I lean more to the Macy’s box, but I prefer skincare. My Glam Bag this month was awful - I didn’t even get the coral design bag. I got an old bag from several months ago 🤦♀️ And you’re spot on about the lippie. TFS!!
I don't think either one was the winner. But I'm also getting tired of both of these boxes/bags. I guess I'm just over a box where all you get are small samples. That's why I love Allure and Beauty Fix, because you always get full size products plus samples. I'm old 😂, so i remember when alot of these samples we now have to pay for, were free.
I admire your enthusiasm and you’re so upbeat with your unboxing! Both the IPSY and MACYS boxes were TERRIBLE! I would feel duped, like I wasted my money.
I like the pallet I the ipsy bag But. It isn't worth anything close to $32. More like $6. I like the benefit lipstick but us soooo small. I don't like anything clay
I am so happy I ditched Ipsy. They should be ashamed of themselves that palette is horrible as for the benefit they have always done those tiny samples all the way back to their debut. Great Video 👍
So, yes. I prefer Macy's 300% more hehehe. Kiehls is a great brand and those sizes are perfect for travel and enough for you to test them, which is the whole point of these mini products. I actually canceled my ipsy glam because I couldn't take the bad products from random brands and those little bags that are just useless after a while.
I canceled my ipsy too. I was not impressed so I signed up for allure this month. I did ipsy for 3 months and the only stuff I actually liked were my add ons.
It honestly really upsets me when I'm packaging up orders and I see in these mystery bags the "sample" sizes that are in these..... There's not even enough for a sample!!! And some of the products are in a half an inch tube 🤷♀️ and ppl are paying money for this 🤦♀️
I was also disappointed with the pallet, the highlighter broke apart for me on first use. Therefore for me the macys box is definitely the winner. I am loving the eye cream, only need a little bit and it has been super helpful under my concealer to prevent creasing.
I prefer the Macy’s takeover box w/all the same brand items minus the foil packet. I did however like the Ipsy GB. It’s almost even. Both were not the best month of products. Ipsy’s items r just so small. Love yr earrings & makeup in this video. TFS! ❤❤
I always choose the palette too. I got this one...pans are tiny. I like the green haha. Def not $32!! I like kiehls so they were about even for me but sort of meh.
That face pallete in the Glam Bag looks a lot like the Offra one that was offered in the BoxyCharm recently(in 201r. Ut not sure when-april or may?). I passed on it for that exact reason- looked cheap like temu.
'I'm so critical today,' Sydney. Love it actually. It's refreshing and I like that you are not beholden to getting/not getting Ipsy PR. I think June's Ipsy bag is blah.
My Macys 10$ off coupon won’t work on the travel size YSL libre perfume and I’m upset because it did work when I got coach love perfume travel size. I wonder why
I am still happy with the Macy’s box although several of the products wouldn’t be best for my dry, aging skin😅. I ended up gifting some of the items so they didn’t go to waste!
I would lean towards the Macys box only because it’s a way to try the Kiels products. However, when it comes down to which one was better, I agree with you that it is a draw. 🦋
I think generally that the IPSY and Macy's boxes are a good deal for the price. I usually LOVE the IPSY bags - love this Summer one! However, I have so much product (still!) I used to have an IPSY subscription and had to stop it, and I went crazy with the Advent calendars in Oct - Nov, so I'm waiting for the Advents this year. I love watching these unboxing videos, though - so much fun!!!!!
