@@segadoeswhatnintendont they'd have to pay an infinite amount of collectors each a finite amount of money (still an infinite amount of money) in order to get it to me in a finite amount of time!
Its like when you clicked through the recommendations long enough to swap over to the dark side of youtube, were you'd only see cursed videos, alien abductions and spanish ghost caught on tape videos.
1/5 stars, the hotel manager kept asking everyone to move rooms every time a coach came with infinite passengers. There were a countably infinite number of coaches which kept arriving my whole stay.
A fellow hilbert enjoyer, I see. In the video, she says that it will take an infinite amount of time for room service to get to your room. So not only does the hotel have countably infinite rooms, its hallways are also space filling. The result is that you never actually get to your room, everyone is just stuck in the hall.
@@prototypeinheritance515 That's actually also fine, just: place passengers from limousine 1 in rooms that are powers of 2, passengers from limousine 2 in rooms that are powers of 3, passengers from limousine 3 in rooms that are powers of 5, passengers from limousine 4 in rooms that are powers of 7, passengers from limousine 5 in rooms that are powers of 11, passengers from limousine 6 in rooms that are powers of 13, and so on. There are infinitely many primes and each has infinitely many powers and they are all different numbers, which means you can easily fit them all and still have plenty rooms left.
0:15 Objection - since there is an infinite amount of time, and my hotel room is presumably a countable number, the food *will* eventually get to my room
True but you may be dead before it gets there because although there are infinite guests and infinite rooms there was no mention of infinite individual longevity.
overruled! 1. with only countably many rooms they still might not all be a finite distance from each other, depending on the ordering - for example, in the ordering 0,2,4,6,...1,3,5,7,... any odd-numbered room is infinitely far away from any even-numbered room. 2. even if they are ordered in the usual way 0,1,2,..., you still can't guarantee any fixed amount of time between ordering room-service and getting it, because there are rooms that are arbitrarily far away - in fact, for *any* finite time frame, 100% of rooms can't get service that fast
Sisyphus is rolling a boulder towards the Grand Hilbert Hotel. The hotel has an infinite number of rooms, but they are all full, so they may not be able to accommodate him or his boulder. If you choose to divert him, his boulder will destroy the Ship of Theseus. But the ship has had all of its constituent parts replaced, so it may not actually be the same ship. Is Sisyphus happy?
No, it isn’t the same ship. I gathered up all the old parts as they were thrown away, and reassembled them, so I’ve got the original. It looks pretty ropy, since all the parts were worn out, and I had to use a lot of duct tape to keep it together, but it is the real Ship of Theseus. You’ll have to pay if you want to see it, though.
I disagree that the food never gets to your room. Even though there are infinite rooms, every room is identified by a finite number, and therefore it takes a finite amount of time to get to that room.
You assume that a finite room number means a finite distance between kitchen and room. Ignoring the leap of logic there, why would the infinite hotel have anything less than infinitely long hallways?
I have been making youtube videos like since 2008, and i can't even remember when was the last time i was something so.. just wow! :D your channel encapsulates why i loved this platform in the first place! thank you so much for existing and creating. Keep up
@@aarongarcia5037 Over the years She faked a bunch of mental illnesses for attention, and most recently lied about being pregnant to take her viewers' money
Well, that's definitely a bigger hotel. The advertisement hotel here sounds pretty much like an 𝛂 infinity hotel, which is a pretty comfy small amount of Infinity
I love the free unlimited refills there! They never stop flowing! ......Even when you're crying on the floor whispering "make it stop, I can't drink anymore of this apple juice!" 10/10 hotel
They're getting more crafty every day! A friend of mine got a mysterious envelope with a letter claiming his long lost uncle bequeathed him a grimoire containing the secrets of immortality. As you might've guessed, delivering that mysterious tome involved navigating temporal anomalies and layline warpfields for which the guy needed to provide the blood of the innocents or recite ancient incantations. If I hadn't talked sense into him, he would've become a vessel for an eldritch abomination... These scams work, because they prey on the gullible, the desperate, and those who seek to discover what man was not meant to behold :(.
everything fun and games until infinitely long bus arrives with infinite numbers of passengers each named with infinitely long distinct combination of "AB"
“Wow free unlimited refills… WOW free unlimited refills” is now cemented in my brain as an obscure reference I will think of every time I see free refills.
I've imagined there being a movie about people in Hilbert's movie having to go to a room double in number after an infinite amount of people arrive. Then there's a quota of how far you need to walk each day to get to your room. If you don't meet your walking quota for the day, then the turrets will lower from the ceiling.
@@JMcMillen They supposedly always have an infinite number of rooms free, so no one should need to move ... this is the key to understanding that the "paradox" is just a way to demonstrate how easily someone can be fooled by a faulty premise and then let their confirmation bias take over.
Camille, these bits are some of the funniest new material I think anyone has produced in about 40 years. A natural wit & talent without affectation, you have great potential for big-time success, just when it knocks, always keep to your own way of doing things & retain artistic control, run your own production, don't become anyone else's product. These sketches are great for many reasons - intelligence, wry deadpan humor, surrealism a big plus, the kind of intimate, 'claustrophobic' atmosphere is a signature style, nice crossover between 'lo-fi' & 'hi-tech' methods, soundtrack ideas, all great. Hard to pinpoint exactly what it is about the production that's so charming & engaging, something about how it teeters on the borderline between hi- & lo-tech, the quick flow of ideas, the surrealism, & just you, funny & gifted & very watchable playing all the parts, no complaints to see 3 of you in a row! These are great, keep up the good work, & make a good living without 'selling out', there's something very pure about your work, never lose that.
All naturals and no reals makes Hilbert a dull boy. All naturals and no reals makes Hilbert a dull boy. All naturals and no reals makes Hilbert a dull boy. All naturals and no reals makes Hilbert a dull boy. Heeeeeeeeere's Bertrand!
I like to think that, since the hallways are endless, you would be able to encounter creatures from different worlds, condemned to never be found out of the maze.
In Hilbert's hotel, the room service will actually reach you in finite time, no matter which room you're staying in, despite that fact that the room service cannot visit every room. Infinity is fun.
I was a little dispirited when I arrived as it appeared all the rooms were fully booked, however the receptionist had a marvellous idea: they put me in room 1 and moved the guests in 1 to room 2, the guests in room 2 to room 3, and so on.
Love the chaotic funny yet cosmically, existentially terrifying vibe! You just earned a subscriber forever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever...
This feels like the kind of class project that is completely different from every other presentation, but is presented first and confuses the shit out of everyone.
I thought I watched an old youtube clip with a few million views, but I was wrong. So happy to see that videos like this still get uploaded once in a while.
Once in a while youtube puts to my front page something I haven't seen million times before, I wish it happened more often but hey it happened now and this was great.
This has a really great like ratio for such a small video. Feels a bit like old RU-vid, and it helps that the content creator, despite being cute, can really pull off a deadpan stare into your soul.
I like the vibe this has. It's just the right amount of silly and uncanny. Like an ad that plays in some horror game that's trying to be spooky but not afraid to be silly spooky
As a hospitality person I can only shudder at the thought of the infinite hotel's infinite kitchen that stretches on forever into the distance And the tickets without end that are made and sent out knowing that they will never make it to their destinations
Understanding that of the hotel felt like it was too infinite, it could simply start placing people at decimal points between their already infinite rooms, which could themselves be infinite. Additionally, they could have luxury suites at decimals of Pi.
1/5 not recommended. Never got my breakfast in time, and got to move out of my room everytime new guests came in. At least they're honest about the former.
When I got there, I had to ride the elevator for a day and a half to get up to my room. The room service took a week to get to me, so I decided to go swimming in the meanwhile. The pool was so long it had its own ecosystem and I saw sharks! Clean your pools! By the time my food got to me, it was already cold and growing mold. Couldn't even eat it. And the room delivery guy's employee number was so long it took me several tries to report him for late service. 2/10 Go to a finite hotel instead.
Sounds like one of those nightmare places you check into, but to the outside world never come back out of. I figured this would reference the types of infinities, with a bus of infinite people, and then an infinite number of buses of infinite people, and how to accommodate everyone.
