Also I like the Wendy card. it's essentially a removal card that also gains you two lore in the process for 3 cost and possibly taking out another with it when it is challenged or doing it again if their board is low and have nothing to attack it right away the turn after you utilize the effect.
Glad you're enjoying them! We have a great time trying to at least take an objective look at each card and try to give some logical unvarnished opinions. Take it for what it is, just our opinions! 😅 Glad we're at least able to provide you some value! Agree to disagree on Wendy 😅 She's extremely situational removal, which I believe we did mention. You're not wrong though!
Been really enjoying this whole series and it actually has been helping me reevaluate my own decks after you discuss the cards. I built a blue/steel item deck to utilize locations due to some of the challenges presented at my LGS Lorcana night and started to really like the idea of item decks while also coming down a lot on locations as a whole. Been tinkering with this item deck more and I think it's in a solid place. Because of that, I personally think that Audrey is better than you guys said she was but do think that she does come out a bit later than she probably needs to. However, given blue as a color is the ramp option, she can usually come out roughly on T4 if things go well. My main pop off play with her that went very well was have Belle's House, Uncle Moneybags Scrooge to reduce items, Ariel, Eye of the Fates, and Audrey (obviously this was a bit later in the game but the game was going a bit slower than usual.) With this combo you tap Fates, give the lore to Ariel, quest with Audrey (2 lore), ready Fates and give it to Ariel then quest with her (3 lore), quest with Scrooge (1 lore), play an item from hand for basically free and ready Ariel then quest (3 lore), repeat combo for however many Pawpsicles you have for no cost. I was able to pop off with I think a 12 lore turn with that combo later in the game. Yes all of the pieces had to be there, but for Blue they weren't that difficult to get in play. So I personally think Audrey is better than B- and would personally put her at B+ given the Fates combo that she can do. With that said, I think I agree with pretty much everything else you all said and actually really like the fairly bold placing of Lucky Dime in C. It has such a wide range of possibility that it has to be C tier lol
Even going off of what you said, that's still 5 cards needed to do what you did. In our opinion, if a singular card needs that many other cards or support to "be powerful" (for lack of a better term), that card lives in the C and low B tier. You won't get any argument that what you did is cool, and CAN be powerful...it just requries a lot of time and resources to pull something like that off. Remember this is coming from the guy who loves Ariel, Whoesit Collector too 😅.
