. Because Xiong nu doesn’t wear strong armor, so this usually were used for cutting cloth and animal skin armor. They should have some small guards. But this design is used for cutting not exactly thrusting. Because Xiong nu didn’t have much defense, they really just want to hit them with big movements. Also because it’s a mass produced weapon. It probably didn’t develop bigger guard because they want to mass produce. Also I don’t think the one used in Han Dynasty were nearly as flexible as these two blade. So they shouldn’t have an overly flexible problem. I don’t think these two swords are historically correct. Due to the fact they are extremely flexible.

@johngifford7725 3 года назад

Upgrade that short one with a bit of a guard and a kydex sheath and it's looking pretty appealing.

@britannia2129 3 года назад

All you need is a 7.62 round, and the test will be complete!

@vumanhtung 3 года назад

lol not again 😂

@michaeldecuffa8762 3 года назад

Is there a way you could test the zatoichi straight blade from musashi .I bought it and I'm quite happy with it nice fit and finish but I haven't abused it and it's my first sword to collect and I'd be really happy to see you're opinion.and it's been a bit since you reviewed a budget sword of that price

@jasonbrannock1698 3 года назад

Love the sword reviews!! Don't want to get those swords.thanks for saving me money.I'll stick to long swords.what books on longsword do you recomed?? I'm a beginner and need help.J

@malachilaws9238 3 года назад

You should really do a heavy test review on the Mutiny by kailash blades!!!! I just purchased one and i want to know the kind of abuse it can take before i take it out to the woods.