Is Boone REALLY the Problem? BT EXPLODES after Disastrous Loss! 

Cashman is more to blame for this horribly flawed roster, but lazy errors, low IQ plays, and bad baserunning are on the manager. The fact that the Yankees haven’t stolen a base in 20 games with the current rules is absurd.

BT and much of Yankee fandom really need to lose the "This Is The New York Yankees!!!" mentality. It's 2024. The Yankees are no longer "different" than anyone else. The myth of the pinstripes is a relic of the past and has been for some time now.

Hal Steinbrenner is the problem! This is a guy that didn't want to be owner. Boone won't be fired for one reason. You can't fire a guy for doing the job of being the yes man he was hired to do.

how does Aaroon Boone still have a job and Buck Showalter loses his job after a 100 win season?

3 years ago the Phillies were horrible they fired Joe Girardi and hired Robbie Thompson look at the difference that move made. Don't tell me a manager isn’t important

Cashman and Boone both have to be fired

Roster may be overrated..agreed, BUT players adopt the personality of their manager 100%. If your manager is Mister freaking Rogers then the product is predictably pathetic.

It’s like 2022 all over again

Same old Yankees. Every year.

This keeps happening every year.. they look great in the spring and turn into manure in the summer... then scramble in September for a playoff spot and are finally ELIMINATED. This is not sudden and this is a consistent pattern under Boone.

The Mets showed everyone the reality of the Yankees this year. They are not constructed well.

Even when times were good earlier this season I said the second half of this lineup was a disaster being carried by Judge and Soto and the bullpen wasnt going to fly in October… it can be both things here Cashman and Boone are both equally atrocious.

Agree 100%. Boone does not know how to play the small game; as a manager he never won a close game. I have not seen this Yankee team making sacrify bount to put a runner in scoring position. Boone is not managing.

Boone just spits sunflower seeds

Boone is not inspirational, pure and simple. Yes the players are not playing as hard as they can but all that can be fixed with a leader that inspires people. Boone aint that guy.

Boone's poor in-game decision have probably cost the Yankees 4-6 games this season. But Virtually all the roster questions entering the season, have come back negative, Rizzo, even prior to the fracture, wasn't hitting or fielding well, DJ hasn't hit the ball well in three years, Holmes is not now and never will be a bonafide closer. Torres has had a horrible season offensive and defensively. Not a single productive bat off the bench all season, that is unacceptable. Grisham has not worked out, trade him. Good fielding, no hit center-fielders are a dime a dozen. How is Jones on this roster.

And when was the last time we had a real leadoff hitter 🤔 What the hell,this is the New York Yankees we are talking about here,act like it !!!!

The Yankees stink!

Judges hitting coach let the cat out of the bag..... NYY in house instruction SUCKS!!!

Look up the definition of insanity. This is baboone and the Yankees. Team will never get better with Cashman and baboone

Players gotta be held accountable too

Yankees need to trade Soto for some prospects. It’s obvious they are not going to spend $500 million to resign him in offseason so at least get some prospects back for him. But watch they will lose the Wild Card and let Soto walk.

Brandon had the NYY winning the World Series in May. 😑

They’ve done this before….they’ll be the best team in baseball for 60- 70 games then completely crater. In the aggregate they’re basically a mediocre team over the last few years yet they vacillate between crazy extremes. They have 2 amazing hitters, a third always hurt power bat, and nothing beyond that. Pitching has been erratic, especially without Cole as a stabilizing force. They’re a good team when fully healthy but they’re very top heavy and too many players in important positions are wildly inconsistent. Holmes is great or terrific, Gil is Koufax or a single A pitcher, Stanton is hitting bombs or hurt, Volpe is an excellent young SS or a lazy disaster, Gleyber is Gleyber, DJ is totally shot, Rizzo is cooked…..what happens if Soto leaves and Judge starts to regress within a couple years?

Still remember two weeks ago you guys were like " the yankees will be fine, they are still better than the Orioles". lol 17:23 also, simple answer.....Yankees first 70 games, the best team they beat was the Brewers. So basically, the first half of games have been easy

Bad baseball fundamentals, lack of hustle on plays and repeating the same excuses are a reflection of the manager and the coaching staff. Sorry but that's a fact.

You cannot have an intern as a manager of the best franchise ever! That guy on the right with the glasses would allow a Yugo engine in a Lamborghini & then sobs away into oblivion when the car struggles at 30 mph. Boone not the problem? Fentynol talk. Teams are sign stealing is the main thing and it shows since the Astros did it in ‘17. Boone still doesn’t have a clue cuz he isn’t a real manager! Who puts a guy who just made the team a day ago as clean up hitter? Not even in softball would a crackhead move like that would be done.

Yes I agree 100% Aaron Boone is not the right manager for the New York Yankees the hitting coaches

BT telling everyone Boonie "is a good baseball man" is laughable. The guy got the job out of the tv booth with no coaching or managing experience, minors or majors. He's there because he's a puppet of the gm. Managers with a track record, who actually manage need not apply under Cashman.

Aaron Boone may not be the problem but he sure isn’t the solution. I disrespect this guy who wanted so badly to be the Yankees manager that he kowtowed to being Cashman’s lapdog.

The Fix> 1. Fire Boone immediately 2. Trade DJ LeMahieu, Rizzo, Stanton and Judge .... all over 30 years old. Judge is still good and should give a good return but the other guys are WASHED UP and are a salary dump. Get the most you can in YOUNG PLAYERS 3. Trade Cole, Cortez, and Rodon... they are old and washed up. Get the most that you can in young pitchers in return. 3. Trade Torrez for whatever you can get. Fill all holes with players from AAA that would include Jason Dominguez and Spencer Jones, and anybody else who has a pulse 4. Promote the AAA manager to manage the Yankees. 5. Look for a young CLOSER in the minors or in exchange for a trade of Judge. 6. Do not even attempt to resign Soto. He will laugh in your face, and does not want to even be on this team. If I am going to finish last I want to finish last with young players who I can build upon and not finish last in order to finish last again with the same washed up and/or unmotivated players.

Clubhouse has 3 clowns Stroman Rodon Verdugo and many players are not happy

The Yankees think this is the 60s-90s every team is great now u can’t just sign the best bombers the best pitchers and win u need speed defense contact hitting. Look at the Sox Os DBacks etc they barely have any big name stars

It’s not about the offseason…it’s about internal development, which thankfully the Mets have realized after failing to buy a WS. Look at the Orioles….absolutely loaded. FA/trades are for supplementing the team you’ve already built. Even if you bring in a star the team needs to be ready to win without them. One player in baseball, even Trout or Judge or Ohtani or Cy Young DeGrom doesn’t mean all that much. It’s a team sport.

Holding players accountable? No repercussions? Of course there aren’t. We live in a world now where the individual is celebrated and you can’t offend anyone or hurt anyone’s feelings. Yeah they may be wrong or need to be yelled at but when it’s all said and done the person who disciplines them is going to be worse off for being insensitive or discriminating or whatever. Just keep running around the bases smiling and pointing to the sky after you hit a solo home run when you’re losing 8-0 in the 8th inning. (While wearing whatever color shoes you want with your gold chains and personalized headgear)

Cashman should have been fired years ago. Boone has no ability to motivate this team. Even if you say this team is overrated there is no excuse for the lazy way they play the game. No hustling and constant mental errors are the sign of an unmotivated team. That is on Boone. He is incapable of kicking any player’s ass. In his postgame press conferences he looks and sounds bored. I never hear any criticism of the players no matter how lousy they play. Cashman and Boone need to go. If Hal Steinbrenner doesn’t care about failure he should sell the team. Hal is ultimately to blame for this mess. His father would have never accepted this sorry state of affairs. At this point I would not be surprised if the Yankees don’t even make the playoffs.

This is deja vu all over again !!!! Just like last year ! Boone has been the pr for years !!!!!!! He said the most important thing to him is…his friendship with the players !!!! B S !!!!! He never gets angry with players that screw up !!!!!! He will never give the players any tough love !!!!! Managers pull players and sit them down when they screw up !!!

How on earth have the yankees gone from one of the best teams in mlb a few months ago to now????? teams have ups and downs. Look at the Mets.... they stinked a few months back and now they are doing really well now.

BT is spot on. Sal saying it's not on Boone, this dude doesn't know sh*t about baseball

Managers matter in baseball. You stick a REAL manager on this ball club and you wouldn't see the nonsense we see on a regular basis from this team.

The Yankees have nothing after Volpe Soto and judge. I never thought I’d say it this year but the Mets look like a more well rounded team.

Cashman was at his best when he played with Gene Michael and Bob Watson 's roster. Cashman and Fishman can't put together a World Championship roster at 300 million, yet the owner believes he can win with a lower payroll. The organization is lost from the top down

How Boone got a job when having zero managerial experience will always boggle my mind out of all the people they could have gotten they chose this guy the Yankees downgraded going from Girardi to him

BT is on point!!!!

I'm loving how the Yankees are seeing why Boston doesn't miss Verdugo 😂😂😂😂😂

When Sal started barking 😂😂

It’s funny Giradi is one win away from a second American League Championship. He was fired after the Astros cheated. Boone has had so many disastrous games but sticks around.

I don’t want to hear about how there’s no more rivalry w the Red Sox. They have OWNED NYY for years!!!!!

Aaron Boone is just one of many problems, but yes he’s obviously a contributing factor.

Rizzo, DJ, Torres, Trevino need to go. Players dont care. Theve signed a contract. Get payed no matter what. Unlike golf. Dont make the shot. Dont get payed. Yes Grisham sucks

Boone has been the problem for years 😂

Yankees can't win games without homeruns and that's what the real problem is.

How can u say a different manager (the correct different manager) won’t make any difference? The Edmonton Oilers brought in Knoblouch halfway thru lst season and came 1 game away from winning the Stanley cup after a terrible strt to the season so YES if you get the rite guy for the job somebody who will lite a fire under players a$$e$ and hold them all accountable things can definitely change for the better!

I highly doubt a new manager will be allowed to call the players out. Most of us Yankee fans are scared of getting just a BOONE 2.0 They need to clean house on ALL managers on the bench, we need a change and until that happens I doubt the Yankees will be in the playoff's let alone the World Series. they are not making it to the post season, and to be honest, I do not want to see this team in the post season. Make some changes, this crap is not working for the past 7+ years. DO SOMETHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

How can someone listen to Boone post game. According to him everthing is rosy

I’m loving this! Yankee rooters totally flipping out.

If you listen to Cashman, Boone was the most sought after free agent manager.

The answer is Cashman and Boone both need to leave town

It's everything has been for years now they only show up against bad teams and get embarrassed by good teams plain and simple

Pretty soon the Mets won’t be the only .500 ball club in town

This is so wonderful to listen to as a Mets fan when all we heard was how good they were the entire first half of the season. I hope Soto is seeing how bad there situation is in the Bronx & how cheap they are & their silly little budget.

If you have players that need a “kick in the ass” by a manager to motivate them to at least carry themselves as professionals, then you have the wrong players. This team has a lot of the wrong players.

Yes boone is a problem but come on some of these guys should of been benched smh

My thought when i found we traded for soto got stroman and verdugo and nothing more was they did just enough to keep butts in seats and nothing more than that

Sal... how can you possibly still defend Aaron Boone?

>What is definition of insanity, Doing the same thing years after year by Hal Steinbrenner and keeping same mediocre manager Boone and Cashman and expecting new results. Cashman hasn’t brought NYC a championship since 2009 that’s 14 years ago and counting. Boone no championship in 7 years as manager. Boone and Cashman should be Fire 🔥 if the Yankees don’t at least get to the World Series or win championship. Hal needs to hold Cashman and Boone accountable for the Yankees failure for last 6 years. The last time the Yankees won a championship it was under George Steinbrenner watch. Hal Steinbrenner is not maintaining the Yankees winning championships, he breaking that tradition by his mediocre style of running the Yankees organization

O's fan here. We have a series coming up with the Yanks, looks like you'll probably gain some ground there.

This team has personalities that Boone cannot handle. That alone is reason for a change.

'BT Explodes.' How did he keep it all in until 10 am? Let's say he woke up 5:30 am. Couldn't he call in The Warmup Show and explode? Lol, I was actually listening live 😅

Hal is the opposite of his dad clearly, if this was George Boone is gone.

B.T. IS 100 PERCENT RIGHT....

Overpaid Section 8 resident that only plays DH in between hangnails,230Avg 100k,s 20Hr?CF manned by a giant that should strictly be DH to preserve his knees ,joints,and ligaments from getting destroyed with a 280 lb frame covering a lotta grass.Too many untradable downward career trajectory retread players soaking up cap to even have a pipedream of signing Soto longterm,farm system sparse from buying their way out of the celler seasons,Boon just knows how to lick the Steinyheiny with Cashman selling dimwit Yankee fans the circus show,the Yankees have years in the making of this glass cannon dumpster fire,it will take years to get the dead weight off the books and some losing seasons to restock young talent, couple that with an avalanche of Yankees contracts due to reset after 24 and they will be forced to re up contracts in house,compounding the problems,they should have ate a few losing seasons and dedicated big money to players they developed in house

Shake it up, Baby. A change has got to come.... whatever it may look like. Desperate times deserve.... Culture shock the only way to shake it up, and see what we got?

What's the way out??? Like Adrian said. "WIN!

Good point Fix the problem, get new players, the manager, coaches from now and bring up your rookies and let them Rake🎉🎉🎉

whether they win or lose. - i would play volpe, cabrera, rice ,austin wells full time, and bring up s jones as well and dominquez when hes healthy ..play these guys full time. also anyone who is performing very well in the farm system bring them up!

Yankee mystique died years ago! Reality people it's been 15 years and counting! They are just another mid team.

@5:18 I strongly disagree with you guys. Verdugo is trying to light a much needed fire within this clubhouse. He had been struggling, he finally got a hold of one and sent it to the moon. I have no problem with guys tryna boost confidence. And look what happened Yankees went on to win 14-4

I guess yanks don’t need a manager.. if nothing is his fault… let yanks manager one another .

I think the least mentioned aspect of those dynasty teams was their ability to eliminate losers from the locker room. They had no tolerance for players who weren't winners.

What's wrong with the Yankees? 2 words - Cashman's ego.

It'll make a difference if u bring in someone in w a backbone who's gonna have the guts to hold players accountable. Imagine going to work for a boss who doesn't hold u accountable for anything, yet u sit & witness how bad things are as a result of your boss's failure to shake things up. U lose interest & go thru the motions while not enjoying going to work bc u know things aren't gonna change.

The Yankees are a collection of talent not a TEAM.

5 of the last 18 is a major collapse. Only thing i'll say if the Mets can bounce back from a horrific start , the Yankees can also. Still they'll have big issues but honestly a move or 2 in the deadline and role players stepping up can put them back in good graces. But....... they may not advance far in the playoffs. Mets still arent out of their mess but the NL is much more attainable then the AL.

Boone doesn’t want to hurt other players feelings. Players pick up on that

The Yankees are a business. Hal doesn't care bout winning like his dad did. This is only gonna change when Hal's pockets get affected & people stop going to the games & the YES ratings plummet. Otherwise buckle in bc this ain't ending anytime soon.

Let's hire David Cone

Hate to agree with Sal, but he is right! It is everybody!

No such thing as a disastrous loss in July 😂

I'm old enough to remember BT saying how this lineup was deadly etc etc etc etc. LOL!! Cashman is a huge problem. I hate to agree with Sal here but that lineup was playing above itself at the beginning of the year. They are falling apart. At the beginning of this year the Yankees' lineup, at best, had 4 good and consistent hitters. Judge, Soto, Verdugo and Torres. And Torres has been awful. Fans were hoping for return to forms for Stanton, Rizzo and DJ and looking for Volpe to take a step forward. Stanton held up his end of the deal but is, once again, hurt. Volpe started off great but is in a rut. He can pick it up, I think. Rizzo and DJ are awful at the plate. Ben Rice has been great so far but what happens when Rizzo comes back? Do they send Rice down? DH? What about when Stanton comes back? This is a long winded way of saying Cashman is also culpable for this mess. He needs to go before Boone, but Boone is no prize with his coddling of these players.

If Boone is gone, Boone 2.0 is replacing him

Michael Kaye doesn't think Boone is the problem. He's not the only problem but he is a problem, including the entire coaching staff. I've said ever since was annointed manager that they will never win the World Series with Boone! He has sat players down for a day off WHEN THEY'RE IN THE MIDDLE OF A HOT STREAK! And then he won't set them down when they're slumping! Eventually they sat down Torres (Goober) and it helped for a minute but he's not being coached well either at bat or in the field!! They acquired JD Davis a .225 and he slotted him in the cleanup slot!!! I could go on forever but I'm tired already. There's not much more than a handful of players that I would keep!! And I'm not a Clay Holmes fan, at least not as a closer.

If the Yankees have a policy about facial hair and wearing a suit when they go to another stadium, why not one for this look at me crap that has infested MLB. I cannot stand Bubbles as manager; in fact, Dent's HR means more to me than his. I would like to finally see Mattingly as manager not some yes man puppet to Cashman.

BT you never learn a couple of weeks ago you said this Yankee team is going to the WS....STOP,, ,they still may not win a playoff spot..as of this writing Judge is 2 for 20. strikes out many many times. Volpe should go back to the minors and bring up Arias. In my opinion Volpe is not a major leaguer. Do not laugh I would release Torres and ask the Mets for Mc Neil, he could still hit, 290 career avg, Lead him off and put Rice your catcher to bat second. Bring up Warren and Beeter and put Gil in pen. Get Belly from Cubs at trade deadline...Release Boone ASAP

George is turning over

I agree with both of them.

Culture culture culture! It's a toxic culture, & yes it's the managers fault. He's done nothing, or held anyone accountable. It doesn't matter who we get, if the culture doesn't change the results will always be the same.

Manager in baseball will not make a difference, it is so analytically driven, the decisions are taken out of the managers hands. Rob Thomson again and again says takes starters out cause of the matchup analytics.

“HowwwwwEVERRRRR 💅💅”/…zesty Sals favorite word

Good guys finish last.